What Broke The U.S. Immigration System?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 มี.ค. 2024
- 2023 saw record-breaking numbers of migrant crossings at the southwestern border, with Border Patrol reporting nearly 250,000 encounters in December alone. But today, less than 1% of those looking to reside permanently in the U.S. can do so legally, according to CATO. The Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse estimates that the immigration court currently has a backlog of over 3 million cases. So how did the immigration system in the U.S. get so broken? And can it ever be fixed?
In the U.S., 62.6% of permanent resident, or “green,” cards go toward family-sponsored immigrants, compared with just 21.1% for employment-based sponsorships, according to the Department of Homeland Security. Cato Institute estimates that just 1 in 1,500 new hires in the U.S. receives a green card through employment sponsorship programs.
The U.S. legal immigration system is in dire need of reform to make it work for the U.S. economy, experts say.
“I think the limitations for the numbers of annual immigrants was last updated in 1990 when our population was smaller and when the kinds of work that we did in this country was different,” Brown said.
Simon Hankinson, a senior research fellow at the Heritage Foundation, said, “What I would like to see are reforms to make the majority of people who come here legally as immigrants to come because our economy needs them.”
Watch the video to see why the U.S. is having so much trouble solving the immigration crisis.
Chapters:
00:58 Legal pathways
04:12 Border security
08:55 Political stalemate
Producer: Juhohn Lee
Editor: Nora Rappaport
Animations: Jason Reginato
Supervising Producer: Lindsey Jacobson
Additional Footage: Getty Images
» Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBC
» Subscribe to CNBC TV: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCtelevision
About CNBC: From 'Wall Street' to 'Main Street' to award winning original documentaries and Reality TV series, CNBC has you covered. Experience special sneak peeks of your favorite shows, exclusive video and more.
Want to make extra money outside of your day job? Take CNBC’s new online course How to Earn Passive Income Online to learn about common passive income streams. Register today and save 50% with discount code EARLYBIRD: cnb.cx/3Iwblnk
Connect with CNBC News Online
Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedInCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/InstagramCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
Follow CNBC on Threads: cnb.cx/threads
Follow CNBC News on X: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
#CNBC
What Broke The U.S. Immigration System?
because the us government doesn’t want it solved. saved you guys 12 minutes 😅
Not because the gov doesn’t want it solved lmao It’s because it’s impossible to accommodate a billion immigrants. Learn economics it’s literally how the world works 😅 4:20 is what I'm talking about, for those who asked
A billion immigrants? Lol bro there is only 320 Million people on the US wtf are you talking about? @@JamWell
All by design
💯
@@JamWellthe US is not responsible for the entire world population. Gov needs to take care of their own citizens.
Illegal immigration not immigration.
This is what blows my mind. This lady is saying "we are seeing a lot of immigration because employers are looking to hire". Excuse me, what? Some uneducated non-English speaking 28 year old from El Salvador with 4 kids decided to illegally enter because he heard Goldman Sachs is hiring?
Immigration is the international movement of people to a destination country of which they are not usual residents or where they do not possess nationality in order to settle as permanent residents
@@nieshamccoy9419cool. They are still illegal
If they're seeking asylum they are not illegal
@@soastersoas5827gotta go to a port of entry to claim asylum. These people aren’t.
Politicians could’ve fixed this problem a long time ago, but they didn’t want to fix it because it’s not profitable for them to fix the problem. It’s profitable for them to leave the system broken.
Yeap agreed, but you have to ask, how many lives killed because of fentanyl & Billions from hard working Americans has been spent to illegal immigrants' luxury hotel, food, legal fees and healthcare? These are vote buying schemes spearheaded by Biden & Democrats to intentionally turn them to voters at the expense of Americans
@cedricjackson7521President Trump did fix it.
down with biden
@@sn0_ We will all have an opportunity in November, including some og the 10 million illegal aliens Biden has let into the country.
Trump just torpedoed the bipartisan border patrol backed bill so he could keep the problem and campaign on the issue. That really happened. Look it up
The government should fine employers who hire undocumented workers or people who pay "under the table."
Right, cap the legal immigrant allowed per year, but just allow everyone in if you are illegally entering is a great solution..... Then complaint that immigration is important to our sustainability. Why not increase the cap for legally entering instead?
Well, that's why it is broken and needs reform, but both side won't work together because of politics.
Totally underrated comment
Because immigration is not important for our sustainability. We don't need more dishwashers from South America, Africa, Middle East. If you want to let anyone in, it should only be people in specialized career fields, it should be temporary, and they should be from other first world countries as to not lower our standard of living. The founders would have never let in millions of third worlders.
“Why not increase the cap for legally entering instead?”
I wonder if it’s partially due to housing limitations. I didn’t look up exact numbers but it seems we have a somewhat unique issue, in the US, where we have a lot of real estate that’s not developed let alone options for residency & quality of living (eg: Midwestern territory, blank and open for infrastructure development). If the resources were made available for such a project; it would provide a very quick outlet for resettlement, further warranting an increase in the immigrant-count/annum limit. But idk, economics is out of my wheelhouse; wouldn’t be surprised if I was missing quite a few details
But who will vote to ban Tiktok if we switch to immigration reform
It can be solved. No one in power has the stones to do the necessary.
One man does
Stop voting for democrats!!!!!!
@@mwyeh768how did that work out tho
they wanted chaos, and their plan is working. don't you see Biden is working hard to fight TX, keeping the border open?
Lol.. they are all blackmailed.. hahahha
The dual citizens are running this
why cant i find an entry level job if the economy is booming
Because the economy is not booming.
