TR: "So yeah, we're super high energy, everyone plays twelve instruments and is all over the stage during live performances." Pino Palladino: " I'm going to stand in one spot and play bass the entire show and it will be the best thing ever." TR: "Okay, I can see it."
Look at these modern "artists" live verses these tried and true bands that got their start performing live in front of small crowds. Nowadays they can make my screeching cat-in-a-tree grinder voice sound like Adele the computers and mixers they use and it shows when the "artist" has come out and lip sink to their own music.
It's incredible how amazing NIN live sounds. I've seen a lot of bands who just arent the same outside the studio production, but not NIN. Trent Reznor is truly a music god.
One of the best performances I've seen on TH-cam My husband got to see them before he passed away. And he told me it was too incredible. He couldn't put it into words .just a big fucking smile on his face for days!! Thank you NIN. for giving him one of those once in a lifetime happy as shit moments!!!
So awesome Deborah.. YOU put it into words so beautifully…….. It moved me…. I’ll now always use: “happy as shit lifetime moments” with respect to you 🖤🖤💜💜
Finlay Poulsen seen em back in the 90's on their downward spiral tour. Great show.We had balcony and security let us on the floor because he was blocking our view. Lady luck.
Finlay Poulsen Seen NIN twice in my life...first time 1994, Denver, CO, with Marilyn Manson opening. Then 2008 at Voodoo Fest in New Orleans. I have always loved and still do love Trent Reznor...
They have a good sound engineer because they sound amazing. This concert is at staples center in LA and that arena is huge so the acoustics is not always great. This is the best live version of this song I have ever seen. Amazing!
Tim Schrum dude I saw them live after having chemo in the morning... then did the exact same thing the next day after a decent drive to the next city.. back to back days of chemo and NIN.. good luck to you brother beating that awful disease.. you seem in good spirits and that goes a long way
Already knew them because of Hurt one of my favorite songs because I really can connect to the lyrics, it baffles me that I did not found this song earlier though. By the way I love that the NIN Fans do not react toxic to the promo by black mirror, it's the first time I don't see a "war" between "dumb opportunists who just ruin everything" and the "I knew them before it was cool" people.
I nearly collapsed in the front row when they played this in Spokane. DRINK LOTS OF WATER BEFORE A NIN SHOW. I drank tequila. big mistake. LOVE U TRENT!!!!!!!
@@Akshaykumar-bs9ml In Black Mirror season 5 episode 3 Ashley O is this pop star played by Miley Cyrus who is shown singing a pop song where the beat sounds like the original nine inch nails one. At the ending Ashley sings the actual song by them . That's all I'm gonna tell u though since you should watch the episode and I don't want to spoil it .
Exactly why I love watching all the liv shows from 90s through Now & I hope More-Trent Reznor is able to truly emote in a way I’ve not seen from other Artists & though stages of life-good-bad-Up-down though decades..... I feel him & feel the changes & what an inspiration Thank you for living & giving
Trent is one of the best music writers and producers of our generation, he made the music industry change when nin formed to give us alternative or industrial.
The awesome moment when your 4 year old sings this at you when you try to take toys off him so he can go to sleep. I'm pretty sure i've got this parenting thing right :D
That's hilarious! My 7 year old sings this song, as well as other Nine Inch Nails songs. It's so funny hearing kids singing this type of music. It just proves they have awesome parents.👍🏻
That's how the authentic to honing their craft into a profession by a pure bred obsession for perfection raging blaze hearts roll. Few and far between, fr fr
@@stephenrussell8600 Trent Reznor said he heard #TheCure when he was young & he'd never heard anything like it & it changed EVERYTHING! they were a major influence for him.
So glad I got to see NIN with a perfect circle many many years back!!! Crazy Trent is still doing his thing, kinda figured he would a retired years ago
They always put on a great show. Saw them in the 90's in Toronto, they had this nuclear orange light that light the whole place up during the riff of WISH 👌
YUMMY THE WHOLE SHOW A TESTAMENT TO TRENT'S GENIUS..THE LIGHTING IS HIS AMAZING CONCEPT THAT PRO'S AROUND THE WORLD CAME TO SEE..EVERY WORD EVERY NOTE PURE GENIUS,,I ADMIRE ADORE AND AM AMAZED BY HIM AND HE NEVER CEASES TO SURPRISE ME EVERY TOUR...LOVE LOVE LOVE HIM,,,,,
Sooo many memories come flooding back! The second concert I ever went to was NIN! It is one of the best and clearest memories from high school I have!.
