Ajay Sharma such a commendable effort to put down your thoughts about a film which people have only rubbished and then stopped talking about ,altogether! It was a film that needed( rather deserved) to be viewed with a different sensitivity, if that didn't happen, eventually so, at-least wished for all the whitewashing of it to stop. Beyond a point, it made me re-think and come to an understanding that not every film needs to be reviewed just as long as it's a film, for this was something that needed to be experienced. Glad that you resonated with the film differently and took to seeing,exploring, interpreting and feeling of the components of the other ends of its pitch ,than that of it which people confined themselves to, missing the rest and thereby writing it off! At the same time, yes, it's by no means a great film. People have somewhat lost the knack of connecting with good films anymore, the film either has to be "great" else it's trash! In an attempt to probably "cleanse" themselves and elevate their taste , thanks to a lot of shit that bollywood have been subjecting us all to since long(for which it s identified more), with the era of different cinema and great films kicking in, and starting as a wave, people have only gone overboard to the extent that they just don't identify with just "good" films anymore. Eventually, the brunt of that is unfortunately felt by films like harry met sejal which are neither great nor bad. It's just good! People need to respect the good for being good and not failing at trying to be great, maybe most don't intend to be anything more than being just good! This was one such film at the end of which I felt fresh, peaceful, rejuvenated and sweet and warm from within, it didn't feel like a film at all, rather, a beautifully sweet and fun trip to unwind into!
Thank u so much film companion team .....u have given me sunshine and rain to grow up once again.....u guys making this world more beautiful and free to learn ...ur my Wikipedia of Hindi cinema...and special thanks to Anupuma mam.....
Sadly I didn't notice that! I watched Rockstar only once, and even though I loved the movie and Ranbir in it, I couldn't bring myself to watch it again because if the horrible HORRIBLE performance of Nargis. So I didn't catch him the first time I saw!
The best love story ever made in Bollywood so far. I rate it more than #DDLJ. #JabWeMet defines Imtiaz Ali as one of the finest directors. But #JHMS disappointed many. I agree.
It still bamboozles me how can Imtiaz Ali, who has created so beautiful films, made Jab Harry Met Sejal. -_- He could have created something wonderful with SRK.
Mr. Ali I can not thank you enough for this movie. It soothes the eyes and pleases the soul. It gave me hope that if Geet being her crazy self can find someone to love her then may be I can get lucky as well. Every single girl could relate to her and I must say that you know women so well to etch out your female characters so well. I know how amazing you are even in the technical aspects cause I could see Aditya weep away and hear it fade away as the water tricked down the stream right next to the backyard restaurant when he decided to let her get back to her boyfriend. I can tell you about so many other scenes from this masterpiece of a movie where you made me and many others feel exactly how the characters were supposed to see. Please take your time to create the masterpieces you are known for and we will wait eagerly for your creation.
wtf? Why is he explaining the scene to us? It's such a simple scene. That's not how "Inside a A scene" works anyway! Explain us the craft, how the scene was shot, what all prep went behind it. 10 years of Jab We Met made me so look forward to this, but I am extremely disappointed. What a waste of a segment.
Rohit Mujumdar exactly, as if it's something out of a nolan film! I mean imtiaz himself could ve picked something else such as one of the moments from his film Tamasha, which would be something more apt for this!
I really liked what imtiaz said at the end that when you’re in the process of making movie you don’t look at it through the point of view of enjoying it and feeling it, you’re more inclined towards the logistics and all and more involved in rationalization of actions and reactions and judgments. Same goes for life, when you’re desiring something you focus too much about the how’s and whys and when’s and judgements that you simply lay-off the feel of enjoyment which really propelled the desire.
Was expecting the way scene was shot.. and how lead actors approached the scene and even director. Imtiaz was narrating many obvious things. Expected more.
Jab We Met has been a curse for you!! Its the best romantic film I have ever watched in my entire lifetime. Sorry to say, that was your ONLY best work till date. Alas it has set the standard so high I doubt you would ever make a film better than that. Good Luck!
