Благодарю! Я прослушала эту запись дважды. А я,-в силу своей необразованности,-не знала,что Кристоф Эшенбах замечательный пианист. Три года тому назад,когда у меня появилась возможность слушать музыку с помощью интернета,-он поразил меня своим искусством дирижирования симфоний Г.Малера. Я прочитала об этом выдающемся Музыканте в интернете. Ещё раз,Благодарю!
Среди фортепианных коцертов много шедевров - от разных авторов. Концерт Шумана среди них - красивейшее, интереснейшее и, конечно, бессмертное творение. Исполнение Eschenbach - изысканное, пылкость исполнителя нигде не становится жёсткой. Дорогой Sofronichrist! Думаю, вам часто говорят об уникальности вашей подписки. То, что вы делаете - сохранение значимого и значительного пласта культуры - вызывает уважение и искреннюю симпатию. Спасибо. С Рождеством!
une excellente version originale le pianiste nous accroche avec son entrée très personnelle et on le suit jusqu'au bout malgre les imperfections de l'orchestre
First time that I heard a recording from Kleiber that is not sublime, but this concerto is really hard to make it sound full with this particular orchestration...
Yes for sure, however Furtwängler wasn't any maniac of perfection but Kleiber was. So I cannot understand to fail the entrance of the Schumann Concerto. A good conductor should take care of being together [orchestra and piano].Furthermore these few bars Intro are also too fast and without any adequate expression, in German 'flüchtig'. But anyway Sofro. Nobody is perfect, even Carlos Kleiber isn't. I admire him a lot BTW. Greetings
@@berlinzerberus Regarding this concert, CK said that it was a total disaster. He also hated doing concertos, because it meant he'd have to give in at times, and CK, being a perfectionist as he was, would never have liked that. This explains the lack of concertos in his rep. (Beethoven 4, Beethoven 5, Schumann and Dvorak Piano concertos. Each of these he did only once) Also, Whenever someone complimented after a symphonic concert, he would say "Yes, but a few years ago in Prague, it was not so good!"
@@MrTann2010 You shouldnt use my profile picture in your channel! Or dont you have the phantasie to find another own one. Perhaps you are a plagiarist! 👎🥶
@@MrTann2010 I knew about Beethoven's concerto 4 with Brendel and 5 with Michelangeli, but do you know if it is possible to hear the tape of 4 and the rushes of 5?
Straordinario! Questo è un documento fatntastico!! Un Kleiber di cui nessuno sapeva dell'esistenza!
Благодарю! Я прослушала
эту запись дважды.
А я,-в силу своей необразованности,-не знала,что Кристоф Эшенбах
замечательный пианист.
Три года тому назад,когда у
меня появилась возможность слушать музыку с помощью интернета,-он поразил меня
своим искусством дирижирования симфоний
Г.Малера.
Я прочитала об этом выдающемся Музыканте
в интернете.
Ещё раз,Благодарю!
Wow, the rarest YT upload of the Year!
Ahaha thank you very much !
Upload of the Year!
Thank you very much! Glad to hear it from an expert of Carlos :)
Una auténtica joya, geniales, tanto el director como el solista. No conocía esta grabación de este maravilloso concierto. Gracias por compartir.
Thank you !
Среди фортепианных коцертов много шедевров - от разных авторов. Концерт Шумана среди них - красивейшее, интереснейшее и, конечно, бессмертное творение. Исполнение Eschenbach - изысканное, пылкость исполнителя нигде не становится жёсткой.
Дорогой Sofronichrist! Думаю, вам часто говорят об уникальности вашей подписки. То, что вы делаете - сохранение значимого и значительного пласта культуры - вызывает уважение и искреннюю симпатию. Спасибо.
С Рождеством!
Thank you so much for your support ! Merry Christmas :)
Мой Привет,Вам,из Екатеринбурга! Послушаю
завтра и Спасибо!
Thank you !
une excellente version originale le pianiste nous accroche avec son entrée très personnelle et on le suit jusqu'au bout malgre les imperfections de l'orchestre
Bé, non sono mica i Wiener o i Berliner.. Ma non mi pare proprio così imperfetta
TY
You’re welcome :) !
First time that I heard a recording from Kleiber that is not sublime, but this concerto is really hard to make it sound full with this particular orchestration...
There are other recordings that are not great, such as the one of Beethoven's PASTORALE.
The opening chords are NOT together!
..Not that good for such a proficient conductor!
It can happen, even to the greatest ( Furtwangler! )
Yes for sure, however Furtwängler wasn't any maniac of perfection but Kleiber was. So I cannot understand to fail the entrance of the Schumann Concerto. A good conductor should take care of being together [orchestra and piano].Furthermore these few bars Intro are also too fast and without any adequate expression, in German 'flüchtig'. But anyway Sofro. Nobody is perfect, even Carlos Kleiber isn't. I admire him a lot BTW.
Greetings
@@berlinzerberus Regarding this concert, CK said that it was a total disaster. He also hated doing concertos, because it meant he'd have to give in at times, and CK, being a perfectionist as he was, would never have liked that. This explains the lack of concertos in his rep. (Beethoven 4, Beethoven 5, Schumann and Dvorak Piano concertos. Each of these he did only once) Also, Whenever someone complimented after a symphonic concert, he would say "Yes, but a few years ago in Prague, it was not so good!"
@@MrTann2010 You shouldnt use my profile picture in your channel!
Or dont you have the phantasie to find another own one. Perhaps you are a plagiarist! 👎🥶
@@MrTann2010 I knew about Beethoven's concerto 4 with Brendel and 5 with Michelangeli, but do you know if it is possible to hear the tape of 4 and the rushes of 5?
The final movement starts like a hurricane -- much too fast. Definite "no" to this performance.