@@McInHeather Yeah, but at the TorchWood episode David tennant had to say goodbye, and gave her a version of him as a human, so she could keep him, but like a human version.
McInHeather She kind of got to keep a mix of the two. The meta-crisis doctor didn’t have the tenth Doctors memories, so he was in some ways closer to nine than ten.
For a practically immortal timelord who has seen the universe begin and end and everything inbetween David Tennant gave this guy the humanity of a broken soul
So beautiful. Most of the sadness and greatness of the romance happened after she was lost. Tennant missing his Rose made it the beautiful thing it is Although..... I would have liked it if in that scene he said "Her name IS* Rose" instead of "Her name WAS* Rose" Would have been a sad moment of him not losing hope of seeing her again, and also the hopelessness of realisation that he will never see her again
@@1GuyWith6Guns you can see his happiness because he is talking of rose but you can hear and see the pain at the same time because he remembers he cant see her anymore
,,, the scene where donna mentions bad wolf had me bawling. He's so desperate, clinging onto a single spark of hope that she found a way back. I can't with this show, it still gets me even after having been a fan of the show for 8 years
@@DoctorWhoKage it's because R.T.D. era was ending and everyone was mentioned to that...that's why in the end Doctor "say goodbye" to every his friend, it's like saying goodbye to all, that create R.T.D.
Yea, also the bad wolf thing always confused me, can u explain it to me plz? Why does “bad wolf” link with rose, which episode did it come from? And why “bad wolf”
"I'm sure it's bad, I get that. But, Rose is coming back. Isn't that good?" Donna Noble, the Doctor's best friend, knowing how to cheer him up when all seems horrible.
@@DeltaDubs89 exactly. She will always be iconic for me because she was never romantically into the doctor. She really just wanted to be his friend, genuinely and she helped him so much emotionally.
That "her name was Rose" scene is so perfect. You can see the wave of grief hit his face when Donna asking about her catches him of guard. He can barely muster a smile after saying her name. Truly a masterclass in subtle facial acting.
Idc how great all the new companions are, Rose will always be my favorite. Simply because she was so normal. She was a normal average person who became something greater because of her humanity.
"The north wind blows and carries down the distant Rose" "Oh no that's where you've made a mistake because that name keeps me fighting" ❤❤❤ She won't be forgotten, Doctor. Ever.
she certainly wasn’t forgotten up to s4, but aside from the 50th anniversaries special shes not brought up all that i can remember. S4 wrapped everything up beautifully, but nothing carried over to the moffat era aside from what he himself wrote (and im still salty abt that. give me good ol tenrose / Doctor donna content any day)
I wish I could agree, but the 11th Doctor forgot all about her. Im pretty sure in The Day Of The Doctor there was a part where 10 got really angry at 11 because he didn't recognise her name at all :"(
@@justaplasticcupaaaaaa1350 well, she was brought up in "Let's kill Hitler", when the 11th was dying, and he felt guilty about Rose. Maybe he just want to forget them all mindfully and move on
I just love that in the Family of Blood Episodes even though the Doctor lost his memory of being a time lord he still dreamt about Rose and remembered her by name. if i recall he didn't even remember the name of the TARDIS. That just speaks to how much he loved her.
I have to say Donna was my favourite companion. No romantic feelings for the Doctor, just a wholesome friendship that Ten cherished. She was excited for him to reunite with Rose, something a best friend would do. I was absolutely devastated when her memories had to be wiped for her own safety.
I love Donna so much! She didn't mind the Doctor's obsession with Rose and tried to cheer him up that Rose was coming back, not jealous like Martha. :)
Well Donna didn’t have feelings for him, I feel Martha is unappreciated and people find her annoying bc she likes the Doctor and he doesn’t like her back
I understand why people might not like how jealous Martha was, but looking at it from her perspective, she met a gorgeous ageless man who kissed her the first time they met and then invited her to travel through time and space with him. It's totally understandable that she ended up falling in love, and that it was difficult for her to be as understanding when the Doctor kept bringing up Rose and being completely oblivious to Martha's feelings. Donna was never attracted to the Doctor and vice versa, so it just wasn't an issue. He even said, "I just want a mate" when they first met, so the expectations for the relationship were very clear.
This is why I liked Donna more than Martha, Donna found out about Rose and accepted that an alien with an inhumanly long lifespan would have other people he cared about. Martha on the other hand saw rose as a challenge and got super jealous.
