Hello, hello! I am Ruchika Sharma! I teach history for a living (the idea to blend makeup and history was incidentally suggested by a student :)). I am pursuing my PhD in History from the Centre for Historical Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi. Previously, Ive also completed my MPhil and Masters in History also from the Centre for Historical Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi. Here are a few papers/chapters in books that you can read for more info on Women in Manusmriti Patrick Olivelle, Manu's code of law: a critical edition and translation of the Mānava-Dharmashāstra Uma Chakravarti, Conceptualising Brahmanical Patriarchy in Early India: Gender, Caste, Class and State Georg Buhler, Laws of Manu Timestamps 00:00 Introduction 03:16 What is Manusmriti 06:51 Select 16 Verses
@krishnanusharma6186 I'm also a Hindu, i believe in God and pray to God but i view manusmriti as Dent on Hinduism and it books like that have no place in Hinduism. The the you may have read must be a modification.
Reformer Tarabai Shinde criticize Manu in her marathi book Stripurush tulna (woman man comparison) in 19th century! Babasaheb Ambedkar burned Manusmriti in 1925 in our village mahad. I feel proud of our great progressive tradition!
its really frustrating that how much women have to suffer in her life does'nt matter in which century you're living even till today women are struggling to get equal rights.
We men are perpetual manipulator of women's mind.It starts with our home only. The important question is how to escape this cycle of conditioning? If possible kindly advise 🤘
Now stop playing victim card, today you are not being ruled by manusmriti, your rights are given/protected by the constitution of India. So if anyone's that stopping you to do something, that's you ...... Unless you're from a extremely backward mentality family..
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchikasince you are a "historian" Your arguments should be based on evidence. Do you have any evidence that BJP and RSS tried to change Constitution with Manusmriti? Just Give me one evidence
Well after listening my laymen mind is not able to distinguish between Sharia and Manusmriti in context to woman rights. Can you please make a comparative video on how these two legal system view women in a negative light.
Kudos. Please make more such videos on other religions as well when they treated unfairly women and other religions. As they ruled India simultaneously
@@garimakilledar5810 so u make videos only on books written in India? 😂 Do u have any idea how many people in India follow the books not written in India? Mughals were part of Indian history or not and which book did they follow?
@@garimakilledar5810 so what ?? Even if not written in India but people following those books are living in India, ryt ? They form a part of Indian society and hence there should be a proper discussion on which religious rules guide their social customs..... maybe u come across that their books are more patriarchal than Manusmriti 😅
Most viewers of this video, including myself, are encountering Manusmriti for the first time, so it would have been helpful to provide some context about the time period and the people that wrote this .. taking 16 verses from a book is a strawman . it would be interesting to know about texts history that has impact us till date especially from an academic .. still your channel is unique and i love your videos
mam , thanks for this deeply researched video. i have two question. 1) you said manusmriti was written between 2-3rd century CE. it's basically the pre-gupta period(I heard that gupta period is known for hindu orthodoxy). Then what is the motivation or political factors to write such a text in a 'pre-hindu period'. Had it been composed in gupta period(400 CE onwards), It would have been more acceptale. please share yor thoughts? 2)many hindutvawadis ask to point out the names of the kings who implemented manusmriti in their kingdoms. can you mention some of the names and the period of their rules?
You forgot to mention that "A MAN SHOULDN'T BE EATING THAT FOOD FROM THE PLATE WHICH IS TOUCHED BY A WOMEN IN PERIOD HE SHOULDN'T BE LOOKING AT HER SHOULDN'T TALKING TO HER HE SHOULDN'T BE STAYING ALONE WITH HER" 😂😂
Kudos to you Ruchika. ❤️ There will be no saviour but women themselves 🤘 Hmare desh me pati aur pita ko kuch jada hi izzat di jati h, jabki they are the custodian of patriarchal society 😑
@@beingdevotional618 But not with a bamboo. Islam gave women the right to property which no other religion had given such rights. Please educate yourself before commenting.
@PandaPingu-pq4nm Considering that your phone doesn't have Google or you don't know how to use it.. Here's the shlok.. त्रिंशद्वर्षो वहेत् कन्यां हृद्यां द्वादशवार्षिकीम् । त्र्यष्टवर्षोऽष्टवर्षां वा धर्मे सीदति सत्वरः ॥ ९४ ॥ Here's the translation by Ganganath Jha "A man thirty years old shall marry a charming maiden twelve years old; or one twenty four years old, a damsel eight years old; in the event of his duties suffering, he may do it sooner."-(94) YOU CAN ACTUALLY GOOGLE EVERY VERSE SHE HAS MENTIONED IN THE VIDEO.
@PandaPingu-pq4nm 1. I obviously had to copy paste the verse I'm not learning this misogynist text verse by verse. I got better things to do. 2. Commentary doesn't matter more than the direct translation. And the words you explain in the commentary aren't even there in this verse. What this verse actually has is the words for the EXACT numbers.. like Dwadash (12) Asht (8) etc. 3. There's a hell lot of verses that she mentioned. Go search and find all of them. They are there. Don't defend with false logic. How many verses will u defend. As a fellow Hindu I urge you to stop this mockery.
