To give you an idea of how fast this was: Their brain and nervous system were completely destroyed in less time than it takes for a signal to reach the brain.
@@joannakemp3710 Indeed. Imagine you are watching a movie and then the screen turns to black because of a connection error. That's how it was for them.
The Australian engineer who built James Cameron's submersible said "Cameron was obsessive about every detail and would debate for hours as to whether a titanium washer was better than a stainless steel one." That is the kind of attention to detail and seriousness required for such a dangerous venture. Now ask yourself What's worse, Losing your life for $250,000 or Throwing your life away for $250,000?
Both equally bad and dumb … man 250k , bro I’m selling my house for another 250k profit …. And moving to Puerto Escondido Mexico , already have close family friends there , I’ll be the pele Tojo of the town lol .
@@hahahahaha7237 unless the car is only a carbon fiber shitbox too. I mean you can get armored stuff for around that money, bulletproof S-class or something like that.
You don't get powerful engine and sophisticked aerodynamicchassis designed in wind tunnels.Also carbon fiber is more expensive than metal but lighter, reason why carbon fiber cars are expensive.Also high speed gearbox, interiors, 700hp engine, latest tyres and even self healing interiors
Why do people like blaming the billionaires? They paid that much because they were convinced that it was safe. They even said that NASA and other well know agencies approved the Titan when it wasn't the case. That would be convincing for everyone. So it's 1000% fault of Oceangate. They were just billionaires who wanted to see the Titanic, and I don't blame them for that if they had the cash. It's the same with people whose life wish is to see outer space with their eyes. They'd paid a lot of cash for it if their safety is guaranteed.
@@enderethan144 The whole body was probably just liquified by the immense instant pressure. You can imagine what would happen to your body if you squished by the machine they use at junkyards to crush cars. But do it very very fast. Probably liquified instantly.
just remember that carbon fiber itself is glued together, the same as particle board or plywood, it's many layers of base material, but the glue can be the weak point.
@@ericgolightly8450 Faster than that. It happened so fast their brains and nervous systems would have had no time to even register what was happening before being completely destroyed.
No one was vaporized the heat from the implosion would never get hot enough to vaporize cause the rusing water would cool things too quick. All the carbon fiber imploding is incredibly sharp and would have been another reason they died but no one was vaporized the temps just cant get that high enough fast enough......
@@hyy3657No I think he's talking about what ultimately happened based on the debris recovered, and how this simulation failed to accurately depict the implosion based on what we do know... that the front end and tailcone with both intact.
@@TokenTombstone As I was going to St. Ives, I met a man with 7 wives, every wife had 7 sacks, every sack had 7 cats, every cat had 7 kittens, kittens, cats sacks and wives.
I can't wait for a movie to depict this whole debacle that lead up to this. The movie should be called Oceangate: Fall of the Seafaring Titan, and have Stockton Rush as the main character and the doomed anti-hero of the story. I call Kathy Namijy to play Shahzada Dawood's wife lol!
Titan’s hull was made of carbon fiber instead of industry standard metallic. Bonded to titanium caps on both ends sealed via epoxy and galvanized prone bolts. Ocean Gate played Russian roulette with each dive. Not a matter of if but when.
@@gnryushi No lol, there was not enough oxygen available to burn them a lot, and it happened so fast there was no time to really burn them. And even if it was super hot the actual quantity of energy contained in that small volume of air was too low to do any real damage. it also didn't have any real explosive force as it too was surrounded by the ultra high pressures of the depth.
@@gordonbyron5145 It was the speed of compression of the air inside the sub that created all the heat. It was literally the temp of an oversized cylinder of a diesel engine. The speed of compression is the key. There are plenty of actual sub experts that have explained this here.
Unfortunately Rush got the last say - he lived life and built the submersible on his (horribly wrong) terms, and died too fast to have learned anything from it
@@margotamago He must have known before at some point this occurred that he screwed up! A sort of ''damn I screwed up'' moment before the actual implosion.
Evolution says when his next generation comes he will make improvements so in his future generations he'll survive his stupidity Imagine if evolution was actually based on facts
The extremely high temperatures they suffered when exposed to the pressure created at that depth is beyond imagination for most people, thankfully they never knew it happened..
What’s more scary? Knowing that you’re about to die? Like staring down the barrel of a gun, or dying in the hospital? Or NOT knowing you’re about to die? Like casually driving on the streets about to be hit by a drunk driver, or randomly chilling in a submarine deep in the ocean? To me, I’d rather know that I’m about to die, so that my brain can process it. If you die quickly unexpectedly, you never get the chance to process it. You never even knew you died. That’s absolutely terrifying if you ask me. 😔😔
Lmao everyone is just copying what they heard from others. Yes we all know all of this, heard it on the news every time the subject comes up. Can you possibly write a less original comment? Or do you think people really think you are talking from experience?
@@Senator-KO Well, I guess, technically, when you die, you never knew you died? So either way doesn't 'really' matter. But if I had to choose, I'd rather have a 'chance'. I get where you're coming from. How confusing.
fun fact: People have died from implosions but no one has ever experienced them. It takes from around 200 milliseconds to 2 seconds for the pain to be received by the brain. They probably didn't even see it as most implosions take around 40 milliseconds. This one was so deep that some people speculate that it could even take nanoseconds (1 millisecond is 1000000 nanoseconds). Bodies will also never be found. Imagine it as a diesel engine. There's oxygen (gas) inside of the submersible and diesel fuel. When it implodes, the implosion is so fast that it creates so huge pressure that it (with extremely high temperature caused because of it) will destroy every organic material (even bones) inside.
