Transformers One SPOILER REVIEW - What Worked And What Didn't

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ธ.ค. 2024

ความคิดเห็น •

  • @7472wayne
    @7472wayne 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +13

    A good 8/10. Megatron’s transformation from D16 was slightly rushed, but I couldn’t fault anything else.

    • @702Sinatra
      @702Sinatra 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I didn’t feel like it was rushed. Imo. I thought it was done perfectly. Megatron was the “company guy”, follow the rules. Loved the boss. But then in a short amount of time he seen how his boss was using him and his friends, selling out his race to their sworn enemies, and took out their cogs at birth so they can live miserable lives as slaves to give himself a better life. He found all that out in 5 minutes. So it makes sense for him who was an intense supporter or fan to do a complete 180 and want to kill and expose Sentinel. It felt like a more realistic response than Optimus who was always the rule bender but then finds out sentinel was evil and just kind of being like “we’ll expose him and live happily ever after”

  • @tripleairgoddess
    @tripleairgoddess 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    thank goodness. someone who actually gave us a real review instead of "best movie ever" stuff. I'll still see it because I need to analyze things for myself.

  • @fishpop
    @fishpop 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    "The Fall" actually takes cues from the 86 ost, specifically the music when Prime finally succumbs to his wounds.

  • @DavidSilva-mn4dz
    @DavidSilva-mn4dz 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I think D16 to Megs turn is natural if we want a foil for D is not in Orion, it is in Elita-One. Both follow the protocol to a T yet the latter ads Orion's optimism on her outlook, slowly developing a kinship to Pax's. D-16 on the other hand is always led by Orion, he just wanna work and yearns yet doesn't work for it, is Orion who always push him forward, is curious that D admires the Heavy Hitter of the Primes while Orion's is not idolizing them as much. So when D turns into Megatron he see the opportunity to be on top, he is harbouring resentment while Pax use that to fuel them to seek a better future. Megatron is slapped to the face when the planet inself, Primus and the freaking Primes including Megatronus Prime chose Orion to turn into the new leader and bringer of Life, Optimus Prime. Megatron now have the Elite Guard thirst of past glory that will follow him to justify their existence and conflict. Megatron will gaslight everyone to justify his new low vices. I love that this saga will see the 2 coins of post revolution: Reform and change vs Destruction and the same system with different opresors.

    • @pepita2437
      @pepita2437 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Well written.
      I agree with you.

  • @MrTragedious986
    @MrTragedious986 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    I felt like once Megatron saw the truth and gets his T-Cog, his turn to the bad guy felt pretty abrupt since during the first half he’s always like chilled guy but now he’s rash, delusional, and really angry all of the sudden.
    Should have like few more scenes of him becoming evil.

    • @pepita2437
      @pepita2437 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      'and really angry all of the sudden'
      He just learned that he was mutilated before he came online, just like millions of other transformers, who were forced into the mines, and lived like secondary citizens. (and there are things which the movie implies, like when D-16 told that they deserved being hit because they talked back to a supervisor, or how some workers weren't even allowed to leave the production areas they worked in)
      He learned that all the humiliation, hardship, and abuse he went trough was for nothing. I would be angry as well.

    • @MrTragedious986
      @MrTragedious986 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@pepita2437 yes i would piss as well after the person that I looked up is a liar. But I wish they have like have 15 more minutes to flash it out.

    • @ethanpena2030
      @ethanpena2030 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@MrTragedious986it is not needed, what happened in the film was great and doesn't need changes or it was "rushed"

    • @MrTragedious986
      @MrTragedious986 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @ if it gives few scenes of his turn then I’ll buy it. Still a good movie.

  • @TakeTheJurny
    @TakeTheJurny 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    I agree with everything you said man, shocked no one else felt the megatron evilness was rushed and a bit all over the place motivation wise. Still good and yeah they didn't want to make a 2 hour movie but they def could have cut a few scenes prob from the first 2 acts.

