Ricky Figueroa the two best guns 💪 in the gang are micah and Arthur, and dutch saw Arthur was no longer well enough to live so he had no choice dutch is not a gunner he is a talker if marston was there on the cliff ditch would have shot micah and escaped with john
Arthur Would Tear Micah Apart If he was in chapters 1-6 Easily Micah had no chance against him in those chapters, but Micah couldn’t have EVEN won that fight yes he had the advantage but since Dutch hit his head during the failed mail station robbery trolley ride He didn’t realize who his most loyal man was, and like Dutch Always said ‘Loyalty Is Everything’ and Arthur knew but THEN after Hosea Died Dutch just lost his mind, and Micah played him good, and made him win although Arthur won in all of our hearts even his, because he KNEW john would avenge him because like Arthur Says Their Brothers
Van Morgan not really People like you think they’re smart for recognizing patterns or something but you ain’t shit He was an absolute mad man who would fight Arthur any ways
Arthur got his TB from a farmer you collect a debt from during a Strauss mission, Mr. Downes. And no Micah didn’t get TB. Either way, he got killed by Dutch and John in the epilouge later on. I was just saying that it would have been more satisfying for me if he would’ve actually got TB from Arthur. And died that way.
I think he did. It takes some time to take effect. It might not have been much of the disease. It probabilities lies dormant. It probably started to affect him a few days before you kill him.
Once I saw Lenny die I started to hate this game kind of I'm pretty sure he was one of the only black characters that you'll see in the game that won't hate you
16:26 I just love this scene. I love the sudden change in Colm's facial expression, changing from a smug or bored one, to an actually stressed and pressured one, as he realizes that he will soon die now that his boys are held by sadie and dutch. Also, I adore how Arthur waves at him.
So many scenes I enjoy watching but this is just pure gold. Like you said it’s the sudden change of expected soon realizing how fucked he is and is finally facing death.
XKillO8X Arthur was not purposefully letting hosea die is my point. John could’ve done it but didn’t on purpose and Arthur didn’t because the plot didn’t call for it.
@@leavethischannelisdeadleav3280 when John ask dutch at the cabin,he says "same as you I suppose",he also there to killed Micah,he realized he should have saved Arthur
The saddest part about Hosea's death is Dutch mentions that he doesn't really want to rob the Saint Denis bank. He's nervous and doesn't want anyone else to die. Hosea is actually the one who ultimately convinces him that it can be done. And that as long as they execute *the plan* properly, then everything will work out. Their execution was flawless, but Hosea and Lenny still die. This is Dutch's true breaking point. At this point, he can't trust anyones word but his own.
@William Anderson - true; I just feel like Hosea had that "snake oil trader" kind of charisma, whereas Dutch had the kind of charisma that rallies people together, and lets him act as a leader.
Lenny and Sean really surprised me the most. They just... happend out of nowhere and it really lays testimate to the superb writing of this game that there deaths are so grittily realistic and unsatisfying.
Sean was my favorite character I love the snarky funny guys who come off as douche but are actually kind and just want a simple life and spent an hour and a half processing his death by just riding around the world looking at landmarks and stuff, so unexpected
@@skittles970 Hosea was the wisdom and reason for Dutch. He held things together, and they worked together from the very start. The gang started from Dutch and Hosea, and Arthur. Once Hosea died, Dutch was gone. But as John said he always had this side to him but it was finally revealed.
The minute Colm saw his escape plan foiled, with Arthur having taken out the sniper and with Sadie and Dutch holding his two men in the crowd hostage, that is where the scene gets interesting. I like how this confident and evil criminals suddenly gets scared as he knows he’s about to die and there’s no way out for him this time.
Everyone fears death. Death is the greatest uncertainty in human history. Here's to Colm, a bastard who is in damnation and is getting to lick the floors of hell with his tongue for his crimes.
Anyone else felt emotional after Sean’s death. That wagon scene when you are riding back from the braithwathes, and he is talking about starting a new life, he just wanted to escape all this carnage. He just couldn’t be as lucky as John.
I'm going to meme you You know how Arthur has a journal, well if you look through it you’ll see that he drew Sean’s body after you do the mission where Sean dies
This is the realest game we've gotten in a while, what did Jack say in Mass Effect? "A happy ending is just a story that isn't finished yet" The fact that these characters are so mortal is exactly what makes them so compelling.
John Witling wdym? That’s a damn good quote. I was going to say the epilogue is actually VERY happy. Almost campy. But the credits hint at the first game, and johns eventual death. It was a happy ending, but only because his story isn’t over yet.
RDR2 Dutch to John: It's either him or us. The way I see it It might as well be him. RDR1 John to Javier: It's either you or me. The way I see it it might as well be you. I just realized that little detail.
Also, as you may already know, the speech that Dutch makes when he and Arthur are surrounded by the army and have to jump off a cliff into the river mirrors the speech he makes when he jumps to his death in RDR1. "You can't fight change, you can't fight gravity"
i thought they did so well portraying how panicked and afraid he was to be hanged. he starts hyperventilating and you can tell in his eyes he's scared. i loVED IT
During most of the character's deaths I wasn't sad or something, I was more angry than anything, It was like a friend dying, and somehow by my fault, I just wanted to shoot due to vengance. Arthur's one make me cry like a little boah...
Agent Ross and Milton are sad characters since they are the incarnation of this quote "whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster" from Nietzsche. They are so obsessed to capture outlaws that they became outlaws, taking a man's wife and sons then shoot him like a dog. Quite Ironic .
It's fairly ironic, in Ross's quest to capture and kill the gang he ends up being the catalyst that drives Jack to kill him in the end. In a bid to get rid of the outlaws all he did was create more.
@@ddhouston3380 I won't complain about it. The amount of people that died in 1 and 2 was enough. Arthur, Hosea, John, Dutch, Javier and the rest. And yes I was almost emotionally devastated by the amount of deaths.
There was a period of time where I was playing through the game as fast as I could after Hosea and Lenny died and Arthur was diagnosed with TB, because the game was depressing me that much. Everything from Guarma until the Epilogue is a blur for me...
William Anderson no he didn’t see what happened he only saw everyone pointing guns at Arthur and John so he probably guessed that they were betraying the gang and picked the gang over them.
