Is Modi's India flirting with fascism? | Head to Head
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ธ.ค. 2015
- In this episode of Head to Head, Mehdi Hasan challenges Ram Madhav, National General Secretary of India's ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and former spokesman of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), the right-wing Hindu nationalist organisation and ideological wing of the BJP.
Last year, the election of Prime Minister Narendra Modi signalled a new era in India politics: promises of extraordinary transformation and economic development, but also a turn to right-wing Hindu nationalism, which has been accused of anti-Muslim, anti-minority rhetoric.
We explore whether Hindu nationalism is inherently exclusionary and if it is compatible with secularism and democracy, and probe violence against minorities. We also discuss human rights abuses in Indian-administered Kashmir, and how to bring peace to the region.
Joining the discussion are:
Dr Nitasha Kaul, a Kashmiri novelist, academic, economist and poet, and Assistant Professor in Politics and International Relations at the University of Westminster in London;
Dr Gautam Sen, a former Advisor to the Prime Minister's Office in Bharat and previously a lecturer in political economy at the London School of Economics;
Mehboob Khan, a British Indian presenter at UN Radio, and former BBC journalist and Indian-administered Kashmir correspondent.
Follow us on: / ajheadtohead ; and @AJheadtohead
Head to Head is Al Jazeera's forum of ideas, a gladiatorial contest tackling big issues such as faith, nationalism, democracy and foreign intervention in front of an opinionated audience at the Oxford Union.
More from Head to Head on:
- TH-cam - aje.io/4a46
- Facebook - / ajheadtohead
- Twitter - / ajheadtohead
- Website - aljazeera.com/headtohead
#AlJazeeraEnglish #BJP #MinoritiesInIndia #KashmirConflict - บันเทิง
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 67 | คู่เอก "นักรบ vs ทาเกียร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eahGc1XmrEU/mqdefault.jpg)
Bjp spokesperson after facing an uncomfortable question,they be like -"No youre wrong let me tell you"
Absolutely
This is happend when u think u are going to intervew arnab gohswami and u find mehdi hassan😂😅😅
😆😅😅😅
@Salman Khan you are that
😜😜😜
mehdi hasan said islam is peaceful in a video😂😂
@Salman Khan jali 😂😂😂
14:17 The level of hypocrisy!!!. The phrase "go to Pakistan" is being used so much so that people don't find it offensive anymore.
Why to shy away from saying to stay in the shitland of your forefathers.
Ur idiotic rude should also know to let the other person speak.
it should be replaced with classic 'go to gulag'
@@hfur7758 you should watch your tongue. Phone pe Ye baatein likh kr apne apko modi ki lodi mat smjha kro. You’re not a good representation of your backward country eother
@@raamizrehman3545 UK is not a backward Country. Light a Candle.😅😅
"Your ISIS" - The worst reply I have ever seen on an international show.
🤣🤣🤣
I understood why he said Your ISIS. only Islamic fenatics and ignorant seculars don't agree
@@EdwinPSaldanha Islam is not related to isis in any way shape or form.
@@Omardawood207 the name itself starts with it😒⚠️
@@orbhaikiahal so tomorrow I will call my toilets "Durga Mandir" and hindu extremist will pray in it ??
These type of journalists are the need of India, but unfortunately there is nobody like him, thank you mehdi hassan for taking this BJP minister on head to head and bash him logically.
so glad these guys are exposed in international media.
@ilk d he isn't leader of hindhu.indian constitution is secular not representing any religion
Muslim media you mean?
secularism does not mean minority appeasement....secularism does not mean butchering through your religious practice creating social disharmony...secularism does not mean killing the native culture.....if you expect so then be ready for the reaction.....
@@masimomozini1 lol your a joke. Pick a lane and stick to it u hypocrites
@@masimomozini1 Secularism does means respect of minorities... and it does mean freedom of religion...
26:47 “your ISIS” 🤦🏻♂️ that’s so messed up
Imagine if an educated minister is actong like this
How would a supporter of his would react to a muslim
Al-jazeera gets access to terrorist occupied places , how this happens ?? No other media gets that privilege.
Dr Nitasha Kaur! Hats off to you. Outstanding, bold and amazing
Natasha Kaul'
..This debate should be again in 2020..👍👍👍👍👍
Agree
Modi govt haven't had a press conference in last 9 years. Because his lies will unfold
Hindu are indigenous people unlike Islamic colonialism.
PPòŕñòhhp
@@rebel.3087 Modi has given Interview to India's most Popular Journalist - Arnab Goswamy and India's Top Channels.
nitasha kaul must be a 5 star activist.. she didn't spoke one word on genocide of *kashmiri pandits*
+Hatma Exactly i was thinking the same... kashmiri pandits are living as refugee in their own country...
+Hatma kashmiri pandits didnt feature in this discssion exactly why 26/11 attacks didnt feature..the debate was about the role of the indian state. so unless you are implying that the indian state was responsible for the pogrom there was no need to bring that up..and i am sure your cognitive abilities went into a partial paralysis when she pointed out that she was herself a kashmiri hindu
+Dinesh Bagaria The Indian state didn't either perpetuate the murder of Mohsin Shaikh, Ikhlaq, nor did it kill any of the rationalist, and all of that was gloated on this show. You blame others of defunct cognitive abilities. Look who's talking
+Hatma She shut the mouth of you Hindu extremist
+Dinesh Bagaria
Kashmiri pandits was extremley relevant to showcase collateral damage. It was not only the muslims that suffered but also the hindus and many army men and women who were shot/bombed by the seperatists
If I was an Indian, I would simply be embarrassed
Mate you have a Minecraft pfp you should already be embarrassed
At what though? Above, or how backward and underdeveloped India is compared to China?
