DRIVEN 2018: Perodua Myvi vs Proton Iriz vs Kia Picanto - review in Malaysia
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ก.ค. 2024
- Driven Web Series is back, powered by Petronas Primax! This is the one you’ve all been waiting for - we compare the 2018 Perodua Myvi against its two closest rivals, the refined Proton Iriz and the brand new Kia Picanto. Which one will be the winner?
Pics and details: paul.my/Driven-2018-Myvi-Iriz...
Music: (Vlog No Copyright Music)
Lakey Inspired - In My Dreams
Joakim Karud - Waves
Floppy Circus - Good To Me
Dj Quads - The Improv
&
Empty Beatz - Lonely City - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Wow this show has improved so much since the start. Its no longer trying to be like top gear or any other car show. It finally has its own identity. Very good and informative reviews also
Thanks for the kind words. We try ;)
Isn't every other car show that isn't Top Gear or Grand Tour like this? But it doesn't matter. The point is to be mildly entertaining and very informative. After all people may decide which car to buy after watching this (or at least get useful suggestions).
I agree
The first few seasons is so cheesy. I can finally some improvement. But would be better if you guys use much higher quality recorder. And sound.
Good to see that Malaysian car reviewers are stepping up their games in car review videos. Keep it up! And can sense the element of autobuzz in this video, which is a very good thing!
Kia is Korean product, the main feature is aimed for a user/driver friendly. I like how every thing is being thoughtfully made. Except the small legs room at the back. My sister drives this. If you want an affordable but “canggih” and safe (airbags) choose Picanto!
Proton Iriz has a lot of airbags, a compact body (my car was hit by a lorry but it had not a serious damage), it has a fair room legs for back passengers, great engine sound (mine is the first edition), the riding, cruising and cornering is smooth,
Perodua Myvi is giving a new look and i like how the USB ports are placed at unique places. My younger brother drives it, he likes his car, except for the sound system-he likes the one in my car better.
I have experienced riding all three but i cant explained everything here for it’s going to be long hehe, every thing is well explained in the video anyway. but again,each of the car has their special uniqueness to offer.
But Kia Picanto should be compared with Perodua Axia.
Which one fuel consumption is better? I’ve had hard time for my Iriz 1.6 (1st version). Fuel consumption very high 💆🏻♀️
Muhammad Azim setujuu
Shalieza Ismail yes same here. it goes back to the engine i guess. Iriz is 1.6 .. i have no factual or scientific research but few things that i can share is from the speed and consistency that i drive on (I usually drive at 90km/h.. speeding only when necessary) and the temperature of my AC (the colder, the faster it combusts #iNotice) and also the formula of the petrol would play a factor too (i use petronas and it does save up) hope it helps!☺️
Honestly speaking, you guys did an awesome job with video. Awesome comparison!
Thank you. Much appreciated!
Wow! Paultan hired new video team to shoot this new season? This look much much much better than previous Seasons! Cinematic and Color editing is awesome! Plus, three hosts are performing well, getting nature when facing camera! Great job!
I dont know why but I love seeing iriz fullspec on the road compared new perodua. 😅😅😅
The myvi's styling is a bit too bland if im honest, nothing particularly striking or remarkable but still an all-round inoffensive design
Design itself,is way matured but yes theres nothing new to see.Iriz already 4 years in the market but still everytime i see the 1.6 on the road,its still catch my attention
Me too.. iriz still awesome design..
darko omg i think I'm the only one. Yeah u r right it really catches my eye especially the new Red Colour and Citrus green premium model
I dont like all new Myvi seats. No tights support 👎
For a 4 years old IRIZ, it’s still quite a looker. Evergreen look.
Azlano has better taste... That's why Iriz stay evergreen... I've been driving almost 4years... Tak pernah boring dan bosan. Yang cakap macam2 tu totally bias dan anti proton
Joel Miller ... yg ckp mcm2 pasal Myvi tu pun anti Perodua Juga...
Alsaddam Suhaimi ... Myvi generasi pertama pun masih diminati ramai disebabkan design yg senang diterima ramai... ape guna evergreen when yg tgk Iriz nie is like either u like it or hate it? yeap... big fat boy Iriz
Tasteless
iriz the best
dalam banyak2 kereta segmen hatchback, rim iriz yg ni paling cantik. mcm kelopak bunga. I like it
notre reine for me more like sayap rama2 atau burung bila tengok dari belakang.
Copy
The Iriz still caught my attention. Too bad im driving the before refinement model. But it’s still fun too ride
mytprojects ... coz u own it... so u said so
the long awaited review, thanks and well done guys!! 👏👏
Well done guys! I hope there will be more videos like this. Really enjoyed it. Two thumbs up!!!
I'm impressed with the quality of the video this season, keep up the good work!