William Anderson honestly I think he Loved Dutch more then he did Arthur. If you learn how he was brought into the gang then then it makes a lot of sense why he would choose Dutch over Arthur and John
Everybody who lived past red dead 2: Abigail John Jack Charles Javier Bill Dutch Trelawny (not positive, but didn't see him die) Mary-Beth Karen(I think, never saw her die) Mr. Pearson Rev. Swanson(read bout him in newspaper) Sadie Adler Tilly Lumbago
I all I ask from R* Is a revamp of gta 5's story, get a bit more interpersonal with the characters and make a villian I give a shit about rather than making me wanna kill them literally only because they're pointless nothing characters
@@WhoopEaterz both Arthur's and Hoseas death made Dutch truly snap. Arthur was like a son to Dutch same with John Hosea was more like a brother to Dutch.
@@-sanju- sometimes your children do stupid shit, it's been said that both Arthur and John grew up together in Dutchs care, John grew and saw what life outside of the outlaw lifestyle was like and seeked his escape with his family, Arthur wasn't that lucky because the only love he had rejected him for his lifestyle, Arthur grew to trust Dutch with little doubt up until he was diagnosed and reflected on everything they ever did. Dutch saw his grip on John was loose after all these years so he decided John could find his own way with his own decisions when he needs to.
@@-sanju- Yes he did, John was like a son to him, so much so that at one point Arthur says to John (arguing over who is Dutch's favorite), "I was a prize pony too once, now I'm a work horse." It's just that Dutch doesn't have as a tight a grip on John as he does on Arthur, partially because of Abigail & Jack and partially because John is generally portrayed as more intelligent than average for his time.
timestamps: 1:22 Sean’s Death 4:18 Kieran’s Death 7:13 Bronte’s Death 9:17 Hosea’s Death 9:38 Lenny’s Death 10:53 Levi’s Death 12:35 Molly’s Death 15:42 Cornwall’s Death 17:15 Colm O’Driscoll’s Death 18:57 Milton’s Death 25:43 Arthur’s Death 28:30 rancher’s Death 32:19 Cleet’s Death 37:10 Micah’s Death (Best death in the game)
I swear to god Charles has got to be the most underrated character in the game. Edit:Ok I wasn’t aware that people actually talked a lot about him so yeah I guess he is not underrated
Its just to make you hurt inside and then give you a character who dies like everyone else. You are nothing special next to everyone else. Your all gunslingers and good ones.
@@Chonksta The Pinkertons find Micah's body, so they try and find who killed him. Eventually it leads them to John. It shows it happen during the credits
Arthur saying "I gave you all I had. I did" to Dutch, damn, it hit my soul real hard. I didn't noticed I was crying during this part. Dutch choosing that rat Micah over Arthur, the boy he raised and is with him for more than 20 yrs, it's a damn cold betrayal. This is absolutely a masterpiece.
Dutch realized it was too late and he had fukd up real bad...after that i belive he got real depressed and mentally very ill alltough he had been that for a while after hosea's death
Red dead 3 should be about charles tbh...his time before the van der linde gang, his time with them and what he could do after would make for a pretty amazing story.
My favorite part is that throughout the game, the gang slowly starts to go from a family who love one another to a band of disoriented associates who can’t trust one another. It’s amazing story telling.
My favorite characters and ones that shouldn’t have died 1. ARTHUR OF COURSE he was a good man and Strauss was why he died 2.Sean he was still young and killed too suddenly 3. Hosea he was a very respectable character and didn’t deserve to be an example 4. Lenny man he was so cool and I liked doing missions with him (Edit)5. Dutch he had a plan and also was determined but although he dies in rdr1 I liked how he never gave up but was kind of mad that he turned on Arthur because he was like a father to him
Sean’s death for me was fucking hard no main characters had died yet so I wasn’t used to seeing anyone of them die and he was acc one of my favourites. It caught me so off guard
Sean: Would take Arthur and Johns side Kieran: Would taken Arthur and Johns side Lenny: Would have taken Arthur and Johns side Hosea: Would Have stopped it in the first place.
Bugeye0704 I don’t know if you tards are being serious or not lol , if you are being serious he barred the scene because it’s too gruesome for TH-cam and will probably make him get demonetised
I swear to god when lenny died I shot both of the guys who kill him with dead eye before they could fire, turns out they are invulnerable for a second or two untill lenny dies. That made the whold thing just super frustrating for me
Not as satysfying as killing Ross in RDR. Seriously, Micah's death was so... Anticlimatic because of how he pretend that nothing happened and fell on the ground.
“ When I die, face me to the west so I can watch the sunset and think about all the good times we had together,” Makes me cry everytime, considering everytime Hosea had to bury someone, he faced them to the West. Charles did so for Arthur and Susan. I want so for myself.
Most famous last words “Now it don’t feel right, I coulda to-“ We can get across here.” “Our time has passed John” Least famous last words You shot me, you shot me pretty good.
I've never shed a tear for any character in a game but for Mr. Morgan... Man... I cried..... That part where he thanked his dying horse... Ugh. Right in the heart.... And Marston, pleading with Dutch, his "father", then having Dutch walk away....Heart breaking....
As hard as Arthur’s death hit me (I love this character) I really was hurt over Hoseas death. Such a wise mind and a father figure to both Arthur and Dutch. Just shows you how great these characters are and how much they get you invested into what they’re doing
That’s Leopold Strauss’s fault he got arthur to take that debt collector job and get money from Thomas downes then he coughed in Arthur’s face that caused him to get Tuberculosis
Lennys death could’ve been so easily avoided. I was aiming at the guys head using dead eye but it wouldn’t let me shoot him for so long it pissed me off
My heart literally dropped when Sean and Lenny died. They were so sudden and out of no where. This game really messed me up a bit with how things in life doesn't go as u think. Nothing lasts forever. I love the message and plot of this game.
