I feel like this was one of those moments where two people who were in love meet again and aren't the same people. They will always love each other because they were first loves but i think emma wants to move on. Wishing someone was dead so that it would be easier to put them behind them does not sound like someone in love.
@@sassenach387 she was in love she’ll always love him but not be in love with him 2 different things since he was her past when she was younger he showed her things but now that she had matured she knew she wanted to move on find something new she’ll keep him always in her heart since he was her first love but he was not her epic last love it was hook
@@stephmarie5056 Your focussing on a few words over her whole speech and it's intent. Of course it's a given that she'll have a place of love for him in her heart, but that isn't something to get pressed over. You don't worry about an ex hurting you again if you're now in a neutral place with them. She never really got over him. And they presented her as still being in love with him.
@@Mini-Toast_she said she was in love with him. She just didn’t trust that he wouldn’t hurt her again. And with Henry too consider she didn’t want to take that risk of Henry being affected as well.
@@duckysguidetoshipping8930 Then here is all as Emma had said to Henry to 1x09 neal was a young firefighter and emma a young waitress in a restaurant and bar and neal frequented regularly the restaurant, and more later he asked her to go out with him and she has agreed and they went to an amusement park or Neal Tells him about his childhood (like to 3x22) And in a gaming stand, neal wins a dream catcher and emma wins a key ring, And later they make a weekend in a motel and neal offers holiday to emma. (Or she chose Tallahassee) and 1 week later, Neal finds out that Emma is wanted for stealing of watches in the city of Phoenix and advises him to go to the police and she agrees to go to the police for love of neal and he decides of retrieve the watches . and a month later (While than Emma is in prison) Neal recovers the watches And meet August And he speaks to him of emma and Neal Decides to go see the chief of fireman And to tell emma that he died saving a family from a fire,And decides to give a letter of love for emma to auguste And give her if she discovers the truth about magic or if the curse is broken,And when emma leaves of prison she goes to see the chief of fire and suspects that neal is always alive.
Hannah Baldwin the way he hugged her like that was so beautiful. You could tell it was one thing he wanted for so long. His love for her has always been genuine. He loved her enough to want what is best for her.
This secret was the reason Emma could never really be with Neal again. Because although she loves him and he loves her, and he hurt her to help her, she could never truly forgive him. There would always a part of her that would resent him for what he did, for not looking for her or fighting for her. And he hurt her so bad her greatest secret was she wished he was dead. :(
Neal was not Emma's true love. I think the journey of couples in the show was to find their true love. I don't think it was fan pressure to put hook emma together I think early on they had a great journey together as a couple and it was natural that they fall in love and be each other soul mates. If Emma ended up Neal she would have settled, for Henry sake, for the sake of loving him once, but with Hook he took her whole heart not pieces of her.
@KenyaGirly how he literally chased her gave his Jolly Roger away for her, went to the past for her, stuck with her through her dark one times and she too did the same went to hell for him, made him the dark one so he wouldn’t die they loved each other so much they couldn’t let each other go which is different from Neal she was ready to let go and have him dead but not with hook since he was her epic true love
I think Emma was saying she will always love Neal, but considering all the pain he caused her, wishing for him to actually be dead seems legitime. I think she meant that she's sorta over him, she won't allow herself to fall for him once again at least, but she keeps him in her life for Henry.
She was saying that she will always always be in love with neal and that scares her because she doesn't want to go through the pain of losing him again
It amazes how much alike are both Emma and Snow. Snow wanted to forget about Charming, she chose to run away from her feelings and drank that potion in order to be free of her feelings regarding Charming. And Emma is doing the same exact thing! She's running. She's running away from her feelings. There's simply a lot of parallels between Snowing and SwanFire. They're endgame, while it's been hinted that Tink will end up being Hook's happy ending.
This scene made me cry, I think is one of the best Swanfire's scenes! I like Hook and I feel sorry for him, but Emma and Neal belong each other and nothing can change this. They deserve an happy ending :) #swanfire ♥
Well hook literally has made emma happier than neal gram and even walsh now captain swan is married and they have a daughter who is a product of true love. Emma went to hell for hook (litterally) hook traded the jolly roger for emma and there love was classified to be true. And captain swam is a kick ass couple.
I remember first watching at this point in the season and being soooo conflicted over who I wanted Emma to be with because I genuinely liked Neal and Hook for her, I honestly would have been fine with either, but then they just killed Neal off for good and then I was like... ............. ._. well then... I guess they made the decision for me xD lol
I am a big captainswan shipper but I do see the swantheif in this scene, Emma and Neil did truly love each other and I do believe that she still loves him, but there is to much pain and I really don't think she can live with this pain anymore. So many quotes say you will never forget your first love and I do believe (even though I don't ship it) that Neil and Emma are each others first loves. But I don't think they are true loves, even though Captain Hook might not be her true love(although I hope he is) I do believe there is someone else that is Emma's true love, it's not Neil
Suuure, Hook and Emma are more a "interesting" pairing... But truly, Neal and Emma were a beautiful one. The one that seemed real. Why do so many shows these days have such twists? They slowly destroy the most pure relationships just so they could pair up one person from that relationship with someone else, because they have some sort of "wicked chemistry." The "Captain Swan" shipping really didn't do well for Hook's and Emma's characters. "Swan Thief" however... Tragic, really. :(
Yeah I hate the love triangle that's in every show these days! Just once I'd like to have a show that sticks to a relationship and builds on it. I like hook and Emma together and they do seem more interesting to watch, but like you said, Emma and Neal's relationship was more genuine.
As a Neal and Emma fan, I admit my eyes welled with tears at Hook's confession and the look on his face when Emma and Neal fell into each others arms-loved that moment talk about raw, heart-breaking honesty! I think Hook deserves a happy ending himself but I just can't get behind he and Emma anymore! Oh, why couldn't this have happened last season.
Am I the only person who wanted her with Neal instead? I mean I like Hook and all, I just genuinely preferred her with Neal, but everyone wants Captain Swan instead, and I was just there by myself shipping her with Neal xD
+THGQueen I think it's something that the writers could have written well. They have enough chemistry and Henry for it to be able to be believable. But I don't think it could ever be true love. Simply because Emma has magic and you could see when Emma lit the candle using magic that Neal would find it really hard to except it (no saying that he never could) thanks to Rumple choosing magic over him but I don't think he could encourage it like hook did (as well as others). And I don't think Emma would have done magic as much as she did without the encouragement which would have been a shame as it's such a big part of her and is the reason she succeeds as much as she does in the future. But I know your not the only one who shipped swanfire and wanted it to work, (the number of vids and fanfictions proves that) it's a nod to the acting and relationships between the actors that means their are so many different ships that you can see working. I do think it was a real shame he died so early as you hardly saw any character development or plot with him (compared to other characters)
+THGQueen Everyone doesn't want it, but unfortunately, it's what most fans want. I shipped Emma with Neal, too, well at least after Graham was gone. I thought Emma-Graham would have made a lot more sense than Emma-Hook. But once Neal showed up, I thought that Emma as a character gained considerably more depth and their scenes were so well-acted and organic. The Captain Swan scenes feel so forced and phony, like the writers are trying their hardest to make them likable. They lack the chemistry of Snowing, Rumbelle, or even OutlawQueen. I will say that it's more from Morrison's side that I think the acting is unconvincing in regards to Captain Swan. I think O'Donoghue is convincing. I just think Morrison was more organic in her scenes with Raymond-James.
This was one of my favourite moments between Emma and Neal in 3x06: FROM THE MOMENT I SAW YOU IN NEW YORK IN INSTINCT YOU STUCK BACK IN MY LIFE I KNEW I NEVER STOPPED LOVING YOU BEFORE I EVEN HAD A CHANCE TO TAKE A BREATH I LOST YOU ONCE MORE AND ALL THAT PAIN THAT I HAD PUSHED DOWN FOR ALL THOSE YEARS IT JUST CAME RUSHING BACK I DIDN’T KNOW IF I COULD GO THROUGH IT AGAIN I LOVE YOU AND I PROBABLY ALWAYS WILL BUT MY SECRET IS THAT I WAS HOPING THAT THIS WAS A TRICK I WAS HOPING YOU’RE DEAD BECAUSE IT BE EASIER FOR ME TO PUT YOU BEHIND ME THEN TO FACE ALL THE PAIN THAT WE WENT THROUGH ALL OVER AGAIN
what i got from her speech was that neal's her first love and she'll always care about him but she doesn't want to love neal anymore because all that causes her is pain. she's saying she wants to move on. i believe she already has feelings for hook so i think in the end, she'll choose the one who makes her happy and gives her hope
+lightchester I agree, I can't understand why people say they're true love either. I mean I get it if they mean first love, because yeah, Neal was Emma's first love, but TRUE love? No. I just don't see it. He destroyed her trust, and also kind of treated her like crap when he came back into her life. He doubted her constantly and chalked up her suspicions and instincts up to petty jealousy, never believed in her or her super powers, and even told her if he knew who she really was when he first met her he never would have gone near her. I mean if they really are true loves, who in the world would say that they never would have went near them if they knew who they really were in the beginning?? I just don't' see how people could say Neal was Emma's true love, first love yes, but not true love.
lightchester wow, it has nothing to do with chemistry, that. emma said this because DESPITE their chemistry, Neal hurt her in the past. she was hoping him being alive was a trick, because she does not want to face losing him all over again. She tells him that the instant she saw him again in New York, she knew she never stopped loving him. But she was terrified. Because she lost him twice already (when she ended up in jail, and when he fell through the portal, the pain she thought she had buried, rushed back to her.) the very FACT that Neal still elicits that kind of emotion from Emma actually is only a testament to the STRENGTH of her feelings, and the reality of the fact that no relationship is perfect. Swanfire was true and REAL. It had angst, but it was REALISTIC and heartwrenching in its own right, not just for drama's sake, but which actually fit the characters and their history. Emma LOVED Neal, but she was hoping he was dead was because to her, it would be easier to know she has to move on, than face a future with him. NOT because she does not love him or for lack of chemistry as you so shallowly put it, but because of the fear that enveloped her heart at the thought of facing losing him again. BECAUSE she loves him so much, she does not want to face losing him again and suffering those emotions all over again. Not to mention after the confession, Neal EMBRACED her tightly. He understood why she felt that way, and he never once criticised her for it, but accepted that his past actions reaped the consequences. In this case, her fearing that opening herself up again to him, would leave her shattered all over. How that spelled "awful pairing" to you, I have no idea.
