Star Trek: TNG Review - 3x18 Allegiance | Reverse Angle
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 ต.ค. 2020
- Picard singing immediately made it clear how incredible a musical episode of this show would be.
Thanks for watching! Consider supporting us on Patreon: / reverseangle
--------------------
Sources:
Manning, Richard, and Hans Beimler. “Allegiance.” Star Trek: The Next Generation, created by Gene Roddenberry, Season 3, Episode 18, Paramount Television, CBS, 1990.
봉준호, director. Snowpiercer. CJ Entertainment, 2013. - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![NONT TANONT - ดอกไม้ที่รอฝน (spring) - Reimagined [Live Session]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nY2PsFZFEOg/mqdefault.jpg)
I love how the crew goes crazy that Picard "buys" them drinks that A. Don't actually cost anything and B. aren't real alcoholic beverages anyway.
This is a great treat before bed. Thanks fellas!
oh also the song picard sang in this episode was used to show how his singing created a bar fight in another tng edit lol.
The best group of TNG edits. I don’t know why, but replacing all of Mark Twain’s dialogue with all his random noises is the funniest thing ever.
Fun episode - extra marks from me because we get to see Patrick Stewart being silly + *four* different aliens in a single episode. And elaborate alien makeups, not just wrinkley foreheads. BTW is it me or did the alien abductors look kind of like Bruce Campbell? :-)
You're right, it did look a bit creepy when Picard went for Haro's throat. I'm assuming he was going to check her pulse?
The big mystery: was there a toilet in the holding cell or did everyone just hold it in until they returned to their homeworlds?
Haha, some good points.
I’ve actually sat in a very similar chair to the one in the beginning. It’s actually pretty comfortable and I’d totally believe reading a book in one. Maybe not drinking anything because sitting up to drink every time might be a little hard.
a few years ago I was making parody edits of the show and in one of them I looped the footage of Picard "choking" that woman while laughing . I also had Picard himself eat Thol in the end and say he's a delicacy.
this was probably the episode with the most useful materials for edits. all the scenes with the fake Picard were used in multiple edits , making it look as if that was the real picard and he's always weird like that
You should post a link if that's up somewhere, it sounds funny.
@@reverseangle here it is : th-cam.com/video/jWQLOb9TQT0/w-d-xo.html
Esoqq's world Chana sounds fascinating. A completely anarchist society, like Klingons dialed up to 11. How does that work? Did they achieve warp drive on their own or just club a visiting Vulcan over the head and steal their ship?
Patrick Stewart's rendition of "Heart of Oak" will forever be one of the great Trek moments. The goofiness behind the scene is so perfect for the context of the episode. I love it! 🤪
I’m just amazed you not only found a recording of that hymn and it actually matched Picard’s pitch. Or you pitch corrected the recording which is also fantastic. Really enjoying your videos!
It was way more than pitch correction. The manipulation to line those tracks up took longer than the rest of the review combined, but I'm very happy with it.
-Nick
@@reverseangle Major props! I’ve done similar audio work myself and sometimes you have no idea what you’re getting into until you’re already hours through it.
Used to sing that in sea cadets... Wish I knew Picard did a rendition!
The humor was good. Easy to solve mistery but the aliens look cool and the plot makes sense.
Re 7:15, the crew didn't contact Starfleet because (see 1:40) Picard ordered radio silence.
There's an imposter among us.
1:05 checking pulse on carotid artery.
Common place to check a pulse.
Also why he's doing it with one hand as opposed to both hands, which is what most people use when actually choking people.
I like when they go for a twilight zone esque episode lol
I'd give it a B I feel they did a good job focusing on the idea of different species as lab rats. The makeup and costume work in this one was also good.
*Pogo Data & Picard*
I'm pretty sure Chana is the same species that stabbed Picard through the heart during a fight over a game of Damjat when Picard was in his final year of Starfleet academy. I think that's why he knew the species so quickly. If, of course, he said the species was Nausican. I'm such a dork
Hoping you guys would catch it and not shown here but towards the end on the bridge when the aliens replace the fake Picard, they actually replace the wrong one. They appear where the real Picard was standing.
"Hey. Picard's acting weird." Original title of Picard.
Huh, missed this episode earlier. I liked the concept for this one, however, Star Trek personnel get abducted more than people from the X-Files.
I thought of this one as a throw-away episode that was decently done, but as usual, it was quickly wrapped up at the end.
I love this episode
Pretty sure Picard was just reading the Myst linking book there.
This is a great episode
You said, Picard was replaced in one of the previous episodes by an energy being. Which episode was that?
Lonely Among Us:
th-cam.com/video/Z3FkqS-YPsA/w-d-xo.html
Definitely an oddball episode. I liked how it made Picard the laboratory rat, so to speak. The deductive reasoning the "Test subjects" were using was pretty decent at least too.
The hidden premise here that I picked up on was: You can study all you want about a species but, dammit, sometimes you just have to kidnap one of 'em to see how it all comes together in real life... lol
ok we will leave but you must give us ONE member of your crew.
Wesley go with them.
and don't forget to use rectal probing!
I like this one. B+
I agree with Nick. This one was just strange.
Ahh yes the Jay Leno aliens
I like th eepisodes where both of them disagree. It offers a nice balance of perspectives.
Great review as always guys. But I think you’re being too harsh on this episode. The mutiny scene was extraordinary for writing and acting. I’ll give it a “B.”
AMONG US
do you guys ever watch tng edits. its quite something because this episode has a scene that they used to basicly show how well the plot of the edit was riker got a cloaking device(form joridi) and used it to rape cpatain picard(thats not a joke) and data uses the dailouge from this episode at the start saying he is dectecting a strange reading from captain picards quaters and worf goes in and worf looks shocked and confused and picard just goes mr worf SOME PRVICY!
Can safely say I haven't seen that.
@@reverseangle yeah its insane there Is an episode about the enterprise vs the defiant aka siscko vs Picard. Also another episode where David Tennants doctor visits the enterprise. And yeah just a bunch of insane stuff.
@@reverseangle yeah its insane there Is an episode about the enterprise vs the defiant aka siscko vs Picard. Also another episode where David Tennants doctor visits the enterprise. And yeah just a bunch of insane stuff.
Someone should have edited your post to adhere to English. And did you know that sentences are supposed to occasionally end?
I loved this episode, could they have written it better, yeah probably, the song was boring, but they are not song writers, so: A-
This is a great review you guys. Honestly this is one of the stupidest episodes. Not horrible, just stupid. They're in the middle of space where amazing things happen all the time and they're like, iT's NOt PoSsiBle thE cApTaiN HaS BEen RepLAceD
"F" due to their forgetting what's spoonfed every week, "to seek out new life forms and *cough* to subvert audience exp- *cough* new civilizations. 🤪 😅
These shows were written largely without any thought of continuity. Accounts for the clumsy writing.
Lol, what?
These shows have some of the best continuity of any show created.
I've always found this episode oddly racist....against extraterrestrials. Here Picard and co. are, bragging about how great humans are, and all the alien species are some combination of stupid, arrogant, and violent. It's very gross.