![Red Dead Redemption 2 & 1 - All Gang Members' Deaths (from Davey to Abigail) [PC, 4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5gjVpYQ9DWQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Dead Redemption 2 & 1 - All Gang Members' Deaths (from Davey to Abigail) [PC, 4K]](/img/tr.png)
the fact that Dutch chose Micah over Arthur is the most frustrating part of this game
Ricky Figueroa the two best guns 💪 in the gang are micah and Arthur, and dutch saw Arthur was no longer well enough to live so he had no choice dutch is not a gunner he is a talker if marston was there on the cliff ditch would have shot micah and escaped with john
Agreed. Dutch really lost his mind, betraying his own son like that.
Patrick star Lenny was good too
He seemed to believe Arthur at the end in my ending because he didnt go with Micah
P A I N But then years later he was back with Micah until he and Marston shot Micah
I teared up at Lennys death
I will always remember that one night in valentine...
Moses G. LeNnY!! WhErE ArE YoU
Same
LENNY MY BOAH
@@KxlsoFR *YNNEL* !
I found u leNnY
Micah only ever picked a fight with Arthur when he was about to die of TB. He was too much of a coward to fight a healthy Arthur.
Even like this, Arthur still the winner if Dutch didn't appear when he was about to kill Micah with that revolver
But, if Micah had a fight against the healthy Arthur, there is no doubt that Arthur would have him on the ground in seconds.
Arthur Would Tear Micah Apart If he was in chapters 1-6 Easily Micah had no chance against him in those chapters, but Micah couldn’t have EVEN won that fight yes he had the advantage but since Dutch hit his head during the failed mail station robbery trolley ride He didn’t realize who his most loyal man was, and like Dutch Always said ‘Loyalty Is Everything’ and Arthur knew but THEN after Hosea Died Dutch just lost his mind, and Micah played him good, and made him win although Arthur won in all of our hearts even his, because he KNEW john would avenge him because like Arthur Says Their Brothers
Van Morgan not really
People like you think they’re smart for recognizing patterns or something but you ain’t shit
He was an absolute mad man who would fight Arthur any ways
Ain't no way a rat could beat a healthy Arthur. He could barely beat a dying Arthur.
When you see Micah:
You have entered legendary Rat territory
Just imagine all the animal fat you’d get from skinning that rat.
Hey there mister. Looks like we're the same person
Come here BOAH
Yet you cant skin it because its rotten
Will you stop calling him a rat? He’s a good friend. He’s always there for me
RDR1: I don’t want to play as jack I want to play as John...
RDR2: I don’t want to play as John I want to play as Arthur...
Stolen
Rdr 3 you won't wanna play as arthur
@@thatcheappodcast8153 impossible
Nice copy
Lumbago I was thinking the same when playing as John in RDR2 boah was I wrong
God, Lenny. Didn't even get a cutscene death like Sean. There's something about that that makes it more real.
KeiosKod i swear they always kill the chillest characters Lenny Hosea and Arthur they were all chill
It's raw and just goes past so quickly. I think it really shows how callous death can be, especially in these types of scenarios.
What really sucks is he can easily be saved but the game doesnt let u
@KeiosKod - Not going to lie, I thought I did something wrong at first. xD
@@Ben-pi6hc alot of the people could've been saved
I would’ve been satisfied had Arthur spread his tuberculosis to Micah during their fight.
Sly Deceiver you kill Micah in the last mission
Bradybravo7 bro what😂 TB is totally spread the coughing my friend
Bradybravo7 do you know how Arthur got it? By getting coughed on, you better pay more attention.
Arthur got his TB from a farmer you collect a debt from during a Strauss mission, Mr. Downes. And no Micah didn’t get TB. Either way, he got killed by Dutch and John in the epilouge later on. I was just saying that it would have been more satisfying for me if he would’ve actually got TB from Arthur. And died that way.
I think he did. It takes some time to take effect. It might not have been much of the disease. It probabilities lies dormant. It probably started to affect him a few days before you kill him.
I wish we never broke Micah out of that prison in Strawberry.
Jail*
Yeah
i wish we didn't have to break him out
ikr he was a fed informant
@@mayarussell like a choice
I swear when I first saw kieren die he was holding his own head...
Socks-with-sandals man it was a glitch
Right? I remember being extra shocked by his lifeless black eyes
Yeah me too, did they censor that in other countries or something?
Nick Martin idk, just asking 😔
Socks-with-sandals man that was part of the cutscene, they cut his head off and blew his eyes
Micah killing Mrs.Grimshaw
Dutch:sO WhO iS bEtRaYiNg mE
Micah
God she was thicc
@@mo-ab7315 lol
I mean she still cared for the group.
Dont worry dutch has a plan
I Loved Hosea so much that I couldn't believe what I was seeing
Hosea was like a Grandpa to Arthur
He had so kind face
I cried. I had to pause the game. I couldn’t focus on that damn mission after. I failed repeatedly because my eyes were so teared up. f r i c k
Now as I finished game I am like who is Hosea I want Arthur back😭
George X Hosea was a father to Arthur, but also hilarious as SHIT, but also the ONLY ONE IN THE GANG THAT HAD SOME GODDAMN COMMON SENSE.
( TIMESTAMPS FOR DEATHS )
0:00 - Sean MacGuire
2:48 - Kieran Duffy
5:50 - Angelo Bronte
8:32 - Hosea Matthews
9:34 - Lenny Summers
10:03 - Levi Simon
11:04 - Molly O'Shea
13:06 - Leviticus Cornwall
15:50 - Colm O'Driscoll
17:40 - Andrew Milton
19:15 - Arthur Morgan
26:38 - Laramie Leader
28:40 - Cleet
32:33 - Micah Bell
And Arthur's horse
And Miss Grimshaws
**SPAMS ON MICAH'S DEATH TIMESTAMP**
You know how fast I clicked on the rat
@Commando ! and Levi
When Arthur screams “NO LENNY,” that really hits the feels.
Prees f tow pae respect
@@terriblebadedits3814 press m1 to avenge lenny
They loved each other
AS FRIENDS
Once I saw Lenny die I started to hate this game kind of I'm pretty sure he was one of the only black characters that you'll see in the game that won't hate you
YNNEL?
Arthur walks to heaven:
HaHa Found Ya Lenny
i wish they would make that a cutscene
I reed it with Arthur’s voice oh no
@@cen3684 i did too
Arthur wasn't religious
@@darukan we know.
16:26
I just love this scene.
