Orthopedic Spine Surgeon Rates 11 Movie Injuries On Chances Of Survival | How Real Is It? | Insider
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ก.ย. 2024
- Dr. Antonio J. Webb takes a closer look at spinal injuries in movies and rates them for the character's chance of survival. Webb addresses physical injuries from falls at a height, such as Keanu Reeves' parachute fall in "Point Break" (1991) and building fall in "John Wick: Chapter 3 - Parabellum" (2019). He looks at car-crash injuries, such as in "Doctor Strange" (2016), "Anchorman 2: The Legend Continues" (2013) and "Bleed for This" (2016).Would Leonardo DiCaprio have survived the bear attack in "The Revenant" (2015)? And would Christian Bale's spine have been fixed without surgery in "The Dark Knight Rises" (2012)? Do real-life injuries sound just like Hilary Swank's neck hitting the boxing stool in "Million Dollar Baby" (2004)? Webb breaks down some of cinema's most iconic scenes. Dr. Antonio J. Webb is a fellowship-trained spine surgeon, having completed a combined neurosurgery and orthopedic spine surgery fellowship at Texas Back Institute. He spent eight years in the US Air Force as a medic and licensed vocational nurse, including a deployment north of Baghdad in 2005. He practices in San Antonio, Texas.
For more, visit: @antoniowebbmd
/ antoniowebbmd
antoniowebbmd....
MORE HOW REAL IS IT VIDEOS:
Physicist Rates 11 'Fast And Furious' Movie Stunts | How Real Is It?
• Physicist Rates 11 'Fa...
Shaolin Master Breaks Down 10 Kung Fu Movie Fights | How Real Is It?
• Shaolin Master Breaks ...
Special Ops Sniper Rates 11 Sniper Scenes In Movies | How Real Is It?
• Special Ops Sniper Rat...
------------------------------------------------------
#Movies #Injuries #Insider
Insider is great journalism about what passionate people actually want to know. That’s everything from news to food, celebrity to science, politics to sports and all the rest. It’s smart. It’s fearless. It’s fun. We push the boundaries of digital storytelling. Our mission is to inform and inspire.
Subscribe to our channel and visit us at: www.insider.com
Insider on Facebook: / insider
Insider on Instagram: / insider
Insider on Twitter: / thisisinsider
Insider on Snapchat: / 4020934530
Insider on Amazon Prime: www.amazon.com...
Insider on TikTok: / insider
Insider on Dailymotion: www.dailymotio...
Orthopedic Spine Surgeon Rates 11 Movie Injuries Based On Chances Of Survival | How Real Is It?
![เขามัทรี - เอ็กซ์ ศุภกฤต - จอนนี่มิวสิค [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AS9ufKuQIVs/mqdefault.jpg)
Hollywood: “Human beings are actually pretty tough and resilient”
Real Doctor: “Ya’ll might as well be made of glass and tissue paper”
Nah man, for everyday life humans are pretty resilient. Even without modern 1st world commodities humans are pretty tough.
Less so when in car accidents, falling from buildings, getting stabbed, getting mauled by bears...
Bruh ppl die from choking, slipping in the shower, eating expired pasta,
@@Venomonomonom people also survive being picked up by tornados and getting mauled by bears
@@Venomonomonom There is also people who survived a parachute fail lol
The human body is quite resilient. Until it isn't.
I lost it when he was looking at John Wick’s and started by saying “that’s a pretty hard fall”
That John Wick survives that fall is already ridiculous until you realize it's also been like a week since the first film ended and he barely survived that one. 😂
I love those movies but that pushed the limits of my suspension of disbelief a bit.
@@Madness-te7dr Bulletproofed suits are a real thing. But they can only stop handgun bullets, not rifle bullets just as shown in the film.
I completely forgot that scene from JW3 and I started laughing so hard at the clip and him saying that rt after
@@gaming4ever418 They are filled with Kevlar and are quite puffy, John Wick's bulletproof vests don't exist
Yep, along with most of the car stunt scenes. I don't find it believable at all, and feels like someone said they needed a car chase or fight/action scene involving vehicles, and so they did some destruction derby action
shooting and driving scene.
"His legs - both legs - were in a bag in the corner. Pretty typical day..."
I just.... I'm so glad people like him exist.
Wow the medical footage of the woman getting pulled by her strap and hearing her bones crack will live with me for a while
Right!? It was like a jump scare in a horror movie.