    • @sparkside217
      @sparkside217  3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Feels like a lot of TF fans are just kinda taking him becoming evil at face value because it's something we already know is gonna happen, which is basically my main critique of the movie. Even the second time, I felt like it would've been trivial to at least give him one angry outburst in the beginning, or save Orion a few times so that "I'm done saving you" made more sense

    • @pepita2437
      @pepita2437 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I still think him behaving the way he did makes sense.
      Sentinel mutilated millions of bots even before they came online. HE mutilated D-16. And then he forced them into working in the mines, living their lives as secondary citizens. (and there are things which the movie implies, like when D-16 told that they deserved being hit because they talked back to a supervisor, or how some workers weren't even allowed to leave the production areas they worked in)
      Sentinel exploited them, opressed them, and then turned around and basked in their admiration, and praise, behaving like their benefactor.
      I pretty much understand the anger D-16 felt, and why he changed so drastically.

    • @sparkside217
      @sparkside217  3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@pepita2437 Yes, being mad at Sentinel made perfect sense. But why drop Orion? What did he do besides get in the way a bit, and when did he save him before to warrant "I'm done saving you"?

    • @pepita2437
      @pepita2437 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@sparkside217 Orion betrayed D-16.
      He protected the person who ruined D-16's life, Orion protected a person who took everything form D-16.
      They were friends, almost like brothers, shouldn't have Orion stood by his side?
      Yes, I know Orion was right, and he did not betray D-16. But from D-16's perspective... I undertsand why he believed he was betrayed.
      Also yeah, D-16 did saved Orion multiple times. The movie starts by Orion being chased by police, D-16 saved him by distracting them, and smuggled Orion on the train (and it was made clear that this was not the only time this happened). Or D-16 took the punch Orian would have gotten after Elita was fired. Or he saved Orion's life not long after they got their T-cogs, and there was a vehicon trying to shoot at Orion (the first time we saw D-16's vehicle mode) Or D-16 pretty much saved all of them when he kickd Starscream's ass (they would have been tortured, and killed btw)

    • @sparkside217
      @sparkside217  3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@pepita2437 Good point, I guess those are some good examples of him saving Orion. I think maybe though those acts were overshadowed by the race sequence, where he doesn't save him, and it's more about Orion putting them in danger
      And when he saves them from Starscream, I feel that could have been a little cleaner in terms of pointing that out. Feels like D was already just thinking about himself at that point rather than any concern for Orion

  • @702Sinatra
    @702Sinatra 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Megatron(from this movie) was a person who followed the rules, stayed out of trouble and lived his life that way. When Optimus kept dragging him into unnecessary situations it was already making him upset but in the end, he had the mindset that it would get them recognized by sentinel. So when the sentinel betrayal happens Megatron is broken and blames Optimus because he feels like if they just fell in line, that would’ve never been revealed to him and he wouldn’t have a rage of wanting to kill Sentinel. Never the less his mind is no longer in following the rules but on killing Sentinel. The “I’m not going to save you anymore” comes from the places of, every bad situation you’ve been in, you got yourself into it, running from the security guards at the beginning, getting Megatron punched. Was all Optimus Primes fault. So when he shot Optimus on accident he tried to save him at first. But he became conflicted because Optimus always gets him in trouble, always disrupts his way of life (at this point it’s become revenge) and is a burden. Optimus sees him contemplating that’s why he says “No” then Megatron fully embraces the fact that Optimus is dead weight to him and he’s going to kill Sentinel no matter what. Megatron was written perfectly in this movie I feel like. You can see his eyes continue to get darker the more his mental state becomes “corrupted”(I don’t even think corrupted but from revenge, to destructive) you never see in this movie him flat out say he has an evil plan to rule the world. But his actions started becoming that of a dictator

  • @RubberhoseYTP
    @RubberhoseYTP 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    My only two gripes with this movie are D-16’s rushed character progression and b-127 but other than that this movie is amazing

  • @fishpop
    @fishpop 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    12:40 Airachnid, not Blackarachnia

  • @fishpop
    @fishpop 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Having Peter Cullen as Primus would've been cool

  • @juniorramirez2314
    @juniorramirez2314 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    Tell me how many times and even off screen have d-16 save orion so many times and doesnt listen to him so why does d-16 have to listen him when sentinel torched d-16 and 2 even said dont be like sentinel comparing him to sentinel that was crazy in my opinion if you think abt it but then again igz idk understand you saying it was quick. Also d16 would know that orion would still try get in his way not to kill sentinel prime so idk.

