Lenovo Legion 5i Vs HP Omen | Gaming Laptops for Video Editing
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ก.ย. 2024
- In this video, I am going to put the 2020 HP Omen 15 and the Lenovo Legion 5i. I have run these two laptops through 14+ creator focused benchmarks covering video editing in Premiere Pro and DaVinci Resolve, motion design, graphic design, photo editing, 3D modeling, and more. ►⏩►⏩ Check specs and pricing in the links below…
💻 Lenovo Legion 5i 16GB Model geni.us/Legion... - Commission Earned )
💻 HP Omen 15 ( geni.us/Omen15... - Commission Earned )
Let’s talk about the look of these two laptops. Both have very similar appearances. The Legion 5i with its matte green and iridescent Legion badge, and the HP Omen with its deep matte gray top cover and iridescent shape. Regarding which one I would feel more comfortable in a client meeting, I would choose either one with confidence
Concerning the build quality each laptop stands out in its own right. The HP Omen with its plastic top cover, bottom cover, side panels and aluminum keyboard deck, and the Legion 5i with it’s all plastic build and soft-touch keyboard deck..
I am a big fan of the HP Omen’s redesign, especially since they added the aluminum keyboard deck, this is a nice touch. Regarding durability, these laptops are going to be about the same. The aluminum keyboard deck is nice, but I don’t think it will lead to THAT much of an improvement on how durable the laptop will be over the soft-touch plastic. All in all I give the Legion 5i and the HP Omen a tie on build quality.
The ports selections are quite different, and the HP Omen stole my heart with it’s built-in SD card reader. It is one of the only gaming laptops that still features this nifty little port for video editors and photographers.
The HP Omen comes with:
x2 USB-A 3.2 Gen 1
USB 3.2 Gen 2 (power-off charging)
USB-C 3.1 (DisplayPort + Charging)
HDMI 2.0
Mini Display 1.4
SD Card Reader
Network Port
Mic/headphone combo
And the Legion 5i comes with:
USB-A 3.1 Gen 1
3 x USB-A 3.1 Gen1
USB-C 3.1 (DisplayPort)
HDMI 2.0
RJ45 ethernet
Mic/headphone combo
As I open the lid on each of these laptops I am able to do so with one hand. The hinges are smooth and strong. There is only a slight bit of screen flex that is equally present on the HP Omen and Legion 5i. I would rate the hinges as a tie-breaker. Both are solid and sturdy.
Before we move onto the screen quality I want to discuss the ventilation on these two laptops. Both the HP Omen and the Legion 5i have generous vents for cooling. They both have vents on the bottom cover, and behind the keyboard deck.
However the HP Omen has an extra vent on the top of the keyboard deck.
The Legion 5i has vents on both side panels, whereas the HP Omen only has a vent on the right side. But the HP Omen has a vent on the top of the keyboard deck where the Legion 5i does not. So I guess it all evens out.
The Lenovo Legion 5i comes with a 15.6 inch FHD 16x9 display that can reach 144Hs. At full brightness it can reach 350 nits with a color gamut range of 99% sRGB - 80% Adobe RGB - 80% DCI-P3.
For a gaming laptop this is a fantastic screen, and the HP Omen is just as impressive.
The HP Omen comes with a 15.6 inch FHD 16x9 display that can reach 144Hz. At full brightness it can reach 320 nits with a color gamut range of 91% sRGB - 74% Adobe RGB - 74% DCI-P3.
The Legion 5i comes with a numpad whereas the HP Omen does not. Personally I am completely fine with this detail because I have never used the numpad on any computer I have owned.