Fabulous! It is so good to see Imtiaz Sir enjoying that wonderful scene. I would love to watch Anand L Rai explain a scene from Ranjhanaa, Imtiaz Ali explaining that cafe scene in Tamasha and Sanjay Leela Bhansali explaining the scene between Bajirao and Kashibai.
Imtiaz plz make jab we met 2 by taking shahid and kareena in the sequel i loved that movie its my all time favorite movie its my humble request to you 👍😍😘
I understand that there is no use of explaining such a simple scene.... A scene which was easy to understand... But I think instead taking digs at him for 'underestimating our intelligence and all' we can see and enjoy what all went into the making of the iconic scene... Inside A Scene doesn't just dissect complicated scenes... But the the director also explains the making of the scene...
Love Imtiaz to death but this is such an irony. The guy who gives the audience so much credit and never over explains stuff in his movies is explaining such a basic scene. When does the INSIDE part of this segment begin?! I guess the brief given to him by FC was plain wrong! Im cringing outside the scene! Peace!
Love Imtiaz Ali. More than anyone. He is my Dronacharya, in film making. Jordan, Ved, Tara and Heer and my soulmates, always grateful to him for having created them, I mean it...Please do one from Rockstar/ Tamasha. This was great but then it was describing something already that is so obvious. Rockstar is so intense and so layered. Please please
Worst Inside a scene video. No insights or how it was done except what he said about the art director in the beginning. Why is he analysing such a simple scene? For eg : the receptionist is shocked that this business is now in trains.. business development.. Why does he need to explain that?
Dear lovely people at Film Companion. I truly appreciate the efforts that you guys are putting in but if you are spending time, money and effort on something then at least do it right. Inside a Scene must be about how to director chose to stage the scene, block the camera, direct her/his actors, prep that went into the film rather than whatever this was. If you can't brief the guests on your show properly about what it is that they need speak then please hire someone who can understand the needs of the audience and what future filmmakers must take from this segment to help you with briefing these amazing guests. If that seems over the budget, feel free to contact me and I am willing to do it free of cost. (Just reimburse travelling and food expenses.) :)
plz do more videos in these segment...its very informative to know things about behind the camera and circumstances of shooting,acting such scenes....Thanks FC😍😍...
Now that Imtiaz says he enjoyed this scene, I would recommend he watches the whole film again and introspect on his current standards. What happened to you man? Rockstar was good, but you screwed it up by casting Nagris. Tamasha was nice, but had nothing new to say and the writing fell flat towards the end. Highway was good, but you ended the film on a conveneient melodramatic speech. The less we talk about Harry met Sejal, the better. Please get serious and make something substantial next.
Dear Imtiaz, why are you trying to explain the scene. ? It's a simple scene which everyone understood while watching the movie. Please explain the technicalities of the scene. I remember how Anurag Kashyap talks abt the long opening shot of GOW. Now tats "inside a scene"
Ajay Sharma Oye penzy dhyaan se dekh kya likha. Padh Fir se agar padha likha ho to. Chalo nahi hai koi baat nhi Achche din itni jaldi thodi na ayenge fir chahe hum kitni bhi scheme on layenge. Main samjhati hu bachche. What I mean was ke ab jabki uski legendary shit film jab harry met sejal flop hui tab achanak se usko jab we met ki yaad ayi. He thought he could make a movie like jab we met again but all his hopes shattered aur ab he is on a nostalgia mode for jab we met. I think he understood that vo khud bhi isko fir se nhi bana sakta.
mera khyal ha imteyaz ko bohut muskil say yahi scene yad aya k.kia intresting hua tha is ma...i think woh lag bhag bhool gya ha. .jb k aysay loog bholty nahi magar he has so much work and work load so possible ha k yahi yad aya ho ya asan lga ho is ko batana ...othervise yah ha bunda outstanding. ..and hassen tareen imam ali ka bf
Please do the 'Medical Center' scene from Dil Dhadakne Do, where the whole family has the discussion after a false alarm about Anil Kapoors' charecter's health.