As China has shown, in order to get things done you need centralised authority, something democracy gets in the way of.
And I love that you are not INdian so stfu and mind your own buisness. We know whom we choose as leader
You don't have any knowledge about india so keep quiet 🤫
Trust me, i am embarrassed
"Worlds largest democracy , Now flirting with Fascism"
What a perfect sentence.
India will never be a fasicist country you loser
Are u serious modi lost so badly in west Bengal and don't have a lot of power in a lot of state governments
@@therealissacnewton It will be ma much better country once it is.
@@EMPtaticz can you elaborate your comment
@@therealissacnewton Let him flirt with his stupid words
To criticize the government is the highest form of patriotism " Howard Zinn
@vinayak singh yeh
*Psychology of criticism is apathy. Do not talk too much. First measure the level of psychopathy. Then plan a cure. Attack like a black panther or antiviral immunization if want to change the disease & bring peace*
HOWEVER, KNOW THAT EVIL WILL WIN IN ORDER TO GOD TO DESTROY THE WORLD & start Judgment Day. So, do not despair. Be kind to self & point out all examples of racism that you experience personally in REAL TIME! Don't hold back. Hit while hot.
Howard Zinn a Jew, who wants ONLY criticism of occupied lands in Filistine but no ACTION like Quran asks if OPPRESSED? What a crook!!
Then why Israel has Nuclear Bombs and endless weapons enough to destroy themselves? May all those nukes go into their GUT. Amen!!
You can't as seen they'll say you support Pakistan and try to label as traitor that is India
True. It is better than being a yes-man for the government
Dear friends, I am muslim. I am 40 Yrs old. My most of friends are Hindus and they are following their religion and we are following our believes. They join us for Eid, we make special dishes (vegetarian) for them. We never offer them what they don't eat. We did not eat beef. Practically speaking, majority of Muslims don't eat beef. I see only people who cannot afford, they eat beef. We have to ignore people who makes derogative comments in media. Interviews are useless. Intellectuals are causing more harm to society than a common man. If we see more these kind of programs, we are more disturbed. Life is very short, please enjoy, we have families, we have to give time to them. No political leader giving time to their families. There should be a law, like labor law, political leaders restricted to work max 10 hours in a day. So that, they can give time to their families. If they spend time with their families, they know the importance of life. Please let us work for patch up.
+Asrar Shaik well said
+Asrar Shaik right brother love u.... they want to devide
Well said brother. I was really disturbed when they were openly maligning my motherland by uttering false.
+Asrar Shaik Simple and Sweet !!! That s very much true .. Intellectuals and these media is causing more harm than good !!!
+Asrar Shaik Aray jiyo dada!! Party karte hain chalo!
21:35 That " Highly Condemnable " MP is now Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh the most populated state in india and next in line for Prime Minister!!!
I m from UTTAR PRADESH AND I M PROUD OF MY CHIEF MINISTER🙏
@@shaharukhnadaf7084 you do know i can see your comments on other videos right?. "I'm Gujarati muslim and voted for BJP 7 times". If you're gonna lie atleast hide your trails. Side effect of too much BnD I guess.
@@basimramzan948 Good one, they are a bunch of scammers..having nothing to do.
@@shaharukhnadaf7084 He is a national disgrace
If he can sit there and say “ your isis “ just imagine him being alone with his politician thugs
The BJP leader was gotten airtight by logics of Anchor and audience. His feelings just let me flee in the backdoor...
Before these comments get out of hand: I am an indian christian, and my opinion on this is that while I admire Ram for some of his thoughts, for others, I don't feel the same. Let me just say that as an indian christian i feel completely indian and safe in india, where y family has lived forever! Secondly, I do feel that india has been losing its culture-for me india's culture is indeed hindu-The mughal rulers in their dairies themselves called the land they were ruling hindustan, and continued to address it that way whilst they lived there. The mughals also considered themselves indian, according to their own words! Hence mughlai, indus, kushan, and all these time periods that bear a different culture at some point in indias long history are truly indian. I am also glad that the all the people except that one kashmiri are patriotic about india! They all equally care about the structure and way of life in india hence the reason why there is such arguments! Its much better then in the pakistani head-too-head, where literally that women kept continuously accepting her incompetency...She kept saying I accept my mistake, to the point the whole interview became about her mistakes. She didn't propose any argument(solution)t rather just accepted the fact she and her government in general failed. Like to have that much failure exposed...
+Nigel HenriquesLaslty on the issue of kashmir, I think it is in india's interest, although it is the state of jammu and kashmir, to just let kashmir vote. If they do become completely independent, we unfortunately will severe our ties, refuse trade or entry, and let it become the next pakistan/bangladesh, where people are dying to try to get into india, to the point india has to build a wall surrounding itself. India can otherwise spend the million of dollars going to "improve" kashmir on other things such as the poverty that everyone shames us about- we need to get rid of somewhat of that poverty!! And we need to focus on the things that we definitely and efficently and quickly handle such as the environment, our natural resources, education, textiles,etc. That reminds me- CAN WE PLEASE STOP THE GLOBALIZATION OF INDIA!!!??? I wish india culd be self -sufficent instead of trading with other countires. We have enough to feed ourselves, and enough labor to fulfill food, clothign and technological needs.Then we would be imitatiing the sucess of japan, and still unlike japan conserve our culture, another important thing. I love hindu(indian) culture.I also wish I could someday rule india lol...I feel my ideas and the new generations ideas, such as supporting vegetarianism, and the use of mother-tongue in education are vvalues regarded highly by me.
