LISTEN TO WHAT SHE CAN DO! Diana Navarro - Sola REACTION
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ธ.ค. 2022
- Exploring another song by Diana Navarro and amazed at what she does her vocally! Enjoy the Ride to Spain. Let me know what you think in the comments below.
BUT WAIT - before checking out the comments section of this video, make sure to subscribe to this TH-cam channel & ring the notification bell for more awesome content!
BUY ME A COFFEE TO SAY THANKS :)
www.buymeacoffee.com/rosalier...
SHOP LATEST COLLECTION
rosalie-reacts.creator-spring...
SUPPORT ROSALIE
patreon.com/rosaliereacts
If you want access to more content, exclusive videos and covers, AMA, Q&A, special lives and chat community, upcoming merchandise and more, consider becoming a patron and gain direct access to special awards.
________________________________
CONNECT
Follow me on rosaliereacts
_______________________________
Rose E Music
/ roseesongs
theofficialrosee
theofficialrosee
_______________________________
Original Song:
• Diana Navarro - Sola ... - บันเทิง
Hi Team, Enjoy this epic ride with the lovely Diana Navarro and her powerful vocal abilities. Here is some information, which I wish I would have added in the video:
Diana's music often mixes genres such as Copla (poetic form common in Spanish writing) and flamenco with different rhythms such as Arabic or classical music.
Flamenco was influenced strongly by Roma (Gypsies), who originally came from Northern India and India was at one point conquered (in part) by Arabs. Note: Spain was formed as an official state AFTER centuries of Muslim rule.
Also, you can find Melisma (a group of notes sung to one syllable) in Gregorian chants, Arabic ;), Jewish, Orthodox Christian, African, Indian ragas, etc. Tho “world music” is a huge genre, it is common to find melisma among it.
Please note for those who felt some kind of way about me referring to "Arabic notes" versus using the terms melismas etc (tho melismas would def. be a more accurate/better way to explain what she did here):
Arab and African influences are all over and that's a beautiful thing. We all learn and are influences by each other. Arabs have actually been around for a very long time (before many Europeans conquered other countries and Spain even became it's own state) and they too fluctuate with notes when they sing (called Arabic quarter notes from what I’ve learned), so it’s not too far fetched to see a similarity in my opinion. Seeing those similarities is not to take away from the beautiful heritage and history of Spain, Andalusia etc. We all influence each other and ideally learn from one another. The world is a beautiful place.
El flamenco nace en Andalucía España en el tiempo de ocupación árabe,el germen fueron las jarchas mozárabes( cristianos que vivían en los reinos ocupados) que tenían su propia lengua una mezcla de castellano antiguo mezclado con árabe,y los romances cristianos,luego aportaron los judíos y los gitanos y se formó lo que ahora se conoce como flamenco después de siglos de historia,aquí ( Andalucía) los melismas los flamencos los llamamos quejios si son cortos y para dar sentimiento y caracoleos si son rápidos para dar belleza,esto no se estudia,aquí decimos que te lo da dios,aprendes escuchando a los mejores y cogiendo cosas de los que más te llegan,desde niño,en este caso el maestro virtual de Diana principal fue el gran Antonio Molina si puedes reaccionar hazlo o solo escuchalo y verás la influencia.por cierto a ver si encuentro un vídeo de Diana cantando copla pa morirse con 17 añitos ya se veía que sería muy grande un saludo y feliz navidad
Aquí te dejo a Antonio Molina para que lo escuches. th-cam.com/video/VtlPMyLBFC0/w-d-xo.html
Aquí te dejo a Diana Navarro con 17 años su debut en la televisión Andaluza,por cierto perdió el trabajo por ir a la televisión ya que no le dieron permiso para ausentarse. th-cam.com/video/lLmj3rnZcBw/w-d-xo.html
@@gominola66 Muchas gracias por esta información. Feliz Navidad.
ARABE NO, FLAMENCO.
Diana navarro is one of the worlds very best singers and needs to be known as such.
I lived in Spain for over 6 years, and I absolutely love Diana Navarro. From what I heard from my time there is that there is a lot of crossover with Arabic music as the Arabs had conquered a lot of Spain at one point in history.