The HP Omen I am reviewing comes with:
CPU: AMD Ryzen 7 4800H (8 Cores 16 Threads)
GPU: NVIDIA Geforce GTX 1660 Ti 6GB GDDR6
RAM: 16GB DDR4
Storage: 256GB SSD
Whereas the Lenovo Legion 5i comes with:
CPU: Intel 10th Gen Core i7-10750H (6 Cores 12 Threads)
GPU: NVIDIA Geforce GTX 1660 Ti 6GB GDDR6
RAM: 16GB DDR4
Storage: 512GB SSD
If you’re looking for a high performance Ryzen 7 laptop with an aluminum keyboard, great cooling performance, and one of the best keyboard decks and trackpads I have ever used, with a screen that has excellent color accuracy then you should be taking a look at the HP Omen.
However, if you’re looking for a handsome matte green laptop with a comfortable soft-touch keyboard deck that performs cool and fairly quiet while getting great benchmarks results in photoshop, video editing, 3D modeling and motion design, combined with a bright color accurate screen then you will want to snag the Lenovo Legion 5i.
------
DISCLAIMER: ALL LINKS IN DESCRIPTION ARE AFFILIATE LINKS if you make a purchase through the links provided I will get a small commission but at no extra cost to you, but that is what keeps this channel alive and the helpful content coming your way. 🤘 😊
Thanks for Supporting Our Channel!
Great Review as always, just ordered my legion 5 ryzen 7 4800h variant. Will be reviewing as soon as I get it.
@@qsm Sure thing, I'll make a comparison video soon. waiting for my macbook
got one with ryzen 7 4800h + rtx 2060 a week ago and it's friking amazing dude
@Ihtesham TechTalks @Delicious bread I just ordered the same 17" configuration with a 2060 too!
hows Cyberpunk run? i won't get my received til expected January 8th
guess I'll have to settle running Cyberpunk on my Dell Latitude E6540 until then😅🤣
@@goqwertygo Haven't tried cyberpunk yet, but it should run smoothly
Hp omen Intel i7 or legion i7 pls reply
Dude, the power button on the Legion 5 is white, that means it's in "Balanced mode". You should switch the thermal profile by pressing Fn+Q, to switch to "Performance Mode" (indicated by the red dot in the power button). This kinda nullifies all your comparisons.
This is the most helpful review for editors like me esp in after effextz and premiere pro test!! Tysm 🙌🏼🙌🏼
Pretty
I had a go at both devices and decided to go with the Legion 5. I feel that despite having no aluminum chasis, the Legion feels more well built as the HP has this weird flex. The keyboard for my taste is the Legion. I type a lot, answering emails everyday and the Omen's keyboard does not give me the tactile feeling
Battery which one is better ?
@@No-cc1fq hP Omen
@@No-cc1fq legion you can use MUX switch
I got a question. If the monitor only 60hz but fps more than that. Does it gonna effect the performance?
@@No-cc1fq if you mean performance in game then a little bit if you play FPS, but games like League of Legends doesnt mean much if you have high refresh rate. However, if you can afford high refresh rate screen then go for you, or save up
Can you please compare Lenovo legion 5i/5 vs Acer predator Helios 300 2020?
Great video by the way!🤩
Thanks for the review...I think MANY people are evaluating these two systems as their potential next system. Overall these laptops are pretty evenly matched. It would be really interesting if you compared the Ryzen 4800H versions of BOTH laptops but the Intel vs Ryzen comparison is also very helpful because sometimes you can get diff components on an intel version vs amd version (e.g., you can get a 500nit panel with the Legion 5i (intel version) but not on the Legion 5 (amd version) and also the GPU's available may be different). One note...The HP Omen is actually much lighter than the specs state...several prominent viewers have the HP Omen coming in at just 4.64lbs (rather than the 5.4lbs? stated in the specs) compared with the Legion 5's 5.1lbs. Not sure why HP did this.
I was looking at both of these laptops and decided to go with the Legion 5 rather than the HP Omen largely because the Legion 5 (on sale) was a bit cheaper ($200) than the HP Omen and I also liked the fact that many of the ports of the Legion 5 are on the rear of the laptop versus the side...which just make things a LOT cleaner.
