The Myth of the Andalusian Paradise - Spanish Reconquista Documentary
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ส.ค. 2024
- How hard was life as a Christian in Muslim Spain?
Well life as a Jewish Person or Christian in Al-Andalus, as Muslim Spain was called back, then was anything but easy.
Support me on Patreon via here: / post_tenebras
Remember to follow me on Instagram
/ post_tenebrastv
Join our chat on Telegram
t.me/Post_Tenebras_Free_Talk
Paradise or Hell 00:00
The Conquest of Spain 01:18
Battle of Covadonga 02:25
Al-Andalus 03:04
Being a Dhimmi 03:53
Paying Jizya 04:34
Other disadvantages 05:56
Lack of protection 07:20
Places of worship 09:19
Expulsion 09:39
Taifas 10:52
Human value 12:21
The Harems 13:48
The Reconquista 15:23
Romanticizing Al-Andalus 16:10
Al-Andalus in Academia 17:38
Qatar and universities 18:54
The positive 19:43
In total 20:14
![แฮงแงงแฮงงาม - บอย ศิริชัย [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vCGJTy9ZeP8/mqdefault.jpg)
Colonization is bad unless it’s from non Europeans, then it’s a good thing 😂
What is your point? It appears to be: "We can criticize European Conization, and blame it for present day ills, but please don't point out the fact Europeans themselves were Colonized and enslaved and raped, because... " Wait, why? Why do you want to suppress history that fairly chronicles a time? And attribute historical accounts as some sort of offense? Why are you so biased and Euro-phobic?
I have always joked about this to my friends 😂
I cannot believe you have only 1500 subscribers! This is some top tier content!
I'm from India, this is not just a western academic issue, but a universal issue. In india far-left academicians publish books romanticising Islamic invaders and their architectures by carefully deducting jizya, apartheid suffered by local population. Those who counter it by publishing critical books we're called islamaphobes.
Jizya lmao. You don't even know the definition of it. US citizens pay 30% , jizya is 2.5%-5% for males. Cry about it.
@@justahuman00If you don’t pay your taxes you get your assets seized. If you don’t pay the Jizya you die, get expelled from your land, or become a slave.
Also the Jizya is humiliating. So, you pay for the Jizya and stop listening to your imam’s propaganda.
There is reason india and israel 🇮🇱 are friends
@@jamesbrowning9210 Cow worshiping? Lack of conscience? Paganism? Flexible religion? Deceivers?
@@justahuman00 Another lying Moose Lem.
Excellent! We must make justice to History. Sine ira et studio, but telling the harsh truth.
Thank you so much I really appreciate it and yeah we indeed need too.
On that note where did you encounter the video?
I like this Tenebras guy. Informative and very high energy! Very cool!
Wow, what an amazing video, I'm blown away by your editing skills, is hard to find this good quality videos anymore, keep up with the good work! 😁
😀🌱
Iron sharpens Iron
Hidden Message in the
Torah /Tanak / Bible
You are Not Alone
Hidden within within your genealogy , The first Sons from Adam. Genesis 5 : 3-32
NAMES ---- Name
MEANINGS
Adam - Man
Seth - Appointed
Enos - Mortal
Cainan - Sarrow
Mahalaleel - Blessed GOD
Jared - Shall come Down
Enoch - Teaching
Methuselah -His Death shall
Bring
Lamech -To Make /Low
Mighity
Noah -Rest / Favor /
Fulfilled
Name Meanings : written in a
Sentence 😳
Man appointed mortal Sarrow Blessed GOD shall come down
teaching His death shall bring to make low/MIGHTY , rest favor FULFILLED
My Interpretation:
Jesus given a task to preform from this earth feeling of deep distress BLESSED GOD shall come down as Jesus teaching Jew as a Rabbi His death shall bring SALVATION to make low to hang on a tree becomes MIGHTY rest/ favor/ FULFILLED HIS Purpose 🤔
Keep this in mind 🤔all 10 generations timeline took place up to chapter 5 of Genesis ,Hidden Message telling Jesus COMING 😲
Approximately 4 thousand years later before it HAPPENED ! Only God
Ten Trillion people could not have placed 1 fact and placed it in a book Foretelling of there coming Christ 4K years before it Happened
Who is He ?
THE LORD JESUS CHRIST
JESUS was a JEW
Choose you this day whom you
SERVE 🤔✝️😇😇
Take my yoke upon you for it is LIGHT and EASY
Jesus Loves You
Believe ON THE LORD JESUS CHRIST
You are BORN AGAIN
See you on the Clouds
Rapture any Second
Snatching away , have no FEAR it is not Death
Extra
For what shall it profit a man,
If he shall gain the whole world,
And lose his his own soul !🤔
Thank you so much I truely appreciate it.
Tak for en spændende og enormt velproduceret video. Jeg vidste ingenting om Andalusien, udover at det havde været muslimsk i den tidlige middelalder.
Tusind tak for din fede kommentar.