But Martha still had a plausible reaction, her time was still quite enjoyable she just didn’t fully understand the two hearted elongated life span genius from an alien planet who looks after earth so fair enough on Martha
@@MagnetMagicGirl See, that's fair enough, but the Doctor wouldn't stop talking about Rose. Martha: Doctor, I've cured Space Cancer! Doctor: Rose would be so happy about that... :'(
@@jandiqar ofc he couldn't he missed her, he was grieving. he's allowed to. imagine losing your closest friend and when you move on and try to talk about her to your new friend she just says "get over it and love me instead???" "oh here we go again with your dead friend" and basically not caring that you might be grieving just wanting all your undecided attention. God Martha had SUCH POTENTIAL and they had to make her main personality trait jealousy
Have... Have you not seen it? Amy to the doctor - "I've been thinking about what I want... who I want..." The doctor to Rory - "we need to talk about your fiance. She tried to kiss me!" / "I kissed her mouth." Granted she was sexually frustrated but it's still relevant.
this series portrays loss in a way i've not seen many other series do - subtle reminders of their existence, so many series forget a character existed or have only one or two reminders - but doctor who did not forget rose EDIT: blimey, i only posted this a day ago and it says i have 28 thumbs up, what the heck? :)
@@liamwalton4183 Warch the pain in Graham eyes. Feel more natural and subtle that Tennant constant crybaby moments that feel so out of character for a Time Lord.
When Donna said Bad Wolf it makes me so sad he got so excited. I like to think after Journeys End Rose stayed with the Doctor, travelling forever. I know this isn't what really happened, but a girl can dream
there is a deleted scene in journeys end where donna gives rose and meta-crisis doctor a piece of tardis coral so they can grow their own, even though this is a deleted scene it is still considered cannon
"-She's gone. -Gone where ? - I lost her. - Then hurry up and lose ME! " If you think about it, so sad this exact scene actually happen in Journey's End.
@Ike Ike In the episode "Journey's End", Tenth says goodbye for good to Rose on the beach, and then about 20s later he has to do the same with his friend when she draws his attention
Not everyone likes Rose. Can't say I do. But there's no way to deny what she meant to the Doctor. You can spin his feelings one way or another in fan theories, but you just can't deny it.
It's more Tennants acting so well being in love with her and lost her. The best "Rose moments" happened after her being gone. As this video shows. So like it wasnt a great romance for the sake of romance, but the "better to have loved and lost than to never have loved at all" mixed with "I'd do anything to get her back, I can save or destroy planets if I wanted, but am powerless to do anything to get her back" performance Tennant gives, it's beautiful. Like he's lost all hope but also filled with joy that he met her and knowing she's still alive somewhere
Martha was such a good character, that had so much potential. She was smart, determined, resourceful, independent, not afraid to speak her mind and stand up for herself, but all of that was pretty much swept under the rug because the writers somehow decided to make her one-sided crush for the Doctor her entire personality. Now all that she’s remembered for is how she always had a chip on her shoulder over the fact that she was living in the shadow of someone she knew she’ll never be - despite the fact that she literally helped save the world and the Doctor’s life a few times. Martha and her actress deserved better.
@@lesley1204 Of course, Martha also had the horrid luck to fall in love with a man who had _just lost the love of his life_ and hadn't had time to get over her. The Doctor was comically oblivious to how she started feeling about him, and a lot of that IS because he was still mourning Rose. How he treated her wasn't really fair... but neither was getting upset with him over it and acting jealous when he's still obviously in mourning and honestly had no idea how she really felt. The Doctor always tends to have a special talent for missing the blatantly obvious. I do think the Doctor was dwelling on her _too_ much though, and Martha eventually making her stance clear when she left helped him realize it, giving him the push he needed to start making a real effort to get over her; which Donna ended up helping with, due to being supportive about it, instead of getting snippy every time the topic of Rose came up.
You could tell how much he loved Rose. You could see the pain in his eyes whenever he remembers her or talks about her. Like the only time we actually saw him cry was when he had to leave her for good. He probably missed her every single day since then.
My take on why Rose is so important to the Doctor is because: She healed his wounds from the Time War, with friendship and love. She was the first human that breathed vigor and life into the TARDIS again. Without her, Doctor would still be hurt and traumatized by the War. That's why she's important. It's not because she is someTwilight-ish love story or anything for the Doctor. She's so much more than that.
It`s been 14 years ago and still brings pain. And i love how fandom is still talking about Ten and Rose. Fandom will never forget them. UPD: and don`t forget 9!
Donna shipping the Doctor and Rose is a beautiful thing! I do think, once the two girls met and got used to each other because as jealous as Martha was of Rose, Rose too would have felt insecure upon meeting Martha, I do think they would have become friends and it would have been like when Sarah Jane and Rose met and after a couple of hours they started talking and then laughing over things the Doctor did.
@@jamesjackson4741 The episode when River Song regenerated from Mel...oh yeah Let's Kill Hitler! He's dying from poison and he tells his TARDIS to show him something that brings regret from himself. The TARDIS then shows a hologram of Rose. In a later episode (don't remember which) Matt Smith says: "I can help Rose Tyler with her homework-" before blurting on about something completely different.