I was NOT ready for that pull... damnnn
I don’t know any chiropractors that do tgat
@@RobertFergusonDCFIAMA because it’s a medical procedure not chiropractic move. Chiropractics has no definitive benefit and does literally nothing according to research.
@@tobiasliebstvonobelitz6554 I hurt my back as a roofer, I went to a chiropractor when I could barely walk and I poured sweat I was in so much pain just getting into or out of my car seat. I couldn't move my right foot forward even a foot at a time, I was twisted at the hips and my neck was killing me. My chiropractor had me standing up straight and probably 85% reduced the pain in literally 2 minutes. 2 minutes. So the research is highly suspect. It worked for me.
I love how matter of fact way he speaks. No matter what happens, his inflection barely changes 😂😂😂.
That's exactly who I want in a crisis.
@phillyslasher Yeah, I was just thinking being amazingly cool-headed must be a really useful if not vital attribute for that job.
It's just how we get after doing all of our training and years of experience helps as well.
Well he said he was a medic in Irak so I guess that's sure helps him
@@9michelee9 oh absolutely
@@TaraConti Same. My mother is a gynaecologist and she would let me accompany her sometimes while she performed c-sections. Seeing the insides of a human bod like the uterus and placenta, the peritoneal fluid being sucked out and pumped back in, I got insensitisied to all of it, at a very young age.
John Wick falls off a 20 story building after being shot
Doctor: 😐that’s a pretty big fall 😐
Its 5-7 stories besides he hit that slanted shit which slowed the fall and then the emergency fire scape so yes its a hard fall indeed
@@JustASimpleGuy the railing is as likely to kill him as the ground. Concentrated force.
@@scotcoon1186 yea John would have had a much higher survival chance if he just straight fell into the plastic covered dumpster. Most of the shots from the rooftop would have broken couple of ribs and arm bones regardless of the nanometer thin kevlar suit. But hey it's John wick.
Noto to mention he was shot. That also counts as an injury, pretty sure high chances of internal bleeding not only from the impacts on surfaces but also the bullet wounds. Him getting up wasn't John Wick anymore.. He's just The One now
@@Chrononaut2006 I believe he was wearing a bulletproof suit
Doctor : This is your Spine
Me : Wtf.. Put it back
Never gets old
@@MeatBunFul Finally! Someone who agrees haha
Jesus Christ! John Wick: "The chance of someone getting up and walking from a fall like this is pretty low 1/10" No he would most likely be dead!
The Revenant: "Leonardo DiCaprio is in shock" WTF! It cannot have something to do with him wanting the bear to think he is dead or at least not a threat.
The amazing spider-man 2: Not mentioning that the webb gave her head a whipping effect, smashing the back of her head against the ground! Would think it would be worth mentioning since her head would crack like an egg.
"He would most likely be dead" and "The chance of someone getting up and walking from a fall like this is pretty low" sound like you both came to the same conclusion. Yeah, someone who gets mauled by a brown bear is probably in shock. The character also likely knew to play dead, but given this is a medical professional giving his evaluation of the injuries based on their survivability, I think we can forgive him for not going into bear survival tactics as well. Also, I think it was pretty clear he was evaluating the survivability of the rest of the fall. Obviously if someone falls from that high up and cracks their head like that, they're dead, but he was pointing out that even if she hadn't hit her head, she wouldn't have survived.
But but he’s Batman
How humans have stayed alive for so long is astounding considering we are so soft.
We have mastered multiple evasions and developed protective devices. lol
It's because we're soft, meat is good at absorbing kinetic energy, these are the types of scenarios where you'd want to be at least abit of a chunky monkey, the only problem with that is then your heart and organs generally aren't as in as good shape as someone with a 'normal' body type so might not handle the extra pressure
@@kalumbailey5103 doesn't weight equal force and speed tho? A fat American falling from standing on Funniest home videos is worse than a bug falling from a tree
Humans are surprisingly fickle when it comes to dying, you can trip over your own feet and you body would say "Guess I'll die" or you fall several thousand feet with no parachute and live
@@kamlong7358 depends on your luck
Sometimes I wonder: "maybe I should have gone to medical school." Then I watch 2 seconds of someone performing spinal surgery. "Nope, nope, nope, I definitely would not have done well there."