It's a relative boom I guess. Booming when compared to the rest of the world, and when compared to what it was like a year ago. Not booming compared to "normal times".
The booming economy is for the rich
Because there hiring immigrants with fake papers basically there favoring them blame white people
Who else learned absolutely nothing???
I learned that people breaking immigration laws means that the immigration system is broken.
CNBC is good at going into every minute detail of the problem without building up to a conclusion. Old media habits die hard I guess. I like the approach of HowMoneyWorks, who proposes a thesis and then argues it.
I learned Media part of the problem by down playing crimes based on their color
@@Radi0he4d1 It's hard to arrive on a conclusion when the left is encouraging this "migrations". 😅
CNBC LOVES immigration, its designed to waste your time saying so much while not actually saying anything at all
As a legal immigrant and a tax payer, it’s insulting to us if illegal immigration takes precedence over legal.
Not to mention the current wait times to get a green card on employment based sponsorship. Current estimates are around 20+ years for a majority of the legal immigrants
And now the waitlist will be massive after Biden’s first term. I pray he’s gone and Texas can slow it down
And then y’all start problems with gangs and theft 🤣
@@Will-ck7hi You think this is all one side? America has been encouraging migrants to come to the US since the beginning of the 1900s and made no effort to organize migration. In recent decades, American politicians from the left and right have benefited from their never-implemented "plans" for the border and immigration so they have no reason to fix it. Betsy Devos' family adoption organization made lots of money off "placing" immigrant children in homes via government funds. Just like homelessness, immigration is most beneficial to everyone at the top left a mess and until they can't make money off it nothing will change.
@@Will-ck7hiBiden's only term*.
@@AwesomeHairoI pray you’re right. He can’t make any decision on his own and created this crisis.
as a latino with parents that immigrated to us , i think its unfair for ppl who do thing right and have to wait and spend money to get in to this country , that ppl just cross the border and are given priority and resource based on what they say ,i belive legal immigration just like my parents you cant just cut the line and be rewarded
@lilblackfish2009 But President Biden has created a system where you can.
@@dennisweidner288thats why as a latino and a product of legal immigration iam for TRUMP , make it make scene !
@@lilblackfish2009 Latinos will play a major role in the coming election.
These people are American like you.....
@@bmc868 Crossing the border illegally in no way makes these people American citizens.
Let’s not forget. Hard working Americans’ paycheck will go towards taking care of illegal immigrants. $150 billion. And illegal immigrants still pocket zero taxed paychecks. Yet many Americans still about how to take care of our family, bills and future retirements. It’s a beautiful world
I know illegal immigrants that get mad because that have to pay taxes, but they still get government help for their kids....
So they always look for jobs that pay under the table
I'm a Mexican/ American
I feel bad for all those who fought so hard for this country back then during wars. 😢 RIP to those.
The vets? Yeah It's a pity :/
A big part of the problem is Latin America. I'm in Mexico and Obrador has OUR southern border here completely open with absolutely no restrictions. It's a mess on BOTH SIDES.
What is your point? Mexico don't have the luxury to spend more in immigration, and even if do, now the south mexican border will be overwhelmed and will make a problem between mexico, Guatemala and Belize
you should be president of mexico
@@linuxsisschannel8602 You didn't understand what I said? My point is that Andrés Manuel López Obrador has MY southern border here completely open. So that's a huge part of the problem as to why there are so many migrants on YOUR southern border. All the Latin American countries here are to blame as well. And right now it will be bye Obrador but here comes his puppet who is sure to win: Claudia Sheinbaum. So it will be more of the same and this will never end. But if you're ok with that then ok..
Well... I had replied to the person who asked me that what is my point but apparently my reply to him or her was too politically incorrect. So I guess I don't have the liberty to freely express myself. If you don't understand my original comment then I don't know what else to say. But counting the days here for Obrador to leave. Have a good one!
@@edyannWelcome to social media, where you have free speech unless the left disagrees.
It took me more than 15 years and 10s of thousands of dollars to become a citizen and I have a masters degree in Computer Engineering, an investor, a musician and a family man. Between me and the rest of my family we’ve paid 100s of thousands of dollars in university fees. I almost got kicked out of the country because I couldn’t find an employer to “sponsor” me. Make it easier please. We need people to keep inflation down.
Hey there 👋 great work! Happy to have you here.
Finance degree here; more migrants means higher demand on housing; meaning higher rents and home costs. More people working means a higher demand on a lower amount of goods; causing a rise in all prices.
More migrants hurts us tremendously in almost every single way.
@@magicxsquare_ This is not true. You're finance degree didn't teach you enough about economics and labor demographics. As the U.S. population trends towards having more retirees, we need more people of working age to fill in key roles such as nursing, construction, farm work, etc. There's currently a higher demand for these jobs than ever before.
Housing would literally be solved if we simply built more homes. Bottlenecks contributing to low housing supply are material shortages, labor shortages, and NIMBYISM. If we block migrants that are propping up our labor markets, we're going to be in for a shitshow in the next 10-15 years when the demographic skews even more towards the elderly and not enough people to care for them / fill in the gaps.
@@magicxsquare_ that might be true under normal circumstances. The aging population and Covid really put us behind as far as a young, working population goes. We need people to work. Until AI, robotics and automation make up for the lost productivity, we will need people to do low skill jobs. This is not even debatable at this point. The question is what’s the most ideal way to get young workers and be able to fill the void that boomers are leaving considering how small gen X is. You need more than finance to see the big picture. Thanks for the kind words by the way and I could be wrong about my entire assessment. Have a great day!😊
@@stevencheng468 hello and thank you for your emotional input; although it doesn’t align with reality. And are mostly speaking from the common left wing conspiracy theories we hear today “not enough people to work”; “not enough people to fill the military”.