@PandaPingu-pq4nm So this so called "great book" can be increasing caste bias, degrading Shudras to mere servitude, supporting child marriage to double aged men, promoting gender inequality and mysogyny.. and still I'm the vulgar one here for just pointing it out. Claps claps to our great society. 👏
Please make these type of videos on hadiths , old testament and other religious scriptures so we can know how different religious text treat or have opinions on woman
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika we never see such discussion on other cult text books. In Institutions there are discussion on hindu text , even question from hindus text are common in civil exams and so in coachings . But i can say approx zero discussion in institution and questions in exam on other religion text . Why ? I see a chain like structure focused on discussing only hindu cult text .
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchikaYou mean management of the education is biassed against hindu so only target hindu text by letting them prayer in school .
क्यों झूठ फैला रहे हो ।। Manusmriti 3:52 स्त्रीधनानि तु ये मोहादुपजीवन्ति बान्धवा:। नारी यानानि वस्त्रं वा ते पापा यान्त्यधोगतिम्॥3.52॥ जो पति, पिता आदि सम्बन्धी वर्ग मोह वश स्त्री धन से (बेटी अथवा स्त्री आदि के) भूषण, वस्त्र और सवारी इत्यादि बेचकर गुजर करते हैं, वे पातकी नरक गामी होते है। Manusmriti 3:57👇 शोचन्ति जामयो यत्र विनश्यत्याशु तत्कुलम्। न शोचन्ति तु यत्रैता वर्धते तध्दि सर्वदा॥3.57॥ जिस कुल में बहू-बेटियाँ क्लेश भोगती हैं, वह कुल शीघ्र नष्ट हो जाता है। किन्तु जहाँ इन्हें किसी तरह का दुःख नहीं होता वह कुल सर्वदा बढ़ता रहता है। Manusmriti 3:56👇 यत्र नार्यस्तु पूज्यन्ते रमन्ते तत्र देवताः। यत्रैतास्तु न पूज्यन्ते सर्वास्तत्राफलाः क्रियाः॥3.56॥ जिस कुल में स्त्रियाँ पूजित (सम्मानित) होती हैं, उस कुल से देवता प्रसन्न रहते हैं। जहाँ स्त्रियों का अपमान होता है, वहाँ सभी यज्ञादि कर्म निष्फल हो जाते हैं। Dr Surendra Kumar की विशुद्ध मनुस्मृति पढ़ो और इन बहरूपिए से बच्चो । ये असल में मूली है ।
Haa re Manusmriti likhi ja skti h br br..but Geeta ni likhi ja skti br br? Sale kvi max Muller kvi kis Abe kha k bchoge Tm log kutto vle nslo k bhri log ho Cancer ho tm cancer
Mam ye baat sach hai ki manusmriti me womems ko leke kaafi cheeje galat likhi gayi hai but hinduism me aisa koi hard and fast rule nahi hota ki aapko koi cheej manni hi manni hai. Hindu log apne religion ko leke rigid nahi hote hain jo cheej galat hoti hai use galat kehte hain or vaise bhi manusmriti hinduism ki koi single authority nahi hai sanatan dharm me sabse uper upnishads or agamas ko rakha gaya hai or unse uper koi nahi hota! Sanatan dharm me paramparao ke naam par kai saari kuritiyan rahi thi jo ki culture ke roop me present thi jaise sati pratha, devadasi pratha, jaati pratha(jo ki aaj bhi hai) or inme se kaafi cheejo ko hamne sudhara bhi hai or aage bhi sudharte rahenge par hamara dharm keval inhi cheejo ke baare me nahi hai or bhi bahut si cheeje hain jaise agar women empowerment ki baat ki jaaye to hamare dharm me naari ki puja ki jaati hai devi ke roop me or kai saari women saints bhi rahi hai kai saare shlokas hai jo females ki empowerment ki baat karte hain. Vaise mam i really like your videos acha lagta hai jab history pe is tarah se different different views or thought sunne ko milte hain. 😊
Some shlokas from our texts: O scholarly woman, the way a river breaks away mightiest of hills and rocks, the scholarly woman destroys myths and hypes through her intellect alone. May we bow to women through our polite words and noble actions.” - Rigveda 6.61.2 “A scholarly woman, the entire life of society depends upon you. You provide us the right knowledge. May you bring knowledge to all segments of society.” - Rigveda 2.41.17 the Devi Mahatmya (a religious text expounding upon the glories of the Goddess) states, “All forms of knowledge are aspects of Thee, and all women throughout the world are Thy forms.” The Vedas mention several female scholars and sages, such as Vac, also known as Ambhrini, Ambani, Romasa and Gargi.
It is possible to simultaneously oppress women and worship Goddess.. I'm no feminist but an equalist .. abundant source exists about oppression of women
Dikhane m or reality m bht frk hota h Kerala m women's k breast p tax lgta tha..jise tipu sultan n hatya tha..toh sarswati,sita,Durga,Kali etc k sth v asa he hota tha? Mtlb jo glt h vo tmhri ni or jo shi vo tmhri haa? Kha tk bhagoge tm log islye he toh bhri consider kehlate ho qki tm cancer lkr aaye Bharat m Tmhri ramcharitmanas or vedo tk m bht kch glt likha h shudro k bare m.. Tmhre chutye logo n divide & rule policy follow kri
I Accidentally Glanced Your Discussion With Saurabh Dwivedi. By Typing Your Name,I Searched Your Channel. Finally Our Historians Started Telling Truth.It Requires Great Courage To Say The Truth. Great Work. Be Blessed By The Divine.