+Nigel Henriques Dear friend how can you say we should allow Kashmir to vote for their independence when the real kashmiri people (pandits) are living as an internal refugee in india. During Islamic terrorism in kashimir, terrorist have killed lakhs of hindu pandits and another millions of them are current living as refugee in refugee camps inside india. If we allowed these so called "kashmiris" to vote they will definitely wants to ceded from india because on religious basis. First india government should remove article 370 and then bring those kashmiri pandits back to kashmir and then we will vote.
+Inebriated Assistant I know what you mean....Again, when kashmir does get independence, we can severe all realations, trade, etc with them. They will then either be taken over by military and terrorist pakistan(not all the country is like that just its powerful government/army) or they will die out due to lack of resources and being able to fund themselves.
Inebriated Assistant Look at pakistan today They broke off an ancient land just to create a country where they could live in peace and harmony. Yet now you europeans are catching pakistani 'refugees' pretending to be syrians in order to get into europe. They bring fake passports, and travel like those Somalians across the terrible waters to get into turkey etc.
Inebriated Assistant This leads to the point: Why aree they fleeing from pakistan? Europe isnt governed by a muslim leader??? They split from india to be governed by a muslim leader!!! So why are they going to europe in such large amounts, to the pointit has been noticed by all news outlets?? They cannot live in peace amongst themselves unlike india-truly secular. So the same will happen to kashmir. Honestly godbless kashmir...I hope they realize it was so much better sticking with india. I do admit atrocities are being commited, but at least dont run away from the problem by simply wanting to split-thats what pakistan did and look at them now.
Pakistan (Muslim majority)-
islamic Republic
India (Hindu majority) -secular
"it's a secret, it's so strict that we can't tell you" 😂 Mehdi is the best at making jokes during a debate
His pacing is really bar to none!
Watch his debate with dawkins 🤣🤣🤣
@@abhasanand6060 what about it? They debated very intelligently
Hes hinduphobic
@@InsaneCopePosse no he is just rephrasing what that sadistic guy said in a more clear but correct way. You look like those excuse-making zionists who call you an antisemite if you oppose the murderous israeli government.
4 years ago,
Al jazeera were ahead of their time and we are seeing what's happening now...
Nein,
whats happening ????
@@vishnukumarkr3499 Ha Ha Covid -19
@@zazammtl5902 fir v 2024 mei jitega
@@zazammtl5902 that happened in every country
Should be named - Roast. This wasn’t even a discussion. It was plain roast 😂😂
So truee
I dont agree, I think Ram Madhav stuck to his points of inclusion. I didn't find him retracting his stance anywhere.
@@pranshunagpure9781 I agree, he defended his party well
Kis trah SE konse timeframe pe 😂😂, "plain roast" keep your opinion to yourself or explain where he got roasted and failed to give befitting reply. Come on
@@somebody1121 although I am not BJP supporter but I Agree that ram Madhav was not roasted. He stuck to his points well.
"I will tell you when it's necessary, not necessary now" 🐸
His body language is funny 🤣
Watching after 5years, still so relevant!
Because it is for mehdi hassan
Even more now
yes bcz modi is in power again with thumping majority..
This guy represents BJP... Modi hain toh mumkin Hai... He didn't understand most of the questions.
Narendra moody
Think if there was modi how he represent his country
....
@@drbrangz8206 he'd get up and leave just like he did with that interview
Why don't you guys send your PM here, might be its helps you much better who have Guts and who Don't have.
@@laxman6223 ever saw owaisi debate.He is pretty civil and answers really well
Ram Madhav is a very slippery card.
Hats off to Mehdi Hassan for nailing his arguments, repeatedly.
Chop banchod
@@rajendrapramanik7244 You have displayed your lack of education, gutter character and street upbringing in few words.
You might want to practice insulting without gutter level abuse.
Your lesson for today: Gargle your mouth with a toilet cleaner and join an English speaking class. Good insults without abuse conveys intelligence and education.
You have displayed neither.
@@sanjivb53 I am a well educated person so I will not learn from you that what is good and and what is bad for our country.everyones head will be crushed who will speak against India and we are everywhere in the world from Kolkata to Mumbai from Tokyo to New York .no one will be speare who will speak against India it is an open challenge
@@rajendrapramanik7244 Let me get this clear. You are actually threatening violence against people who don't agree with your opinion? Disgraceful, isn't it? India used to be the land of Buddha, of Gandhi. And now we cannot even tolerate a different opinion from ours! Peace.
@@SandipanNath123 different opinion is acceptable and welcome in india.criticism of modi is acceptable but any word against india is not acceptable
😂😂😂😂 Madhav be like : Every document You have is wrong 😂😂😂
Mehndi hasan is baised ....