Preach it. As a kid I was so amazed by saving lives at a hospital, then I get hit with some of the most gorish operations I've ever seen. I noped really fast.
When I was in my mid-20s, just out of college, I had this idea that I wanted to be a paramedic. Spent a couple thousand going to school for it and then we had to do rounds in a hospital emergency room over one weekend as part of the training. The sh*t I saw that weekend cured me of my delusion. Went in the next Monday and quit on the spot. Some people are made for that work and I give them all respect but I am not one of those people. They say you can get used to absolutely anything but I'm just going to take their word for it, thanks.
@@kpe727 hats off to you for trying and those who stayed my stomach is far too weak to look at severed injuries
There’s other fields to work in. You could be a proctologist or a podiatrist, no spinal surgery with those two fields.
Orthopedic surgeon here also - I have a hard time enjoying any action movies/television shows because of the exaggerated injuries followed by near comical superhuman resilience/recovery. I'm that jerk that talks to the TV, and my wife won't even watch these shows with me anymore...
(I always try not to provide commentary, but then I watch something like The Fast and the Furious, and I can't help it!)
Maybe you can help me with this. I had seen another doctor say that since the scene in TDKRises is vague that it’s possible he only had a rotated disk, which would still protrude differently enough that the doctor may say “it’s protruding” but not be as severe as a slipped or fractured disk. This doctor said If you were really lucky that you could knock this injury back in place and then hanging/traction would help it heal in the correct alignment.
Obviously the film doesn’t make this explicit, but it seems to fit in the description well enough. Does that sound plausible to you?
Med student here I wince throughout all action films. Or I say "he's dead. Yup. Dead"
I think your biggest problem is you're watching "Fast and Furious" :D
I'm the same way but with martial arts
".....that kick has no power. Might as well be a slap. Why are you spin kicking here? An elbow would flow better here" etc
GIVE. US. COMMENTARY.
I broke my neck almost 8 years ago. If is wasn't for people like this gentleman I'd still struggle to walk. I'm happy he's training people to help people like me.
Fantastic video.
"There's this new instrument called a Y-Strap that they use to essentially- OH MY SWEET GOD NO!"
Why do movies make stuff up when actual medical sh*t is so horrifying?!
I came just to comment this.
I'm also an orthopedic surgeon, and I think this same thing during almost every action movie/tv show I watch.
I'm not ok after that clip.
@socialex yeah me too
That crunch though, so satisfying...
Just wanted to post this. WEAR A SEAT BELT AT ALL TIMES. I lived what happened to Vincent in “Bleed for This”. Three of us in the car at highway speed with a head on collision. Two lived. Obviously me being one. Why. Two has seat belts on. My other friend hit the windshield head first and died seconds later. I was in the icu for a night due to injuries sustained from the force of stopping in such a short distance. The SEAT BELT not only saved my life, but also broke my ribs, and I had a small fracture on one vertebrae. Now imagine what may have happened to me (I was in the back seat) without a seat belt on. I’ll make it easy. My other friend was in the front passenger iseat directly in front of me. I would have been a 170lb projectile laughed at him from behind while he was a stationary object. If I wasn’t wearing my seatbelt. I would have died and killed him in the process. It’s so easy to do. Just WEAR it. Since then, I’ve been in situations where older vehicles has broken belts or none at all. I made other plans. It’s that serious. Also want to say to the doctor, I was able to stand and pull my living friend out of the vehicle off pure adrenaline. No my deceased friend was not laying against the door with his head out the window. He was actually sitting in his seat like he was driving still. But the facial trauma was there as was the cracked windshield with blood on it. So that view is a 9/10 for me in terms of realism. Less blood in real life, and obviously a 0/10 for survival. ALSO important. Caused by a drunk driver. It’s 2020. If you plan to drink ANYTHING. Make sure you do not drive. Take an Uber, cab, or call a friend. If all else fails, call your local police. They WILL help you get home safe.
Oh my god I'm so sorry that happened to you. Seatbelts are so important and it's such a shame that people refuse to do it. Even if you survive, the effects can be catastrophic. At 19 my father was in a collision (driver was drunk), he wasn't wearing a seatbelt and was flung from the passenger seat. Ended up partially paralyzed. He was an athlete but he can't run or jump anymore, he's had dozens of surgeries on his back and knees and hips, has chronic pain and is permanently on crutches. He'll need a wheelchair eventually.