The Latest Manusmriti Version we have today was written by Britisher , so trust is an issue. But we have to accept the fact that In every part of World, woman was oppressed, in India as well.
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika You said that there are no verses to praising women in manusmriti: Let's see Yatra naryast pujyante ramante tatra devatah Yatraitastu na pujyante sarvastatraphalah kriyah” Manu smriti 3-56, Mahabharata 13-45-5 Manu Smriti 8.352: Those who rape or molest women or incite them into adultery should be given the harshest punishment that creates fear among others to even think of such a crime.
Manu Smriti 3.56: The society that provides respect and dignity to women flourishes with nobility and prosperity. And a society that does not put women on such a high pedestal has to face miseries and failures regardless of how so much noble deeds they perform otherwise.
Please go through Manu Smriti 3.55: ... 3.59, 3.62, 9.26 , 9.96 Manu Smriti 4.180 Manu Smriti 9.4 , Manu Smriti 9.101: , Manu Smriti 9.11: , Manu Smriti 9.89: , Manu Smriti 9.90-91 , Manu Smriti 9.130: Manu Smriti 9.131: , Manu Smriti 9.212-213: , Manu Smriti 8.28-29: ,Manu Smriti 3.52: ... And so on
Gargi was a hijacked named from a Buddhist history actually it was a Pali word "Gagi" not Gargi. An inspiration was found saying " Gagi putasya Sugan Raje" which means "Sugan Raje The son of Gagi " who was a Buddhist king. Vedic civilization was a patriarchal one and women were not allowed to read and write. Later they created a hypothetical character "Gargi" who defeated Yagyawalk the Rishi... Total Gapodfiction... This character was fictional one just like Chanakya.
Hi Ruchika ji, is there any evidence where some of the content from ManuSmriti overlap with Mahabharta? Since both of these are written contemporary same time
Yes, there are verses from the Manusmriti mentioned in the Mahabharata. You are absolutely right, Patrick Olivelle's critical edition on the Mahabharata has it
I have a question for you. Manu Smriti was for Sat Yug, Yajnavalkya Smriti for Treta Yug, Sankha and Likhita for Dvapar Yug, And Parasara Smriti for the Kali Yug If we are in Kal Yug. Then why are discussing about a law book which don’t apply to this Yug? Why are you reading english version of Manusmriti? If you are a historian or history teacher you should read the book in original language. Just like the ex muslims who learned arabic so they can recite versus from quran and explain it in detail. I urge you to learn sanskrit then read the book understand it and then explain it so we all can gain knowledge. If you really want to justify your claims then prove me wrong
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika ita kya buta lag gaya ? Kal yug mai hai hum parasar smriti padho aur explain karo logo ko bhi pata chale kya likha hai hinduo ki law book for kalyug? Democracy hai toh iska matlab yeh nahi ki aap wrong transition padh kar logo mai misinformation failao?
@@MrOdwolf India mein ab ek hi kitab lagoo hoti hai, constitution. Aur usmein auraton ka jo Mann karein wo itihass mein se nikaal kar discuss kar sakti hain. Tu rokega humein?
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika joh discuss karna hai karo, lekin original scripture padh kar karo, fake translation padh kar misinformation kyu faila rahi ho aap? Aur yeh tu taa ki bhasha padhi likhi aurat ko shobha nahi deti, ho sakte toh manners bhi sik lo thode 🙏. Topic se hat kar baat mat kijiye. Original scripture par video bana kar muzhe bhi samjhaiye kitni krur vyavasta thi ya hai. Agar sach mai logo tak verified information pohchani ho toh itna toh kar hi sakti ho. Aur agar sirf views k liye video banane hai toh banao fir. Machao gandh jamm ke 👍
Ohh that, make up thing is ruining all the impact. It feels like you are not serious about what you are talking.you should avoid doing that, make two different videos.
Totally agree mam but it is written by a human not by any saints and Gods king manu is noted as first male on earth according to our holy scriptures and he wrote manusmriti more then 1800 years ago and mam as we know at that time people aren't educated with the term equality they aren't educated like us so there is nothing to take serious about this text (manusmriti) and definitely it has nothing to do with our Dharma (religion)
We won't let this country become bhogabhoomi this is the land of बुद्ध महावीर श्रमण ब्राह्मण राजपूत गुर्जर जाट यादव we won't let this kind of culture grow in India that would keep her eyes equal to man Tell me your address where do you live
hail manu for not that i agree with all he wrote but to make "muhhhhh caste atrocity" cope & seethe + it was written at a different time at a different place you cannot view it with the same moral standards of today. + also look at the misogyny of lord buddha and the leader of dalits Mr. ambedkar himself despite him being a 19th century human + you're an atheist so your opinion is invalid in the matters of dharma and dharmic texts.
I'm sure Manu is in agreement with you. Men like you were his target audience. Imagine if we said that about Jews being killed! It was a different time and place.
What about Commentaries of medatithi 😆Show that😂 Because without commentaries, you will get so many verses in manusmrti and other shastras which will contradict the verses which you have shown
The commentaries of Medhatithi are mentioned in the critical edition of Manusmriti from where this verse is taken. The full details are mentioned in the description
Give me your Instagram Id or of Any other platform where I can talk to you. You have not seen medatithi's commentary of a single verse. And also one of your verse should be understood from puranas and Ramayan. You are just misinterpreting
Hello, hello!
