Valmik Thapar Slams Modi Govt Over Bringing Cheetahs To India, Says Indigenous Species Will Suffer
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2022
- Seventy years after they went extinct in the country, cheetahs are all set to walk again on the Indian lands. India is all set to welcome eight cheetahs on September 17 when the big cats will be brought in from Namibia as part of a special agreement. tember 17 (Saturday).
On Thursday, a modified passenger B747 Jumbo Jet, painted with the face of a tiger, landed in the Namibian capital of Windhoek to ferry the big cats. The plane will take off from Hosea Kutako International Airport in Windhoek with eight Namibian wild cheetahs, five females and three males, on board.
On September 17, Prime Minister Narendra Modi will release the cheetahs in the Kuno National Park in Madhya Pradesh. The day also happens to be the birthday of the prime minister.
#cheetah #narendramodi #namibia #newstoday #rajdeepsardesai
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today TH-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
Download App: indiatoday.link/wHaj
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday.in/
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
![ตรงที่เดิม - ฝน พรสุดา [ต้นฉบับ :เบส ขวางหวัน]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/c5YnbGEztI8/mqdefault.jpg)
Hats off to Rajdeep, he always find people who have something to speak against the central govt. policies or initiatives.
Having debate is what makes democracy.
He picks up people having a totally opposite opinion from the remotest part of the earth, sometimes even resurrects them from the dead, just so that he can give them coverage.
@Garam khun You don’t need to be a bhakt to observe Sardesai’s consistent biased reporting and journalism; something which is beyond khujali wala aapiyas’ intelligence levels.
I am no fan of Rajdeep but there is nothing wrong in discussing counter points and opposite view points.
You need only the person who praise central govt. 😂. You just listen him wht he tells.
When Jairam Ramesh proposed the same many years ago everyone had a huge lollypop in their mouth.
Medha Patkar said so many negative things about the dam. Now proven she was wrong. Mr Thapar is trying to do what Patkar did earlier.
You should not neglect ecology and biodiversity. What Valmik Thapar is saying is very correct. Any wildlifer will say samething.
@@ApurvPirke r u one?? When u just listen to one side this happens, he is not even part of the group bringing cheetahs, he thinks he is right but its not govt was one fine day be like lets bring cheetahs tomorrow , research to listening to every side all these things happen.
@@rakshit8570 It was a forgone conclusion that the government would get their way. They always do. I guess you haven't noticed. Children are starving, but we are building "vanity projects" for crores of rupees. Think about it. We are being ruled by a certain class of people who are buddhus.
@@ninamenon it's like saying why do u do anything untill everyone is fed, everyone is medically fit and insured.
I mean logic of doing vanity project equating it to food is just wrong.
We give 800mln free food during these periods and what vanity project do this central vista is vanity project qhne SC, congress and all want that yo be expanded, bringing all ministry close and become rent free which we are giving.
I mean what to say, I can agree govt will always do dumb things but this govt is less dumber than any govt we had earlier that's why we can see development all our the country from toilet, roads and highway, hospitals, vaccines, innovations, space, free business less bureaucracy and less complainces, less corporate tax, retrospective tax which was biggest mistake in last 2 decades, defense, make in India.
But still I agree there will always be fools in govt , in bureaucracy which is the biggest downfall and judicial and police reform these three are the biggest culprits.
@@rakshit8570 my point is your first paragraph. Huge statues, the "vista" African cheetahs. WHY?
Modi - *promotes oxygen*
Le rajdeep : We can survive on CO2. Who needs oxygen?
🤣🤣🤣🤣
modi bhaiji ne toh oxygen ke plant ka kharcha hi kaat diya delhi se. aur license bhi nahi baate. 5 mange the keju ne 2 hi diye.
@@alarmclock92 kyuki keju ne extra leke blackmarket kiya tha crisis time me bhi…
We dont need external enemies, we have plenty of internal anti-nationals.
Bro how he is being anti nationalist ? Don't talk shit bro
😂
In this particular case, however, Mr. Thapar is making sense. It's commendable that the government is focusing on wildlife related issues but Mr Thapar has raised some very valid points. Nevertheless it's quite good to see the kind of awareness this project has raised in the general population about wildlife.
Yeah so much sanghis here
Indian news media funded by western NGO and George Soros
All Thapar have anti Modi DNA....this Thapar, Karan thapar, romila thapar😄😄😄
Thapar got a good Thappar .
