You missed 2 goofs you showed, when the twins are traveling to the clay pits the back one is moving faster than the front one and hits it, and the running board of Edwards first coach in the storm is broken and hanging off
4:07 The wires were on Edward and Henry's buffers, and David Mitton dropped it, and got so excited at the Thomas and Friends show that he put the train power to have Edward pull the coaches and move faster so the audience to cheer them on.
1) the first coach foot rod is bend down at the back 2) the break coach's square light thing is backwards 3) there's hardly any light at Gordon's shed 4) the lights at both James and Duck's shed is too low 5) the light at Edward's shed is a bit too high
Because of stock footage being used, studio equipment is seen at the top right of the screen. Due to portions of the script being taken word for word from the original story, the narrator as Henry says "Did you see him (Edward) straining?" even though Edward was still at Knapford and the "heavy" train contained of only 3 coaches. Edward's train has no brake coach. When the engines watch Edward struggle, Edward, Gordon, and BoCo's eyebrows are missing. Also, the back roof of Knapford is missing. In the close-up of Gordon, the man next to him has Blu-tack under his feet. When BoCo says "You're right, Duck!" his face mask moves a little. In a close-up of Edward struggling to pull his train, his second front wheel is derailed. When Edward leaves Knapford, the last coach's paint is peeling up. When Duck says, "Edward's better than any of you," a steam platform is visible underneath Edward. The first coach of Edward's train has a loose running board. In one shot, BoCo's angry face is missing the eyebrows. Fingerprints are visible in the dust on top of Bill and Ben's brake vans. When Bill and Ben arrive at the quarry, someone on the back of Bill's brake van wobbles. In the close-up of Edward's driving wheels without the side rods, some of the stickers used for Edward's lining are badly torn up. In the shot of inside Edward's cab when his driver says "Well done, boy. You've got them! You've got them!" The reflection of a crew member's face and beard can be seen in the window. BoCo's shed doors on his berth at Tidmouth are hanging off and Gordon's eyes are wonky. When Edward pulls into Knapford alongside Henry, blue wires are visible on his and Henry's running board, near their headlamps. Also, blu-tack is visible under the Fat Controller. Edward mysteriously gains headlamps when he passes through Crosby. In the close-up of Edward's fireman sanding the track, Edward is not moving. When Edward says "I'll try, sir," the end of the set can be seen behind him. As Edward begins to the visitors back home and the weather changes, it is still sunny while thunder sound effects are heard. Edward's driver says that both of his side rods were taken off, but only his left one was removed while his right one is still on his wheels as he passes the trees before he passes through Crosby. When Edward enters his berth at Tidmouth Sheds, his left side rod is back on. In the shot of Edward puffing through the signal box during the night, the roof of the last coach is loose.
4:30 Edward's siderods on the only left side was back on, and David Mitton put it back on for Robert Gauld the art director to took his work which is called plagiarism
1:45 The toy model brakevans (not cabooses) have white fingerprint dust on them, and Robert Gauld the art director was so excited for the Thomas and Friends show that he accidently dipped his fingers on the white fake snow and picked it up without washing his hands
2:20 For stormy clouds, the art director made a silly mistake by using the paper to draw white clouds and a dark blue sky, instead of extra black clouds
2:08 We could really hear thunder ⛈️⚡ in the background on the Thomas and Friends layout at the show. The art director forgot to add down heavy 🪨 drops of water 💦 in it.
1:55 As the brakevan (not the caboose) stops, the toy man model inside wobbles, and the art director did the right thing. He added the toy man model inside the toy model brakevan, and didn't put some extra glue to make him stand up to ride in it.
It's okay. Surely it could've been adapted for television a bit better. When Duck told the big engines to shut up he could've instead told them to settle down or keep quiet or words to that effect. After all that's what happened in Steam Roller [Sir Handel told the other engines annoying him to be quiet instead of shut up]
3:04 to 3:10 you can see that both of Edwards drive wheels are moving on that side, but they said he would be like a single meaning only two drive wheels would be spinning, it is kinda hard to spot, but if you stare at his rear drive wheel you can see it moving, correct me if I’m wrong. I understand that they couldn’t exactly replicate that since all four of Edwards drive wheels were powered.