With the progression of robotics almost all migrant jobs are being replaced. We have chef robots that can now cook every meal; we have robots that can pick every fruit tree and sort it; we also can 3D print houses…
The amount of labor required is dropping significantly for low skilled jobs.
Unemployment is tremendously good for inflation; dropping the demand on goods causing higher supply dropping all prices.
Having people fill every single job is not good for our country and is economics 101. Literally what brought down Roman Empire 😂
@@magicxsquare_ Cool, it's clear that you're viewing this from a political standpoint rather than looking at economics as a whole. The fact still stand that there is not enough people.
Let me know when the number of houses built by "robots" exceed the number of houses built by traditional developers.
Also you should quit your job since you stated it's "good for the economy." Pretty clear you only read surface level bullet points without any deeper thoughts about the implications or driving factors.
Have fun playing with your transformers bro.
This administration is putting many families in difficult situations. A lot of people are financially struggling to live, put a roof over their head and put food on the table. Things are getting worse these days, if you don't find means of multiplying your money you might wake up a day to realise you didn't plan well for yourself and family.
I agree with you and I believe that Professionals are currently dominating the market since they have access to both the necessary strategy for making money in this industry.
That's awesome to hear. I invested 5k in Robin hood about a year ago and it steadily went down, now my portfolio is down to $800. I don't know what to do and i am in between jobs
Understanding your financial needs and making effective decisions is very essential. If I could advise you, you should seek the help of a financial advisor. For the record, working with one has been the best for my finances.
@@melissagrice I’m Glad i stumbled on this. Please, if its not too much of a hassle for you, can you drop the details of the expertise that assisted you and how to get in touch with him.?
I’m Glad i stumbled on this. Please, if its not too much of a hassle for you, can you drop the details of the expertise that assisted you and how to get in touch with him.?
Engaging with books has significantly elevated my perspective on investing. True wealth isn't built through mere savings; financial freedom stems from strategic investments. I've learned that accumulating wealth hinges on making prudent investment decisions.
Whichever firm you select, make sure you get your insurance from a reputable financial adviser, such as Angela Lynn Schilling, who has dedicated her career to financial planning. Because they will assist you in escalating, navigating better, and completing the task in a safer manner..|
Because they don’t want to. If they actually solve the issue, what are they going to rail against during the following election cycles?
Healthcare, education, student loan, housing, separation of church and state, gun reform, cybersecurity, climate change, AI, Russia and Ukraine, middle east conflict, any many more. There is ton of issue that need resolving, but congress just doesn't want to work together.
@@faketruth7740 These problems are because of Congress working together. Healthcare is a mess because of government, our kids don't get educated because of government. College is so expensive because of government guaranteed loans, guns don't need reforms, climate change will happen no matter how much we pay on taxes. "Government save me" 🤣😂
@duerf5826 What is this "THEY"? President Trump had the problem solved. Biden created the problem by opening the border.
@@peterponcedeleon3368
So? You don’t want your Social Security pension. That’s fine.
@@whathell6t I want my money. I worked for that money, so it’s my property. And government still can be cut by at 30%
Me after breaking into your house "I'm not a burglar, I'm a migrant"
undocumented roommate
Welcomed visitor….and you owe them a cerveza……
@@Nut-ml5wc i think "newcomer" is the term of choice according to Biden and Pelosi.
Windows safety bars will go up in price.
Welcome! Let me give you preferential treatment and setup a room for you. Feel free to change to decorations to your liking. I want to be as supportive as possible! Would you also like a temporary allowance?
Govt. do not have money to give border control, but they can give money to buy arms to Israel and Ukraine.😂😂😂
The govt has sent billions to Venezuela alone. They give millions and millions of dollars to the NGO' who support the migrants. This is all deliberate. The goal is to turn the US into a communist country.
The stupid asylum system needs to be fixed thats for sure.
the core to solve this issue are rules and regulations, we need to pass bills/acts that make legal immigration easier at the same time making illegal immigration as difficult as possible.
No, we need to just close the borders. We don't need to make the already overinflated legal immigration numbers even larger. We let in more legal immigrants than anywhere else in the world, and we allow more legal immigrants now than at any time in history. You don't have to negotiate with foreigners that have nothing we need. We just need to say "No"
@tony1960 There are rules and regulations, but President Biden opened the border.
@@dennisweidner288
Do you actually have citations in MLA or APA format to back your claim that the border is open?
He has Fox News timestamps.
@@doujinflip I find it fascinating how Progressives hate Fox. They can't stand it that a network exists which will treat conservative ideas honestly. I suggest you read the First Amendment and educate yourself as to how important that is.
The system isn’t broken, it’s made that way by design. They could easily fix it but they don’t want to do that.
It all about control
If you voted for Biden, you voted for this.
Damn straight. And I'd vote for him again! 😎🍦
@@darkchocolate3390 surely thats a sarcasm sentence
FJB
@@MST-cf9dsyou can't be sure... I know people that voted for brain dead Joe and will vote for that again. Because they have been brainwashed by the FAKE media.. they drank the kool Aid!
trump wouldn’t have helped either. simply not profitable to fix the problem for politicians.
In the meantime, getting a green card while already having a job in the US (legally and highly skilled) is almost impossible, so frustrating
Really? Some people get their green cards from employment so easily. What are the cases that you are seeing that are “almost impossible”? Certain countries of origin? Certain industries? Certain U.S. states?