The expert can share his point of view/objections to the decision on the show. But why is he sounding so argumentative and aggressive?
so what your problem.
@@c.augustedupin8860 Didn't the whole India was buring some day back, when a lady in her aggressive tone quoted something from someone's book.
@@kanchandevi9051 ah..apple and oranges, i preserve my judgement based on the merit of the argument and context ,not on the tone
If pappu can survive this 8 cheetas will survive 100 times better than him . This cheetas are much intelligent than pappu cheeta
these are congress sleeper cells
Thapper is wrong, all cats are rivals.
Don't give up before trying.
The project will be success.
He did raise a valid point. There isn't sufficient prey base for the cheetahs. As for competition from leopards, cheetahs are used to that even in Africa.
@@brijeshshukla4696 he seems to hold a very extreme view, even irrational.
He's confusing reintroduction of a disappeared animal with a translocation of a completely new species.
@@sinatra7407 Absolutely not. I completely disagree. This takes us back to the big question. What exactly is the purpose of this re-introduction? African cheetahs are not indigenous to India. Asiatic cheetahs are long gone. What exactly are we achieving by introducing them? If it is the conservation of African cheetahs, then why not focus first on Indian endangered species like the India rhino, tiger and gir lions. Then the question we need to ask is, can a different sub-species be a replacement for another? Introduction of siberian tiger genes in Dudhwa has already made the tigers there racially impure, genetically. When it comes to conservation, sub-species can be considered different enough to not be a replacement for another. But this is a contentious point of view with arguments for and against it. My personal opinion is, this does nothing for the indian wildlife except being a show of sorts. I would have been supportive of this move had cheetah been imported from Iran , being the asiatic variety. That would have been re-introduction. Not this.
@@brijeshshukla4696 1. India is doing really great in protecting Indian Rhino, Tigers and Gir lions. Project Tiger and lion has been successful. India is home to 80% tigers and 85% rhinos in the whole world. And as for Gir lions, their population is also increasing.
2. Yes I agree that different sub-species cannot be a full replacement for indigenous species, but they would help in maintaining the ecosystem. With the extinct of cheetahs in 1952, the open grassland ecosystems were constantly degrading.
3. When the Wildlife Protection Act was introduced ( I believe in 1972 ), Indian government was already working with Iran to re-introduce cheetahs, but for some reasons it did not progressed.
@Environment Lover Bro I have 1 question... What do you mean by " Until we introduce gazelle or black bucks"? I mean gazelles and black bucks are already present in India. Also black bucks are native to Indian subcontinent only. They were exposed to South Africa a few years ago. Today they are present in India and Nepal only.
do you think the people who are involved in this project knows less than this man?
True . People who are involved are highest level expert and involved in animal preservation globally . But some bunch of armchair experts must oppose anything for the sake of opposing it .
@@a9a9d being a vet doctor i know how much effort it takes to do such projects , it takes years to understand and learn a project and these opposer come out of their shell and starts barking .
He is paid actor.
Questioning govt policies is not wrong....its core of democracy
@@krackr6618 question without logic is wrong. Matlab kuch bhi
As Rajdeep and Thapar is useless they think everything which is happening good is also useless and the main objective is talking against govt 😂
Citizens also have their judgement. R & T have lost respect in general population for their constant negative coverage
What's your answer now?
Knock! Knock! … what do you say now??? Bhakt ji!
9 cheetah dead, who is right now?
@@alexcotton4658 total 13 cubs now and not even one of them died . Shoe licker of this barker😂😂😂😂
Just a question to Mr. Thapar, one of his major concern was what would be their prey. So how cheetah’s lived in Indian forest before 70-100 years ago? Of course they have preyed on local herbivores. So the reintroduced African have to adapt with this
Asiatic cheetah is different to African cheetah, both are not the same, their habitats are different. It is a very bad idea to transport species from one continent to another.
@@artus198 whats the difference...only few kilos?
@@yashpalchaudhary9752 BRuhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
African Cheetahs have a much diverse prey base that spans the whole African continent. Asiatic Cheetahs have a much smaller prey base than their African cousins. They prey only on small and medium-sized animals.
Cheetah can't compete with leopard and bears in india.
Bhaiyya prey kaha hai. No prey suitable. Back then smaller antelope were in plenty.
