When An Indian Historian Lashed Out At The West | REACTION!! (Slovak European)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 มิ.ย. 2023
- See what I have to say as Slovak European about the Indian Historian and his point of view on the west.
When An Indian Historian Lashed Out At The West | REACTION!! (Slovak European)
For more reaction videos, check out my channel zuzanareacts / @zuzanareacts
Follow me on IG: zuzanareacts
Original video here: • When An Indian Histori...
I hope to see you in the comments
#india
#history
#west
#indian
India was colonized by British for around 170 years during which they looted 45 trillion, as INDIA was the richest country in the world and at the time shares 25% of global gdp alone which was 1/4th of the entire world.
real shame!
25% means 1/4 brother
25% is 1/4 of 100%
@@jaichauhan5306 yes I apologize for that by mistake I put the fraction of 20%.😅
@@martin96991 exactly 👍
4 million people died of Churchill's induced famine in Bengal.
wow and he is celebrated. Sometimes I feel like all history was twisted... but I guess he helped to stop WW2. - ...
@@zuzanareactsI can understand why he's celebrated in Europe and America and even the world because he basically saved it from German and Japan takeover. But some people's heroes can be other people's villain you know.
S
@@zuzanareactshe was way worse than Hitler,not gonna lie
@zuzanareacts by the way do you know how 🇺🇸 was inducted into the war ?
War was already broken in Europe. Germany 🇩🇪 made its way into the English channel with its submarines ( u-boat ). At the same time a US passenger ship SS Athenia was heading towards London. Winston Churchill deliberately didn't give any protection to the ship as it entered the English channel. As a result of it, the ship 🚢 was sunk by Germany 🇩🇪. When the lives of American citizens were lost in that tragedy, US got itself inducted into the war and the same was expected by Churchill ( a@#$%&* )
Around 50 children lost their life including so many neonates and infants.
Churchill said that lost life of children helped much more than a thousand soldiers.....
Atrocities of Churchill are much more.....
@@zuzanareactsyep, war was won by Churchill's dirty games and American nukes, that's it..... couldn't won an inch if they had fought rightfully.
That's what western world does when they run out of options right ?? Bloody hypocrites
FYI...Wilson Churchill was the most cruel person in the history of world...even worst than Hitler..for UK and west They may consider him as hero but he is ultimate evil person for us..he is the reason for Bengal femine...just do research about that you will know..😢and yes...we defeated English Empire because of our freedom fighters many of them died for the freedom and we respect them...❤
and we never forgot and will never forgive them who did this to us..🇮🇳🙏
sending lots of love ❤
Churchill, man who was thrown out of the military for indiscipline, elected as the PM of the same country by its people. Epic
@@zuzanareactsi have no sympathy for Churchill what ever he said about indians i don't care about it but bengal famine happned because of forced industrialization and war similar to what happened in Ukraine during Stalin's rule i don't think british did it deliberately secondly british librated india from Muslim rule which was far worse than british so i am thankful to them and i admire west and Europe they build greatest civilization in human history btw I'm Indian
He is speaking the damn truth. Surely he has the guts.
it's only fair enough
Looted 200 years...minimum 40 trillion
But history repeats itself, India will again be the wealthiest
Then we will take back everything,with sorry,apollogy and with interest by respect😢
A day without hypocrisy is a day wasted - western/europian countries. 😊 By the way you are nice person 😊
awww bless you! Thank you so much. Sending lots of love ❤
Yeah nice cities, nice people built on the barbarism and exploitation of today's so called "3rd world countries" ..... I understand that today's generation is not to be blamed but u can't 100% ignore attrocities commited by your ancestors...... Your today's privilege is in some extent the direct result of it........ I know it's easy to say what u say when u r at the other side of the world, bravery would be to just imagine your kids hungry for 3 days and then say what you say now ........
