Edgar Allan Poe | Mental Health & Personality
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ย. 2024
- This video answers the questions: Can I analyze the mental health and personality factors that may be at work in the life and death of Edgar Allan Poe?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Dean, H. J., & Boyd, R. L. (2020). Deep into that Darkness Peering: A Computational Analysis of the Role of Depression in Edgar Allan Poe’s Life and Death. Journal of Affective Disorders. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2020.01.098
Would you like to listen to my content in podcast form? With my partners at Ars Longa Media, we released True Crime Psychology and Personality: Narcissism, Psychopathy and the Minds of Dangerous Criminals. Subscribe to it anywhere you listen to podcasts.
I'm looking forward to putting more of my content into audio and developing new, original podcasts on mental health topics. Visit us online, and feel free to reach out with your questions or ideas by going to arslonga.media.
Dr. Grande’s True Crime Psychology and Personality podcast: www.arslonga.m...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/...
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 78 | คู่เอก "ปกรณ์ vs ฟาบิโอ"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LSOmgl0Th2c/mqdefault.jpg)
“The early 1800’s were a rough time as far as remaining alive..”
Sounds like it.
Seems to me the early 1800's and the early 2020's have something in common.
The average life expectancy was 37??? I would be long dead.
Not to wax morbid, but I'm not supposed to be outliving my own suffering. For me dying at 37 would have been a luxury.
@@joearzs2851 I gave birth to my son at 36... So dying at 37 wouldn't have been ideal...
Cactus Flowers Average life expectancy, not life expectancy.
Alone by Edgar Allan Poe
From childhood's hour I have not been
As others were-I have not seen
As others saw-I could not bring
My passions from a common spring-
From the same source I have not taken
My sorrow-I could not awaken
My heart to joy at the same tone-
And all I lov'd-I lov'd alone-
Then-in my childhood-in the dawn
Of a most stormy life-was drawn
From ev'ry depth of good and ill
The mystery which binds me still-
From the torrent, or the fountain-
From the red cliff of the mountain-
From the sun that 'round me roll'd
In its autumn tint of gold-
From the lightning in the sky
As it pass'd me flying by-
From the thunder, and the storm-
And the cloud that took the form
(When the rest of Heaven was blue)
Of a demon in my view-
Robyn Avery / nice, never heard this one before.
I guess that's deep in it's on way
Robyn Avery I'm obsessed with Poe the man and Poe the writer. This particular poem always makes my cry...for Poe and for everyone that feels this way.💔😔
Beautiful!
You beat me to it! This poem speaks to me in a way which gives me shivers to my core. Ahhh, Poe! ❤
The famous painter, Edvard Munch would be a good one to analyze. He painted “the scream“ along with many other emotive works. He had a tremendous amount of loss in his early life, but then there was a period as an adult were his life was much better. What’s so interesting is you can see it in his paintings.
Agreed
What if it is really a picture of a dog with long ears screaming?
I love his art style. Probably my favourite.
I became insane, with long intervals of horrible sanity. Grande Rocks!
One of my favorite quotes, and quite telling since he wrote it about himself in a letter to someone.
A lot of people may relate to sanity as the illness! I know, at times, I do!
Owe do owe Him thanks for the detective and crime mysteries! Love those, as well as true crime and court room cases. Thanks, Poe! Thanks Dr Grande!🧡✌️
This dates back to Poe's experience in dealing with Virginia. Virginia after contracting tuberculosis took years to die. But every time while at the brink of death, she'll suddenly recover. So Poe each time actually even prepared for her possible funeral. This were most of his most miserable years but also more creative
@@sergiopacheco2939 what you wrote is true but you wrote it in such a powerful way. wow
@@angelahamon6730 saw it on documentary and have read it on some prologues... The raven, poe wrote when Virginia was dying of tuberculosis, hence "nevermore".... Because this meant to Poe that Virginia was really going to die this time. Also, poe only had one jacket, because of his poverty, and to keep her warm he'll even put a black cat on top of her chest, and his jacket, in order to deal with the brutal winter of new York.