It might not be canon, but Unlucky Tug's Saga about Edward explains that Edward's returning to the sheds takes place weeks after the station scene and he was repaired over those weeks. It would have been nice if the narrator said that in the actual episode.
Look at the State of Edward's Drive Wheels at 2:54, In the original & Remastered versions, They look fine But in the Restored version, They're Badly Chipped (especially the Left-front one)!
3:47 The crew member's face is reflecting on it, and Terry Permane made a silly mistake by getting the camera 🎥📸 almost close to Edward's toy model window inside his cab
2:32 The Green area isn't disappearing, and Robert Gauld the art director accidently dipped the long drawing paper of the sky with green paint while preparing for the show
0:50 Edward and Boco's eyebrows are missing and Robert Gauld the art director was so excited for the Thomas and Friends show that he forgot to use the black marker to draw the eyebrows on
1:27 The orange paint on this last coach is peeling off, and the art director was in a rush to start the show that he had to add on the old train model orange coach that was painted a long time ago
Goofs you didn't mentioned: 1. Throughout this episode, Edward's train doesn't have a brake coach. 2. 1:05 When Duck says "Edward's better than any of you" a steam platform is visible underneath Edward. 3. Edward's driver say that he'll take both of his side rods. But this isn't true because Edward's left side rod is the one is only removed because when Edward passes through the trees before Crosby he has his right side rod. 4. 3:55 When Edward passes at the signal box during night, the roof of the last coach is on loose. 5. 2:42 The first coach of Edward has a crooked running board.
4:34 Boco's shed doors are coming off, and going to fall down, and the art director was such in a rush to start the show that he accidently dropped the toy model big engine shed
I think your wrong useful Edward fan because you said driver, but it's not a driver, it's a fireman. And also in the coaches secne, that guy in a hat is the guy in the episode, james and the coaches. And 2 secnes of berties are the sames secnes in season 1 and 2
Edward was broken down and The Fat Controller was a hot-headed as he was, just want to find something to be angry about when things don't go his way. OK, I understand how you feel Topham but you don't do my homie Edward like that. He deserves better and you didn't even praise him that he brought the passengers back safely.
Good effort, but you missed 2 goofs nonetheless: 1. Duck is a prat. He told James, Gordon and Henry to shut up just because they had a point about Edward struggling. Instead he could've said; 'Settle down!' Or he might've said: 'Keep quiet!' OWTTE 2. Why do James and Henry smile after Duck scolded them? Shouldn't they look either shocked or angry?
Gordon, James and Henry are just ungrateful cartoon character trains because they can’t never get the job right and take it out on other people especially Gordon and James as well
This is not a goof, but, at 1:39 the engine behind the front engine is moving slightly faster causing them to bump into each other. I don’t know why I noticed this, but it’s kinda weird.
You Missed these goofs: 1. A Red Paint Was Painting Through The Windows Of The Brancline. 3:29 2. What Is Up With Edward Just To Move Around In The Tracks, And It Happens 2 Times In A Scene. 3:37 3. Why The Background Changed Through Day Into Night Just In The Second? 3:51 4. Why His Eyebrows Look Like Just Suspicious At All? 4:40 5. How Did Someone Closed Edward's Shed Doors?, Is It A Ghost That Is Trying To Making It Fade The Scene And Doors That Are Opened Now? 4:44
3:18 driver has sticky tac
That could also be the ground
You missed 2 goofs you showed, when the twins are traveling to the clay pits the back one is moving faster than the front one and hits it, and the running board of Edwards first coach in the storm is broken and hanging off
2:39 sticky tac is under the red bucket
in the shot of the passengers cheering at knapford the sign moves
EDWARD'S BODY MOVES AGAIN
4:07 The wires were on Edward and Henry's buffers, and David Mitton dropped it, and got so excited at the Thomas and Friends show that he put the train power to have Edward pull the coaches and move faster so the audience to cheer them on.
