I’m calling it, AJ never escaped at all, or at the very least she never got to ponyville. In fact, I’d wager she’s dead. But I think Twilight in some way or another took/drank some variant of the sleeping potion and gave it to all of the mane six. Unlike how it was in the first story, where the ending suggested maybe it had an unreliable narrator with there never being any potion, THIS is the one with the unreliable narration. They’re suffering the effects of the potion and hallucinating AJ the same way she imagined Filthy Rich. We’re getting the perspective of them stuck in the madness we didn’t get with AJ originally.
Well the narrator wasn’t the one saying that. It was twilight herself, the potion DID exist, but twilight denied its claim of existence so she could have deniability. Remember in the first part AJ was hallucinating and believed that filthy rich was attacking her when he wasn’t, so what if they all somehow ingested the potion (keep in mind flutter shy mentions about eating the desserts pinkie prepared before and how they tasted off, maybe somehow it was in there) and that there all simply hallucinating AJ because of there guilty conscience.
It’s interesting how each mane six have their own perspective of how apple would look and act after all those years in prison -Twilight : malnourished and crazy -Pinkie pie: wicked and vengeful -Fluttershy: Demonized and manipulative I can’t wait to see what happens next! Great story!✨✨
@@nonamenoname9322 i like to think that it was both of them that saw AJ as a demon, i guess they both just have different concepts of what a demon acts or looks like, in this case AJ, or they have different perspectives on what AJ supposedly looks like after so long, but then again it is being theorized that what remains of the mane six have drank the potion that pushed AJ to the point of insanity in the first place. Edited.
So basically it's kind of similar towards the inverted shadow's own story of the elements of insanity, excluding TF 2 characters course a great series I highly recommend watching can't wait to see more of this current story.
I'm gonna run with the theory that this is Appleblooms doing, since it's been teased and left ominous what happened to her. And seeing she's studied potions before, she could've given it to the remaining mane 6 as a sort of revenge since it was "their" fault she lost her sister, something she held onto so dearly.
I like how you can hear Fluttershy's animals trying to reason with her amidst the madness. You can even hear them speaking to each other asking "What is she doing?" at 49:00
My prediction here is the same as what some others have posited: AJ isn't actually present at all in the story. This is just the girls collectively hallucinating after accidentally imbibing the Sleep Prevention Potion. There's numerous hints that point toward this. Applejack is mysteriously able to avoid any damage thrown her way. None of the others besides the Mane Six react to her. I'm calling it. Twilight accidentally killed Starlight when she blew a hole in the wall. Pinkie stabbed Mrs. Cake. Fluttershy killed her animals without provocation.
I’m honestly leaning towards this theory purely because in the last vid Twilight said that some of the potions Applejack drank were indigestible. According to this worlds logic, she should’ve like- exploded or thrown up by now if she really was there.
It would explain why Starlight seemed confused while dying, why the cake family didn't want Pinkie to even touch them, and why even when "demonized" the animals stopped for a moment when Fluttershy killed the bear.
I leaned to this theory too because Mr cake pushed pinkie away angerly and it could explain why pound cake was just so desperate from getting away from her and when animals all just stopped in fear when Fluttershy killed hairy
This is my theory too. Though I also think Twilight pulled another stupid idiot moment and caused this somehow. (I don't actually hate Twilight, but I sure as hell hate this Twi in this story)
I have to admit, AJ’s second voice really freaked me out. The stark contrast from Lost’s voice where AJ is rough, angered, and loud is the complete opposite to the additional voice. AJ’s second voice being calm, quiet, and even sweet sounding really hits hard as such a pretty voice says such awful and disturbing things.
The softer voice is definitely more disturbing, usually softer voices in the context of a horror story are already terrifying, especially if the voice belongs to the antagonist, it either grants people a false sense of security, or activates their fight or flight instinct and cause them to react irrationally, or cause them to freeze completely, for me this is personally the reason why bad guys with softer voices freak me out so much, it's precisely why Mama Bear from Dark Deception creeps me the hell out, in this context it does a great job with making AJ all the more scarier. Tldr, Bad guys with friendly sounding voices are terrifying, and it fits AJ like a charm in this case.
AJ: in a crazed murderous state “ *I’M FOLLOWING N DOING WHAT MY PATH LEADS ME TO DO NOW, AFTER YOU ALL ABANDONING N FORGOTTEN ABOUT ME, AND FOR THAT YA’LL WOULD BE MEETING YOU ALL’S ULTIMATE FINAL DEMISE!!!* “ no hesitation near regrets completely lost her mind and sanity! Hey 0.01 of her might be still in there just stuck in their…
Idk you tell me what she’s thinking within her and what her goal is complete or not or they can idk just kill her off like I know they might hesitate but it’s the only way to end her rein of terror and maybe going to hell after wards for AJ! But still?
I know everyone in the live chat was commenting on the audio mixing (which is AMAZING) but I didn't realize until listening another time around during Fluttershy's segment that some of the muffled/distant voices in the background, not the glitching/overlaying narration, but actual lines of dialogue, are what the animals are saying to Fluttershy. Things like "but I'm hungry..." when she was shoving them outside, and crying out her name upon seeing her next to Angel, saying "we can't let her get away with this" right before the big fight. Even during the fight, I heard muffled lines of "don't touch me", "we should help her" and "what is she doing?". This is all supporting the idea that Applejack isn't physically there, maybe she doesn't even exist, more of a hallucination caused by stress, sleeplessness and grief. Because if she was.. why wouldn't any of the animals comment on her being there?
@@LynnisZesty Can't wait to see Part 3 I hope none of them are dead because if Celestia and Luna find out they're gonna be so mad at Applejack for it.
In 2020 Twilight successfully gaslit me when I saw the first one, thinking that the potion not being real was some sort of plot twist. I can't believe I got gaslit by Twilight frickin' Sparkle smh.
That happend to me too. But it was mainly becouse I had only basic understanding of english. When I re-listened it not so long ago, it hit me hard. I hate this version of Twilight, what a princess of friendship. 🙄
I was completely right to doubt myself when Twilight said the potion didn't exist in the first place, it just seems too convenient and even suspicious, i even felt sorry for AJ at the original Applesleep's end, but it only because she never got to know what happened to Applebloom so it's nice to see that the potions existence was basically proven by the brand new narrative here. But then again, the original apple sleep experiment didn't say the potion didn't exist after all, that was just Twilight trying to save face and forget she played a role in AJ's downward spiral into sleep deprived induced depravity. (Real tongue twister there wow)
I AM SO SORRY FOR LAUGHING AT THIS COMMENT THE ENDING CAUGHT ME OFF GUARD- yet i agree! i wasn’t gaslit, but the ending did leave me questioning the true ending and who was the real villain of the story.
Hay at the part where angel just died.. and we first see aj talking to the bear.. you can hear an animal saying something.. just like the sqearls.. but I can't make out what the voice said.. does anyone have any idea?
@@doctorwhoscpblitzkrieg770"Fluttershy ... not gonna get away with this ... her eyes, look at her eyes ... please don't hurt me ... but i'm hungry, it isn't fair, I dunno what it is ... [sobbing?] ... [???] ... I was [???] ... how come you did this ... [???] ... something extra has to drop ... fluttershy ... but I'm eating, *what?* .. we [???] like this ... fluttershy ... perfect"
Hear me out Remember in Apple Sleep Experiment how AJ was hallucinating in the first part? She was so sure filthy rich was taunting her but he essentially wasn’t. What if this is the case with the mane 6? So haunted by there own guilty conscience that there hallucinating AJ and spreading chaos through that? I mean in the part with pinkie if AJ truly was there would pound and the father have blamed pinkie and refused to follow? No they would have followed her immediately. There simply is NO applejack and it’s all in there heads. Edit: I also want to add that during the part with pinkie applejack was seen just.. chilling in the fire??? Obviously even if she somehow was there and maybe the potions effected her, she still would of reacted in some way to the fire (remember when pinkie threw the hot Carmel at AJ she reacted by SCREAMING in agony, yet somehow the fire touching her does absolutely nothing to her. To also add she would have been consumed by the flames and thus stuck in the building, yet somehow at the exact same time she’s going after flutter shy. The timing simply makes no sense.
Honestly, that's my thoughts too. I'm picking up on the additional voices going on in their heads from another Voice Actors (as well as the second Applejack voice) I betcha they're being experimented on in some way and the guilt along with other emotions is causing it I have no way to know but it's my theory
You’re probably right, as in the first part Twilight experiences the same side effects that AJ did. I thought it was just the potion but then Fluttershy and Pinkie had it too. And Twilight would never have given them the potion. So this could be a lack of sleep plus extreme paranoia.
@@akki-san4987YES, THATS WHAT I WAS THINKING TOO I don’t know why Twilight would ever attempt to use that potion again, she really does seem guilty of it in the first place (to me, at least). But it was mentioned how this huge event was making the rest of the six work night after night, there’s no doubt they haven’t slept for a while and even been overworked, it wasn’t exactly the potion that made Applejack go crazy, but the lack of sleep it gave her. Twilight, Pinkie, Fluttershy, maybe even more, they’re all going through the very thing Twilight had lied to Applejack about in the first place. Being worked into mental break.
In defense of the caramel vs the fire, boiling caramel is HOT. It can leave serious burns even if you touch it for just a second, that stuff can mess u up
I think Applejack has been dead this whole time and this truly is just the sleep potion mixed with the heavy guilt.... I wouldn't say it was so far-fetched to think this was the rest of the apple family's revenge discovering what really happened all those years ago and wanted to avenge their fallen family...
So from what ive watched, and what ive read in the comments, this is the theory i have: Applejack did escape. But she didnt get directly to ponyville. She went to the farm. She found her family, along being Apple Bloom who was severely hurt from the incident but happy to see her sister having been cured. The family blamed her friends, mostly twilight after Apple Jack let them know the whole time, none of them sent her anything or tried to visit her. (The true reasoning that twilight didnt want the friends finding out she did actually give her a potion that caused this, so she would have friends and family turned away and all letters and packages sent back.) AJ told her family the truth about the potion. Apple Bloom became furious with the friends, and used her lessons in potion making to remake the potion but slightly different. To make it more potent and with the taste of rotten apples so that it would make them think of apples and in turn Apple Jack, while also making their stomachs upset. Apple bloom then makes her way to the castle and into the kitchen and offers a hoof to Pinky to which she gratefully accepts with all the things shes making. As Apple Bloom helps, she sneaks potion in to every desert. Whenever Pinky noticed, Apple Bloom would just say its vanilla, and that a little goes into any desert to help boost the flavors. Once the deserts are done and everything has been tainted with the potion, Pinky offers some to Apple Bloom to which she lets her know she has to leave, Big Mac told her to be home by a certain time and it was a few minutes til as she rushes out the door. Pinky then gets the treats out to her friend's which they all eat one of everything. Everything thats tainted with potent version of the sleeping potion. And the last thing they all looked at was the sculpture of Apple Jack. Twilight destroyed her own potion room which is how the lock was undone. Starlight was scared and locked her door and a shard of the crystal wall flew and killed her when Twilight burst it open. Pinky killed Mrs.Cake She pulled down the curtain and lit the house on fire. Fluttershys animals were trying to get her attention as they usually did when they could sense something was wrong, that she took as them still being hungry and being aggressive. She closed them in a closet. She saw angel bunny and went for him. Though when they crashed into the wall, his neck broke. Harry managed to open the door and saw a deranged looking Fluttershy over a dead angel bunny who started fighting them. He defended himself and accidentally sliced her thigh. She then killed him with the idea he was trying to kill her. The animals were shocked and were trying to get past her to escape to which she beat the rest of them under the guise that they were attacking her. Theyre all suffering from the potion, but a more potent form. Edit:I HAVENT CHECKED MY NOTIFICATIONS FOR THIS. 300 LIKES AND SEVERAL COMMENTS, THANK YOU!!!!