  • @pepita2437
    @pepita2437 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Things I did not liked in this movie:
    I don't like the magically getting powers aspect. Megatron was such a formidable warrior in other continuties, because of his focus, skill, determination, hard work, and lust for violence. In this version I feel like it cheapens Megatron character that his power, and skill does not come from centuries of struggle, and self improvement. In other continuities Megatron uses violence as a precision tool. In this film, he doesn't know what he's doing, and he gets flabbergated by his own agression/violence.
    A Megatron who got his transformation powers five hours ago beating Starscream (the leader of the High Guard) is just absurd. This elevates the T-cogs to some mystical macguffin instead of a simple organ which just allows bots to transform.
    I also don't like that most of the Autobot cast can be seen in the mines. I foud it cool that originally there were autobts from all classes. There were scientists like Perceptor, or Wheeljack, or nobles Mirage, doctors like Rachet, First Aid, police like Prowl, even Cultural invstigators like Jazz.
    I wish they spent a bit more time fleshing out the class system which the wrietrs kind of imported from the IDW/Aligned continuity.
    Alsoabout the 'refrences' they throw at you.
    There is a ton of them. And a lots of people won't even notice. There are little inconsequential easter eggs like Orion spending his time in the Archives, being a history nerd (which is a clever nod to TFP) and there are lore elements taken from previous TF media which pretty much influences the plot in significant ways. Like the caste system (which was taken form the IDW/Aligned continuity) D-16's low class miner bot origins (again taken form IDW, and Aligned continuty) Orion being a low class manual labourer (G1) Orion being sworn brother with Megatron, fighting against a false Prime, and his opressive corrupt government (Aligned continuity).
    Every single story arc, lore you see in this movie are taken form already existing lore. :)

    • @sparkside217
      @sparkside217  3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Yeah I agree about it being an amalgamation of existing lore, but visually there were very few queues or characters from the franchise. I just personally prefer the Cyberverse approach that mixes characters, rather than starting over with G1 characters for the hundredth time
      And that kinda speaks to what you're saying about all of them being miners. Like not only is it all G1, they're all already together in the mines? Why not mix it up at least a little bit for future stories/spin-offs

    • @ethanpena2030
      @ethanpena2030 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Yeah your just wrong :/

  • @alberts8305
    @alberts8305 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I thought i saw red alert in a background shot

    • @sparkside217
      @sparkside217  3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      The G1 version was clearly there but I didn't see the Armada one if that's what you meant

  • @somerandomhater490
    @somerandomhater490 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    6/10 for me. Top 2 Transformer movie tho. I didn’t think it was bad but felt very rushed. The first two acts were ok. 3rd act was really good but carries the rating in the movie. This movie coulve been so much better if they went a different route that dives deeper into other bots like jazz,red alert, shockwave, thunder cracker,etc the list goes on lol. One thing that absolutely bugged me was that Optimus didn’t want megatron to kill sentinel but he had to problem bumblebee killing vechicons while enjoying in fact HE LAUGHED AFTERWARDS. Also how in the world did megatron lose to arachnid but elita-1 who has zero fighting experience beats with ease arachnid the assassin who sees everything. Like am I being picky or is that not good criticism.

    • @geohyuga5778
      @geohyuga5778 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I think they gave Elita too much credit and I only saw the trailers to understand that

    • @tripleairgoddess
      @tripleairgoddess 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@somerandomhater490 I haven't seen it yet, but when I get time, I think Elita One looks too much like Arcee in the face. And if Optimus Prime is Orion Pax, her name should be Ariel, with a pony tail.