When I took a Psych 101 type class in college, the instructor gave us an assignment to pick a famous person who doesn't have a publicly known diagnosis of a mental illness, and we were suppose to write a paper of speculation on what thier diagnosis might be. I chose Edgar Allen Poe. My thoughts were that for someone to write the type of works he did, the macabre, that he probably had some sort of mental disorder. My unprofessional diagnosis was Bipolar disorder as it seemed he had highs and lows and moments of absence for several days at a time. I put alot of research and thought into that paper. 😊
I've often wondered about Stephen King's mental state. If I correctly recall, I think he said he had a drinking problem as he was trying to get his career going. I remember he said he and his wife Tabitha were extremely poor when they married.
@@roxannemoser and his appetite for cocaine💯
I am Bipolar and, like other Bipolar intellectual types who like a bit of imagination, I was attracted by the sorts of things he writes about, in my younger days, but I have grown out of it now that I'm older, as Bipolar settles down more with age... I still sometimes delve into this darker side of life, but nowadays I prefer to read about factual cases, rather than fictional ones. And they only hold appeal in the depressed phase, never in the up phase of the cycle.
May we read your paper?
@@babblingalong7689 oh my goodness, would love to share but, this was probly 9 or 10 yrs ago. I don't have the paper anymore. I was in a Culinary Arts program so my focus wasn't Psychology anyway.
I totally get what you're staying with his wife's slow death. My grandpa died of a bone marrow/prostate cancer combo. I visited him all the time, up until he died.
As much as I dreaded the thought of him actually dying, I remember feeling strangely relieved when I got the call that he had passed. I felt like his suffering was over, which in turn ended my suffering
Sometimes death isn't the worst thing...
I felt the same way when my father died after a long illness with COPD. but then I felt guilty for feeling that way.
@@patarnold4134 I completely understand. My father died of the same thing over 20 years ago. It was a slow, horrible death. I was relieved not to see him gasping for every breath anymore. I miss him every day, but I’m so glad he’s no longer suffering.
@@QueenOfTheNorth65 Thank you for that.
That's a good point: after years of illness, after my dad died, a part of me was quite happy being done with doctors and hospitals.
I think it's also the relief of them no longer suffering that help the mood of those left behind!
@@demmimorelle4654 Yeah, it's several things. Different doctors with different prognoses. When dad did die it was closure and a feeling of "that's enough."
@@kelleybrown1666Did he die by suicide?
“A rough time as far as remaining alive...” Relatable content...
You tell them sister
I chuckled.
Acetyl Covid was never mentioned.
Please stop
@@Acetyl53 shut up
I am a closet literature fan. In high school, I loved literature so much that I couldn't wait to get to class after lunch. None of my friends knew because I literally knew no one who enjoyed literature. I learned about Edgar Allan Poe in high school literature class and found him curious. He made an impression on my young mind. I can remember feeling quite gloomy learning about him. Sure didn't make me want to race to class, that's for sure. He experienced a lot of loss, and I think that when one experiences a lot of losses, particularly at a young age, it *can* interfere with that carefreeness that commonly goes along with being young. I feel compassion for him. Life seemed hard back in the 1800s and I'm glad I wasn't around during that time. I can't say for certain I would have fared better than he. Thank you for this! ♥
Come out of the closet - the world needs more readers
I always learn, something new from you Dr. Grande.
I do believe, alcohol abuse when one has a mental condition. Makes it more severe. Abuse of it alone. Can cause many, mental and physically debilitating.
As usual you scored on this!
Take a rest Dr. Grande. You have really grown your channel and deserve a break. Thanks for making the show.
I have not clicked on a video so fast! I find Edgar Allan Poe’s life and death so incredibly fascinating!
One of my favorite authors and a fellow Baltimorean!!! One of my favorite people analyzing another one of my favorite people... 😍😍😍
Kimberly Spears The Baltimore Raven’s have to be named after the famous poem he wrote. Have you ever been to his house?