This theory is genuinely so awesome, also the bit of Applebloom becoming furious with the rest of the main six (considering in this theories context she isn't dead or dying just gravely injured but alive) makes sense, it also shows how fierce her love towards her family is, or at least AJ since she idolize's her to some extent. Thinking about it for an alternate universe definitely. Edited.
Eh I don't rlly see Applebloom being the type, or any of them being the type to do such a thing, KNOWING what would happen if they took it, that innocent lives would be taken. I say AJ did escape, and is either dead or out there somewhere, although it does make me wonder HOW they drank the potion
Okay my first theory was that Twilight had accidentally or intentionally drank the sleep experiment and Applejack was all an illusion in her head from the guilt and the potion... But now I believe they all drank it and are reliving the horror that Applejack went through..
Spoilers + Theory: Wait.. Did pinkie kill Mrs Cake? Mr Cake ran away from her so we aren’t sure why (besides protecting pumpkin) and Pound had a very interesting reaction.. he tried to escape her, he bit her, kicked her, struggled against her… I don’t think he’d do that since he was practically raised by her. I think she might have killed Mrs Cake in front of the cake Twins and Mr Cake, prompting their reactions. Maybe they all might have drank the potion? It explains why Applejack sounds and looks different pony to pony, and why Applejack is practically invincible. Starlight’s confused glare? The struggling from Poundcake? Fluttershy’s sudden aggressive and hate? And she’s been like that for at least a day, since Rainbowdash was confused by her angry reaction to her being late, not to mention the glitches… sounds like they drank the potion either by mistake or somepony poisoned them with the potion. Maybe AJ did escape but didn’t do anything in the story other than poison them with the potion. Thanks for listening to my theory :)
I agree with you completely, though technically Pound could have been fighting to go back into his mum, truly not believing she was dead and needed help.
17:30 Wait, was that a reference to “something sweet to bite” where Apple Jack was covered in caramel due to hearing the children laughing that was from the candy mare?
The eerie, solemn music during Fluttershy's part mixed with the taunting whispers of her name before Fluttershy goes mad is incredibly haunting and really fits the hopeless, sinister feeling of being trapped and being hunted. Very well done.
This reminds me of a line a heard once, “you hope hatred may someday replace the pain. But it never goes away. It makes a man hideous, inside and out.”
I'm wondering if Applejack had a mind-reading potion in the terrible menagerie of concoctions. Or the potions not only killed her but also turned her into an angry wraith. Or it'll be that Applejack was never there at all like a 'it was all a dream ending' energy.
Come on, be supernatural and don't have a 'it was all in their heads' ending...at least have something supernatural with Applejack that pushed the others to madness. Please.
I feel like they are hallucinating due to fatigue, as Pinkie shows signs of great fatigue and some madness, and also because they feel guilty.And how did AJ know about Twilight's secret lab. Especially those sounds and screen noise in the background that made me feel this way
I love how at 39:10 in the drawing there are the palismans of the owl house characters: Stringbean (Luz's palisman) Ghost (Amity's palisman) Emmiline Bailey Marcostimo (Gus's palisman) Clover ( Willow's palisman) Flapjack & Waffles (Hunter's palismans) I love the little crossover between the two fandoms in one drawing. My Owl House heart is actually screaming with joy right now! thank you so much 💗
Part two was.....AMAZING I really like the idea of AJ targeting them and everything they love. It'll be interesting to see Applejack and rainbow dash...as well as rarity... I feel really bad for fluttershy and Pinkie knowing their love was for family and what they do.
The whole thing does feel like a blind vengence, causing just as much, if not more, suffering and pain to those not connected to the moment(simplest point being only one of them being fully aware to the potion's existence, and to something bigger in the casualities not even connected except by their friendship). Perhaps there'll be a moment of regret from whoever is behind this(someone from the Apple family as some are saying, or in some twisted way, Twilight herself partially due to the title as she's the only one who has conducted such an experiment before while using it on herself to be seen as just another victim).
Damn Fluttershy really let that dawg out she had a whole super saiyan transformation moment like her seeing angel cut in half and then she transforms into a super saiyan.
I notice that after they start hearing the voices,Applejack appears. She attacks them personally with their own guilt. I don't know if she's actually really here or not Edit: She's definitely not real
@@Soniosuperstar If they are hallucinating the bad stuff happening would fade having never been there to begin with. you can't touch hallucinations And they don't cause deaths to happen.
I was thinking this in the first part, but now more certain of it in this one: AJ isn't physically there at all, but somehow she's able to get into the heads of the others and convince them that she IS there. Twilight killed Starlight, Pinkie killed Mrs. Cake, and Fluttershy killed her animals. I did see someone mention how it could be how each pony interprets what AJ might look/act like after all the time she spent in prison, and that's the version they see when she "appears", which would explain why some accounts of her have specific weaponry/tools and others don't. No matter what, I absolutely LOVE how this series is going and I cannot wait for the next part!!
At first I thought that Twilight was the one going on a rampage but it seems as tho all of the main Six are having a shared psychosis that might be brought by sleep deprivation. This begs the question, wtf is Luna doing??
@@ReesesBees What if Celestia and Luna requested them to not tell the truth to save Applejack from execution? It would've been a bad idea to do in the first place because there would be mobs of Ponies who seriously Applejack executed and want her blood and I don't think Twilight Spike and their remaining friends telling her what happened to Apple Bloom would've made things better either.
I have a theory. Applejack is either dead or still locked up in Canterlot prison because it’s appearing that Applejack is a hallucination to the main six. This could explain why she’s fast, immune to fire, seamlessly invincible. I also noticed that no other pony besides the main six themselves acknowledged Applejack was even there (Mr. Cake and the twins didn’t acknowledge Applejacks presence at all). I think maybe some pony else is at play with all of this like getting the main six to drink the sleep potion and causing them to hallucinate all these things and committing horrible acts like Applejack did when she drank it? Applejack with every one of her victims she killed, she always hallucinated she was beating and killing Filthy Rich. Twilight accidentally killed Starlight by blasting a hold through the wall. This could explain why Starlight was in a state of confusion towards Twilight before she died. Pinkie accidentally stabbed and killed Mrs. Cake with the knife. This could explain why Mr. Cake pushed Pinkie away in such a angrily manner instead of escaping with the cake twins to safety and Pound Cake being so desperate to escape from Pinkie to the point he bit her. When he did escape from Pinkie, he took off running away from her. Fluttershy turned against her animals and killed them including Angel in defense, survival, and them being “demonized” by “Applejack”. The seemingly “demonized” animals even stopped in shock after Fluttershy killed Hairy the bear until “Applejack” resumed the animals to continue attacking her. I noticed the narration that continuously distorted every time the ponies were in deep thought and the time when it came to “defending” themselves from “Applejack”. This is very similar to Applejack’s distorted thoughts and actions. Pinkie was up at the crack hours baking cakes (Applejack was up at the crack hours canning zap apples)… Pinkie was performing multiple tasks (Applejack was performing multiple tasks)… Pinkie got annoyed very easily (Applejack got annoyed easily and went off on Apple Bloom)… Applejack appeared differently to Twilight, Pinkie, and Fluttershy. For Twilight, AJ appeared malnourished and a insane maniac. For Pinkie, she appeared very vengeful and unforgiving towards her. For Fluttershy, she appeared as being a demonic black magic user who used her powers to turn her animals on her. Overall, I think some pony else got the main six to drink the sleep potion to see how it reacts on different ponies… Conducting another experiment perhaps? Maybe thats why this is called “Another Apple Sleep Experiment” **DUN DUN**
I can agree with you there. All of them have dealt with different situations. Somepony is experimenting on this, and I wonder who could be recording the results.
I’m not sure why but this one line just had me laughing at bit when applejack said “ANIMALS KILL ANIMALS ALL THE TIME SURVIVAL OF THE FITIST FLUTTERSHY” caught me off guard I guess also the whispers were a nice touch
After rewatching both parts, I'm noticing each of what's left of the mane six seemed to have wildly different variations on how AJ looks. She was malnourished but quick with Twilight but was built large and had her rugged hat with Pinkie and glowing eyes and full of dark magic with Fluttershy's perspective. Its either a) the different potions AJ consumed are having wildly different effects or b) all of them are suffering some sort of mental break due to exhaustion with Twilight possibly putting some kind of potion in that tea. Potion like the one she gave to AppleJack 7 years prior. It would explain Pinkie's ability to stay up for 3 days and continuously bake. Twilight's clear exhaustion but still able to keep up with the preparations. Fluttershy's obvious grouchiness and bags under her eyes but still have the energy to put her animals first. The potion would also explain other things like how Starlight was sad and confused as she held her slit neck after coincidentally Twilight held shards of glass in her magic. Or how Pinkie's family didn't hear the noise AJ was creating but only came rushing down the stairs as Pinkie threw knives and burned the kitched down. And how Pound Cake ran away from her whe she tried to save him from the fire. Or, how Fluttershy's animals (mostly consisting of prey animals) were not sensing any danger even as Fluttershy irged them to run. But then again, Pinkie DOES have a lot of energy on ADHD insomia levels and Twilight is known to pull all nighters constantly and fret about celebrations. And Fluttershy could've been mad and drain from Rarity's extreme attention to very minor details. Maybe there was no potion at all. Maybe they all had seperate mental breaks with the stress and time of year. Or maybe, even c) Discord could be behind it all to break apart the elements of harmony. Guess we'll only know when the rest of the story comes out.
Jesus tap dancing Christ, I thought the first Apple Sleep experiment was messed up, but this is a whole other level of demented in the best way possible. Well done, Lost, you and the team have outdone yourselves again. The way the multiple narrators overlap and the visuals distort really allows us to see the deteriorating mental states of the characters. Also, I don’t think Applejack is there at all, like, this is all a hallucination from lack of sleep. Guess this makes the Mane 6 the experimented this time around….I cannot wait to see where this goes next.