I knew Imtiaz was an overrated filmmaker. All his movies has been on the same theme of traveling and self exploration. This video gives a confirmation to that. We understood the scene Sirjee. Why did you think for this and what importance it had in the script was the point.
Loved Jab We Met? Download the script here: bit.ly/2h09CKs
Ajay Sharma such a commendable effort to put down your thoughts about a film which people have only rubbished and then stopped talking about ,altogether! It was a film that needed( rather deserved) to be viewed with a different sensitivity, if that didn't happen, eventually so, at-least wished for all the whitewashing of it to stop. Beyond a point, it made me re-think and come to an understanding that not every film needs to be reviewed just as long as it's a film, for this was something that needed to be experienced. Glad that you resonated with the film differently and took to seeing,exploring, interpreting and feeling of the components of the other ends of its pitch ,than that of it which people confined themselves to, missing the rest and thereby writing it off! At the same time, yes, it's by no means a great film.
People have somewhat lost the knack of connecting with good films anymore, the film either has to be "great" else it's trash! In an attempt to probably "cleanse" themselves and elevate their taste , thanks to a lot of shit that bollywood have been subjecting us all to since long(for which it s identified more), with the era of different cinema and great films kicking in, and starting as a wave, people have only gone overboard to the extent that they just don't identify with just "good" films anymore. Eventually, the brunt of that is unfortunately felt by films like harry met sejal which are neither great nor bad. It's just good! People need to respect the good for being good and not failing at trying to be great, maybe most don't intend to be anything more than being just good!
This was one such film at the end of which I felt fresh, peaceful, rejuvenated and sweet and warm from within, it didn't feel like a film at all, rather, a beautifully sweet and fun trip to unwind into!
Hey! Here's something that might interest you: th-cam.com/video/Qe8FWbiVEj8/w-d-xo.html
Film Companion ggh
Film Companion Guys please make available the script of Yeh Jawaani Hai Deewani.
Thank u so much film companion team .....u have given me sunshine and rain to grow up once again.....u guys making this world more beautiful and free to learn ...ur my Wikipedia of Hindi cinema...and special thanks to Anupuma mam.....
The receptionist guy is a FANTASTIC actor. He was a highlight of the film for me. So surprising to see he wasn't actually cast for the role.
Annie hey do you also remember the same guy in Rockstar, while Jordan tries singing Sheher Mein Hoon Mere Tere and this guy helps in between??
Sadly I didn't notice that! I watched Rockstar only once, and even though I loved the movie and Ranbir in it, I couldn't bring myself to watch it again because if the horrible HORRIBLE performance of Nargis. So I didn't catch him the first time I saw!
Annie I dont understand why they chose Nargis who has no talent at all.
He was also in Chor bazaari song as the taxi driver.
Exactly hope to see more of him
The best love story ever made in Bollywood so far. I rate it more than #DDLJ. #JabWeMet defines Imtiaz Ali as one of the finest directors. But #JHMS disappointed many. I agree.
Of everything in the film, the receptipnist left a lasting impression. That "ek dum khadak" line was delivered so well. Unforgettable.
ok the most insightful thing about the video? I never knew her full name was GEET DHILLON
LOL
Exactly 😂
Same
It still bamboozles me how can Imtiaz Ali, who has created so beautiful films, made Jab Harry Met Sejal. -_- He could have created something wonderful with SRK.
I'll just watch JWM now for a zillion times again before resuming life. Totally worth it!
I love film companion for bringing out such great people of the industry sharing their insights for aspiring filmmakers🙏
Right back atcha!
Mr. Ali I can not thank you enough for this movie. It soothes the eyes and pleases the soul. It gave me hope that if Geet being her crazy self can find someone to love her then may be I can get lucky as well. Every single girl could relate to her and I must say that you know women so well to etch out your female characters so well. I know how amazing you are even in the technical aspects cause I could see Aditya weep away and hear it fade away as the water tricked down the stream right next to the backyard restaurant when he decided to let her get back to her boyfriend. I can tell you about so many other scenes from this masterpiece of a movie where you made me and many others feel exactly how the characters were supposed to see.