Paul Bonney They are! And we have three Ravens as mascots named Edgar, Allan, and Poe is the most famous one LOL
I’ve been to his grave several times , placed black roses on his tombstone 🥀 . And went to the bar where he had his last drink in fells point. His house I saw , but didn’t go into. It’s in the middle of the projects . It’s not a very nice environment, but his house of course is a historic site
Black environment I'm guessing, you know we're really decent people if you get to know us..
Odd how ppl admire and seek out pedophiles just so long as they were talented.
A-bove A-ve-rage all I know it was connected to government housing .the upkeep was not very nice in the area .
bianca mitchell he apparently only married that thirteen year old girl to save her from an forced, arranged marriage?. Ad he never slept with her?.
That’s very cool! I’ve been to a pub he often visited while in Massachusetts, it’d interesting to see other landmarks of his
Could you analyze the poet Sylvia Plath at some point?
@Marianne Havisham no I haven't seen that film but I would love to. I'll make a point of it.
Another tragic writer. Her son died by suicide several years ago. So sad :-((
@Marianne Havisham Now that's interesting! He's certainly the common denominator in all 3 of their lives. I wonder if he was also abusive to her like he was to Sylvia?
@Marianne Havisham well there's the idea that my depression these days is so bad that anything that I would watch could only perk me up. Okay, that's a bad joke. Anyway, I appreciate you warning me that the movie is particularly depressing before I watch it.
@Marianne Havisham oh for sure! I absolutely agree with you that there is a genetic component to depression. I'm sorry you've been going through this :-((
When I was 16 I was obsessed with Poe. I read all his works, all biographies about him and collected pictures of him, and things related to him. I tried to figure out the mystery of his death for years and was fascinated by the unknown person that would leave a half full bottle of cognac and red roses on his grave on Poe's birthday. IDK the exact reason why I was obsessed with his life, other than to say... Teenager.
Me too. I believe the reason is because you have a lot of empathy and maybe have had a lot of pain. Therefore a person a kind person who cares about humanity. I don't know maybe.
Poe's death was from chronic alcoholism.
I’m a lifelong Marylander and love attending the International Poe Fest in October. This year it’s virtual, for obvious reasons. Fun times in Baltimore!
I didn't know there was such s thing. Will check it out!
Didn't know about that, I love Poe and live around the DC area! I do find it interesting how Baltimore claims Poe as their own even though he only briefly lived there.
Makes sense why several teachers worried about me because he was my favorite writer. Got it.
Quoth the Doctor: "You are high in neuroticism, Poe."
Lol
Quoth Dr. Grande, nevermore! lol jk
@Fernando G we remember these with the acronym RAVEN lol
Never more!
"Eat my shorts!"
I became my parents’ love letter to the horror genre when they decided to give me “Raven” as a middle name. I guess they loved this poem so much they couldn’t imagine not using it. Thanks mom and pops! ❤️
Love it!
"Raven" could have been your first name.
I’ve had a fascination with Alan Poe since childhood, even though my perception of his “persona” felt alienated from reality ... it is very difficult to explain, anyway, my favorite part is:
Leave my loneliness unbroken!-quit the bust above my door!
Take thy beak from out my heart, and take thy form from off my door!"
Quoth the Raven "Nevermore."
Thanks Dr Grande ❤️
Another very interesting video. Long ago, when I was studying the literature in the university, much more emphasis was placed on Poe's opium use, and less on the alcohol. Given the paucity of hard evidence, this may reflect the attitudes in our culture about various drugs [including alcohol] at various times. This is, on a number of levels, an extremely thought-provoking video.
Ooooooooh, what about the painter Vincent van Gogh?
Excellent! And Princess Diana too! :-)
Yes, as Doctor Grande would say, you do have a problem when u chop ur ear off!
Yes, please do Van Gogh
It's actually kind of remarkable how after every thing Poe suffered, he was able to leave such a literary legacy... Or maybe because of what he suffered? I'd love to hear your thoughts on this doctor: does art need suffering? Great video as usual, thanx, Dr. Grande!!!
Van Gogh is an essential analysis. Monet would be great as a companion piece as well.