@@Phoenix-ro6wh the term Bad Wolf signifies the end of the universe. That by itself is pretty big but it also reminds him of Rose because (sorry if I'm about to spoil something you don't have to continue reading) she's Bad Wolf.
I love how basically every doctor has mentioned rose or remembered her all the way from 9 to 14 they all had a scene where they remembered her showing just how important she was
Now I have to rewatch... and I’m halfway through twelve.... I promise I will rewatch all of 9 and 10 after I’ve finished 12. I love this show so much, damn
I got literal chills on turn left when that iconic 10 music plays and Donna says bad wolf god I loved that when I first saw that. Also who else really really wants to see jack in doctor who again just for one episode
I just believe that Rose was that special person for Doctor's heart, someone who can never be forgotten and meant so much... His friend, his saviour, his family, his home, a person who will always hold his hand
The Doctor and jack reuniting was beautiful. Its both sad and happy to see cursed veterans knowing their friend was safe, but can't ever see them again.
I’ve really come to appreciate Rose in these past few years, I always thought she was annoying with the 9th so it bled over into her run with the 10th. ...but the way Davíd Tennant’s eyes look the second she is brought up breaks me into little pieces. So much heartache and pain. Also, this video reminds me how much I dislike Martha as a companion. She was so desperately annoying and jealous. Donna was literally the perfect companion so I’m glad she came into the show quickly.
I thought it was just me who thought Martha was obnoxiously jealous! They could be in a life threatening situation and Martha could somehow just make a jab at Rose and she’d never even met her!
I think that Rose was probably the best damn companion ever. I stopped watching the show after Clara was introduced mostly bc there wasn't that spark that Rose and the Tenth doctor gave to the show. That's just my opinion though...
Yeah but the 12th doctor and Clara had a pretty interesting relationship. Not exactly romantic, but something like soulmates. It's hard to define. It's kind of like what Missy described, but with way less history. I'm starting to think that the Doctor's relationships are always going to be way beyond romance simply because he's a timelord.
But what about the Ponds? Honestly, I’m still mourning those two, lol. Still nothing like Ten and Rose, but Amy and Rory and Eleven were fantastic together ❤️
@@flavoredchin It works because Donna is initially meant to be the complete opposite of Rose - small-minded, self-centred, unimpressed by The Doctor and uninterested in seeing the wonder of it all.
1:57 his voice here will never fail to break my heart, every goddman time i hear him my heart shatters into pieces. at this point this is not acting for me. he's the doctor and he lost the woman he was in love with.
The Doctor is really terrible at explaining any previous emotional experiences he had, if the audience picked up the show after season 2 without knowing what happened to Rose, it'd be another mystery like the Doctor's childhood, life on Galliery etc.
But that makes sense, when people lose a loved one they're not gonna go around telling everyone everything about them, it takes time. A lot of time. We, the audience know what happened but to anyone after I think giving too detailed sn explanation would have been too much for him for a long time
Martha Jones: Caring friend. Donna Noble: Best "Mate". Amy Pond: Best friend. Clara Oswald: Trustful loving companion. Rose Tyler: The one person he truly ever loved. ... Oh, and there's River Song but nobody ever talks about her
back when the series was giving me goosebumps and i couldnt wait to watch the next episode time and time again.....and the music brings in so many angsty emotions its crazy
I love that the Doctor and Martha’s relationship was basically:
“Doctor, I love you”
“My friend Rose used to say that same thing”
You deserve to rule the universe
Feckin friendzoned
When your current lover keeps bringing up his ex
At least Martha finally stopped simping and found a life for her own at UNIT
this comment 😂😂😂
Me: I'm okay
Doctor: her name was Rose
Me: I'm not okay
I'm not okaaaaaaay.
Me neither 😭
he full on chokes up...i cant handle it
Wow literally me lol 😂
(I Promise)
When he almost calls Rose’s family his family...
I caught that too 😭
@Malk Von Batshit damn xD
Timestamp please?:')
@@LilVeehive 0:48
Got one now 😊
Rose is the luckiest companion ever. She actually got to *keep* her version of the doctor.
She didnt, Christopher eccleston was her first doctor
@@McInHeather Ummm yes she did, because she was in love with Ten. It's not even a question.
@@maralonent6257 Rose even kissed the human doctor
@@McInHeather Yeah, but at the TorchWood episode David tennant had to say goodbye, and gave her a version of him as a human, so she could keep him, but like a human version.
McInHeather She kind of got to keep a mix of the two. The meta-crisis doctor didn’t have the tenth Doctors memories, so he was in some ways closer to nine than ten.
Martha: The stars are beautiful tonight.
10: You know who else is beautiful?
Martha, blushing: ...who?
10: Rose.