U really think getting green card is easier 😂😂@Happyllama220
@@Urbanhunter49not that I think. I know. I have evidence. Not sure what you’re laughing about. That’s why I’m asking for specifics. Maybe one population is subject to more restrictions, or just so exceed their quota is just numbers game?
@@Happyllama220 tell me you have no idea about immigration without actually saying it. at this point, it is much easier to fly to Mexico and cross the border than wait for the application process,
@@haihengh I have been through the process myself. So don’t assume things about me. I am asking for specifics. These statements cannot and should not be generalized.
Why are we still discussing illegal immigration ??? illegal immigration is illegal and should be handled by law. by discussing it you are incentivizing illegal immigration and discouraging legal immigration system. Your are not solving legal immigration and path to citizenship for the people that are following all laws, investing here, contributing to community and paying taxes. make immigration cost effective, fix broken immigration system ( by increasing quota or different categories for south america, path to citizenship) and penalize illegal immigration.
The current governments of North America are not being held accountable for protecting the borders . We got what we voted for
Illegal immigration gets incentivized by the legal paths only getting tougher to clear.
The legality of immigration keeps getting more narrow and qualified, but we're not funding the staffing to process the backlog it creates.
How is the economy booming when businesses are closing and crime is increasing? How are employers supposed to hire when the skills needed to fill positions are not present and the language barriers exist? How can anyone give all those people jobs? There aren't enough to go around.
It's also overwhelming americans. And our tax money
Other countries don’t let in people just because your relatives live there. The UK, Australia, Canada and other countries operate on a skills-based/education-based immigration system with strict enforcement on illegal immigration.
Stop giving out incentives to come here and it will stop
Incentive like what? Give some examples.
@bakerkawesa food stamps, clothing, children becoming citizens if they're born here. Do you live under a rock? I mean there's a thousand incentives to come here.. %85 of those who come here end up on welfare so you can be happy knowing you working is saying their bills and millions more are coming.. better put in some overtime
@@bakerkawesa look up what percentage of them end up on welfare. How about automatic citizenship.
@@KingFergus Illegal immigrants aren't entitled to welfare. Only refugees and asylum seekers get any government help. And those ones are legal. Automatic citizenship only applies to their children if born on US soil. Some immigrants also enjoy special status such as Cubans. But that's it. Nobody illegally in the United States can claim welfare or citizenship. In fact, most illegals keep their heads down to avoid deportation. They live and work under the table.
It's more the _disincentives_ to immigrate "properly", with the ever narrowing and lengthening paths towards legal immigration.
Our young population isn’t growing because we can’t afford to have kids. You’re not solving that problem by letting immigrants in because in the end we still suffer.
True
stop believing you can't afford to have kids. A lot of people managed generations before us. My grandma had 7 kids coming to the u.s. in the 80s and all her kids are doing well now. She only had a factory job and did it alone after my grandpa died yougn.
Explain?
@@dmaxwell910901the aliens overpopulate everything overrun everything take over everything.
So less pure blooded Americans
Excellent video which makes some of the points which do not appear as much in other places.
My employer is more happy to sponsor me but still I need to get the visa from a lottery and the chance is less than 10%. My boss asked me “why couldn’t the people who are contributing the society stay?” This is how ironic the immigration system is
Weak people, weak laws, weak borders, weak government.
When we drove from Russia to Finland, there were six check points. No way could anyone get into those countries unchecked. We need to use that model and invest in it wisely.
We have generations of illegals and their anchor babies who’ve wormed their way into government and protect illegals more than US citizens. Their whole agenda is to steal from Americans to care for the illegals
I just spent 2 years going thru the k1 visa process. The hurdles were insane. My fiance had to fly to the capital and had to return to the photo booth 4 times because her visa pic kept getting declined. i probably spent $5000 and this is without a lawyer. Im a tax payer and it is insane to think i could have just bought my fiance a ticket to mexico city and have her meet me at the texas border. Even when my fiance gets here it will be months before shes legally allowed to work while illegals work immediately. this system is a shame and anyone who supports illegals are insane.
IF you think K1 is insane, try getting an H1B work visa and then get employer to sponsor a green card. It's much easier to fly to the moon than winning a work visa lottery and begging employers to sponsor a green card
How ironic
And that's why illegal immigration is trending: legal paths keep getting increasingly difficult to complete. It's probably faster nowadays to process an asylum claim with how many legal hurdles our lawmakers keep placing in the path of legal immigration.
@@doujinflip Yes, a lot of people get green card faster claiming asylum and cheaper as well than applying through a job having to beg employers and wait 2-3 years
That’s insane. Damn
NO MORE ROOM. AND THE ROOM WE DO HAVE IS FOR US TO GROW
RIP America.
Agree, thanks Biden/Harris.
Every country has immigration problems. It’s been like that for hundreds of years.
@zalronwow7222 OH you think Trump can fix it? He's gonna make it worse.
@@EbenezerNimhHis stay in Mexico, the wall and other items were not working with some of the lowest border crossings. We could lock kids up in cages like Obama started?
@@user-rs3lm1ci6nNo, it is about practicality, how is the resolute of the Democrat cities that are now crying about a few thousand immigrants, while TX is being overrun, literally for years now?
Computer Engineering, an investor, a musician and a family man. Between me and the rest of my family we’ve paid 100s of thousands of dollars in university fees. I almost got kicked out of the country because I couldn’t find an employer to “sponsor” me
You obviously haven’t learned proper English as well
I meet young Americans with STEM degrees working minimum wage service sector jobs. You think youre entitled to go ahead of them?
@@telescopicS627 I think the point was that illegals are entitled to go ahead of him with work authorization and no fear of deportation while he never had the right to work freely until he got his green card.