Thank you for "fleshing out" a rather enigmatic figure to me, Dr. Grande. I studied Edgar Allen Poe's works in school and also love his poem "The Raven," but didn't realize his many struggles. Sounds like a hard slog for the poor man, so I thank you for sharing his very tragic background. It adds another dimension to his works for me.
I recently listened to a compilation of all his short stories. What a genius! It’s so difficult for me to believe that he could write so intricately, and be such a raging alcoholic at the same time. I’m sad that his life was so tragic, yet grateful for his legendary masterpieces.
While he’s known for horror and I do love horror, he actually also wrote my favorite romance quote too. “And we loved with a love that was more than love” from the poem Annabel Lee
Okay, I LOVE that poem, I Love Poe. But you can't say it isn't creepy to go lay next to your dead lover. Straight up horror genre.
And so, all the night-tide, I lie down by the side
Of my darling - my darling - my life and my bride,
In her sepulchre there by the sea -
In her tomb by the sounding sea.
"Maybe he was indifferent to life and death" - I think you nailed Poe in a nutshell with that closing line. Another great one.
What a fascinating analysis! I love EAP's writing! The first time my parents left me alone in the house, I settled down in the family room and began The Murders in the Rue Morgue. What a mistake that was. I think I was 11 or 12 years old and I was absolutely petrified. I turned on all the lights in the house and could have sworn I heard someone breathing in the bedroom, though I was far too frightened to check. I don't think I have ever been so happy to see my parents. I would love to see more analyses of historical figures. Great video!
Nice! I live in Richmond and there's a tiny museum dedicated to Poe about 15-20 minutes from me. I always feel sad when I think of him. Not sure why.
Thanx Dr.G!
Another excellent analysis, as usual, and I even learned some things I didn’t know....that he served in the Army, and was accepted to Westpoint. Given how he ended up, I can only imagine what his military career might have looked like, especially if he was an officer of any ranking! Thanks!
I also learned many things I didn't know!
How about Henry the Vlll and Winston Churchill? Thanks Dr. Grande.
Henry AND his eight wives! Six...I meant 6...
Nah, he's pretty clear. Giles de rais would be interesting, and Isabella of France.
FOr Henry VIII a diagnosis might be Frequent Wife Syndrome.
I called him that when I was a kid meself :-) :-) :-) :-)
Yes, especially Henry VIII !!!
Thank you for your analysis on Edgar Allan Poe who is a favourite poet of mine! Throughout his life he experienced heartbreak, tragedy and immeasurable loss.
He certainly had great facility with words and expression and was able to share his innermost thoughts and feelings in a deep and profound way. The tone of his poetry was very sombre and melancholy so he may have been suffering from depression. It would be understandable given his complex and difficult history. Ironically, the pain and loss he experienced throughout his life informed some of his greatest works. He was a pantheon in the world of poets and poetry. Anyway, appreciate all the diverse topics you research and share with us!
.
Thank you for this speculation on Eddie's mental health. He was a brilliant writer and poet...with a hard life. Yes, lots of red flags intertwined with a long string of excessive stressors. Very tragic and sad life.
You really researched his life and delivered a great analysis! While I enjoyed his writing, I felt he was in emotional pain..poor guy suffered through so much loss..
I appreciate the people taking the time to type in a couple of Poe's poems! My favorite was "The Bells". His works were genius! Thank you, Dr. Grande for this excellent analysis!
I can relate to how he was not in a state of depression after losing his wife. I once had a cat who was very sick, everyday I thought she was going to die. She was like that for 3 years before she actually died. I was surprised myself by my ability to recover from grief at that time. instead of grief i was more relieved, because I knew that the cat didn't have to suffer anymore and was relieved because I was free from the worry that I used to feel every day when the cat still alive. Still miss her sometimes tho.
I have always found the story and life of Edgar Allan Poe fascinating. Annabelle Lee was my favorite verse he authored. Thanks for this "inside look" at the mind of a mesmerizing writer.
Could you do Vincent Van Gogh? Many people's favourite painter (including myself)
Suggestion : Klaus Kinski (famous german actor) i believe he was diagnosed with antisocial personality disorder
Wow, really ???
He molested his daughter.