LOL
Ha
That’s just the 3rd season explain in an nutshell
Gregg rulz ok
For a practically immortal timelord who has seen the universe begin and end and everything inbetween David Tennant gave this guy the humanity of a broken soul
The Lonely God
Danii Decay not always, the last time war truly broke him. Certain companions hurt him more even while helping him in the short term
Danii Decay so have I, who’s with me
Best doctor hands down
@@eldritchcupcakes3195 Here, brother.
Jack and the Doctor celebrating Rose's safety, just so precious.
Till then they were both lowkey hating each other, but remembering Rose made them make up... I think that's really cute.
The doctor really needed that hug.
I think the fact that they just despise each other until Rose and that's the one time that they're like best friends. I think that's so sweet
She was special to nine and ten hope they bring her back
There like the best friend who hate eachother then make up and are cool again
“Her name was Rose” 😭😭😭
you can hear the pain in his voice. such an interstellar actor.
So beautiful. Most of the sadness and greatness of the romance happened after she was lost. Tennant missing his Rose made it the beautiful thing it is
Although..... I would have liked it if in that scene he said "Her name IS* Rose" instead of "Her name WAS* Rose"
Would have been a sad moment of him not losing hope of seeing her again, and also the hopelessness of realisation that he will never see her again
@@BAZ1NG3R He seemed happy to answer that question. It was the first time Donna asked about Rose in a positive manner.
@@1GuyWith6Guns you can see his happiness because he is talking of rose but you can hear and see the pain at the same time because he remembers he cant see her anymore
Felt like each time he started to mention her name more, he got a bit better but he obviously still always thinking about her
David Tennant is such a great actor. That scene where he remembers Rose while watching a man and a blonde woman dance gives me goose bumps.
TheCaitOfLin somehow just as i reached that scene, i reached this comment
No thats the power of editing. Well done John Richards.
Same
That scene was too good
11th is better than 10
"Is that what you said? To your friend? Did she trust you?"
Fuuuuck me. Bloody hell that was a loaded line
That was such a British reaction lol. 😅
How dare you swear with *that* profile picture
Lyra H. Strings boB ROSS WOULD BE *_ASHAMED_*
the moment i felt my heart claw it's way up my throat and free itself from my body
@@uatoto7783 so your an Ood now
,,, the scene where donna mentions bad wolf had me bawling. He's so desperate, clinging onto a single spark of hope that she found a way back. I can't with this show, it still gets me even after having been a fan of the show for 8 years
tbh I feel it was more fear of what would be causing that to be possible
And I hate that they completely dropped them all (not just Rose) after the Tenth regenerated into the Eleventh.
@@DoctorWhoKage it's because R.T.D. era was ending and everyone was mentioned to that...that's why in the end Doctor "say goodbye" to every his friend, it's like saying goodbye to all, that create R.T.D.
So true
Yea, also the bad wolf thing always confused me, can u explain it to me plz? Why does “bad wolf” link with rose, which episode did it come from? And why “bad wolf”
"I'm sure it's bad, I get that. But, Rose is coming back. Isn't that good?"
Donna Noble, the Doctor's best friend, knowing how to cheer him up when all seems horrible.
Donna is awesome. My favorite companion alongside Rose and Amy. The Doctor’s true best friend!
Yeah. I love how they were more best friends then romantic. It's why it hurt so much to have her forget him.
@@DeltaDubs89 exactly. She will always be iconic for me because she was never romantically into the doctor. She really just wanted to be his friend, genuinely and she helped him so much emotionally.
The Bad Wolf arc was the most epic Who storyline ever.
Amen
True. Til this day.
The Bad Wolf is basically just the living embodiment of all six infinity stones
i got chills from it!!!!!
Trueee
those were the days when doctor who was at its peak
No, is the Rose Tyler's show.
He seemed happier with Rose
@@justanotherpiecashit7782 He was more happy with the Ponds, his family.
Doctor who is still so good
Peak
I love Jack's reaction to Rose being alive
@Ahror I so wish we'd have gotten to see more of 9, Rose , and Jack.
Well she gave him life longest life to be honest i will had act like him if that happend to me. Its speacil gift.
@@sanityisrelative I wish we had gotten more of 9 in general.
Bad Wolf. That scene still gives me chills.
Always 😭
Same I loved it
goosebumps at uncontrollable levels every time... even over 10 years later.
Absolutely the same
Dude, same
You can see the pain in his eyes Every time rose is mentioned. I loved the doctor and rose together. They need to bring her back 😭
They are and the human doctor as well I AM EXITED!!!
Tia allum x WAIT IM SORRY WHAT
@@maggiem5528 oops spoilers
@@robbie._.7914 NO PLEASE WHERE DID THIS INFO COME FROM
@@maggiem5528 I have my ways anyways I think it's either 2020 or 2021 but shhhhhhhhhh
That "her name was Rose" scene is so perfect. You can see the wave of grief hit his face when Donna asking about her catches him of guard. He can barely muster a smile after saying her name. Truly a masterclass in subtle facial acting.