@@telescopicS627 What majors?
@@wilmerruizc3152 CS, engineering... for 20 yrs no shortage of anecdotal stories of Americans getting to train their replacement who comes in on an H1B visa
The cannot because they make it hell for those trying to do it the right way. Why it takes 1 year to process a naturalization for a permanent resident, or why it even costs 5000$, why it costs students 1200$ to apply for Training permits, its absurd. Specialized workers being awarded permits on a lottery should tell you all you need. Speed up and make it more streamlined for Family sponsored immigrants and Work based ones. They are the ones doing it right and they pay taxes. These are the people who will not use the welfare systems since they have a support system but nope, it takes years in addition to the stupid cost.
If I am coming here to work and bring technical skills, when I am paying 150k annually in taxes, make it easy for me! I am a valuable immigrant and my family will be too.
Streamlining Legal Immigration
“We’re not a nation that kicks out strivers and dreamers who want to earn their piece of the American Dream. We’re a nation that finds a way to welcome them. We make them earn it, but we welcome them in as fellow human beings, fellow children of God. And we harness their talents to make the future brighter for everybody.”
President Barack Obama, November 21, 2014
When they talk about illegal immigration they keep bringing up the economy. However, there are so many citizens that need help economically, that need jobs. How are you to bring people in, help them get on their feet so that companies can hire them all the while looking over the people in the states who already need help, need jobs! The truth is there's no pipeline for jobs for the citizens already here. Why don't we see these jobs that need to be filled? Why doesn't the news add it on their websites to easily find? But if a migrant comes to the US, the NGO's and etc points them in the direction of jobs that need to be filled??? This doesn't make complete sense at all. Before making it seem like Americans just aren't working to support the economy let's see a push to help the American people.
It’s not a broken system, it’s the fact that the rest of the world sucks and has failed its people and society as a whole.
Imagine what the situation would look like if every country had the same opportunities, education, freedom and quality of life as the USA. People would only migrate due to maybe a company offering better pay or maybe someone found their dream home with a view that they couldn’t find anywhere else.
The main thing that irritates me and even my South American wife, these people coming waving their flags with pride then demanding that we bow down to their every wish they ask for. You ran away from your problems like a coward, leave that pride back home or go home.
why argue about this. Just look at what's happening in Europe, Germany in particular. I think what needs to be done is obvious.
Close the border completely, no
exceptions.
It's beyond that now. We need a closed border with mass deportation.
Ohh it's sooo simple because they don't want to solve it. This thing can be solved so easily.
@dennisc4563 Actually President Trump solved it.
@@dennisweidner288 yep, for it to all go to smokes.
@@dennisc4563 I am not sure what you mean, but President Trump had the border under control. This is not an opinion. It is a fact, just look at the DATA on illegal immigration. No smoke, just FACTS. Biden opened the border. That is what broke the system. And the terrible thing is the border is not the worst thing that Biden has done.
Trump's hardline attitude ironically brought a record surge of irregular entries once the implementation got figured out.
The solution to the immigration crisis is not actually that difficult at all. The solution is the “ remain in Mexico” policy, but,of course, the leftists will oppose fiercely to it.
Sad for you, Mexico refuses to take them back
"RIGHT OF SOIL" also needs to be amended... many people bank on that to come in and remain permanently after childbirth on US soil. Removing it will incentivize many to not come as well. But it may only stop 10% of the overall population coming in.
It doesn't last the lifetime though. Once the kid comes of age or gets provided an alternative guardianship, the parents can still be subject to deportation with like a 10 year ban on reentry.
birthright citizenship needs to end, majority of EU countries and Asian countries have not such thing.
The Old World is made up of ethnostates, that's why. In the whole Western Hemisphere, citizenship by birth is the norm.
@@haihengh Jus soli is the norm in the entire Western Hemisphere though. Largest country that follows the strict Old World citizenship by ancestry model is Haiti.
@@doujinflip well I am Chinese, and those systems never make sense to me, especially when you set up welfare system and allow loopholes like this exist, the welfare system is going to fail eventually. I know a ton of Chinese illegals have been getting free government money for decades, and Chinese are not even 1% of the entire illegal immigrant population.
Let's go brandon
Make a good immigration reform that benefits those that truly want to make a productive life here. Start with those that are already here and have not committed any crimes in 15+ years. Give them work permits for 5 years, then residency, then citizenship
I thought illegal immigration to get cheap labor was the system.
That's part of the reason Republicans fail to actually be tough on immigration like they say they would. Actually securing the borders would seriously hurt the workforce and profits of their corporate sponsors.
@@doujinflipTrump had the border under control and Republicans impeached Mayorkas for his actions but the democrat run Senate wouldn’t bring it to trial in defiance of constitutional guidance.
@@doujinflipBiden has created two programs bringing in millions.
American with a German wife. Got married April 2016 and she and our daughter joined me in the states in February 2017. Visa process was a pain and cost a lot of money (especially for a military E5 at the time) but we did it and did it right because it was worth it to us. Can't believe this is even an argument in our country when it's not even considered in other places
Tump wouldn't let this happen ... Even here in, the 🇬🇧 migrants are getting hotels and even spending money 😮
Ironically Trump oversaw a record-breaking surge of illegal immigration.
Nobody who cared about this country and its people would let this happen. Biden is a traitor putting American citizens at risk with this open borders b.s.
He did. He literally had the Honduran caravan come in. I’ve met workers who once came in that way illegally but now legal.
Biden is also giving 700 $ a month to each illegal.
What does it say about a society when there is the acceptance and tolerance of illegal immigration?