4:14Goofs: "Knapfords" signs are swinging.
3:52 edward got his side rods back
I honestly didn’t see that!
no he didn't that was the other side of him
@@Stxern yes, but the driver said he took BOTH side rods off
@@owendinostudios1200 EXACTLY
I don’t really get it
0:48 Gordon is missing his teeth
0:42 is an old scene in S1. In the original video, we can see there is Thomas's steam.
1) the first coach foot rod is bend down at the back
2) the break coach's square light thing is backwards
3) there's hardly any light at Gordon's shed
4) the lights at both James and Duck's shed is too low
5) the light at Edward's shed is a bit too high
THE END IS FUNNY, CAUSE 3 GOOFS
Edward's Exploit BOOM🔥
3:45 I can see Ringo Starr's face on the cab window! lol.
It's very hard to see
@@CheStErCarToonZInc If you look closely I can see something that looks like sunglasses and a mustache.
Really?!
@@jamesleopard8518 yes, If you look closely I can see something that looks like sunglasses and a mustache.
2:32 I knew that goof
Hi i am a fan of yours
0:55 theres a small gap in beetwen duck's face and eyes
2:49 the person on the right is really dirty and is missing his hand
Ducks handrail was Crooked
Edward has side rods to spite his driver saying he took them off 3:52
2:41 the 1st coach step is broken at the end 3:38 to 3:40 Edward is Shaking
Looks like the last coach in some shots is actually Annie
EDWARD'S BODY IS SLIGHTY MOVING
Because of stock footage being used, studio equipment is seen at the top right of the screen.
Due to portions of the script being taken word for word from the original story, the narrator as Henry says "Did you see him (Edward) straining?" even though Edward was still at Knapford and the "heavy" train contained of only 3 coaches.
Edward's train has no brake coach.
When the engines watch Edward struggle, Edward, Gordon, and BoCo's eyebrows are missing. Also, the back roof of Knapford is missing.
In the close-up of Gordon, the man next to him has Blu-tack under his feet.
When BoCo says "You're right, Duck!" his face mask moves a little.
In a close-up of Edward struggling to pull his train, his second front wheel is derailed.
When Edward leaves Knapford, the last coach's paint is peeling up.
When Duck says, "Edward's better than any of you," a steam platform is visible underneath Edward.
The first coach of Edward's train has a loose running board.
In one shot, BoCo's angry face is missing the eyebrows.
Fingerprints are visible in the dust on top of Bill and Ben's brake vans.
When Bill and Ben arrive at the quarry, someone on the back of Bill's brake van wobbles.
In the close-up of Edward's driving wheels without the side rods, some of the stickers used for Edward's lining are badly torn up.
In the shot of inside Edward's cab when his driver says "Well done, boy. You've got them! You've got them!" The reflection of a crew member's face and beard can be seen in the window.
BoCo's shed doors on his berth at Tidmouth are hanging off and Gordon's eyes are wonky.
When Edward pulls into Knapford alongside Henry, blue wires are visible on his and Henry's running board, near their headlamps. Also, blu-tack is visible under the Fat Controller.
Edward mysteriously gains headlamps when he passes through Crosby.
In the close-up of Edward's fireman sanding the track, Edward is not moving.
When Edward says "I'll try, sir," the end of the set can be seen behind him.
As Edward begins to the visitors back home and the weather changes, it is still sunny while thunder sound effects are heard.
Edward's driver says that both of his side rods were taken off, but only his left one was removed while his right one is still on his wheels as he passes the trees before he passes through Crosby. When Edward enters his berth at Tidmouth Sheds, his left side rod is back on.
In the shot of Edward puffing through the signal box during the night, the roof of the last coach is loose.
4:30 Edward's siderods on the only left side was back on, and David Mitton put it back on for Robert Gauld the art director to took his work which is called plagiarism
1:45 The toy model brakevans (not cabooses) have white fingerprint dust on them, and Robert Gauld the art director was so excited for the Thomas and Friends show that he accidently dipped his fingers on the white fake snow and picked it up without washing his hands
2:41 The first coach's running board isn't fixed on properly.