Idc how great all the new companions are, Rose will always be my favorite. Simply because she was so normal. She was a normal average person who became something greater because of her humanity.
100%
I fully agree! I love her character and she's my favourite alongside with Donna
Donna and her were the only ones who seemed properly human. There were no parallel timelines and other motives, it was just pure and beautiful.
"everybody except rose"
*Cut to Rose*
DON'T HURT ME IN THIS WAY
That was a fantastic episode :)
I deadass cried when Donna asked for Rose's name and his voice just cracked like wtf I know it's be a decade but it still gets me
"The north wind blows and carries down the distant Rose"
"Oh no that's where you've made a mistake because that name keeps me fighting" ❤❤❤ She won't be forgotten, Doctor. Ever.
When you realize that they put North wind in Sherlock BBC and doctor who which is weird.
@@civilmagpie1454 I haven't seen Sherlock
she certainly wasn’t forgotten up to s4, but aside from the 50th anniversaries special shes not brought up all that i can remember. S4 wrapped everything up beautifully, but nothing carried over to the moffat era aside from what he himself wrote (and im still salty abt that. give me good ol tenrose / Doctor donna content any day)
I wish I could agree, but the 11th Doctor forgot all about her. Im pretty sure in The Day Of The Doctor there was a part where 10 got really angry at 11 because he didn't recognise her name at all :"(
@@justaplasticcupaaaaaa1350 well, she was brought up in "Let's kill Hitler", when the 11th was dying, and he felt guilty about Rose. Maybe he just want to forget them all mindfully and move on
I just love that in the Family of Blood Episodes even though the Doctor lost his memory of being a time lord he still dreamt about Rose and remembered her by name. if i recall he didn't even remember the name of the TARDIS. That just speaks to how much he loved her.
Natalie Ybarra I cry 😭
I didn’t even realize that OUCH
I have to say Donna was my favourite companion. No romantic feelings for the Doctor, just a wholesome friendship that Ten cherished. She was excited for him to reunite with Rose, something a best friend would do. I was absolutely devastated when her memories had to be wiped for her own safety.
You must be so excited now with the special!!
You can celebrate now
I don't care what you say there has never been nor ever will be an on screen relationship like rose and the 10th doctor.
I mean...Vex’ahlia and Percival Fredrickstein von Musel Klossowski de Rolo III is pretty great.
Dr: "It's staring me right in the face and I can't see it.."
Martha: :)
Dr: "Rose would know."
Martha: :'0
Me: *oof*
Ik. That made me laugh then cry
omg doctor why would you lead her on like that-
IL omg
FriEndZoNEd AgaIN
The Doctor: ßēgøñë thøt
Can we all just take a moment to think of how Jack must have felt when he seen that Rose was dead on the list.. :(
I love Donna so much! She didn't mind the Doctor's obsession with Rose and tried to cheer him up that Rose was coming back, not jealous like Martha. :)
Donna is just the best
Well Donna didn’t have feelings for him, I feel Martha is unappreciated and people find her annoying bc she likes the Doctor and he doesn’t like her back
@@NelsonTheAwesome I love Martha, I just never noticed that bit about Donna before :)
I understand why people might not like how jealous Martha was, but looking at it from her perspective, she met a gorgeous ageless man who kissed her the first time they met and then invited her to travel through time and space with him. It's totally understandable that she ended up falling in love, and that it was difficult for her to be as understanding when the Doctor kept bringing up Rose and being completely oblivious to Martha's feelings.
Donna was never attracted to the Doctor and vice versa, so it just wasn't an issue. He even said, "I just want a mate" when they first met, so the expectations for the relationship were very clear.
I always loved and respected Martha for realising she was worth more than pining after someone who didn’t appreciate her value.
This is why I liked Donna more than Martha, Donna found out about Rose and accepted that an alien with an inhumanly long lifespan would have other people he cared about.
Martha on the other hand saw rose as a challenge and got super jealous.
Miroku Gaming That, right there, is why I couldn’t stand Martha!
But Martha still had a plausible reaction, her time was still quite enjoyable she just didn’t fully understand the two hearted elongated life span genius from an alien planet who looks after earth so fair enough on Martha
Miroku Gaming very true, and I agree with you. But Donna did not fancy the Doctor, as Martha did. I see your point.
@@MagnetMagicGirl See, that's fair enough, but the Doctor wouldn't stop talking about Rose.
Martha: Doctor, I've cured Space Cancer!
Doctor: Rose would be so happy about that... :'(
@@jandiqar ofc he couldn't he missed her, he was grieving. he's allowed to. imagine losing your closest friend and when you move on and try to talk about her to your new friend she just says "get over it and love me instead???" "oh here we go again with your dead friend" and basically not caring that you might be grieving just wanting all your undecided attention. God Martha had SUCH POTENTIAL and they had to make her main personality trait jealousy
I think Matt's doctor felt similar with Amy. The pain in his eyes during closing time when he sees her is heartwrenching
The Ponds are his family and I hate that they never was mentioned again.