Because it's stupid writing. And words are meaningless. Chemistry is about feeling a connection between 2 characters. Emma and Neal felt like true loves, not the guy she's ended up with.
i wish he was still alive, we are in season 5 and i am still not over it :(. I try to like emma and hook but it just doesnt click with me.....i like them separately but not as a couple....
Did he hear it? Like i don't understand it, because Hook told Neal later that he kissed Emma. But why? Didn't Neal hear that when Hook told it to everyone in that place? Weird thing. So I don't think that Hook heard her secret here
I thought this revelation by Emma was completely ridiculous. Emma had come so far at this point, had forgiven Neal for betraying her, had told Snow that she never stopped loving Neal and wanted a chance to tell him that. And then THIS crap? Wishing her stayed dead? Utter nonsense. And all to jumpstart the debacle that is Captain Swan!
I actually think this makes a lot of sense. Just because you forgive someone for hurting you doesn't mean you want them back in your life. I think when Neal left he broke something he couldn't fix. No amount of forgiveness would ever change that.
I agree with you +drlee2 because what she told to her mother w so personal and when she said it she showed true emotion. She will never have that much emotion with hook. If you think about it If neal didn't sacrifice his life for emma they would of been together. Also neal was the person who retrieved Emma's memory and without him the story wouldn't be the same. Emma will always have something more with neal than she will EVER EVER EVVER have with hook. Capitan Swan was a utter mistake!
Yeah, I'm just not buying Morrison's acting when it comes to the Captain Swan relationship on this series. I recall seeing this scene for the first time when the episode aired and my stomach turned knowing the writers were starting to force-feed this CS nonsense upon the viewers. Emma couldn't even freakin stand Hook at this point in the show. I don't care even IF she really wished Neal were dead and wasn't in love with him anymore, how does she end up with a guy who made her physically recoil and wince more than once for an entire season until she had to start acting like she cared about him?
As someone who's between ships, I can understand why she feels this way. Emma has been running from her feelings for a long time, and it would've been easier for Neal to have been dead than for her to face her feelings for him. Plus, I do believe that she really was beginning to feel something for Hook and Neal being dead meant that she wouldn't have to make a potentially difficult decision between them.
Emma è Neal.... Adoro questa scena, mi ha rubato il cuore....li ho amati dal primo momento, lui non doveva morire ci ho sperato fine alla fine, per un loro lieto fine, e con lui che doveva restare insieme al loro hanry!!! Emma e Neal tutta la vita!!!!
I really really really hope Captain Swan is not the outcome. Because that would prove, for the thousandth time that the fandom was right and I was wrong. After Neal=Baelfire and Henry Goes To Neverland, I am NOT having it!!!
I agree, this was a sad scene, and they did love each other a lot, but I have to say Hook is better for Emma. Now don't get me wrong, I liked Neal, and their backstory was very cute, and they have amazing chemistry with each other, but to me, Hook was always a better match for her. Sure Emma and Neal had something way back when, when she was young, but ever since Neal did what he did, she changed, and grew up. And that change made her into a completely different person. They just weren't the same anymore, and seemed better as friends and as parents who got along pretty well for their child. Especially since Neal was about to marry someone else. Let's be real here, if Tamara hadn't turned out to be evil and betrayed him, he still would have married her. He didn't even want to start something with Emma again until Tamara betrayed him. Every time Emma tried to tell Neal that she had a bad feeling about Tamara, he just blew it off and chalked it up to jealousy. He never once looked at her like he wanted to get back with her. To me, Hook was just better for Emma in many ways.
When she looks him in the eyes and says, "I *love you -* I probably always will", you can just hear (and FEEL) the passion in her voice and *OML* this is one of the times I question if I prefer Hook or OG Neal
okay now before anyone jumps at me, i'm not bashing ST/SF but someone explain to me how hoping someone is dead because you can't deal with the pain they cause you is running away from your feelings of love for that person? neal abandoned emma, he let her go to jail and no matter the reasoning nothing is going to change that fact; emma has always and will always look at it as neal setting her up and running off with the $20thousand they were supposed to share; neal had ten years to find her and explain and he didn't go after her, whether he was scared or not he didn't search for her the woman he claims to love (when he was engaged to another not five minutes ago)
Running off with the $20,000? You really need to rewatch Tallahassee because he gave August the money to give to Emma when he gave him the keys to the car. August was the one who ran off with the money (Neal even said something about it in The Evil Queen) and he's the one who sent Emma to prison, not Neal. The writers have already said that.
Ok first thing first umm the only reason why he did not go looking for Emma is because he was scared(one reason she shouldn't be with him)cause ponokio knew he was bae so he was all lolo Second she is running because she doesn't want to get hurt again(another reason why bae and Emma won't be together)and hook realized that so that's why she loves hook he understands her and that is all she cares about Third she knows hook is not gonna abandon her because he has been through the sane things she has That is why she was hoping bae was dead
aulii napu well said. Emma loves Neal (like she said she always will) And even in Hook's secret, he said he still love Milah and never thought he could let her go until Emma. Emma basically said the same thing to Neal just in different words. She wanted to move on from him. It is funny too - Emma crossing that bridge and looking back seeing all the people of her future, and Neal behind her locked away (her past), very symbolic and beautiful writing.
Feel moment!!! My heart! Go Swanfire!!!! The moment the barrier of his cage was gone and that hug, I was like "Yes!" This moment made me want to cry!!!
+xRaineDropsx Because a bunch of vocal fans preferred the prettier, one-dimensional Hook character to the less attractive, gritty, multi-faceted Neal character! The acting is so much better here. Emma shows genuine emotion with Neal because she's loved him more than anyone. Morrison tries to do it with Hook, but it's just not there. And it's sad, too, because otherwise I find her to be an excellent actress on this series. It's weird that Emma ends up with Hook because she's literally had more chemistry with every other actor she's been "paired" with: Graham, August, Neal, but NOT the guy she's going to end up with! I think the writers literally flipped the script in the summer between Seasons 2 and 3 and opted to go with Captain Swan over Swanfire due to fan pandering.
wanna know? cause Neal doesnt even bother to admit whatever his feeling to Emma. let me make this straight, Emma, a women, risk her pride to tell her ex she still do love him. and what Neal do? boom. nothing. great job
+drlee2 I disagree. Hook is anything but a one-dimensional character. Throughout the whole series since he showed up in season 2, we've seen Hook grow and evolve as a character. JM has amazing chemistry with both CO and MRJ. Emma shows just as much emotion with Hook as she has with Neal.
+angien306 No, Emma TRIES to show emotion with Hook, while with Neal it was much more natural. Morrison's acting with the Neal rang more true. Captain Swan is the result of a rabid fandom clamoring for pretty boy Hook over the more substantive Neal. Hook's never had depth. His episodes are some of the dullest, most empty of the series.
drlee2 Again, I have to disagree. Emma DOES in fact show true emotions with Hook. I can name dozens of scenes throughout the series in which she shows just as much true and real emotions as she's done with Neal. And do you even know the definition of a one-dimensional character? It's a character who lacks depth and doesn't seem to ever grow. Hook has grown as a character ever since he came on the damn show. Emma has made him grow and evolve into a better man. His character is SO much different than it was when he first arrived. Now, I'm not denying that Emma doesn't have real chemistry or whatever with Neal, because I ship them as well. I liked her with Neal, but I see so much better chemistry with Emma and Hook.
Emma and Neal loved each other and never really stopped because they never really fell in love with anybody else. Emma came close to falling in love with Graham, but he died right after they got together. Emma also came close to falling in love with August, but he turned into wood and then a boy before he and Emma could officially start to date. Neal didn't really love Tamara;he just went after her because he wanted a life without magic and I that will cause problems for the 2 of them later on.
It was all about confessing deep, dark secrets. When she said she wished it wasn't true, him being alive and all, it's because she does still love him-Neal and is afraid to love him because of all the pain loving him cost her the first time.