So Pinkie & Fluttershy are at a new low now. They betrayed their own identities. So I’ll take it that’s AJ’s plan, not to kill the other Mane 6 (excluding Starlight who took her place) but instead to make them every bit as low as she was forced to become. I can scarcely wait to see how Rarity & Rainbow Dash are going to get their dues
... I get it now *Spoilers* Twilight must have given herself, Pinkie, and Fluttershy the Sleepless potion without knowing. Probably why the AJ Twilight said "Does that make me the experimenter or the experiment?" She used them to experiment on a new version of the potion. Or Sweetie And Scootaloo spiked their drinks with the potion to get revenge for what happened to Apple Bloom and the rest of the Apples. Oh I can't wait for what happens with Rarity and Rainbow.
Spoilers ahead Oh my god. She's not killing them herself. She's ruining their lives. Just like they did to her. Killing Starlight, burning down Sugar Cube Corner, turning Fluttershy against her animals and vice versa... It's heavily implied that Fluttershy is dead, but not confirmed. The horrors at play could be her killing her animals. Twilight, Pinkie, and Fluttershy are forced to live in order to face the fact that their lives have been torn out from under them. AJ is making them suffer her nightmare. I have no idea if AJ is real or just a hallucination shared by the rest of the Mane Cast, like others have suggested, but either way this is delicious poetic justice.
@@POOKESEE she didn't help her apparently, and believed the guards lies that she rejected her letters, she ruined her life for giving up on her. Really sad honestly.
There's no justice anywhere. Pinkie never did anything to her, neither did Starlight, or the Cakes she killed, or Fluttershy. If she just went after Twilight, then she'd have a justification, but she's became just an insane and vindictive killer. Either that or the theory that all the mane 6 somehow drank the sleepless potion is correct, although i really hope this isn't the case. I can say that whatever pity felt for Applejack in the first story is gone in the sequel, since Applejack is hurting innocent ponies and this time she doesn't have a sleepless potion as an excuse. Something's for sure, tho, everyone's she's messing with seems to have come to the conclusion she has to be killed, so there is a chance they'll start hunting her down, and if that's gonna be the case, then, ngl, i'd look forward to seeing that hunt take place
Ok but did anybody notice the palisman from The Owl House at 39:50? And Flapjack eating flapjacks AGGGGGHHH SO CUUUTE!!!! A nice little break from the psychological torment.
i cannot be the only one who is on applejack's side. after all, twilight was the one who drove her to this level of pure insanity with the sleepless potion. she did try to warn applejack, yes, but applejack was trying to look out for her family. all she wanted to do was repay that debt of hers and her family's. EDIT: i'm speaking *purely* about twilight here, not about any of the other mane six.
She's going too far. It's one thing to exact her revenge on the deserving, but Fluttershy and Pinkie were both too kind. Their "excuse" is that neither of them are really strong enough to stand up for themselves initially, usually being pushed to the limit before even considering it.
That just seems contrarian? Twilight wouldn't have fully understood the effects of the potion, and I think it's safe to assume would've tried damn hard to cure it. Even so, being a victim or of not sound mind doesn't _justify_ revenge - nothing does - especially if it involves committing such heinous violence upon innocents. You can't be held accountable necessarily, but you can't be dismissed to act as the "arbiter of justice" either, that's kind of ridiculous. Applesleep is so emotionally gut-wrenching because there _is_ no one to blame; it's a tragic and needless cruelty, leaving so many with directionless, bottled-up guilt and grief. You don't have to be on anyone's "side". Uh, if you take this sequel at face value, at least, for now until we have more context...
@@stardustandflames126 I'm gonna nna disagree with the revenge bit, because I think personally that it should've just been Twilight if anyone, as she kinda is the only one AJ actually blames. The rest..... She can be mad at them, but tearing their very lives apart seems a tad too far for my taste in vengeance.
Yk, I remember watching the first original story, and these new parts got me on the edge of my seat and DEFINENTLY not how I saw this story going. Well done, Lost!
Wow!!! Amazing continuation of the story! It’s so well written - AJ’s lines gave me goosebumps!! Editing really added to the dread and suspense and it paired so well with everybody’s voice acting talent and beautiful artwork. Once again, thank you all for your contribution and dedication!! Can’t wait to see what’s in the next part!! ❤️❤️❤️
It's really interesting how the story mimics the first one! The first one ending in Twilight passing out, just like how Applejack did, and then the next scene being a young character being woken up by another character having seemingly stayed up all night in the kitchen...
Real quick before it's too late I'm going to drop my theory, So the ongoing Theory right now is that all of this is going on in Twilight's head my theory is that what if all the friends are hallucinating? Can't wait to see what happens in part 2!
Oh wow, got a couple theory’s in mind about what’s going on in all this. Almost feels like the girls are hallucinating all this, like they’ve been drugged with the same stuff apple jack was in the first Apple experiment. That or Apple jack “is” really there and one of the many potions she drank at twilights place gave her mind fuckery powers. Lol either way amazing work again guys, I’m loving where it’s all going and I can’t wait to see what’s in store for Rainbow dash and Rarity. 😈
For rainbow i cant think of anything but rarity omg that one could be soo brutal and so sad i could end up feeling awful for rarity but yeah rainbow i got nothing but hbu watcha think?
@@latesonic2006 as to who’s getting the most brutal punishment out of the two? Rainbow honestly, feel like her and Apple Jack shared the tightest friendship.
🎶 I know what darkness means...(and the void you left for me....) The isolation stings....(so thick it wants to bleed...) The echoes in my brain.. (all the things you said to me.....) You took my everything....(Now I'm coming for you!!) I won't back down! I will not bow! (I come to bring you Hell.....) And I can't forget, the things you did!! (I come to bring you Hell....) The shadows that you see... (in the places that you sleep....) Are memories of me.... (better pray your soul to keep....) The truth behind your eyes! (You know, the thing ya never see....) Your darkest little lies....(I'M COMING FOR YOU!!) I won't BACK DOWN!!! I will not BOW! (I come to bring you Hell.....) And I can't FORGET! The things you did!! (I come to bring you Hell....)🎶 Applejack singing "Won't Back Down" by Fuel.
Okay so all of the main 6 are somehow affected by the same thing Twilight was in the first. Applejack is also definitely not real. Considering the fact both Twilight Fluttershy and Pinkie aren’t sleeping and are both shown to be very twitchy (and the voice distortions) I’m assuming it is the sleep potion amplifying their emotions and causing them to see Applejack (like how the potion amplified Applejacks rage and made her see Filthy Rich) but I don’t know how they all ingested the potion. Also my god Pinkie killing the entire pie family except pound and Fluttershy killing all her animals 0-0
I was there for the premiere and the amount of people who genuinely despise Twilight for all of this is somewhat disconcerting. That aside, this was very enjoyable to watch and I can’t wait for the next installment
@@reap3514 I mean like Twilight isn’t entirely innocent I’ll admit (considering she’s the one who gave AJ the potion in the first place) but I feel like it was Filthy Rich who actually pushed AJ over the edge. Could just be me though. Also I just like Twilight in general
I guess people are angry at her for actually abandoning Aj, hiding the truth about why she went nuts and trying to gaslight Aj into believing it's her fault alone. And from what we saw she didn't really stop experimenting with potions of the same kind that driven her friend to insanity. So understandable that people are angry at her mostly. Because FR is dead already anyway.
@@K1ttyGam3rthis version of twilight did nothing to help AJ and pinned all the blame on her knowing her potion was causing applejack extra stress. I say this version cause OG Twilight would of had a fit if anything like this happened to her friends I don't think people hate twilight, just this version of her. And rightfully so, along with her friends if Pinkys section is true and they all knew or had some idea.
Chapter 2 was absolutely spectacular and sensational Lost! I loved every second of it, It would definitely worth the wait and once again both the art and voice acting was all done ever so marvelously make no mistake about it, Major props and kudos to everyone who participated in bringing this vid to life you all did such an incredible and fantastic job! Simply glorious work!!!
The deaths are so sus. I think the others are on the same pathway as AJ did, but not in the sense that they’ll have the same outcome. Plus, the victims could have easily been killed by the mane 6
I finally got to hear this and damn, the voice acting was outstanding!! I love the voices when their losing their mind, it's to good and different and excited how Rarity's and rainbow dash scene will go.
Im beleving that AppleJack was never real theory. Mostly bc of the echos Fluddershy and Pinkie Pie are having like how AppleJack had. Also none of Fludder's animals noticed applejack so shes possibly a hallucination created by something. Possibly caused by sleepless nights working twords the celebration
I agree with the theory that the remaining mane 6 are hallucinating, especially with the way apple is described in the fire during pinkies part, then theres how apple found twi's hidden lab and got past a magic lock
Yea it’s all so..suspicious and coincidental (impossibly coincidental). Plus her injuries from each pony she terrorizes doesn’t get described by the next main 6 members. Neither Pinkie nor Flutters mentioned cuts (from the glass with Twilight or the other injuries she might of had I forgor), and Flutters doesn’t mention burns or caramel..she’s also the only one to mention glowing red eyes and that weird possession ability
Make a bet when part three comes out Fluttershy is going to be mortally wounded, but all those animals died. And the next time you see Applejack, she’s going to actually have a notable injury.
If you listen closely during the Fluttershy section, you can hear the thoughts of some of the animals peeking through. Some notable examples I caught were “but we’re hungryyyyy” as Fluttershy tries to shoo them out, and “Is she okay?” As attention is brought to Angelbunny
Im in love/obsessed with how this story is going and I can't wait for part 3! Love your narration for these and i also love that the fact that Scribbler is also narrating a little as well! Anticipating the next part! Ive listened to these 2 parts 5 times now because i cant get enough!
Kill #2: Ms.Cake Cause Of Death: Knife thrown into her chest by Pinkie Pie after she succumbed to The Sleepless Potion; Burned alive in house explosion. Kill #3-4: Mr.Cake and Pumpkin Cake. Cause Of Death: Burned alive in house explosion. Note: If any of these characters revealed to be alive by the end of the story(which i doubt they will be), their deaths will be taken off the count.
Considering that the Potion took over Aj is crazy. I do have theory about Filthy rich and the others. Twilight took the potion and gave her a SMALL anmesia. She confronted Aj saying she doesn't remember giving it to her. (Definitely the side effects of the potion she took) it wasn't completely twilight's fault. Applejack is at fault too. But in reality the true fault is The potion. I'll probably do alot of theories about this.
I wanna thank everyone who made this possible this was a good audio book and a good read on fimfiction thank you all for your hard work and dedication for bringing this fic to life and thank you to all the voice actors for doing fantastic work this was beautiful I also want to thank you for still bringing out g4 mlp content I appreciate everyone and the content y’all make I hope yall doing well and having a good life ❤🎉😊
Wow that was incredible!! I haven’t felt a rush like that for such a long time!! The scenes with fluttershy were flawless, gave me chills. I was right to be so excited. Can’t wait for what’s to come! ❤️
Pound cake is going to need therapy after what happened, i feel awful for him. And i wonder if it was actually Apple jack there, what if it was Pinkie pie who did it like others had said? good fanfic
Who else recognized the palismen? also, I like how with Fluttershy, AJ’s voice isn’t so deep and gravely, instead she sounds just the way she did before the whole disaster. It sounds like the Applejack that Fluttershy once knew. And that’s what makes all her degradation hurt even worse.