    • @ethanpena2030
      @ethanpena2030 หลายเดือนก่อน

      My guy the "soldiers" were basically drones, they talk nothing like normal cybertronians :/

    • @somerandomhater490
      @somerandomhater490 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@ethanpena2030 my guy I know that they are used for comedic effect in other shows but in this movie Orion doesn’t know that they are droids or mindless they see them as loyal soldiers to sentinel prime. Just another Cybertronian bot. It’s bad writing and it can be blamed on the fact that the movie was rushed.just like d-16 change. He made it seem like Orion was just one big liability too him.

  • @kendrickvieraramos
    @kendrickvieraramos 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Oh yeah sparkside I know what store you can visit buddy’s toys and collectibles

  • @Verschal
    @Verschal 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Getting a Blurr (or whom ever cameo) i would loved that, however if a movie is filled with that, your no longer watching a movie, you are looking for the next reference. This is why i watched Fallout (by our vault-tec) twice, it was great, but very distracting.
    Megatron letting Orion pax go is poetic to me.
    Your g1 argument does not make sense, this was at the very start. Why would there be anyone from those generations?
    There are some miner :) nit picks with this movie, but it is good fun at the end of the day it is a kids movie with homage to kids from 40 years ago.
    Edit: I am a dumbass: Arachnid is also not G1, she is from transformers prime,so your argument makes sense.

    • @sparkside217
      @sparkside217  3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Well I don't want the movie to have references for the sake of them, but if you're gonna have multiple scenes with huge casts, why not include some familiar faces for fans, especially younger fans who grew up with different casts or versions of characters? Just felt like an obvious thing to do for fun that I was surprised didn't happen.

  • @AJFromBatuu
    @AJFromBatuu 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Sentinel Prime’s chin wasn’t large enough, 0/10.

  • @J_Cat3910
    @J_Cat3910 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    3:28 that “nice wonder theme” is from the final episode of Transformers Prime season 3, where bumblebee dies in the finale.

    • @sparkside217
      @sparkside217  3 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Wait really, is it the same score?

    • @J_Cat3910
      @J_Cat3910 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@sparkside217 yep

    • @tafa_matai3184
      @tafa_matai3184 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      I believe that theme also plays at the end of Season 2 when the Autobots abandon their base. I could be wrong though.

  • @geohyuga5778
    @geohyuga5778 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Are Megatron and Optimus getting taller after their final transformation ?

    • @maxmc55_0
      @maxmc55_0 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      yes

    • @sparkside217
      @sparkside217  3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      yeah they make that explicit

  • @unplugged123
    @unplugged123 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    i didnt like the animation style and designs. felt like i was watching a 1.5 hr version of the transformers animated tv show. optimus and megatron felt too modern, "bro"-ey. and megatrons turn happened way too fast.
    also they got starscreams voice so wrong.

  • @LeaderoftheKaijuprideOftheprim
    @LeaderoftheKaijuprideOftheprim 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

    At least there's no humans in it at least

    • @sparkside217
      @sparkside217  3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Honestly I have never cared for the whole "we need a movie without humans", but it did work here and was kinda refreshing in some ways.

    • @LeaderoftheKaijuprideOftheprim
      @LeaderoftheKaijuprideOftheprim 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@sparkside217 absolutely for now it may be animation but this time maybe you never know in a few years time will we will get a real nice and proper transformers movie on Cybertron again it'll be probably a different story in a few years time but we still be no humans as well just like this one

  • @Charbelo
    @Charbelo 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    His review was as the same as how this guy reviewed it- terrible and repeatable - also seems he went on Hasbro shopping spree on the last 12 months

  • @ethanpena2030
    @ethanpena2030 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Yeah no, you just objectively wrong about your "criticisms" and the execution of the film :/

  • @sup3414
    @sup3414 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    2:11 Take the L, son.