@@adityaabhatt007 his data comes from the government of India
Madhav mental constipation, turning into verbal direhorea .Just look at his body language, Shananigans Bulltalkies 🍓
@@adityaabhatt007 How 🍓007 🍒
@@adityaabhatt007 based*
I am a Hindu though but that "your isis " remark is very much significantly tell that , how is Islamophobia is been advertised by rss . I also like that mendi hassan still act in a very cool and calm manner .🔥
look at the thumnail very carefully. first look modies hand than his face.
@@camelpissdrinkernabimuhamm6611 India is a diverse country. The countries you mentioned have almost 95% muslim populations. And your username explains your character
@@mazdikhan2556 India should be a land of Dharmic religion and others should be second class citizens exception can be made for parsis and Jews
@@mazdikhan2556 if 95 percent can lead to be an Islamic nation then 85 percent should also be criteria for Dharmic religion.....
@@ABHISHEKSINGH-xx4gs 85%? If thats the case by India's population there will be more than 300 million non hindus. And BJP lead Dharmic nation will be extremely opressive.BJP is basically Extremist Hindus who ignore the Gita.
Speaker: how are you?
Ram Madhav: actually you are completely wrong, let me tell you
Hahhaha 😅
Well said
Savage
@@Alone-fx6uh whatever helps you sleep at night mate
@@Alone-fx6uh whatever you say. 👍
hindus have a right to resist onslaught on their decaying culture
Lolz sickular more like it. Appeasing minorities. .. long live israel
+Abdul Taha take a look at the hindu perspective. they have a burden that was not invited... pakistan is like an arab state in Asia muslims in a Hindu state where 33 million gods are revered so naturally yes appeasing is the only way to highlight apparent difficulties. .. truth is hindus have been dormant for along time but they waking up. as for you being turkish Russians prolly feel the same way about the hagia sophia. im all for fairness on conscious level... not pretend. ..
+Mawao Myers Don't bother, for them 'Ummah' transcends boundaries, irony is he won't talk of atrocities on Kurds.
+relentlessrock :its an ailment man ... history apparently runs 1400 years... what about other cultures and traditions and their history before that... you pushed yourself on so many parts of the world and the ripple effects are being felt now. second largest religion in the world well look... if Christians or hindus decided to compete in having more babies then yes we might near enough be equal. .. but wait there might be enough cows to go round for beef burgers. .. damn!!!
+relentlessrock :its an ailment man ... history apparently runs 1400 years... what about other cultures and traditions and their history before that... you pushed yourself on so many parts of the world and the ripple effects are being felt now. second largest religion in the world well look... if Christians or hindus decided to compete in having more babies then yes we might near enough be equal. .. but wait there might be enough cows to go round for beef burgers. .. damn!!!
hamari dosti bani raahe!
such a debate should be held again regarding how Supreme chomu handled COVID19.
After listening him u realy think india need any enemy..
aqqal ke dushman saray
Mehdi Hassan definitely need to do a part 2 in this!
Mr.BJP wants to know you location.
@@watcher1133 😏
Yeah true 😂
Call Subramanyam Swami this time, if you have the balls, I dare you
@Please help me reach 10 subscribers without a video Agree my friend :)
Excellent journalism shown by Mehdi Hasan.He had no answer for his questions.
He should interview subramanya swamy, and not these ppl who cant speak in public audience.
@@kumarsena62 that 1dollar =1 rupee guy 😂😂😂 he is a gr8 comedian
This bloke Ram just embarrassed the whole lot of India.
The boy from Azad Kashmir, Pakistan ❤️❤️ cha gaye mere Bhai inshallahhhh Jammu and Kashmir bhi jald azad Hoga.
Not just flitting, it's sleeping with Fascism
We we all know which relegion sleeps with terrorism , I am sure u know it very well
@@erwinrommel5593 please mention it ,fam.
@@mohammedashfaq4019 well let me give u a clue they attacked on 9/11 , 26/11, They are at their worst in Syria ,Lybia trying to implement the so called koliphat. I didn't mean to offend u , but that is how I feel abt it
@@erwinrommel5593 opinions are most welcomed. :)
@@mohammedashfaq4019 And so are facts. He is talking about Islam, and he is correct.
Exceptionally grilled. They are the biggest liars.
@@simplymirage whataboutism
@@yeetman4953 No it's not. It's just pointing out the hypocrisy of the hidden jihadi mehdi hassan.
@@kshatriyapa mullo ki gand jalegi kuch nhi kar payenge...
@@kshatriyapa what about him?
BJP is grilling ur lies all over this time ..... So take it gaandu liberal
_Suvarna_singh
I have sheer tension that the panel members will fight each other. They’re sitting Almost one another’s lap
Loved this debate
Al Jazeera just nailed it.......
Let them ask Questions on Establishing Democracy in Qatar......
This guy messed with mehdi by saying to him "your ISIS "
He did not get away with it
he actually showed his true face , himdu fascist mindset
I think it has less to do with the host and more with the audience. He only realised he messed up when the audience booed. We don't see the audience booing this nonsense at indian studios hence rest of us have to tolerate this hatred.
Yes Mehdi doesn't represent Qatar based Islamic funded propoganda machinery that works for Islamic good ignoring Islamic invasions and atrocities and violence and millions or billions killed in 1400 years and continuing.
he never move on
At which point of video.
Kashmir is not anybody's property...kashmir belongs to us we kashmiri ppl.
true that
@Trilok Jit Dey india and Pakistan don't allow us referendum... That's the whole deal
Unfortunately thats not how statecraft is implemented.