Thank you! The team worked hard on this :)
wow, your show improve soo much.. it's kinda satisfying to watch it now.. GOOD JOB
Hi, i'm from Indonesia and i've been subscribe to your channel since 1.5 years ago. I think this video is one of the best video from your channel. The landscape was amazing. Really enjoy your video..
Makasih ya bapak!
Glad you enjoyed it :)
It is nice to see you guys back in action again
Especially Harvinder Singh!!
Surprisingly good! Very informative and clear detailed reviews. Proud these boys are local. More pls.
Masa mula-mula guna Iriz ada orang tanya "kenapa tak beli myvi?"
Some people just don't understand
Aliff Sahli IKR. kawan i tye knp tk guna Jazz? Err
Jawablahh....sbb myvi buruk....
Fatin Amirah me too..😆
@@Pepperoni249 sbb nak kumpul duit untuk buat hantaran kat awk :)
@@yamahaorhonda Iriz Lagi buruk!!!
Great comparison! Driven has come a long way since back in the day! Less try-hard and more realistic! Keep it up!
Really professional reviews and videography. Thumbs up and keep up the great works!
Awesome as always... please make more driven episodes...you guys are doing a great job. I hope we can see more episodes of driven... Frankly speaking it is a good as top gear during the days of Jeremy Clarkson, James May and Richard Hammond.
The videography and script are excellent ! Good job to all !
@Paul Tan's Automotive News - Kudos to this year's review - VERY straightforward, all in all but just one aspect - Matthew should have added a little bit regarding practicality, in the aspect of Proton where he could have mentioned the fact that if anyone can't get on with the lack of boot space of the Iriz can still SAVE UP a few thousand Malaysian Ringgit for the Persona Premium - keep the reviews going!
Finally it's here. Such as long wait.
Its good that u guys classified the noise by full throttle, idle and steady cruise. Both national carmakers got a lot of homework to do as the Picanto has proven to be highly refined, most comfortable drive, with the best cabin fit-finish quality.
That surprised us too. The importance of testing the cars back to back.
Wait till you hear the axia's mad levels of noise. 90db
If may I ask. The higher idling noise for both iriz & myvi, is it due to compressor/aircon-system or anything related to the engine?
Both, actually - the engine and air-con fan.
But the Proton has the louder fan at idle.
over the years, i still love the intro music as much as it could be. :D We love driven, more please :DD
Thank you!
Nice review paultan. Entertaining without overdoing it. I hope u guys keep this up.
FINALLY DRIVEN IS BACK ! regarding the result , i was quite surprised seing perodua is actually at number 1 . few years ago , perodua is at last position when they compared the axia vs picanto and the iriz and it’s truly amazed me seing that perodua is at first place rn . perodua has changed so much in these few years . keep up the goodwork and kudos to team perodua !
and to proton you guys should learn how to make a car and profit like perodua did !
Congratulation for your AMAZING video! :D
Great work guys!
Honest reviews is always appreciated.
there is no doubt..this is the best car review on our land..cograt douhh
Thank you. Very kind words indeed.
Best compare video I’ve ever seen!!! Keep it up👍
I think it would be great to re-visit these cars after say 1 year of ownership. Which car have the most issues or common issues and how difficult is it to get parts and also the cost of parts from each manufacturer to compare with. Atleast the audience have a good feel and confidence of the cars from each manufacturer.
Great idea
Nice one, guys! Where was the opening footage filmed? Stunning skyline view.
Let’s be honest, Iriz is the game changer. Safety wise, it make competitors up their game. Isn’t it?
Yup. Without the Iriz, Perodua will still be happily selling tin kosong Myvis.
What game changer? With the quality of its engine and poor fit and finish? 🤣
m haz sooo windows 95 bro... the Quality has been improved.. and the new campro vvt engine is also has alot of improvement... the new pesona fuel cosumption is like the old Vios maa... but yeah... still lot of work to do... and still a lot of improvement to be done... Proton had improvement we cant denied it.... #protonbuyer #notperfect #buthaveimprovement
Syafiq Khir yupp setuju... Proton bukak mata utk jenama2 kerata lain meningkatkan safety mereka kalau x perodua masih keluarkan perodua Viva yg mcm tin aluminium ajee.. skrg baru laa nampak perubahan kat keluaran baru Perodua... Axia.. Myvi 2018... generasi Perodua yg safety telah di pertingkatkan....
Samad Teganu ... u buy Proton cars of course u Jilat Proton lah... but u cant denied that this Iriz is very poor in sales... even in this review also stated the Myvi built Quality is even better than Iriz.. what u can talk about Iriz is handling and HPF safety which are not everyone choice compare to practicality, fuel saving, better Quality Built, good after sales service and more interior room...
Good stuff!
Thanks, man!
But it became all so serious.... No fun! Like the prev series better
Hafriz Shah perut nampak
i prefer this serious approach over the previous series approach.