BTW when considering costs I would suggest that viewers price out the entire system including support so that they can get a true overall cost of the systems.
Great video,
I prefer the Legion 5 Ryzen if we consider the price.
Cheers
100% agree, I managed to get my amd 6600m for only $600.
A review u never knew u needed
Neil nitin mukesh lite😂😆👌
😆😆😆Pada likha version
I was eagerly waiting for this comparison
I have HP Omen and 1 problem is with deck itself, it's nice and sharp and corners. They hurt if you place your hands along diagonals. OFC they'll help you to get to proper sitting position cause if you bend back you'll start feeling pressure on your hands :)
Does these laptops compatible with windows 11
Great overview, thank you 😊💖
Great as always
Thank you for the detailed video Ben and letting us choose our own playback speed
Ok, I have watched 100 videos, probably 50 of them were yours. I am more confused than ever. I do not want want to break the bank, waiting for the next iteration of the MacBook to come out in a year or so. Right now I need to know what you would buy with $1500? That will make my life much easier. Thanks
Awesome video, very informative, I like that format.
Please do a live game streaming test for games like
Apex Legend, COD: War zone on both laptops,with the stats of GPU & CPU temp,fps enabled it could be helpful
U can see separate videos on each laptop from separate creators
asus rog strix g512li core i7 10750h vs lenovo legion 5i 10750h which is better for gaming please help me choose
So why was 4k playback much better on lenovo (fewer dropped frames)? Because of i7 vs ryzen7?
I'm deciding between i5 omen vs ryzen5 omen. Which would make more sense for 4k editing in davinci
My son prefer buying a case like a desktop. What do you recommend me: Lenovo Legion 5 vs Hp Omen 30 Litros. En both cases as a case not as a laptop? Thanks for your support
Great review thanks
amazing review, lots of useful info, thanks.
Hi, your videos are so useful.. waiting for new MacBook pro comparison with theese lap... I have a suggestion instead of showing decimal sound measurements, can u record the fan noise so we can get a much better idea
can you do make on omen ryzen 7 vs macbook m1 16 gb? waiting for this, please make
I am just chilling here with my g14
What's your specs?
Giveaway results?
Can you please do a gaming comparison of these very same laptops?
Which one u will suggest in HP Omen, ryzen 5 with 1650 or i5 with 1660 ti ?
Great vid👍👍
You didn't address Omen 15 screen wobble in the build quality
Great Vid Ben, Thanks a lot for your content, Just one thing i noticed that made the review a bit hard to understand for me, You are speaking way too fast, yet i appreciate ur content a lot.
Lower the video speed
Why? You should compere legion ryzen 7 4800 h vs this same hp omen. Amd serii4000 is 20% better for video editing till Intel
Thank you.
Overall I think HP omen 15 is better choice.
Keep rocking bro 👍.
the more expensive the price, the better the quality
@@aryadwiramdhani5564 Not always.
@@Nkc_Aryan Always has been🔫
Which one has longer battery
@@No-cc1fq omen
I bought the legion I5 during a Labor Day dale for $900. It’s the model with the intel i7-10750h a Nvidia gtx 2060 and 8gb of ram. But I added another 8gb and it has been an absolute unit of a laptop. I couldn’t be happier.
Got a 16gb version for 999 same specs where did you find one for 900?
And how are the thermals mine is arriving soon
@@osvaldor4298 Best Buy last Labor Day, yours was more probably because of the ram. And the thermals are nothing to write home about. I bought a stand to get more space underneath the fans and that helped a lot.
@Lu- Eslava I’m a double math and finance major, so I’m using it for online classes and some simple coding in python and matlab. Only thing I’d say is it can be kind of loud, but you have control over the fans. Oh, and the battery life isn’t great.
@[ARB] Evil Aura I can make it through a 2 hour class. I think. Everything is online so I haven’t tried it yet. But I worry about when I’m back in a classroom, I honestly think I’d have to get a different type. Kind of ironic as it’s advertised as a sleek business style of laptop.