I am Ruchika Sharma! I teach history for a living (the idea to blend makeup and history was incidentally suggested by a student :)). I am pursuing my PhD in History from the Centre for Historical Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi. Previously, Ive also completed my MPhil and Masters in History also from the Centre for Historical Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi.
Here are a few papers/chapters in books that you can read for more info on Women in Manusmriti
Patrick Olivelle, Manu's code of law: a critical edition and translation of the Mānava-Dharmashāstra
Uma Chakravarti, Conceptualising Brahmanical Patriarchy in Early India: Gender, Caste, Class and State
Georg Buhler, Laws of Manu
Timestamps
00:00 Introduction
03:16 What is Manusmriti
06:51 Select 16 Verses
Why don't you convert most feminine religion Islam 😂😂😂😂
@@saikatbaug1937 why don't you take your small manliness elsewhere? 😂😂
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika history shitter 3rd grade jnu product has a place in aurangzeb haram 😂😂😂.
@@saikatbaug1937 tere last name main India ke poore 200 saal se bhi zyada ka colonialism hai, pehle usse theek kar. Lol!
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika ok pancherchap mulli 🖕🤮🤮🤮 just saw your comment on somnath trample, justification of islamic bigotry is awesome.
You didn't covered even worse part.... Where its written that mother and child should not be left alone in room
No such verses man
@@krishnanusharma6186 actual verse is even disgusting
@@5th-wall_breaker just read it in sanskrit or translate it
There's no such verses man
@krishnanusharma6186 Already did, and yes there is almost no change,trust me i read Medhātithi version
@krishnanusharma6186 I'm also a Hindu, i believe in God and pray to God but i view manusmriti as Dent on Hinduism and it books like that have no place in Hinduism. The the you may have read must be a modification.
She and her work is becoming obsession for me .. i keep watching them in loop.
🙏🏻🙏🏻
Mam much better if you written this verses list in you discription btw thankyou a lot 🎉🎉🎉@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika
There should be a whole series on this vile book .
That book ain't vile you are a Cuck you bloody madarchod loser
Reformer Tarabai Shinde criticize Manu in her marathi book Stripurush tulna (woman man comparison) in 19th century! Babasaheb Ambedkar burned Manusmriti in 1925 in our village mahad. I feel proud of our great progressive tradition!
Stripurush Tulna should have a video of its own, someday for sure
Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru said, "India has its large people slaves of dogma". Its sad but true many women will uphold manusmriti
Much needed, in the era of deadliest combination of arrogance and ignorance
Thanks! :)
Seconding this!
Actual video starts at 03:40
its really frustrating that how much women have to suffer in her life does'nt matter in which century you're living even till today women are struggling to get equal rights.
Absolutely, Komal! But the struggle must go on 💪🏻💪🏻
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika for sure ma'am we will fight for us no matter what
We men are perpetual manipulator of women's mind.It starts with our home only. The important question is how to escape this cycle of conditioning?
If possible kindly advise 🤘
Now stop playing victim card, today you are not being ruled by manusmriti, your rights are given/protected by the constitution of India.
So if anyone's that stopping you to do something, that's you ...... Unless you're from a extremely backward mentality family..
RSS and BJP wants manusmriti as constitution of hindu rashtr!! My best wishes to all hindu woman and shudras!!!
Precisely why wome should not be supporting such organisations!
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika sharia state 😂😂😂😂, don't warry you will safe in my haram
@@saikatbaug1937 khud ko mental colonialism se safe kar le pehle Baug 😂😂
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika it's ok vomiting garbad to called history 😂😂, we know what kind of nonsense come from jnu 🤬🖕🖕🖕
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchikasince you are a "historian" Your arguments should be based on evidence. Do you have any evidence that BJP and RSS tried to change Constitution with Manusmriti? Just Give me one evidence
Honestly where were you until now? We badly needed you!!
I came here from Buffalo intellectual poadcast of yours, finally found someone who talks on History without agendas.
Abe chutiye she has left Agenda don't lie you bloody Madarchod
A suggestion - let us hv an episode on Sanskrit - its origin, who spoke it ,its elite character , how did it die ?
Well after listening my laymen mind is not able to distinguish between Sharia and Manusmriti in context to woman rights. Can you please make a comparative video on how these two legal system view women in a negative light.
Kudos. Please make more such videos on other religions as well when they treated unfairly women and other religions. As they ruled India simultaneously
Thanks for the suggestion!
Manumriti is bad but how is it related to history? Are u going to do video on Quran Bible as well?
Quran and Bible were not written in India whereas Manusmriti was.
@@garimakilledar5810 so u make videos only on books written in India? 😂 Do u have any idea how many people in India follow the books not written in India? Mughals were part of Indian history or not and which book did they follow?
@@garimakilledar5810 so what ?? Even if not written in India but people following those books are living in India, ryt ? They form a part of Indian society and hence there should be a proper discussion on which religious rules guide their social customs..... maybe u come across that their books are more patriarchal than Manusmriti 😅
Most viewers of this video, including myself, are encountering Manusmriti for the first time, so it would have been helpful to provide some context about the time period and the people that wrote this .. taking 16 verses from a book is a strawman . it would be interesting to know about texts history that has impact us till date especially from an academic ..
still your channel is unique and i love your videos
Thanks! The first 5 minutes of my video do talk about what Manusmriti is when it was written who wrote it etc
mam , thanks for this deeply researched video. i have two question. 1) you said manusmriti was written between 2-3rd century CE. it's basically the pre-gupta period(I heard that gupta period is known for hindu orthodoxy). Then what is the motivation or political factors to write such a text in a 'pre-hindu period'. Had it been composed in gupta period(400 CE onwards), It would have been more acceptale. please share yor thoughts? 2)many hindutvawadis ask to point out the names of the kings who implemented manusmriti in their kingdoms. can you mention some of the names and the period of their rules?