Please take your time to create the masterpieces you are known for and we will wait eagerly for your creation.
wtf? Why is he explaining the scene to us? It's such a simple scene. That's not how "Inside a A scene" works anyway! Explain us the craft, how the scene was shot, what all prep went behind it. 10 years of Jab We Met made me so look forward to this, but I am extremely disappointed. What a waste of a segment.
Rohit Mujumdar exactly, as if it's something out of a nolan film! I mean imtiaz himself could ve picked something else such as one of the moments from his film Tamasha, which would be something more apt for this!
Rohit Mujumdar wah yr you are intelligent
Exactly... Yeh toh asa lag rha hai school mein teacher chapter samjha rhi hai
Karan did this section very well
Exactly
The receptionist knocked it out of the park!! This was the funniest part of the movie.
Still one of the best Rom-Coms in bollywood!
This movie will remain my favourite no matter what💜
I really liked what imtiaz said at the end that when you’re in the process of making movie you don’t look at it through the point of view of enjoying it and feeling it, you’re more inclined towards the logistics and all and more involved in rationalization of actions and reactions and judgments. Same goes for life, when you’re desiring something you focus too much about the how’s and whys and when’s and judgements that you simply lay-off the feel of enjoyment which really propelled the desire.
I love jab we met and watched it more than 100 times and iam big fan of imitaz Ali sir
Was expecting the way scene was shot.. and how lead actors approached the scene and even director. Imtiaz was narrating many obvious things. Expected more.
Whenever I m alone n emotional I watched jab we met...its awesome movie all time favourite movie
This movie so boom!! In Indonesia, falling in love with Shahid & Kareena. Please! jab we meet 2 😍😍😍😍 I hopefully!!
Jab We Met has been a curse for you!! Its the best romantic film I have ever watched in my entire lifetime. Sorry to say, that was your ONLY best work till date. Alas it has set the standard so high I doubt you would ever make a film better than that. Good Luck!
Well, that is subjective and personal choice.. For me it will always be JWM!
What about highway and love aaj kal ? Do u think these movies are good
Hi Anupama and Film companion - the "Inside a scene" series is such a great idea.. would love to see more of these!
WTF! The receptionist is the soul of the scene & he wasn't an actor. Wow !! Trust Imtiaz instinct to come up with gems 😂
Fabulous! It is so good to see Imtiaz Sir enjoying that wonderful scene.
I would love to watch Anand L Rai explain a scene from Ranjhanaa, Imtiaz Ali explaining that cafe scene in Tamasha and Sanjay Leela Bhansali explaining the scene between Bajirao and Kashibai.
Thank you for the suggestion, we'll definitely take it into consideration. Keep watching!
Yes that would be too good!! Esp Tamasha scene where Tara turns down Dev’s proposal to marry him!
After the video I didn’t want Imtiaz mansplaining the scene, I wanted to know how he shot it
Lol thanks amtiaz Ali for the SHERLOCK CLUE. OF COURSE WE GOT WHAT THEY WERE TRYING TO PORTRAY !!! 😑
Bob hahahaha ikr. Was thinking same!!!
Very well said...
This is all abt the inside or back of the scene..We all want to know..He is describing what we all.knw
Shows he has directed the scene with such a perfection and he has also potrayed the thing what he was trying to tell
Imitiaz wrote us the script of the college drama while he was still a student at Xavier's in Bombay.
I really like the way Imtiaz Ali is enjoying the seen ❤️
Totally love geet character and energy put by kareena kapoor
This is too good. Thanks a lot film companion. Thoroughly enjoyed it. Please do come up with more
Thanks for watching, Ankit. Stay tuned.
Jab we met
Tamashaa
Highway
I want nothing more
Imtiaz plz make jab we met 2 by taking shahid and kareena in the sequel i loved that movie its my all time favorite movie its my humble request to you 👍😍😘
I understand that there is no use of explaining such a simple scene.... A scene which was easy to understand... But I think instead taking digs at him for 'underestimating our intelligence and all' we can see and enjoy what all went into the making of the iconic scene... Inside A Scene doesn't just dissect complicated scenes... But the the director also explains the making of the scene...