It takes 100 milliseconds for you body to prosses pain, 13 milliseconds for your eyes to prosses sight, and the implosion happend in 1/40 of a milliseconds
I wonder what an actual physicist would say about this, keep in mind that water has alot of mass and inertia, isnt compressable and the pressure of 380 bar at 3800m depth is static pressure - as soon as the hulls resistance to the water is gone and the water is allowed to move its pressure will drop and the water has to be accelerated by the water behind and above it - keep in mind that water isnt compressable so there is no elastic energy stored but the water has to be pushed into the cavity by more water starting to move behind and above it. I highly doubt that these super short times for the implosion people come up with are true. My guess would be that it took at least a tenth of a second - 100 milliseconds. There is no chance it took less than one millisecond - unless there is enough elasticiy and compressability in the water that the high pressure is being maintained once the water is moving into the cavity.
Bro the fucking Logitech controller survived. The implosion blast from the byford Dolphin incident left remains. The one that was blown out the hatch was grossly dismembered
It happens so fast, the didn't even know they died. One second they were looking at the wreckage of the Titanic, the next second they seeing Jack Dawson waving at them.
They all had 1 minute to process the fact that they were all going to die. All while stacked up on top of each other in complete darkness. Must have been chaos inside the sub during this time. They didn't see or feel the implosion, but they were all screaming and crying milliseconds before it happened.
I have a carbon fiber seat post on my bike and it broke after a year of use. I only weigh 100lbs but it snapped like a branch one day while I was biking through the woods. There is no way in hell I would have even gotten on that glued carbon fiber sub even when it was docked.
Try searching MYTHBUSTERS IMPLOSION. That would be a better comparison because they put "something" as experiment and that was gore as hell. Liquification etc.
the video showed an implosion happening at about 1.4 seconds ish and it happened in just 1-5 millaseconds for a total collapse. So it was a minimum of 1000x faster lol
Really nice perspectives but a lot of pieces remained intact irl, including the front hatch as well as the hull from what I believe although carbon fiber was strung everywhere at the ends of it.
Interesting. I'd like a slowed-down and a 'real time' version. The frame rate is such that the real time video would have Titan in one frame and fragments in the next.
Everyone says the implosion was so fast they didnt even feel anything. I am pretty sure that they knew atleast few Seconds before that something is going wrong. They heard atleast something, and death isnt just only about if u feel pain or not.
Yeah, but knowing you are about to dying and actually dying are two separate things. You can't feel pain or conceptualize anything if your brain and literally every other cell in your body is ripped apart and destroyed faster than nerves can communicate with the brain. That is instant death
A newly released text stream indicates that Rush fought the sub for eighteen minutes to try to get it to surface but something on the sub was gaining sea water and holding the sub down. It could have even been an opening in the layers of carbon fiber creating a reservoir for water to be forced into. They knew they were about to die for eighteen very long and terrifying minutes.
the faster than normal descent right from the beginning speaks to a failure from the very beginning, that didn't fully manifest until later. And surely has something to do with their inability to ascend.
Debatable, and in this case especially. There is no proof of any 'afterlife'. The closest they've gotten are the NDE's people have been reporting on and which is an area of research. An NDE, however, would require a functional brain to occur, and in the case of an implosion that's not going to be the case.
With the help of youtube vanced, I was able to speed up the video 5 times. So when watching the 25 times slower one, it was actually 5 times slower or 200ms instead of 40ms. And even there it was insane. I just wonder how it would have appeared if you saw it happen before your eyes.
for a full collapse at that depth less than 5 millaseconds. it would just look like one second there was a submarine and instantly you would be seeing bubbles. You wouldnt see the actual implosion would be too fast.
They said some human remains were found. My guess is as the submarine began to fail, the in rushing water forced/compressed everyone into one of the titanium end caps. Extreme force and heat have left some remnants, sintered onto the titanium cap.
This needs to be in the intro of an oceangate movie,very well done theres gatta be one eventually this story is huge and ties with the most famous ship of all time
There was speculation that the point-of-failure was the acrylic viewing-port, which was only rated to 1300 meters. Also, when they brought up the titanium end-piece of the cylinder, the viewing port had been blown out.
Could not say for sure though coz it might be blown off during the implosion due the water rushing in the hollow space Because the they are to withstand pressure from outside only and can crack much easier with pressure from inside Or it might just have been unscrewed to unload the cap off the ship since there was no other mounting point on the cap . This one is more likely since there was no remains of the metal flange or the nuts and bolts used the mount the acrylic window In case of implosion we would likely found some thing at least 1 bolt hanging in their. So can't say for sure what happened
I think the fact that the ring holding the viewport in being gone suggests that it wasn't the point of failure. It looks more like the spike in pressure inside the pressure vessel forced the viewport out (probably shattering it along the way), and in the process pulled the bolts holding it to the nose right out of the end-cap. If it had shattered first, you'd expect to see that retaining ring still there, probably with remains of the port lodged inside.
Coming back to this a year later, it's at least a small amount of comfort knowing that they felt no pain because of how fast this happened. It happened in around one-thousandth of a second.
not at alllll. Something like this took multiple engines to run for sure such a great job with the way he simulated everything caving in at the exact same time so well done
Rush: "If you want to be safe, never leave your bed. I've broken alot of rules to get where I am." Remember kids; safety is for cowards. If you want to get anywhere in life, ignore all safety. if anyone says what you're doing is dangerous: fire them. safety is a waste of time and gets in the way of innovation. now excuse me while I go build a plane entirely out of highly flammable wood with no parachutes on board and fly it close to a forest fire. my pride is on the line!
@@JeremySnyder-p3d Yes, because it was all uncharted territory and people didn't know what they were doing. this is the modern era and OceanGate had people who knew what they were doing, and fired them. that is no excuse.
This is the most accurate implosion simulation out there. According to latest news, water sipped in through the front titanium ring ripping it off completetly clean of from carbon fiber hull.