I love the sudden change in Colm's facial expression, changing from a smug or bored one, to an actually stressed and pressured one, as he realizes that he will soon die now that his boys are held by sadie and dutch.
Also, I adore how Arthur waves at him.
So many scenes I enjoy watching but this is just pure gold. Like you said it’s the sudden change of expected soon realizing how fucked he is and is finally facing death.
ITS FUNNY WHEN ARTHUR WAVES AT HIM ITS THE FUNNY PART 😂😂💖
Same it's awesome
(in the distance) HELLOO BOAHH
Lol
Realistically Arthur could’ve used his dead eye on agent Milton, agent Ross, and the rest of the Pinkertons to save hosea
XKillO8X John died on purpose to save his family
XKillO8X Arthur was not purposefully letting hosea die is my point. John could’ve done it but didn’t on purpose and Arthur didn’t because the plot didn’t call for it.
Realistically dead eye doesn't exist
@Killan yeah but the orginal commenter said realistically
@@glossyplane542 yeah, but he still tried to shoot them with Dead eye. But there were too many of them...
Kieran: So no head?
At least he got head from Mary beth
gastricchair983 kieran bangs mary beth the night of jack’s return party that’s headcanon
Toes that way he at least gets a happy ending, if you know what i mean
It feels really creepy, the music, the body pose. It looks like headless horseman.
Toes blood effects are off
The fact that Dutch raised Arthur but betrayed him is the only worst part
Arthur should’ve left with Mary
Dutch you teamed up with Micah but you shot micah and betrayed Arthur and Dutch you are a rat with Micah burn in hell
Dutch Van Der Linde f u dutch , f u ..
Was the plan Tahiti and mangos by any chance
@@leavethischannelisdeadleav3280 when John ask dutch at the cabin,he says "same as you I suppose",he also there to killed Micah,he realized he should have saved Arthur
The saddest part about Hosea's death is Dutch mentions that he doesn't really want to rob the Saint Denis bank.
He's nervous and doesn't want anyone else to die. Hosea is actually the one who ultimately convinces him that it can be done.
And that as long as they execute *the plan* properly, then everything will work out.
Their execution was flawless, but Hosea and Lenny still die. This is Dutch's true breaking point.
At this point, he can't trust anyones word but his own.
@@lavish263team5 - he wrong in underestimating the Grays and Braithwaites in Ch. 3.
Hosea should have been the leader of the gang not dutch
@@bigvs3495 - he had a better head on his shoulders, that's for sure. But Dutch had the charisma.
@William Anderson - true; I just feel like Hosea had that "snake oil trader" kind of charisma, whereas Dutch had the kind of charisma that rallies people together, and lets him act as a leader.
The plan went downhill because of Micah who gave the Pinkertons all the info
Lenny and Sean really surprised me the most. They just... happend out of nowhere and it really lays testimate to the superb writing of this game that there deaths are so grittily realistic and unsatisfying.
lenny was one of my favorites and when he died it was a gut punch.
Sean was my favorite character I love the snarky funny guys who come off as douche but are actually kind and just want a simple life and spent an hour and a half processing his death by just riding around the world looking at landmarks and stuff, so unexpected
@@willhuey4891 I always loved lenny. I treasure every game of five finger filet.
Kieran is really out of nowhere too. And his dead really traumatized me lol.
And Kieran they weren’t even 25 just kids
Once Hosea died Dutch snapped.
nah it started when he got hit in the head earlier. From that point on you can see him progressively get worse
@@skittles970 He got a concussion, but that's not what made him go crazy.
Exactly
@@skittles970 Hosea was the wisdom and reason for Dutch. He held things together, and they worked together from the very start. The gang started from Dutch and Hosea, and Arthur. Once Hosea died, Dutch was gone. But as John said he always had this side to him but it was finally revealed.
@@TRxh98 Yeah he totally snapped once all that happened but I noticed it started with the concussion
The minute Colm saw his escape plan foiled, with Arthur having taken out the sniper and with Sadie and Dutch holding his two men in the crowd hostage, that is where the scene gets interesting. I like how this confident and evil criminals suddenly gets scared as he knows he’s about to die and there’s no way out for him this time.
Colm's facial expressions were spot on! You could see exactly what was going though his mind. Arthurs wave topped it off! Haha
Everyone fears death. Death is the greatest uncertainty in human history. Here's to Colm, a bastard who is in damnation and is getting to lick the floors of hell with his tongue for his crimes.
Stefanie Vickers that shit made me laugh so hard
i Roberto
I doubt that cloth tugging back on his mouth would let him do that.
Lawless Dandy oh well R.I.P my eye sight
Anyone else felt emotional after Sean’s death. That wagon scene when you are riding back from the braithwathes, and he is talking about starting a new life, he just wanted to escape all this carnage. He just couldn’t be as lucky as John.
bro i finally found closure and now u gotta say that 😔
@@thickhubb4190 sorry bro lol
John didn’t get lucky his family did :(
@@legodragon537 He at least got to experience a small part of life after being on the run. Sean didn't get anything.
Hristos Paraskevas true :(
Seans death like fully gave me a dropping feeling in my stomach when he just unexpectedly got his brains blown out just out of the blue
That's what made me realize that no one was safe at that point
I actually yelled "NO SEAN!!!" out loud when it happened. Same with Lenny.
He was one of my favorites I was so sad when that happened
You forgot:
- Micah killing Miss Grimshaw
- Strauss was captured and killed by the law.
- Eagle Flies shot and killed in a factory
i don't think we ever saw strauss' death, just charles mentioning it. i could be wrong however
Rhys Newlands // You’re right, but the scene of Arthur throwing him out and then the clip of Charles would’ve made it perfect.
But Strauss never talked
They also forgot Catherine Braithwaite and Leigh Gray too
what about davey at the beginning of the game
Ever since Arthurs first subtle cough i knew it meant something
I got that feeling too
I thought it was just because the weather
Same! Not only that but you can see his subtle change in appearance as the game goes on...
and then it didn't go away smh I was praying it was pneumonia because at least he'd have a chance
@@zachabsher5528 Well a pneumonia in 1899 will still kills him I think...
Micah: *Rats out the gang*
Auther: *stays loyal*
Dutch: NoW wHo iS BeTraYiNg mE hERE?