4:38: Gordon's eyes are wonky, and David Mitton fiddled around with the train model remote, with the switch spinning it around
2:20 For stormy clouds, the art director made a silly mistake by using the paper to draw white clouds and a dark blue sky, instead of extra black clouds
2:08 We could really hear thunder ⛈️⚡ in the background on the Thomas and Friends layout at the show. The art director forgot to add down heavy 🪨 drops of water 💦 in it.
1:55 As the brakevan (not the caboose) stops, the toy man model inside wobbles, and the art director did the right thing. He added the toy man model inside the toy model brakevan, and didn't put some extra glue to make him stand up to ride in it.
0:50 Gordons eyes are a little wonky
Yeah i like edward's exploit too
It's okay. Surely it could've been adapted for television a bit better. When Duck told the big engines to shut up he could've instead told them to settle down or keep quiet or words to that effect. After all that's what happened in Steam Roller [Sir Handel told the other engines annoying him to be quiet instead of shut up]
Me three 👍👍👍
2:35 The toy model of Edward's driver was sticky tak all over it, and the art director was so nervous that he accidently dropped it on the glue
3:04 to 3:10 you can see that both of Edwards drive wheels are moving on that side, but they said he would be like a single meaning only two drive wheels would be spinning, it is kinda hard to spot, but if you stare at his rear drive wheel you can see it moving, correct me if I’m wrong.
I understand that they couldn’t exactly replicate that since all four of Edwards drive wheels were powered.
3:57 David Mitton put Edward's headlamps on the toy model of Edward for Robert Gauld the art director, and took his work
2:43 look at the coach's ledge it is crooked
gordon: just giveup
duck: SHUT UP
Edward uses exploits and other stories
next episode: Ghost Train
It might not be canon, but Unlucky Tug's Saga about Edward explains that Edward's returning to the sheds takes place weeks after the station scene and he was repaired over those weeks. It would have been nice if the narrator said that in the actual episode.
1:14 Boco's face mask was shaking loose, and Robert Gauld the art director put one drop of glue on it, and got nervous for the Thomas and Friends show
Look at the State of Edward's Drive Wheels at 2:54, In the original & Remastered versions, They look fine But in the Restored version, They're Badly Chipped (especially the Left-front one)!
3:47 The crew member's face is reflecting on it, and Terry Permane made a silly mistake by getting the camera 🎥📸 almost close to Edward's toy model window inside his cab
2:32 The Green area isn't disappearing, and Robert Gauld the art director accidently dipped the long drawing paper of the sky with green paint while preparing for the show
4:01 Fat controller has sticky tap on his feet
So does the person in the dark green jacket
True
0:50 Edward and Boco's eyebrows are missing and Robert Gauld the art director was so excited for the Thomas and Friends show that he forgot to use the black marker to draw the eyebrows on
Okay there's a reason why there's no rain and wind it was due to the limitations of models at the time
No steam is coming from Edwards funnel
2:41 The 1st coach running board is crooked
0:54 The back roof of Knapford station was missing, and the art director made a silly mistake by not adding it on before the show starts
Where’s the next episode
1:23 track pops off
1:27 The orange paint on this last coach is peeling off, and the art director was in a rush to start the show that he had to add on the old train model orange coach that was painted a long time ago
Goofs you didn't mentioned:
1. Throughout this episode, Edward's train doesn't have a brake coach.
2. 1:05 When Duck says "Edward's better than any of you" a steam platform is visible underneath Edward.
3. Edward's driver say that he'll take both of his side rods. But this isn't true because Edward's left side rod is the one is only removed because when Edward passes through the trees before Crosby he has his right side rod.
4. 3:55 When Edward passes at the signal box during night, the roof of the last coach is on loose.
5. 2:42 The first coach of Edward has a crooked running board.
4:34 Boco's shed doors are coming off, and going to fall down, and the art director was such in a rush to start the show that he accidently dropped the toy model big engine shed
2:48 man was so dirty
You Forgot One More Goof, Edward's Eyes Were Wonky Too
2:05 Welcome to my world!