I think rajdeep always look after the people who are aginst the Modi government. Do you think that Modi knows about the wildlife. There must the wildlife expect who have advised about this plan to the Government.
No for the first time he is right , cant compare africa with india human habitation in kuno national park. So its very risky .
The same experts who adviced natebadhi; lockdown; bullet train
@@Behappy-wn8rk it's not that different,Africa is along equator too🙄it's same like belly problem when we travel other states,chill they r not snowleopards
@@minazulkhan8287 no experts who islamized India with wakf act
@@Butunmallick7851 beta modi ji tumhe dharm k naam pe hi uljha rakhenge ... I hope u earn well in life
The guy makes a very valid point about Asiatic lions, india has been putting the worlds population of Asiatic lions at risk and has yet to take any further steps to reduce the risk of loosing the lion population to distemper.
Thapar's objections don't make sense at all ☹️
It makes as a biodiversity expert , when we bring exotic animals they can be a danger to existing wildlife
@@stephenrane isn't the African cheetah a close relative of the Indian cheetah
@@jamesjc there are many species who are close relatives of many cats around the world . My objection is to why India wants a new wildlife conflict when already it has many wildlife issues to solve . We are not having proper scientist and neither can our govt pay good beside that our forest officers are not trained well . It has been for years that NGOs are doing capacity building projects to help forest officers gear up .they don't have proper weapons , no vehicles . It is always exciting to see something new but scientifically the cheetah may create exotic species interconnection adaptability problems related to behaviour change in existing wildlife .
@@stephenrane sure we can all have a set of priorities different from the one being implemented; but in this instance I do not see the cheetah as an exotic animal as there used to be cheetahs in India; whether they are going to re-adapt successfully remains to be seen
@@stephenrane Ha hamare paas scientist nahi hai, forest officers nahi hai. Tigers aur lions ko toh tune bada kiya hai dudh pila pila k. Aur tujhe wild life conservation k liye weapons kyun chahiye bey? Ye kiya chu+iya logic hai. Africa ka cheetah, African leopards, lions, hyenas, wild dogs k sath rahta hai jo India se size mein bada aur more aggressive rahta hai. India ka hyena dekah hai. Woh ghanta kuch nahi ukhad sakta.
Cheetahs did exist in India for Centuries before being extinct in 1947 due to incessant Hunting. If Cheetahs could have existed back then, why not now? Although with a smaller population
These type of people have the problem to criticize everything 😡
Nambia and Madhya Pradesh are climatically similar. Nambia is a subtropical country and the northern part of India is also subtropical, where kuno national park is located, cheetah will survive, just food and water should be fine.
@Environment Lover They're a subspecies of the same species, close enough to be the shadow of the Asiatic cheetah. The Iranian population is tiny and declining, Asiatic cheetah will likely be extinct in the next century unfortunately, so amials from another population absolutely make sense.
Cheetah were once common in and around Kuno and can thrive hunting deer, hares and other animals. There are some gazelle and antelop in Kuno too.
Wait and see. They'll do fine.
Before 1947 there were plenty of space. Much much more Forrest lands than now. Deforestation happened in large scale. Mountains were mined out. Before 1947 population was 30 crore and now Its 140 Crore .
Things has changed now .
Save Indian wildlife
U were correct Mr Thapar. We regret the loss of Cheetah's life
These guys (including the channel) should at least for a while PAUSE their "object to anything BJP does culture" and do something else to relax their constipation.
Meditate, Retrospect, Watch Nature (not your own nature)!!
Cultivate the "Thinking Culture".
Most Indian news media funded by western NGO and George Soros they're anti india anti govt anti hindu
👍
Mr thapar! Everytime we think that we know more than nature, nature proves us wrong! Relocations are the fundamental piece in the puzzle of evolution! Species will learn to survive and Co exist! Ur opposition seems to be more inspired from the fact that u have not been involved in this project!
It’s not about cheetahs. He’s just hateful
We support Valmik Sir.... Today on this date 28-04-2023...this comes as a very stunning fact....
Please tell what's wrong with sardesai?? He only those people for panelists those who those who hate modi no matter how, can't this so called cheetah expert see under modi regime in Gujarat lion popular increased .