Just got better. I like how aj was done. Looks like no one but her friends can see her. Either aj died or all those potions she drank turned her into a actual demon. I'm looking forward to next part to know how this going to turn out. ^^
Aint no way applejack is real, the fire didnt even burn her. Ive also noticed each of them see applejack differently, twilight saw her without her hat, no more than a skeleton. Pinkie saw her with her hat, messy but not emaciated with her toolbelt, and fluttershy saw her with her hat and muddy, but her fur is still bright orange and she ONLY had the shovel. Not to mention her voice is slighty different to each pony. Given the close timeline of their encounters, this raises suspicions.
Incredible video, each of the Mane Six is losing what/who was most dear to them the way Applejack lost Applebloom due to the potion IMO there's two possibilities to explain what's going on 1. Applejack isn't there, she's actually dead (might have died soon after the first story considering how Pinkie's mail got returned) and the other Mane Six ingested the sleep potion either by accident or on purpose to get everything ready for the memorial 2. Applejack did escape but she hasn't done anything other than somehow slip the others the no sleep potion, causing them to hallucinate and destroy everything they hold dear the same way Applejack did. She's somewhere near by watching the carnage unfold
I have a feeling Apple Jack never escaped. Either dead or still alive but still in her prison. Even if she did escape it's merely impossible for her to go unnoticed. Twilight's discription of A.J sounds like the most likely way A.J would look since she would probably be aware of A.J's condition.however i think everyone is sleep deprived. Either twilight tested a potion or they are just depriving themselves of sleep by themselves or it could be a different reason.they are all hillucinating and here's why i think that's the case: Twilight having a secret room that no one seems to know about and the door is locked by magic. No way AJ could get in there before her. Twilight is also the kind of person to obsess over things and takes them too far at times. The fact that twilight is unable to open the door is something.either locked from the other side or starlight was locking it with magic ((the latter can only be the case if twilight was chasing a hillucination and scared starlightght)) magic bounced off the castle door was a bit off. Not sure if the door is like that because of what its made of. I noticed a few people bring up Starlights confusion . I think she was confused because she could not exactly tell what twilight was saying because she is bleeding to death here but also that Twilight accidentally killed her Pinkie is a bit more clear. She looks HELLA SLEEP DEPRIVED so she is more likely to hillucinate on her own even without a potion. She's been making treats non stop so it makes sense.she sees AJ way differently compared to twilight and unlike twi being blamed for how AJ ended up pinkie sees AJ as an old friend that felt betrayed and forgotten.someone she gave up on and she feels guilty about it. Notice how the cakes SOMEHOW don't hear AJ nor Pinkie. I think they did and probably noticed Pinkie acting off and talking to something that's not there but feels real. The sceane where pinkie throws the knives could have been a result of her accidentally killing mrs cake .the cakes don't seem to react to AJ before this at all . The fire is told to be pinkie's doing fore being careless .and AJ stayed in the fire as if she is immune clearly not possible Fluttershy is already tired and has been so busy that she was unable to take care of her animal friends properly for probably dayd And this time the animals decided to act on instinct to attack her. After she kills the bear the rest of the animals attack her for it .the betrayal of Fluttershy killing one of them plus their hunger amplified their violent behaviour . AJ is seen as someone that can control the animals and is discribed way differenly here too . But fluttershy's cottage is on the otherside of ponyville (correct me if i am wrong) how has no one spotted her or heard her. With broken hined legs there is no way she would be fast let alone get to fluttershy's cottage THAT quickly without being seen after the fire at sugar cube corner. Notice how AJ only appears when the girls alone befor anyone dies
I love the tones and shifts we got with Applejack in this one, it feels so out of reality and within reality. If we didn't have the distortions, I'd say Applejack was just going through some mood crisis after all those years and was approaching in different behaviors because of who she was dealing with due to her past experiences with them. 45:25 OKAY, this drawing made my eyes widen slightly with how demonic and crazed Applejack looked. Of course I'm siding with the fact that this could all be some horrid nightmarish allusion built up by their paranoia, stress and guilt all weighing heavily on their shoulders. Or Twilight never learning her lesson and giving altered versions of the potion causing each other the mane six to have different horrible outcomes to how it changed their behavior and the hallucinations that came with it. Some part of me feels like this will end with Twilight being thrown in the same prison cell where Applejack laid imprisoned and instead of seeing an empty room? It'd be a corpse instead as the terrifying reality connects with Twilight that Applejack NEVER escaped causing her to rethink and soon remember everything as how it TRULY was instead of what her stress and over pressured work life showed within the allusion of her madness growing of all the possible factors (that never happened-) causing her to have some kind of mental snap. // Anyway, I wanted to explain some wish I had when I saw Pinkie Pie was going to be the first to be bothered by this dark presence. When Applejack basically said her whole façade was basically bullcrap and all those morbid thoughts were going through Pinkie's head while trying to outrun "Applejack" I was hoping she'd snap and we'd see some Pinkamena Diane Pie moment where'd we see one morbid figure against another who struggled to keep her demons inside, only reason why I wanted this was I wanted to hear Applejack say along the lines of.. "I guess we all have our inner demons huh, Pinkamena..?" "Here I thought I was the only boogiemare in ponyville, but I guess two monsters occupy this space huh, Pinkie Pie?" "Here I assumed you had nothing but sunshine and rainbows as you kept saying, but I guess I broke what was left of that right, Pinkie Pie?" I dunno, my imagination is vast and goes all over the space so I thought it wouldn't been a cool little badass moment or scene, I knew it'd never happen but that doesn't stop my mind from hoping and wondering of these "What Ifs" ya know? Thanks for reading my messy comment lol.
29:30 Since Pinkie was left alive, my personal theory for this stories end game is that once every other member of the mane six is dead, Pinkie is going to come back for one last showdown with Applejack to seek revenge for the cake's deaths No matter what happens, I'm sure it'll be awesome! ❤
![The Friendship Test [MLP Fanfic Reading] (Grimdark)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fZmPJqoxMQo/mqdefault.jpg)
![Silent Ponyville [COMPLETE] [Pony Grimdark]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wVRMnyD0mCg/mqdefault.jpg)
PART 3: th-cam.com/video/gcyds853F6Q/w-d-xo.htmlsi=78kD7d8Bb1dRXE8i
I’m calling it, AJ never escaped at all, or at the very least she never got to ponyville. In fact, I’d wager she’s dead. But I think Twilight in some way or another took/drank some variant of the sleeping potion and gave it to all of the mane six. Unlike how it was in the first story, where the ending suggested maybe it had an unreliable narrator with there never being any potion, THIS is the one with the unreliable narration. They’re suffering the effects of the potion and hallucinating AJ the same way she imagined Filthy Rich. We’re getting the perspective of them stuck in the madness we didn’t get with AJ originally.
You know what? I can see that.
Yeah, because the distortion seem like hallucinations their having
That is 100% true. I bet that will be in the finale in part 4
Well the narrator wasn’t the one saying that. It was twilight herself, the potion DID exist, but twilight denied its claim of existence so she could have deniability. Remember in the first part AJ was hallucinating and believed that filthy rich was attacking her when he wasn’t, so what if they all somehow ingested the potion (keep in mind flutter shy mentions about eating the desserts pinkie prepared before and how they tasted off, maybe somehow it was in there) and that there all simply hallucinating AJ because of there guilty conscience.
Yes yes! I also think they are hallucinating, I think it's from exhaustion and guilt.
It’s interesting how each mane six have their own perspective of how apple would look and act after all those years in prison
-Twilight : malnourished and crazy
-Pinkie pie: wicked and vengeful
-Fluttershy: Demonized and manipulative
I can’t wait to see what happens next!
Great story!✨✨
This can imply they all may have accidentally drank the potion, since she seems to look different in each version of the mane 6’s stories
It was Pinkiepie that saw her as a demon, not Fluttershy.
@@nonamenoname9322 i like to think that it was both of them that saw AJ as a demon, i guess they both just have different concepts of what a demon acts or looks like, in this case AJ, or they have different perspectives on what AJ supposedly looks like after so long, but then again it is being theorized that what remains of the mane six have drank the potion that pushed AJ to the point of insanity in the first place.
Edited.
So basically it's kind of similar towards the inverted shadow's own story of the elements of insanity, excluding TF 2 characters course a great series I highly recommend watching can't wait to see more of this current story.
🎯
This is the point of why everything they went through wasn't real
I'm gonna run with the theory that this is Appleblooms doing, since it's been teased and left ominous what happened to her. And seeing she's studied potions before, she could've given it to the remaining mane 6 as a sort of revenge since it was "their" fault she lost her sister, something she held onto so dearly.
Yes im absolutly sure that Applejack is not real because she never harms them herself
@@meisterdetektiv7050?
I think she’s dead vs side of the memorial statue at episode 1.
Im sure applebloom is dead
Maybe she is dead as she did get a big hit on the face and we haven’t hear anything from her
I like how you can hear Fluttershy's animals trying to reason with her amidst the madness. You can even hear them speaking to each other asking "What is she doing?" at 49:00
Ooh that a cool detail I missed
My prediction here is the same as what some others have posited: AJ isn't actually present at all in the story. This is just the girls collectively hallucinating after accidentally imbibing the Sleep Prevention Potion. There's numerous hints that point toward this. Applejack is mysteriously able to avoid any damage thrown her way. None of the others besides the Mane Six react to her. I'm calling it. Twilight accidentally killed Starlight when she blew a hole in the wall. Pinkie stabbed Mrs. Cake. Fluttershy killed her animals without provocation.
I’m honestly leaning towards this theory purely because in the last vid Twilight said that some of the potions Applejack drank were indigestible. According to this worlds logic, she should’ve like- exploded or thrown up by now if she really was there.
@@Gore-Labs or at least become something equivalent to splatter punk levels of body horror, whichever comes first.
It would explain why Starlight seemed confused while dying, why the cake family didn't want Pinkie to even touch them, and why even when "demonized" the animals stopped for a moment when Fluttershy killed the bear.
I leaned to this theory too because Mr cake pushed pinkie away angerly and it could explain why pound cake was just so desperate from getting away from her and when animals all just stopped in fear when Fluttershy killed hairy
This is my theory too. Though I also think Twilight pulled another stupid idiot moment and caused this somehow. (I don't actually hate Twilight, but I sure as hell hate this Twi in this story)
I have to admit, AJ’s second voice really freaked me out.
The stark contrast from Lost’s voice where AJ is rough, angered, and loud is the complete opposite to the additional voice.
AJ’s second voice being calm, quiet, and even sweet sounding really hits hard as such a pretty voice says such awful and disturbing things.
The softer voice is definitely more disturbing, usually softer voices in the context of a horror story are already terrifying, especially if the voice belongs to the antagonist, it either grants people a false sense of security, or activates their fight or flight instinct and cause them to react irrationally, or cause them to freeze completely, for me this is personally the reason why bad guys with softer voices freak me out so much, it's precisely why Mama Bear from Dark Deception creeps me the hell out, in this context it does a great job with making AJ all the more scarier.