Also have a family friend who was in a van crash without a seatbelt. Three others who weren't wearing seatbelts died and the friend suffered a terrible brain injury that's taken a decade to recover from. Even now she struggles and isn't quite how she used to be. Everyone else in the van who was wearing a seatbelt? Absolutely fine. These things are absolutely preventable.
Thank you for reminding me of my deep hatred against drunk drivers. Too many good people have died from those assholes.
I had motorcycle crash at 115mph and believe me still after 6 years my back pain is 7 into 10
But hi Thank god i am alive
Yeowch that sounds painful. But I'm glad you're still alive!
Speed recovery, mate 😭
You should try to find a DO that specializes in ONMM.
Pretty sure you've heard about chiropractic. That might be your remedy
Im actually glad bleed for this had such a good score compared to others even though its still a 6/10😂
Can't believe Christopher Nolan put something unrealistic in his movie.
Because he's batman
@@aryankaushik93 because he's Deadpool playing Batman.
Its funny this batman was suppose to be more real but there is so much unrealistic stuff
@@thestranger9608 he is more realistic than all other superheroes
@@aryankaushik93 the correct answer is the Punisher
This man has 0 enthusiasm and is completely stoic. Why am I so entertained by this? lol
He seen horrible shit and probably adjusted a guy's vertebrae after this video
It's in stark contrast to the extreme nature of what he's talking about.
Why would he be enthusiastic? Yeah it's a movie, but he sees the real deal probably on the daily...and not all of them even make it
Hes enthusiastic to share his knowledge, yes
And he was a combat medic, dudes hard
My whole body is hurting after watching this video.
I always pop my knees when in my bed. I am in my bed as I watch this and Im scared to death to pop them
Mine too. I'm getting 😨 scared now. I think I'm going to move away from unrealistic films from now on. Don't want that crap occupying my head & influencing me to have unrealistic expectations.
Batman: *gets vertebrae punched into place
Me: sleeps funny and is sore for days
Sleeps slightly out of the groove my body has made in the mattresses 😂
@R. Schowiada71 Are you sure Batman only had a single vertebra lunched in? Could've been more than one. I never saw his Xray.
I slept weird like two weeks ago and my neck still hurts. It was so bad that I literally couldn't turn my head for the first three days.
I love how understated he is whenever he's like "tearing your blood vessels after a motor crash could be considered pretty fatal"
I love how he is rating it on survivability, not in realism
Its based on how realistically they'll survive 🤯
Well I dislike that. NOW how am I going to learn how to fake a spinal injury?
Came for this
it took me a sec to get that 😂
Why does everyone say she dies from him breaking her back with the one web around her waist? Her head clearly hits the floor, you hear it aswell, definitely one of the most brutal deaths in a 'marvel' film.
I’m guessing maybe he’s saying that it wouldn’t have been a survivable injury regardless of if she hit her head or not? Based on how the web attached to her body.
Even if she never hit tiger ounce he would’ve had to decelerate her body extremely fast and she would’ve snapped her neck anyway to at least paralyzed or death
Because that's how she dies in the comics
@ShalakumX Simba Imagine thinking being subjected to more violence that you've become accustomed to it is a good thing 💀
Is rating how realistic it is or the survival rate? I'm confused why he gave the spiderman scene a zero
To call Dr Webb an "orthopedic spine surgeon" is selling him very short.
He has had a quite stunning career and been a true hero. I rarely see this brought up.
The man has survived over 100 mortar attacks while saving the lives of almost 1000 people during his military career. And just continued saving lives after it.
Wow. WOW. Thanks. 👍✅
This man deserves to play the doctor role in John Wick 4
I like his matter of fact delivery.
I think the last thing they need is him on the set calling, “Bullshit, that guy will never get up from that fall. Hell no, I ain’t co-signing that bs on camera.”
The hole movie would be John wick in a hospital bed
Nah he's dead!
Interested! Ha
thank god there are these health professionals cause if I ever saw someone in an accident scene with leg amputations i'd be passed out for sure
No joke. I never look at car accidents. what you put in your head you can't take out.
Me: nah, he can take that
Him: He will absolutely NOT survice
Me: Agreed
This guy is the oprah of death: YOU get a fatal injury and YOU get a fatal injury and YOU get a fatal injury and YOU-
But but he’s Batman
Michael Keaton Voice -
"No, I'm Batman"
“That’s a pretty hard fall...” lol
The movies:
Literally everyone else:
Him: nope they’re definitely dead.
