I’m sure I missed other bands who fit the bill. I would definitely encourage you to let me know which ones I forgot. Also, let me know if you think that too many member changes make you rethink liking a band. Tell me all that, and anything else that applies, in the comments below.
What about Whitesnake? David Coverdale literally turned over the entire band at least twice in the 80's. Went to Wikipedia and there's at least 30 listed as members, and 24 or so lineup changes.
I could be wrong but since you are not including hired guns, would King Diamond, Ozzy and Yngwie count as they are technically solo acts and not bands. I would think the majority of the members of these acts were hired guns and not members of the "band" meaning corporation (Zack Wylde with Ozzy, Mickey Dee with King and everyone with Yngwie).
I find it hard to believe some of those numbers. Over 30 different members in some of my favorite bands? Just seems crazy. I'm thinking "There is no way Krokus had over 30 members" - then I look on Wikipedia, and say "Well craaaaaaaap" :)
Cloven Hoof , Saxon , Manowar , Poison Idea , Descendents tons of bands. I like New Accept even if Wolf is only one. Saxon too as long as they stay true to music. Bands evolve it happens.
I don't see 21 for Anthrax There's only been 4 guitarists since Danny... I think. And Only three singers, two drummers three bass players. I count 13. ??? Overkill... Absolutely as Dan Spitz was apart of that carousel. And shouldn't kiss be on this list? Dig the list. Crazy to see.
My guess Tobias Forge had the most band members come and go. If not he’s right up there. Good topic Matt. You are right I’m surprised at a lot of these bands.
Interesting but solo artists don't count! Blizzard of Oz was over when randy died, while sabbath doesn't seem that high. Three worst bands in the genre: megadeth, quiet riot after metal health and maiden. Dave mustaine is an overrated ex-metallica (known primarily because they fired him) druggie while im actually makes Judas priest sound listenable. Maybe try a similar video about classic rock bands if not already done.
I’m sure I missed other bands who fit the bill. I would definitely encourage you to let me know which ones I forgot. Also, let me know if you think that too many member changes make you rethink liking a band. Tell me all that, and anything else that applies, in the comments below.
I saw the title of this video and instantly thought "Megadeth".
Iced Earth has big lineup changes over the years.
Cradle of Filth. I'm not quite sure of the amount, but I read somewhere it was 41.
That was just crazy!! One band I thought of not metal but Molly Hatchet count is 24!
What about Whitesnake? David Coverdale literally turned over the entire band at least twice in the 80's. Went to Wikipedia and there's at least 30 listed as members, and 24 or so lineup changes.
They were sort of Post Punk but The Fall had so many members come and go through the decades until Mark E Smith's death. Astronomical.
I could be wrong but since you are not including hired guns, would King Diamond, Ozzy and Yngwie count as they are technically solo acts and not bands. I would think the majority of the members of these acts were hired guns and not members of the "band" meaning corporation (Zack Wylde with Ozzy, Mickey Dee with King and everyone with Yngwie).
Every high school band...ever
Megadeth and Black Sabbath are the top 2 that come to mind. Iron Maiden had about half a bazillion changes in their formative years as well.
Malevolent Creation has a lot
Great topic mate. Enjoyed this one loads! 🤘
Iron Maiden - most of those are before 1979. Since 1999 they have the most stable line-up ever with ALL members from 1983-1993 combined.
Cradle and dimmu come to mind straight away lol
I find it hard to believe some of those numbers. Over 30 different members in some of my favorite bands? Just seems crazy. I'm thinking "There is no way Krokus had over 30 members" - then I look on Wikipedia, and say "Well craaaaaaaap" :)
Wow!! Great video topic. I would expect Yngvie to be in there and Napalm Death. Surprised by Suicidal Tendencies and Krokus!
Cloven Hoof , Saxon , Manowar , Poison Idea , Descendents tons of bands. I like New Accept even if Wolf is only one. Saxon too as long as they stay true to music. Bands evolve it happens.
As long as it's not a core member that can impact the sound it personally doesn't bother me too much. Interesting video, thanks!
I’m a big fan of Yes, so kinda used to line-up changes by now 😅
Surprised Whitesnake and Deep Purple arent here
I think Ministry is over 60 at this point, lineup change every album
The numbers are incredible if you take into account the small number of albums some bands/artists made.
wow!! that is nuts. 😵💫
Riot is Another Band That Had Numerous Lineup Changes
Ritchie Blackmore's Rainbow. The same lineup never last two albums back-to-back.
Marilyn Manson should be on the list. The lineup changes every album and they went from five members down to basically one
What is up with the suicidal tendencies. Used to be a huge fan of that band
Any idea where I can find the music used on the countdown? Its really cool
figured ozzy would be top 3 he is my favorite rocker voice.
Wait a minute, Anthrax hasn't had twenty line up changes have they?
Any bands with the same members from the start?
I don't see 21 for Anthrax
There's only been 4 guitarists since Danny... I think. And Only three singers, two drummers three bass players.
I count 13.
???
Overkill...
Absolutely as Dan Spitz was apart of that carousel.
And shouldn't kiss be on this list?
Dig the list. Crazy to see.
Spinal tap as of 1982 had 67
Rainbow, numerous lineup changes
I honestly thought Cradle of Filth would definitely have been on this list 🤯🤘
I was so happy to see Napalm Death and Gwar on the list. I can leave the vidja now.
This is a megadave video isn't it?
Flotsam and Jetson have had about 40 changes over the years since their in 1982 !!!!
Sinister from Netherlands and Cradle of Filth🥵
I thought Cradle of Filth would’ve made the list. They must’ve had a lot less than I thought.
Megadeth and Death come to mind.
Not really metal, but Agnostic Front top 30. Cro-mags must be pretty high too.
Not a super popular band but London is known for having many ex members who made it big after leaving.
Anthrax really ? I think I have to take a look at this
My guess Tobias Forge had the most band members come and go. If not he’s right up there. Good topic Matt. You are right I’m surprised at a lot of these bands.
HAWKWIND and the UK SUBS have a ridiculous amount of lineup changes!!
Rainbow ,about 17 members
No Rainbow ? Or Deep purple ? Not even Whitesnake ? I’m surprised.
I think Exodus should be included
19. Just under the cut.
What,no Rainbow?
GWAR.
You didn't mention Kiss...
Not that shocking when you consider many of these bands have been playing for 40+ years.
L.A. Guns guessing over 30 now.
No MushroomHead?
Micheal Schenker group !
Lynard skynard maybe?
Megadave
I was surprised to not see Slipknot
I thought machine head would be on this list.
Wow… unbelievable huh. Talk about a hostile work environment 😂😂😂
Interesting but solo artists don't count! Blizzard of Oz was over when randy died, while sabbath doesn't seem that high. Three worst bands in the genre: megadeth, quiet riot after metal health and maiden. Dave mustaine is an overrated ex-metallica (known primarily because they fired him) druggie while im actually makes Judas priest sound listenable. Maybe try a similar video about classic rock bands if not already done.
Of course it's Lars Lannerbäck. Who else could it be?
Sepulatura and chelsea grin have no original members
Death.
Green Jello
Yngwie I thought was much worse
You missed L.A. Guns and the "136" member changes. Lol, I think they are at 53 seriously.
Ritchie Blackmore rainbow changed group members before the albums even came out,