Yes, I know chemistry is subjective, but I don't think Neal has chemistry with ANYONE. Except maybe Wendy. DarlingFire > SwanFire If Hook and Emma don't end up with each other, Hook won't be with anyone else. He is a pretty committed guy. If Emma rejects him for Neal (and since Hook will be the one to bring Emma's memory back, I seriously doubt that she won't take that into consideration. He will make her remember her parents, the people she has always wanted in her life), then Hook won't end up with Tinkerbell, I see them as more of a friendship. Back to Neal and Emma's (in my opinion) nonexistent chemistry, the only reason the writers would make SwanFire endgame is because he is Henry's father, which gives him an advantage. I think it's obvious that Neal wants the best for Emma. He just can't give it to her. I think she really needs someone like Hook who will support her. There is no baggage there (sorry, can't forget Neal let Emma go to prison for his crime while he got off scot-free and then forgot about her for eleven years and then got engaged and then didn't believe Emma when she thought Tamara was evil). Hook has done everything to redeem himself while Neal is still working up to it. Then there is the upcoming death? Honestly, if they were going to kill Hook, I think they would've sent Neal to Emma's door a year later. Anyone heard that they cast Blackbeard? He'll have something to do with Hook, and why would they bother going more into Hook's history if they're going to kill him? Really, it's between Neal and Belle. And it's likely they'll kill Belle because she is Rumple's path to goodness, and that's the way to go if they want him to go bad. But, Neal could be on the chopping block too. I mean, he's reconciled with his father, which is his main plot point, so...? Don't mean to offend anyone, just my opinion :)
I don't understand why so many CaptainSwan fans think that this scene isn't for SwanFire. Well it's not for CaptainSwan either, sorry. Emma looked like she could care less when Hook confessed. She said that she loves Neil, always will. She's not her mother. It was never love at first sight and fairytales for Emma. Ever since she was young she was on her own. She has trust issues, so just because she was easier for her to think that Neil was dead than go through the pain of possibly having to lose him again doesn't mean that she doesn't love him. True love isn't always so simple for everyone, and especially not for people like Emma and Neil. These two deserve their happy ending more than anyone. Besides, Hook did a lot of bad things in his life that are hard for me to forget, despite the fact that he is good looking. What he did to Rumpel was not humane, and this was before Rumpel became evil. I know that he and Mila loved eachother, but that doesn't give him any right to act the way that he did and kill Rumpel's self esteem after breaking apart his family. Besides that, he was a pirate and murdered people for their money. He hasn't redeemed himself in my eyes yet, as what he is doing is just to help Emma and he only acts unselfishly when it's for the people he loves. Also another big thing. He loved the mother of Baelfire and now he loves Baelfire's first love? That's gross. Or maybe not and I'm just weird.
You are not weird. I think what's going on with Hook is transference. That he's transferring all that love he has love for Milah onto Emma. Hook doesn't need a girlfriend; he needs a good therapist.
Hook deserves love too. You are right, he hasn't redeemed himself but it's only the seventh episode so i think many many things will happen in the second part of the season. Oh yeah, if you are so so sure about Emma's love for Neal, Why when Hook ask her to choose between him and Neal, she didn't say "Neal"?
Mirou M because she wants her son back and this is the only thing she is thinking of at the moment. No idiotic love triangle or whatever. she wants the person back she loves more than her own life and after she gets him back the less important thing can come (thats kind of what i think is going on in her mind) I think Hook deserves someone who really loves him for who he is and who would love to get on board with him and ship wherever they want to go While Emma needs someone who understands that Henry is the most important person in her life and she will never ever just let him down like Milah did with Bealfire to be with Hook
Oh and another thing, Emma didn't seemed to phased by Hook's confession. Nor did she look torn when fell into Neal's arms so easily. There was nothing in her face that said "torn". But of course that'll probably come later.
Yes and now they-Emma and Neal can do that together. I remember watching the episode "Tallahasse" and really only paying attention to Emma and Hook, I mean Emma's back story was good but I wasn't really interested but after I fell in love with Neal I went back and rewatched it and you could see how his heart was breaking when August told him that Emma had a destiny and he wasn't part of it. But destiny intervened again when she found him in Manhatten. Coincendnce? No. Fate? Yes.
I was welling up with tears as I watches this, but when Neal embraced her and wrapped his arms around her, that was when I just turned into a puddle. T_T Emma was just afraid to confront him and face her pain. It was easier to think that he was dead and push it all aside. But I think confronting it will help Emma grow and strengthen. And she said that she "Loves" him and "Always will..." Why would she said that if she wanted to move past him?
This clearly proved Neal is not her true love. Can anyone even imagine Snow wishing Charming was dead no matter what he did? (Or Belle with Rumple, etc.)
I'm sorry and no one kill me but I don't get how this is a happy moment between Emma and Neal. Yes, they were each others first love and honestly you will never ever forget your first love no matter what anyone says. But Neal broke her heart, I cant even imagine being alone for your whole life and then finally finding someone to love you but then he leaves you and for 10 years you were thinking he didn't love you. But Emma wished he was dead which shows me she doesn't want to be with him anymore and all she wants is to move on from him. I'm sorry but first love doesn't make it true love. I don't think Swanfire is endgame.
***** I don't think they'll find someone else because in a recent interview with the writers they have confirmed that their plan was for Emma to fall in love with Hook since the beginning of the series. So I doubt they are going to change that.
Leslee G Since... before they even had the rights to use Hook? I don't buy that, Emma and Hook's relationship feels so forced and last minute, done just because the fans liked the actor.
They were going to get the rights regardless. And I honestly don't care what you think. If you say it is because of fan service thats fine keep thinking that. But if they were doing fan service do you really think Emma would be with him right now? No. Because CS isn't the biggest fandom. And the writers liked the actor. There is nothing wrong with seeing something and thinking "hey, I like him, I want him to stay" and you have a different perspective than others because to me it doesnt seem forced. They still have a long road ahead of them.
this moment is so beautiful😍😍😍I get that everyone became so exited about Emma and Hook in previous episode!but honestly they had more chemistry in S2!that kiss ruined it!because Emma was clearly on no mood to have any kind of relationships!not even with her own parents and wasn't even platonicly interested in Hook!and in the episode before that she admit that she still loves Neal💔and this scene also proves that her passion over Neal is still stronger than any kind of lust or chemistry which she had with Hook!she loves him the way she doesn't want to get hurt by seeing and then loosing him again!and after this,Neal told her that he still believes that they can have their happy ending together,even if she no longer believes and tries to move on💔💔💔 I don't care what anyone's gonna say but Emma and Neal's love story has been the most beautiful and in the same time painful road I've seen on this show😭😭😭😭😭
I any cases, this is not going to be your typical love triangle-thingy. It's so just sad for all of them: Hook and Neal are both people that were so hurt and alone all their lives. As much as I ship Emma and Hook, it's going to be hurtful whatever happens :(
please, PLEASE!! don't ruin this relationship with CaptainSwan. I feel it just came out from all the girls who found Colin hot, so they want them together. I can't feel anything between them! and i really feel Neal and Emma is right. Maybe true love, maybe not, but even so, i don't think they believe in that of "true love". They are beyond that magic world, although they are from there. I mean yes, they born there, but they are from this world. they simply love each other, they are not gonna die without the other, but they DO love each other. In a more simple way :) (please don't kill me)
I wont kill you but... YOU CANT FEEL ANYTHING BETWEEN THEM? Sorry for shouting. I just think that this thing between them is pure, bittersweet, melancholic but lovely chemistry. And I am astonished that you didn't feel that.. They compliment each other so well.. And while I really started liking Neal as a person (hated him in the beginning, not quite sure why) I don't like him with Emma in a romantic way. He is a marvelous dad, a great friend and a really good person, but I think Killian and Emma have found in each other their true love. I still respect your opinion though, it would be lame if we all were shipping the same people :D
Emily H. haha thanks for forgive my life! I know it must be chemistry between them because a LOT of people see that. But i swear, i can't feel it :( But by the fact that everyone love them, i have been like.. " psychoanalyzing myself" to understand why i don't. I realized that i used to love the "first love". Like in Inuyasha (an anime if u don't know it) i preferred Kikyo (the first one) and no Kagome, although i do liked her (just one example of several). It sound stupid just say it like that, but what i mean is that when they sell me a "couple" and i like it, i used to imagine the rest of their love story in my head, and i fell in love with them. And then, no matter how annoying things they write, like that Tamara's arc, i am like "uuh.. ok ok! let's pass this, let's go for their story!" and i can't blame the characters but the writers for the annoying and bad situations. I loved Emma's character and story, Bae's character and story, AND their "Tallahassee" episode, so i automatically fell in love with them! it was such an original and unique story Regarding Hook, i loved his character on season 2, he used to be so different from other characters, and now i feel he is in every minute more and more like a "charming" and that's not the character i loved so much.. Sorry i write a lot ( even deleted a lot) but was funny to explain :)
Yeah, he's not half the badass he was when we came in, haha :D But I put that under character development, I think it was important. He actually was the reason why I started watching OUAT. I saw by accident a fanmade video about him and Emma and I instantly fell in love with the characters (I was devsstated though when I found out he'll first appear in seasoun 2) so I shipped them from the very beginning. Although I couldn't stop myself from "aaaw"ing about her and Graham. ♥ I know how it feels like when you have a fictional character's future life all figured out and it all comes crushing down :D → then The Hunger Games taught me better than thinking you know what's gonna happen.. :D
Emily H. ooh thank you, u understand me :') i think if i had been in your place, i might liked them together. But as i know him with that badass attitude i didn't like that change of personality. I understand that about the character development, but i preferred it has developed in a different way. I mean, i don't imagine (for example) Jack Sparrow being married with a princess, having children and living happily ever after. I totally could see him having his own happy ending still with his pirate life, with some woman resembling to Mila. (besides everything i really liked that couple). I used to prefer a very good story rather than a happy ending, so although i COMPLETELY love Emma and Graham, his story was really great. Regina showing that she can really kill someone and show how far is she willing to go, specially if someone was about to discover everything. It gave to the show a more dark side, and i loved it! so, i could accepted it. Then, the reason i started to watch OUAT was Rumpelstiltskin. I ABSOLUTELY love him. He was the soul of the show. His story was the best one in my opinion, the deeper too, and that included Bae. So i loved the character. At least his story. (and i also liked the idea of Rumple being the father in law of Emma, to be honest) :P
As much as I love Neal and Emma, I'm glad they didn't end up being together. It kind of defeats the purpose of Emma's character development in my opinion. Emma is always stuck in the past and unable to open up because of it. Neal was Emma's first love and a part of her will always love him, but he is also a painful reminder of her past and them being together only encourages the idea that Emma is unable to move on. Whereas her being with Hook allows for Emma move on and open up once again- not even just her but for Hook as well. They are both two people clinging on to the past who have been unable to see any hope in the future, and so them being together enables that :) That's just my opinion anyway!