It was explained to me that for a flamenco singer to be really good, they have to have "duende" which is to have soul or a heightened state of emotion. And Diana transmits the emotion of her songs so well, to the point that you don't even have to understand the words because the emotion is so powerful. It always affects me when I listen to the 2 songs of hers you have played.
I am a real convert to flamenco music. There are different styles from traditional to modern and everything in between.
I've been back in Australia since 2013, and mostly, I listen to Latin music because it is very expressive.
¡Viva la música latina!
Please, don't call it Latin music. It's almost an insult to us. It's an anglo French invention to refer to the countries of South America. It began to be used in the XIX century. I could explain how it began to be used but it would take too long. Nowadays is used in the USA as a racial meaning, what's stupid. It doesn't exist such a thing as a Latin race. Believe me, the languages which come from Latin are called romance languages. Flamenco and all its different variants are from Spain and not from South America. Greetings form Spain.
Muy buena puntualización, me evitaste hacerla a mi.
Es música española, de España.
Los latinos eran una etnia del centro de Italia, es ridículo confundir una etnia con un idioma.
Además de q en España somos de otras etnias, celtas e Iberos mayoritariamente, el idioma español no deriva del latín, deriva del Romano, por eso es lengua ROMANCE y no latina. Pero no es la única, tb del árabe, ibero, griego, etc.
Por todo eso el español no es latín y ni comparte estructura gramatical con el latín. El español se conjuga, el latín se declina.
Ni fuimos, ni somos, ni seremos jamás de otra etnia, la latina, por hablar español.
La siguiente que tienes que reaccionar de el ángel Diana Navarro es ADIÓS.te recomiendo el audio oficial.intenta traducirla al inglés.escucha con atención la letra . puede que te emociones.un saludo desde Madrid
I'd suggest her La Saeta del Larios. Singing from a balcony a cappella during a Holy Week procession. Absolutely chill inducing .
Diana is an excellent singer. Knowing what part of her country she comes from helps you understand the beauty of her singing.
Tu si que sabes su primo viva Andalucía la tierra del arte y el salero 💃💃💃💃💃
Phenomenal vocal abilities for sure.
Very good reacction!
Reacts to "Cuplerias" Gala premios Ceres 2012.
And "Adiós" official video.
Es única,bella,sexi,simple,hermosa,con una voz única,tenemos que estar orgullosos los españoles,de esta joya que es nuestra.
Diana Navarro is a very versatile singer who sings different musical styles. With that particular voice that she always transmits when she sings. On this occasion I recommend a live update called " .cuplerias gala de los premios ceres" you will be surprised what she does with her voice.
Diana is our favorite Flamenca 💃
Wowwww!!!
Robe "la canción más triste"
It's a máster piece
And Diana Navarro "cuplerias" (gala de los premios Ceres)
Please
Magnífica!!!Diana.👍👏👏👏👏👏gracias por tu reacción 👍⚘️💃
Fabulous.
AS always a great ride I like Diana Navarro she has a very nice voice and range and the way she uses emotion in her music gives it a kind of different flare sometimes it reminds me of middle eastern singing but with Spainish lyrics other times it gives me a feeling of flamingo music (tango beat in there too) she has talent and if you can really listen to it beyond the idea of middle eastern sound you get to hear her voice work breath control and range thanks for the ride today as always your ride or die forever EyyyOooo
Beautiful vocals. Love her tones!
In the beautiful Plaza Mayor in the incredible city of Salamanca,
Diana Navarro has an angelic voice and enters our bodies enveloping us. Thanks for putting her songs. Cupleries could you put it?
El tránsito en Salamanca, es alucinante
Ave Maria, deeeeepressssing!!!
Escucha por favor la canción de Diana Navarro ADIÓS auténticamente espectacular, alucinante
Diana Navarro “summertime “,”adiós “
DIANA NAVARRO MEZCLA COMO NADIE LO FLAMENCO CON LO MODERNO Y LAS RAÍCES ÁRABES DE LOS CANTES DE ESPAÑA ...SOLO NACE UNA VOZ COMO ESTA DE MUY TARDE EN TARDE
The Arabic sound you mention is called melismas and comes from flamenco, Diana Navarro's roots are flamenco and copla and she executes it perfectly. I suggest you listen to the song cuplerias which is a "copla" sung in a branch of flamenco called bulerias and if you really want to freak out with her voice listen to her sing the saeta de larios, another branch of flamenco sung a cappella to the Virgin Mary in the holy week of Malaga (Andalucia).