Tldr, Bad guys with friendly sounding voices are terrifying, and it fits AJ like a charm in this case.
Oh my gosh I was thinking the same thing I just didn't know how to articulate it but yes
Reminds me of season one AJ, maybe this is how flutter shy remembered Aj, I can see her talking softly to Fluttershy from time to time. I love it 😢
@@SphericalNervousSystem Oh my god that’s such a cool way of seeing it!
@@akki-san4987
Bet the potions AJ drank gave her growling red eyes.
Everyone: "AJ! Where did you come from? Why are you even here? They said you were cured!!"
AJ: " *emotional damage* "
AJ: in a crazed murderous state “ *I’M FOLLOWING N DOING WHAT MY PATH LEADS ME TO DO NOW, AFTER YOU ALL ABANDONING N FORGOTTEN ABOUT ME, AND FOR THAT YA’LL WOULD BE MEETING YOU ALL’S ULTIMATE FINAL DEMISE!!!* “ no hesitation near regrets completely lost her mind and sanity! Hey 0.01 of her might be still in there just stuck in their…
Are you shur or is it that simply she is CRAZY 😵💫😵💫😵💫😵💫😵💫😵💫
Idk you tell me what she’s thinking within her and what her goal is complete or not or they can idk just kill her off like I know they might hesitate but it’s the only way to end her rein of terror and maybe going to hell after wards for AJ! But still?
Plot twist: AJ's not doing this because her friends abandoned her, but because of all of the years of background pony jokes.
@@Nyorane she would destroyed them
@@Nyorane yes lol that would make sense good thinking!
"SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST FLUTTERSHY"
Favorite line of AASE pt 2
Same here
Friggen rule of the wild too 😂
I know everyone in the live chat was commenting on the audio mixing (which is AMAZING) but I didn't realize until listening another time around during Fluttershy's segment that some of the muffled/distant voices in the background, not the glitching/overlaying narration, but actual lines of dialogue, are what the animals are saying to Fluttershy. Things like "but I'm hungry..." when she was shoving them outside, and crying out her name upon seeing her next to Angel, saying "we can't let her get away with this" right before the big fight. Even during the fight, I heard muffled lines of "don't touch me", "we should help her" and "what is she doing?".
This is all supporting the idea that Applejack isn't physically there, maybe she doesn't even exist, more of a hallucination caused by stress, sleeplessness and grief. Because if she was.. why wouldn't any of the animals comment on her being there?
I'm so glad someone caught those ;)
@rach3092no wayyyyy
No way!!!!!!!!!!!! I heard that but I didn’t pick up on what it was
@thelostnarrator I love you're narrations! I'm so happy this got a sequel to it. Also nice storyline, it's dark and thrilling. I love it.
@@LynnisZesty
Can't wait to see Part 3 I hope none of them are dead because if Celestia and Luna find out they're gonna be so mad at Applejack for it.
In 2020 Twilight successfully gaslit me when I saw the first one, thinking that the potion not being real was some sort of plot twist. I can't believe I got gaslit by Twilight frickin' Sparkle smh.
That happend to me too. But it was mainly becouse I had only basic understanding of english. When I re-listened it not so long ago, it hit me hard. I hate this version of Twilight, what a princess of friendship. 🙄
I was completely right to doubt myself when Twilight said the potion didn't exist in the first place, it just seems too convenient and even suspicious, i even felt sorry for AJ at the original Applesleep's end, but it only because she never got to know what happened to Applebloom so it's nice to see that the potions existence was basically proven by the brand new narrative here. But then again, the original apple sleep experiment didn't say the potion didn't exist after all, that was just Twilight trying to save face and forget she played a role in AJ's downward spiral into sleep deprived induced depravity. (Real tongue twister there wow)
TWILIGHT FUCKING SPARKLE*
I AM SO SORRY FOR LAUGHING AT THIS COMMENT THE ENDING CAUGHT ME OFF GUARD- yet i agree! i wasn’t gaslit, but the ending did leave me questioning the true ending and who was the real villain of the story.
@@joshuaball5916The hell are you here for then?😂
Lost's fanfic readings aren't just fanfic readings. They are an EXPERIENCE. A feast for the eyes and ears. Bravo everyone, outstanding job!
Bravo to you! You knocked it out of the park! Thank you again so much for lending your voice for this!
Even though I knew you were apart of this and you were gonna kill it. Your performance still caught me off guar.
Hay at the part where angel just died.. and we first see aj talking to the bear.. you can hear an animal saying something.. just like the sqearls.. but I can't make out what the voice said.. does anyone have any idea?
@@thelostnarrator D'aww thank you! I had a blast, thanks for inviting me on! 😊
@@doctorwhoscpblitzkrieg770"Fluttershy ... not gonna get away with this ... her eyes, look at her eyes ... please don't hurt me ... but i'm hungry, it isn't fair, I dunno what it is ... [sobbing?] ... [???] ... I was [???] ... how come you did this ... [???] ... something extra has to drop ... fluttershy ... but I'm eating, *what?* .. we [???] like this ... fluttershy ... perfect"
Hear me out
Remember in Apple Sleep Experiment how AJ was hallucinating in the first part? She was so sure filthy rich was taunting her but he essentially wasn’t. What if this is the case with the mane 6? So haunted by there own guilty conscience that there hallucinating AJ and spreading chaos through that? I mean in the part with pinkie if AJ truly was there would pound and the father have blamed pinkie and refused to follow? No they would have followed her immediately. There simply is NO applejack and it’s all in there heads.
Edit: I also want to add that during the part with pinkie applejack was seen just.. chilling in the fire??? Obviously even if she somehow was there and maybe the potions effected her, she still would of reacted in some way to the fire (remember when pinkie threw the hot Carmel at AJ she reacted by SCREAMING in agony, yet somehow the fire touching her does absolutely nothing to her. To also add she would have been consumed by the flames and thus stuck in the building, yet somehow at the exact same time she’s going after flutter shy. The timing simply makes no sense.
Honestly, that's my thoughts too.
I'm picking up on the additional voices going on in their heads from another Voice Actors (as well as the second Applejack voice)
I betcha they're being experimented on in some way and the guilt along with other emotions is causing it
I have no way to know but it's my theory
You’re probably right, as in the first part Twilight experiences the same side effects that AJ did.
I thought it was just the potion but then Fluttershy and Pinkie had it too. And Twilight would never have given them the potion.
So this could be a lack of sleep plus extreme paranoia.
You might make a good point there!
@@akki-san4987YES, THATS WHAT I WAS THINKING TOO
I don’t know why Twilight would ever attempt to use that potion again, she really does seem guilty of it in the first place (to me, at least).
But it was mentioned how this huge event was making the rest of the six work night after night, there’s no doubt they haven’t slept for a while and even been overworked, it wasn’t exactly the potion that made Applejack go crazy, but the lack of sleep it gave her.
Twilight, Pinkie, Fluttershy, maybe even more, they’re all going through the very thing Twilight had lied to Applejack about in the first place.
Being worked into mental break.
In defense of the caramel vs the fire, boiling caramel is HOT. It can leave serious burns even if you touch it for just a second, that stuff can mess u up
I think Applejack has been dead this whole time and this truly is just the sleep potion mixed with the heavy guilt.... I wouldn't say it was so far-fetched to think this was the rest of the apple family's revenge discovering what really happened all those years ago and wanted to avenge their fallen family...
Though it begs the question, how did the potion get into each of then?
@@nameynamd9212 through desert probably
So from what ive watched, and what ive read in the comments, this is the theory i have:
Applejack did escape. But she didnt get directly to ponyville. She went to the farm. She found her family, along being Apple Bloom who was severely hurt from the incident but happy to see her sister having been cured. The family blamed her friends, mostly twilight after Apple Jack let them know the whole time, none of them sent her anything or tried to visit her. (The true reasoning that twilight didnt want the friends finding out she did actually give her a potion that caused this, so she would have friends and family turned away and all letters and packages sent back.) AJ told her family the truth about the potion. Apple Bloom became furious with the friends, and used her lessons in potion making to remake the potion but slightly different. To make it more potent and with the taste of rotten apples so that it would make them think of apples and in turn Apple Jack, while also making their stomachs upset. Apple bloom then makes her way to the castle and into the kitchen and offers a hoof to Pinky to which she gratefully accepts with all the things shes making. As Apple Bloom helps, she sneaks potion in to every desert. Whenever Pinky noticed, Apple Bloom would just say its vanilla, and that a little goes into any desert to help boost the flavors. Once the deserts are done and everything has been tainted with the potion, Pinky offers some to Apple Bloom to which she lets her know she has to leave, Big Mac told her to be home by a certain time and it was a few minutes til as she rushes out the door.
Pinky then gets the treats out to her friend's which they all eat one of everything. Everything thats tainted with potent version of the sleeping potion. And the last thing they all looked at was the sculpture of Apple Jack.
Twilight destroyed her own potion room which is how the lock was undone.
Starlight was scared and locked her door and a shard of the crystal wall flew and killed her when Twilight burst it open.
Pinky killed Mrs.Cake
She pulled down the curtain and lit the house on fire.
Fluttershys animals were trying to get her attention as they usually did when they could sense something was wrong, that she took as them still being hungry and being aggressive.
She closed them in a closet. She saw angel bunny and went for him. Though when they crashed into the wall, his neck broke. Harry managed to open the door and saw a deranged looking Fluttershy over a dead angel bunny who started fighting them. He defended himself and accidentally sliced her thigh. She then killed him with the idea he was trying to kill her. The animals were shocked and were trying to get past her to escape to which she beat the rest of them under the guise that they were attacking her.
Theyre all suffering from the potion, but a more potent form.
Edit:I HAVENT CHECKED MY NOTIFICATIONS FOR THIS. 300 LIKES AND SEVERAL COMMENTS, THANK YOU!!!!
This theory is genuinely so awesome, also the bit of Applebloom becoming furious with the rest of the main six (considering in this theories context she isn't dead or dying just gravely injured but alive) makes sense, it also shows how fierce her love towards her family is, or at least AJ since she idolize's her to some extent. Thinking about it for an alternate universe definitely.
Edited.
Wow…just wow. Bravo *claps*
Eh I don't rlly see Applebloom being the type, or any of them being the type to do such a thing, KNOWING what would happen if they took it, that innocent lives would be taken.
I say AJ did escape, and is either dead or out there somewhere, although it does make me wonder HOW they drank the potion
@@vixymix101
They accidentally drank it without knowing it.
I thought Applebloom is dead but I haven’t watched the Apple sleep experiment in a long time so I could be remembering it wrong
Okay my first theory was that Twilight had accidentally or intentionally drank the sleep experiment and Applejack was all an illusion in her head from the guilt and the potion... But now I believe they all drank it and are reliving the horror that Applejack went through..