They would probably see small cracks forming (on the outside* they would probably start hearing tiny thuds.) a second before the sub completely imploded, in this case they most likely tried an EMBTB but it wouldve been too late, so the sub wouldve just imploded, and wouldve exploded from all that force the sub wouldve developed. It wouldve curled extremely fast, broke into a million pieces and probably both sides wouldve hit causing an explosion. Ive heard carbon fiber breaks fairly easily under extreme force like aircraft aluminum, so it would probably only bend just a tiny bit. Nothing couldve saved them. Any heat wouldve been caused from energy most likely from that pressure build up. Simply, there couldve been one crack that probably caused small flooding, the crew probably tried an emergency main ballast tank blow, but unfortunately being too late, the sub would start shrinking, fiber would start breaking off, the 5 occupants wouldve died, the pressure caused major heat, blasting everything apart. And finally, the loss of communication. We can never know the full answer, but all we can say is that it simply was a fault that lead to 5 deaths.
At that depth there is no such thing as flooding. The pressures and forces involved are either held back or catastrophically let in, there is no inbetween...
They would not see the cracks , there was an inner liner / interior. You could not directly see the pressure hull , and were talking mice fractures , not visible . They heard it before it happened
@@dougle03 The transcipt is suspected of being fake, but if Titan did dive at 50% faster rate than it should have, and if was barely able to ascend even after dropping both ballast and landing gear, there would have to be something compromising the buoyancy. Speculations? Water entering the failing carbon fiber hull due to delamination, equipment in the tail cone section being flooded, or the possibility they had replaced some components with heavier substitutes. However, the only one which would explain the implosion is the hull having been compromised.
@@Katoshi_TakagumiThe Transcript is accurate with the timing. ALSO James Cameron knew already that they did dropped the ballast…. Clearly someone from within communicated this information to him and that same people probably leaked the whole thing. The Sub community is very small.
NO, it did not happen like this, the implosion happened at the rear (it was already leaking at the rear). It propelled everything inside down the carbon tube like a canon (50kg of TNT of force), smashing the contents against the front titanium dome, blowing it, the window off and ring off and out (these items have been found and recovered with human particles on them). So unlike what is so often misrepresented the carbon tube was as least as strong as each titanium end and would not have reacted in the ways shown above, quite the reverse, it would have acted like a gun barrel transporting everything from one end to the other in a millisecond.
End caps were completely intact , only the hull exploded into fragments of carbon fibre , all titanium components maintained their form , including the pieces glued to the carbon fibre that were bolted to the titanium ends . So far I’ve seen one simulation that would be close , minus the hull destruction , in that one they just show it squished , with the human gel being pushed out the porthole at the front . Witch would be more accurate . Probably why there was no porthole , verything went out that way because they think it happened at the back
@@calebmurdock2028 Yup, they were kind of crushed and shoved into the rear dome cap. And the pieces floating around were relatively large compared to the animation too.
I dunno why they didn't just stick the two end caps together to make a solid metal sphere instead of making the body out of a carbon fibre tube...seems like a very obvious failure point when under those extreme presures.
The CEO was trying to make more room to bring down more passengers. Other subs that can do it are spherical but they only have a maximum capacity of 2 including the pilot. It was all about the $$$.
As cool as this is it’s incredibly inaccurate The implosion is hypersonic. It’s unfathomably quick and powerful and would’ve ejected debris incredibly far from the event. It also would’ve been concentrated to the carbon fibre cylinder not the entire submersible
@@weekiely1233 The implosion in the simulation has a duration of 40 milliseconds, which is the estimated duration cited by investigators. They didn't get it wrong. You're just underestimating how slow 1/25th speed is. This simulation does have inaccuracies. The submersible should not be fragmenting like glass, and we know that the titanium end caps were mostly intact, as they have been recovered. However, the duration of events is actually pretty spot on.
I personally doubt the debris traveled "incredibly far" I've seen videos of 50 caliber bullets fired below the surface of swimming pools and they only travel just a couple meters or so because the density of the water slows them down quickly.
Fast objects do not go very far in water. Even a rifle round will stop after a few metres, and generally fragmenting after a short distance. On another note, Blender really isn't the right tool to simulate something like this. You'd need to use proper engineering FEA and CFD tools, and even then these tools start to get inaccurate when you try to model rapid material failure. The resolution (both in mesh size and timestep) needed to simulate something like this accurately becomes prohibitively expensive. It's still possible to use these tools to model failure (think car crash tests and similar), but generally you've got a lot of good test data from physical experiments which you can use to develop and refine your simulation model. For something with more unknowns the problem becomes harder and less certain.
This video doesn't take into account the fact that the water crushing in would be almost as fast (and as powerful) as a bomb exploding. It's what killed them.
*At that pressure, and according to Naval investigators, the Titan imploded at the speed of 1/20th of a second (split a second twenty times). In essence, their mind didn't even get a chance to register the event. Meaning, one second they were conscious and the next they were not. In very simple terms, the time it took your mind to process any word in this sentence was a lifetime when contrasted. At least they did not suffer. We can be thankful for that.*
Not true. The implosion was fast but they had about a minute at least between signs of major failure like loss of comm to implosion. They had about a minute to know they were going to be killed
If only they’d just respected the shipwreck as a gravesite rather than a tourist attraction, then the implosion would not have happened in the first place.
I am aware of the titanium end caps being intact, this visualization was made before pieces of the wreckage were recovered.
Excuses.
@@Profile.4*Unicron voice
@@Profile.4 Cry about it.
@@linuxtuxvolds5917 already did, cope.
@Profile.4 not enough.
To give you an idea of how fast this was: Their brain and nervous system were completely destroyed in less time than it takes for a signal to reach the brain.