Thank you for the suggestions and info :) I need to check out more.
@@rosalieelliottofficial Saeta de Larios it's amazing. As a singer, no other music style could be most dificult, because a saeta it's only your voice and the kind of the 24 saetas you can chose to try. No music, a bunch of people around, you are alone with your talent, and usually you don't have a micro. Scary but an honour, bc it's a religious flamenco style used in the Holy Week (the week before Easter), when the statues of Christ and Virgin Mary are in the streets. Be chosed by a Brotherhood to sing to their statues, or received permission for do It, it's very serious responsability here in Andalucía, so not much professional singers even try. But Diana is an expert in the Málaga saeta kind, she's a "saetera" since very Young, and won a competition with 17 yo.
Tienes que escuchar a Diana Navarro cantando " Summertime" en directo en programa de radio .Thank you
Diana Navarro : "Adiós"
Diana is an amazing vocalist! One of the best spanish singers by far. Her 2 best lives are "Cuplerias, gala de los premios Ceres" and "Romance de la otra, homenaje a Plácido Domingo". Her vocals in these lives are totally insane (Breath control, fast vibrato, dynamics, riffs and runs, resonance, agility...). I recomend you another 2 spanish singers: The first is Buika, with here live song "Oro Santo". The other one is Silvia Pérez Cruz with here live song "Corrandes d'exili" in catalan, one of the co-oficial languages of Spain. This is the link of the song: m.th-cam.com/video/JxyOG42YE8U/w-d-xo.html
Hi, thanks for you video. For me, Diana Navarro is the best Spanish singer of her generation. She is amazing!
Amazing voice
Diana no es de este planeta 💃♥️🙌🏻
Her vocals are amazing.. great reaction
Hola,muy buena reacción,de este mismo concierto está "El tránsito",te dejará asombrada
Lo que has hecho al final del vídeo de Diana está muy bien, te hechas una siesta y ella aún no acaba la nota, que viva España y sus artistas.
Diana Navarro es Malagueña, viva Andalucía, cuanto arte.
💗💗💗
Diana le dedico esta canción a su amiga que había quedado viuda.
Hola.
Diana Navarro es maravillosa e increíble, tiene muchísimas canciones que son impactantes.
Te recomiendo de ella:La saeta en la calle Larios.
Y también te recomiendo otra cantante andaluza muy buena.
Pastora Soler en Eurovision: Quédate conmigo.
Un saludo y Feliz Navidad
La Verdad. Ella es muy increíble
Me gustaría que escuchara clupleriAs de Diana Navarro
Don’t want to die without seeing her in a concert!
Imaginate que esto es en directo..., esta mujer es musica, no le des mas vueltas, unica, sola, maravillosa, Diana Navarro..., sobran comentarios.
Me gustaría que reaccionaras a "En la cabaña que habito" cantada por Diana Navarro y acompañada de dos excelentes guitarristas. La canción es preciosa. Un saludo.
Por dios.Diana!! Cuanta.potencia.👍💃🇪🇸⚘️
Excelente video!! Diana Navarro es simplemente espectacular!! Si quieres conocer una de las mejores voces del mundo te recomiendo que reacciones a Cristina Ramos de España, tiene una voz prodigiosa.
Her voice just flows
I really like her song Ea as well
💃
Please, react yo Summertime Diana Navarro Cover
Liliac....Just released...Live@ MadLife....."Let me go".....live in concert, 2021, but just released last weekend....
Flamenco y árabe son dos artes diferentes.Aquí en España y sobre todo Andalucía,región española,tenemos muy arraigado el flamenco y hay al margen,raíces árabes por la obviedad de 800 años de presencia arabe en España.