I don't think that Emma and Hook will end up together either. Hook is a pirate; a man who is always looking for an adventure. Emma likes adventures, but with a life of always moving around I think she wants a home. She wants to spend the rest of her life seeing her son and parents just about every day of it. I don't think that Hook would be happy living any life but the life of a pirate and never really fit in with Emma's family.
You know what? I never believed in CaptainSwan being endgame for that EXACT reason; Hook is a man of the sea, and could never be able to settle down with someone. But after the 2x22 and 3x05 flashback, and after everything that happened in Neverland, I realized I was wrong. Hook wants nothing more THAN to settle himself, and he wants nothing more than a family and a place to belong. We saw him becoming friend with Charming after he saw a bit of Liam in him, and we sam him caring about Henry (he was glad that he survived). He's a guy of devotion and he needs to love. The only reason he crave adventures was because he was just running
Emma doesn't want Neal anymore but Hook didn't hear that. He just saw them hug and heard Neal say he won't stop fighting for her. I just want both Hook and Emma to move on from the pain of their past loves towards each other cause they give hope and bring out the best in each other :'(
Well this is Emma, who's afraid of her own feelings. Hoping he wasn't alive meant she didn't have to take the risk. So I think it makes sense. I mean come on this isn't your typical disney love story.
I really want a new twist to this love triangle...I do believe that Neal is better for Emma, but I like how they're twisting it up with something different like her ending up with hook .. My feels
Continued: I love the series and fell in love with Emma and double hook they bring color and fun in their bickering with one another. Love Emma and Hook
Then here is Emma said Henry 1x09 neal was a young firefighter and emma a young waitress in a restaurant and bar. neal and regularly frequented the restaurant and later he asked her to go out with him and she agreed and they went to an amusement park or Neal said of his childhood (like 3x22) and a game booth, neal wins a dream catcher and emma wins a keychain and later they get a weekend in a motel and neal offers holiday has emma. (Or she chose Tallahassee) and 1 week later, Neal finds out that Emma is wanted for stealing watches in the city of Phoenix and advises him to go to the police and she agrees to go to the police for neal love and decides to recover the watches. and a month later emma is in jail and Neal recovers watches, August and met speaking to Emma and Neal decides to go see his chief fireman and asked him to say that he died of a gain emma family of a fire, and it gives a love letter for emma was in August if it discovers the truth about magic or if the curse is broken and when emma gets out of jail, she will see the fire chief and suspected neal is still alive and before August 1x22 turns the wood gives him the letter from Neal.
I Think your right. Emma is so afraid to love Neal again. Love hurts..and he took her heart years ago. With Neal she loose control and she cant loose control until she finds Henry. Love Neal and Emma together. Go and find Henry now..
i really liked Emma and Neal, but i did feel like after some time they both deserved to move on which i’m glad they did. Don’t get me wrong, i really liked Neal and Emma but i feel like if they ended up together it would’ve just been emma settling bc it was more convenient. They were good for each other, they grew from one another, and found love. But growing also means change and they both have and it shows. Emma and Hook are now great together and very happy. I’d always been hopeful for them seeing their chemistry since the beginning, sad for Neals ending but he’s happy now i suppose♥️
NEAL COOOMMMMEEE BACK TO ME NUUUUUU I miss Neal so much i miss his smile i just wish he was my boyfriend when the killed home i was like -_- i hate you -_- i was so mad i want Neal back so much #Neal
Although swan fire were adorable they were just each other first love and she will always love him as she said but not in love and you can see how she wanted to have something new and not be stuck in the past and this is where hook and Emma story will start they are each other epic true love . Emma went to hell for hook and hook traded his Jolly Roger for her
![ร้อยพ่อพันแม่ - WanMai [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XY2pNYASEbg/mqdefault.jpg)
I feel like this was one of those moments where two people who were in love meet again and aren't the same people. They will always love each other because they were first loves but i think emma wants to move on. Wishing someone was dead so that it would be easier to put them behind them does not sound like someone in love.
She has and always been in love with Neal . She just said in this video
@@sassenach387 she was in love she’ll always love him but not be in love with him 2 different things since he was her past when she was younger he showed her things but now that she had matured she knew she wanted to move on find something new she’ll keep him always in her heart since he was her first love but he was not her epic last love it was hook
@@stephmarie5056 Your focussing on a few words over her whole speech and it's intent. Of course it's a given that she'll have a place of love for him in her heart, but that isn't something to get pressed over. You don't worry about an ex hurting you again if you're now in a neutral place with them. She never really got over him. And they presented her as still being in love with him.
@@Mini-Toast_she said she was in love with him. She just didn’t trust that he wouldn’t hurt her again. And with Henry too consider she didn’t want to take that risk of Henry being affected as well.
I just love how even after she just admitted that he still throws his arms around her the second the cage disappears. They’re so cute
you have loved swanfire you too ?
if you are interested, I have an alternative version for swanfire at episode 2x06
@@soixsantes can I read? I’m a cs shipper but would still love too
@@duckysguidetoshipping8930 Then here is
all as Emma had said to Henry to 1x09 neal was a young firefighter and emma a young waitress in a restaurant and bar and neal frequented regularly the restaurant, and more later he asked her to go out with him and she has agreed and they went to an amusement park or Neal Tells him about his childhood (like to 3x22) And in a gaming stand, neal wins a dream catcher and emma wins a key ring, And later they make a weekend in a motel and neal offers holiday to emma. (Or she chose Tallahassee) and 1 week later, Neal finds out that Emma is wanted for stealing of watches in the city of Phoenix and advises him to go to the police and she agrees to go to the police for love of neal and he decides of retrieve the watches . and a month later (While than Emma is in prison) Neal recovers the watches And meet August And he speaks to him of emma and Neal Decides to go see the chief of fireman And to tell emma that he died saving a family from a fire,And decides to give a letter of love for emma to auguste And give her if she discovers the truth about magic or if the curse is broken,And when emma leaves of prison she goes to see the chief of fire and suspects that neal is always alive.
@@soixsantes oh wow this is so freaking good!!! Thank you !!!
He hugged her and my heart genuinely stopped for a moment there. I bawled when he died.
Hannah Baldwin the way he hugged her like that was so beautiful. You could tell it was one thing he wanted for so long. His love for her has always been genuine. He loved her enough to want what is best for her.
The first time a show had ever made me cry was when Neal died.
I agree and I cried so much at that scene T^T
"I love you, i probably always will"
That Hurts After The Rest Of Season 3
I liked Morrison's acting in House, but in OUAT she does such an amazing, beautiful job, always moves me to tears.
This secret was the reason Emma could never really be with Neal again. Because although she loves him and he loves her, and he hurt her to help her, she could never truly forgive him. There would always a part of her that would resent him for what he did, for not looking for her or fighting for her. And he hurt her so bad her greatest secret was she wished he was dead. :(
Neal was not Emma's true love. I think the journey of couples in the show was to find their true love. I don't think it was fan pressure to put hook emma together I think early on they had a great journey together as a couple and it was natural that they fall in love and be each other soul mates. If Emma ended up Neal she would have settled, for Henry sake, for the sake of loving him once, but with Hook he took her whole heart not pieces of her.
That is why Emma belongs with Hook. Because never mind how many lives he would save, he'd choose her.
I agree, Neal is her real love.
@KenyaGirly how he literally chased her gave his Jolly Roger away for her, went to the past for her, stuck with her through her dark one times and she too did the same went to hell for him, made him the dark one so he wouldn’t die they loved each other so much they couldn’t let each other go which is different from Neal she was ready to let go and have him dead but not with hook since he was her epic true love
I think Emma was saying she will always love Neal, but considering all the pain he caused her, wishing for him to actually be dead seems legitime. I think she meant that she's sorta over him, she won't allow herself to fall for him once again at least, but she keeps him in her life for Henry.
Manon Sarah no I don’t think she’s over him. I think she’s just terrified of losing him again. That’s why she wishes he was dead.