LOL so funny.
Jesus Christ! John Wick: "The chance of someone getting up and walking from a fall like this is pretty low 1/10" No he would most likely be dead!
The Revenant: "Leonardo DiCaprio is in shock" WTF! It cannot have something to do with him wanting the bear to think he is dead or at least not a threat. The amazing spider-man 2: Not mentioning that the webb gave her head a whipping effect, smashing the back of her head against the ground! Would think it would be worth mentioning since her head would crack like an egg.
@@schaubdanaareeskimobrother9013 pretty sure the bear wouldn't just stop to think "wow maybe this person isn't a threat, I'll just leave now"
@@CarlosGutierrez-qw6pr Oh dude! Have you seen this movie?? It is a mother bear with her cub. The reason she attacked was to defend her cub! Once your no longer a threat they usually leave you alone. There are countless of examples of mama bears attacking or almost attacking because they want to defend there cubs. However it is extremely rare that a bear attack humans because it wants to eat you! If so, the bear is usually starving to death. Men with guns is also in a higher risk of getting killed by bears than people without guns. The bear often do a charge attack, a "fake" attack where It comes at you full speed, only to stop 15 - 25 feet away from you. This attack is just to scare you away, but men with guns will often open fire because of the natural fear. if they don't kill it but hurt it, the bear will attack 4real.
@@schaubdanaareeskimobrother9013 it depends what kind of bear tho. If it was a Grizzly Bear or a Polar bear they will literally rush the person and end his career
Doctor: This is an unsurvivable ingury
Gwen Stacy: I know
This made me laugh out loud 🤣
broke my tibia and confirm adrenaline allowed me to walk about 10 feet before collapsing from pain.
1:37 i love that deadpan "that's a pretty hard fall"
That car crash with people thrown out reminds me of a story that our neigbour's wife told my parents back in the late 80s/early 90s. I overheard the story as a young lad and it still gives me chills.
So our neighbour back then was a firefighter paramedic. Great guy, always funny and always telling the best jokes. Turned out that he had to be medically retired due to severe PTSD.
He had been struggling before but never openly spoke about anything that happened at work. The straw that broke the camel's back for him, according to his wife, was a late night car crash involving an intoxicated driver and a young woman. Driver lost control, flipped the car and crashed. Passenger was not wearing a seatbelt and was ejected from the car. Our neighbour was the guy who found her unresponsive in the undergrowth in a ditch at the side of the road. She was, as he said months later, roughly the size and age of his daughter and also had long blonde hair which was pretty tangled up. When he wanted to move her hair to the side to take a look at her face...he found that her head was twisted 180 degrees. She was pronounced dead at the scene "due to injuries incompatible with life". What followed were years of therapy for him, and that was at a time where mental health was barely talked about openly and any mental issues were kept a secret, because "what will people think?!". Oh, and the driver only sustained a few bumps and bruises and was able to walk away. No idea what became of him though - but I hope he was punished. There are just no winners in this story.
Werner....I know you cannot read this anymore, but I am so sorry you had to live through this. :'(
❤️
Mike Tyson: “I broke my back”...
This Doctor: “sir, your body is made up of a complex system of..
Mike Tyson: “spinal”
Underrated comment
Sthpinal
I like that everyone like this guy so much that no one talks about the camera quality..
nobody can stand watching these injuries so doesn't even notice the camera quality
Pretty sure it's just his laptop/tablet/phone webcam over Zoom. After almost a year of video calls you realise some people have terrible internet and cameras.
Pandemic
Bruh, we are all to focused on all that he is saying.
Checking my Spine while watching this video
Reading this comment made me want to check my spine was ok
my homie died from internal bleeding after his motorcycle accident. he also was doing 118 so... also gwen stacy not only breaks her spine but the back of her head was probably caved in...
Him: i like sounds of bones breaking
Me:...
there's also a crackling sound when you alineate a fracture that is SOOOO satisfying
Yeah, it's a bit weird to hear but thats probably because I'm not an orthopedic surgeon lol
I died at that y-strap demonstration
that *NOISE*
I imagine it's easier to stand the noises when you know you're fixing the person and not crippling them. 😂
Made me retch a little, not going to lie
God i bet it feels goood
It's amazing how totally broken people can get, and just as amazing how some people can fully recover from those same injuries
I wish he covered the scene in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 2 where Doc Ock stabbed the needles into his spine to attach the robot arms to his body. That can't be healthy for the spine.