I don't think 11 was IN love with Amy.
But I felt the Ponds were like his family.
Amy was certainly in love with him ;)
@@bi_cycle No, is just a imaginary friend. She really loves Rory. Clara and Rose are in love to him.
Have...
Have you not seen it?
Amy to the doctor - "I've been thinking about what I want... who I want..."
The doctor to Rory - "we need to talk about your fiance. She tried to kiss me!" / "I kissed her mouth."
Granted she was sexually frustrated but it's still relevant.
this series portrays loss in a way i've not seen many other series do - subtle reminders of their existence, so many series forget a character existed or have only one or two reminders - but doctor who did not forget rose
EDIT: blimey, i only posted this a day ago and it says i have 28 thumbs up, what the heck? :)
No, Graham O'brien did that more subtle like Amy tears for Rory in "Vincent and the Doctor". This is just manipulation.
@@mayotango1317 You must be fun to be around
@@liamwalton4183 Warch the pain in Graham eyes. Feel more natural and subtle that Tennant constant crybaby moments that feel so out of character for a Time Lord.
@@mayotango1317 That's just manipulation
@@liamwalton4183 No, Tennant is.
This is actually so upsetting to watch
When Donna said Bad Wolf it makes me so sad he got so excited. I like to think after Journeys End Rose stayed with the Doctor, travelling forever. I know this isn't what really happened, but a girl can dream
there is a deleted scene in journeys end where donna gives rose and meta-crisis doctor a piece of tardis coral so they can grow their own, even though this is a deleted scene it is still considered cannon
@@scantopup2226 cool thx I did not know that
That's not a deleted scene rose does end up living a life with the human doctor
@@mb-sb5ever The scene with the Tardis coral was deleted.
"-She's gone.
-Gone where ?
- I lost her.
- Then hurry up and lose ME! "
If you think about it, so sad this exact scene actually happen in Journey's End.
Why must you hurt me this way?
wait what? i dont understand. how! pls explainnn:)
@Ike Ike In the episode "Journey's End", Tenth says goodbye for good to Rose on the beach, and then about 20s later he has to do the same with his friend when she draws his attention
@@johana3065 saw the episode. got it. thank you, you're very kind! :)
Whenever the women mentioned Roses name and The Doctor said “well big mistake because that name keeps me fighting!” Literally gave me goosebumps
Not everyone likes Rose. Can't say I do. But there's no way to deny what she meant to the Doctor. You can spin his feelings one way or another in fan theories, but you just can't deny it.
It's more Tennants acting so well being in love with her and lost her. The best "Rose moments" happened after her being gone. As this video shows.
So like it wasnt a great romance for the sake of romance, but the "better to have loved and lost than to never have loved at all" mixed with "I'd do anything to get her back, I can save or destroy planets if I wanted, but am powerless to do anything to get her back"
performance Tennant gives, it's beautiful.
Like he's lost all hope but also filled with joy that he met her and knowing she's still alive somewhere
WHAT ROSE WAS THE BEST
Why don’t you like Rose tf
Love Rose
@@syno894 Because everyone has different tastes and opinions."
The pain in his eyes when his bad wolf girl is mentioned destroys my heart
1:06 you can practically feel the pain and bitterness pouring out of him over losing her, absolutely great acting without saying a word
He is nearly crying. Every time😭😭
When I first watched the scene at 1:57 I remember BAWLING THE PAIN IN HIS VOICE AND FACE WAS TOO MUCH FOR ME
Their relationship really was irreplaceable. No one will ever be as close to him as she was, what a magical bond.
Love how Donna was always so supportive of the doctors memory of rose where as Martha was always so bitter and jealous
Martha was such a good character, that had so much potential. She was smart, determined, resourceful, independent, not afraid to speak her mind and stand up for herself, but all of that was pretty much swept under the rug because the writers somehow decided to make her one-sided crush for the Doctor her entire personality. Now all that she’s remembered for is how she always had a chip on her shoulder over the fact that she was living in the shadow of someone she knew she’ll never be - despite the fact that she literally helped save the world and the Doctor’s life a few times. Martha and her actress deserved better.
@@lesley1204 Of course, Martha also had the horrid luck to fall in love with a man who had _just lost the love of his life_ and hadn't had time to get over her. The Doctor was comically oblivious to how she started feeling about him, and a lot of that IS because he was still mourning Rose.
How he treated her wasn't really fair... but neither was getting upset with him over it and acting jealous when he's still obviously in mourning and honestly had no idea how she really felt. The Doctor always tends to have a special talent for missing the blatantly obvious.