Trilok Jit Dey they will give you your funds back but will you give back life of people those of been taken by the same people who gave them funds
Shouvik Bunny Mondal yes make them feel like Indian keep them in India and give them space and freedom within Kashmir.
When he said "an intellectual wouldn't say that" I lost it xD. He really called Mehdi stupid? Lmao. Seems like he was talking about himself and his government
Only if the Indian media had half the balls of mehdi hasan🤣
If he has the guts let him do a interview with Arabs and ask them some tough questions.
So many balls that too of metal required during an interview with a foreigner?? 🤣🤣
Exactly. Hassan hasn't got them gonads
West Bengal is becoming another Kashmir, UP with the exodus of Hindus and take over by Islamic radicals and the State Govt under TMC (Mamata) just letting is happen 😡 But no one will talk about it. Al Jazeera + artificial seculars will only spread propaganda against with lies.
mehdi should go india to face the indians if he's got balls
Ram Madhav condemns Yogi Adityanath's statement here but in Reality , Now that guy became Chief Minister of UP🤣🤣🤣
World foolish country india😄😄😄
@@abdulsamadpk417 Still better than Pakistan lol
@@AmitJana143 i think no bro the Current conditions of india is very bad the GDP price leasnthan bangaledsh
@@abdulsamadpk417 You do realise that India is 2nd most populated country
@@AmitJana143 you do realise being better than Pakistan doesn't mean much lol. Both shitehole backwards countries.
this is the journalist we need in india
Yes , who only backs up Muslim
But at that time you will not be in India.....
yea we need more idiots like him
All journalists and media within this planet are insipid tools to divide the public in order to make weak politicians have a persona of strength and courage.
@IHS Production atleast he won't say earth is flat, 😂😂😂
The way Mehdi said "Come On" at 43:13, deserves an oscar.
Wow . I am checking after 7 years. India has not become fascist yet. Except this anchor has moved to msnbc and asking the same question. What a hit job
Al Jazeera should do more interviews with BJP politicians.
Do hindus deservea geographic e'ntity like the jews
They get rejected every time they try to do so
@Cricket Classics ☝️
Wish India had such gutsy anchors!
india have😂Arnub,sudhir, Rohit
Bro I India media is on Sale
arnab give us so much content to laugh 🤣🤣😆😂
🤣🤣🤣
Hahahaha...
gutsy?
full of cherry picked questions even incorrect datas
8 years later, things have only been going down.
This is what an interview against ruling party should look like which can make the person of power nervous and accountable for his actions
Godi Media people should learn something from here
I want to see the PM of India answering the questions.
QUESTION for Mehdi: Why ask questions, if you dont have patience to listen to its answers? SUGGESTION: If you have enough guts, then ask the US Senate or better yet, President Trump, to come and talk about the 27 million illegal immigrants in USA, who have conveniently replaced Blacks, as the new HIDDEN SLAVE'S of 21st century. Or better yet, see if you can call the Queen of England, to ask her about the reparations of 45 trillion Pounds (in current valuation), for looting India during its British Raj? Have guts Medhi, to solve the issues that relate to millions of indirect slaves in US or regarding the loot that British's has all over the world. PROOF: Go to the palaces or the British museum and look for yourself. British's have put their looted items on display in the museums !!!! ----------- Have guts to solve the real issues !!!
@@simplymirage yeah Shi Jinping, Donald Trump, Imran khan also should say answers
@@simplymirage Ask Trump about what he think of all the illegals used as slaves? The man literally his campaign on building a wall and deporting them. Slave problem solved for him.
Next Queen Elizabeth looting...
Why are hindutvawadis always talking about about looting? I will tell you why.
Being not a global power ruins the hindutva philosophy that they are so superior than everyone, so then they try to to use looting as an excuse why they are behind..but it doesn't work. Israel and UAE build ultra modern nations from no resources at all only desert in 30 years.
He's busy meditating somewhere in the Himalayas.
@@Truthseeker838 He is Doland Trump.
Was flirting with fascism 5 years ago,fascism has apparently accepted the proposal.
Lol
Godhra was planned by these BJP twats...
Not one india...its so called federal...so u cant undermine other cultures
dumbos
@Mithu Bhattacharya I am not, I wish they had done more for the state. But BJP is worse. It could be a very bad situation in Bengal, if BJP wins the 2021 WB assembly election. The development and other things are gonna remain as they have been, but in addition, there would be communal violence.
Watching this in 2023 .. and the situation Have become worst now .. Yes I am "Hindu" .. As a Hindu I feel most hurt by seeing all this happening
As I watch the current situation in 2023, I cannot help but notice the deteriorating conditions around us. I find myself deeply troubled and saddened by the escalating unrest and turmoil unfolding before our eyes. The ongoing events have caused significant distress, and it pains me to witness the discord and turmoil affecting communities. This sense of hurt stems stems from a profound concern for the well-being and harmony of our society, emphasizing the need for empathy, understanding, and unity to address the challenges at hand. It is imperative that we strive towards fostering a culture of peace, tolerance, and mutual respect, transcending religious and cultural boundaries for the greater good of our nation and its people.
What is happening? Give examples with sources
This might be the first instance where the international media came to know how unapologetically BJP lies blatantly on the face 😂
The reaction of the woman panelist at 22:20 is literally everyone in the universe. 🤣
You are funny. Humans are NOT everyone in the universe. What they discuss is so trivial, that the fact you find it funny, I should think you non living.