"CUPLERIAS" CERES awards from the Roman theater of Merida, please
Desde jovencita, tiene el apodo, de "La Niña de los 3 Pulmones". Ya sabes por qué
Diana Navarro.. Adiós, obra de arte
Aquí se nota mucho mejor su raíz flamenquita. Maravillosa Diana Navarro!! Olivia Ovidia es otra canción memorable de esta mujer
Listen to her cover of Summertime. Thank you very much for your reaction so interesting
tu y yo necesitamos respirar pa vivir , ella ........ lo dudo ajjajaja
I got the same feeling of arabic influence when she sang. And with what skill! As if her vocal cords were played like a string instrument. Amazing. This has nothing to do with the forced vocal excercises so many other female singers are known for to just show off.
And although the spanish chanson-esque style of the music isn't my cup of tea, you have to give credit to where it's due: to a singer, a true artist with incredible capabilities. Again, not as an end in itself but as part of an artistic expression.
Okay, could've just said: not my music but she's one in a hundred million...😉💛
thank you for continually sharing comments that are eloquent and interesting to read! agreed. credit where credit is due and I think that's special when we can enjoy music for its art even if it varies from our usual playlist or musical taste.
@@rosalieelliottofficial Thank you very much - I sometimes think that my frequent comments might be a bit unnerving. But what i love about your channel is that you expand my musical horizon - I may not like all of it but that's not the point. You said it: enjoy music for its art!
BTW: I made it a habit to always visit the featured artists and leave a like so they also will profit at least a little bit from your reviews. Maybe you could put that out as sort of a recommendation as well from time to time? Well, not that I do it, but that the rest of your riders do it as well and support the artists...
@@flamedealership Not at all! On the contrary. You are a rider now (at least in my book) and something would be missing if I didn't see a flaming (get it!? :) ) comment every so often. Keep em coming! I value what you have to say. And yes! that's a great idea!!
Spanish music, especially Andalusian music, has a lot of Arab influence due to the eight centuries of Muslim presence on the peninsula. Without that history, the famous Spanish guitar, heir to the medieval string instruments brought to Spain, would not exist. as well as the melismas: the intense vibrato. Typical of flamenco, it comes from the melismas of Muslim music. Diana Navarro sings here a mix between pop and copla, which is an Andalusian genre (much simpler than flamenco and very popular). In Spain we say that Diana is the woman with two lungs, due to her extraordinary vocal abilities.
@@himilcecastulo5579 Thank you very much for your quick tour of hispanic music history. As I said in my original comment I truly admired her capability of using those melismas. I could only reference it by saying the usage of her vocal cords were similar to a string instrument being picked by a very skilled musician. She always was spot on. I couldn't hear one single missed note. And I admire her for that even though the music itself doesn't effect my old German soul..😉💛💛
It touches you really, altough music has no borders and language can transform in emotions ..
Check your Dna … you look pretty spanish to me🤗
:) I am half Cuban. Possibly quite a bit of Spanish in there :)
@@rosalieelliottofficial
Aha see 🤩
Wish you the best Madame,
I enjoyed your revieuw off this song so thanks again 🙏🏽
Muchas gracias por esta maravillosa reacción. Le recomiendo reaccionar a: Diana Navarro - El perdón .
Le aseguro que le va a ENCANTAR 😘
Ya a reaccionado buscalo que ya lo hizo 😉
@@gominola66 Ah vale, gracias
Todo el concierto salamanca 2005 es una maravilla !!!!
El adios de Diana Navarro es la mejor cancion👍🙏
Hola simpática Feliz Navidad y un prospero Año Nuevo
Hola Rosalie, me gustaría conocer tu valoración sobre otras canciones de Diana Navarro, mi paisana. Entre otras: Adiós, Romance de la Otra (Directo en el homenaje a Plácido Domingo), y tantas otras más. Saludos desde Málaga (España)
20.000 personas en la plaza de Salamanca.
Tienes que escuchar "Peces de Ciudad" cantada por Pablo Alborán y Pablo López . Te va a gustar
Escucha a Diana: (Mira lo que te has perdido) Fnac directo. Mira lo que hace en el minuto 1:30🎻🎻🎻🤯 alucinante.