Do you ever wonder why the whole Year Zero show/movie thing hasn't worked out? I think it's because your living it. You are changing the world, Trent!!!!
@Trentreznorofficial oh wow... that is really you then. Ahah that's huge, it reminds that the greatest people are also the humblest. Honestly I am not a huge fan of NIN anymore and you have been doing so much better music lately... It's incredible how fresh and original it is, like totally brilliant. So I wouldn't look back, even if I can understand that it's a temptation and it's also normal to do so sometimes. I will gladly listen to your last works in the next days :) Kindly Sara
@Trentreznorofficial but of course, listen to yourself to know better, regardless of others' opinion. One thing is for sure, the music you and Atticus Ross made for the films is a standalone work of art.
It was amazing to see Head Like A Hole performed live. I've been a fan since I was 13 and I was 35 when I got to see NIN in concert during the Tension tour. I got a selfie in the light and lemme tell you, that was the. best. lighting ever! I got to see my childhood idol live and get the best picture of myself ever! 😂
what is TRULY STUNNING...Pretty Hate Machine was Composed, arranged and performed in studio all by Trent Reznor himself...then on tours he'd hire artists to perform with him...kinda sad that he doesnt do that any more :S
Too many years ago when this song first came out all of my friends and I got the album. For me it was the first CD I ever owned. I listened to it so many times that that Cd needed to be replaced several times! Still amps me up just to here the opening cords!
![NIN: "Cars" with Gary Numan, London 7.15.09 [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6qlUFKFHNIU/mqdefault.jpg)
TR: "So yeah, we're super high energy, everyone plays twelve instruments and is all over the stage during live performances."
Pino Palladino: " I'm going to stand in one spot and play bass the entire show and it will be the best thing ever."
TR: "Okay, I can see it."
I guess he takes his own name too literally :V
Now his daughter is an amazing musician.
For being so electronically dependent in the studio, it always blows me away how amazing they always sound live.
Sound engineers can only fake so much live.
Look at these modern "artists" live verses these tried and true bands that got their start performing live in front of small crowds. Nowadays they can make my screeching cat-in-a-tree grinder voice sound like Adele the computers and mixers they use and it shows when the "artist" has come out and lip sink to their own music.
you normies have no idea what goes into music production
Electronically dependent Music still sounds great live what?! Ignorant comments make me sick.
One word, "Talent"
It's incredible how amazing NIN live sounds. I've seen a lot of bands who just arent the same outside the studio production, but not NIN. Trent Reznor is truly a music god.
He most certainly is a music God. NIN are amazing on stage full stop!
All the best bands are as good if not better live... they can't be contained by the studio.
Head like a hole will always be a thousand times better when it's heard live...
13 year old me really liked it on his dad's stereo at max too
100% YES!
I wish I could hear ot live...😢
One of the best performances I've seen on TH-cam
My husband got to see them before he passed away. And he told me it was too incredible. He couldn't put it into words
.just a big fucking smile on his face for days!! Thank you NIN. for giving him one of those once in a lifetime happy as shit moments!!!
So awesome Deborah.. YOU put it into words so beautifully…….. It moved me…. I’ll now always use: “happy as shit lifetime moments” with respect to you 🖤🖤💜💜
That's so great-I'm happy he got to see them- May he Rest In Peace & Bless you with peace too- Thanks for sharing
💞
A new way to describe pure happiness
Happy as shit moment!!! Thanks
Nice 👍!
Pino Palladino is an amazing bassist and he just kills it here, one of my idols playing one of my favorite songs 💯
Oh yeah! [and the dude played with The WHO]
Rich McLenson hell yeah, as well as John Mayer Trio(not that it matters lol), he’s a real talented bassist for sure
My life ambition is to see NIN at a concert
Finlay Poulsen same though
Same here!
Finlay Poulsen seen em back in the 90's on their downward spiral tour. Great show.We had balcony and security let us on the floor because he was blocking our view. Lady luck.
Finlay Poulsen Seen NIN twice in my life...first time 1994, Denver, CO, with Marilyn Manson opening. Then 2008 at Voodoo Fest in New Orleans. I have always loved and still do love Trent Reznor...
Finlay Poulsen same. I can't die until I see a NIN concert.
CALL ME CRAZY BUT I THINK I LIKE THIS VERSION BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL. IT'S SOUNDS SO RAW, HEAVY, AND HAS PURE ENERGY!!!!!!!