Jeg er glad for at du godt kan lide videoens stil og fandt den informativ.
Det er tragisk hvordan vi får så lidt at vide udover "pop-history" hvilket giver den almindelige person et totalt forvrænget billede af vores historie.
Lad os håbe at videoen får nogle flere seere så jeg kan lave om på det!
Subscribed and Post notifications on. Saw your John Cantlie documentary, and came back to check out the channel. Very good content. I love how you touch on topics main stream media rarely covers.
I appreciate how you're able to give different perspectives on al Andalus without completely demonizing Islam as a whole. Much of the discourse surrounding this religion historically is almost always one-sided and often, I find, the truth lies somewhere between the dominant narratives.
Yeah I wasn't trying to demonize any faith or come with any ridiculous generalizations since that obviously doesn't represent reality and such a long period is naturally complex.
My point was simple to dispel this purely political myth.
I'm also quite interested in religion and when you truely start reading it becomes obvious that many interpretations and iterations of practically any larger belief system exists
So all in all much appreciated!
@@posttenebras Islam is not the religion of peace.
@@posttenebras Sadly what the Mohammedans did in Spain they're doing to West Africa. Please faithful Catholics and heretic Protestants as well are being persecuted particularly Nigerian Catholics who according to one study has the highest rate of Mass attention.I don't want to demonize Islam. BTW Maliki Islam is also the dominant Islamic thought in West Africa with Tijanni school so many commonalities. I believe what happened in Spain will happen in West Africa. If you a Catholic pray for Catholics in West Africa. Pray please.
@@posttenebrasI think there is no doubt that when Muslims first conquer Islamic Spain that Jews felt they were getting a better deal. Whuch they were compared to their previous visigothic rulers. And I do believe that there was a golden age of Muslim Spain when it comes to tolerance. But this golden age was a golden age for the Christian and Jewish elites living in the urban centers for about 150 years.
Hello, based department? You guys might want to take a look at this:
Excellent
based
Great and incredidbly important video
Thank you so much, and I'm glad you think so!
It isn't
@@justahuman00It is.
@@diogobarata6346 It isn't. It is for academically and intellectually weak morons.
Just take a look at the pact of Umar and tell me how other Abrahamic faiths were treated, and that's not even talking about Hindu's and other faiths in other parts of the world. And I don't even blame them minority populations ruling places often had to rule with a hard hand, who I do blame is academia, media, politicians etc etc who try to make that period be something it was not for politcal clout.
Exactly, the pact of Umar is very clear when it comes to how society should be structured for non Muslims but they act like it doesn't exist but that Qatari money at least has to be good right? 😂
As a portuguese person, thank you for the amazing video!
Btw, could tell me what was your source here 5:10-5:16 please?
SNEED
Just discovered your channel! Amazing content!!! Keep grinding, my man
I live in Brazil and I would love to hear a video about the current party elected for presidency (PT - “Worker’s Party”).
Just to let you know, our current president, Lula, was condemned for money laundering and corruption (millions of dollars involved). These actions were made when he was the former president (2003-2011).
But then, in a completely political decision, our Supreme Court set him free and made him eligible.
Now, even freedom of speech is threatened here.
Cheers!
You should get a twitter acc
pulitzer is read pewlitzer not pullitz
good video
would you be interested in producing a german version?
cheers
Yeah that would be very cool if that's something you are interested in and ah thanks I'm gonna remember that
If you want to talk more about a potential German version feel free to write me on Instagram or Telegram
Among others world famous islamic arquitectural treasures ; the Palace of Alhambra in Granada; the Cathedral- mosque of Córdoba and Palace of Reales Alcázares in Seville UNESCO jewels possibly except taj- mahal the most beatiful exemples of art in islamic arquitecture ; Alhambra is the 2nd position in enciclopaedia británica in artistic value in islamic arquitecture and mosque of Córdoba in 7th position; today ; Cristian place of worship in Cathedral- Mosque of Cordoba after the " reconquista " and Palace use exemples with Alhambra or Reales Akcazares; they were much more refined which does not mean that they were good in general; i think the moors mostly ;seen the inmense beauty this these sites
The Cathedral-Mosque of Cordoba was a church originally
@@posttenebras originated is a mosque construction in 784 ; the teory It was earlier church IS not very among the experts there is talk of the cult of San Vicente mártyr ; but others historias disagree the closest data to the catholic church was in xll century with the Cristian conquest i am a spanish Cristian born in Córdoba and i know plenty what is in almost all.islamic countries
the moops did nothing of value.
Good video, what is the source of churches destroyrd/converted? Need it for arguments
The Mosque-Cathedral of Córdoba is a great example
PLS BLIV MED MED AT UPLAODE BROR
Bare rolig det kommer jeg skam også til, en ny video er på vej lige nu.
Desuden mange tak for støtten!