What was the name of the German director Kinski was always associated with? Their volatile relationship was stuff of legend. So legendary in fact I can't remember the director's name.
Good god Kinski was a complete monster in real life, even worse than the horrific characters he played in films
Oh, I hope he does Kinski, he was a maniac but I loved his work. If you want to see more about his life, check out Verner Herzog's documentary, "My Best Fiend". And, if you haven't seen it, watch "Aguirre, The Wrath of God". I only discovered some of Kinski's best films after I discovered Herzog - about 10 years ago.
Dr. Grande, you are brilliant! Poe and Hemingway are my two favorite authors. I watch every video. Thank you. God bless you and your family. Can you please do an analysis of my favorite painter, Vincent Van Gogh?
He is my favorite artist. Would love for Grande to do him.
Could you please please please do an analysis of Joseph Smith Jr. the Mormon prophet
Lynn Patterson This would be fantastic. I am related to him so it would be extra interesting for me.
That would be interesting.
Megalomaniac
A 19th century version of L. Ron Hubbard.
What about a video on the topic of art therapy and how artists throughout history may have been using art as a coping mechanism? Or any more videos about various artists and creatives would be awesome! :)
E. A. POE!!! Thank you so much! It is so cool to be able to get a tighter grasp on the mental health and personality factors of such profound creative people. His writings ✍ really influenced my teen years. There used to be a nice little E.A.Poe museum in Richmond VA, but it has been over a decade since I visited it. .... So many people have substance abuse issues; it is too bad because those addictions take so many talented people away too soon. Thank you so much, Dr. Grande!!!! 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️
It would be interesting to hear your thoughts on H.P. Lovecraft, Dr. Grande.
Elon Musk personality profile PLEASE
I second this. I'm definitely curious to know what is going on in that guy's mind.
Two words , expensive lawyers
i think he's just weird, like too smart to function and ended up weird kinda type. the same goes with his gf grimes.
I heard Elon Musk has said that he has Autism.
Poe didn't have anywhere near- musk's money.
Thank you for this, one of my favorite authors! While I love your sense of humor I so appreciate you refraining from indulging. I always felt, based on the many biographies, that he was in line with bipolar and certainly Alcohol use disorder. I think you could make the case for Opium Use Disorder as well. Certainly the irritability, risk taking, depression, and described manic periods point to a mood disorder, my two cents anyway. As disagreeable as he was reported to be, I would have loved for the chance to sit with him for an hour. Lord Byron runs a close second. Another great job!
This is an interesting video. I have avoided Poe thinking most of his writings were too dark, negative...now I think I will read more of his work from a new perspective. Thank you
Please read Annabel Lee! He was really something, still gives me chill even I've memorized every line 💕
@@beyzaaydn2974 Will do! thanks
@@garygardner902 You're welcome! 😇
Interesting change of pace, Dr. Grande. If we imagine Poe doing an apology video, we'll get some idea of how times have changed.
I lived in Providence for many years and Poe is part of the local legend and lore. I've walked by the Whitman House many times, and by and in and through the Providence Atheneum, the oldest private library in America and one of their meeting places. Her parents called off their marriage, but she, a poet herself, remained loyal to him, his work and reputation, for the rest of her life. Some people claim to have seen Poe walking near her house late at night. (Lovecraft, who worshipped Poe, is still an important literary presence in Providence, too.) Years ago, I read the Jeffrey Meyers bio of Poe, and it's quite good.
I enjoy your literary profiles and hope to see more of them. Hemingway was a great American "head case" and seems to provide endless material for psychological speculation. Others here have suggested Sylvia Plath, and I find her interesting, too.
Thanks, again.
When it rains it Poe’s
out---->
Vegetable Television 😂😂
This is a really cool direction, diving into writers and artists. Another possible source of content could be analyzing literary figures like Hamlet, Narcissus or Jane Eyre.
One author I think everyone would love a video on is Sylvia Plath.
I’m pretty sure Narcissus was a narcissist. 👍🏻
@@rachelraquel758 waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat!? ;)
This is easily my favorite channel on TH-cam, thank you son much for making these educational videos! 🙏
💯
The early 1800s was a rough time in terms of... remaining alive...”