Love Imtiaz to death but this is such an irony. The guy who gives the audience so much credit and never over explains stuff in his movies is explaining such a basic scene. When does the INSIDE part of this segment begin?!
I guess the brief given to him by FC was plain wrong! Im cringing outside the scene! Peace!
He's gonna read all these comments and probably learn !
Love Imtiaz Ali. More than anyone. He is my Dronacharya, in film making. Jordan, Ved, Tara and Heer and my soulmates, always grateful to him for having created them, I mean it...Please do one from Rockstar/ Tamasha. This was great but then it was describing something already that is so obvious. Rockstar is so intense and so layered. Please please
Worst Inside a scene video.
No insights or how it was done except what he said about the art director in the beginning.
Why is he analysing such a simple scene?
For eg : the receptionist is shocked that this business is now in trains.. business development..
Why does he need to explain that?
I love his work and am a big fan of his. It's just that I didn't gain anything from this one like I did in Angamaly/Neerja/Kapoor&sons
I was thinking the same thing when I watched the video!
Yes kinda self explanatory
My God this scene was easy to understand, why is the director explaining this shit haha
Agreed, this scene is pretty self understood
My most favourite movie very thanks to Imtiyaz sir .. Karina n Shahid .. I watching again n again .. thank you so much
This was also the first scene where shahid’s character lightened up a bit.
Yeah the first time he smiled and that was because of Geet's innocent silliness 😂😂
Very good .
Scenes from director's perspective.
Director commentary ..
Loved this Idea .
I want more this could help us learn more about film-making.
We'd love to showcase more of these. Let us know if you have any suggestions!
Film Companion If they revel some of the technical asspacts of the scene or film - it would be great.
We feel you'd enjoy this one: th-cam.com/video/PLRnamhzY6U/w-d-xo.html
My favorite scene of the movie I remember watching it again and again
Dear lovely people at Film Companion. I truly appreciate the efforts that you guys are putting in but if you are spending time, money and effort on something then at least do it right. Inside a Scene must be about how to director chose to stage the scene, block the camera, direct her/his actors, prep that went into the film rather than whatever this was. If you can't brief the guests on your show properly about what it is that they need speak then please hire someone who can understand the needs of the audience and what future filmmakers must take from this segment to help you with briefing these amazing guests. If that seems over the budget, feel free to contact me and I am willing to do it free of cost. (Just reimburse travelling and food expenses.) :)
What a movie❣️ Golden time for bollywood ☺
Remember watching movie in theatre back then cant believe its been more than 10yrs funny scene 😂
plz do more videos in these segment...its very informative to know things about behind the camera and circumstances of shooting,acting such scenes....Thanks FC😍😍...
Definitely! Thank you for watching.
Waiting for your combo movie with shahid kapoor to again make magic onscreen
This movie is a masterpiece. Best movie of last 20 years
jab we met is the best film of imtiaz
It's a very nice movie with nice songs i love this movie
Please make more movies like Jab We Met Imtiaz ..
Now that Imtiaz says he enjoyed this scene, I would recommend he watches the whole film again and introspect on his current standards. What happened to you man? Rockstar was good, but you screwed it up by casting Nagris. Tamasha was nice, but had nothing new to say and the writing fell flat towards the end. Highway was good, but you ended the film on a conveneient melodramatic speech. The less we talk about Harry met Sejal, the better. Please get serious and make something substantial next.
Karthik Kumar rockstar was boring
Okay so, while I agree that JHMS was an incredible film, the rest of your comment was quite disgusting and unnecessary.
Tq Soooomuch FIlm Companion
always for imtiyaz ali
Why is Imtiaz Ali explaining the obvious, that was a silly video.
Dear Imtiaz, why are you trying to explain the scene.
? It's a simple scene which everyone understood while watching the movie.
Please explain the technicalities of the scene. I remember how Anurag Kashyap talks abt the long opening shot of GOW. Now tats "inside a scene"
nice film shahid & kareena is best
i want see kareena and sahid again
Great FC team!!