Spoilers + Theory:
Wait.. Did pinkie kill Mrs Cake? Mr Cake ran away from her so we aren’t sure why (besides protecting pumpkin) and Pound had a very interesting reaction.. he tried to escape her, he bit her, kicked her, struggled against her… I don’t think he’d do that since he was practically raised by her. I think she might have killed Mrs Cake in front of the cake Twins and Mr Cake, prompting their reactions. Maybe they all might have drank the potion? It explains why Applejack sounds and looks different pony to pony, and why Applejack is practically invincible. Starlight’s confused glare? The struggling from Poundcake? Fluttershy’s sudden aggressive and hate? And she’s been like that for at least a day, since Rainbowdash was confused by her angry reaction to her being late, not to mention the glitches… sounds like they drank the potion either by mistake or somepony poisoned them with the potion. Maybe AJ did escape but didn’t do anything in the story other than poison them with the potion. Thanks for listening to my theory :)
I agree with you completely, though technically Pound could have been fighting to go back into his mum, truly not believing she was dead and needed help.
@@Parasolhyena fair point, but then why would he run away from the fire after being pulled out of it? 👀
@@Stardr0p7-t8t
Maybe so he doesn't die in it too
It’s the sleepless potion. It has schizophrenic effects on users
@@Soniosuperstar exactly what I’m thinking! But it’s just a theory.. a FILM THEORY
17:30 Wait, was that a reference to “something sweet to bite” where Apple Jack was covered in caramel due to hearing the children laughing that was from the candy mare?
Ye.
The eerie, solemn music during Fluttershy's part mixed with the taunting whispers of her name before Fluttershy goes mad is incredibly haunting and really fits the hopeless, sinister feeling of being trapped and being hunted. Very well done.
I feel like Pinkie's voice sounds better here than it normally does. Applejack's too.
Same it just come out more natural and accurate
This reminds me of a line a heard once, “you hope hatred may someday replace the pain. But it never goes away. It makes a man hideous, inside and out.”
I'm wondering if Applejack had a mind-reading potion in the terrible menagerie of concoctions. Or the potions not only killed her but also turned her into an angry wraith.
Or it'll be that Applejack was never there at all like a 'it was all a dream ending' energy.
Come on, be supernatural and don't have a 'it was all in their heads' ending...at least have something supernatural with Applejack that pushed the others to madness. Please.
I love the idea of the whole potion thing killed her and did that as it would be cool to see it and make total sense
@@bleakautomaton4808FR I don't want it to be a "it's all a dream" ending LET RM GO MAD
I feel like they are hallucinating due to fatigue, as Pinkie shows signs of great fatigue and some madness, and also because they feel guilty.And how did AJ know about Twilight's secret lab. Especially those sounds and screen noise in the background that made me feel this way
The fact that I recognized all palismans from The Owl House at 39:40 I can't get over MLP and TOH. Love this channel.
SOMEONE NOTICED THEM TOO!!!
I love how at 39:10 in the drawing there are the palismans of the owl house characters:
Stringbean (Luz's palisman)
Ghost (Amity's palisman)
Emmiline Bailey Marcostimo (Gus's palisman)
Clover ( Willow's palisman)
Flapjack & Waffles (Hunter's palismans)
I love the little crossover between the two fandoms in one drawing. My Owl House heart is actually screaming with joy right now! thank you so much 💗
I noticed the same thing!
Owlbert's in there too! It's so cuuuuute!
@@mossandthings2457 Oh wait I just saw that lol
@@balloonkill3r251 I'm glad I'm not the only one who saw it lol
I noticed it too! As the photo was slowly zooming out, I noticed Stringbean's face in the corner at 38:03 and I had to do a double take 😂
Part two was.....AMAZING
I really like the idea of AJ targeting them and everything they love. It'll be interesting to see Applejack and rainbow dash...as well as rarity... I feel really bad for fluttershy and Pinkie knowing their love was for family and what they do.
The whole thing does feel like a blind vengence, causing just as much, if not more, suffering and pain to those not connected to the moment(simplest point being only one of them being fully aware to the potion's existence, and to something bigger in the casualities not even connected except by their friendship).
Perhaps there'll be a moment of regret from whoever is behind this(someone from the Apple family as some are saying, or in some twisted way, Twilight herself partially due to the title as she's the only one who has conducted such an experiment before while using it on herself to be seen as just another victim).
@@nameynamd9212
And if Applejack did escape from prison there are going to be bounty awards demanding her turned in for even worse crimes.
Damn Fluttershy really let that dawg out she had a whole super saiyan transformation moment like her seeing angel cut in half and then she transforms into a super saiyan.
AJ’s voice is absolutely perfect. So rough and raspy- sends shivers down my spine. Absolutely amazing work~
I notice that after they start hearing the voices,Applejack appears. She attacks them personally with their own guilt. I don't know if she's actually really here or not
Edit:
She's definitely not real
But that’s just a theory… a fanfic theory
@@Soniosuperstar
If they are hallucinating the bad stuff happening would fade having never been there to begin with.
you can't touch hallucinations
And they don't cause deaths to happen.
@@Soniosuperstar
Lol that's perfect. I was right though!
I was thinking this in the first part, but now more certain of it in this one: AJ isn't physically there at all, but somehow she's able to get into the heads of the others and convince them that she IS there. Twilight killed Starlight, Pinkie killed Mrs. Cake, and Fluttershy killed her animals. I did see someone mention how it could be how each pony interprets what AJ might look/act like after all the time she spent in prison, and that's the version they see when she "appears", which would explain why some accounts of her have specific weaponry/tools and others don't.
No matter what, I absolutely LOVE how this series is going and I cannot wait for the next part!!
At first I thought that Twilight was the one going on a rampage but it seems as tho all of the main Six are having a shared psychosis that might be brought by sleep deprivation. This begs the question, wtf is Luna doing??
Luna went on vacation maybe???
@@avacadotoast5571 That or Twilight used magic to prevent Luna from entering their dreams, as a means to prevent the truth from coming out.
@@ReesesBeesI can totally see her doing that tbh.
@@ReesesBees
What if Celestia and Luna requested them to not tell the truth to save Applejack from execution? It would've been a bad idea to do in the first place because there would be mobs of Ponies who seriously Applejack executed and want her blood and I don't think Twilight Spike and their remaining friends telling her what happened to Apple Bloom would've made things better either.
Exactly where the fuck is Luna?!?!?! Right about now she seems like the perfect person to stop this psychosis!!
I have a theory. Applejack is either dead or still locked up in Canterlot prison because it’s appearing that Applejack is a hallucination to the main six. This could explain why she’s fast, immune to fire, seamlessly invincible. I also noticed that no other pony besides the main six themselves acknowledged Applejack was even there (Mr. Cake and the twins didn’t acknowledge Applejacks presence at all). I think maybe some pony else is at play with all of this like getting the main six to drink the sleep potion and causing them to hallucinate all these things and committing horrible acts like Applejack did when she drank it? Applejack with every one of her victims she killed, she always hallucinated she was beating and killing Filthy Rich. Twilight accidentally killed Starlight by blasting a hold through the wall. This could explain why Starlight was in a state of confusion towards Twilight before she died. Pinkie accidentally stabbed and killed Mrs. Cake with the knife. This could explain why Mr. Cake pushed Pinkie away in such a angrily manner instead of escaping with the cake twins to safety and Pound Cake being so desperate to escape from Pinkie to the point he bit her. When he did escape from Pinkie, he took off running away from her. Fluttershy turned against her animals and killed them including Angel in defense, survival, and them being “demonized” by “Applejack”. The seemingly “demonized” animals even stopped in shock after Fluttershy killed Hairy the bear until “Applejack” resumed the animals to continue attacking her. I noticed the narration that continuously distorted every time the ponies were in deep thought and the time when it came to “defending” themselves from “Applejack”. This is very similar to Applejack’s distorted thoughts and actions. Pinkie was up at the crack hours baking cakes (Applejack was up at the crack hours canning zap apples)… Pinkie was performing multiple tasks (Applejack was performing multiple tasks)… Pinkie got annoyed very easily (Applejack got annoyed easily and went off on Apple Bloom)… Applejack appeared differently to Twilight, Pinkie, and Fluttershy. For Twilight, AJ appeared malnourished and a insane maniac. For Pinkie, she appeared very vengeful and unforgiving towards her. For Fluttershy, she appeared as being a demonic black magic user who used her powers to turn her animals on her.
Overall, I think some pony else got the main six to drink the sleep potion to see how it reacts on different ponies… Conducting another experiment perhaps?
Maybe thats why this is called “Another Apple Sleep Experiment” **DUN DUN**
That would be pretty cool actually, but just btw I think apple jack has all those abilities cause she drank all of twilight’s potions ^^
@@pinko_ponko1869 That was only due to Twilight's hallucinations.
I can agree with you there. All of them have dealt with different situations. Somepony is experimenting on this, and I wonder who could be recording the results.
I’m not sure why but this one line just had me laughing at bit when applejack said “ANIMALS KILL ANIMALS ALL THE TIME SURVIVAL OF THE FITIST FLUTTERSHY” caught me off guard I guess also the whispers were a nice touch
After rewatching both parts, I'm noticing each of what's left of the mane six seemed to have wildly different variations on how AJ looks. She was malnourished but quick with Twilight but was built large and had her rugged hat with Pinkie and glowing eyes and full of dark magic with Fluttershy's perspective. Its either a) the different potions AJ consumed are having wildly different effects or b) all of them are suffering some sort of mental break due to exhaustion with Twilight possibly putting some kind of potion in that tea. Potion like the one she gave to AppleJack 7 years prior. It would explain Pinkie's ability to stay up for 3 days and continuously bake. Twilight's clear exhaustion but still able to keep up with the preparations. Fluttershy's obvious grouchiness and bags under her eyes but still have the energy to put her animals first. The potion would also explain other things like how Starlight was sad and confused as she held her slit neck after coincidentally Twilight held shards of glass in her magic. Or how Pinkie's family didn't hear the noise AJ was creating but only came rushing down the stairs as Pinkie threw knives and burned the kitched down. And how Pound Cake ran away from her whe she tried to save him from the fire. Or, how Fluttershy's animals (mostly consisting of prey animals) were not sensing any danger even as Fluttershy irged them to run. But then again, Pinkie DOES have a lot of energy on ADHD insomia levels and Twilight is known to pull all nighters constantly and fret about celebrations. And Fluttershy could've been mad and drain from Rarity's extreme attention to very minor details. Maybe there was no potion at all. Maybe they all had seperate mental breaks with the stress and time of year. Or maybe, even c) Discord could be behind it all to break apart the elements of harmony. Guess we'll only know when the rest of the story comes out.
Jesus tap dancing Christ, I thought the first Apple Sleep experiment was messed up, but this is a whole other level of demented in the best way possible. Well done, Lost, you and the team have outdone yourselves again. The way the multiple narrators overlap and the visuals distort really allows us to see the deteriorating mental states of the characters. Also, I don’t think Applejack is there at all, like, this is all a hallucination from lack of sleep. Guess this makes the Mane 6 the experimented this time around….I cannot wait to see where this goes next.