2:04 where did that come frome
I think your wrong useful Edward fan because you said driver, but it's not a driver, it's a fireman.
And also in the coaches secne, that guy in a hat is the guy in the episode, james and the coaches.
And 2 secnes of berties are the sames secnes in season 1 and 2
That combined with the crooked tender🚂😮 And that would be my oh face
Nice
Edward was broken down and The Fat Controller was a hot-headed as he was, just want to find something to be angry about when things don't go his way.
OK, I understand how you feel Topham but you don't do my homie Edward like that. He deserves better and you didn't even praise him that he brought the passengers back safely.
Do Percy Ghostly Trick
At 2:57 Edward's face is Coming off!
Edward doesn't have a break coach!
Make goofs in a bad day for sir hendle
But that episode is from season 4
thats why they wobbles because they are toys
so many goofs
3:02 The end of the set is invisible, and Terry Permane got the camera 🎥📸 very blurry
Epic
3:26 is the middle coach okay?
This also may not be a goof, but at 4:25 the Knapford sign is wobbling.
Did anyone Notice that in the nighttime scene of Edward puffing past the sheds his side rods were back
2:18 at this scene you see Edward's tender is crooked or I don't know what it called
Good effort, but you missed 2 goofs nonetheless:
1. Duck is a prat. He told James, Gordon and Henry to shut up just because they had a point about Edward struggling. Instead he could've said; 'Settle down!' Or he might've said: 'Keep quiet!' OWTTE
2. Why do James and Henry smile after Duck scolded them? Shouldn't they look either shocked or angry?
Wow, what a condescending tosser.
@@stevemcqwark7061 How do you mean?
2:06 this does not count as a goof because the storm is coming and that’s why their was thunder
You missed a goof, Henry’s lamps has loose glass
Ooooofff
at the start of the episode these footage are reused ones from season 1 and 2
since when did boco has moved to there sheds????
2:41 You missed a goof. The foot plate on Edward's first coach is hanging off.
At the beginning, 2 of Edwards coaches have crooked rooves
3:41 isn't that Gordon's cab
No because Gordon's cab has circular spectacles.
@@PabloAndresColomaMadornes2006 Therefore my first comment is correct. 😎
Gordon, James and Henry are just ungrateful cartoon character trains because they can’t never get the job right and take it out on other people especially Gordon and James as well
You missed one when Edward is happy that they are moving his right eyebrow is not like the left one
2:43 look that coach it's crooked
When u said is that thunder I thin k It might be a rainy day outside the studio
This is not a goof, but, at 1:39 the engine behind the front engine is moving slightly faster causing them to bump into each other. I don’t know why I noticed this, but it’s kinda weird.
Anyone else wondering what happened to GWR studios?
He abandoned his Channel
Is Henry already new shape in this episode?
You Missed these goofs:
1. A Red Paint Was Painting Through The Windows Of The Brancline. 3:29
2. What Is Up With Edward Just To Move Around In The Tracks, And It Happens 2 Times In A Scene. 3:37
3. Why The Background Changed Through Day Into Night Just In The Second? 3:51
4. Why His Eyebrows Look Like Just Suspicious At All? 4:40
5. How Did Someone Closed Edward's Shed Doors?, Is It A Ghost That Is Trying To Making It Fade The Scene And Doors That Are Opened Now? 4:44
1:20 Lol
I don't think you noticed that his crank pins are all still intact.
2:41 the footplate on the first coach is coming off
You missed a goof at 4:14 Edward's light is sticking Out and his headlamps is crooked
Edward's tender whells are not moving 1:31
3:45 looks like dad
You are catching more goofs than the carton manist how ever the smoke disappears to quickly 2:45
Film cut
0:44 0:45 0:50 0:51 0:54 0:58 1:17 1:27 1:48 1:49 1:55 1:56 2:09 2:25 2:33 2:36 3:02 3:03 3:47 3:59 4:00 4:06 4:07 4:10 4:28 4:33 4:36 4:38