Well considering that he now gets a grafted exoskeleton, his spine is actually healthier !
Just kidding, it must hurt like hell all the time and ESPECIALLY when he walks on those legs which are externally drifted in his spine core lol.
@@oneoranota imagine lying down or sitting down. Ouch
@@oneoranota maybe that's why he's a villain lmao he's actually in incredible pain all the time and it causes him to hate the world
@@BenjiQ575 That's a good one
Spider-Man*
As soon as this started, I immediately sat up a little straighter
The doctor is so calm and precisely describes what he's really think what is "actually" happening depending on the scenes is pretty much appreciated.
*Neck cracking*
Everybody:...
Doc: I love those sounds!
Seems like the ?/10 scale keeps switching between "how real" and "how survivable".
1000/10
It's how realistically they'll survive
No, it's "how survivable" for this video
I was in an ER room years ago and was fortunate to see an orthopedic surgeon set a hip joint. You have to be pretty damn strong while you’re standing on top of somebody pulling their limb in what appears to be barbaric abuse! It took A LOT of violent tugging to get that hip back in place. It was very odd to see in a modern ER.
Sometimes the old ways are the best ways. Now where did I put my leeches?
In the immortal words of CinemaSins: "He survives this"
In the immortal words of Th3Birdman:
"you padding the sin count bro? I think you're padding the sin count".
Weekly Dose of Aviation: "Luckily no one was injured"
Dr. Webb: "Here's all the ways you can die when you break this bone"
Thank you Dr. Webb for doing the challenges you do. Thank you also for taking the time to work with Insider on these videos.
*sounds of neck breaking*
"I love that sounds."
Yep. Nice intro.
This spine surgeon is awesome. He has his own channel. His story is very inspirational.
He’s got the white coat on, Everything he says carries more weight with me.
I had a c1/c2 spinal fusion and was in a halo for 3 months. The scene in Bleed For This is spot on.
Anyone else get funny feeling in their legs when watching videos like this? Like something is holding your kneecaps or something. I don’t know if I should run away or what, I don’t speak legs so well, but I endured the whole thing and gained nothing but pain, misery and propably lost one night of good sleep from it.
I should sleep
When I see people getting hurt, my knees ache. It has always been like that. I thought I was the only one
you're probably contracting your legs musscles
My legs tingle
I get that feeling in my feet and shins! I'm so glad it isn't just me! We are clearly empathetic people!!!
He gives the Gwen Stacey scene 0/10, saying it's an "unsurvivable injury"... yes, we know, that's why she died. So it's a pretty accurate scene then, 10/10
I think he rated the survivability (if that word exists) of the injury not the accuracy. Therefore 0 is correct. Not survivable
You didn’t understand his score system clearly
read the title again dude, it says "Rates Based On Chances Of Survival"
When Leo was laying still in the revenant clip, it wasn’t really because he was in shock. He was a hunter in that film and he knew the best chance he had at survival was playing dead
"Your heart, your lungs, your kidneys..." *points at liver"
Lmao
I have been watching Dr. Webb’s TH-cam channel for a long time now and I’m inspired at all he has done which gives me hope and strength to get through my classes to hopefully one day be where he is.
I was in a head-collision in 2011. Both vehicles combine impact was 100mph. I just remembered everything going completely dark , and I couldn't see anything , but I could hear it , and feel my car spinning . I was pretty lucky . Had to have stitches in multiple places , including my face above my right eye. My head was hitting the air bag so hard , and repeatedly to were the stitching gave me these perfect line cuts that looked like Freddy Kruger cut me from my eyebrow across the forehead on the right side. The ER Doctor said it was one of the weirdest scares he's seen from airbag. Also the airbag gave burns all over arms & legs , and I suffered from stage 3 concussion , which can be dangerous ..only stage higher is a 4. Present day I have a bad back , and some days it really sucks , especially standing 10 to 11 hours at work, but considering the wreck I was in , and literally walking out of it , I should be counting my blessings .
I took first aid & CPR my Jr yr of high school - Mr VanValkenberg, I’ll never forget him, one of my favorite teachers. He told us how he saw a high school football player take a helmet to one of his collateral knee ligaments and it snapped. Mr Van said it sounded like a gunshot. He ran onto the field to help set the kid’s misaligned knee and told the kid not to hold back his mouth when Mr Van pulled on it. The kid screamed the most foul language he’d ever heard. But the thing that really haunts me to this day is Mr V describing the sound when the kid’s ligament went.