Well said doc. Now I feel a bit small for complaining about how I get 50 cable channels that I don’t even watch.
Awesome discussion Dr. Grande!
You frequently out do yourself!
My "FBI son" had to be treated for tuberculosis after being spat on by a gang member. Not one of things Hollywood includes in their action movie plot lines.
I love that you are open to using word analysis as a tool, but not as the only tool. Two top notch Doctors could have identical psychological data, and still differ on causation.
I enjoyed the Alan Parsons project musical interpretation of Poe's work. :) Thanks again doc for a truly content rich video. I must confess, I wish I could see your bloopers and outtakes. ;)
Next up, Dr. Grande reciting "The Raven" for us 😄!
An analysis of the raven would be interesting for real!
This is an incredibly interesting analysis. Thank you! I would love to hear more historical analysis such as Lincoln or other presidents and public figures.
Or John Wilkes Booth
I know this is a sad story but seeing this video notification made my day!
Oh, no! Dr. Grande, of wit extraordinaire and thorough research, isn't perfect! I'm devastated!😪 If Poe attempted to OD in 1948, as you'd said, he'd have set a world record for life span. He was born in 1809.
Lol! It's all right. I got a chuckle from it. I've read everything that Poe had ever written and The Raven is my favorite poem, as well. Stories?? Tie between The Fall of the House of Usher and The Oblong Box.
Thanks for the information about his life. His was such a melancholy personality that reeked from the poems and stories that he wrote. Very strange that his COD papers are missing!
I am very embarrassed to admit that I have never read any of Poe's works. But I did enjoy learning about him and a little bit about his life. It does seem like he went through a lot of loss as a very young child. Again another sad story. Thank you Dr Grande. Have an enjoyable weekend.
Thank you for another interesting video. I started reading Poe’s work when I was 13, and still enjoy it today among other authors of that time period such as Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky. That being said, this is the most fair and I would say more reasoned profile of Poe I’ve come across in a long time. It always seemed like most people who would talk about Poe and his life and work would usually do so in ways that reduced him down to a degenerate drunk, a womanizer or both. This profile you did showed an objective balance between his short-comings and of his talent as a writer. Thanks again for the video, and I’ll continue watching when new videos become available.
James Heady
I remember learning about Poe in 7th grade, because my teacher loved him and had us reading a lot of his work and it really spoke to me being a young writer myself from a broken home and a lot of problems that twelve year olds shouldn't be having.
I didn't realize until then just how much your own turmoil reflects in your work for better or worse and after that I actually started hiding my work, carrying it around in a binder with me as if someone were waiting for the chance to lunge and steal it.
I never really write in first person, so I wonder what could be deduced from my own work under the eyes of analysis.
I'd love to hear Dr G's take on Marcel Proust!
Dr Grande Now this is a really interesting episode. Please, do more literary or historical figures. Or maybe some crazy musical geniuses. Any chance of longer episodes? Selfish I know, I just think many are left wishing for more of your analysis. Great. love from Ireland.
I'd love if you could do an analysis of Stanley Kubrick. The man is such a mystery.
An “average” life expectancy of 37 means nothing, as it does not allow for the high infant mortality rate in that period. It’s true there were fewer effective medicines available at that time, but if you could survive to adulthood, you had a pretty good chance of making it to old age.
When are you going to do John Wilkes Booth, Dr G? Come on, you know you want to!
Surely it changes your outlook on life if kids are dying left and right. Wouldn't say it means nothing.
Poe's parents were actors, and his mother was highly regarded and performed often and all over the country; but his father was an amateur, not a very good one, and an alcoholic. Poe's maternal grandmother was an actress in England.
Very true, re: life expectancy. My ancestors on my mother's side were mostly farmers, and they tended to have 10 to 17 kids, most of whom survived to adulthood, and ditto their kids. The adults tended to live well into their sixties, and even into their eighties and nineties-- fresh air, good food, hard work. It wasn't until the 20th century when they started moving to the city did the number of children and life expectancy go down. I don't have as much info on my dad's side, but what I have tells me much the same.