@@zuzanareacts you should learn our history first
@@zuzanareactsister sister please read history and then talk that's the problem of Western European countries they fake that they know everything but they do not know a single one but instead throw there poor knowledge on us and lecture us if you are gaining something from indians views and be thankful to it and one more thing you said one thing that is actually you threw out the British yes dear sister we threw British by kicking their ass kindly read history about subhash chandra bose ina and bhagat singh and various other freedom fighters I also know you can't digest that india is growing and we are beating you and Don't worry there will come a day soon when we tell you what India is capable of jai hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@zuzanareactsWhen i listen to people like you my blood boils by anger you are continuously justifying all rhe things which have done by your europeans colonial mindset people you still have a mindset that we are superior to you well that's a joke everyone in this is world is equal according to indians not know about others we believe in vasudhaiv kutumbakam the world is one family but that does not mean that we will listen everything which you will say and today I am saying you europeans have courage than stop India from growing my country was world superpower before the Britishers and will become superpower you have power than stop us bharat mata ki jay vande mataram 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Its a known historical fact that 200 years back India and China were basically USA of today's. India and China together accounted for 2/3rd of world GDP.
I always said that britishers was looted India in the form of gold, ancient artifacts ,temple treasury and construct and developed their countries and declared themselves as advanced civilization. We have history of 10000 years ; do have atleast 500 years of history of british empire.
I hear you!
Bruhh 200 years not 500
@@zuzanareactsRead something and also read my other comment on this vidoe
Yes, everything he said is true before british invasion india shared 15 to 23% of world gdp and before islamic invasion india shared more than 32% of world gdp and about throwing britishers out he is referring to 1946 indian army revolt which was under British at that time seeing the revolt British were so scared that most of them ran from india and finally decided to free india because they knew they will not be able to hold india for long
aaaah - thank you for sharing that!
Before islamic india gdp share was more than 60% and during british invasion it was 40%
@@yeager825 no your are wrong there it has been a debate to find the exact gdp contributions of india but the things we are sure about is that indian gdp was reduced during mughal invasion but still we were at the top for obvious reasons but during British rule we became one of the poorest
@@yeager825 thank you for sharing
I’ll not call it finger pointing. I would rather called it the victims of bullies started retaliating. I mean how much can someone tolerate, one or the other day they will learn how to defend themselves. It’s completely natural, every action has an equal and opposite reaction, you reap what you sow, karma, it’s the reaction of an action.
agreed
Yes we threw them out, it was not gandhi nor the greatness of Britishers that we got independence it was Subhas Chandra Bose who United a army and revolted and that got us freedom.
amazing
If you could describe the western behavior in one word - Hypocrisy
....
Totally agree
Coloniel mentality is still there,look at the west's newspaper article about india always try to make fun of india.
it's like the big bullying the smaller ones type of thing. But this is usually done by media and I don't think common people think much like that.
@@zuzanareactsI have seen many Street interviews and most of them have same image of india like BBC shows, I don't know why you are still supporting that argument that only newspapers have that mentality, it's rooted in people,if people were against it then media wouldn't have shown something like this on daily basis
U said big bullying.....who s big here????
Lol what you said here is delusion no offence, Look all over the Internet and you will see how hated India is. @@zuzanareacts
He tell absolute true 👌
he does
1:14
Bengal a place in India , known for its high quality jute production.
thank you!
Take a very simple example.
You point guns and sticks on a farmer and force him to grow cotton. You impose 66% tax on land produce and buy the remaining 33% at a fixed, very low rate on behalf of the state. Now, you ship that raw material without any custom or tariffs to Britain, get clothes manufactured in private and state run mills and then ship it back to India. You import these products with a high custom duty which will be borne by Indian consumer. You either ban and outlaw any local manufacturers or you impose exorbitantly high taxes that they shut down. Now the only option left with Indian public is to produce cotton, pay 66% tax, generate almost no profit, buy British finished cloth at high prices and also pay the added custom and tax on it. That tax money will be used to pay civil servants brought in from Scotland and Britain as well as pay extravagant incentives to British private investors to come and build railway tracks in India so that those raw materials could be transported more easily and with lower cost.