As a Canadian I would love to live and work in the States but it is hard for me.
Likewise it is not cool when the government supports and doesn't deport this illegal behaviour.
When you allow this you let the world know you are ok with rewarding bad behaviour.
Just walk across the border and claim asylum lol that's what the whole world is doing
Would you cross illegally?
It means there's a big disconnect between the wants of the people (both legal residents and prospective immigrants) and the laws defining "legal" entry.
@@Happyllama220Your question is do you want to be a criminal?The answer is no.Anyone who has basic decency and commonsense will refrain from breaking the law .
Cheap labour costs is the long term business aim.🙄
Well when you offer cash to break the law…
It’s basically to reduce wages by increase immigration, increase the military cause they can’t meet the requirements for quotas for amount of people, increase political power in their state.
Who would want to defend a country that is so lawless.
Cause the Govt is more concerned about Tiktok being a so called national security threat than securing the actual border.
To understand this issue in its entirety, all you have to ask yourself is "who would these people vote for when they are here?"
ask yourself the question...why is Biden fighting TX to keep the border open. TX volunteers to build the wall, and Biden hates it. I hope people wake up.
Nobody, because they're, you know, illegals? Kinda need to be a citizen to vote.
And before you complain about lack over voter IDs, the verification isn't hard. If you're a registered citizen in a State, you get one vote for that name. If a name not on the list votes, that's an illegal vote. Also all the conservative states have voter ID laws anyway.
It’s not about vote. The plan is much more sinister. Wake up!
Funny how there's always hundreds of billions foe Ukraine but the US can't afford 500m to sort the border
Because UKRAINE IS FIGHTING OFF RUSSIA TO KEEP PUTIN FROM TAKING OVER HALF OF EUROPE! If Ukraine falls, Europe is SCREWED! We can cope with this!
Ukraine literally gave us almost 1 billion or more just to house their refugees. We don’t even know how the money is being spent.
God forbid if a European wanted to emigrate there, work & contribute with their tax $ to your system... Visas are declined left right & centre.
It's worse for Indians and Chinese students and engineers.
For Europeans it's super easy
It’s the price you pay
The poorer and more populous the country, the harder it is to convince the American consular officer at the visa window that your qualifications are bona fide and you'll remain in the parameters of your visa (i.e. not overstaying it).
Only Haitians and Venezuelans are allowed apparently
Similar but different problems in Canada. You can't count your immigration numbers so that's a big problem. We can count ours, and its very high, its also a big problem without infrastructure to allow it to keep working.
Blame India Lol.
This won't be solved when half the country and the president don't want to change anything.
What is the point of doing paper work and doing administration stuff if u can get in by entering through a hole in the wall ?
It's not broken. It's just not enforced
They don't want to shut that sh*t down
It's not enforced because the "small government" party is terrified of the amount of spending needed to actually seal the border.
That Wall they keep talking about is just a massive blank mural and Tough Mudder event without the _paid government officials_ who are trained, equipped, and positioned to react to every approach.
Illegal immigration not immigration
Immigration is the international movement of people to a destination country of which they are not usual residents or where they do not possess nationality in order to settle as permanent residents
@@nieshamccoy9419 ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION is the arrival of people from one country into another country without entering via LEGAL methods. No one is complaining about legal immigration, it's the ILLEGAL aspect that is the problem.
The Cloward-Piven strategy is a political strategy outlined in 1966 by American sociologists and political activists Richard Cloward and Frances Fox Piven. It is the strategy of forcing political change to societal collapse through orchestrated crises. The “Cloward-Piven Strategy” seeks to hasten the fall of capitalism by overloading the government bureaucracy with a flood of impossible demands, amassing massive unpayable national debt, and other methods such as unfettered immigration, thus pushing society into crisis and economic collapse.
And? At this time one could argue both major parties endorse this strategy.
@@bengaltiger96 who cares, its not a problem any one is trying to so solve, its designed to collapse the USA and turn us into a socialist bunch of people.
Republicans proudly sabotage good governance for political gain. Something about a "small government" ideology despite -- or perhaps because of -- a weak state not being able to effectively challenge the entrenchment of private industry strongmen, whom they're conveniently already in relations with.
@@bengaltiger96they do, seemingly, either knowingly or unknowingly
@@rowbart3095 I'd say there are elements of both in both parties. There are those that want this whole thing to collapse by design (in both parties), and those who will have it happen by their mere incompetence. And hte sad thing is we can prevent both, either through the ballot box or not giving power to the former by not giving them oxygen (I don't mean deplatforming, as I am a believer in 1A, but just ignoring them).
How thorough are the background checks on these people? What are they doing once they get here?
I’m worried about the poor Black & White folks alraedy here!
Easy fix close the border until you catch up.....DONE
We're not funding the _paid government staffers_ required to process the current backlog. That's why irregular entry has become so popular.
@@doujinflipWhat backlog? Just don't let them in to begin with.
The backlog where the wait to _get in line_ at a US embassy for a _tourist_ visa is now more than a year. Imagine how much worse the process is for those wanting to legally move here.
Its a lot easier to complain about the problem than it is to find a common sense solution.
You act like legal immigration doesn’t exist. When you travel to another country you get to get a visa. Yet you don’t complain to that country that they should change their laws
@@rickysampson8759no he know their is an issue but no one wants to solve it
Legal immigration doesn't exist with a practical amount of paperwork and processing. Applying for legal entry shouldn't require years in advance trying to prove impossibly specific qualifications.
common sense solution is to deport every illegal entry like the rest of the world does, yet only in America your first act of entering the country is a criminal offense we allow you to stay without penalty, and also provide you housing, food and health care, which most citizens of the country will need to work for it, that is the most insane solution I ever heard.