Movies that show patients on mechanical ventilators are often ridiculously inaccurate too. 🤣 But I’m a Respiratory Therapist with many, many years of experience. However, even when I was a student in training, I could clearly see the gross discrepancies. It’s fun to see how you’re able to use these movie clips as teachable moments. My guess is that everyone with deeper knowledge in their occupations could also point out similar Hollywood gaffes, 😂. But at least they create more dramatic scenes 🎥🎬🍿. Thanks Doctor for sharing!😉
I notice it too, likely because i've been Vent dependent 27/7 since 2010. Having renal failure and MD(DMD) let pneumonia take me down. 60 day coma resulted.
My wife is an experienced RT as well, and she's always going off on TV shows and movies when it comes to vent and airway inaccuracies. 🤣🤣 I'm always like, "It's just a movie babe" 🙄 Lol!
It go's the same for ex soldiers watching war movies and chefs like me watching all the kitchen magic and me trying not to explode knowing that what she or he is preparing or cutting is not what they show seconds later.
@@TitusFFM Are you referring to the Rachel Ray type shows or the cooking competition type shows? It would be interesting to know how much they actually prepare on set.
Yeah. I saw one movie where the “ET tube” was actually a yankauer and it only went up to the first bend. I can’t remember anything else from the scene because that was all I could focus on.
“Bleed for this” is a true story. Vinny Paz survived and went back to boxing.
Dr Webb, I'm so excited to see you on Wired.. Finally 😊
Thank you!
The amount of chills I’ve get just by listening to him and watching this video.
As someone that’s been in a MVC rollover, he is correct about the cervical collar. Thing was so tight that I could hardly breathe
Ayyyyy it's Dr. Webb!!! His youtube channel is great 👏🏽👏🏽
I thought that was Chidi in the thumbnail.
Haha
Dr Webb is awesome. Have seen his videos for years. Humble sounding dude.
I could listen to this guy all day!
Follow his channel! He’s great!
@@jaycechristian7023 what's the name of it?
@@jaycechristian7023 I did, I found it and it’s very cool too! Thanks 🤘🏻
@@trevorjames7490 Just search "Antonio Webb". He is a great surgeon and even greater person. Check it out.
Thank you!
11:05 that fall broke my heart
I died laughing 😂😂 there were so many ways he could've saved her but since he holds back his full strength she was just collateral damage spiderman is a manipulator don't be fooled
5:32 I lost it, when he thought the blood came from his his neck, but he got stabbed twice in the back. Didn't he hnow that stabbed people in movies always bleeding from their mouth? :D
Jackie Chan : Hold my beer doctor.
"Been to Iraq as a combat medic." Hell yeah, 68W's represent
When a patient come in with these falls we generally call it a YACF injury. You Are Completely Fucked it's usually fatal
.. most patients will die : 2/10
Gallows humor lol
This is how imagine an ideal doctor to be stoic and completely objective. Real Professional.
John wick didn’t walk away someone took him and Spider-Man her head made contact with the ground
I think he walked off the fact that he couldn't save her pretty quickly 🤷
Was expecting a fun time, but this video triggered my anxiety.
longtime subscriber to Dr Webb's channel here, thank you for having him on this series!
Let's be honest we are happy and regretful we watched this.
The Revenant! I read the book about him, WOW! The stuff he went through, but he was able to survive and eventually walk again, just amazing.
When I was going to a chiropractor, I was beyond nervous when it came to the neck snap. It didn't help that she said "Do not tense up your neck when I do this. Stay calm." I was like "WTH, am I going to die?!?!".
But after she snapped my neck I felt WONDERFUL instantly. Not just because of the sound but because you literally feel better. Sadly I couldn't afford it after about a year and now I feel like crap again.
"snapped my neck"
There's been no scientific evidence for chiropractor effectiveness except for some improvement in lower back pain
Chiropractors are quacks. It will do more damage in the long term. Get yourself a good physical therapist.
Use yoga to accomplish the same muscular elongations.
Take a good look at your ergonomics, how you sit, especially if you sit for long periods of time, at a desk or computer.