Agreed. Live versions are a sheer ecstasy.
+LadyCarlaM Agreed
Whippybox_grHD! concur
Whippybox_grHD! Agreed, also I love your profile picture. Green Day is my favourite band and Insomniac is my favourite Green Day album.
It does kick some ass.
This is one song that needs the distortion of live performance. It always sounds a little more powerful performed live.
So true, this and Terrible Lie.
+Nicholas Vladd Hurt is another one that's amazing live.
Pino is a hell of a bassist....he has played with The Who, Don Henley, Elton John, John Mayer, Jeff Beck and many more.....but I love him with NIN.
They have a good sound engineer because they sound amazing. This concert is at staples center in LA and that arena is huge so the acoustics is not always great. This is the best live version of this song I have ever seen. Amazing!
I'm sitting through chemo therapy after a brain tumor and this song seems fitting.
+Tim Schrum Peace be with you my man.
I Wish you the best luck :)
your disease isnt funny man, and Im sorry for you, but that joke gave me a hearty chuckle. Keep on living man
Tim Schrum dude I saw them live after having chemo in the morning... then did the exact same thing the next day after a decent drive to the next city.. back to back days of chemo and NIN.. good luck to you brother beating that awful disease.. you seem in good spirits and that goes a long way
Are you still here Tim?
A song for our times. This should be the soundtrack of our lives at the minute. Says it all.
Sums up the present time perfectly!!
Totally! Sums up the last 2 and half years
It's been relevant since the dawn of time!
Great rhythm section!
Love how Black Mirror introduces the entire new generations to NIN. Now bow down to the original...because this is what they deserved
Already knew them because of Hurt one of my favorite songs because I really can connect to the lyrics, it baffles me that I did not found this song earlier though. By the way I love that the NIN Fans do not react toxic to the promo by black mirror, it's the first time I don't see a "war" between "dumb opportunists who just ruin everything" and the "I knew them before it was cool" people.
I nearly collapsed in the front row when they played this in Spokane. DRINK LOTS OF WATER BEFORE A NIN SHOW. I drank tequila. big mistake. LOVE U TRENT!!!!!!!
Was it the summer? Spokane? No water? Sorry you had to go through that, man.
*Ashley O has left the chat*
Haha 😂 just came from watching it today.
@@codesecond3695 me too
Really glad that people discover some good music through this episode/miley cyrus
Care to tell me what this is about? :)
@@Akshaykumar-bs9ml In Black Mirror season 5 episode 3 Ashley O is this pop star played by Miley Cyrus who is shown singing a pop song where the beat sounds like the original nine inch nails one. At the ending Ashley sings the actual song by them . That's all I'm gonna tell u though since you should watch the episode and I don't want to spoil it .
Sound quality A++ Each member kills it equally..
It’s absolutely amazing to see Pino on stage with Nine Inch Nails
pino bass is awesome
0:19 trent will forever be the quake guy for me
HAHAHAHAHHAHA
HUAGH
Got to see them on this tour! So Fukin GOOD!!!!
Exactly why I love watching all the liv shows from 90s through Now & I hope More-Trent Reznor is able to truly emote in a way I’ve not seen from other Artists & though stages of life-good-bad-Up-down though decades..... I feel him & feel the changes & what an inspiration Thank you for living & giving
Everything is perfect about this live version, the line up, the sound, the atmosphere, the way Trent screams 'Thank You!' at the end, just everything.
If this song doesn't define the 90's, then I don't know what does. Such a timeless and tasty jam!
Some RATM songs too
Did not expect to see Pino Palladino on bass! What a badass!
thezoexperience1
He also did it for Gary Numan which is brilliant
An example of why a true artist ALWAYS sounds better live than the studio recording. All Hail NIN!
What the fuck, is that Pino Paladino playing bass??? Legend
He is a true Legend.
Trent is one of the best music writers and producers of our generation, he made the music industry change when nin formed to give us alternative or industrial.
We saw NIN in Melbourne for the first time. Fooking unreal!! Hope to see more of them in Oz. Come back soon Trent
28 years later and it still gives me chills
Saw this live last night, and it melted my face off. This was amazing!
I wish I could go see them! The closest they're coming to near me is 5 hours away. Maybe next year
As much as I miss Trent singing the chorus to this so he can save his vocal chords, this still absolutely goes off.