Es el video que tiene un vestido negro y el escenario es rojo.
Tienes que verlo
Another tip
India Martinez (artist) El aire y el baile (Wind and Dance).
Este trozo canta a capela y su voz es musica siempre.
Je..je, gracias simpática
👏👏👏🤩
Please react to "Adiós", by Diana Navarro......🤗🤗
DEAR ROSALIE, YOUR COMMENT AND EVALUATION, EVEN ALTHOUGH YOU DID IR IN ENGLISH, WAS A COMPLETE MASTERPIECE, THANK YOU VERY MUCH. PLEASE OFFER US MORE COMMENTS OF GOOD SINGERS, FOR INSTANCE THE SONG GABRIELA BY AMIRA, THIS IS IN SWEDISH, BUT IS A VERY NICE SONG AND WE WOULD LIKE TO READ ON YOUR OPINION ON THIS AMIRA´S SONG..... . GREETINGS FROM LIMA PERU...CHEERS..... LUIS.
Thank you very much, Luis :)
Esta versión es una fusión. Te recomiendo k conozcas la original en flamenco.
React to EL TRANSITO ( saeta: flamenco religioso) by Diana Navarro ( a cappella) Salamanca 2005 . Thank you and greetings..
React to LA GENTE by Diana Navarro. Plza Mayor de Salamanca (LIVE ( 2005). Thank you and greetings from Zaragoza ( Spain).
Los árabes estuvieron en España desde el año 711 al año 1492, como no vamos a tener esas reminiscencias?
Diana is the women Witherspoon tree lungs
👍👍
Please reaction romance de la otra , diana navarro
Diana Navarro is the woman with tree lungs
air control over9000
No arabian touch, its flamenco, andalusian way of art
Flamenco was influenced strongly by Roma (Gypsies), who originally came from Northern India and India was at one point conquered (partly) by Arabs. Before Spain was a united state, it was under Muslim rule for centuries. Arab and African influences are all over. We all learn and are influences by each other. According to resources Diana's music usually mixes "genres like copla and flamenco with different rhythms like Arabic or classical music".
@@rosalieelliottofficial prima el flamenco se divide en dos ramas el cante gitano y el cante flamenco andaluz,cada uno tiene su eco y su forma de cantar pero los dos sobre unas reglas inamovibles y exactamente iguales,lo unico que varía es como lo siente,el flamenco es improvisado,cantas como lo sientes en ese momento,yo te canto la misma bulería 2 veces y no te la canto igual.el conjunto del cante gitano y el cante flamenco andaluz es lo que se denomina flamenco,y no tu coges a un gitano o un andaluz que no allá nació en casa flamenca y no sabe cantar flamenco.
@@rosalieelliottofficial eso sí,pero sus quejios ( melismas son de la copla y el flamenco) esto que canta ella aquí no es flamenco es fusión, te dejo a ella cantando un fandango que sí es flamenco,todo lo que no sea guitarra,palmas y un cajón ,si lleva más instrumentos eso ya no es flamenco puro.
Aquí está cantando flamenco th-cam.com/video/nrEaAxwivhU/w-d-xo.html
React to EN TIERRA EXTRAÑA by DIANA NAVARRO LIVE CANAL SUR RADIO TV Program SOMOS MUSICA. Thank you and greetings from Zaragoza / Spain).
No es árabe, ella canta copla y flamenco, fandangos, bulerías.... es decir, cante tradicional español
th-cam.com/video/xgao6FxtMLI/w-d-xo.html Te lo recomiendo. Diana Navarro es muy versátil. Esta canción la interpreta con un grupo gallego, espero que la disfrutes.
Te equivocas el concierto es en directo y con público, como van hacer diferentes tomas?
Otra de diana es el perdón
Beatificación reacción:)
I sugests you to react to anoche Diana song, "Cuplerias" at "Gala de los premios Ceres" (Ceres awards Gala)
José Malia roca todos los palos
Diana sing flamenco .