Totally agree!
Finally comes back.. good job!!
I would pick out of the trio, the Perodua Myvi. The Myvi offers an interesting design, supreme practicality, and the fact it has a built in SMART-TAG reader so it is convenient for passing through toll bars.
Waited this comparison for years!
Yay! Always great to watch Driven 👏
Thanks PT for bringing Driven back this year. Super first episode, really enjoying the fresh content and Matt is a great addition.
For next episode, would really appreciate a shootout between the latest CRV, CX5 and Tiguan, preferably in top spec with all the options on. Thanks in advance.
Errmm.... Mr Singh you forgot to mention that , Hyundai-Kia Automotive Group own it's in-house steel mill to supply steel sheets for the production of automobiles. Thier latest version of automotive steel which is used in all new Hyundai and Kia cars (including the Picanto) is called Advanced High-Strength Steel or AHSS for short. This steel has been tested globally and is considered one of the best quality steel products used in the automotive industry, by a mass production company. Just putting it out there... 😉
Driven is the first automotive video which spark my interest in the automotive industry.
Yesssss its back.....a lot of categories to go so i cant wait
PAULTAN VIDS HAVE IMPROVED SO MUCH
Good stuff, less bias review. Really like the last part where you guys say good stuff about the other car :). Keep up the good work. Support x3
welcome back boys!!!! good comparisons
Don't agree when u guys said that the Iriz has outdated looks especially the refined 2017 Iriz. Proton Iriz still looks good from the inside and out. Picanto has improved a lot compare to the previous model in term of look but saying that MYVI looks better is clearly a bias statement. We all know and understand no matter how MYVI looks, Malaysian will still want to buy them. They buy MYVI is not because of the look or quality but simply the fact that PERODUA has successfully cemented the positive image of MYVI or Perodua a long time ago, no matter how much other brand (eg. PROTON) has improved
tony kimin ... Proton has being longer in building cars than Perodua... how come they cant match with Perodua today? I totally cant accept what u said that people buy Myvi Just because of its brand image... ur making statement SYOK SENDIRI or perhaps u own an Iriz too... recently before CNY 2020, my grandma brought an new car... we actually want to buy her the new Toyota Yaris but she insist the new Myvi as she said the new Myvi looks better... we even took her to test drive the Iriz but she Just turn her head and she hate the rear looking of the Iriz... like a big fat boys butt...
Finally!! Next please review Proton Persona vs Honda City vs Toyota Vios, as this is top three sedan in B Segment market interm of sales
I wonder why most people abit dislike with the Iriz look? Is it because of the brand? I think it look European design and not outdated at all. The 3rd quarter body looks abit like the A Series (not the newest launch recently)
I don't quite understand it either. It's not the best looking car, but neither was the outgoing Myvi. And the new one isn't prettier either. But it doesn't have to be, it has to be practical.
I love the look of the Iriz. Especially with the spoiler. I guess it's too bold for most people? I consider the new Myvi to be very conservative.. When it first hit the roads, I had trouble distinguishing it from the Ford Fiesta or that other Kia model, what's it called? The Rio? The new Myvi has a very generic overall shape.
Agree, me too prefer the iriz design over the over heavily make up myvi anyday, just a bit too fancy to me. Just personal preference, no offense
the front looks ok, the back is just weird imo. reminds me of the old kenari
Its design makes me think that they hired different designer for its front and rear of the car .
Great review. Deserves a thumbs up
Would love to know how much it costs to replace the windscreen, since the dealer organised insurance quoted RM400 per year over and above the +/-RM1600 annual insurance, which I think is a lot for an A Segment car with no rain sensing, front demisting, or AEB sensors.
A properly exciting Driven episode!
finally!!! been waiting for this
driven is finally back!! been waiting for ages
good and clear explaination. kudos guys!
Yeeahh..
Harvinder Singh is back!
I just drag the bar to where Harvinder doing the review (only interested in the Myvi)
A very well done video!
can you guys do a review on Proton Preve 2018 variants?
as it previously had a hose pipe problem.
nice detailed comparison and reviews!
Nicely done, guys!
Please add another section that focus on safety of the car. For example moose test, emergency brake test and so on
Please do a video like this for Nissan x trail, Mazda cx 5 and Honda crv thanks!
Great glad to see driven is back!!
I lost it with the song choice when they rammed through the boxes with picanto and iriz. Great video nonetheless I had a good laugh at that part!
Awesome work here. Thank you.
Hey, can you pls do another comparison between myvi 2018 and iriz 2019 ?
Iriz all the way 🌹
a levelup in cinematography game, woah goodjob paultan
Yes Myvi won overall. But being mindful of the long queue though for about 3-4 months waiting list for the full spec MyVi Advanced 1.5, a major setback for potential buyers
21:31 Does lowering the ride height affects the ASA camera / requires recalibration ?