Now you extend this economic policy nation wide for a duration of over 200 years and you get the colonial rule.
You do a simple calculation of all direct and indirect wealth transferred to Britain, adjust it for inflation and you get the amount of 45 trillion Pound Sterlings.
I see - I appreciate you sharing!
Secularism in India -😂 Hindu temples under government control, but not Muslim mosques and Christian churches. My secular India where only hindu temple pay taxes to govt. 😅
wow
@@zuzanareacts which means minorities are imposing their values, whereas the majority are facing the issues... it doesn't mean secularism. India is the only country where hindus are in majority and even over here we can not speak bluntly about our cultural values
@@jaichauhan5306 I'm hindu bhramin 😎 but Scared to live in India.
@@Sanatandharam1996 brother look what have you written it's not about caste it's about religion... In our religion all people have been continuously leading their caste that is why we are divided and others are getting benefits of it even our old literatures have not mentioned about it... And I hope you must know everything depends on a person in which skill he is master..
@@jaichauhan5306 👍 caste toh waise hi likha h bhai. Hm sb ek h hindu ...
Bengal is an Indian state. Now it's divided into Bangladesh (which is now an independent country) and West Bengal (Indian State). Britishers stole not just money aka wealth but destroyed the social structure. C'mon can you blame him. Didn't Europe destroy the world, especially Africa and Asia? Oh no Zuzana, everyone knows about the west at least the Africans and Asians.
About the money. He is saying for instance before the British invasion of India, India and China were the richest countries on this planet. And when the British left India, India become one of the poorest countries of the world. Britain especially is made from stolen wealth. You should investigate more of Indian history.
Sorry Zuzana, the Europeans destroyed the social fabric of Africans. You need study about the African continent and slave trade. Africans were used as slaves do not mention Indians as slaves by the British.
Every affected country is not India.
This is an old video Zuzana. India is coming up with solution. Maybe if you are interested, I could recommend some videos. Meanwhile please do a reaction on TATA's business empire part 1 and 2. You said in your last video you wanted to learn about Indian industries.
Anyways it's nice to hear from a Slovak. I would love to visit your beautiful country one day. I've been to Romania.
Thank you for your comment. I'm aware of the Africa - I'm even aware how the 'west' tries to go and preach and provide solutions that don't work there. I worked in that capacity so I got some insights there. Feel free to recommend. I'm collating all the videos and will work through my reactions - it will take me a bit of time not going to lie - just please bare with. I'm actually aware of tata - I have someone from my family employed there. Thanks again for the support and your thoughts! ❤🙏
@zuzanareacts I am sorry, I commented and recommended some videos and answered some of your questions from your last video. I don't know what happened if it got deleted or something. Anyway, l your❤ reactions. Please keep asking questions, I am no expert, but I do know a thing or two about finance and geopolitics.
Just wondering after how long the crimes committed by a county can be forgotten and forgiven.. So much injustice were done to Indians and Africans...But we hardly talk about it
I'm not too sure ... I feel like we all need not to wait but forgive in our hearts and move forward without expecting anything and build great lives.
@@zuzanareacts I agree with you sister.. But to much injustice were done to Indians for thousands or years by invaders.. We should forgive but must not forget so that our future generations do not have to go thorough similar situation again in the future.. As it is said history repeats itself
@@netpro4379 I agree we should definitely learn from it. Though the history has the weird thing of repeating itself - I wonder how to stop this or if this is meant to be like that...
You can understand this lecture after complete understanding of 200 years history of India during British period. Friend read India's history during British period.
I shall
@@zuzanareacts still many people have colonial mentality. They think they are superior. But you are one of the exceptions from colonial mentality.