*HmMmM I WoNdEr WhO iT iS*
Micah: *Shoots Ms.Grimshaw*
Dutch: WhO's BEtRAyINg mE
Dutch: I have a plan
Gerardo Torres who’s Micah and Dutch I know Arthur
@@DMVGREY you saw micah kill ms grimshaw right in front of you
That moment when you realize Arthur drew Sean’s body in his book
I'm going to meme you
You know how Arthur has a journal, well if you look through it you’ll see that he drew Sean’s body after you do the mission where Sean dies
@@limbino868 3 years late but why are you talking to yourself?
@@moderatelydumb the guy I was replaying to delete his comment
My Fave Characters
1.Arthur
2Charles
3.Sean
My least fave characters
1.Micah
2.Micah
3.Micah
4.Micah
5.Micah
But... What about hosea?
I'd say Hosea would be #3, John is #4 for me, then Sean.
@@sonofjack6286 I'd say first is Arthur then is Hosea and third are Sean/Charles
It’s the real Bean for least favorite character what about Dutch
Lenny?
This game is so depressing man
This is the realest game we've gotten in a while, what did Jack say in Mass Effect? "A happy ending is just a story that isn't finished yet" The fact that these characters are so mortal is exactly what makes them so compelling.
Boss Hoge wow what a crap quote lol
John Witling wdym? That’s a damn good quote. I was going to say the epilogue is actually VERY happy. Almost campy. But the credits hint at the first game, and johns eventual death. It was a happy ending, but only because his story isn’t over yet.
Douggie Webb it’s saying that no story finishes in a happy way which is just bollocks
To be fair, it was always going to end this way.
Arthur: *gets shot in gameplay*
Gets shot in cut scene:
MaY I STaNd unsHaKennn
theassasingamer 427 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
He had tuberculosis
MSKULL24 not in cutscenes though
yEs
@@CatchTheMarmosets yes, when the o' driscolls kidnap you, they shoot you
God the look on Arthur's face when he gets told Molly never actually talked and died for nothing
but wasn't molly the one who told about the saint denis bank robbery?
@@salle2149 It was Micah
@@NoiseTheSilent are you sure, how do you know?
@@salle2149 Because he's a rat. A rat. It's also said in this video it was Micah.
@@salle2149 i see you didn't watch or play the game at all
At least arthur is with his wife and his son
John Marston John lmao same goes for you
@@simoneshull7721 nah just his wife
Micah is a rat...
@@DMVGREY I know Dutch Micah won and deserved to passed away... 😯😔☹🙁
@@DMVGREY im sorry...
RDR2
Dutch to John: It's either him or us. The way I see it It might as well be him.
RDR1
John to Javier: It's either you or me. The way I see it it might as well be you.
I just realized that little detail.
Also, as you may already know, the speech that Dutch makes when he and Arthur are surrounded by the army and have to jump off a cliff into the river mirrors the speech he makes when he jumps to his death in RDR1.
"You can't fight change, you can't fight gravity"
nice good deadeye :3
Nice catch!
The fear in Colms eyes
Somehow and in some way, i feel bad for him
But i am glad he is dead at the same time
It made me laugh. I loved it.
i thought they did so well portraying how panicked and afraid he was to be hanged. he starts hyperventilating and you can tell in his eyes he's scared. i loVED IT
I felt bad for him i dont know why
It was kinda sad seeing a man go from so calm to terrified in just a few seconds
During most of the character's deaths I wasn't sad or something, I was more angry than anything, It was like a friend dying, and somehow by my fault, I just wanted to shoot due to vengance.
Arthur's one make me cry like a little boah...
Same😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Revenge is a fools game
I hate Dutch so much because without him interfering Arthur would have dead eyed Micah to dust
Arthur still could have when Dutch left but he didn't for some reason.
His dead eye core must've not been full
I think Micah knew Dutch was there and that's why he kind of hung back when Arthur was crawling
RTRthe3rd He would’ve died still. From Tuberculosis.
I wish you did draws without deadeye. It’d be so much more epic
They forgot the most important death
CAIN that bastard micah shot him
Charlie Deganich it’s a special cut scene that not everybody sees
Tropical Gamer how do you see it?
waiT HE DID WHAT
Charlie Deganich I saw him later after the cutscene
It’s not a cutscene
It’s something Micha says to Jack
Agent Ross and Milton are sad characters since they are the incarnation of this quote "whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster" from Nietzsche. They are so obsessed to capture outlaws that they became outlaws, taking a man's wife and sons then shoot him like a dog. Quite Ironic .
TheMaximus874 only to get killed by an outlaw
It's fairly ironic, in Ross's quest to capture and kill the gang he ends up being the catalyst that drives Jack to kill him in the end. In a bid to get rid of the outlaws all he did was create more.
They have to justify their wages
Honestly hes just a piece of shit, he never did anything in the game that was good or honorable ever
17:24 Sadies laugh after Colm O'Driscoll got hanged gets me everytime
*HA. HA. HA.*
the deaths what got to me was lenny , hosea and arthurs
Sean didn’t deserve it
Lenny’s damn death didn’t deserve to happen. I liked lenny.
I liked sean
TwisT Aaa See that’s the thing with this game and morality. All of them deserve it. Without a doubt. Objectively.
I named my new horse "Horsea" in his honor... Then it died too.
Sean, Hosea, Lenny, and Arthur's death's hit hard
Sean was my favorite character
Sean and Arthur's death hit home for me
WHY IS EVERYONE NOT TALKING ABOUT THE HORSE
Yeah I loved Sean fuck you micah
Will Allison Sean’s death wasn’t sad for me because it was so sudden and the way how the characters act after his death really frustrates me.
Am I the only one who thought Micah’s death was hilarious?
Like he just says “Welp that happened” and falls.
JiffyJelly and also because he deserved it.
"That's the way it is"
Communist _Racoon I guess Micah was just like
“I’ve been living too fast, I’ve been living too long”
Its funnier when you get him in the forehead
Shit you beat me to it!
I miss Sean, always loved it when he sweared at Arthur. He was a charmer.
Kieran’s death scared the shit out of me
Woops Same, I felt so bad for him....He saved Arthur’s life but couldn’t return the favour. I felt bad because nearly everybody in the gang hated him.