All hail Imtiaz!
Ekdam Kadak 💯
We would love to know how Ganne ke khet scene came into existence 😂
Imtiaz ali wears the best shirts ever
way he said beuuuuifilphooollll is so gooddd
Love you kareena
So now he is talking about jab we met after making a debacle like jhms
Ajay Sharma Oye penzy dhyaan se dekh kya likha. Padh Fir se agar padha likha ho to. Chalo nahi hai koi baat nhi Achche din itni jaldi thodi na ayenge fir chahe hum kitni bhi scheme on layenge. Main samjhati hu bachche. What I mean was ke ab jabki uski legendary shit film jab harry met sejal flop hui tab achanak se usko jab we met ki yaad ayi. He thought he could make a movie like jab we met again but all his hopes shattered aur ab he is on a nostalgia mode for jab we met. I think he understood that vo khud bhi isko fir se nhi bana sakta.
Actually Kareena made this film hit n so Imtiaz ali got reputation. Wonder y he didn’t work with her again
Abdur Rafay yeah I also don't understand she gabe one of the most iconic performances in the history of Bollywood
Shah Anaam true this movie is as popular as ddlj
Abdur Rafay no it‘s not
zoro 95 it's infact it's called sometimes as kareena_shahid's ddlj
Shah Anaam pahahaha yeah of course😉😂👌🏽
One of my frnd livs in RATLAM
She said ppl were annoyed n couldn't release d film in RATLAMs theatre
My life time favourite flim
Plz make jab we met 2 amtiaz bhai
mera khyal ha imteyaz ko bohut muskil say yahi scene yad aya k.kia intresting hua tha is ma...i think woh lag bhag bhool gya ha. .jb k aysay loog bholty nahi magar he has so much work and work load so possible ha k yahi yad aya ho ya asan lga ho is ko batana ...othervise yah ha bunda outstanding. ..and hassen tareen imam ali ka bf
Such a gentleman!!
Please do the 'Medical Center' scene from Dil Dhadakne Do, where the whole family has the discussion after a false alarm about
Anil Kapoors' charecter's health.
When will we see kareena in your movie again???
Teddy maurya was oeffo/the perfect cast..... Nobody Cudve done it better
This was translation. Karan Johar's inside a scene was what we are interested to know.
Teddy Maurya kinda looks like Mika Singh.
I just feel bad for Vijay,he just missed a good role simply because he couldn't reach due to whatsoever reason!
Jai Paramatma ❤️
Movies, business and life are related 😊
He didn’t explain the 3 gante meaning 😂
She's thinking that sharmna kyu means it's awkward talking that we can't afford
Do more inside a scene videos!!! Very informative and entertaining too...!!
We feel you'd enjoy this one: th-cam.com/video/PLRnamhzY6U/w-d-xo.html
superb movie
Nice story fabulous movies
Geet being 'Geet' ..
Excellent movie.
Why is he analysing the scene ...we get it by watching the movie what it meant...we ain't dumb...
Epic scene
superb move
Авинаш Тивари лучше 👍💐 Авинаш великолепный 👍 Авинаш заслуживает награду 🏆
Фильм 💖 Лэйла и Мажнун 💖 классный благодаря Авинаш 👍
Why the hell can you not bring better mics on board?
Wow finally an answer to how he could make a debacle of a film like jab Harry met sejal. His choice of scene for this video is equally worse!
Jab we met was english movie ???
His in rockstar movie also.....
What happened to Karan Johar's inside a scene of the kabhi alvidaa na kehna song?
Dear imtiaz we are not idiotss
He is explaining the scene, there is not much of insight as to how it was shot or any technicalities behind it.
Worst video but jab we met my fav movie n Bebo ❤❤❤
Lovd the movie
Please do more movies with Bebo
Aswm movie 💛
Best movie
I knew Imtiaz was an overrated filmmaker. All his movies has been on the same theme of traveling and self exploration. This video gives a confirmation to that.
We understood the scene Sirjee. Why did you think for this and what importance it had in the script was the point.
Y r u telling the stry.. tel the insides