The speed they died has to be of some small comfort to the families.
@@joannakemp3710 Indeed. Imagine you are watching a movie and then the screen turns to black because of a connection error. That's how it was for them.
Imaging paying all that $ just to implode
Although if the ship transcripts are to be believed, they were dealing with loss of power and "cracking noises" for a while before it happened
@@goodlookinouthomie1757yup 19 mins of fear
The Australian engineer who built James Cameron's submersible said "Cameron was obsessive about every detail and would debate for hours as to whether a titanium washer was better than a stainless steel one." That is the kind of attention to detail and seriousness required for such a dangerous venture. Now ask yourself What's worse, Losing your life for $250,000 or Throwing your life away for $250,000?
Both equally bad and dumb … man 250k , bro I’m selling my house for another 250k profit …. And moving to Puerto Escondido Mexico , already have close family friends there , I’ll be the pele Tojo of the town lol .
@@hadesunderworld4203buying a 250k car is smarter than going down in a carbon fiber sh1tbox lmfao
@@hahahahaha7237 unless the car is only a carbon fiber shitbox too. I mean you can get armored stuff for around that money, bulletproof S-class or something like that.
You don't get powerful engine and sophisticked aerodynamicchassis designed in wind tunnels.Also carbon fiber is more expensive than metal but lighter, reason why carbon fiber cars are expensive.Also high speed gearbox, interiors, 700hp engine, latest tyres and even self healing interiors
Why do people like blaming the billionaires? They paid that much because they were convinced that it was safe. They even said that NASA and other well know agencies approved the Titan when it wasn't the case. That would be convincing for everyone. So it's 1000% fault of Oceangate. They were just billionaires who wanted to see the Titanic, and I don't blame them for that if they had the cash. It's the same with people whose life wish is to see outer space with their eyes. They'd paid a lot of cash for it if their safety is guaranteed.
One second you’re biology, the next you’re physics
More like geography
@@pootisengage6672how
More like history..
More like chum
After their bodies were completely destroyed, they sunk to the bottom and became a part of the ocean floor.@@BringBackCyParkVendingMachines
They were turned into mincemeat by the pressure in matter of milliseconds, fast and painless but gruesome beyond imagination.
Reality for you
@@Dustparticle000 reality sometimes can be scarier than fiction i know.
And the shattered Carbon Fiber acted sort of like an electric fence being shot out faster than a bullet and in a ton of tiny pieces too
Were their bones turned into tiny particles?
@@enderethan144 The whole body was probably just liquified by the immense instant pressure. You can imagine what would happen to your body if you squished by the machine they use at junkyards to crush cars. But do it very very fast. Probably liquified instantly.
I suspect the failure point was at the junction between carbon fiber and titanium where it was merely glued together.
Dude holy shit thats fucked. Glue?? Wow
just remember that carbon fiber itself is glued together, the same as particle board or plywood, it's many layers of base material, but the glue can be the weak point.
@@rupe53 Or the fiber layers delaminate and only the outer layer remains attached to the adhesive on the metal rings.
I suspect the failure point was when the CEO shrugged off doing safety tests
@@xplayman then ignored multiple experts
It’s hard to even imagine how quickly it happened because it was quicker than what we can even imagine
It happened like 0.1 milliseconds Before they could react or see it i watched the explanation and for them it was like lights out
@@PbjCat2099it's quicker than we can imagine.
Like, Quick imagine anything!! Not done yet? Well, the implosion is
It took about 1/25th of a second. Basically the blink of an eye.
@@ericgolightly8450 Faster than that. It happened so fast their brains and nervous systems would have had no time to even register what was happening before being completely destroyed.
Not quicker than how quickly you neglected basic grammar!
It still blows my mind that 1 second they're probably in mid conversation and the next they're vaporized.
That's insane.
Not even 1 second
I know, my brain can't even process it. Wow.
No one was vaporized the heat from the implosion would never get hot enough to vaporize cause the rusing water would cool things too quick. All the carbon fiber imploding is incredibly sharp and would have been another reason they died but no one was vaporized the temps just cant get that high enough fast enough......
@@TENNESSEETRACKHAWKYou must be fun at parties.
The actual implosion, was probably faster than ours eyes can blink. That's how instantaneous it was.
Noooo reeealllyyyy
lots of pressure vessel experts are suddenly appearing:)
There's no way they didn't experience it. Even if only for a fraction of a second. And they knew it was coming for twenty minutes.
nah
@@goodo5691 or they heard it from professionals? :))
Needs the front and rear titanium ends to remain intact.
the parameter of material still not prefect
@@hyy3657No I think he's talking about what ultimately happened based on the debris recovered, and how this simulation failed to accurately depict the implosion based on what we do know... that the front end and tailcone with both intact.
Can we also get a few red paintballs?
Speaking from someone that was there :-) :-) 🙂
@@TokenTombstone As I was going to St. Ives, I met a man with 7 wives, every wife had 7 sacks, every sack had 7 cats, every cat had 7 kittens, kittens, cats sacks and wives.
no simulation can accurately depict Rush's illusions of grandeur
I can't wait for a movie to depict this whole debacle that lead up to this. The movie should be called Oceangate: Fall of the Seafaring Titan, and have Stockton Rush as the main character and the doomed anti-hero of the story. I call Kathy Namijy to play Shahzada Dawood's wife lol!
@@sdlock83 i'm already looking forward for the michael bay reboot where the implosion is an explosion that destroys half the ocean
@@mark6302 And it turns out the incident was caused by alien robots that have been inhabiting the deep sea since 500 BC.
"Delusions" not "illusions".
@@sdlock83this would be an actual GREAT movie. A documentrary would also be interesting. Would be eerily similar to what lead to Titanic's fate...