Cheetahs are used to living with leopards in Africa,they be just fine thapar sir,but you are right if modi govt want to do something for wild life in India then they should do more to protect and preserve Indian Asiatic lions,tigers,snow leopards and black bucks etc.
its bad news for africa
Thapar's remarks are noteworthy. Government should be extra cautious when deciding on bringing exotic species to Indian mainland 🤔
Very fact said... As Madhypradesh govt. Asks center to find another place to relocate them as they r struggling...
Good perspective but I think this is a positive move. Still it's always wise to hear the other side
Having cheeta making comeback is a great idea.
If the same action is taken by a Cong govt he would heap praises as they are the custodians and saviours of animal kingdom.
Why didn't they understand the fact that two chittah and 70 leopard(enemies of chittah) are like playing with the life of chittah. Like seriously why media Is like modi modi modi why don't you understand the fact that this will gonna dangerous for for chittah.
May I please suggest that, all stray wild dogs fed by RWA animal lovers should be sent to this location as well.
And then the natural instinct of cheetah takes its own course.
Shut up!!! Your own origin indian species was lost, no ways to getting back this, what did that time government and naturalist in since1950 when India's last cheetah haunted by maharaja!!!
How does your rant that relate to this ????
He is absolutely right. I would hope they survive, but fear they will not. As the big cat expert says they will face dangers from many sources. How long can they be fed buffalo meat?
The cheetah also learned to hunt spotted deer . This barker knows nothing about the cheetah. Already 3 cheetah gave birth to 13 cubs now the cheetah population is 27. Like to see his reaction now
Rajdeep always find people like him
Mission lion,tiger is one of the success project bringing cheetah is good decision and i think it will make successful project and create new lessons for the world
I agree with his views, surely he had a point why it might not reach the expected results
Imagine somebody capturing all cats...and repeating RRR iconic scene...
थापा मैं आपके प्रश्न का उत्तर देता हूं।
भारत सरकार ने भारत की धरती से खत्म हो गया चीता बापस लेकर आए है , चीते पहले भी भारत में थे, जो ज्यादा शिकार की वजह से खत्म हो गए थे , आपने किया दूसरे स्टेट अफ्रीकन जिराफ लेकर आएंगे जेवर लेकर आएंगे । अफ्रीकन जिराफ और जेब्रा को भारत में जंगल में छोड़ा नहीं जा सकता । क्योंकि वह इंडिया में कभी होते ही नहीं थे ।
Agreed.
Valmik Thappar should know that leopards and cheetahs co exist in Africa along with lions, hyenas and wild dogs. In India cheetahs will also co exist with leopards, hyenas, wild dogs and tigers.
Cheetahs don't co-exist with tigers in Africa since Africa have no tigers. Cheetahs in India will suffer.
Africa is a continent and India is a country.
Cheetahs are slender yet fastest animals. Given the presence of other carnivores it's a tough competition to catch prey. Very unlikely to succeed. Nevertheless, the project can teach us about importing such animals .
@@pratik_mohanty555 first learn to read and understand English. I know tigers don't exist in Africa... Did I say cheetahs co exist with tigers in Africa..read my original comment again 10 times😂
@@prasunhalder7875 ok smarty geography professor...let's not say Africa...say Kenya, South Africa, Zimbabwe..
The rebuttal is from capable naturalist with greater knowledge Mr divybhanuji and Mahesji
Wild asiatic cheetah exist in the very same place palpur kuno
The western world love trophy hunting and it’s funny how people believe that’s actually good for wild life. I guess this guy here believes that too.
But translocation is bad. This would be a hit just like the save tigers projects.
Trophy hunting removes the vulnerable individuals in a population like the old and scared to bring in new individuals to mate and increase the diversity in the gene pool of that species so yes trophy hunting is good for some animal species. And the concern is obvious the wild is not like a zoo where man feeds every layer in the ecosystem to keep it sustained. The wild has its own structure introducing a new species will burden the other layers. You don't just take any organ and put in your body. Your body needs to accept it and to increase the chances doctors give you medication induce coma etc etc.. So he's right we should be concerned with investing on a project that may or may not go well, because we haven't done the prep work. Introduce more prey to balance it out or decrease threats so it has a fighting chance. Being critical about your governments desicion is your right so don't call out on people who think it's wiser to make libraries, schools and hospitals rather than statues all over the country.