Direct competitor to myvi and iriz from kia is actually rio. But well in malaysia we compared to pricing.
nothing wrong in that bro. at the end of the day, pricing is what matters
there’s absolutely nothing wrong with that lol . this purpose of this video is to help and guide us to buy the right car not to buy a car by its segment .
Pricing matter. Plus Rio's pricing too high. Rio should compare with Jazz instead.
Buy an old volvo can already
Distorted market.
"fabric is better than fake leather"
hahaha
Just want to ask when 2018 rush will come to malaysia? Since indonesia had it already
WELL DONE GUYS...GET A LOT OF INFO..THANKS U GUYS~
okay.. it's been 5 years and I came back just to rewatch the lala song scene again😂
Very informative and complete review. Myvi wins it. Kia is cheaper, smaller but more refined. And while Iriz handles the best, it loses out on the other two because of its age and the fact that proton is still finding its feet after all of these years.. 😉
Good job guys and keep it up!
Been using the iriz for 6 months. So far the car has been doing fine. Engine and transmission noise would definitely become louder if you drive above 120, provided this is not a hybrid or V6 car. The handling is good, but not great. One should try the Waja, old Persona, Satria Neo, Gen2, Preve and Suprima S to know the true essence of precise Lotus tuned handling. Comfort wise, it is livable. However fuel consumption is still not bad. Proper driving style without overly depending on the air con would give u smtg like 13.5km/l. But if you all are looking to buy a new Proton, get the Persona instead. The new Persona has better value of money.
good job guys, great info..
Certainly very informative without any biasing factors. Just a quick question, which is better in terms of handling between 1.3 New Saga & 1.3 Myvi. .
Zahemi AZUL ISLAMI saga lagi sedap sebab sedan car lagi stabil. Walaubagaimanapun iriz menang bab handling sebab ianya dicipta untuk import ke Eropah. Iriz lagi sedap dari persona baru
Comprehensive review. However, the video editor, please step up your colour grading. It hurts so much that some really good cinematography went to waste with that flat, dull and down colour.
Will do, dude..
:)
i like the way Matt talks. hahaha.. he shows the satisfactory sound when he talks. .. and i noticed that picanto windshield cracked
Hi guys could you guys di a episode on compact crossover like nissan qashqai and honda vezel
Hope the face-lift model will look beautiful than it's previous model. I also hope they look into sound insulation while on the road as I own the 2015 product and the road noise is abit too much, plus the engine itself just roars at ya. Now, I know that it's the newest product at the time, hence my statement. Would love to see big improvements on the Iriz.
Where’s that parking lot? Looks like a nice place to take photos.
if we always turn off the eco mode is anything going to happen to the car?
Please review B segment car.... Honda City, Toyota Vios TRD and Proton Persona Premium CVT 2016...
Saw windshield crack at the picanto... Which is why maybe the car is shown with its back rather than its front as compared to the two other cars, myvi and proton...
Good review..but just don't understand why the Myvi gets all the positive vibes. I have driven the full spec 1.5 Myvi. It is a good car except for the ride. It is spine shattering over large potholes. And Malaysian roads are full of potholes. Funny thing bezza suspension is much better. Iriz plus points - does come with really comfortable seats suitable for long distance travel + the really good handling.
When to get SUV's cars 3008/Cx5/Crv ?
Harvinder, where have you been?
I prefer Iriz. The only car made of high tensile steel. The best car on Malaysian state roads, tampal, lubang, compared to the other city cars?
Somebody please tell me the location where they shoot the video
Tiga2 model klau beli pn berbaloi value for money
This review just reaffirms my interest in picanto. It looks fun, premium interior (carplay!), and cheapest in its class. Myvi's interior sucks. Iriz's design is 4 yrs old, but it looks really outdated. Go for picanto, folks. Am considering one for myself.
Great video!! 2018 CRV VS CX5 VS TIGUAN pleazzz
Sounds good, actually. How about the Peugeot 3008?
Also can...the toughest fight is between CX5 & CRV...😊😊
I like iriz few years back. But now the picanto should be the overall's best as it has the best build quality and price among other two cars, despite losing iriz in terms of handling.
How I wish I could have all the goods from different band integrated into a car.
Got the latest Myvi 1.5Av. Really satisfied wit it. For me if they add middle arm rest n auto cruise then the car will be perfect.
Excited that Driven is back but will it be truly back unlike last year?
Yeah finally!
What happen to picanto's windscreen? Cracked already ke? See at 19.27
probably because of the crash into boxes
Dylan Ch'ng nah it was from bird poop dude. It was there when he was talking about the interior.
The crack was caused by a stone that was kicked up into the windscreen while we were filming the driving shots.
No wonder at the end of this video only picanto face the other side