Absolute form me to koe bhi book implement nahi ki gae
kisi bhi form me kabhi kisi ne nahi implement kiya..and in india there were around 36 or maybe more dharmasutras. @@lovkeshjangra674
You forgot to mention that "A MAN SHOULDN'T BE EATING THAT FOOD FROM THE PLATE WHICH IS TOUCHED BY A WOMEN IN PERIOD
HE SHOULDN'T BE LOOKING AT HER
SHOULDN'T TALKING TO HER
HE SHOULDN'T BE STAYING ALONE WITH HER" 😂😂
Kudos to you Ruchika. ❤️
There will be no saviour but women themselves 🤘
Hmare desh me pati aur pita ko kuch jada hi izzat di jati h, jabki they are the custodian of patriarchal society 😑
Thank you and I concur with you :)
Great historical revolution 👏
You have not covered fully. It also mentions how woman should be thrashed. There are several disturbing verses against women which were not said.
Reminds me of a verse from Quran which tells when & how a woman can be beaten..... 🙂
Qur'an 😂
@@beingdevotional618 women can be beaten by a kerchief and not with a bamboo as mentioned in Manusmriti.
@@beingdevotional618 But not with a bamboo. Islam gave women the right to property which no other religion had given such rights. Please educate yourself before commenting.
Correction ma'am - 9.94 says a 24 (not 18) year old man can marry a girl of 8 or sooner.
It's worst.
@PandaPingu-pq4nm
Considering that your phone doesn't have Google or you don't know how to use it..
Here's the shlok..
त्रिंशद्वर्षो वहेत् कन्यां हृद्यां द्वादशवार्षिकीम् ।
त्र्यष्टवर्षोऽष्टवर्षां वा धर्मे सीदति सत्वरः ॥ ९४ ॥
Here's the translation by Ganganath Jha
"A man thirty years old shall marry a charming maiden twelve years old; or one twenty four years old, a damsel eight years old; in the event of his duties suffering, he may do it sooner."-(94)
YOU CAN ACTUALLY GOOGLE EVERY VERSE SHE HAS MENTIONED IN THE VIDEO.
@PandaPingu-pq4nm
1. I obviously had to copy paste the verse I'm not learning this misogynist text verse by verse. I got better things to do.
2. Commentary doesn't matter more than the direct translation. And the words you explain in the commentary aren't even there in this verse. What this verse actually has is the words for the EXACT numbers.. like Dwadash (12) Asht (8) etc.
3. There's a hell lot of verses that she mentioned. Go search and find all of them. They are there.
Don't defend with false logic. How many verses will u defend. As a fellow Hindu I urge you to stop this mockery.
@PandaPingu-pq4nm
So this so called "great book" can be increasing caste bias, degrading Shudras to mere servitude, supporting child marriage to double aged men, promoting gender inequality and mysogyny..
and still I'm the vulgar one here for just pointing it out.
Claps claps to our great society. 👏
The extent to which the society goes to control women knows no bounds.
Indeed, really depressing! 😞
th-cam.com/video/5dSYPCPe7bY/w-d-xo.html
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika please go through this video it's my sincere request to you mam
And by the why are you only pointing out Manusmriti and why not Quran
@@tanmaydeb7995 I've only uploaded the video, so I've clearly gone through it.
Please make these type of videos on hadiths , old testament and other religious scriptures so we can know how different religious text treat or have opinions on woman
Thanks for the suggestion!
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika we never see such discussion on other cult text books.
In Institutions there are discussion on hindu text , even question from hindus text are common in civil exams and so in coachings . But i can say approx zero discussion in institution and questions in exam on other religion text . Why ?
I see a chain like structure focused on discussing only hindu cult text .
@@ChasKa_ majoritarian bias, the same that leads Hindu prayers to be performed in schools
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchikaYou mean management of the education is biassed against hindu so only target hindu text by letting them prayer in school .
@@ChasKa_ no, dumdum! Since there's a majoritarian bias, the hindu culture is often touted as the national culture when it is clearly not
Keep it up mam 💯💯👌👌🙏🙏. And thank you for bringing the truth of Manusmriti 👌👌🙏🙏
दलित और महिलाओं को एक अवस्था में रखा मनू स्मृति मै।।
क्यों झूठ फैला रहे हो ।।
Manusmriti 3:52
स्त्रीधनानि तु ये मोहादुपजीवन्ति बान्धवा:।
नारी यानानि वस्त्रं वा ते पापा यान्त्यधोगतिम्॥3.52॥
जो पति, पिता आदि सम्बन्धी वर्ग मोह वश स्त्री धन से (बेटी अथवा स्त्री आदि के) भूषण, वस्त्र और सवारी इत्यादि बेचकर गुजर करते हैं, वे पातकी नरक गामी होते है।
Manusmriti 3:57👇
शोचन्ति जामयो यत्र विनश्यत्याशु तत्कुलम्।
न शोचन्ति तु यत्रैता वर्धते तध्दि सर्वदा॥3.57॥
जिस कुल में बहू-बेटियाँ क्लेश भोगती हैं, वह कुल शीघ्र नष्ट हो जाता है। किन्तु जहाँ इन्हें किसी तरह का दुःख नहीं होता वह कुल सर्वदा बढ़ता रहता है।
Manusmriti 3:56👇
यत्र नार्यस्तु पूज्यन्ते रमन्ते तत्र देवताः।
यत्रैतास्तु न पूज्यन्ते सर्वास्तत्राफलाः क्रियाः॥3.56॥
जिस कुल में स्त्रियाँ पूजित (सम्मानित) होती हैं, उस कुल से देवता प्रसन्न रहते हैं। जहाँ स्त्रियों का अपमान होता है, वहाँ सभी यज्ञादि कर्म निष्फल हो जाते हैं।
Dr Surendra Kumar की विशुद्ध मनुस्मृति पढ़ो और इन बहरूपिए से बच्चो ।
ये असल में मूली है ।
Haa re Manusmriti likhi ja skti h br br..but Geeta ni likhi ja skti br br?