I mean this is like those subway free riders in NY going through the unlocked emergency gate instead of the turnstile (according to City Journal an estimated half a million daily if you include city buses). Flawed policy? JUST LOCK THE DAMN GATE!!
Why wasn’t the fence finished on September 12, 2001?
Biden is to blame.
#separationofchurchandstate screw maga
@@vsznryNah, screw Biden and the Liberal democrats.
@@vsznryscrew libs
The right to seek asylum was incorporated into international law following the atrocities of World War II. Congress adopted key provisions of the Geneva Refugee Convention (including the international definition of a refugee) into U.S. immigration law when it passed the Refugee Act of 1980. Not only does the US have an international legal obligation to do so, based on the requirement of complying with the object and purpose of the 1951 Refugee Convention, and implementing legal obligations in good faith, it has an obligation to do so under its own domestic law. Anyone can apply for asylum. Normally, however, it is a person who considers themselves at risk of serious harm in their country of origin, or who is compelled to leave their country in search of safety in another country. As a signatory to the 1967 Protocol, and through U.S. immigration law, the United States has legal obligations to provide protection to those who qualify as refugees. The Refugee Act established two paths to obtain refugee status-either from abroad as a resettled refugee or in the United States as an asylum seeker. Similar to a refugee, an asylum seeker is someone who may be in search of protection due to dangers in his or her home country. While every refugee is initially an asylum seeker, not every asylum seeker will ultimately be recognized as a refugee. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services made changes that affirmative asylum applicants must bring an interpreter to their asylum interview if they are not fluent in English or wish to proceed with their interview in a language other than English. Unfortunately, it hasn’t slowed things down.
most ALL the so called "refugees" don't come here straight from war torn countries while others are in fact illegal Economic Migrants looking for entitlements.
we need to pull out of these treaties and international agreements, it's such a stupid loophole that people can exploit to gain free access to our country.
What are they going to do about the measles outbreak in the shelters in chicago....isn't it very contagious?
MY BROTHER SERVED IN VIETNAM. HE WAS JUST A REALLY KIND HARDWORKING, person. WAKE UP AMERICANS.
I lived in the U.S for 2 years and the U.K for 4 years. The U.K caught on quick, hence brexit. The U.S is heading for disaster, they should shut every inch of the border and get the military to monitor every inch of the border. The effects on healthcare, education, housing, to name a few. Im South African and we have the same issue with Zimbabweans crossing our border, not on the scale we are seeing in the U.S, creating more poverty, crime. DEbt at 35 Trillion$$$$
Brexit is why the UK’s economy is struggling now and will be in the foreseeable future. The conservatives sold you a lie and the immigrants are STILL coming.
Had it shut down and trying to get the POS out of office that opened it up.
Brexit has damaged trade and only addressed legal migration though, we still haven't stopped the boats from the Mediterranean, which is a major issue. If people could claim asylum legally, they wouldn't get on boats. I don't know enough about the US system.
The UK is becoming a mix between pakistan and afganistan , very very bad example
Get the National Guard to work in cooperation with the Coast Guard and Border patrol.
The LEGAL immigration system we have is not that bad if it is followed by all including all states. Some small tweaks could help I guess. The MAIN problem is that isn't happening and one political side sees a bunch of votes in their future if they can just bring a bunch of 'em in and give them voting rights, social benefits, etc... nothing more than those politicians making a play to entrench their political power long term.
But if we don't raise the caps on immigration then it just means there will be more illegal immigrants. We don't have the manpower to process all these people who want to come to the US, leaving them stranded on the border.
I agree that drug cartels and smuggling people are a big problem on the border. You fix that by hiring more border agents and immigration judges to determine who should and shouldn't come into the country.
@@PASH3227 there are too much illegal immigrants not working, and too little legal immigrants working hard.
Explain why it can take YEARS at minimum to get a *visa* in this country, let alone almost a DECADE to get a green card for permanent residence.
Make legal immigration *practical*.
@@r1_anon immigrants contribute much more to our economy than you realize, then.
Meanwhile the other political side sees an endless supply of cheap labor they can abuse and eject at the pleasure of their businessowner constituents, while deliberately not providing "government spending" to staff up and actually process all the irregular entry and visa overstay cases properly.
I live abroad and am trying to get my wife a green card. She is the mother of a us citizen with no criminal record and the process takes an unbelievably long time and is very expensive
Canada uses Newcomers to pay pensions of old Europeans through tax
Would be better off just telling the Europeans to have more babies, instead of actively dissuading the people who built the country from having children.
No immigration....no social security. Old boomers need to learn this.
REALLY? READ THIS: judiciary.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/republicans-judiciary.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/camarota-testimony.pdf
I'd give up social security if it meant having a country still.
It’s crazy that this woman said young population won’t grow and they need migrants. Maybe change the way you pay workers first?
I live in Denver and it is getting flooded with Migrants. It’s a disaster.
I’m a legal immigrant who received an advanced degree here, working here and paid perhaps hundreds of thousands of tax dollars throughout my career. One day I had to visit the immigration office to get some work done. Upon my arrival, there was an extremely long line that lasted several blocks waiting outside. Luckily, I asked the security guards and there was a separate line for legal immigrants (with 3 people). The other line was presumably undocumented immigrants seeking asylum. I’m glad I asked and didn’t wait in the wrong line.