Speaking of which, where was his head in this video?
Grey Fox must have glitched out.
Auto Correct This was what I hated about that video. That Kieran’s head wasn’t shown when his death happened. Very annoying. 😡
@@rjayzz1186 marybeth liked him
Why on holy f*cking Earth do so many people play with the music turned off????? That's like watching the Lord of the Rings movies without the music.
This vid would get demonitized if he had music on
Hmmm. Why do people blur main brand logos on tv shows?
You should make a better comparison that doesn't relate to music such as, It's like eating a cake without the Icing.
@@DMVGREY because they get killed
@@DMVGREY and you're 6 feet under.
Well..... At least Charles and Sadie LIVED.
Sure.
charles is hot
Andree Tungcab that’s it lol?
@@ddhouston3380 I won't complain about it. The amount of people that died in 1 and 2 was enough. Arthur, Hosea, John, Dutch, Javier and the rest. And yes I was almost emotionally devastated by the amount of deaths.
@@virgin5415 Dude, obviously I'm sad that Arthur died, as did the others and soon almost all of them will.
12:36 LMAO bills “DAYUM” always gets me 😂💀
It cracks me up every time lmfao
32:34 lmaooo there's literally a rat walking around when John calls for Micah 😂
Y’know how Arthur’s spirit animal is either a deer or a wolf, well Micah’s a rat.
@@arkxerxes8017 or an eagle
Micahs true form
John Marston doesn't look the same without his long hair
Ctc Tv can’t his long hair grow back if you play as him and don’t cut your hair?
@@d1ld0sagg1ns9 well yea probably but I was just saying
@@d1ld0sagg1ns9 yes it can just like arthur's
he ends up looking exactly like in RDR 1 by the time the epilogue is over
@@d1ld0sagg1ns9 John rocks full-length hair.
Don’t forget the most important character in this game
Arthur’s horse
I invested so much time and love into my horse, only for him to die...That was the biggest surprise XD
What would happen if you stole one for the mission
MSKULL24 I got that spoiled so I bought a new horse to save mine, all that happens is he looks back for a sec but keeps running
@William Anderson no, reread my comment and the previous comment
Ikr I got a $1000 horse right before that mission and now I'm like aww shit
4:27 I think Ur Kieran broke, he's meant to have his head in his hands.
@NOU TFF or just a console 🤷♂️🤷🤷
This happened to me too. I thought it was just part of the game lmaooo
Sean's death pissed me off like... "No... THEY CAN'T DIE"
Then O' Drisc K boy
"STOP"
Then Hosea and Lenny
"I really don't like this game"
Then you're really going to hate what happens at the end of Chapter 6.
There was a period of time where I was playing through the game as fast as I could after Hosea and Lenny died and Arthur was diagnosed with TB, because the game was depressing me that much. Everything from Guarma until the Epilogue is a blur for me...
William Anderson no he didn’t see what happened he only saw everyone pointing guns at Arthur and John so he probably guessed that they were betraying the gang and picked the gang over them.
William Anderson honestly I think he
Loved Dutch more then he did Arthur. If you learn how he was brought into the gang then then it makes a lot of sense why he would choose Dutch over Arthur and John
@@madamebkrt It felt like a bad night, and the epilogue felt like waking up in the morning, feeling fine until the guilt sets in again
Everybody who lived past red dead 2:
Abigail
John
Jack
Charles
Javier
Bill
Dutch
Trelawny (not positive, but didn't see him die)
Mary-Beth
Karen(I think, never saw her die)
Mr. Pearson
Rev. Swanson(read bout him in newspaper)
Sadie Adler
Tilly
Lumbago
My favorite character was lumbago
Mary-Beth had told John that she found Karen but she’s presumably dead from alcohol poisoning
Karen was alcohol poisoning. Trelewany moved away I believe, cut scene end of game
Lumbago 😂😂😂😂
Elathe best uncle
I really liked Hosea and Lenny Rip
Those deaths really got me. So sudden and so sad. Both were great characters, the most likable ones for sure.
LEEEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNNNNNY!!!
LENNY MAH BOI!!!!!!
@@legohero451 LEEEEEENY WHERE ARE YOU??????????!!!?!?!?!?!??
Manny Garcia lenny nooooo
Gotta admit Micah's immediate shot after Sean dies was pretty impressive. How his reflex was a perfect shot less than a second after sean died
Watching Arthur die without music is still as sad as it is with music. This goes to show how connected Rockstar makes us to characters.
Your profile picture doesn’t inspire such emotions.
I all I ask from R* Is a revamp of gta 5's story, get a bit more interpersonal with the characters and make a villian I give a shit about rather than making me wanna kill them literally only because they're pointless nothing characters
connected to characters and disconnected from their servers
I feel like Micah should've caught tuberculosis from that fight
Hoseas and Arthur's death was so sad due to the fact Hosea and Arthur had a bond for 20 years.
And Dutch. Pretty sure that's what made him snap
@@WhoopEaterz both Arthur's and Hoseas death made Dutch truly snap. Arthur was like a son to Dutch same with John Hosea was more like a brother to Dutch.
@@Crow-nc1oo Dutch didn't much care for John, don't see how he was like a son to him.
@@-sanju- sometimes your children do stupid shit, it's been said that both Arthur and John grew up together in Dutchs care, John grew and saw what life outside of the outlaw lifestyle was like and seeked his escape with his family, Arthur wasn't that lucky because the only love he had rejected him for his lifestyle, Arthur grew to trust Dutch with little doubt up until he was diagnosed and reflected on everything they ever did. Dutch saw his grip on John was loose after all these years so he decided John could find his own way with his own decisions when he needs to.
@@-sanju- Yes he did, John was like a son to him, so much so that at one point Arthur says to John (arguing over who is Dutch's favorite), "I was a prize pony too once, now I'm a work horse." It's just that Dutch doesn't have as a tight a grip on John as he does on Arthur, partially because of Abigail & Jack and partially because John is generally portrayed as more intelligent than average for his time.
Colm's death was the most satisfying video game death in a VERY long time for me. Executed perfectly (no pun intended).