Carbon emissions is a concept where the west spreads a huge lot of propaganda taking advantage of the mathematical ignorance of their population. They always talk about totals instead of per capita. Not dividing the number by population is simply unfair. For example India's total emissions are about 2533 million tons and Slovakia's are only 36 million tons, looking at this you would think India is a huge polluter but when you divide this by population India's per capita emissions are only 1.91 while Slovakia's are 6.77. This data is for 2016 from "worldometers" or you can simply search "carbon emission per capita by country". They use this trick in various other negative stats like crime etc. to make themselves look good and lecture others. Then they use this propaganda to impose carbon related taxes and sanctions thereby denying fair competition.
I hear you and trust me I know - there is a limit to what one can say on here though
If European union charge pollution tax, India will charge pollution tax on the country according to the history. India has started collecting data of Industrial revolution and will charge history carbon emission tax on European Union and USA.
love it - it's like batch at you b*%$ haha
Respect from India, keep doing more ❤❤❤❤
thank you - means a lot! Lot of love ❤
Please listen Sashi Tharoor lecture in UK. That will clear your doubt.
thank you for the recommendation!
Thanks to Germany for ww1 and ww2 these made Britain weak
that's a point
You should check Shashi tharoor's address at Oxford University regarding should England owe reparations to India?
Also he is talking about colonialism and Bengal famine in India which was a man made famine that was due to the militant policies of Winston Churchill.
Also you should read about postcolonialism and anti colonial struggles. Read the works of Franz Fanon as well I think you will be more educated about colonialism.
Regarding environment it was the west who polluted this earth first with their so called industrial revolution. Now since they are advanced they dont want other non industrialise countries to industrialise who couldn't initially because of the colonialism and slave owning whites. So why cant other countries industrialise and be on an equal footing with the west? Should west only be the one to industrialise itself and then lecture others on industrialisation? Bit rich from the west.
I'm there with you!
I think you misunderstood his stance on dealing with climate change (not blaming you as he didn't really explain it 😅but this argument comes up in almost every climate debate), so I'll try to explain it as best I can..
He is referring to how the industrialization of West was achieved by degrading the climate by excessive use of fossil fuels and due to this development the western countries can now afford to switch to more sustainable alternatives without much effort.. In contrast, much of the developing world lacks even the basic infrastructure (let alone the advanced tech needed for sustainable solutions) and any efforts for industrialization would have to include using natural resources excessively (something we already lack due to the "development" in the west) and this would result in dire consequences for the world..
The only way to resolve this issue would be the developed world financing the sustainable industrialization of the developing world.. However, this is a HIGHLY contentious idea in the west since politicians know their voters would not tolerate a significant burden to their wallets fighting climate change in "third world" countries (heck, many of their voters don't even believe in climate change 😅)..
Hope this helps.. Peace! 🙏:)
thank you for sharing - I hear you!
Your reply sounds empty .......totally ......always defending west type ......not your fault though .......stay safe be defending like this in future also
You do need a lot of ground on many fields like World History, Climate Change, Industrial Revolution, Slave Trade etc etc before you can understand a simple video clip like this ! Bless you in your endeavour to learn 🙏🏻🇮🇳🙏🏻
thank you! I appreciate it.
Ground work* Edit that
True that 👌
When you ask questions like this in such video sometimes I wonder “what is west teaching there kids in school”….. we are taught our own history, world history including French Revolution, Russian revolution, renaissance, WW1, WW2, china opium war etc in 9th 10th grades…. 🙄
we are still taught a lot to be fair - I just don't think we go in that much detail and focus on our region more.
Indian Government :- we will become carbon neutral country by 2070.
Announced at Conference of party 26, Glasgow
amazing - cannot wait for this!
@@zuzanareactsnot gonna happen in your life time 😅
Please read the entire comment so that you will understand what the speaker meant when he said "you are giving us our money"-
Quick History -
Civilization in Indian Subcontinent goes back to at least 10,000 BC.
Cotton was first cultivated in the region.
Port cities, such as Lothal, were used to trade with other civilisations.
Coins were minted using standard weights.