Titan’s hull was made of carbon fiber instead of industry standard metallic. Bonded to titanium caps on both ends sealed via epoxy and galvanized prone bolts. Ocean Gate played Russian roulette with each dive. Not a matter of if but when.
@@John-te1kw are you 10?! Lol
@@John-te1kwthat was so cringey.
@@John-te1kw The teenage boy showed up
26, why?
@@John-te1kw Go be fatherless somewhere else.
The fact that they got shattered into pieces like glass is disturbing
They didn't. His sim is wrong
@@gordonbyron5145 They did. You're wrong. They absolutely got vaporized. The air inside was compressed so fast that all bio hydrocarbons were ignited.
@@gnryushi They didnt shatter into pieces, they were liquified.
@@gnryushi No lol, there was not enough oxygen available to burn them a lot, and it happened so fast there was no time to really burn them. And even if it was super hot the actual quantity of energy contained in that small volume of air was too low to do any real damage. it also didn't have any real explosive force as it too was surrounded by the ultra high pressures of the depth.
@@gordonbyron5145 It was the speed of compression of the air inside the sub that created all the heat. It was literally the temp of an oversized cylinder of a diesel engine. The speed of compression is the key. There are plenty of actual sub experts that have explained this here.
1912 : This ship will never gonna sink!
2023 : This sub will never gonna implode!
💀
Omg
Delete, "gonna" because it makes you sound like a caveman. Never will gonna sink
@@TheMsr47gaming😂
@@TheMsr47gaming Never will gonna give you up never will gonna let you down
Good English
Unfortunately Rush got the last say - he lived life and built the submersible on his (horribly wrong) terms, and died too fast to have learned anything from it
Correct!
@@margotamago He must have known before at some point this occurred that he screwed up! A sort of ''damn I screwed up'' moment before the actual implosion.
And selfishly took several people with him.
But his postdecessor will learn a lesson from his mistake.
Evolution says when his next generation comes he will make improvements so in his future generations he'll survive his stupidity
Imagine if evolution was actually based on facts
The extremely high temperatures they suffered when exposed to the pressure created at that depth is beyond imagination for most people, thankfully they never knew it happened..
'extremely high temperatures' - which existed for less than a millisecond, so had no effect on them whatsoever.
What’s more scary? Knowing that you’re about to die? Like staring down the barrel of a gun, or dying in the hospital? Or NOT knowing you’re about to die? Like casually driving on the streets about to be hit by a drunk driver, or randomly chilling in a submarine deep in the ocean? To me, I’d rather know that I’m about to die, so that my brain can process it. If you die quickly unexpectedly, you never get the chance to process it. You never even knew you died. That’s absolutely terrifying if you ask me. 😔😔
They knew it was coming for an entire 19 minutes. Scary 😨
Lmao everyone is just copying what they heard from others. Yes we all know all of this, heard it on the news every time the subject comes up. Can you possibly write a less original comment? Or do you think people really think you are talking from experience?
@@Senator-KO Well, I guess, technically, when you die, you never knew you died? So either way doesn't 'really' matter. But if I had to choose, I'd rather have a 'chance'. I get where you're coming from. How confusing.
"blender simulation" sounds awfully brutal if you don't know what the Blender software is
😯
Yeahhhhhhh thasss me
Oh i didn't know it was a software name...teeny bit less mordid.
It may have been painless, but the mental strain they had was there for who knows how long that they were not gonna make it
fun fact: People have died from implosions but no one has ever experienced them. It takes from around 200 milliseconds to 2 seconds for the pain to be received by the brain. They probably didn't even see it as most implosions take around 40 milliseconds. This one was so deep that some people speculate that it could even take nanoseconds (1 millisecond is 1000000 nanoseconds). Bodies will also never be found. Imagine it as a diesel engine. There's oxygen (gas) inside of the submersible and diesel fuel. When it implodes, the implosion is so fast that it creates so huge pressure that it (with extremely high temperature caused because of it) will destroy every organic material (even bones) inside.
It takes 100 milliseconds for you body to prosses pain, 13 milliseconds for your eyes to prosses sight, and the implosion happend in 1/40 of a milliseconds
the glass started slowly cracking beforehand so they knew what was about to happen
I wonder what an actual physicist would say about this, keep in mind that water has alot of mass and inertia, isnt compressable and the pressure of 380 bar at 3800m depth is static pressure - as soon as the hulls resistance to the water is gone and the water is allowed to move its pressure will drop and the water has to be accelerated by the water behind and above it - keep in mind that water isnt compressable so there is no elastic energy stored but the water has to be pushed into the cavity by more water starting to move behind and above it.
I highly doubt that these super short times for the implosion people come up with are true.
My guess would be that it took at least a tenth of a second - 100 milliseconds. There is no chance it took less than one millisecond - unless there is enough elasticiy and compressability in the water that the high pressure is being maintained once the water is moving into the cavity.
Light moves 30cm in 1 nanosecond, you are suggesting that multiple cubic meters of water moved at or close to the speed of light to fill the cavity?
Bro the fucking Logitech controller survived. The implosion blast from the byford Dolphin incident left remains. The one that was blown out the hatch was grossly dismembered
It happens so fast, the didn't even know they died. One second they were looking at the wreckage of the Titanic, the next second they seeing Jack Dawson waving at them.
They never got to the wreck
Loll as other said , they never got there , have you not been watching the news or reading articles about this 🙈
Correction guys they did get there. Right after it imploded smh 🤦🏾♂️
@@jovonpecou6134technically Titan did, they were evaporated
That was a good one. Sorry everyone had to try and correct you. 😂
They all had 1 minute to process the fact that they were all going to die. All while stacked up on top of each other in complete darkness. Must have been chaos inside the sub during this time. They didn't see or feel the implosion, but they were all screaming and crying milliseconds before it happened.