I do think the Doctor was dwelling on her _too_ much though, and Martha eventually making her stance clear when she left helped him realize it, giving him the push he needed to start making a real effort to get over her; which Donna ended up helping with, due to being supportive about it, instead of getting snippy every time the topic of Rose came up.
You could tell how much he loved Rose. You could see the pain in his eyes whenever he remembers her or talks about her. Like the only time we actually saw him cry was when he had to leave her for good. He probably missed her every single day since then.
“Everything she did was so... human.”
I love that... so much 🧡
The nostalgia is strong with this one...back when Doctor Who was...perfect.
Bro this makes me want to re watch the whole series!!!
MrYutbe57 i did and after years i finally watched the last Christmas special moffat wrote and i bawed so hard.
Never forget even matt smith had rose moments. I think that’s just how important she was in this show.
My take on why Rose is so important to the Doctor is because:
She healed his wounds from the Time War, with friendship and love. She was the first human that breathed vigor and life into the TARDIS again. Without her, Doctor would still be hurt and traumatized by the War.
That's why she's important. It's not because she is someTwilight-ish love story or anything for the Doctor. She's so much more than that.
It always gets me when his voice breaks and sais "her name was rose" its like a knife to the heart.
"oh big mistake, because that name keeps me fighting" 😭😭😭
It`s been 14 years ago and still brings pain. And i love how fandom is still talking about Ten and Rose. Fandom will never forget them.
UPD: and don`t forget 9!
Donna shipping the Doctor and Rose is a beautiful thing! I do think, once the two girls met and got used to each other because as jealous as Martha was of Rose, Rose too would have felt insecure upon meeting Martha, I do think they would have become friends and it would have been like when Sarah Jane and Rose met and after a couple of hours they started talking and then laughing over things the Doctor did.
Thx for that video. Rose was my favorite companion
Sentark mine too
Mine too, but donna and amy come pretty close:)
Bruh, what about when Matt Smith mentioned her?
@@jamesjackson4741 The episode when River Song regenerated from Mel...oh yeah Let's Kill Hitler! He's dying from poison and he tells his TARDIS to show him something that brings regret from himself. The TARDIS then shows a hologram of Rose.
In a later episode (don't remember which) Matt Smith says: "I can help Rose Tyler with her homework-" before blurting on about something completely different.
Vincent Does Things epico
I'm here to see that.
Its funny how the tardis shows him holograms of companion and when its rose hes like," MORE GUILT..."
@@FortNightPG no... He said "thanks, give me guilt" when the TARDIS showed rose. He said "more guilt" when it showed Donna
HIS FACE WHEN DONNA SAYS BAD WOLF MAKES ME CRY EVERY TIME
Wait why does it make him react like that
@@Phoenix-ro6wh the term Bad Wolf signifies the end of the universe. That by itself is pretty big but it also reminds him of Rose because (sorry if I'm about to spoil something you don't have to continue reading) she's Bad Wolf.
@@avonic2874 thank youuu I watched this in a long time ^^
@@Phoenix-ro6wh no problem! It's been a long time for me too 😂
I know the doctor loved Rose but just realised Jack literally traveled to the end of the universe to find out what happened to her
BRING BACK ROSE
WarriorAngel4God
BRING BACK ROSE
who are you... I'm the doctor.... but... you're a woman....
Please don't
They brought her back once.
No she is Terrible. I like Donna More
I love how basically every doctor has mentioned rose or remembered her all the way from 9 to 14 they all had a scene where they remembered her showing just how important she was
Now I have to rewatch... and I’m halfway through twelve.... I promise I will rewatch all of 9 and 10 after I’ve finished 12. I love this show so much, damn
I got literal chills on turn left when that iconic 10 music plays and Donna says bad wolf god I loved that when I first saw that.
Also who else really really wants to see jack in doctor who again just for one episode
I still get chills when Donna says, "Bad Wolf." The music swell is fantastic
Couldn't agree more
“And we was together” I love this part so much
I just believe that Rose was that special person for Doctor's heart, someone who can never be forgotten and meant so much... His friend, his saviour, his family, his home, a person who will always hold his hand
The Doctor and jack reuniting was beautiful. Its both sad and happy to see cursed veterans knowing their friend was safe, but can't ever see them again.
The fact that he drew her in his tiny note book I'm sorry. 😢😂❤
The one where he says "We we're together" always makes me so happy XD
The love he has for her shines through even when he replaces his memories 😭❤️
no matter what I do, the words "BAD WOLF" still sends shivers down my back
1:57-2:02 You can definitely see the pain in his eyes when he said, "her name is Rose" :'(
Girls: There isn't a more tragic romance than the titanic.
Me:
When Donna asks what Rose's name was is still one of the most heart breaking line deliveries from David Tennant.
To this day this depresses me, just rewatched the first 2 seasons after years and I miss the doctor and Rose being together
I’ve really come to appreciate Rose in these past few years, I always thought she was annoying with the 9th so it bled over into her run with the 10th.