Are you deleting my comments bruh? 😢😂
Well they conquered a lot themselves I guess it was karma
This happened a loooong time before the colonization of America
Did Europe "deserve" to be conquered because its NOT YET CREATED colonial empires?
What are your sources? A lot of this is news to me and some of what you've said is blatantly wrong. I'd like to review them if I can.
Hey I tried to post a lot of my sources in the video but much of it can be found in "the myth of the Andalusian paradise" which I highly recommend reading if you have time.
What are the specific things you found that you think are blatantly incorrect?
@@posttenebras I'll definitely check it out, thank you!
A few of the things you mentioned like Zoroastrians being "People of the Book" and the way Jizya was collected were incorrect. I can make a full list another time when I've gather sources but for now, I'll just mention these 2:
Very few, if any, scholars of Islam claim that Zoroastrians are considered among Christians, Jews, and Sabians to be People of The Book.
Jizya, despite having a different purpose than Zakat and other taxes, was often collected in much the same way as any other tax would, not by brutalizing the people who owed it. It was also only to be levied on able-bodied, battle aged non-Muslim men.
@@pyrosimba2014 with regards to the definition of "people of the book" it's totally true that it depends on the interpretation but since I wasn't going to make islamic law the main focus of the video in any way shape or form I didn't decide to go into that more than needed and with regards to how the jizya is paid my source is within "the myth of the andalusian paradise" just "search" jizya within the book and you can find the part with furthering sources.
I appreciate your genuine interest in actually finding the truth and being critical.
@@pyrosimba2014those were the people who could afford the judges you. And if the people who had to pay the jizya didn't pay it they would be killed as well as there would be enslavement for the non-paying dhimmi
The book you’ve suggested reading to others “The Myth” has itself been described and reviewed by others in academia as itself a Myth…oh wait, all the other academics are all in on this big lie because they all got that rich arab money therefore we can’t trust what they say according to you and we can only trust you(!)
Oh and also this book is written by a dude who couldn’t even study the source material in it’s original language and relied heavily on translations. Go figure! Imagine all his ideas were misinterpreted because he simply did not have access to the language the source material was in, how much material was he forced to over look? Maybe there were untranslated sources of info that COULD’VE led him to other conclusions? Oh well, guess we’ll never know because all we have to do is JUST TRUST YOU(!).
Be honest with me dude, you’re just here to get some of that rich arab moneyz too😅 i mean, you shamelessly plugged in your patreon links after “poisoning the well” so it does seem like you’re only in it for personal financial gain and not so much the Truth.
Oh and one more thing, do you realise you and perhaps a bunch of crazy extremists may have something in common- you may both share the same views and interpret verses of the quran and hadith in the same extremists ways 😂
I sure hope you don’t.
Accept the facts bro😂
What matters is what Muslims in medieval Spain believed and practiced when studying the history
The book has not been considered a myth. The criticisms it got were for not addressing problems in Christian Spain, which is absolutely a ridiculous point, because the book is focused on Al-Andalus.
@@CarlJancorda But you are not accepting the facts
😀🌱
Iron sharpens Iron
Hidden Message in the
Torah /Tanak / Bible
You are Not Alone
Hidden within within your genealogy , The first Sons from Adam. Genesis 5 : 3-32
NAMES ---- Name
MEANINGS
Adam - Man
Seth - Appointed
Enos - Mortal
Cainan - Sarrow
Mahalaleel - Blessed GOD
Jared - Shall come Down
Enoch - Teaching
Methuselah -His Death shall
Bring
Lamech -To Make /Low
Mighity
Noah -Rest / Favor /
Fulfilled
Name Meanings : written in a
Sentence 😳
Man appointed mortal Sarrow Blessed GOD shall come down
teaching His death shall bring to make low/MIGHTY , rest favor FULFILLED
My Interpretation:
Jesus given a task to preform from this earth feeling of deep distress BLESSED GOD shall come down as Jesus teaching Jew as a Rabbi His death shall bring SALVATION to make low to hang on a tree becomes MIGHTY rest/ favor/ FULFILLED HIS Purpose 🤔
Keep this in mind 🤔all 10 generations timeline took place up to chapter 5 of Genesis ,Hidden Message telling Jesus COMING 😲
Approximately 4 thousand years later before it HAPPENED ! Only God
Ten Trillion people could not have placed 1 fact and placed it in a book Foretelling of there coming Christ 4K years before it Happened
Who is He ?
THE LORD JESUS CHRIST
JESUS was a JEW
Choose you this day whom you
SERVE 🤔✝️😇😇
Take my yoke upon you for it is LIGHT and EASY
Jesus Loves You
Believe ON THE LORD JESUS CHRIST
You are BORN AGAIN
See you on the Clouds
Rapture any Second
Snatching away , have no FEAR it is not Death
Extra
For what shall it profit a man,
If he shall gain the whole world,
And lose his his own soul !🤔
Sir this is a Wendy's
That's what we call Islamophobia briefly
History?
Nothing can stop you!!! Become a YT god = Promo_SM!