@@babblingalong7689 I don't think you understood the comment.
Oh shit you've gone and done Poe. And on a Friday night no less. Alright guys let's grab the booze and see what this is about. Gonna have to post this on FB for all my Poe fanatics.
Oh yeah!!! Dropped everything to watch this!
You're fabulous Dr. Grande. It's enriching to have this deeper understanding of significant historical figures. I love it. Thank you.
Could you do a video on Victoria after Albert died or Lincoln after his son’s death? I love your videos. My Goth 19th century heart was so excited when I saw the title. Or Sir Alfred Russel Wallace and spiritualism?
I loved this vid! Poe is my favorite, too. I am haunted by his stories about pale, slowly dying women, clearly a result of his lifetime losses. It's a series of stories titled with female names, as well as the Fall of the House of Usher and the Oval Portrait. I would love to see more videos about the mental health and personality of figures like Lovecraft, Van Gogh, Beethoven, Rachmaninov, etc. Russian writers and artists in particular are extremely interesting to me in terms of mental health!
Great video. I love Poe. It is fascinating to hear about his mental status throughout his life. I’m grateful that he lived long enough and was emotionally strong enough to write imo masterpieces that will forever be enjoyed.
The Raven about this video will be aproPOE.
Incredible work Dr. Grande! I've had a fascination with Poe and his writings ever since I was a kid (and got a book of his work through scholastics), and love your breakdown of his life and what might have brought about his end. It's important to note he wasn't so much a sick and twisted man, as a depressed and suffering one, and you did a great job in bringing together the details of his life (some of which I wasn't aware of) into an impressive psychological picture of the writer. Thanks!
Great video, thank you! Could we have a vid on death row groupies?
I appreciate that you read through the comments...as an aside, here's suggestions on future videos:
1) the Texas Tower Shooter in 1966...Charles Whitman
2) the New Orleans Howard Johnsons roof sniper in 1972-73...Mark James Robert Essex
3) the Dallas murderer of police July 7, 2016, Micah Xavier Johnson
4) the Baton Rouge murderer of police July 17, 2016, Gavin Eugene Long
“The Cask of Amontillado” is one of the most chilling stories I have ever read. He asked to be expelled? Weird! Why did he not just quit? He married his 13-year old cousin.🤔
Yayyyy for Edgar Allan Poe, thank you Dr. Grande!
I believe I own every available published work of Poe’s. I found him in elementary school, where The Raven was required by the curriculum. This is from the way back machine. I was hooked. Even as a sixth grader I recognized his tormented soul.
Thank you, Dr. Grande.
Thank you, Dr. Grande, that was so excellent. What do you think about the correlation between depression and other mental illnesses and creativity? Poe and Van Gogh being two examples.
Im an avid fan. Thank you for all of your work, and presence in my life.
Have you done a video like this for H.P. Lovecraft yet?
I came to suggest the same. So much has been said about his personality problems but i would like a qualified opinion for once.
Jonathan, this was my next request! You beat me to it!
Oh, I’d love that!!
What a talented writer. Great example of how such amazing writing can come from incredible pain, disconnection, mental illness and addiction. Glad he was able to pour his feelings onto paper. It was probably the only thing that helped him to cope.
Devoured with relish! Your acumen is thrilling! Keep it up! Cheers Doc!
Thank you so much for one more truly interesting analysis, Dr Grande. I studied Poe at university and your video brings a lot of new interesing information to it. Fantastic artist.
Yeeees! I've been waiting for this topic, I'm so glad you covered it. 💕
That was very illuminating. I personally really love Poe's works. His use of language is simply beautiful.
Fascinating to hear Poe's mental state discussed from a modern point of view!
Dr. Grande, if you haven't looked into it already I would like to recommend Hervey Allens' biography "Israfel--The Life and Times of Edgar Allan Poe" from 1934, an excellent book with lots of information and many illustrations including a photo of the house that inspired the House of Usher. There's not much information about Poe's biological family but from what little is said of Poe's sister it appears she was developmentally disabled.