Sale kvi max Muller kvi kis Abe kha k bchoge
Tm log kutto vle nslo k bhri log ho
Cancer ho tm cancer
Gandu ki padaish ho lag raha😂😂😂aise sab achaa acahaa dal doge khud se kyu 😂😂na jane bajar me kitni manusmriti hai , 1000 o aisi milengi
4 achii chiz dikha diye ho gya 😂😂
Mam ye baat sach hai ki manusmriti me womems ko leke kaafi cheeje galat likhi gayi hai but hinduism me aisa koi hard and fast rule nahi hota ki aapko koi cheej manni hi manni hai. Hindu log apne religion ko leke rigid nahi hote hain jo cheej galat hoti hai use galat kehte hain or vaise bhi manusmriti hinduism ki koi single authority nahi hai sanatan dharm me sabse uper upnishads or agamas ko rakha gaya hai or unse uper koi nahi hota!
Sanatan dharm me paramparao ke naam par kai saari kuritiyan rahi thi jo ki culture ke roop me present thi jaise sati pratha, devadasi pratha, jaati pratha(jo ki aaj bhi hai) or inme se kaafi cheejo ko hamne sudhara bhi hai or aage bhi sudharte rahenge par hamara dharm keval inhi cheejo ke baare me nahi hai or bhi bahut si cheeje hain jaise agar women empowerment ki baat ki jaaye to hamare dharm me naari ki puja ki jaati hai devi ke roop me or kai saari women saints bhi rahi hai kai saare shlokas hai jo females ki empowerment ki baat karte hain.
Vaise mam i really like your videos acha lagta hai jab history pe is tarah se different different views or thought sunne ko milte hain. 😊
Some shlokas from our texts:
O scholarly woman, the way a river breaks away mightiest of hills and rocks, the scholarly woman destroys myths and hypes through her intellect alone. May we bow to women through our polite words and noble actions.” - Rigveda 6.61.2
“A scholarly woman, the entire life of society depends upon you. You provide us the right knowledge. May you bring knowledge to all segments of society.” - Rigveda 2.41.17
the Devi Mahatmya (a religious text expounding upon the glories of the Goddess) states, “All forms of knowledge are aspects of Thee, and all women throughout the world are Thy forms.”
The Vedas mention several female scholars and sages, such as Vac, also known as Ambhrini, Ambani, Romasa and Gargi.
It is possible to simultaneously oppress women and worship Goddess.. I'm no feminist but an equalist .. abundant source exists about oppression of women
@@Anshu.24383 toh fir madam phule ki study se kya dikkat aa rahi thi
Dikhane m or reality m bht frk hota h
Kerala m women's k breast p tax lgta tha..jise tipu sultan n hatya tha..toh sarswati,sita,Durga,Kali etc k sth v asa he hota tha?
Mtlb jo glt h vo tmhri ni or jo shi vo tmhri haa?
Kha tk bhagoge tm log islye he toh bhri consider kehlate ho qki tm cancer lkr aaye Bharat m
Tmhri ramcharitmanas or vedo tk m bht kch glt likha h shudro k bare m..
Tmhre chutye logo n divide & rule policy follow kri
Earth ki age triliyan yers hogi or insan ki age 89/90 yers hogi...unme se bachpan 15 yers hoga to kya 60 yers me hum erth ko samz sakte he
Konsi bhasha hai yeh?? 😂😂 Samz?? 😂😂😂
Very good channel especially for history students.
Loved the explanation in every video very nice efforts
Thank you :)
I Accidentally Glanced Your Discussion With Saurabh Dwivedi. By Typing Your Name,I Searched Your Channel.
Finally Our Historians Started Telling Truth.It Requires Great Courage To Say The Truth.
Great Work.
Be Blessed By The Divine.
Thank you so much 🙏
The Latest Manusmriti Version we have today was written by Britisher , so trust is an issue.
But we have to accept the fact that In every part of World, woman was oppressed, in India as well.
These verses are from Patrick Olivelle's critical edition of the Manusmriti. It's a solidly academic work, and there's no reason to doubt it.
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika
You said that there are no verses to praising women in manusmriti:
Let's see
Yatra naryast pujyante ramante tatra devatah
Yatraitastu na pujyante sarvastatraphalah kriyah”
Manu smriti 3-56, Mahabharata 13-45-5
Manu Smriti 8.352: Those who rape or molest women or incite them into adultery should be given the harshest punishment that creates fear among others to even think of such a crime.