“Animals don’t have cutie marks anyways”😦 Jesus bro this one was intense…
So Pinkie & Fluttershy are at a new low now. They betrayed their own identities. So I’ll take it that’s AJ’s plan, not to kill the other Mane 6 (excluding Starlight who took her place) but instead to make them every bit as low as she was forced to become.
I can scarcely wait to see how Rarity & Rainbow Dash are going to get their dues
... I get it now
*Spoilers*
Twilight must have given herself, Pinkie, and Fluttershy the Sleepless potion without knowing. Probably why the AJ Twilight said "Does that make me the experimenter or the experiment?" She used them to experiment on a new version of the potion.
Or Sweetie And Scootaloo spiked their drinks with the potion to get revenge for what happened to Apple Bloom and the rest of the Apples.
Oh I can't wait for what happens with Rarity and Rainbow.
I have a bad feeling Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo will be somehow involved…
@@tootsiepop13 maybe they spiked their drinks with the potion? It's all possible
@@KitsuneRokakuI was thinking more like “Applejack” was gonna kill them, but yeah maybe.
But that’s a theory…. A grim dark theory! 😃
SO COOL THE OWL HOUSE CREATURES ARE IN THE SCENE WITH FLUTTERSHY THROWING THEM OUT THE WINDOW!!😂❤
44:42 Listening to Flutters cry like that made ME cry! 😢 Whoever voiced her did an ASTONISHING AMAZING JOB!!!!!
Spoilers ahead
Oh my god.
She's not killing them herself. She's ruining their lives. Just like they did to her.
Killing Starlight, burning down Sugar Cube Corner, turning Fluttershy against her animals and vice versa...
It's heavily implied that Fluttershy is dead, but not confirmed. The horrors at play could be her killing her animals.
Twilight, Pinkie, and Fluttershy are forced to live in order to face the fact that their lives have been torn out from under them. AJ is making them suffer her nightmare.
I have no idea if AJ is real or just a hallucination shared by the rest of the Mane Cast, like others have suggested, but either way this is delicious poetic justice.
Brah what did pinkie pie do to her
I love this theory, it’s honestly very interesting and cool to think about
@@POOKESEE she didn't help her apparently, and believed the guards lies that she rejected her letters, she ruined her life for giving up on her. Really sad honestly.
How is it implied fluttershy died we left off with her killing a bear and fight smaller animals she can stomp on hell Applejack took a pause
There's no justice anywhere. Pinkie never did anything to her, neither did Starlight, or the Cakes she killed, or Fluttershy. If she just went after Twilight, then she'd have a justification, but she's became just an insane and vindictive killer. Either that or the theory that all the mane 6 somehow drank the sleepless potion is correct, although i really hope this isn't the case.
I can say that whatever pity felt for Applejack in the first story is gone in the sequel, since Applejack is hurting innocent ponies and this time she doesn't have a sleepless potion as an excuse. Something's for sure, tho, everyone's she's messing with seems to have come to the conclusion she has to be killed, so there is a chance they'll start hunting her down, and if that's gonna be the case, then, ngl, i'd look forward to seeing that hunt take place
Ok but did anybody notice the palisman from The Owl House at 39:50? And Flapjack eating flapjacks AGGGGGHHH SO CUUUTE!!!!
A nice little break from the psychological torment.
God, the first part of this video already got me unnerved...but the second part...I was left speechless. absolutely stunned and horrified.
38:22 Luz's palisment under fluttershy's hoof, Nice reference
i cannot be the only one who is on applejack's side. after all, twilight was the one who drove her to this level of pure insanity with the sleepless potion. she did try to warn applejack, yes, but applejack was trying to look out for her family. all she wanted to do was repay that debt of hers and her family's.
EDIT: i'm speaking *purely* about twilight here, not about any of the other mane six.
She's going too far. It's one thing to exact her revenge on the deserving, but Fluttershy and Pinkie were both too kind. Their "excuse" is that neither of them are really strong enough to stand up for themselves initially, usually being pushed to the limit before even considering it.
That just seems contrarian? Twilight wouldn't have fully understood the effects of the potion, and I think it's safe to assume would've tried damn hard to cure it. Even so, being a victim or of not sound mind doesn't _justify_ revenge - nothing does - especially if it involves committing such heinous violence upon innocents. You can't be held accountable necessarily, but you can't be dismissed to act as the "arbiter of justice" either, that's kind of ridiculous.
Applesleep is so emotionally gut-wrenching because there _is_ no one to blame; it's a tragic and needless cruelty, leaving so many with directionless, bottled-up guilt and grief. You don't have to be on anyone's "side". Uh, if you take this sequel at face value, at least, for now until we have more context...
She (Twilight) could have just payed her friend's dept and all of this would have never happened or got her and hr friends to help her xoxoxo
@@stardustandflames126 I'm gonna nna disagree with the revenge bit, because I think personally that it should've just been Twilight if anyone, as she kinda is the only one AJ actually blames. The rest..... She can be mad at them, but tearing their very lives apart seems a tad too far for my taste in vengeance.
I swear if Applejack hurts or kills my waifu in the next parts... ;-; I already have to deal with poor Dash dying in so much fanmade stuff...
Yk, I remember watching the first original story, and these new parts got me on the edge of my seat and DEFINENTLY not how I saw this story going. Well done, Lost!
I really admire how you guys can do all this as part of a big team of talented artists, actors and technicians.
This is about to be insane! An AJ vs. Twilight showdown! Happy ending or not this will be amazing!
Wow!!! Amazing continuation of the story! It’s so well written - AJ’s lines gave me goosebumps!! Editing really added to the dread and suspense and it paired so well with everybody’s voice acting talent and beautiful artwork. Once again, thank you all for your contribution and dedication!! Can’t wait to see what’s in the next part!! ❤️❤️❤️
I’m so excited for Part 2 tonight! More Applejack spooks 😈🍎
Same Too I Watched Part 1 it Was Amazing.I Have A Feeling This is Gonna be 20%Cooler
@@RazorStallion46 Agreed 😈🍎 let’s what happens next after P1~ ✨
Who bets Applejack ends up being cured in the end
46:26
Ok I'll admit, the glowing red eyes are pretty cool!
It's really interesting how the story mimics the first one! The first one ending in Twilight passing out, just like how Applejack did, and then the next scene being a young character being woken up by another character having seemingly stayed up all night in the kitchen...
Real quick before it's too late I'm going to drop my theory,
So the ongoing Theory right now is that all of this is going on in Twilight's head my theory is that what if all the friends are hallucinating?
Can't wait to see what happens in part 2!
Oh wow, got a couple theory’s in mind about what’s going on in all this. Almost feels like the girls are hallucinating all this, like they’ve been drugged with the same stuff apple jack was in the first Apple experiment. That or Apple jack “is” really there and one of the many potions she drank at twilights place gave her mind fuckery powers. Lol either way amazing work again guys, I’m loving where it’s all going and I can’t wait to see what’s in store for Rainbow dash and Rarity. 😈
For rainbow i cant think of anything but rarity omg that one could be soo brutal and so sad i could end up feeling awful for rarity but yeah rainbow i got nothing but hbu watcha think?
@@latesonic2006 as to who’s getting the most brutal punishment out of the two? Rainbow honestly, feel like her and Apple Jack shared the tightest friendship.
🎶 I know what darkness means...(and the void you left for me....) The isolation stings....(so thick it wants to bleed...) The echoes in my brain.. (all the things you said to me.....) You took my everything....(Now I'm coming for you!!)
I won't back down! I will not bow! (I come to bring you Hell.....) And I can't forget, the things you did!! (I come to bring you Hell....)
The shadows that you see... (in the places that you sleep....) Are memories of me.... (better pray your soul to keep....) The truth behind your eyes! (You know, the thing ya never see....) Your darkest little lies....(I'M COMING FOR YOU!!)
I won't BACK DOWN!!! I will not BOW! (I come to bring you Hell.....) And I can't FORGET! The things you did!! (I come to bring you Hell....)🎶
Applejack singing "Won't Back Down" by Fuel.
AJ hitting us with the Mortal Combat “Finish her”, loved this!
Okay so all of the main 6 are somehow affected by the same thing Twilight was in the first. Applejack is also definitely not real. Considering the fact both Twilight Fluttershy and Pinkie aren’t sleeping and are both shown to be very twitchy (and the voice distortions) I’m assuming it is the sleep potion amplifying their emotions and causing them to see Applejack (like how the potion amplified Applejacks rage and made her see Filthy Rich) but I don’t know how they all ingested the potion. Also my god Pinkie killing the entire pie family except pound and Fluttershy killing all her animals 0-0
You mean she killed most of the "Cake Family" and left Pound as an orphan.
@@RedWolf777SG I mean it could also be, killed Mrs cake, manslaughtered Mr cake and Pumpkin and left Pound as an orphan.
I was there for the premiere and the amount of people who genuinely despise Twilight for all of this is somewhat disconcerting. That aside, this was very enjoyable to watch and I can’t wait for the next installment
Why is it disconcerting??
@@reap3514 I mean like Twilight isn’t entirely innocent I’ll admit (considering she’s the one who gave AJ the potion in the first place) but I feel like it was Filthy Rich who actually pushed AJ over the edge. Could just be me though.
Also I just like Twilight in general
Yeah this whole situation is a little more complex
I guess people are angry at her for actually abandoning Aj, hiding the truth about why she went nuts and trying to gaslight Aj into believing it's her fault alone. And from what we saw she didn't really stop experimenting with potions of the same kind that driven her friend to insanity. So understandable that people are angry at her mostly. Because FR is dead already anyway.
@@K1ttyGam3rthis version of twilight did nothing to help AJ and pinned all the blame on her knowing her potion was causing applejack extra stress. I say this version cause OG Twilight would of had a fit if anything like this happened to her friends
I don't think people hate twilight, just this version of her. And rightfully so, along with her friends if Pinkys section is true and they all knew or had some idea.
Chapter 2 was absolutely spectacular and sensational Lost! I loved every second of it, It would definitely worth the wait and once again both the art and voice acting was all done ever so marvelously make no mistake about it, Major props and kudos to everyone who participated in bringing this vid to life you all did such an incredible and fantastic job! Simply glorious work!!!
The deaths are so sus. I think the others are on the same pathway as AJ did, but not in the sense that they’ll have the same outcome. Plus, the victims could have easily been killed by the mane 6
Oh the deaths are gay
Applejack might have created a new problem, Flutterdoom.
THE OWL HOUSE CAMEO AAA!
THIS ENTIRE PRODUCTION WAS SO FREAKING IMPRESSIVE.
I finally got to hear this and damn, the voice acting was outstanding!! I love the voices when their losing their mind, it's to good and different and excited how Rarity's and rainbow dash scene will go.
Im beleving that AppleJack was never real theory.
Mostly bc of the echos Fluddershy and Pinkie Pie are having like how AppleJack had.