España estuvo invadida por los árabes 800 años. Es normal que esas notas te recuerden a la música árabe, pero lo que realmente esta cantando Diana es copla. Un saludo
History Tip. Spain was under Arabic goverment for almost 400 years. Thats why the music has that touch
Los árabes estuvieron durante 8 Siglos en España
800 años,NO 400
Hasta 1492
No es toque árabe es del flamenco y la copla dos variedades de canciones solo de España
No es música árabe cualquier entendido en el canto te lo diría si hace melismas muy bonitos y difíciles.
Hola Rosalie: Siento no poder hablarle en su idioma, le voy a presentar a un artista que está considerado cariñosamente como “el padre de Diana Navarro”. Su voz es, unica e irrepetible.
th-cam.com/video/l1uZendNB0I/w-d-xo.html
Perdoneme por este comentario tal vez no sea de su agrado.pero el gitano español es mas de egipto que de la india aunque algo tendrá claro y a Diana la llaman la mujer de los 3 pulmones por que parece que su voz no tiene fin y es capaz de cantar tanto flamenco, copla, buleria etc.etc. Pero si quiere verla cantar algo diferente busque un video de ella en un concurso de canto donde imitó a la grandisima soprano MARIA CALAS. Todos lloramos al escuchar y ver su imitacion. Esta mujer se atreve con todo. Un saludo cordial y perdon por mi largo mensaje, pero creo que cuando la escuche cantar como la gran CALAS vera la grandeza y sentimiento de DIANA NAVARRO ❤👋🥲🎼
gracias por tu sugerenica :) he leido que algunos piensan que vienen de egipto y por eso recibieron el nombre de gitanos, pero en realidad eran de la india. eso es algo que leí. Todavía estoy aprendiendo :)
No os engañéis,es ESPAÑA,con una española andaluza con su salero,arte a la que junto con otras,las demás mujeres europeas deben de mirarse,eso sí estas jamás tendrán el artecespañol andaluz.
Es el idioma que habla más rápido del planeta , no significa nada , es un dato
React to Diana Navarro is Maria Callas son Casta diva Antena 3 TV 18.11.2017. Link th-cam.com/users/user,antena 3 s Thank you and greetings
React to Diana Navarro is Maria Callas son Casta diva Antena 3 TV programa TU cara me suena 18.11.2017 Link th-cam.com/users/user,antena 3 s. THANK YOU AND GREETINGS
Estimada Eve's Planet
Me gustaria que lo leyeras ya que me tome la molestia de escribirlo, tomalo como una crítica constructiva.
Espero que te encuentre bien. Permíteme comenzar diciéndote que soy un suscriptor regular de tu canal y valoro el contenido que compartes con la comunidad. Sin embargo, me gustaría aprovechar esta oportunidad para expresar una crítica constructiva sobre un aspecto que he notado en tus videos.
Durante el tiempo que he seguido tu canal, he notado que gran parte de tus videos se centran en ti mismo, ocupando más del 80% de la pantalla. Mientras tanto, el contenido o tema principal que intentas presentar a menudo se ve relegado a un pequeño espacio, representando menos del 20% de la pantalla. Esta desproporción en la distribución del espacio visual ha sido motivo de frustración para muchos de tus seguidores, incluyéndome a mí.
Comprende que el protagonismo es una parte importante de la creación de contenido en TH-cam, pero es igualmente crucial encontrar un equilibrio entre destacar tu personalidad y permitir que el contenido en sí mismo brille. Los espectadores esperan una experiencia visual agradable y una presentación clara del tema en cuestión. Desafortunadamente, cuando la mayoría de la pantalla está ocupada por tu imagen, resulta difícil enfocarse y comprender plenamente el contenido que estás tratando de transmitir.
Mi sugerencia es que consideres la posibilidad de ajustar la forma en que te presentas en tus videos. Trata de darle más espacio al contenido principal para que los espectadores puedan apreciarlo de manera adecuada. Podrías utilizar técnicas de edición, como dividir la pantalla o reducir tu tamaño en momentos en los que el contenido sea lo más relevante. De esta manera, no solo lograrás equilibrar tu afán de protagonismo, sino que también demostrarás que valoras y respetas a tus seguidores al facilitarles la comprensión del material que compartes.