@@vaishalinpanchal3926 get a brain.
why dnt they talk about 3 lac hindus kicked out from kashmir and thousand killed...and these shamless persons talking about freedom
+SUMIT SUMIT
CNN,BBC,AL JAJEERA ARE indophobic channel.
+SUMIT SUMIT BJP is in coalition with the very same people who kicked them out.For BJP Sajjad lone is ex-extremist...just like other mp's of bjp are ex rapists ,ex murderers,ex extortionists,ex fraudsters./and max pandits fled when bjp was supporting the central govt of VP Singh.SO learn some history first.
+Mayur Panghaal my dear im not supporting bjp or rss...i dnt like these organisation personally...i just said what i feel wrong
+SUMIT SUMIT also seems like u dnt know the history...god bless u...
SUMIT SUMIT
Dude i was also confused about RSS but in reality they are actually "Aid Army" for disasters they saved many lives in 2002 Gujarat floods. and many more they don't promote it that does not mean they do bad things. they also tell all members to stay friends with muslim.
Today i cme to know that why the leaders from BJP party didn't do open interactions.
Do a interview with subarmanyam swami you will know your status...😂😂
@@amritKumar-fk4uq Swamy was ripped by praash Raj.....y u need Hasan fr that😂🤣
@@prashantyaragatti194 I have seen the debate .what you are saying is totally wrong .
@@deepakkarmshil8416 may be u dnt know how debate is won 😂🤣.. Not by making personal comments and entertaining d crowd for claps!
It was by destroying d opponents by facts coz of which dey start persnol cmnts
@@prashantyaragatti194 burnol lagao
He's got a nerve accusing India of attacking minorities. How about he asks Christians in Pakistan how they are treated?
Dude ur username....
@@rosemaria5971 What about it?
🇳🇵Support 🇮🇳
"Do you know who is the worlds biggest exporter of beef?" - "Probably India?" - "You are right!" LOL!
It's Brazil
It's Brazil, it's JBS. India is second though.
Dear Indians: If you think that second and not first is important you don't get the joke.
@@MCFRUGT but dude we are the exporters of buffaloes beef so better you edit that comment
@@Ram-wu6xv Oh okay, Where all the cows end up? being dumped? but they can feed the hungry and can still be dumped (in toilets). What do you say about it????
As a "Hindu" guy from India...I enjoyed the way you Exposed him !! This is music for my ears. I can live happily for years watching these morons getting exposed !
real id se aa bulle
@@PK-fd9fb Petrol Ke liye ghar bech de raha hu, tera bhadwe Modi aur Sitharaman ke liye, tuh hain alsi anti national
Tere kom ko chodo real id bata
@@PK-fd9fb sure.........
@Seljuk Ali he is no hindu!
Why would India fund dissemination of the Qur’an and the Bible? They have their hands full with enough adharmic violence. The BJP should fund dissemination of the Bhagavad Gita and Ramayana to the West so as to civilize them.
We are just reclaiming our roots. For years Indian population avoided it out of guilt towards their minority. As indian history is very intermingled with Hindu religion which was past leftist parties completely sidelined in name of secularism. Present indian government is different, they say we don't need to ignore our own history. India and hindu religion always welcomed every culture, religion and race with open arms. So there is no need to feel guilt to claim your history and showcasing your culture. Its time of Indian renaissance. We hust hope other people don't see it like a attack towards anyone else.
The journalist has done his homework!
Crybabies hired Mehedi to complete their homework against a raw leader and gov of BJP.
Yeah.
Everybody saw that and understood.😂
@@Alone-fx6uh
SHAME ON YOU 😠👎🏼
This Moron journalist said tht ISIS and islam is the peaceful Relegion of this earth .... 😂😂😂
Gaandu journalist of the year
hāppie kohli
At which part of the video he said?
The country which is based on Religion , talks about Secularism ...The Irony in That is amazing
They say you have freedom of religion-they said atleast.
Religion is problem in all countries even America. White Christian's wanna rule
Why what's wrong with it? India promises secularism in its constitution not qatar. They are talking about indian secularism not qatari theocracy.
Asma Anowar An allusion to an utterance of Jesus’ in John 8:7, viz. “He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her.”
The people who have the House Of Glass doesn’t pelt stones at house of other people ...Qatar’s Media has no right to educate on Secularism ...That’s internal Matter of my Country ...And the World knows Al Jazeera’S Bigotry and Bias
@@asmaanowar3008 and what about pakistan? It was a secular islamic country and now it is just an Islamic country
The most unmannered guest I have seen on Head to head ever.
He really said Your ISIS to a reporter. The only thing he's good at is yelling istg. I've been watching these interviews for the last 11months and so far he's the cheapest speaker from all of the hosts I've seen.
*guests
When you prepare for Arnab and didnt study properly.
When u did listen the whole interview and understood nothing along with pre-assumption with a symptom of BJP-phobia and wasting time in tweets of Rahul Gandhi . Then comes this type of nonsense comments
Moral :- u needs basic education
Go and listen the last part 😂
@@ahuman2005 Mehdi comes with all wrong information, inaccurate data, false statistics, untrue numbers according to Ram.
@@ahuman2005 absolutely correct brother... These al Jazeera carrying there own motive to defame the government with there cheap tactics. His questions clearly shows what agenda al Jazeera is carrying. They know nothing about our country, but asking questions like a child. Plus this mehdi putting words into his mouth. Btw I am no fan of either general secretary or this mehdi fool.