She was saying that she will always always be in love with neal and that scares her because she doesn't want to go through the pain of losing him again
Emma's secret wasn't that she loved Neal. Its that he had caused her so much pain she wished he was dead because she *wanted to move on*
It amazes how much alike are both Emma and Snow. Snow wanted to forget about Charming, she chose to run away from her feelings and drank that potion in order to be free of her feelings regarding Charming. And Emma is doing the same exact thing! She's running. She's running away from her feelings. There's simply a lot of parallels between Snowing and SwanFire. They're endgame, while it's been hinted that Tink will end up being Hook's happy ending.
I think Emma's running from everyone
Daniel C nope that's not how it ended at all
Well....you are very wrong doll
Captain Swan won...
Oh my sweet summer child...
This scene made me cry, I think is one of the best Swanfire's scenes!
I like Hook and I feel sorry for him, but Emma and Neal belong each other and nothing can change this. They deserve an happy ending :)
#swanfire ♥
Well hook literally has made emma happier than neal gram and even walsh now captain swan is married and they have a daughter who is a product of true love. Emma went to hell for hook (litterally) hook traded the jolly roger for emma and there love was classified to be true. And captain swam is a kick ass couple.
Neal and Emma had 0 chemistry. Forced cry scenes can't change it.
Fea,apestosa,tonta totalmente
Well I think captain swan is perfect for each other #CaptainSwan
ross Lynchdecendants Rachellbeuty911 Because Neal is dead. But Emma and Neal were made for each others.
When Neal gave Emma that look and instantly hugged her my whole heart exploded 😍😭😭❤️❤️
you have loved neal and emma you too ?
tapo jun I liked Neal and Emma but I love Emma and Hook more
@@MariaCastillo-ec5ue ok thank you
I remember first watching at this point in the season and being soooo conflicted over who I wanted Emma to be with because I genuinely liked Neal and Hook for her, I honestly would have been fine with either, but then they just killed Neal off for good and then I was like...
.............
._.
well then... I guess they made the decision for me xD lol
brucasroxx lol I laughed so hard at this comment mostly because it was me too. But now...I ship captain swan all the way I love them together.
Definitely! Me too! #CaptainSwan
brucasroxx same here
I am a big captainswan shipper but I do see the swantheif in this scene, Emma and Neil did truly love each other and I do believe that she still loves him, but there is to much pain and I really don't think she can live with this pain anymore. So many quotes say you will never forget your first love and I do believe (even though I don't ship it) that Neil and Emma are each others first loves. But I don't think they are true loves, even though Captain Hook might not be her true love(although I hope he is) I do believe there is someone else that is Emma's true love, it's not Neil
I couldn't agree more!
#captainswan #savehenry
Suuure, Hook and Emma are more a "interesting" pairing... But truly, Neal and Emma were a beautiful one. The one that seemed real. Why do so many shows these days have such twists? They slowly destroy the most pure relationships just so they could pair up one person from that relationship with someone else, because they have some sort of "wicked chemistry." The "Captain Swan" shipping really didn't do well for Hook's and Emma's characters. "Swan Thief" however... Tragic, really. :(
I know right!! I hate how shows ruin good couples!!
Yeah I hate the love triangle that's in every show these days! Just once I'd like to have a show that sticks to a relationship and builds on it. I like hook and Emma together and they do seem more interesting to watch, but like you said, Emma and Neal's relationship was more genuine.
I thought they worked really well with each other actually. Captain Swan is my OTP and favourite ship and I’m really glad they end up together:))))
You see the rest of captain swan history?
As a Neal and Emma fan, I admit my eyes welled with tears at Hook's confession and the look on his face when Emma and Neal fell into each others arms-loved that moment talk about raw, heart-breaking honesty! I think Hook deserves a happy ending himself but I just can't get behind he and Emma anymore! Oh, why couldn't this have happened last season.
I can’t get over how Neal IMMEDIATELY rushes to hug Emma the moment he can ♥️ I am still forever Captain Swan but still
Totally loved Neal. He's so cute. Hook and Emma r cute together too
gahh i haven't watched this scene yet without crying!! the music, actors, everything so perfect!
THEY ARE SO CUTE I LOVE EMMA AND NEAL!!!!!
Ship name: Emal. xD
me too
Am I the only person who wanted her with Neal instead? I mean I like Hook and all, I just genuinely preferred her with Neal, but everyone wants Captain Swan instead, and I was just there by myself shipping her with Neal xD
+THGQueen I think it's something that the writers could have written well. They have enough chemistry and Henry for it to be able to be believable. But I don't think it could ever be true love. Simply because Emma has magic and you could see when Emma lit the candle using magic that Neal would find it really hard to except it (no saying that he never could) thanks to Rumple choosing magic over him but I don't think he could encourage it like hook did (as well as others). And I don't think Emma would have done magic as much as she did without the encouragement which would have been a shame as it's such a big part of her and is the reason she succeeds as much as she does in the future. But I know your not the only one who shipped swanfire and wanted it to work, (the number of vids and fanfictions proves that) it's a nod to the acting and relationships between the actors that means their are so many different ships that you can see working. I do think it was a real shame he died so early as you hardly saw any character development or plot with him (compared to other characters)
+THGQueen Everyone doesn't want it, but unfortunately, it's what most fans want. I shipped Emma with Neal, too, well at least after Graham was gone. I thought Emma-Graham would have made a lot more sense than Emma-Hook. But once Neal showed up, I thought that Emma as a character gained considerably more depth and their scenes were so well-acted and organic. The Captain Swan scenes feel so forced and phony, like the writers are trying their hardest to make them likable. They lack the chemistry of Snowing, Rumbelle, or even OutlawQueen. I will say that it's more from Morrison's side that I think the acting is unconvincing in regards to Captain Swan. I think O'Donoghue is convincing. I just think Morrison was more organic in her scenes with Raymond-James.
I shipped her with august until he turned into wood, then back into a little boy 😂
I do, i'm still hoping they'll bring him back to life
+THGQueen
No, I agree with you! #teamswanfire
This was one of my favourite moments between Emma and Neal in 3x06:
FROM THE MOMENT I SAW YOU IN NEW YORK IN INSTINCT YOU STUCK BACK IN MY LIFE I KNEW I NEVER STOPPED LOVING YOU BEFORE I EVEN HAD A CHANCE TO TAKE A BREATH I LOST YOU ONCE MORE AND ALL THAT PAIN THAT I HAD PUSHED DOWN FOR ALL THOSE YEARS IT JUST CAME RUSHING BACK I DIDN’T KNOW IF I COULD GO THROUGH IT AGAIN
I LOVE YOU AND I PROBABLY ALWAYS WILL BUT MY SECRET IS THAT I WAS HOPING THAT THIS WAS A TRICK I WAS HOPING YOU’RE DEAD BECAUSE IT BE EASIER FOR ME TO PUT YOU BEHIND ME THEN TO FACE ALL THE PAIN THAT WE WENT THROUGH ALL OVER AGAIN
what i got from her speech was that neal's her first love and she'll always care about him but she doesn't want to love neal anymore because all that causes her is pain. she's saying she wants to move on. i believe she already has feelings for hook so i think in the end, she'll choose the one who makes her happy and gives her hope
Hook's face... I mean please he was devastated.
I only ship Emma and Neal. Hook is hot and all but Neal is way better for her in so many ways. But that's my own opinion.
,I was hoping you're dead' - Well, what a great chemistry.
I can't understand why people are saying neal and emma are true love.
+lightchester I agree, I can't understand why people say they're true love either. I mean I get it if they mean first love, because yeah, Neal was Emma's first love, but TRUE love? No. I just don't see it. He destroyed her trust, and also kind of treated her like crap when he came back into her life. He doubted her constantly and chalked up her suspicions and instincts up to petty jealousy, never believed in her or her super powers, and even told her if he knew who she really was when he first met her he never would have gone near her. I mean if they really are true loves, who in the world would say that they never would have went near them if they knew who they really were in the beginning?? I just don't' see how people could say Neal was Emma's true love, first love yes, but not true love.
if you are interested I have an alternate version for swanfire from the episode 2x06
lightchester wow, it has nothing to do with chemistry, that. emma said this because DESPITE their chemistry, Neal hurt her in the past. she was hoping him being alive was a trick, because she does not want to face losing him all over again. She tells him that the instant she saw him again in New York, she knew she never stopped loving him. But she was terrified. Because she lost him twice already (when she ended up in jail, and when he fell through the portal, the pain she thought she had buried, rushed back to her.) the very FACT that Neal still elicits that kind of emotion from Emma actually is only a testament to the STRENGTH of her feelings, and the reality of the fact that no relationship is perfect. Swanfire was true and REAL. It had angst, but it was REALISTIC and heartwrenching in its own right, not just for drama's sake, but which actually fit the characters and their history.
Emma LOVED Neal, but she was hoping he was dead was because to her, it would be easier to know she has to move on, than face a future with him. NOT because she does not love him or for lack of chemistry as you so shallowly put it, but because of the fear that enveloped her heart at the thought of facing losing him again. BECAUSE she loves him so much, she does not want to face losing him again and suffering those emotions all over again.
Not to mention after the confession, Neal EMBRACED her tightly. He understood why she felt that way, and he never once criticised her for it, but accepted that his past actions reaped the consequences. In this case, her fearing that opening herself up again to him, would leave her shattered all over.