Cities were planned using standard measuring tools (Harappa is belied to be 1st planned city/civilization in the world).
Indians used to perform plastic and cataract surgery much before anyone (800 BC - Sushruta is considered Father of Medicine).
Indian kings had proper economic, foreign, military policies in 300 BC (in the form of “Arthashashtra” and “Chanakya Niti”).
Aryabhatta invented the numeral Zero (0), Yoga is attributed to lord Shiva and many more such invention and discoveries took place in the Indian Subcontinent.
With everything that natives of Indian Subcontinent had achieved, there were and still are some white supremacists who believed that it is a “White Man’s Burden” to civilize the “uncivilized”.
When British arrived in India, Indian subcontinent was home to almost 25% of World’s population, contributed around 25% of world’s industrial output and India’s share was almost 23% of World’s GDP. When they left in 1947, Indian economy shrank to less than 3%. They were able to achieve this ‘feat” using unfair practices. They levied heavy taxes on Indian exports while discounted British Imports. Our share in Global export dropped from 27% to almost 2%. This destroyed out handloom industry and at the same time fuelled Industrial revolution in Europe. They forces farmers to grow cash crops, such as indigo, instead to food crops (because cash crops had higher profit margins and were in high demand during the Industrial revolution). This resulted in human induced famines during British Raj in India. Millions of people died. In recent time, Winston Churchill was the biggest culprit of Bengal Famine of 1943. He siphoned off the food supplies from India and stock piled for British soldiers during WW2.
So, the speaker in this video is referring to these biased and unjust British policies that resulted in the economic drain of India.
I understand and appreciate the time you've taken to explain. I think that the karma is coming back around and these things can no longer become 'hidden'
@@zuzanareacts I would like to clarify one thing. Even though we were colonized and used for centuries, there is not an iota of ill will against any British Citizen in the hearts of Indians. We do understant it is the policy makers who are at fault.
@@DhruvJoshiDJand yet racism in UK is at all time High, recent survey shows that nearly 60% Indian's in UK have faced racism,and these Indians are not even truly Indian,they hate their own culture,they hate everything related to india,even religion,they try their best to blend into western culture but still gets so much hate because they always forget that they are not white🤣
Background on Bengal Famine 1943:
India as a whole did not have a food shortage in 1943--in fact, it exported over 70,000 tons of rice for use by British troops and British civilians.
Then U.K. Prime Minister Winston Churchill, as part of the western war effort(WW II), ordered the diversion of food from Indians to already well-supplied British soldiers and stockpiles in Britain and Europe.
He even procured food grains at a higher price(US, Canada were willing to provide food grains, but he didn't accepted).
As a result, around 3 million people died(reported data), but experts says the death toll was around 10 million.
Here I quote his words, " I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion." When Informed of the rising death toll, Churchill quipped that he only regretted that MK Gandhi was not among the dead"
2) How UK looted 45 Trillion USD from India:
They mastered the art of looting, and engineered such systems by which they acquired every commodity for free, moreover they even introduced taxed on every produce. The imposed tax rate was so high, that peasants, farmers, traders were not able to pay. So as penalties they acquired the goods, land, etc.
Those who were able to pay those taxes, the britts used the money out of that tax to acquire their goods/produce.
And other things like Gold, Diamonds, Artifacts, etc they just looted and went back to UK.
I hope it answers your questions.
Amazing - thank you so much for taking your time and sharing!
@@zuzanareactsthey literally plucked out precious gems from the forts n palaces. If you go to rajsthan. You can see that happened how they removed gems from the art. Same for taj mahal too. It had lot many gems put into its art which today there's nothing but just art. There are no gems on the taj mahals walls or rajasthan forts/palaces walls🤦
1:05 He is talking about Bengal which was considered as a region of India where Bengal jute(rough fiber made from the stems of a tr09opical Old World plant, used for making twine and rope or woven into sacking or matting) was very famous back then because
of its quality there were evidence of trading through sea route to East Asia and Europe, America was not even discovered yet when this trade was its peak , When they arrived in Bengal in 1612 during the reign of emperor Jahangir ( I am talking about East India Company-a British trading company, Because they were doing trade with East Asia through the Indian ocean that is how they got their name East India Company) they competed with other European competitors(French East India company etc) and started gaining more land to establish its company there after the Battle of Plassey 1757-58, so he is talking about trade between Dundee(India) and Glasgow port
(Uk).