Modi did wrong ! He should have released these cheetah into Rajdeep and Valmik house
Asiatic Cheetah got separated from African 5000 yera ago, where as lion 1lakh year
ago, so not that distinct subspecies traits in asiatic cheetahs
Actually african lion ko congress sarkar me mp up me introduce kiya tha woh ache rahe lekin tiger ne unko maar dala
Main Faunal Species of general tourist interest which are found in Kuno National Park are:
Spotted deer or Chital (Axis axis)
Sambar (Cervus unicolor)
Barking deer or Indian Muntjac (Muntiacus muntjak)
Chousingha or Four-horned antilope (Tetracerus quadricornis)
Nilgai or Blue bull (Boselaphus tragocamelus)
Indian Gazelle or Chinkara (Gazella gazella)
Black buck (Antilope cervicapra)
Gaur or Indian Bison (Bos gaurus)
Leopard (Panthera pardus)
Wild dog or Dhole (Cuonal pinus)
Striped Hyaena (Hyaena hyaena)
Indian Wolf (Canis lupus)
Jackal (Canis aureus)
Wild boar (Sus scrofa)
Sloth bear (Melursus ursinus)
Indian fox (Vulpes bengalensis)
Jungle cat (Felius chaus)
Desert cat (Felin sylvestris)
Common palm civet (Paradoxurus hermaphroditus)
Small Indian civet (Viverricula indica)
Grey mongoose (Herpestes edwardsii)
Small indian mongoose (Herpestes javanicus)
Ruddy mongoose (Herpestes smithii)
Indian hare (Lepus nigricollis)
Indian porcupine (Hystrix indica)
Indian gerbil (Tatera indica)
Indian tree shrew (Tupaia belangeri)
Hanuman langur/Common langur (Presbytis entellus)
Rhesus monkey (Macaque mulata)
There are enough species of animals for cheetah. He is being stupid here. He is saying their are leopard and wild dogs etc. In Africa where they are, there are always leopard and cheetah together. Government is not putting cheetah into national park to pet them. They will fight for survival against predators.
All reputed peoples who knows what life is in kuno national park. What kind of wildlife expert he is. He thinks he is intelligent than all others.
But this is great symbolic step for our country ,and it will help to advertise and save more wild life and Our eco system. We have to wait and watch...
Happy Happy Happy birthday CHEETAHS... may a note of your inauguration and stay..
MODI JI SAID AFTER COMMING FORM TOILET WASH YOUR HAND WITH SOAP RAJDEEP & VALMIC THAPER SAID NO NO WE SHALL CLEAN OUR HAND WITH OUR TOUNGH THAT'S FACT 😆😁😄😃😀😅
You should agree you are an andhbhakta, the man said facts and you totally missed everything
Absolutely agree with Valmiki sir!
A month ago he said that cheetahs will not survive in India,now he is saying that indigenous species will not survive!First he convince himself who actually will not survive? indigenous species,the cheetahs or him.
I totally agree with him. What he suggested in the last segment is absolutely sensible. We need to conserve what we already have here. We need to protect our forests first
Main Faunal Species of general tourist interest which are found in Kuno National Park are:
Spotted deer or Chital (Axis axis)
Sambar (Cervus unicolor)
Barking deer or Indian Muntjac (Muntiacus muntjak)
Chousingha or Four-horned antilope (Tetracerus quadricornis)
Nilgai or Blue bull (Boselaphus tragocamelus)
Indian Gazelle or Chinkara (Gazella gazella)
Black buck (Antilope cervicapra)
Gaur or Indian Bison (Bos gaurus)
Leopard (Panthera pardus)
Wild dog or Dhole (Cuonal pinus)
Striped Hyaena (Hyaena hyaena)
Indian Wolf (Canis lupus)
Jackal (Canis aureus)
Wild boar (Sus scrofa)
Sloth bear (Melursus ursinus)
Indian fox (Vulpes bengalensis)
Jungle cat (Felius chaus)
Desert cat (Felin sylvestris)
Common palm civet (Paradoxurus hermaphroditus)
Small Indian civet (Viverricula indica)
Grey mongoose (Herpestes edwardsii)
Small indian mongoose (Herpestes javanicus)
Ruddy mongoose (Herpestes smithii)
Indian hare (Lepus nigricollis)
Indian porcupine (Hystrix indica)
Indian gerbil (Tatera indica)
Indian tree shrew (Tupaia belangeri)
Hanuman langur/Common langur (Presbytis entellus)
Rhesus monkey (Macaque mulata)
I wish India good luck
Hope they will survive
bad news for africa
No need fir wild animals. We have plenty of wild animals living snd thriving in all major cities.