I guess it’s a dilemma for every (legal) immigrant. While most of us agree that America needs a rule based system, and the rules for legal immigration should be easier, not harder. In the meantime, it’s not the best policy to accept unlimited undocumented immigrants, and those resources should be used to help the legal immigration first. However, we are also concerned about the xenophobia the other side was trying to promote. The leaders from the other side are increasingly hostile towards legal immigrants as well. It’s really difficult for us legal immigrants to survive in America, despite we contributed a lot here.
Where do you feel pressure as a legal immigrant? Do you live in a conservative state? Or are you surrounded by conservative people?
Right, if anything "legal" immigration has gotten so convoluted that it's becoming impossible to complete. Hence why the trend of irregular entry straight to asylum claim route.
If you’re paying hundreds of thousands in taxes, then you are doing more than just “surviving”
US legal immigration system is totally broken where genuine, hard working immigrants are discriminated based on country of origin😳🙄🤦♂️🥺...Economic, high-skillled immigrants aligning with country's labour requirements and needs should be the logical and practical priority of any advanced, well educated administration of a mature nation like United States!
@vijayrangarajanramakrishna318 As President Obama explained ton us, "Elections have consequences": You elect left-wing Democrats' who open the border and you create a problem. And that is only one of the problems they have created.
All immigrants, legal of illegal, foreign or domestic contributes to housing crisis and stolen wages. IT salaries has stagnated because of large numbers of foreigners in IT. Even Canadian liberal politicians acknowledge this.
@@Sushipapi. You are misinformed. Since NAFTA, immigration from Mexico has steadily declined. Most of the illegal migrants through the southern border are NOT Mexican, but from Central America (mostly the northern triangle) traveling through Mexico. Since Biden opened the border the mix of nationalities has hugely increased. Many are still from Central America, but very few are from Mexico.
@@Sushipapi. I have spent a great deal of time living and working in Latin America, especially Ecuador, Chile, Mexico, Venezuela, and Guatemala. I think immigration is very important for America, but not illegal immigration. I never said that Central America is better--those are your words, not mine.
The country that put men on the moon, that could invade a country in the Middle East in a matter of weeks, with the most powerful military and defense spending in the world.. can’t stop unarmed people from crossing it’s southern border…. Or doesn’t want to stop them? If they can’t… why? If they don’t want too.. why? Either question needs answering.
The woman at the 11minute mark really hit the nail on the head. Immigration, like homelessness, is not a single problem. It's a multifaceted issue that requires multiple approaches to properly address. I agree with both sides primary concerns. Legal immigration needs to be simplified and more accessible, and there should be swift and stern repercussions to those who willingly violate immigration laws. Both these aspects COST a lot money to put into action.
"Just .2% of those who try for the diversity lottery are selected" Saying it like that is dishonest because it gives a false impression that it's rare. This diversity lottery allows up to 50,000 people in a year. That's not a small number. US immigration is on the easier side compared in terms of rules to most other western nations; our system is just really overloaded.
Fr I don’t get how people watch this and don’t get that aspect. It’s not that we aren’t trying😭
Want to solve the problem or make less heavy?
Lift the USA sanctions of Venezuela and Cuba so they can improve their economies. Just because they are authoritarian countries doesn't mean usa need to do anything about it
About Haiti, well, that can't be easy to solve...
About the mexican state with an issue on cartel, stop flooding mexico with usa illegal military weapons, and try to stop the drug addition 😑
About Ecuador, well, they are having a similar issue with cartel violence. But everything is because demand
About China and Africans idk tbh
You cant just lift sanctions on a country that is about to invade Guyana
@sammarsh9197 true but we can't take in the entire country of Venezuela either
@@FEB-mz6zr we can send army to secure the border
LOL, allow one-party state in your neighbourhood and not expect trouble spilling into your own backyard?
lmao other countries drug addictions arent the fault of the US when the cartels are more of a problem than we are in that aspect
Y'all called Tom Metzger, Duke, Withrow nuts for trying to stop this...🤣Here's America's Trophy for Stupidity.🏆
Who yall think building the houses they’re getting rich off of ?
Crime tourism and giving out visas like candy
You've obviously never experienced a visa line at a US embassy. Right now the wait for an appointment is like 1~2 _years_.
My take is that, like all other major socio-political issuess in the US, the US government with its two-party system has very extreme and opposing views on Immigration, the left basically wants to let everyone in with or without proper documentation, but the right treats immigrants like a threat to American jobs, culture and way of life…. the solution is somewhere in the middle, but i dont see the two party system solving that
They're both controlled by the small hats.
The small hats are the problem.
@@righteousone1 gee, no tribalism there....
6:14 - Audibly said "Th'f**k?!"
You need to add a 0:00 chapter :)
Trump is the solution
Texas has yall bent over rn taking some licks with these buses until you can learn your lesson that having an immigration policy like the giants offensive line is a bad idea.
I think that all the people who want to successfully immigrate to the USA should study all aspects of the country when they are in their homes on their computers and get as much information about the USA before they set foot on American soil because entering the USA as an illegal alien without any sponsorship will make life difficult.
It's not broken. It can be solved. Just apply the current law and increase the cap for family sponsor, and deport everyone else.
Remove country caps
@@TheAlchemist1089 it's not sustainable to remove it and have unlimited people. Just increase it
@@x-men69-96 country caps can be removed
This is for people stuck in the green card queue
My grandparents came here in the 80's legally using "skill migration" program from the government. Although I embrace immigration, it must be done legally. Close the damn border already. It's ridiculous.
the only way you're going to secure the border is by reforming immigration and creating a legal pathway
The "Migrant Encounters" chart is misleading. The 2019 spike likely records the results of the "Remain in Mexico" numbers. They were "encountered", but after registering, returned to Mexico.