Amazing how this simulation correctly predicts the survival of the tail cone which we see in the latest pictures. Pretty cool.
I have a carbon fiber seat post on my bike and it broke after a year of use. I only weigh 100lbs but it snapped like a branch one day while I was biking through the woods. There
is no way in hell I would have even gotten on that glued carbon fiber sub even when it was docked.
can i be your new bike seat
Maybe you weight 100kg
You gave the best and quickest simulation I've seen.
Everyone else is milking people for time. Thank you!
Try searching MYTHBUSTERS IMPLOSION. That would be a better comparison because they put "something" as experiment and that was gore as hell. Liquification etc.
The "implosion" was probably 100X faster than the video has shown !!!
the video showed an implosion happening at about 1.4 seconds ish and it happened in just 1-5 millaseconds for a total collapse. So it was a minimum of 1000x faster lol
It was slowed.
@@1finalfailure Damned with faint praise....
This joke is going over wayy too many people's heads
It literally says that it's playing at 1/100th speed. 😂
Really nice perspectives but a lot of pieces remained intact irl, including the front hatch as well as the hull from what I believe although carbon fiber was strung everywhere at the ends of it.
The hull was made of carbon fibre , so no , it was not recovered , only shards of it . Read the news lol
@@hadesunderworld4203 It wasn’t entirely carbon fiber, also I made sure to put in “from what I believe” because it might’ve been a false image.
It amazes me how some people think there are bodies to be recovered.
"The animation is not entirely accurate..." Truer words have rarely been spoken!
Interesting. I'd like a slowed-down and a 'real time' version. The frame rate is such that the real time video would have Titan in one frame and fragments in the next.
Real time version: Blink
Everyone says the implosion was so fast they didnt even feel anything. I am pretty sure that they knew atleast few Seconds before that something is going wrong. They heard atleast something, and death isnt just only about if u feel pain or not.
Yep, one of the few smart people here. They knew for about a minute they were doomed.
Yeah, but knowing you are about to dying and actually dying are two separate things. You can't feel pain or conceptualize anything if your brain and literally every other cell in your body is ripped apart and destroyed faster than nerves can communicate with the brain. That is instant death
A newly released text stream indicates that Rush fought the sub for eighteen minutes to try to get it to surface but something on the sub was gaining sea water and holding the sub down. It could have even been an opening in the layers of carbon fiber creating a reservoir for water to be forced into. They knew they were about to die for eighteen very long and terrifying minutes.
It also descended faster than normal. I wonder if they had over ballast and weren't trimmed for that weight? Just thinking out loud.
the faster than normal descent right from the beginning speaks to a failure from the very beginning, that didn't fully manifest until later. And surely has something to do with their inability to ascend.
If they rise up quick, tbeir lungs will explode too so no chance at all
@@DOI_ARTSthat’s not true. The interior stays at atmospheric pressure the entire time.
That’s a really good fake. In reality, their communication was limited to letters and symbols.
0:18 "mission failed, we'll get them next time"
Someone a codm fam as well lmao
"Defeated, don't let this happen again."
“Blender Simulation” Well that is definitely a sentence that I never thought I would hear with Submersibles.
Wow, even in your simulation 1 year prior the tail still intact like irl. this is such a good simulation
I really hope there's an afterlife for the soul so that Stockton's ghost could at least say "WTF?".
Debatable, and in this case especially. There is no proof of any 'afterlife'. The closest they've gotten are the NDE's people have been reporting on and which is an area of research. An NDE, however, would require a functional brain to occur, and in the case of an implosion that's not going to be the case.
Ghosts in the ocean??
@@somethingyoudontknow5788 I think technically they call it 'the abyss'.
With the help of youtube vanced, I was able to speed up the video 5 times. So when watching the 25 times slower one, it was actually 5 times slower or 200ms instead of 40ms. And even there it was insane. I just wonder how it would have appeared if you saw it happen before your eyes.
Probably something like a balloon popping
for a full collapse at that depth less than 5 millaseconds. it would just look like one second there was a submarine and instantly you would be seeing bubbles. You wouldnt see the actual implosion would be too fast.
They said some human remains were found. My guess is as the submarine began to fail, the in rushing water forced/compressed everyone into one of the titanium end caps. Extreme force and heat have left some remnants, sintered onto the titanium cap.
Just imagine hitting a wall at mach 2 and the energy that accelerated you to mach 2 keeps pushing indefinitely.
you need more recognition man!
nice vid
How crazy this predicted that the tail would be intact during the implosion is so bizarre
This needs to be in the intro of an oceangate movie,very well done theres gatta be one eventually this story is huge and ties with the most famous ship of all time
I thought you were going to say on their marketing video. Not that they seem to be needing one any more.
Will Celene Dion sing too?
They weren’t all the way down at 6000psi, but they were descending too fast. Ironically.
There was speculation that the point-of-failure was the acrylic viewing-port, which was only rated to 1300 meters. Also, when they brought up the titanium end-piece of the cylinder, the viewing port had been blown out.
Could not say for sure though coz it might be blown off during the implosion due the water rushing in the hollow space
Because the they are to withstand pressure from outside only and can crack much easier with pressure from inside
Or it might just have been unscrewed to unload the cap off the ship since there was no other mounting point on the cap . This one is more likely since there was no remains of the metal flange or the nuts and bolts used the mount the acrylic window
In case of implosion we would likely found some thing at least 1 bolt hanging in their.
So can't say for sure what happened
The viewing port would have to be blown IN if it failed. It would not have blown out of the end cap.
@@jayhemfindsyou True, but it's impossible to tell what happened. Poor choice of words on my part, perhaps.