Aa gaya aandolanjeevi
Medha Patkar's male version😂
P.S......and under this tree have a cup of tea or coffee with A1 milk...Tea,coffee, A1 milk, etc nothing is exotic! Rajdeep ji, is a baat or aaj sham 'French wine' ,"Jay ho !! "
But in Serengeti, cheetah lives with leopard and lion, why not in Kuno
Valmiki Thapar is correct namaste
Time will tell.
Where are the experts who support the decision and can provide logic in favour ? A discussion or debate is fully incomplete in absence of both pro and anti logic.
without trying no one succeeds....he is simply saying not to try....can see everything negative....lets be positive and pray for the new species to survive
Valmik Thapar son of a Romesh Thapar (1922-1987) was an Indian journalist and political commentator Affiliated with the CPI(M), Explains it all.
Mr. Thapar is absolutely correct.
There is substance in the Argument.
It's not easy to make entirely new environment set up for cheetah
@Mr. ENERGY that was 70 years before & that gap is filled and now there is entirely different environment, cheetahs number is not vulnerable as compared to our lions
And those exotic species can carry diseases that unknown to indian sub continent .
have any idea about how many million years ago pangia existed, once indian sub continent is also attached to Australia
@Mr. ENERGYIAM not criticising modi ji, this is not a new plan we have this plan years ago ,while Indira ghadhi is prime minister
IAM asking how african cheetas be a better option than our lions ,while gir forest is running at it's maximum capacity
Let's hope for good,India has always excelled in wildlife conservation👍
The expert's concerns are understandable and he has made some moot points to consider. Alas, now that the project is going ahead, only time will tell whether it'll be a success or not. Best wishes but is such a huge investment for this project justifiable?
Valmik's concerns are illogical..He is just raising because bcoz he wants to raise concern...Life will thrive in nature...Not sure why he calls himself conservationist as he is saying exact opposite to what a conservationist should say
Modi Hindutva Logic.
I can almost imagine them roaming the ancient ruins of ranthambore well coexisting with there cousins the tigers .
I think that introduction of CHEETAH in Bharat will be successful.
CHEETAHS existed in India about 70 years ago.
It is a great path breaking initiative by The Government of India.
I disagree with Valmiki Thapar.
If Cheetahs can survive in Africa alongside Lions , Leopards , Hyenas, Crocodiles , Hippopotamus, Rhinoceros, Elephants and African Buffalos then they can also survive in Madhya Pradesh in a Jungle where there are no Tigers. Even most of the Leopards have been removed from the area. This means that CHEETAHS are the Apex Predator in that area in Madhya Pradesh.
There is abundant prey in this area.
CATS have the inherent ability to adapt into different Environments and ecosystems.
This is main reason that CATS are found in very diverse landscapes across the World.
Thapar should know atleast someone tried and trying
There is also lepords also present in Africa
I agree with Valmik Thapar.
If other states orders other animals from Africa then what is the problem ? Just oppose, oppose and oppose
The Thapar Clan will oppose anything Modi does Dont take anything this clan says seriously
You were very right, all cheetahs survived no one died
Who said that 10 died but still 4 cheetahs gave birth and now 27 cheetahs are in kuno
Why disturb the flora and fauna of India unnecessarily...
Cheetahs existed in India before. They are being restored.
Any way related to that Dyen Romilla Thapar😁
Mr. Thapar let's try first. It is only 8 cheetah. We live in state where no one think for an experiment. Fear of success or failure is more dominants. Yes you must add to the project so the whatever gaps are there, must be supported.
I agree with Balmik
Its True. Our wildlife cycle has adjusted without cheetah right.
No, we need cheeta back. It's the law of nature.
@@sinatra7407 we needed in 1952, not now.. Actually nature always self adjustng right. It something goes away, it replace it with some alternative.
Now we introduced and nature has to rearrange again.
I agree, this move by Modi is pretty crazy
Kuch hota nhi hai aur koi na koi khada ho jata hai Negative bolne ke liye 🙄🙄
The cheetahs overall will be just fine because there also the most alert and the most swiftest of the big cats
All forest officers will be on full 24/7 alert!!!