@@hasanbasheer5544 well that's a an interesting fact 😂 .... So , u r a Mehedi bhakt 😂
Ram Madhav surely changed his pants immediately after this interview.
Whatever dude, Your comment makes no difference. Modi and RSS will win again this Election, The joke is on you !!!
My comment was not intended to make a difference in the first place.
@@melodicnostalgic3823 well how sad for you then.
Because if modi wins again he will force India into a war with pakistan a nuclear war and as you may know we have more nuclear warheads than you. And you India will start the fight on the basis of false allegations and then a nuclear war will ensue and both sides will potentially be wiped out.
facism will destroy china.
@@melodicnostalgic3823 the joke is on you....you fascist snake....if they win fascism wins
The guest is a literal cartoon. Honestly, he's not mentally or intellectually fit to be debated by mehdi hasan. Great work mehdi
even i being member of rss agrees this is not a good spokesperson from the rss side
There are so communal violence by RSS guys, what do you think about that?
I condemn them.
@@rravitejamavr6650
show me one proved communal attack done by rss
these are just allegations
Mehndi hasan is an intellectual 😂😂😂😂
Don't say to anyone
@@hardcorepreparation6740 You have been given an Award of Sarshole of Bull Bull.
Love you mehdi hassan sir by your speech and your straightforward questions
When you finally get someone on the phone when you call ur cable provider
lol that BJP representative couldn't even justify the claims appropriately this country is in sus hands
he is not BJP guy he is in Rss
@ he is national sevretary BJP too.
LONG LIVE MODI 😎🚩🕉 🇮🇳
Hindu culture and Hindu religion are two different things .
Why dont people get it?
+Ram Lalit Tiwari Hindu is a religion and india is country that has its own unique culture. When you conflate the two you're saying people that don't follow the same religion as you aren your fellow country men and don't matter.
+Uk Gamer The unique culture you are mentioning is called Hindu culture.
Muslims Buddha Jain all are part of that culture.
Ram Lalit Tiwari *face palm*
+Ram Lalit Tiwari Totally agree with you. But its very difficult for "moderate" Muslims to accept that. While pious relate themselves to Gazni and Ghauri more, and take pride on their "Arabic" descent. :D
+Uk Gamer
Everyone who is born in India is a Hindu. The word "hindu" comes from the name of the river "Sindhu" or "Indus" river. I hope you suck it up now
14:45 No one want to leave India (No one is expected to be thrown out of India). And here comes NRC and CAA 🙈
Youre proving his point moron. Caa and nrc dont affect indian citizen. If your illegal then of course
All religions except Hinduism in India are reminder of our past when cruel foreigners came and looted raped and done worst thing possible with Hindus, should we just accept and live happily ever after??
"You have been a very strong guest" That answers everything!😂😂
😂😂😂😂
The laughter of audience on this comments summed it all too
Yeah, and u heard the irony in mehdis voice,
Yeah, truly Very strong Guest who was firm on his lies
LONG LIVE MODI 😎🚩🕉❤️🇮🇳
Now, after 5 years it's becoming clearer how this amazing country is on the path of fascism. After this CAA and NRC things are getting worse. Even today some people are mob lynched.
Please share what CAA and NRC contain and when was NPR was first conducted on the basis of facts
First of all mob lynching is not done by the government and even Hindus are lynched many times but the media won't show that because it's not part of their 'oppressed minority' campaign. Also CAA and nrc deals with the illegal immigrants and not citizens of India, so if you are a legal citizen of India why are you crying?
@@purushothaman6698 dude... Pradhan mantri graduation certificate nahi dikha paa raha hai aur tum logo ko 1950 se pehle ka document dikhane k liye bol raha ho... They will remove people of every religion through NRC and then they again will give citizenship to all other religions except muslim by CAA. What can be more brutal
@@MOHANSINGH-lf8qeKhalistanis
Watching after 5 year, still every issue is relevant.
The look on mehandi's face at 39:45. Exceptional
When the brilliant teacher talks to the rowdy backbencher.
totally underqualified and baseless argument by the ram madhav, and his audacity to joke on sensitive issues that he doesn't have a come back to is really annoying!!!!
Why you getting angry, we will talk it out 🤣🤣
@@charsobishi what a cheap way to answer a valid statement
This RSS leader is a perfect example of wrong RSS and BJP are. They are lost.
Al Jazeera English DID YOU GO SEARCHING FOR A MORON IN THE BJP?? I CHALLENGE YOU TO DEBATE DR.SUBRAHMANIAN SWAMY. TAKE UP THE CHALLENGE ONLY IF YOUR MEHDI HAS THE GUTS. THEN WE WILL AGREE THIS ISN'T PROPAGANDA.
Dude let me tell u it's just some about 30% percent of India knows this english and hardly can reach to 10-15 % of Indians it's it's the bitter truth that bjp is gonna win this
They mostly watches Hindi and regional news channel which is favourable to them and modi is gotta Bhoukal and supported by the most of Hindu families which makes up most of the no and a 20% Hindu hater the liberal one but there are also many Muslim who supports bjp around 20-25% it's a bitter truth and only Hindu population of 70% make more than the half of the population dude half is the majority its a bitter truth that he is gonna win 😅
Sorry to say that
No haterd only peace 🙏
Another 5 years lol, brace for the shitstorm.