I think the fact that the ring holding the viewport in being gone suggests that it wasn't the point of failure. It looks more like the spike in pressure inside the pressure vessel forced the viewport out (probably shattering it along the way), and in the process pulled the bolts holding it to the nose right out of the end-cap. If it had shattered first, you'd expect to see that retaining ring still there, probably with remains of the port lodged inside.
@@ryanhodin5014 ya it likely wasn't the point of failure. I think the carbon fibre hull was
Suleman Dawood. You did not ask to go on this journey- I hope people can remember your name and not your billionaire father.
Coming back to this a year later, it's at least a small amount of comfort knowing that they felt no pain because of how fast this happened. It happened in around one-thousandth of a second.
great video buddy....blender is not a easy software to do such simulations....
not at alllll. Something like this took multiple engines to run for sure such a great job with the way he simulated everything caving in at the exact same time so well done
this information literally crushed my mind
Ah yes, the most terrifying thing I will probably see today.
Really shows how beautiful & complex the human body/mind really is...yet so fragile...R.I.P #HarshReality.
Its fascinating how the force of the implosion eradicated everyone's clothing and made humans look like mannequins just before they were crushed.
There were reports of banging sounds earlier. That might explain lack of clothes.
@@nataldoe3035 you did not 💀
The lord works in mysterious ways they say.
@@nataldoe3035banging sounds? Like moans?
@@nataldoe3035😂😂😂
Great job, you did a great job explaining such a tough topic in time, it really helped me understand how it happened!
Rush: "If you want to be safe, never leave your bed. I've broken alot of rules to get where I am."
Remember kids; safety is for cowards. If you want to get anywhere in life, ignore all safety. if anyone says what you're doing is dangerous: fire them. safety is a waste of time and gets in the way of innovation. now excuse me while I go build a plane entirely out of highly flammable wood with no parachutes on board and fly it close to a forest fire. my pride is on the line!
Tbf, some of the earliest airplanes were pretty dangerous.
@@JeremySnyder-p3d Yes, because it was all uncharted territory and people didn't know what they were doing. this is the modern era and OceanGate had people who knew what they were doing, and fired them. that is no excuse.
This but unironically
This incident will just mean many, many more of those awful and stifling regulations Rush hated so much.
@@IAmTheStig32Regulations are written in blood.
well, that was nice, we needed this, thx for all the vivid stuff ; it wasn't clear until now what happened
The time it took for them to die was quicker than the time it took for a show to change from one camera angle frame to another.
This is the most accurate simulation on youtube of the implosion.
Probably should have looked at pictures of the recovered wreckage first.
Thats... better animation than any you'll find.
Oh look, its 'personaly insulted' Stockton Rush over there...and there...and there...
Right On !
It's been stated a crewmember saw pin holes in the composite and tiny delaminated sections plus the to fast descent , it had to be too heavy
This is the most accurate implosion simulation out there. According to latest news, water sipped in through the front titanium ring ripping it off completetly clean of from carbon fiber hull.
I think the implosion orignted from behind the wall Stock Rush was sitting so he would have been the first ti vaporize
A miniscule difference.
It went out so fast that whatever those dudes are rigth now they still don't know what happened
The banging noises reported were probably from the two end pieces banging on the debris on ocean bottom.
underrated channel bro 36 SUBSCRIBERS??!?!?!?? nahh make that more
It doesn't matter how many millions you have, just one mistake in the ocean and you will become fish food
400 Atmospheres man 💀
At that preasure level I would not trust anything apart from Inches of Titanium.
They would probably see small cracks forming (on the outside* they would probably start hearing tiny thuds.) a second before the sub completely imploded, in this case they most likely tried an EMBTB but it wouldve been too late, so the sub wouldve just imploded, and wouldve exploded from all that force the sub wouldve developed. It wouldve curled extremely fast, broke into a million pieces and probably both sides wouldve hit causing an explosion.
Ive heard carbon fiber breaks fairly easily under extreme force like aircraft aluminum, so it would probably only bend just a tiny bit. Nothing couldve saved them. Any heat wouldve been caused from energy most likely from that pressure build up.
Simply, there couldve been one crack that probably caused small flooding, the crew probably tried an emergency main ballast tank blow, but unfortunately being too late, the sub would start shrinking, fiber would start breaking off, the 5 occupants wouldve died, the pressure caused major heat, blasting everything apart. And finally, the loss of communication.
We can never know the full answer, but all we can say is that it simply was a fault that lead to 5 deaths.
At that depth there is no such thing as flooding. The pressures and forces involved are either held back or catastrophically let in, there is no inbetween...
They would not see the cracks , there was an inner liner / interior. You could not directly see the pressure hull , and were talking mice fractures , not visible .
They heard it before it happened
@@hadesunderworld4203 The cracking noise was more likely the bonding between the rings and the CF tube giving way with the deformation.
@@dougle03 The transcipt is suspected of being fake, but if Titan did dive at 50% faster rate than it should have, and if was barely able to ascend even after dropping both ballast and landing gear, there would have to be something compromising the buoyancy. Speculations? Water entering the failing carbon fiber hull due to delamination, equipment in the tail cone section being flooded, or the possibility they had replaced some components with heavier substitutes. However, the only one which would explain the implosion is the hull having been compromised.
@@Katoshi_TakagumiThe Transcript is accurate with the timing. ALSO James Cameron knew already that they did dropped the ballast….
Clearly someone from within communicated this information to him and that same people probably leaked the whole thing. The Sub community is very small.
Physics is really unforgiving.
crazy to think that a living billionaire turned into fish food in just a matter of milliseconds.
A billion dollar fish food... That's the most expensive dinner since there were being more billionaires inside who suffered the same fate!
Two billionaires.
here before 1 million
and rip to those who died
0:17 the billionaire experience.