How that spelled "awful pairing" to you, I have no idea.
i love swanfire, And you want to hear my alternative version for emma and neal or not
Because it's stupid writing. And words are meaningless. Chemistry is about feeling a connection between 2 characters. Emma and Neal felt like true loves, not the guy she's ended up with.
i wish he was still alive, we are in season 5 and i am still not over it :(. I try to like emma and hook but it just doesnt click with me.....i like them separately but not as a couple....
EXACTLY
All along the scene I felt sorry for Hook, you can see the pain on his face when Emma tells her secret, just after he revealed he love her.
Did he hear it? Like i don't understand it, because Hook told Neal later that he kissed Emma. But why? Didn't Neal hear that when Hook told it to everyone in that place? Weird thing. So I don't think that Hook heard her secret here
I thought this revelation by Emma was completely ridiculous. Emma had come so far at this point, had forgiven Neal for betraying her, had told Snow that she never stopped loving Neal and wanted a chance to tell him that. And then THIS crap? Wishing her stayed dead? Utter nonsense. And all to jumpstart the debacle that is Captain Swan!
I actually think this makes a lot of sense. Just because you forgive someone for hurting you doesn't mean you want them back in your life. I think when Neal left he broke something he couldn't fix. No amount of forgiveness would ever change that.
+sunnykimmy agree
I agree with you +drlee2 because what she told to her mother w so personal and when she said it she showed true emotion. She will never have that much emotion with hook. If you think about it If neal didn't sacrifice his life for emma they would of been together. Also neal was the person who retrieved Emma's memory and without him the story wouldn't be the same. Emma will always have something more with neal than she will EVER EVER EVVER have with hook. Capitan Swan was a utter mistake!
Yeah, I'm just not buying Morrison's acting when it comes to the Captain Swan relationship on this series. I recall seeing this scene for the first time when the episode aired and my stomach turned knowing the writers were starting to force-feed this CS nonsense upon the viewers. Emma couldn't even freakin stand Hook at this point in the show. I don't care even IF she really wished Neal were dead and wasn't in love with him anymore, how does she end up with a guy who made her physically recoil and wince more than once for an entire season until she had to start acting like she cared about him?
2:19 In my opinion, one of the best hugs ever ❤️
is that you have loved swanfire ?
As someone who's between ships, I can understand why she feels this way. Emma has been running from her feelings for a long time, and it would've been easier for Neal to have been dead than for her to face her feelings for him. Plus, I do believe that she really was beginning to feel something for Hook and Neal being dead meant that she wouldn't have to make a potentially difficult decision between them.
Aww Hook looks sad
Emma è Neal.... Adoro questa scena, mi ha rubato il cuore....li ho amati dal primo momento, lui non doveva morire ci ho sperato fine alla fine, per un loro lieto fine, e con lui che doveva restare insieme al loro hanry!!! Emma e Neal tutta la vita!!!!
Been watching this video over and over again, thank you for posting it.
I really really really hope Captain Swan is not the outcome.
Because that would prove, for the thousandth time that the fandom was right and I was wrong.
After Neal=Baelfire and Henry Goes To Neverland, I am NOT having it!!!
I cried so hard when I saw this scene and her secret just came out!!!!
:'( Such a touching scene. Thank you for this!!!!
This scene is so sad and show us how much they love each other.
Ew gross no ✋ team CaptainSwan! FOR THE WINNN!
+Airianna Russell No.
I agree, this was a sad scene, and they did love each other a lot, but I have to say Hook is better for Emma. Now don't get me wrong, I liked Neal, and their backstory was very cute, and they have amazing chemistry with each other, but to me, Hook was always a better match for her. Sure Emma and Neal had something way back when, when she was young, but ever since Neal did what he did, she changed, and grew up. And that change made her into a completely different person. They just weren't the same anymore, and seemed better as friends and as parents who got along pretty well for their child. Especially since Neal was about to marry someone else. Let's be real here, if Tamara hadn't turned out to be evil and betrayed him, he still would have married her. He didn't even want to start something with Emma again until Tamara betrayed him. Every time Emma tried to tell Neal that she had a bad feeling about Tamara, he just blew it off and chalked it up to jealousy. He never once looked at her like he wanted to get back with her. To me, Hook was just better for Emma in many ways.
airianna russell Ewww no CaptainSwan 👎🏻👎🏻
I cried during this scene just because I felt sorry for Hook
He deserved so much better than what he got, even after he died they kept screwing him over
When she looks him in the eyes and says, "I *love you -* I probably always will", you can just hear (and FEEL) the passion in her voice and *OML* this is one of the times I question if I prefer Hook or OG Neal
me I prefer swanfire
okay now before anyone jumps at me, i'm not bashing ST/SF but someone explain to me how hoping someone is dead because you can't deal with the pain they cause you is running away from your feelings of love for that person?
neal abandoned emma, he let her go to jail and no matter the reasoning nothing is going to change that fact; emma has always and will always look at it as neal setting her up and running off with the $20thousand they were supposed to share; neal had ten years to find her and explain and he didn't go after her, whether he was scared or not he didn't search for her the woman he claims to love (when he was engaged to another not five minutes ago)
Running off with the $20,000? You really need to rewatch Tallahassee because he gave August the money to give to Emma when he gave him the keys to the car. August was the one who ran off with the money (Neal even said something about it in The Evil Queen) and he's the one who sent Emma to prison, not Neal. The writers have already said that.
METerrell and i'm saying from emma pov that's what it looks like
Ok first thing first umm the only reason why he did not go looking for Emma is because he was scared(one reason she shouldn't be with him)cause ponokio knew he was bae so he was all lolo
Second she is running because she doesn't want to get hurt again(another reason why bae and Emma won't be together)and hook realized that so that's why she loves hook he understands her and that is all she cares about
Third she knows hook is not gonna abandon her because he has been through the sane things she has
That is why she was hoping bae was dead
aulii napu well said. Emma loves Neal (like she said she always will) And even in Hook's secret, he said he still love Milah and never thought he could let her go until Emma. Emma basically said the same thing to Neal just in different words. She wanted to move on from him. It is funny too - Emma crossing that bridge and looking back seeing all the people of her future, and Neal behind her locked away (her past), very symbolic and beautiful writing.
Feel moment!!! My heart! Go Swanfire!!!! The moment the barrier of his cage was gone and that hug, I was like "Yes!" This moment made me want to cry!!!
Ok... watching this with the "benefit" of hindsight... this just hurts. Just, seriously, owww.
Now explain to me again why CaptainSwan had to happen? I just don't see the chemistry I see with Emma and Neal.
+xRaineDropsx Because a bunch of vocal fans preferred the prettier, one-dimensional Hook character to the less attractive, gritty, multi-faceted Neal character! The acting is so much better here. Emma shows genuine emotion with Neal because she's loved him more than anyone. Morrison tries to do it with Hook, but it's just not there. And it's sad, too, because otherwise I find her to be an excellent actress on this series. It's weird that Emma ends up with Hook because she's literally had more chemistry with every other actor she's been "paired" with: Graham, August, Neal, but NOT the guy she's going to end up with! I think the writers literally flipped the script in the summer between Seasons 2 and 3 and opted to go with Captain Swan over Swanfire due to fan pandering.
wanna know? cause Neal doesnt even bother to admit whatever his feeling to Emma. let me make this straight, Emma, a women, risk her pride to tell her ex she still do love him. and what Neal do? boom. nothing. great job
+drlee2 I disagree. Hook is anything but a one-dimensional character. Throughout the whole series since he showed up in season 2, we've seen Hook grow and evolve as a character. JM has amazing chemistry with both CO and MRJ. Emma shows just as much emotion with Hook as she has with Neal.
+angien306 No, Emma TRIES to show emotion with Hook, while with Neal it was much more natural. Morrison's acting with the Neal rang more true. Captain Swan is the result of a rabid fandom clamoring for pretty boy Hook over the more substantive Neal. Hook's never had depth. His episodes are some of the dullest, most empty of the series.
drlee2 Again, I have to disagree. Emma DOES in fact show true emotions with Hook. I can name dozens of scenes throughout the series in which she shows just as much true and real emotions as she's done with Neal. And do you even know the definition of a one-dimensional character? It's a character who lacks depth and doesn't seem to ever grow. Hook has grown as a character ever since he came on the damn show. Emma has made him grow and evolve into a better man. His character is SO much different than it was when he first arrived. Now, I'm not denying that Emma doesn't have real chemistry or whatever with Neal, because I ship them as well. I liked her with Neal, but I see so much better chemistry with Emma and Hook.
Emma and Neal loved each other and never really stopped because they never really fell in love with anybody else. Emma came close to falling in love with Graham, but he died right after they got together. Emma also came close to falling in love with August, but he turned into wood and then a boy before he and Emma could officially start to date. Neal didn't really love Tamara;he just went after her because he wanted a life without magic and I that will cause problems for the 2 of them later on.
Just wanted to clarify: A&E have confirmed that Neal was in love with Tamara and the two were engaged.
I'm not so sure that she was even close to falling in love with August. Never seemed that way to me at all.
flimmii07 Sorry for sounding stupid, but who the heck are A&E? :o
Adam Horowitz and Eddy Kitsis.
Ah, thanks. That makes sense :e
I'll admit it, I wanted Emma and Neal to be end game.