@@panzerjagertigerpelefant Well we lived in shitstorms since independence under Congress. We will not brace but we will embrace the new 21st century India under MODI govt.
@@recarco yeah, the 'shitstorm' was under Congress, yet unemployment is at it's highest in 40 years NOW, India is declared the most unsafe nation for women NOW, the economy is dipping and Fuel Prices are Rising NOW, I wonder what you'd genuinely call *THIS* if you called that the shitstorm.
Edit: Nearly 1/5th of the 21st century is over so I think we're kinda late to the whole 'embracing' thing but that's what you said, not me.
Again a great exposing debate Mehdi...your debates should be shown on all channels for understanding.
Well, the world can understand the pain of Indian minorities when these RSS fascists.
Isn't the UK a Chrristian country ? Isn't every South Asian country, except India, a quasi theocracy ? We Indians are the only genuinely secular country in Asia.
So South Korea, Indonesia,Phillipines, Malaysia, Kazakhstan, Mongolia, Japan, and dozens of other asian nations are not secular?
+JZ AK But still they have 26 bishops from the sacred church nominated to their parliament. Secular for name sake when religious gurus are part of the law making process.
+Sarfaraz A. Who Are you to say Tilak Shitty, You just proved how tolerant you are. Read a modern Book not a Ancient book which says its the only book worth reading.
+dponcrack yeah, keep watching mainstream.news , fear mongering at its best.
True.. UK, Germany, Italy have no Non Christian National holidays...!!
One of the best I've seen, good work Mr Mehdi Hasan, thanks Al Jazeera
Thank you for watching!
GANDU
Until and unless India has such people like you, there is a hope that India can do well.
@@abhay_r7068 SWAMY is a VILE LIAR who deflects by half truths & downright LIES just like the rest of bjpy& rss
@@fatimachaudhri5655 yes and these AMIM goons are true to every facts??.....like this islamic state funded news channel is showing every facts.....e.g. Kashmir Hindu exodus, islamic terrorism, PFI, SIMI......
The BJP Foreign Ambassador was saying they didn't support any discrimination.
At 26:45 "your ISIS."
Bro dug his own grave. 💀💀💀
We Need more of these head to head debates with Mehdi!
Again a formidable interview lead by Mehdi. Thanks for sharing.
True journalism. Indian anchors and journalists should learn from them.
Very true
I merge my tone with u.....
Why they not invited arnab 😂
Wrong... This is what we call propaganda
@@VeganSanatani Nope what sir Modi says is propaganda.
He answered all the questions and did not hesitate to put across his view, now it is 2021 India is facing new challenges. Time to put the past behind and face the new challenges.
We need a part 2 of this in 2022.
Shamed to be an Indian under this Government
not to be shamed proued to be india for his goverment
Why are you ashamed Khandelwal Sahab? I think you should be proud of them. Finally Hindus are standing up to the bullying.
Gaand me daal le apna 'SHAME' aur apni LULLI kata k ban ja MULLA🤷♂️🤦♂️we don't have anything to do with your 'SHAME'
@Bijay Kisan Have you heard of freedom of expressiion and speech ,
Why do we have such leaders/politicians 😒😒
Because we are coward from inside
ask modi y he appoints this kind of politician?or is it this guy and modi have same commonality.
Because RSS
They represent our population. And you may not be surprised that the streets are filled with stupid people.
23:11 dp you want to say mughals were indians 🤣🤣🤣
Jo bharat me rehta he wo bharat ka hota he warna to aryan bhi india nahi the wo to inveder the lakho ko mara unhone usse to mughal lakh darje achhe the unhone yanha k logo ko apnaya and yanha rahe mughal to mahan the mahan
One of the best I've seen, good work Mr Mehdi Hasan, thanks Al Jazeera,
This RSS leader is a perfect example of wrong RSS and BJP are. They are lost.
The denial of this man is amazing . If you told him the sky is blue he would convincingly and confidently tell you its pink.
He is absolutely bullshithing medhi and the audience.
Yes, my queen 👸🤴
no no not pink he will say orange (at all times)
No he is not denying
He is laughing because the anchor is continously asking the same question of Hindu vs Muslim Propaganda and suppression.
This is not a case in my country.
Visit India and see ur self.
We are not china
Its not a communist government
Its a democratic government
Biggest democratic elections in this world is carried out in india
So just don't blantly believe the news anchor
Come and visit india
You can visit anywhere in my country.
@@avinashkumarsingh4043 Hindu Muslim is the same thing that your media do all day
Sky is not blue
Thank you Jinnah!
Thisnis not the face of India..face of ruling party bjp,rss after they got power in 2013...but what abt pakistan..since 63years..ask forgiveness from jinnah for the mistake he did..
Jinna k bojohse to aj India mei eisa ho raha hei
@@ripondas3677
Independence of Pakistan from British India, has nothing to do with failure of India and its societies.
Hope you take responsibility for your own mess.
@mccolock maq you are beating around bush. Both political personalities are no more, come back we are in 2019. Yes Thank you Jinnah, we are more more than happy in Pakistan. Kindly don't mis quote related with religion, whoever you are preserve your religious view with you, just talk the business, don't be judgemental , no one is perfect except God.
22:28 what is this guy saying? I honestly don’t understand a word. Can someone translate?
They divided country in the name of religion and now look at kashmir,they even don't talk about Kashmiri pandits