1:51 When they started doing trade with us this is following what they did-1) Started acquiring more lands to do their business by pleasing kings of that region.
2)Building railroads so that they can transfer raw materials they need.
3) Started destroying hand weavers and handloom workers so that they can (British) sell their products.(Sorry that's all I know).
2:09 Not with violence(Because we knew that if we would use violence against them they could have done terrible with us) but with non-violence(If you know Gandhi) yes we did threw them out.
3:50 He is trying to say that We as Indians have still lots of work to do to boost our economy so that not only we outnumber China on
population but as a economic power as well and for all of this our industrialization should be fast too and industries emit carbon too
yet we are far behind when it comes to carbon emissions( According to Statista research India holds 4th rank) and now they are saying
you should cut your carbon emission.
4:39 I got your point but It's not like we are not doing anything we proposed this Idea which give them an alternative of co2 emissions
which "One sun one grid one world"(The One Sun One World One Grid (OSOWOG) is a transnational electricity grid supplying power all over the world)
6:27 Yes ignorance is the correct word.
7:06 It is their money they worked hard for it that is why they are developed.
9:04 Yes we all should have to be cautious about environment because it effects all of us.
* Sorry for the incorrect word- America was discovered before this(In 1492).
thank you so much for sharing. I appreciate all your have put there!
Most of the colonizers colonized for the reason of resources,slaves etc resources shipped back which benefited their own country and obviously the countrymen too. In monetary terms UK looted trillions from India and yet they haven't even said sorry. All this colonizers donot have or have limited resources on their own land. Hence at present where colonizing has been done with the decline in most of this European countries has begun.
yep - agreed
I am one of viewer from India, I would like to suggest you to please watch the whole video and then respond. Also, when reacting to some political and historical videos, some amount of research from your end will be appreciated. I still appreciate your effort to learn about India.
thank you for your comment I appreciate it. I wanted to learn with the people was my intention but I hear what you are saying/
I'm sorry but the person is ryt these r not fun topics we r already hurt enough by the suffering of those events pls don't touch those wounds if you're not a doctor or even a nurse who understands the seriousness i hope you get this 🙏
We know that it was the past we also know that no reparation will be there but why dont they teach these history in uk and france about how there ancestors treated other humans and put your egos down and apologize. Still many westerners look down upon indian and african
I hope this to be if true by politicians only ❤
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. The IMF's lending pool is financed by member countries. Each member is assigned a quota, based broadly on its relative position in the world economy. Countries can then borrow from this pool when they fall into financial difficulty. Therefore, IMF basically lends the money back to the owner of the money although not dollar for dollar.
And its not a surprise that IMF leaders are not elected but nominated by US and EU. The voting power is skewed in favour of G7 which implement the loan conditions. Finally the founding members of the IMF were all colonialists and the charter documents till date do not include any inputs from any of the colonies.
Nice reaction 👍
Thank you - glad you enjoyed it! :)
The total loot from India in 200 years - Word Wars 1 and 2 in today's money is calculated to GBP 45 trillion in today's money. The records are available.
I think your disagreement about green energy is valid. But the condensatnding part is india asked for to make a global green fund where developed countries would lend developing countries money to make green energy. But they dont want to do that. And the 2nd part is how developed nations miss climate goal according to paris agreement and force developing countries to become green overnight.
I totally hear you! everyone just watches out for their own interests which is not really the way forward. Hence I like the Indian philosphy of sanatan.