Manu Smriti 3.56: The society that provides respect and dignity to women flourishes with nobility and prosperity. And a society that does not put women on such a high pedestal has to face miseries and failures regardless of how so much noble deeds they perform otherwise.
Please go through
Manu Smriti 3.55: ... 3.59, 3.62, 9.26 , 9.96
Manu Smriti 4.180
Manu Smriti 9.4 , Manu Smriti 9.101: ,
Manu Smriti 9.11: , Manu Smriti 9.89: , Manu Smriti 9.90-91 , Manu Smriti 9.130:
Manu Smriti 9.131: , Manu Smriti 9.212-213: , Manu Smriti 8.28-29: ,Manu Smriti 3.52: ... And so on
@@nimeshpundhir3178 doesn't nullify the existence of the 16 draconian verses against women mentioned in the video
What do you say about Gargi/Gagi. She was an woman scholar. Can you pls suggest some primary sources that mentions about Gargi?
Gargi was a hijacked named from a Buddhist history actually it was a Pali word "Gagi" not Gargi.
An inspiration was found saying " Gagi putasya Sugan Raje" which means "Sugan Raje The son of Gagi " who was a Buddhist king.
Vedic civilization was a patriarchal one and women were not allowed to read and write.
Later they created a hypothetical character "Gargi" who defeated Yagyawalk the Rishi...
Total Gapodfiction... This character was fictional one just like Chanakya.
it was one of the means to oppress women and treat them as inferior
Precisely!
Please read how tantra and agam shastra sees femenine
Hi Ruchika ji, is there any evidence where some of the content from ManuSmriti overlap with Mahabharta? Since both of these are written contemporary same time
Yes, there are verses from the Manusmriti mentioned in the Mahabharata. You are absolutely right, Patrick Olivelle's critical edition on the Mahabharata has it
Karna is the best example
Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) said the best among you is the one who is best to their wives.
He made many women slave 😂
You could do a video with Dr. Seema Anand. May turn out great ;)
मेरे समझ से आपको ये video हिन्दी में बनाना चाहिए था जिससे गाँव की हिन्दी समझने वाली महिलाओं को भी समझ में आ सके।
I have a question for you.
Manu Smriti was for Sat Yug,
Yajnavalkya Smriti for Treta Yug,
Sankha and Likhita for Dvapar Yug,
And Parasara Smriti for the Kali Yug
If we are in Kal Yug. Then why are discussing about a law book which don’t apply to this Yug?
Why are you reading english version of Manusmriti?
If you are a historian or history teacher you should read the book in original language. Just like the ex muslims who learned arabic so they can recite versus from quran and explain it in detail.
I urge you to learn sanskrit then read the book understand it and then explain it so we all can gain knowledge.
If you really want to justify your claims then prove me wrong
Constitutional democracy mein Hain hum, aur sabko sab kuchh discuss karne ka haq hai. Mennu na sikha, daud ja aethon
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika ita kya buta lag gaya ? Kal yug mai hai hum parasar smriti padho aur explain karo logo ko bhi pata chale kya likha hai hinduo ki law book for kalyug?
Democracy hai toh iska matlab yeh nahi ki aap wrong transition padh kar logo mai misinformation failao?
@@MrOdwolf India mein ab ek hi kitab lagoo hoti hai, constitution. Aur usmein auraton ka jo Mann karein wo itihass mein se nikaal kar discuss kar sakti hain. Tu rokega humein?
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika joh discuss karna hai karo, lekin original scripture padh kar karo, fake translation padh kar misinformation kyu faila rahi ho aap? Aur yeh tu taa ki bhasha padhi likhi aurat ko shobha nahi deti, ho sakte toh manners bhi sik lo thode 🙏. Topic se hat kar baat mat kijiye. Original scripture par video bana kar muzhe bhi samjhaiye kitni krur vyavasta thi ya hai. Agar sach mai logo tak verified information pohchani ho toh itna toh kar hi sakti ho. Aur agar sirf views k liye video banane hai toh banao fir. Machao gandh jamm ke 👍
@Mrodwolf is happy with the Ex-Muslims, bt Khabar daaaar koi Humare Sanatan Dharam ko kuch na bole 🥴
अगर हो सके तो इसका हिंदी version भी बनाये।
Quote some from kitab e alamgiri and the treatment of women discribed in it,by Aurangzeb a Mughal who didn't migrate from central asia
Ohh that, make up thing is ruining all the impact. It feels like you are not serious about what you are talking.you should avoid doing that, make two different videos.
Great post 👍👌God Bless You 🙌 💖 🙏 ❤ ✨
Thank you! 🙏
Be critical on Asvagosha and other buddhist texts also
Buddhist texts ka critique Aaj shaam 6:30 baje Wale episode main hai. Dekhiyega!