Also make sure your pillow provides good neck support. If it doesn't your neck can't relax while you sleep and it doesn't get as much blood flow as it might if it's too tense. so you don't get the nutrition and waste removal and healing you might have.
@Sketsaryan Not in my case. People who need it repeatedly may have bad habits and need to examine their ergonomics, and sleep pillow neck support. Also yoga can do the same thing in many cases.
Funny. The scene where the dude got a halo actually happened. He was a pro boxer. Got in a head on and opted for a halo rather than fused spine to fix the injury. Came back and won the title.
Ayyyy nice to see Dr. Webb make it on these videos
"This can be very fatal..." Glad he clarified. I was thinking just being 'kinda' fatal I'd be alright.
This guy is a hero I can imagine he saved many lives as a combate medic
This brought back some unhappy memories. My daughter fell on her back . First thing: I kept her calm so she doesn't move, because she tried snall moves, but they hurt her and made it hard for her to breath. Called the ambulance . They took about 40 min to secure her head and body. Back injuries need attentive securing on the strecher. Thank God it was only a muscle injury and nothing worse. Since then she is very careful with how she jumps.
Tobey: i'm baaaaaack!!!!
Surgeon: survival rate 10/10 but his back, his back.
the best part is him giving his best shot too take the anchorman 2 scene seriously without laughing
Scream: that squirt of blod is not from a neck artery, it's from his mouth, indicating a stab in his lungs.
Spider Man: it's not her spine that killed her, it's the fact that she slamed the back of her head in the floor at around terminal velocity that killed her.
and while interesting to see the survivability rating, i would rather first see a realism rating first.
the following is completely unrelated to the video.
i had a uncle (my dad's brother) who was in a car accident, he drove a Opel Corsa A, the other was a drunk driver in a Dodge van 89, frontal collision on a country road (80 km/h)
his wife, my aunt (my mom's sister) who sat next to him survived with only her left arm ripped off and some broken bones, he, the driver on the other hand was a unidentifieable mess of meat.
my dad was some distance behind them when it happened and was the one who called for help, yesturday (13-11-2020) was the 30th aniversary of the accident, my dad still have regular nightmares of the accident.
Hey man hope everything is getting better. I lost my uncle in a similar fashion. Take care and make sure you reach out for help should you need it.
He loves those sounds because he knows he's fixing something. The rest of us hate those sounds because we don't know if we're being paralyzed until we wiggle our toes.
Maybe I missed something, but is Dr. Webb rating the authenticity of the scene in some of his scores, and the likelihood of surviving it in others??
Even when "I Bleed for This" is a true story. Wish he went into the neck exercise they guy went into.
My face was frozen in a flinching expression this whole commentary. Whewwwwww.
When I was at the psychiatrie because of my depressions I got a lumbar puncture. U have to make a cat hump and the doctor is gonna remove some "nerve water" between your spine with a long ass needle. Your all the time awake and u feel everything. The pressure you get inside of yourself while the needle is inside of you is unbelievable.
@R. Schowiada71 thanks for the kind words and the correction. Have a good day bud
So, they bury him, but he was still alive! He'd heard every word. So, he ends up having to crawl across the wilderness, and then made a raft to go on the river, was out there for SIX weeks surviving on roots and berries., with no pain medication whatsoever! So, just goes to show what someone will do to survive!!
Yessss, they got ma boy Antonio big time!! 💪🏾 Keep grinding bro
Appreciate that! 👊🏾
I fall asleep in an awkward position
My body:
*"So you have chosen death"*
This was a great video! Very informative and fun.
He describes these gruesome injuries so matter-of-fact, it’s like my mechanic describing problems with my car.
“Yeah, so, you need a new timing belt and your vertebra is sticking out of your back. I’ll need a couple of days to get the parts.”
"You can collect three liters of blood inside the chest"
- Err, isn't the human blood full volume around 5 liters?
- Yeah, so? What part of "serious injury" didn't you get?
- video of chiropactor "fixing"someone's neck
Urgh. In another life, I was training in animal experimentation (changed track quickly, didn't like it, wasn't good at it), and one way to kill mice in lab is termed "cervical elongation".
I didn't try myself, but no way I'll let a chiro practice a cervical elongation on me.
I recently dislocated my shoulder. I am immensely grateful for Propofol and not having any memory of someone popping my arm back in and not hearing the sound. Hearing it once was ENOUGH TYVM