When the noose is just right
Yeah and the facial expression on his face gave the scene a lot more realism in which I applaud the dev's and producers of Rockstars to... 😎👌😎👏
I was glad to see him swing, after he tortured Arthur.
Micah’s is the most satisfying one for me , wished he had more suffering though
The way he looked into the abyss knowing this was it was a masterpiece of a moment
timestamps:
1:22 Sean’s Death
4:18 Kieran’s Death
7:13 Bronte’s Death
9:17 Hosea’s Death
9:38 Lenny’s Death
10:53 Levi’s Death
12:35 Molly’s Death
15:42 Cornwall’s Death
17:15 Colm O’Driscoll’s Death
18:57 Milton’s Death
25:43 Arthur’s Death
28:30 rancher’s Death
32:19 Cleet’s Death
37:10 Micah’s Death (Best death in the game)
They kill all the best people in the game... makes sense
For me saddest ones were sean hosea arthur and lenny
Oh Cmon Charles lives.
Not Charles or Sadie.
At least sexy Sadie is still alive
@@jordandennis6794 shes more of a man then you
Is anyone else sad about Kieron Duffy death or just me
I'm am
Naaah
Arthur Morgan you could save him
It was more disturbing then sad
Me, he was a good man, after leaving he O'Driscoll gang, he became an honest man, but he got caught by Colm's men and got killed.
I swear to god Charles has got to be the most underrated character in the game.
Edit:Ok I wasn’t aware that people actually talked a lot about him so yeah I guess he is not underrated
Doctor Strange This. Charles is the man.
Who underrated him
Agreed
I would argue Kieran was the most underrated charecter
Charles isn’t underrated, everyone talks about how badass he is what are you talking about lol
both of arthur's last words on the hill ending. High Honor: In the end, i did.
Low Honor: Damn Us Both!
I feel like Kieran really didn't deserve to go the way he did. I was so sad when I saw that
I felt like Kierans death was Rockstars way of letting us know it's about to get a lot worse.
I felt so bad for Kieran. What's worse is I went fishing with him before he died and I actually started to like him.
Well, he does kind of deserve to die for betraying the O'Driscoll's but damn, nobody deserves that
FilthyFascist yes it was😂
Justin how do you go fishing with someone?
RockStar had to kill off all these characters because they don't appear in Red Dead Redemption 1
Charles and Sadie don't so...
Its just to make you hurt inside and then give you a character who dies like everyone else. You are nothing special next to everyone else. Your all gunslingers and good ones.
Enraged By Everything Lmao yep that’s almost the WHOLE point.
Donkey puncher they left to some place
Oh that’s why WHY!
Arthur's death:SADDEST MOMENTS OF MY ENTIRE LIFE
Micah's death:YES YES FINALLY HIS DEAD THIS IS THE BEST DAY EVER
But then leads to the death of John
@@Adamhulbert95 how exactly tho
@@Chonksta The Pinkertons find Micah's body, so they try and find who killed him. Eventually it leads them to John. It shows it happen during the credits
Stopmotion52 “revenge is an idiots game”
On the same day tho
Bro I literally Paused the game when Sean Died it was so uncalled for
I actually said “what the fuck!?” When he died
12:21
When you do something bad at school and your best friend tells the teacher
😂
but your other friend tells the secrets of your best friend
12:35
That's not your friend if they snitch on you
@@elmatapacos7441 snitches get stitches
Arthur saying "I gave you all I had. I did" to Dutch, damn, it hit my soul real hard. I didn't noticed I was crying during this part. Dutch choosing that rat Micah over Arthur, the boy he raised and is with him for more than 20 yrs, it's a damn cold betrayal. This is absolutely a masterpiece.
Dutch realized it was too late and he had fukd up real bad...after that i belive he got real depressed and mentally very ill alltough he had been that for a while after hosea's death
I'm so glad that Charles survived - but then again, who could actually kill Charles!
Ikr? He's a beast
Joe Charles is a 100% a badass. How quiet and calm he is, it’s crazy how goddamn badass he is...
Red dead 3 should be about charles tbh...his time before the van der linde gang, his time with them and what he could do after would make for a pretty amazing story.
TB or terminal Lumbago can!
Joe he reminds of Conner from AC3
My favorite part is that throughout the game, the gang slowly starts to go from a family who love one another to a band of disoriented associates who can’t trust one another. It’s amazing story telling.
When you think about it. Sean, Hosea, Lenny. Their blood is on Micah's hands.
Micah didn't become an informant to the got back from the Island.
Beastman 00x he was since the beginning
@@supergamerboy7899 nope. agent Milton said that they picked him up after guarma
RadicalReborn before that he snitched to colm who then snithced to milton. Or so i believe.
Every death in this game is on Micah because he botched the Blackwater job
My favorite characters and ones that shouldn’t have died
1. ARTHUR OF COURSE he was a good man and Strauss was why he died
2.Sean he was still young and killed too suddenly
3. Hosea he was a very respectable character and didn’t deserve to be an example
4. Lenny man he was so cool and I liked doing missions with him
(Edit)5. Dutch he had a plan and also was determined but although he dies in rdr1 I liked how he never gave up but was kind of mad that he turned on Arthur because he was like a father to him
Christian Carnalla thanks finally someone sees I deserved a true outlaw death
LENNY!
Matthew Dennin WHAT WHERES LENNY
Oh LENNY! IVE BEEN LOOKING ALL OVER FOR YOU!
Christian Carnalla Lenny was the youngest he was 19 and he was still good with a gun
Sean’s death for me was fucking hard no main characters had died yet so I wasn’t used to seeing anyone of them die and he was acc one of my favourites. It caught me so off guard
All timecodes (comment will be updated):
1:25 - Sean
4:23 - Kieran
7:18 - Angelo Bronte
9:17 - Hosea
9:37 - Lenny
10:52 - Levi
12:34 - Molly
15:42 - Leviticus Cornwall
17:20 - Colm O'Driscoll
18:36 - Agent Milton
25:22 - Arthur Morgan
27:59 - Guy from Laramie gang
32:18 - Cleet
37:10 - Micah
All the people in Dutch’s gang that died throughout the story could of sided with Arthur and John at the end of them game before he died
Bosley I’m sure Sean and Lenny would have, and I bet hosea would have defused the situation.