...but the way Davíd Tennant’s eyes look the second she is brought up breaks me into little pieces. So much heartache and pain.
Also, this video reminds me how much I dislike Martha as a companion. She was so desperately annoying and jealous. Donna was literally the perfect companion so I’m glad she came into the show quickly.
yeah! i loved rose and donna so much, but martha just really grinds my gears y'know?
I fucking hate Donna, shes so stupid, loud and annoying.
@@cadkls Let's just remember Donna made the Daleks look like play toys. DoctorDonna was a force to be reckoned with.
@@AshysWolfie19 aaaaaaaaaaaaand spiiiin
I thought it was just me who thought Martha was obnoxiously jealous! They could be in a life threatening situation and Martha could somehow just make a jab at Rose and she’d never even met her!
The line where Matt smith’s doctor mentions rose is really underrated in my opinion
Me: Shut it, I'm fine
Donna: Two words... bad wolf
Me: Well, here we go again
I loved that plot line and was so sad when she’d gone :(
4:04 that exact moment you see 10’s face change and his instant *need* to confirm that it’s Rose
I think that Rose was probably the best damn companion ever. I stopped watching the show after Clara was introduced mostly bc there wasn't that spark that Rose and the Tenth doctor gave to the show. That's just my opinion though...
I think they tried to do another Rose with Clara but it failed. The RTD era had the best companions.
Yeah but the 12th doctor and Clara had a pretty interesting relationship. Not exactly romantic, but something like soulmates. It's hard to define. It's kind of like what Missy described, but with way less history. I'm starting to think that the Doctor's relationships are always going to be way beyond romance simply because he's a timelord.
But what about the Ponds? Honestly, I’m still mourning those two, lol. Still nothing like Ten and Rose, but Amy and Rory and Eleven were fantastic together ❤️
The majority of Christmas episode Donna pissed me off, I never thought she'd be one of my favorite companions.
Yknow, having matured into an actual adult, Christmas special Donna was gold.
@@flavoredchin It works because Donna is initially meant to be the complete opposite of Rose - small-minded, self-centred, unimpressed by The Doctor and uninterested in seeing the wonder of it all.
Rose acts like she’s the only one who can have the doctor.
As sad as this is I love that Donna wasn’t having any of it 😂
Think one of my favourite is when /11/ says he could help Rose Tyler with her homework
All those years, and he really can't move on
1:57 his voice here will never fail to break my heart, every goddman time i hear him my heart shatters into pieces. at this point this is not acting for me. he's the doctor and he lost the woman he was in love with.
The eyes at 1:06 and the voice at 1:57
I can't. I just can't.
I truly did cry when The Doctor lost Rose. She will always be my favorite companion.
how have i completely erased from my memory the scene where they show the Doctor getting flashbacks of Rose from those people dancing
To painting
I’m crying.. David Tennant is such a great actor..
the first scene always breaks my heart, rose had just been taken away from and donna (although of course she didn't know) just shoves it in his face.
I love the interaction between Donna and the Doctor on 5:33
Donna is so sweet and that smile of 10th was so incredibly sincere
The Doctor is really terrible at explaining any previous emotional experiences he had, if the audience picked up the show after season 2 without knowing what happened to Rose, it'd be another mystery like the Doctor's childhood, life on Galliery etc.
You know until the season 3 finale where the Doctor pretty clearly explains to Jack what happened.
But that makes sense, when people lose a loved one they're not gonna go around telling everyone everything about them, it takes time. A lot of time. We, the audience know what happened but to anyone after I think giving too detailed sn explanation would have been too much for him for a long time
I love Donna, she's the only one that truly talked with him about Rose... there's a reason the Doctor calls her his best friend.
This just makes me miss when Doctor Who was actually good. :(
Doctor: :( :( :( :( :(
Donna:but rose is coming back isn't that good
Doctor: ........yeah!! :D :D
I watched this series like 10 years ago, why am I crying :(
Martha Jones: Caring friend.
Donna Noble: Best "Mate".
Amy Pond: Best friend.
Clara Oswald: Trustful loving companion.
Rose Tyler: The one person he truly ever loved.
...
Oh, and there's River Song but nobody ever talks about her
Wish someone made an updated version of this with the scenes of the 11th Doctor and 13th Doctor mentioning Rose! Gone but never forgotten!
I love Martha, think she is an underrated companion, but I do kind of wish she'd give the Doctor more room to grieve.
Agree but it’s hard when she was in love with him
3:27 I love these little moments when she was trying to reach the doctor that leads up to the end of the series
back when the series was giving me goosebumps and i couldnt wait to watch the next episode time and time again.....and the music brings in so many angsty emotions its crazy
Him sounding like he is on the verge of tears when saying “her name was Rose” really broke me :’)