It was all about confessing deep, dark secrets. When she said she wished it wasn't true, him being alive and all, it's because she does still love him-Neal and is afraid to love him because of all the pain loving him cost her the first time.
Honestly, that sharp-pointed sword could've done at least the tiniest bit of damage to the bloody bamboo cage!
I still can’t believe people couldn’t forgive Neal for what he did, but could forgive Hook, who tried to kill her.
Yes, I know chemistry is subjective, but I don't think Neal has chemistry with ANYONE. Except maybe Wendy. DarlingFire > SwanFire
If Hook and Emma don't end up with each other, Hook won't be with anyone else. He is a pretty committed guy. If Emma rejects him for Neal (and since Hook will be the one to bring Emma's memory back, I seriously doubt that she won't take that into consideration. He will make her remember her parents, the people she has always wanted in her life), then Hook won't end up with Tinkerbell, I see them as more of a friendship.
Back to Neal and Emma's (in my opinion) nonexistent chemistry, the only reason the writers would make SwanFire endgame is because he is Henry's father, which gives him an advantage. I think it's obvious that Neal wants the best for Emma. He just can't give it to her. I think she really needs someone like Hook who will support her. There is no baggage there (sorry, can't forget Neal let Emma go to prison for his crime while he got off scot-free and then forgot about her for eleven years and then got engaged and then didn't believe Emma when she thought Tamara was evil). Hook has done everything to redeem himself while Neal is still working up to it.
Then there is the upcoming death? Honestly, if they were going to kill Hook, I think they would've sent Neal to Emma's door a year later. Anyone heard that they cast Blackbeard? He'll have something to do with Hook, and why would they bother going more into Hook's history if they're going to kill him? Really, it's between Neal and Belle. And it's likely they'll kill Belle because she is Rumple's path to goodness, and that's the way to go if they want him to go bad. But, Neal could be on the chopping block too. I mean, he's reconciled with his father, which is his main plot point, so...?
Don't mean to offend anyone, just my opinion :)
I love neal and emma🥰🥲😭sad.... I still do btw I was hoping for more of them though T^T
me too i loved swanfire, and if you are interested, I have an alternative version for swanfire at episode 2x06
Hook's Face is like "Don't look at me! It's your choice if you want to go see that dude or not"
[nothing against the actors] "...i was hoping you are dead..." yes girl I know exactly how you feel (sailing on the ship of CaptainSwan)
I don't understand why so many CaptainSwan fans think that this scene isn't for SwanFire. Well it's not for CaptainSwan either, sorry. Emma looked like she could care less when Hook confessed. She said that she loves Neil, always will. She's not her mother. It was never love at first sight and fairytales for Emma. Ever since she was young she was on her own. She has trust issues, so just because she was easier for her to think that Neil was dead than go through the pain of possibly having to lose him again doesn't mean that she doesn't love him. True love isn't always so simple for everyone, and especially not for people like Emma and Neil. These two deserve their happy ending more than anyone. Besides, Hook did a lot of bad things in his life that are hard for me to forget, despite the fact that he is good looking. What he did to Rumpel was not humane, and this was before Rumpel became evil. I know that he and Mila loved eachother, but that doesn't give him any right to act the way that he did and kill Rumpel's self esteem after breaking apart his family. Besides that, he was a pirate and murdered people for their money. He hasn't redeemed himself in my eyes yet, as what he is doing is just to help Emma and he only acts unselfishly when it's for the people he loves. Also another big thing. He loved the mother of Baelfire and now he loves Baelfire's first love? That's gross. Or maybe not and I'm just weird.
You are not weird. I think what's going on with Hook is transference. That he's transferring all that love he has love for Milah onto Emma. Hook doesn't need a girlfriend; he needs a good therapist.
Hook deserves love too. You are right, he hasn't redeemed himself but it's only the seventh episode so i think many many things will happen in the second part of the season. Oh yeah, if you are so so sure about Emma's love for Neal, Why when Hook ask her to choose between him and Neal, she didn't say "Neal"?
Mirou M because she wants her son back and this is the only thing she is thinking of at the moment. No idiotic love triangle or whatever. she wants the person back she loves more than her own life and after she gets him back the less important thing can come (thats kind of what i think is going on in her mind)
I think Hook deserves someone who really loves him for who he is and who would love to get on board with him and ship wherever they want to go
While Emma needs someone who understands that Henry is the most important person in her life and she will never ever just let him down like Milah did with Bealfire to be with Hook
Hum, you're right, but i still hope that it will happen something between Emma and Hook...
You say Emma has trust issues. That's totally true! Who gave them to her? Neal. :)
Best scene of this episode and one of the best out of this season!!!:D
Oh and another thing, Emma didn't seemed to phased by Hook's confession. Nor did she look torn when fell into Neal's arms so easily. There was nothing in her face that said "torn". But of course that'll probably come later.
I nearly cried when I saw Hook's reaction. It felt like an arrow through the heart. :(
I'm glad Neal's okay but still...
Yes and now they-Emma and Neal can do that together. I remember watching the episode "Tallahasse" and really only paying attention to Emma and Hook, I mean Emma's back story was good but I wasn't really interested but after I fell in love with Neal I went back and rewatched it and you could see how his heart was breaking when August told him that Emma had a destiny and he wasn't part of it. But destiny intervened again when she found him in Manhatten. Coincendnce? No. Fate? Yes.
I just...I can't... all the SwanFire emotions!
Neal and Emma are shipped by me still can't believe he's gone
+Rebecca Rodriguez same :'(
emma&neal...!!! true love♡♡ to me he is her first and only love ♥ and they have a very special son ♡ they were perfection to me♥
i love this show and i am totally excited for the next episodes :D
This has to be the best #SwanFire moments so far. This scene just keeps making me cry. SwanFire all the way for me!!!
such a sweet swanfire scene love the hug
THE FEELS!!!! Owwwww my heart!!!!
I was welling up with tears as I watches this, but when Neal embraced her and wrapped his arms around her, that was when I just turned into a puddle. T_T
Emma was just afraid to confront him and face her pain. It was easier to think that he was dead and push it all aside. But I think confronting it will help Emma grow and strengthen. And she said that she "Loves" him and "Always will..." Why would she said that if she wanted to move past him?
This clearly proved Neal is not her true love. Can anyone even imagine Snow wishing Charming was dead no matter what he did? (Or Belle with Rumple, etc.)
I MISS NEAL SO MUCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! TT^TT
Me to they seriously need to bring him back im not botherd anymore if his not with Emma .henry needs his dad x
+Aimee -nicole Cheeseman maybe they will (in season5 episode 12)
I hope we see him when they go to the underworld
Me too
+skygirlBAJ Me too. Don't get me wrong, I love Hook and Swan. But I just was IN LOVE with Emma and Neal...
THANKS FOR ADDING THIS PART I LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS PART #SwanFire LOVE NEAL AND EMMA TOGETHER!!
This scene just shows how much Swanfire are meant to be together!
Captain Hook looks so heartbroken behind her :( anyone notice that
i didn't like season 3.. almost nothing of it. but this scene? GOD! this scene is so beautiful and heartbreaking and so well written and performed
I'm sorry and no one kill me but I don't get how this is a happy moment between Emma and Neal. Yes, they were each others first love and honestly you will never ever forget your first love no matter what anyone says. But Neal broke her heart, I cant even imagine being alone for your whole life and then finally finding someone to love you but then he leaves you and for 10 years you were thinking he didn't love you. But Emma wished he was dead which shows me she doesn't want to be with him anymore and all she wants is to move on from him. I'm sorry but first love doesn't make it true love. I don't think Swanfire is endgame.
Yeah but I just hope that they'll find someone else because I really don't want her and Hook at all.
***** I don't think they'll find someone else because in a recent interview with the writers they have confirmed that their plan was for Emma to fall in love with Hook since the beginning of the series. So I doubt they are going to change that.
Leslee G Since... before they even had the rights to use Hook? I don't buy that, Emma and Hook's relationship feels so forced and last minute, done just because the fans liked the actor.
They were going to get the rights regardless. And I honestly don't care what you think. If you say it is because of fan service thats fine keep thinking that. But if they were doing fan service do you really think Emma would be with him right now? No. Because CS isn't the biggest fandom. And the writers liked the actor. There is nothing wrong with seeing something and thinking "hey, I like him, I want him to stay" and you have a different perspective than others because to me it doesnt seem forced. They still have a long road ahead of them.
this moment is so beautiful😍😍😍I get that everyone became so exited about Emma and Hook in previous episode!but honestly they had more chemistry in S2!that kiss ruined it!because Emma was clearly on no mood to have any kind of relationships!not even with her own parents and wasn't even platonicly interested in Hook!and in the episode before that she admit that she still loves Neal💔and this scene also proves that her passion over Neal is still stronger than any kind of lust or chemistry which she had with Hook!she loves him the way she doesn't want to get hurt by seeing and then loosing him again!and after this,Neal told her that he still believes that they can have their happy ending together,even if she no longer believes and tries to move on💔💔💔
I don't care what anyone's gonna say but Emma and Neal's love story has been the most beautiful and in the same time painful road I've seen on this show😭😭😭😭😭
Poor emma and hook so broken from their past first loves I want them together
Amazing scene. Jen and MRJ both broke my heart. It's not going to be easy but I think they'll find their way back to each other again!