@@zuzanareactsYou like Sanatan?🥺💜
You know, Indian history is the longest history in the world,
I am referring to read Indian History
India has eradicated extreme poverty and we r growing rapidly but we know our past..... Today when I see Africa i can relate what they are going through..... So i simply suggest to don't look down upon them, I know it's easier to say than to change your mindset but try once ....
I don't look upon them - I'm actually baffled that it coms across that way.
Some of my comments deleted . Why i didnt use any abusive language 😢 . Just said truth .
hmm - I didn't delete any comments. I see there is a section that some comments are held but I didn't look there - maybe they are there.
Sometimes youtube does that.... TH-cam delete some comments itself even though that comment don't have any abusive or negative words in it...
I have personally seen that.... I commentd in one of my videos from other phone with different usernames and it got deleted....
Bhai meri bhi hui hai bina kisi baat k . Ye TH-cam hi Karta hai pta nhi kyun
Lots of Love ❤❤to you ❤ Slovak.
Watch Mr.Tharoor debate in oxford..u will get gist of indian history
thank you for the suggestion!
World is not just the west. Still lot to learn
Madam To understand, study India for just 600 years , then our tones and words come so powerful, and why the gentle man is furious and blasting we come to terms understanding
ok
Sister please do some research...you will know how cruel the Britishers are and how bad their step brother mother father sister culture is.
its a process - pls bare with
Yeah we weren't so United at that time.....The British perfected their practice of "divide and rule strategy" through various experiments all over its colonies..... That's why if u see sometimes that we indians get united as soon as we hear about the west, it's been engraved in our DNA over centuries of attrocities...... WW lasted for max 5 years, but we suffered it continuously over a couple of centuries !!.... And 1000 years if u consider islamic invasions as well but the 2 cases were very different, we can't compare the two...... Thankfully just 75 years of our independence and we covered a milestone and made our mark known without depriving others or colonializing others
thank yuo for sharing!
Your childhood may have been privileged compared to the experiences of over 2 billion kids worldwide, which makes it challenging to fully comprehend their realities.
The West has historically exploited and plundered resources from Africa and Asia, accumulating wealth in the process. Now, having become prosperous through centuries of polluting the Earth, they seek to hold everyone equally accountable for environmental degradation.
However, many poor or developing countries, most of which gained independence after World War II, have been stripped of their resources and left with limited funds and resources to pursue sustainable paths. Their immediate priorities revolve around providing food, shelter, clothing, and meeting basic needs for their citizens.
It is important to acknowledge that there is a significant disparity in carbon emissions per capita between poor countries and the West, where emissions remain alarmingly high.
Despite these challenges, we recognize our responsibilities and strive to do everything within our limited resources and funds to protect and preserve our shared environment, our mother Earth.
and I'm not saying you are wrong and totally agree with you!
2: 11 why are you laughing when he told we Indians throwed European and especially britishers out of India, our great freedom fighter subhash chandra bose made britishers run for their lives.
I'm laughing because I'm here for it! I love that they did that!
@@zuzanareacts oh I thought you can't believe that Indians would dare to kick the britishers out of India. Ok you enjoyed good,I enjoyed you reaction too.
In simple and short for you to understand.
"You know nothing, John Snow."
don't we all :) - so great we are all willing to learn - well some of us :)
When industrialisation was started in the west and lots of carbon was emitted at that time, than it was good. But later on the developing nation started the same industrialisation after 100 years until when the west became a rich nation and they are now worried about carbon emissions. Do you really think that in African countries some industries are responsible for North pole ice melting. All single houses in West have Air conditioning and Fridge product clorofloro carbon is reducing the ozone layer due to which climate is changing
I'm not saying you are wrong!
It will be good USA , UK, France and other colonialist nations talk less and mind their own business rather than middling in others biz and interfering on a day to day affairs!