Sean: Would take Arthur and Johns side
Kieran: Would taken Arthur and Johns side
Lenny: Would have taken Arthur and Johns side
Hosea: Would Have stopped it in the first place.
Bosley you’re also forgetting how Sadie and Charles would be with Arthur if they weren’t dealing with other problems
And Javier was hesitant
I would’ve loved to see Kieren on aurthurs side
Hosea and Lenny deaths got me
Britaincolds VI I proper liked Arthur as well John’s still cool tho but there something about Arthur which makes him so much more likeable
@@Ss44pol Arthur is chill as fuck.
Ms.Grimshaws death had me seeing red
Sean's Death hit me hard cuz it was the first and I liked him
@@ieditfornoreason8523 Sean's death scared the shit outta me goddamn
Oh your cutscene was censored, in my cutscene Kieran’s body was holding his head. He had things implied in his eyes as well.
I thought theirs was glitched or something. In mine he was holding his head and his eyes had been gouged out.
@Kara Dunn sarcasm?
Beluga Whale don’t think it was
Bugeye0704 I don’t know if you tards are being serious or not lol , if you are being serious he barred the scene because it’s too gruesome for TH-cam and will probably make him get demonetised
That was scary af man its so sad
I swear to god when lenny died I shot both of the guys who kill him with dead eye before they could fire, turns out they are invulnerable for a second or two untill lenny dies. That made the whold thing just super frustrating for me
Hosea's death was the most important
True made Dutch make shit decisions
I think it was Seans since it started the gangs downfall
Yeah. His death was the beginning of the end
No , arthur was the most important
@@angelh8383 Nah, Micah joining marked the beginning of the end, he probably gave Dutch the idea for the boat heist.
Nobody gonna talk about 36:34 ?
When Mich said
"Arthur's been dead a long time..." that pissed me off so much and to this day it still does lol
Kierens death was kinda disturbing
It made me laugh... Not too much though. I just giggled. Why did O Driscoll's take the time to put him in that position?
I felt like I was gonna throw up
@@donya8117 qq
“Kinda”
Ik when I saw I went HOLY SHIT!!!!
37:10 Most satisfying moment in gaming history.
Not as satysfying as killing Ross in RDR.
Seriously, Micah's death was so... Anticlimatic because of how he pretend that nothing happened and fell on the ground.
I would tend to disagree, Mr Polish God
Did nobody notice the fact that Kieran's head wasn't in his hands like it always is?
Love how Strauss was like ... and then walked a bit closer
It’s an honor thing it’s there either way
Evan Alexander you know I don’t actually remember I will replay it tomorrow and let you know
Evan Alexander no need bro I replayed it just now cuz I was bored and yeah it is he has it In his hands with high honor
“ When I die, face me to the west so I can watch the sunset and think about all the good times we had together,” Makes me cry everytime, considering everytime Hosea had to bury someone, he faced them to the West. Charles did so for Arthur and Susan. I want so for myself.
Made me cry 😭
For real
37:39 I love how Micah is just like "Welp,I'm dead."
Micah: guess I'll die
What a badass.
that shrug made me laugh
It looked like he was about to keep talking but then realized that he was supposed to be dead
@@natethenotsogreat8349 LOL
Most famous last words
“Now it don’t feel right, I coulda to-“
We can get across here.”
“Our time has passed John”
Least famous last words
You shot me, you shot me pretty good.
Crazy how I feel so most love for a fictional gang of outlaws
I've never shed a tear for any character in a game but for Mr. Morgan... Man... I cried..... That part where he thanked his dying horse... Ugh. Right in the heart.... And Marston, pleading with Dutch, his "father", then having Dutch walk away....Heart breaking....
@shittyMinecube e i liked that Lenny didnt have a cut scene, it took me by surprise as it happened during gameplay
Guess you've never played telltale's the walking dead then.
@@odinshire4972 i was thinking this but didnt put it
I was able to keep the first horse you get alive through the whole game when he died at the end it was way more emotional than I thought it would be
WERE IT SO EASY!
This game hates Irish people
At least it showed some respect to the Germans, not many games do that.
Just in case you don’t know the character Strauss isn’t german he’s austrian
ikr molly and sean r.i.p molly didn't even rat them out
Nah mate I'm irish and this game has been very nice to me. Stellar game lmao
iwishicouldbefunny I’m Irish is well and I love this game to I’m just found it funny
the look on Colm's face when he realizes no one will save him
*colom*
So satysfying
As hard as Arthur’s death hit me (I love this character) I really was hurt over Hoseas death. Such a wise mind and a father figure to both Arthur and Dutch. Just shows you how great these characters are and how much they get you invested into what they’re doing
If hosea wouldn't have died, then dutch would still be sane. Too bad Arthur would still die ;-;
In the end, it was all a roundabout path, arigato, arthur
@@mariochartouni was that a jojo reference?
@@NorbiZ yes
That’s Leopold Strauss’s fault he got arthur to take that debt collector job and get money from Thomas downes then he coughed in Arthur’s face that caused him to get Tuberculosis
However,the body parts of arthur are all throught america .
Go take em johnny
Lennys death could’ve been so easily avoided. I was aiming at the guys head using dead eye but it wouldn’t let me shoot him for so long it pissed me off
Same, man. I tried saving him at least four or five times only for their heads to be bullet-proof.
KFC Bagles It’s like trying to swing at your enemy in a dream.
Brandon Valencia best comparison
Exactly. The moment they jumped out, my reflexes kicked in but I couldn't shoot them
Would it have worked for you if Lenny was standing in front of the door when it got kicked open and then shot at?
I don’t know if it’s just me, but the last ride mission actually made me cry more than his death. It’s just so powerful.
I loved seeing the pure terror on colms face
My heart literally dropped when Sean and Lenny died. They were so sudden and out of no where. This game really messed me up a bit with how things in life doesn't go as u think. Nothing lasts forever. I love the message and plot of this game.
Listening to Arthur wheeze while Dutch and Micah were talking just.....
*T H E P A I N*
Ahhhhhhhh!!!! Sponge bob is that you?!?!
I liked that people could die in rdr2. It gave a sense of uncertainty whenever you went on a heist or mission.