Rajdeep has said, in central vista, Rajpath ( karthavya path ) central government cut off 400 tress and caused severe damage
Plz welcome cheetah 🌹
All seem to favour indigenous animals/wildlife and forget to show the same concern for indigenous clans, their culture and religious beliefs
Commissions are behind the reason
India goverment try to bring cheetah from Iran..this is real factor
Iran has left with only 12 cheetah.. they won't give these to us. their had been effort in the past but all goes in vain.
@@devanshunegi14 they want indian lion..but his demand rufuse govenment..how they give to india??
Because Modi loves Headlines
the dogs bark, but the caravan goes on
The only person who makes sense is Valmik Thapar, who is a wild life conservationist, why don't politicians talk to the right people.
Right people lol😂
All wild should be rehabilitate.
Some people make living out of opposing everything..
On behalf of Cheetah, we can hand over Sardesai....to Namibia 😎
All logic of a Govt just to show how much money power they have time the rest of the world, whereas the interior parts of India is suffering fir one square of a meal, Shame on the ruling party the BJP, very soon we are going to suffer in the hands of the economy crisis, we are not able to buy vegetables for a week in Bangalore, mumbai, Chennai all the vegetables are rs 80 to rs 100 per kg, tomotoes are rotten this season in Bangalore, Shame on this government
Ya just leave india
You are a real uneducated person.. India ki gdp iis pichle quater 13.5% rhi h.. Highest remittance india ka h all over the world, most Digitalize economy h, Desh me FDI kayi guna badh gya h,, Defence export horha h ab,, Make in India k baad india me startups kyi guna badh gye hai.. Corona or russia war se bhi India pr kuch jyada farak nhi pda.. This is a real futuristic government.. Jb gyan nhi hota h to pela mt kro..Tu Bangluru ka h?? Bangluru ko pure asia pacific me number 2 startup hub bna diya h Modi gov ne smjee... negative keeda
@@Nik-th8fk One uneducated and some educated cannot build a A growth for a country, many pms of other countries are educated, even Indian former pms were educated, Our many parts of our country are still struggling to one square of meal, Ap, Tamilnadu, Maharashtra, Up, Bihar , covid times none of the corporaters of a elected party came and helped the people, So you educate yourself first and then you educate others
@@gregoryantony7491 one square of meal.. 😂 Who are they..?? I don't know..If a person is willing to work, he will earn 8k-10k easily in a month.. But fact ye h ki sb bhikhmange bne fir rhe hai.. Hmare gau se sb gujrat Maharastra even abroad hotels me kaam krrhe hai.. Smjh nhi aata bhookh se mar kon rha h.. Ye sb bkwas h..
Dusri baat CSR ka naam suna h?? just go & read..free vaccine k baad bhi rona dhona..
Tisri baat Don't try to educate me.. I cleared Sbi po last year.. and also cleared uk pcs pre exam in first attempt & now preparing for mains exam..
& Growth to dikh rhi h.. Bata to diya upar gdhe..gnwar k gnwar rhoge tum
@@Nik-th8fk AAj koi bhi bhukha mar jaega to bc kah dena
How about Indian fox
Start hogaya aar kab tak aise oppose ker tae rahoge
Wahi toh .yeh ❤️day kuch karte nhi aur koi kuch kare toh Inka randirona shuru
Rajdeep only objects brings people who object. No appreciation for the effort. If Thapar was involved in this mission; he would have spoken for the Mission. Let’s move ahead. Let efforts be made.
Valmik is absolutely right. He is thinking from biodiversity perspective. Every organism has had a symbiotic nature with its environment. This action of the government is just like introducing Siberian tiger, which is a native of taiga region into the sundarban jungle which is native to the Royal Bengal tiger. Nature does not work like that. Cheetahs are natives of grassland and india is full of bogs and marshes. We have snow leopards, vultures,chiru, pashmin goats, etc that are going extinct. These animals are indegenious species. We should make an effort to protect them not bring exotic animal for another masterstroke fanfare. If we take a little effort, our odds of successes are more. I felt that the argument made was quite poignant. However, the questions asked by the anchor was not hard-hitting enough. If a little pre-study about biodiversity had been done by the news channel, we would have had a great educational talk. But alas, these days media serves the purpose of entertaining rather that educating and dissemenating information.
It's not about who is wrong who is right. It's about money. Who gives it who rcvd it. Then bark against who didn't give you money.
Make sense, we do not want to go unnatural