Boy this takes me back to 1996 first Vacation trip with my friend to San Diego, must of listened to this song 100 times in 6 hours.
The awesome moment when your 4 year old sings this at you when you try to take toys off him so he can go to sleep. I'm pretty sure i've got this parenting thing right :D
That's awesome!!! Love that :)
+Theressa Morello right?! like "no you can't take that away from me!"
That's hilarious! My 7 year old sings this song, as well as other Nine Inch Nails songs. It's so funny hearing kids singing this type of music. It just proves they have awesome parents.👍🏻
I had to explain a Nine inch nails video to my 5 year old son yesterday. Ha ha. That was fun.....
Bow down to the one you serve lol
This song is perfect for what I'm going through & how I'm feeling. I recently ended 2 friendships because they were very one sided.
one of NIN's best!
That's how the authentic to honing their craft into a profession by a pure bred obsession for perfection raging blaze hearts roll. Few and far between, fr fr
I’m so grateful Trent Reznor is still alive and kicking ass like this. Especially these days......😑👍🤘
I think that's Ian Rubin killing it on the drums!
Ilan...yes
I bought a NIN CD at a thrift shop without even being slightly interested in the band (big Manson fan) but I'm glad I did.
NiN gave birth to Marylin, you are welcome. And welcome to the origin story...
@@stephenrussell8600 Trent Reznor said he heard #TheCure when he was young & he'd never heard anything like it & it changed EVERYTHING! they were a major influence for him.
This really is the best lineup of the band imo. Pino is such a badass bass player & that drummer is a fkn beast! Mad props to Fink too.
I can't even imagine what Maynard, Trent and Cantrell could come up with.
That's uncharted territory. Too much epicness
So glad I got to see NIN with a perfect circle many many years back!!! Crazy Trent is still doing his thing, kinda figured he would a retired years ago
Paladino pretty badass with his shades on.
holy shit the bass sounds GIGANTIC.
They always put on a great show. Saw them in the 90's in Toronto, they had this nuclear orange light that light the whole place up during the riff of WISH 👌
I saw them in San Antonio and I was in my first mosh pit at that show I'll never forget it
Love this band!!! I bet they rock watching them live.
Love this mostly reunited version favorites
The debt of gratitude I have to Trent Reznor is staggeringly huge, and this song is what started it all. God bless Trent fuckin' Reznor
YUMMY THE WHOLE SHOW A TESTAMENT TO TRENT'S GENIUS..THE LIGHTING IS HIS AMAZING CONCEPT THAT PRO'S AROUND THE WORLD CAME TO SEE..EVERY WORD EVERY NOTE PURE GENIUS,,I ADMIRE ADORE AND AM AMAZED BY HIM AND HE NEVER CEASES TO SURPRISE ME EVERY TOUR...LOVE LOVE LOVE HIM,,,,,
susan sbrogna Hell yeah, Susan. He really out-did himself with this tour, too. The footage is all crisp and insanely captivating!
Quit yelling at everyone! Lol
THE FUCKING LIGHTING WAS FUCKING AMAZING.
Sooo many memories come flooding back! The second concert I ever went to was NIN! It is one of the best and clearest memories from high school I have!.
"Bow down to before the one you serve.you're going to get what your deserve " the greatest line
Saw them back on Sept. 30 here in Kansas City, awesome show!
I so wish I was there. Trent's creativity and planning is so meaningful.
The cinematography is so spot on! The rule of thirds..... woooo where our eyes naturally focus....
I haven’t listened to this song for years. What treasure it is!
Do you ever wonder why the whole Year Zero show/movie thing hasn't worked out? I think it's because your living it. You are changing the world, Trent!!!!
Better than the studio version.
Different
Big agree
No
whoa let's not go crazy here
You've read my mind.
Trent has gotten better with age you know his wife has had a huge influence as well..the man is genius amazing and yummy.,.
He ages like a bottle of fine wine.
...check out "How to Kill Angels"
It's his and wife's band...
Marriage and kids made him soft...he has nothing to rage against.
@@kirstenrichards8558 if you want your favourite artists to continue suffering to make better music that says a lot about you
@@kirstenrichards8558 not true, as you get older you understand how rigged and manipulated society is. That’s good enough for him it seems
THE GREATEST BAND ALIVE!!!
This band means so much to me
This is one of the best songs ever written... impressing performance, I'd probably have gone insane
@Trentreznorofficial my pleasure :) I'm fine, hope you too.
It looks like, because the new album is superlative!