I any cases, this is not going to be your typical love triangle-thingy. It's so just sad for all of them: Hook and Neal are both people that were so hurt and alone all their lives. As much as I ship Emma and Hook, it's going to be hurtful whatever happens :(
please, PLEASE!! don't ruin this relationship with CaptainSwan. I feel it just came out from all the girls who found Colin hot, so they want them together. I can't feel anything between them! and i really feel Neal and Emma is right. Maybe true love, maybe not, but even so, i don't think they believe in that of "true love". They are beyond that magic world, although they are from there. I mean yes, they born there, but they are from this world. they simply love each other, they are not gonna die without the other, but they DO love each other. In a more simple way :)
(please don't kill me)
First I was for swanfire now Iam CS shipper but you would be surprised how many CS fans are in first case Emma stans/Fans. Just check tumblr :)
I wont kill you but... YOU CANT FEEL ANYTHING BETWEEN THEM? Sorry for shouting. I just think that this thing between them is pure, bittersweet, melancholic but lovely chemistry. And I am astonished that you didn't feel that..
They compliment each other so well..
And while I really started liking Neal as a person (hated him in the beginning, not quite sure why) I don't like him with Emma in a romantic way. He is a marvelous dad, a great friend and a really good person, but I think Killian and Emma have found in each other their true love.
I still respect your opinion though, it would be lame if we all were shipping the same people :D
Emily H. haha thanks for forgive my life!
I know it must be chemistry between them because a LOT of people see that. But i swear, i can't feel it :(
But by the fact that everyone love them, i have been like.. " psychoanalyzing myself" to understand why i don't. I realized that i used to love the "first love". Like in Inuyasha (an anime if u don't know it) i preferred Kikyo (the first one) and no Kagome, although i do liked her (just one example of several). It sound stupid just say it like that, but what i mean is that when they sell me a "couple" and i like it, i used to imagine the rest of their love story in my head, and i fell in love with them. And then, no matter how annoying things they write, like that Tamara's arc, i am like "uuh.. ok ok! let's pass this, let's go for their story!" and i can't blame the characters but the writers for the annoying and bad situations. I loved Emma's character and story, Bae's character and story, AND their "Tallahassee" episode, so i automatically fell in love with them! it was such an original and unique story
Regarding Hook, i loved his character on season 2, he used to be so different from other characters, and now i feel he is in every minute more and more like a "charming" and that's not the character i loved so much..
Sorry i write a lot ( even deleted a lot) but was funny to explain :)
Yeah, he's not half the badass he was when we came in, haha :D But I put that under character development, I think it was important.
He actually was the reason why I started watching OUAT. I saw by accident a fanmade video about him and Emma and I instantly fell in love with the characters (I was devsstated though when I found out he'll first appear in seasoun 2) so I shipped them from the very beginning. Although I couldn't stop myself from "aaaw"ing about her and Graham. ♥
I know how it feels like when you have a fictional character's future life all figured out and it all comes crushing down :D → then The Hunger Games taught me better than thinking you know what's gonna happen.. :D
Emily H. ooh thank you, u understand me :') i think if i had been in your place, i might liked them together. But as i know him with that badass attitude i didn't like that change of personality. I understand that about the character development, but i preferred it has developed in a different way. I mean, i don't imagine (for example) Jack Sparrow being married with a princess, having children and living happily ever after. I totally could see him having his own happy ending still with his pirate life, with some woman resembling to Mila. (besides everything i really liked that couple).
I used to prefer a very good story rather than a happy ending, so although i COMPLETELY love Emma and Graham, his story was really great. Regina showing that she can really kill someone and show how far is she willing to go, specially if someone was about to discover everything. It gave to the show a more dark side, and i loved it! so, i could accepted it. Then, the reason i started to watch OUAT was Rumpelstiltskin. I ABSOLUTELY love him. He was the soul of the show. His story was the best one in my opinion, the deeper too, and that included Bae. So i loved the character. At least his story. (and i also liked the idea of Rumple being the father in law of Emma, to be honest) :P
I wish Swanfire could have remained and that they would have married. I wish he had lived in the end.😢😢😢
so if you are interested, I have an alternative version for swanfire at episode 2x06
As much as I love Neal and Emma, I'm glad they didn't end up being together. It kind of defeats the purpose of Emma's character development in my opinion. Emma is always stuck in the past and unable to open up because of it. Neal was Emma's first love and a part of her will always love him, but he is also a painful reminder of her past and them being together only encourages the idea that Emma is unable to move on. Whereas her being with Hook allows for Emma move on and open up once again- not even just her but for Hook as well. They are both two people clinging on to the past who have been unable to see any hope in the future, and so them being together enables that :) That's just my opinion anyway!
@Kenya Girly lol ur saying the same thing everywhere aren't you?
I don't think that Emma and Hook will end up together either. Hook is a pirate; a man who is always looking for an adventure. Emma likes adventures, but with a life of always moving around I think she wants a home. She wants to spend the rest of her life seeing her son and parents just about every day of it. I don't think that Hook would be happy living any life but the life of a pirate and never really fit in with Emma's family.
You know what? I never believed in CaptainSwan being endgame for that EXACT reason; Hook is a man of the sea, and could never be able to settle down with someone. But after the 2x22 and 3x05 flashback, and after everything that happened in Neverland, I realized I was wrong. Hook wants nothing more THAN to settle himself, and he wants nothing more than a family and a place to belong. We saw him becoming friend with Charming after he saw a bit of Liam in him, and we sam him caring about Henry (he was glad that he survived). He's a guy of devotion and he needs to love. The only reason he crave adventures was because he was just running
alright I tried but I cried no I balled omgosh hooks face made me cry and neal hugging emma made me cry even more
Emma doesn't want Neal anymore but Hook didn't hear that. He just saw them hug and heard Neal say he won't stop fighting for her. I just want both Hook and Emma to move on from the pain of their past loves towards each other cause they give hope and bring out the best in each other :'(
AWWWWWW IM CRYING WITH JOY FINALLY THERE TOGETHER AGAIN :')
Does anyone know the music that played in the background ??
Well this is Emma, who's afraid of her own feelings. Hoping he wasn't alive meant she didn't have to take the risk. So I think it makes sense. I mean come on this isn't your typical disney love story.
I really want a new twist to this love triangle...I do believe that Neal is better for Emma, but I like how they're twisting it up with something different like her ending up with hook .. My feels
All of you see to want Emma and Hook together but ever since I found out Neal was alive I have been pending on them being together again.
I cry at this part they were meet to be together....
Continued: I love the series and fell in love with Emma and double hook they bring color and fun in their bickering with one another. Love Emma and Hook
Nothing against Hook and Emma, but for me, Emma and Neal was better
me too, and if you are interested I have an alternate version for swanfire from the episode 2x06
sure!
Then here is
Emma said Henry 1x09 neal was a young firefighter and emma a young waitress in a restaurant and bar. neal and regularly frequented the restaurant and later he asked her to go out with him and she agreed and they went to an amusement park or Neal said of his childhood (like 3x22) and a game booth, neal wins a dream catcher and emma wins a keychain and later they get a weekend in a motel and neal offers holiday has emma. (Or she chose Tallahassee) and 1 week later, Neal finds out that Emma is wanted for stealing watches in the city of Phoenix and advises him to go to the police and she agrees to go to the police for neal love and decides to recover the watches. and a month later emma is in jail and Neal recovers watches, August and met speaking to Emma and Neal decides to go see his chief fireman and asked him to say that he died of a gain emma family of a fire, and it gives a love letter for emma was in August if it discovers the truth about magic or if the curse is broken and when emma gets out of jail, she will see the fire chief and suspected neal is still alive and before August 1x22 turns the wood gives him the letter from Neal.
Then you liked ?
And if you are interested, I have alternative versions for other characters
Its not a love triangle guys, its like a love circle with Emma in the middle. They introduce like a new person to ship her with every few episodes
I Think your right. Emma is so afraid to love Neal again. Love hurts..and he took her heart years ago. With Neal she loose control and she cant loose control until she finds Henry. Love Neal and Emma together. Go and find Henry now..
Hook looks so upset... After his confession i couldn't handle this i was not happy...
This scene is oddly similar to the underworld scene with the flaming pit below
i really liked Emma and Neal, but i did feel like after some time they both deserved to move on which i’m glad they did. Don’t get me wrong, i really liked Neal and Emma but i feel like if they ended up together it would’ve just been emma settling bc it was more convenient. They were good for each other, they grew from one another, and found love. But growing also means change and they both have and it shows. Emma and Hook are now great together and very happy. I’d always been hopeful for them seeing their chemistry since the beginning, sad for Neals ending but he’s happy now i suppose♥️
so you preferred captain swan better than swanfire ?
tapo jun Yeah i do like Captain Swan better
NEAL COOOMMMMEEE BACK TO ME NUUUUUU
I miss Neal so much i miss his smile i just wish he was my boyfriend when the killed home i was like -_- i hate you -_- i was so mad i want Neal back so much #Neal
I still like hook and Emma
Although swan fire were adorable they were just each other first love and she will always love him as she said but not in love and you can see how she wanted to have something new and not be stuck in the past and this is where hook and Emma story will start they are each other epic true love . Emma went to hell for hook and hook traded his Jolly Roger for her
so you preferred emma and hook rather than emma and neal ?
Made me cry...
I LOVE THE SHOW!!!!