Totally agree mam but it is written by a human not by any saints and Gods king manu is noted as first male on earth according to our holy scriptures and he wrote manusmriti more then 1800 years ago and mam as we know at that time people aren't educated with the term equality they aren't educated like us so there is nothing to take serious about this text (manusmriti) and definitely it has nothing to do with our Dharma (religion)
👍👍
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika please convert to Islam to liberate yourself🖕🖕🤬🤬🤬
@@saikatbaug1937 🤏
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika don't give measurements of your Abdul 😂 😂😂😂
@@saikatbaug1937 tere grey matter se toh sabhi kuchh zyada hai, matar ke daane ke saman dimag Wale! 😂😂😂
We won't let this country become bhogabhoomi this is the land of बुद्ध महावीर श्रमण ब्राह्मण राजपूत गुर्जर जाट यादव we won't let this kind of culture grow in India that would keep her eyes equal to man
Tell me your address where do you live
👌
hail manu for not that i agree with all he wrote but to make "muhhhhh caste atrocity" cope & seethe + it was written at a different time at a different place you cannot view it with the same moral standards of today. + also look at the misogyny of lord buddha and the leader of dalits Mr. ambedkar himself despite him being a 19th century human + you're an atheist so your opinion is invalid in the matters of dharma and dharmic texts.
I'm sure Manu is in agreement with you. Men like you were his target audience. Imagine if we said that about Jews being killed! It was a different time and place.
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika no it was not a diff time it was 19th century post industrial revolution. i have sympathy for the juden.
seethe moar@@AksharaAbigail-hh1yr
Halala par moan kyu😂 kash aap bhi convert ho jao hamare Muslim bhaiyo ko bhi mokka milega one by one . one by one😍
Moan 🤦🏻♀️ woh sab rehne de, pehle likhna seekh le. Creepy khwaab baad mein dekh lena, chirkut
Halala is haram only shia Muslim does that.
But niyog is real 🥴
Tujhe abhi halala kyo yaad aa rha h
Sab sach to likha hai...
What about Commentaries of medatithi 😆Show that😂 Because without commentaries, you will get so many verses in manusmrti and other shastras which will contradict the verses which you have shown
The commentaries of Medhatithi are mentioned in the critical edition of Manusmriti from where this verse is taken. The full details are mentioned in the description
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika have you any Insta Id or any other platform where I can talk to you. I want to show you Something
স্ববিরোধ ছাড়া ধর্মগ্রন্হ সম্ভব কি?
That thumbnail "Aurat ka chakkar Babu bhaiya" 😁😁
😂😂
Everytime post any video in both english and hindi languages
madom, please kabhi islam per bhi video banao
Quran etc pe nat bolne ko suggest karo bina sir ke agla video nahi bana payegi
Tu bol le bhai, sara Kam mein hi karun, khud bhi kuchh karle
Tum karna bhi mat, eyeshadow karne ke badle itihas ban jaogi
@@jayd131 tu bas munh chhupa, darpok, tumse na ho paega
@@jayd131varn vyavastha kuran mai hai
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika youtuber tu bani baithi hai..itni si thumbnail me muh dekhke karegi kya
Aaj kal har koi gadha philosophy par gyaan deraha hain yaha par bhi ek gadhi scripture pat. Gyaan derahi hain jisko philosophy k p bhi nahi aata
Manusmriti is not religions books ....like hevai kitab ....and its like old constitution
Lol abe Ruchika Sharma nahi BeSharma kaho..
Half baked knowledge manusmriti se le aao..aukaat hai toh aana kabhi quran bible pr😂😂
quran bible wale channels bhi hain..app waha ja saktey ho..dikkar kya hai
@ruchika
Islam mohammad or kuran, hadeeso par bhi put some enlightenment..
Mai batau?
4:34
Aurto ko control karna sikhaya hai
2:223
Aurte khet hai
And many more
Age jyada ho jaye to frstresan badh jata he koi aadmi dekh kar sadi karne se man k aaweg sant ho jayenge aap rilex rahogi
Agar yeh comment tu insanon ki bhasha main likhta toh samajh bhi aati. Par tu ne toh kya khichdi pakai hai tu hi samajh 😂😂
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika तू लल्लनटॉप में क्यों गयी थी बेवकूफ औरत
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Don't teach nonsense. Simply tell the disturbing verses. Why do you mince words?
Halala is the best solution for these types of women. I pray you marry a momin n face halala again and again. ameen
Lol, yet another solidly intimidated loser!
हा हा how poor your channel is only ५०० subscriber पहली बार मे तेरे चेनल पर आके पछताया
Quality stuff don’t get mass subscribers…you can go and watch KRK, he has millions of subscribers…thanks…
Comment karne se pahle baat kehne ka salika sikhe janab
@@gauravaggarwal6083 give me your addresses
@@gauravaggarwal6083 thik he lal salaam comrade
She is a prostitute from Aurangabad
Please think twice ore thrice before making a video against a religious book . You can take it as a warning or an advice
Manusmriti as I explain in the video is a legal treatise. Unlike the Vedas it is not a religious book
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchika Mam there are also verses which are in favor of women why don't you mention that ??????
@@tanmaydeb7995 the verses that "support" women objectify them. Please read the Manusmriti before you make such passing comments.
@@eyeshadowetihaaswithruchikahave you read it? You haven't even seen it, just reading it from website 🤡🤡🤡
@@himanshukandwal3203 lol man has never read Manusmriti's critical edition but here we are 😂
She is from jnu
Very unbiased historian I've seen 🤣🤣 jo kisi dusre dharm pe baat krna communal samajhte he magar hindu dharm pe baat krna secular+ woke he
Give me your Instagram Id or of Any other platform where I can talk to you. You have not seen medatithi's commentary of a single verse. And also one of your verse should be understood from puranas and Ramayan. You are just misinterpreting
জিভ বের করা ট্যাঁরা।