NO, it did not happen like this, the implosion happened at the rear (it was already leaking at the rear). It propelled everything inside down the carbon tube like a canon (50kg of TNT of force), smashing the contents against the front titanium dome, blowing it, the window off and ring off and out (these items have been found and recovered with human particles on them). So unlike what is so often misrepresented the carbon tube was as least as strong as each titanium end and would not have reacted in the ways shown above, quite the reverse, it would have acted like a gun barrel transporting everything from one end to the other in a millisecond.
My only question here is does Blender come with physics modeling engines? What were the inputs? Boundary conditions? Etc.?
Such a beautiful video
The people would first be compressed, then incinerated by the heat, not burned by fire
Stockton truly went out with a bang
I want to add the bottom frame of the submersible was released in an effort to ascend quicker.
The reality of physics is nightmare fuel
🥴
This is the best depiction of the implosion I've seen. Good work 👍
YO THATS SO COOL, AND NASTY AT THE SAME TIME, IM DYING TO SEE THE HUMAN REMAINS :0
The remains are microscopic sludge at the bottom of the ocean
Gruesome, but probably one of the best way to go out.
Quick and painless.
Looks pretty accurate
Nope
End caps were completely intact , only the hull exploded into fragments of carbon fibre , all titanium components maintained their form , including the pieces glued to the carbon fibre that were bolted to the titanium ends . So far I’ve seen one simulation that would be close , minus the hull destruction , in that one they just show it squished , with the human gel being pushed out the porthole at the front . Witch would be more accurate . Probably why there was no porthole , verything went out that way because they think it happened at the back
Stonegate CEO should have used Gorilla glue instead of the cheap stuff he got from the Dollar Store down the street.
But weren’t there signs that it would implode? I’m amazed how they made it that deep
New pictures show that the sub's carbon fiber sides did not just break into little bits.
@@calebmurdock2028 Yup, they were kind of crushed and shoved into the rear dome cap. And the pieces floating around were relatively large compared to the animation too.
Maybe update version of video? @@nocluse1
@@abbieconnie2012 maybe, if I have time.
Such a quick death
Quick and painless
This is nature’s way of balance for all the blob-fish unwillingly decompressed being taken to the surface.
I dunno why they didn't just stick the two end caps together to make a solid metal sphere instead of making the body out of a carbon fibre tube...seems like a very obvious failure point when under those extreme presures.
The CEO was trying to make more room to bring down more passengers. Other subs that can do it are spherical but they only have a maximum capacity of 2 including the pilot. It was all about the $$$.
@@SenseiJacksama Mir and Alvin can both fit 3. But yeah it does seem they picked the worse shape in order to maximize the capacity for profit
Thanks for the hard work on the simulation. It gives a realistic view of what happened in less than a blink of an eye...
NOTHING BUT AN EXPENSIVE CARNIVAL RIDE!
As cool as this is it’s incredibly inaccurate
The implosion is hypersonic. It’s unfathomably quick and powerful and would’ve ejected debris incredibly far from the event.
It also would’ve been concentrated to the carbon fibre cylinder not the entire submersible
It says 1/25 speed. This is not in real time.
@@xxfalconarasxx5659 it’s not even close to the actual event even with that reduction is what I mean.
It’s closer to 1/200th than 1/25th
@@weekiely1233 The implosion in the simulation has a duration of 40 milliseconds, which is the estimated duration cited by investigators. They didn't get it wrong. You're just underestimating how slow 1/25th speed is.
This simulation does have inaccuracies. The submersible should not be fragmenting like glass, and we know that the titanium end caps were mostly intact, as they have been recovered. However, the duration of events is actually pretty spot on.
I personally doubt the debris traveled "incredibly far" I've seen videos of 50 caliber bullets fired below the surface of swimming pools and they only travel just a couple meters or so because the density of the water slows them down quickly.
Fast objects do not go very far in water. Even a rifle round will stop after a few metres, and generally fragmenting after a short distance.
On another note, Blender really isn't the right tool to simulate something like this. You'd need to use proper engineering FEA and CFD tools, and even then these tools start to get inaccurate when you try to model rapid material failure.
The resolution (both in mesh size and timestep) needed to simulate something like this accurately becomes prohibitively expensive. It's still possible to use these tools to model failure (think car crash tests and similar), but generally you've got a lot of good test data from physical experiments which you can use to develop and refine your simulation model.
For something with more unknowns the problem becomes harder and less certain.
These sounds with my AirPods and noise cancellation sounds crazy
Well, at least from what I've heard, they all died quickly and painlessly. Hope that's true.
watching this while listening to RUSH What You're Doing!
i like how in the simulation the titanium cyclopse dome implodes where as in real life it was just the window.
This video doesn't take into account the fact that the water crushing in would be almost as fast (and as powerful) as a bomb exploding. It's what killed them.
Poor 19 year old boy
Interesting how an implosion can look like an explosion but it’s just like squeezing a tomato. God be with their families
*At that pressure, and according to Naval investigators, the Titan imploded at the speed of 1/20th of a second (split a second twenty times). In essence, their mind didn't even get a chance to register the event. Meaning, one second they were conscious and the next they were not. In very simple terms, the time it took your mind to process any word in this sentence was a lifetime when contrasted. At least they did not suffer. We can be thankful for that.*
Not true. The implosion was fast but they had about a minute at least between signs of major failure like loss of comm to implosion. They had about a minute to know they were going to be killed
If only they’d just respected the shipwreck as a gravesite rather than a tourist attraction, then the implosion would not have happened in the first place.
@@kathrynhill5796 I think it's more "respected rules and regulations of submersible safety and engineering standards". Many have toured the Titanic.
I looooooove
NESTLE CRUNCH
💀