Great video!
Thanks for the comparison 👍👍 now I know that ryzen(omen/legion 5) faster at exporting and intel (omen/legion 5i) better at live playback
Really great review!
I am interested into buying the Lenovo IdeaPad Creator 5 (with an i5) I need it for photo editing, I am searching for TH-cam reviews for this laptop and I can't find many to say the least.
It would be very much appreciated if you could do a review on this model. Thank you in advance! 😁✌️
Nevermind I bought the Huawei Matebook 14 and it's brilliant!
Great video 👍
can u test gaming benchmark and regular benchmark between asus rog strix scar 15 high end and asus tuf a15 and tell thr true gaming performance and overall performance between these two laptops coz i want to buy a famung laptop if rog is perfect then i have to buy it if u can do it then reply me... and thanjs in advance
How is the audio quality on these two machines? Do they provide acceptable levels of bass through their speakers?
Legion 5 is apparently better. In terms of bass response.
What about the Prestige 15 with the 11th gen for video editing
can you please check the linux(UBUNTU) compatibility(trackpad,battery etc) in hp omen
Hello. Can anyone say, what is the name of the dark-green of Legion 5?
Moss green is the name of the colour
Great job as always, keep like that, and let's get rockin'
Please do a video for legion 5i vs Omen ryzen 5 variant (comparing the CPUs with same cores and threads).
Legion is better in this way
Please give review on MSI GP65 LEOPARD 32 gb ram variant.
What happened about your laptop giveaway result???
Yeah
Yeah
Yeah
I need the update as well 🙂
So finally after 9 minutes of gibberish in this 12 minutes video, you started to talk about video editing. Thanks
Hp omen Intel i7 or legion i7 ??
Dude. The amd chip is waay cooler than the intel one. Im guessing legion has better cooling then
Which laptop has better screen quality colour and graphics ?
Lenovo legion
Lenovo Legion 5Pi review please,new rtx model
I sent with omen and upgraded ram.
hi please reply!
R5 3500u / 8 GB DDR4 2666BUS SDRAM / 512GB M.2 NVMe™ PCIe® 3.0 SSD / GTX 1050 4GB
vs
R5 4500u / 8GB DDR4 3200MHz RAM / 256GB NVMe PCIe SSD / AMD Integrated Graphic Card
which laptop will be better for video editing (premiere pro)
can i do 1080p video editing comfortably??
please answer i am on low budget and very confused
According to what you provided the top would be better. But I have never personally seen that set up before.
MSI Modern 14 B4MW 14-inch Full HD IPS Display Ryzen 5 4500U 8GB RAM 256GB SSD LAPTOP
ASUS D570DD 15.6 inch Full HD Display Ryzen 5 8GB RAM 512GB SSD Gaming Laptop with Nvidia GTX 1050 4GB Graphics
i am from Bangladesh, most of the laptop you suggest on your channel is not available in our country. but i love your channel. you explain everything thoroughly.
can i edit 1080p comfortably in any of these?
thanks for such fast response
What do you suggest among the two laotops? Btw I bought legion 5i
Hey, can you upgrade the ram up to 32gb. Cos im planning to buy a laptop that upgrades to 32gb of ram
@@johnmatira5452 if one slot is installed 8GB and can't be removed then how many GB must be installed in the other slot so that it becomes 32 GB?
@@hasan7664 it supports 32. the configuration process only offers up to 16 3200Mhz (2x8GB)
@@aryadwiramdhani5564 both slot 16gigs
@@johnmatira5452 yes upgradable to 32gb, 2933mhz
intel vs amd comparison doesn't make sense to me
I prefer omen 15 the beast
Legion 5 is the hunter of beasts
;)
Legion - Designed in China
Omen - Designed in USA
Enough said..
(Both made in China though)
Yep. The Legion has the better build quality when compared to that wobbly Omen screen. HP engineers get paid too much for sub standard products - lmao.