Some other authors I would like to suggest for upcoming videos are Virginia Woolf, Sylvia Plath and Anne Sexton.
Poe is one of my favorites! And I agree, The Raven has got to be the best poem ever written. I still get chills whenever I read or hear it!
Thanks Dr. Grande for this analysis. It leaves me with a sad feeling that perhaps Mr. Poe was never really understood and that his creative genius was affected by his various mental states. Thanks again Dr.
Would love to see you do an analysis of the modern day anti-Poe, David Lynch, whose movies are often incredibly dark but whose real-life persona is like a gleeful, enlightened boy scout. In addition to Lynch himself, several of his films (Eraserhead, Lost Highway, and Mulholland Drive) would be worthy of their own videos.
Will you do an analysis of Joseph Smith, the founding prophet of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints?
Secular historians have said it seems as though he was being sincere about his religious experiences. He believed these things happened. And he was martyred. He seemed to have walked right into his death. I am eager to hear your point of view.
Yes...this would be an interesting analysis.
Poe! So interesting. BTW, nice shirt color!
Yes, litterature!!!! One of my things :) Lovecraft could be a good one, the grimest of them all, you feel the depression in every single word
I like the highbrow ones, thank you 😁
This was great to watch! Poe was such a mysterious figure due to the study of his poems and not the man himself in school.
I don't know if anyone has pointed this out but I think you said 1948 instead of 1848 at 7:50. It only matters because I was shocked to hear 1948 and though he lived so close to our era.
I absolutely love Edgar Alan Poe❤️ Thanks for this video, Dr Grande 😊
"Once upon a midnight dreary.."
Nevermore!
He was brilliant. It’s such a pity that he struggled financially, with alcoholism, and depression. I wonder if his writing had received the recognition he deserved in his day if he might have lived longer. It’s probably doubtful because he couldn’t control the alcoholism. “The Raven” is melancholy but beautiful with such a musical quality like most of his poems and sometimes his prose. It has always fascinated me that he wrote the first mystery story. Thanks for another thoughtful analysis.
Thanks for the analysis of one of my favorites. Especially interesting was the language analysis of his writings. I would be interested in more of these videos on historical figures in general. 👍
Dr. Grande,
Have you done a Mental health profile on Lorena Bobbitt? That would sound interesting.
Love the deadpan humor. To me, that's a highlight of your channel, being a jester myself.
I've always felt very drawn to Poe, his stories and poems hold a special power that cannot be easily described, only felt. I live in Baltimore & had visited his grave on a midnight tour once, it's a night I'll never forget; often I am in the car & there's a stoplight just at the corner of that church he's at. His tombstone is right at the edge next to the gate to get in - more often than not, that gate is open and you can see his engraved portrait watching you curiously. Then the light at the stoplight turns green & you move on. But Poe stays there, the gate open and waiting....
I really appreciated this video - I never thought about it but was not surprised to hear that his work indicated a less depressed period after the death of his wife. It makes perfect sense that as much as he grieved her loss, it was a relief compared to waiting & watching her slowly die, also makes sense that after 5 years of this he would have had plenty of time to come to terms with this which explains how he was able to move on to other romantic relationships. That always baffled me but I'm grateful to have a deeper understanding. Thanks, Doc!
Further question: was it typical at the time to marry a cousin? I believe she's his 1st cousin, he's buried with Maria Poe Clemm who's said to be his aunt & mother-in-law. Does that show any other indications of his mental health - perhaps that due to his separation from his family at such a young age it predisposed him to be inclined to marry a relative? For some sort of comfort/trauma healing, I mean?
Knowing the life expectancy I'm less startled by how young she was, she was of child-bearing age & I'm sure that's all that really mattered when you were expected to live to late-30s & infant mortality was probably a nasty probability on its own.
Would love to see an analysis on hitler
I am late! Hi Dr. Grande and everyone, have a nice weekend. 💙
I adore your videos! Please keep making content! Your analysis and evaluation of various topics and people are always easily digestible and ultimately entertaining to follow along with! Thank you for the time and energy you dedicate to your channel. It doesn't go unappreciated 🙏