Greetings :)
@Trentreznorofficial oh wow... that is really you then. Ahah that's huge, it reminds that the greatest people are also the humblest.
Honestly I am not a huge fan of NIN anymore and you have been doing so much better music lately... It's incredible how fresh and original it is, like totally brilliant.
So I wouldn't look back, even if I can understand that it's a temptation and it's also normal to do so sometimes.
I will gladly listen to your last works in the next days :)
Kindly
Sara
@Trentreznorofficial but of course, listen to yourself to know better, regardless of others' opinion.
One thing is for sure, the music you and Atticus Ross made for the films is a standalone work of art.
@Trentreznorofficial what an hacker!!
@Trentreznorofficial but thanks for this moment of joy
One of my favorite 90’s songs!
Trent reznor absolute genius,every song by nine inch nails is an hurricane.
bow down before the one you serve.. you're gonna get what you deserve.. a strong one
It was amazing to see Head Like A Hole performed live. I've been a fan since I was 13 and I was 35 when I got to see NIN in concert during the Tension tour. I got a selfie in the light and lemme tell you, that was the. best. lighting ever! I got to see my childhood idol live and get the best picture of myself ever! 😂
I have seen them 5X in concert... I always walk in looking like myself, I always walk out looking like a disheveled ragdoll.
I will always love this one.
haha I really like that look away that he does like in 0:43. Just like the original music video (with mad max look) of the same song :).
god that build up after the second chorus gives me fucking goosebumps i honestly wish there was a studio version or remix with it
Listen to Head like hole first time in 1990 at a collage in southern NY by a girl dressed in all black with an industrial spiked hair .
Yessss......Down In It the year before!!
"collage" LOL!
Haven't seen this one before. Gave me a shiver when the synth started playing.
Still love it in 2019.
Thank you! After recent experiences in my life, couldn't have been said better!!
Trent and the boys just doin it
Feedurehed As they should!
Que chingón !!!! Saludos desde México 🇲🇽
always wondered what people liked about this. Now I know.
What an awesome video...
Tight venue.
Perfect sound.
Incredible light show.
Excellent video editing.
REAL ROCK!
I luv this song so much ❤️
what is TRULY STUNNING...Pretty Hate Machine was Composed, arranged and performed in studio all by Trent Reznor himself...then on tours he'd hire artists to perform with him...kinda sad that he doesnt do that any more :S
I think the Atticus Ross era is by far his best work
Damn....I wish I could have seen this live...
I did and I was never so amazed in all my life. Been to many concerts and this topped them all.
Nine inch nails going mental with a classic.......meanwhile pino palladino is just chilling in the back lol
I’ve screamed this more than once.
always loved that tune and that has been a very long time...
이거 처음 나왔을 때 엄청 쇼킹했는데, 정말 명곡이다
Pino standing doing his thing. The coolest and best bassist.
Fantastic!!!! I could feel the high energy ! Love it !
This idea of head like a hole was created in the hot snakes studio in new Orleans.
3:08 the best part
+Piera Lane oh you piggy
Owww yeah
Trent's moans = best moans
Yes!!! He's very exciting
I've just started listening regularly. I first watched the 2013 Vevo live concert which turned me on to the complexity, meaning and hard work!
FUCK this sounds huge, and Ilan is such a ball of energy
This is my absolute favorite version. Gets me dancing like a maniac lol
Saw NIN in concert in 2000.
God dammit Trent was amazing as always!
From Honduras great band!!!
My third favourite band
Skulls Sophia Pheef haha who are the first two ones?
Emma Eleutheria Tied for first is Green Day and Pink Floyd. Second is Smashing Pumpkins.
Skulls Sophia Pheef Nice :)
I'd say NIN are probably my second favourite.
All of they're voices in the chorus is so fukin good! Perfectly in tune
3:09 thank you Trent :D
very exciting
Yes
this was the soundtrack to my first experience with acid. some really good acid. I fell in love with both
Imagine TOOL, NIN and AIC going together on an album.
I'd like that!
Or live... O.o.. That would be one hell of a fuckin concert
Reznor, Maynard and Cantrell on the same stage. FUCK YES!
If you really wanna dream...all three of them with Scabbia, Draiman and Mustaine.
That my friends...would be worth anything that they would charge.
Too many years ago when this song first came out all of my friends and I got the album. For me it was the first CD I ever owned. I listened to it so many times that that Cd needed to be replaced several times! Still amps me up just to here the opening cords!