My legion is in i7 10th gen and rtx2060 144hz. I got 2h of just web browsing and typings. Is there anything you configured to get 5-6hours?
Is there any thing suggest mee...too
I got hp omen as it was cheaper here in india. Hp has done a really good job in 2020.
How much did it cost? And what's the specs?
@@math.x_1729 ryzen 5 4600h 1660ti 60hz display 8gb ram 512gb ssd. 1150$ approx. 150$ is tax paid.
What's your review of it? Don't you feel the 60Hz screen is not ideal for gaming?
@@math.x_1729 yes it is but there's no other option which runs so cool with 1660ti and r5 that too at this price. Soon I'll be buying a 144 hz monitor. If you ignore 60hz then this laptop is unbeatable at everything.
@[ARB] Evil Aura i do a lot of gaming. There is no idle fan noise. While gaming fans run pretty loud but that sound is like a jet plane taking off. Very satisfying not irritating like other laptops.
dont take this as offensive, but is it a coincidence that you look similar to greg salazar
1:44 The 17" Legion 5/5i have SD Card readers. I hate that the Omen doenst have a numpad, wasted space for the direction keys, and the power button couldn't be in a worse placement. I just ordered a 17" 144hz DolbyVision Legion 5 with a Ryzen 7 4800H, 16GB, and a RTX 2060 all for less than the base 17" configuration with my work partner discount.
Always check your employee benefits resources. You might find out you get a huge discount too.
I'm upgrading from a still very capable 15" Dell Latitude E6540 that can actually run Cyberpunk 2077😅🤣
(edit) After watching the entire video all the Legion vrs Omen performance comparisons are VOID
both laptops should have bean compared with the same hardware since they are available in the same configurations.
All the performance results is comparing is Intel VS AMD not Legion VS Omen.
Lol true very true I feel the legion would perform better
Yaa!! This video seemed to be biased towards OMEN
HP OMEN
गिबओए कहिले पाउछु के मैंले धेरै कुरे खै
i feel like this review has a bit bias towards hp omen with his choice of words. meh.
Lenovo Nice
❤❤❤❤❤Lenovo Legion❤❤❤❤❤
Which is the best for 4k video editing means Hp Omen 15 Ryzen or Intel I am confused can you please help me out....
Go with intel
Actually Ryzen cpus are much faster mixed with a 1660ti or rtx 2060 (non maxQ)
@@Alex.R.O.P normally i noticed ryzen systems takes lot of power compared to Intel
@@kumarnengg7559 ive seen that intel gets more warm than ryzen and that ryzen is faster because the cpu doesn't need much power to run .. The reviewers ive had a temperature gun or heat seaking camera
@@Alex.R.O.P ok alex which one you recommend legion 5i and omen, in think of productivity, lots of coding and editing , Adobe software especially
Should I buy an i5 10th gen or i7 8th gen? both with 4 cores...
i7 8th gen
ryzen 7
@@cjo7370 But what if the choice is between those 2 only?
@@aimanjain7219 try find 2 laptops with those cpus and then check which one has more performance.. which one has more -> cache , cores, threads, boost clock or you can search up gaming benchmarks of the cpus but remember that the pc needs to have the same GPU and ram size just search i5 10th gen vs i7 8th gen.
Id prefer a i5 10th gen because they are all 2020-21 and have NVIDIA 16 and 20 series while 8th gen all have NVIDIA 10 series and are from 2017-18
🙏
👌👌👌✌
This guy talks so fast
Try watching him with 2x speed😁
I have both of em and this guy didn't talk much about the build quality but the omen just SUCKS! Yeah, it really does. The Legion 5 is just the better option.
Your voice is very low
give away pls 🥺
First
please speak slower!!!
*I Spend My All Time In "Recording" "Editing" And "Uploading" Want All My Brother And Sisters Support Please😍😘❤*
Hp laptops are bad 😂😂😂😂😂