Also none of Fludder's animals noticed applejack so shes possibly a hallucination created by something. Possibly caused by sleepless nights working twords the celebration
I agree with the theory that the remaining mane 6 are hallucinating, especially with the way apple is described in the fire during pinkies part, then theres how apple found twi's hidden lab and got past a magic lock
Yea it’s all so..suspicious and coincidental (impossibly coincidental). Plus her injuries from each pony she terrorizes doesn’t get described by the next main 6 members. Neither Pinkie nor Flutters mentioned cuts (from the glass with Twilight or the other injuries she might of had I forgor), and Flutters doesn’t mention burns or caramel..she’s also the only one to mention glowing red eyes and that weird possession ability
The reference to that gag in the show where she gives the bear a massage was funny 😂 scary, but funny
APPLEJACK GOT THE SHOVEL.
She got Shelia!
Make a bet when part three comes out Fluttershy is going to be mortally wounded, but all those animals died. And the next time you see Applejack, she’s going to actually have a notable injury.
If you listen closely during the Fluttershy section, you can hear the thoughts of some of the animals peeking through. Some notable examples I caught were “but we’re hungryyyyy” as Fluttershy tries to shoo them out, and “Is she okay?” As attention is brought to Angelbunny
Im in love/obsessed with how this story is going and I can't wait for part 3! Love your narration for these and i also love that the fact that Scribbler is also narrating a little as well!
Anticipating the next part! Ive listened to these 2 parts 5 times now because i cant get enough!
Kill #2: Ms.Cake
Cause Of Death: Knife thrown into her chest by Pinkie Pie after she succumbed to The Sleepless Potion; Burned alive in house explosion.
Kill #3-4: Mr.Cake and Pumpkin Cake.
Cause Of Death: Burned alive in house explosion.
Note: If any of these characters revealed to be alive by the end of the story(which i doubt they will be), their deaths will be taken off the count.
and pound cake?
@@woodkiller4496 Pinkie Pie managed to save him from the fire before Sugarcube Corner exploded.
@@woodkiller4496 he ran away after pinkie got him out
@kennybesore2005 you're right
What about Fluttershy? Did she actually died here?
Considering that the Potion took over Aj is crazy. I do have theory about Filthy rich and the others. Twilight took the potion and gave her a SMALL anmesia. She confronted Aj saying she doesn't remember giving it to her. (Definitely the side effects of the potion she took) it wasn't completely twilight's fault. Applejack is at fault too. But in reality the true fault is The potion. I'll probably do alot of theories about this.
Me: *comes in and see what's happening*
Also me: I guess I come at a bad timing *walking backwards while closing the door*
Aaple jack and pinkie fighting in the kitchen-
The cake family casually Sleeping through the Chaos-
47:34 fluttershys scream here is just so..wow
I wanna thank everyone who made this possible this was a good audio book and a good read on fimfiction thank you all for your hard work and dedication for bringing this fic to life and thank you to all the voice actors for doing fantastic work this was beautiful I also want to thank you for still bringing out g4 mlp content I appreciate everyone and the content y’all make I hope yall doing well and having a good life ❤🎉😊
Aw yeah this
38:28 don’t tell me that is string bean in the corner, from TOH.
Wow that was incredible!! I haven’t felt a rush like that for such a long time!! The scenes with fluttershy were flawless, gave me chills. I was right to be so excited. Can’t wait for what’s to come! ❤️
Fluttershy could've become an Evil Animal Emperor...Or this...Thing...But this is Amazing!Can'not wait for Part 2!!!
I think you mean part 3
Yes Part 3@@Deadmothdonoteat
Pound cake is going to need therapy after what happened, i feel awful for him. And i wonder if it was actually Apple jack there, what if it was Pinkie pie who did it like others had said? good fanfic
Who else recognized the palismen?
also, I like how with Fluttershy, AJ’s voice isn’t so deep and gravely, instead she sounds just the way she did before the whole disaster. It sounds like the Applejack that Fluttershy once knew. And that’s what makes all her degradation hurt even worse.
Just got better. I like how aj was done. Looks like no one but her friends can see her. Either aj died or all those potions she drank turned her into a actual demon. I'm looking forward to next part to know how this going to turn out. ^^
Aint no way applejack is real, the fire didnt even burn her.
Ive also noticed each of them see applejack differently, twilight saw her without her hat, no more than a skeleton. Pinkie saw her with her hat, messy but not emaciated with her toolbelt, and fluttershy saw her with her hat and muddy, but her fur is still bright orange and she ONLY had the shovel. Not to mention her voice is slighty different to each pony.
Given the close timeline of their encounters, this raises suspicions.
Incredible video, each of the Mane Six is losing what/who was most dear to them the way Applejack lost Applebloom due to the potion
IMO there's two possibilities to explain what's going on
1. Applejack isn't there, she's actually dead (might have died soon after the first story considering how Pinkie's mail got returned) and the other Mane Six ingested the sleep potion either by accident or on purpose to get everything ready for the memorial
2. Applejack did escape but she hasn't done anything other than somehow slip the others the no sleep potion, causing them to hallucinate and destroy everything they hold dear the same way Applejack did. She's somewhere near by watching the carnage unfold
MOOOOOORRRREEEE!!! HOWDY I'D LIKE TO TAKE A MOMENT TO APPRECIATE THIS I'M EXITED TO SEE WHAT HAPPENS NEXT Y'ALL!
my theory is this is all in their minds, they all drank the potion to keep up with the party stuff and are all under its affects
There’s no way they would willingly take the potion.
39:30 i see those TOH palismen!!
Flapjack and Waffle eating flapjacks and waffles is so cute
This just gets scarier and scarier! Absolutely brilliant job on the reading!
39:49 the owl house reference to lighten the mood just a bit :) you can see multiple palismen in the room.
Spooky horse reading time. Huzzah. I love Lost's readings as they are more than just stories, they are a plethora of sense and information.
16:50-17:01
APPLEJACK GETS HER REVENGE LETS GOOOOOOOO
Gonna watch it before seeing Trolls Band Together!!!! 😁 Applejack looks possessed somepony call an exorcist! 😧
Part 2 Was a BANGER!!!!!!!! I Can't WAIT To See What Part 3 Has In STORE FOR US!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 1:01:25
I have a feeling Apple Jack never escaped. Either dead or still alive but still in her prison. Even if she did escape it's merely impossible for her to go unnoticed. Twilight's discription of A.J sounds like the most likely way A.J would look since she would probably be aware of A.J's condition.however i think everyone is sleep deprived. Either twilight tested a potion or they are just depriving themselves of sleep by themselves or it could be a different reason.they are all hillucinating and here's why i think that's the case:
Twilight having a secret room that no one seems to know about and the door is locked by magic. No way AJ could get in there before her. Twilight is also the kind of person to obsess over things and takes them too far at times. The fact that twilight is unable to open the door is something.either locked from the other side or starlight was locking it with magic ((the latter can only be the case if twilight was chasing a hillucination and scared starlightght)) magic bounced off the castle door was a bit off. Not sure if the door is like that because of what its made of. I noticed a few people bring up Starlights confusion . I think she was confused because she could not exactly tell what twilight was saying because she is bleeding to death here but also that Twilight accidentally killed her
Pinkie is a bit more clear. She looks HELLA SLEEP DEPRIVED so she is more likely to hillucinate on her own even without a potion. She's been making treats non stop so it makes sense.she sees AJ way differently compared to twilight and unlike twi being blamed for how AJ ended up pinkie sees AJ as an old friend that felt betrayed and forgotten.someone she gave up on and she feels guilty about it. Notice how the cakes SOMEHOW don't hear AJ nor Pinkie. I think they did and probably noticed Pinkie acting off and talking to something that's not there but feels real. The sceane where pinkie throws the knives could have been a result of her accidentally killing mrs cake .the cakes don't seem to react to AJ before this at all . The fire is told to be pinkie's doing fore being careless .and AJ stayed in the fire as if she is immune clearly not possible
Fluttershy is already tired and has been so busy that she was unable to take care of her animal friends properly for probably dayd And this time the animals decided to act on instinct to attack her. After she kills the bear the rest of the animals attack her for it .the betrayal of Fluttershy killing one of them plus their hunger amplified their violent behaviour . AJ is seen as someone that can control the animals and is discribed way differenly here too . But fluttershy's cottage is on the otherside of ponyville (correct me if i am wrong) how has no one spotted her or heard her. With broken hined legs there is no way she would be fast let alone get to fluttershy's cottage THAT quickly without being seen after the fire at sugar cube corner. Notice how AJ only appears when the girls alone befor anyone dies
I love the tones and shifts we got with Applejack in this one, it feels so out of reality and within reality. If we didn't have the distortions, I'd say Applejack was just going through some mood crisis after all those years and was approaching in different behaviors because of who she was dealing with due to her past experiences with them.
45:25 OKAY, this drawing made my eyes widen slightly with how demonic and crazed Applejack looked.
Of course I'm siding with the fact that this could all be some horrid nightmarish allusion built up by their paranoia, stress and guilt all weighing heavily on their shoulders.
Or Twilight never learning her lesson and giving altered versions of the potion causing each other the mane six to have different horrible outcomes to how it changed their behavior and the hallucinations that came with it.
Some part of me feels like this will end with Twilight being thrown in the same prison cell where Applejack laid imprisoned and instead of seeing an empty room? It'd be a corpse instead as the terrifying reality connects with Twilight that Applejack NEVER escaped causing her to rethink and soon remember everything as how it TRULY was instead of what her stress and over pressured work life showed within the allusion of her madness growing of all the possible factors (that never happened-) causing her to have some kind of mental snap.
//
Anyway, I wanted to explain some wish I had when I saw Pinkie Pie was going to be the first to be bothered by this dark presence. When Applejack basically said her whole façade was basically bullcrap and all those morbid thoughts were going through Pinkie's head while trying to outrun "Applejack" I was hoping she'd snap and we'd see some Pinkamena Diane Pie moment where'd we see one morbid figure against another who struggled to keep her demons inside, only reason why I wanted this was I wanted to hear Applejack say along the lines of..
"I guess we all have our inner demons huh, Pinkamena..?"
"Here I thought I was the only boogiemare in ponyville, but I guess two monsters occupy this space huh, Pinkie Pie?"
"Here I assumed you had nothing but sunshine and rainbows as you kept saying, but I guess I broke what was left of that right, Pinkie Pie?"
I dunno, my imagination is vast and goes all over the space so I thought it wouldn't been a cool little badass moment or scene, I knew it'd never happen but that doesn't stop my mind from hoping and wondering of these "What Ifs" ya know? Thanks for reading my messy comment lol.
29:30 Since Pinkie was left alive, my personal theory for this stories end game is that once every other member of the mane six is dead, Pinkie is going to come back for one last showdown with Applejack to seek revenge for the cake's deaths
No matter what happens, I'm sure it'll be awesome! ❤
Oh, they're working overnight and denying help?
Oh, where did i see that before.....?
i must say what a performance! I haven't seen anything this entertaining since 1929. so many orphans