Recuerda que tus seguidores son una parte fundamental de tu éxito en TH-cam, y mantener su interés y satisfacción debe ser una prioridad. Al hacer los ajustes necesarios, podrás brindarles una experiencia más gratificante y asegurarte de que tu contenido llegue de manera efectiva.
Agradezco tu atención y consideración para con esta crítica constructiva. Estoy seguro de que, al tomar en cuenta esta observación, podrás mejorar la calidad de tus videos y la relación con tus seguidores.
Saludos cordiales,
Juan
Not arabic.. are you mad?.. It is a mediterranean thing and you will find similar stuff all over it to some degree or another.. arabs werent even a thing when people already used this technique.. and it is "melismas"...You will find it in many diferent folk music in the mediterranean, just that no one does it like the spanish. And btw, arab girls dont sing like this at all neither...This style is 100% spanish and no arabs sing like this ever.. then why people still keep saying silly things like these....
Arabs have actually been around for a very long time (before many Europeans conquered other countries) and they too fluctuate with notes when they sing (called Arabic quarter notes from what I’ve learned), so it’s not too far fetched to see a similarity in my opinion. Spain for example was formed AFTER centuries of Muslim rule.
Many nations have influenced each other over the course of human history. Flamenco was influenced strongly by Roma (Gypsies), who originally came from Northern India and India was at one point conquered (partly) by Arabs. Arab and African influences are all over. We all learn and are influences by each other. Diana's music often mixes "genres like copla and flamenco with different rhythms such as Arabic or classical music". You can find Melisma in Gregorian chants, Arabic, Jewish, Orthodox Christian, African, Indian ragas, etc. The genre “world music” is a huge one, but it’s common to find melisma among it.
But I can tell my comments made you feel the need to get defensive it seems. Finding similarities doesn’t mean it takes away from the beauty of Spanish music and the amazing voice Diana has :)
@@rosalieelliottofficial cuando canta flamenco canta flamenco,cuando canta copla canta copla y cuando hace fusiones hace fusiones,el problema es que tú al no conocer el flamenco no sabes distinguir entre flamenco,aflamencar o fusión flamenca,nosotros los andaluces hemos fusionao el flamenco hasta con rap,pero eso no es flamenco.entiende que el flamenco es algo muy nuestro,los árabes dejaron España hace 500 años ya no pintan na aquí,los tonos,escalas,ecos son distintas a las árabes y si profundizar un poco te darás cuenta.
Music, and modern day music in particular, has embraced cultural influences from thoughout the world. It always astounds me that artists can create so many different songs filled with emotion, harmonies and beautiful melodies that are based on just a few notes available.
Also references made by people listening to music are always based on personal experiences and likes. Where I might get a feeling, I heard a particular style or melody in lets say a classical context, others might contradict that if they don't have my personal musical background.
It's just a sharing of personal opinions and should not be taken as an attack against a cultural heritage. Music in it's entirety is too beautiful to get upset about.
And on the upside we're here because we like music and so we can learn about different styles of music and from people who are deeply rooted in some of it and are kind enough to share their knowledge.
So, as Rosalie said, there's absolutely no need to feel the need to be defensive - let's all just share and have a happy discussion about it.
On a final note: if my memory serves me well, these "different notes on one vocal" or "melismas" were also used in Gregorian chorals which had nothing to do with flamenco at all. Let's not make this a chicken vs. egg matter, though...
@@gominola66 Entiendo que hay diferencias, pero en mi opinión no es tan blanco o negro. No digo que sea lo mismo. Lo que quiero decir es que hay diferentes influencias y culturas que se influyen entre sí hasta el punto de que es difícil diferenciar exactamente qué vino de dónde, al igual que es difícil rastrear de dónde es la gente debido a la mezcla de personas. Por ejemplo soy alemana y cubana, pero bien podría tener raíces españolas también de los españoles que llegaron a Cuba hace mucho tiempo. ¿Tiene sentido?
@@flamedealership very well said! Obviously it is not all the same but cultures influence each other just like there are many countries involved when most people try to trace their ancestry. exactly! Melismas from what I understand way back when, were meant to create a trance like state. Something to be found in Arabic, Jewish, Indian, etc. music. but it's neither here nor there. It's all connected and it's all beautiful