Mam the simple fact about India is, it is a civilization country which have at least 5-7 thousand years of written history. India contribute 25-30% world GDP when Westerners came and when they left India only contribute 2-3% of GDP. They ruins the entire country just for an example education system, health system and many of current days problems are directly linked with westerns for instance boarder dispute with China, they divide India into 2 half, they created socio-religious tensions and yet they try to lecture us every now and then. But one thing general western public don't know is that India is not what you media shows if you wanna really know the ground reality you should watch other sources as well which is obviously not western ( or should i say influenced by left idiology). India has come long way and long way to go, we are slowly reclaiming our position in the world like China did. We know present day westerns are not responsible for what happened in the past but when these same Westerners take pride and say we did gave you this we gave you that, it's pissed us off.
thank you for sharing. I have done a video on the Unseen Truth of India - so I'm aware of the portrayal and I hope India goes from strength to strenght
Zuzana, you are really a very intelligent lady. Lots of love to you from India. 🥰
Thank you so much 😊 - it means a lot to me! Sending lots of love back ❤
Watch Shashi Tharoor's speech in Oxford called British owes india reparation. You will understand this. The colonial mentality that he is referring to is that politicians and also generally people from American, British and European's blame the global South for many of the environmental problems. If India wasn't looted 45 trillions of dollars by the british, where would India be today? They did the same with African people. When westerners talk wreaks of arrogance and colonial mentality because they had the same attitude then and still maintain it today. India was a great civilization and it didn't any Europeans to invade, loot and convert people into their stooges. No offense to you. You are just trying to understand. History has been told by the invaders as far as India is concerned but not by the people of the land. This is slowly changing. Wish you success in your channel.
jotted down - thanks!
One thing i would like to point out....india is the only country to fullfill its promises made in the Paris Conference of Climate Change....plus we also set up some targets in the Glassglow Conference which were to be met in 2030 but at the speed which we are going some of them will be done as soon as 2027-28 ....In that way India is the not the country which only talkes but it also stands by her commitments
it is amazing!!
Western media is like 😇😭
this is the challenge it is the media here that does not represent what people think just goes with its narrative
@@zuzanareacts So, the common people just follows and judge with it blindly?
@@botslayerwr1975yep
They sucked out all the wealth out of India, its time for them to repay.
If u convert in today's time, it will amount to 45 trillion pounds. That's what he means simply
No, meeting somewhere in the middle will me some thing like, let me eat all ur food and then we will share the bill in half. You need to see the past before any questions arising in your mind. But today after G20 summit I see some hope that world will become a better place soon.
India ❤ Russia
Zuzana is Slovakian.
She's Slovak bro☠️they are enemies of Russia, I mean at least their government,so don't write such comments over here
UK's queen is wearing Kohinoor Diamond 💎 in her crown ✨️ 👑 👑 looted from India ..
Shame 🎉🎉🎉
please visit British museum.
I did :)
You want answers about what he is talking about, search Shashi Tharoor speech and you will get all answers
I will have a look!
Sure US and west also take loan from IMF and others, but they practically own these institutions. When we take loan that means US is taking over your economy through these institutions. And about money all members contribute accordingly to their capacity but when loan is given then instructions are given how to spend it.( But US and West don't get any interference as they are the masters themselves)
The British had to leave india because of the retaliation of "British Indian armed forces soldiers" so ya he speaks truth when he says we threw them out.
good
In 1700 when British came to india for business at that moment india alone has 36% economy of the world ...
interesting
Indians don't forget history that's why when we speaks always makes sense and for other its a confusion..
history has been really manipulated and used for political purposes many nations have issues with that. I hope these things are coming to light now and can be resolved.
1:50
Before the South African gold , Indian gold ores were the only source of gold in this world .
We still have a lot of gold and we always have an affinity towards gold ( India wasn't called a golden bird for no reason) .
There is a river in odisha called subernarekha ( famous for having gold as its surface and shined golden )
We were the most civilized one in the world full of knowledge and prosperity
I don't know why God took all those days and that we were innocent.😔By the way loved your reaction
there is always a reason - I think all things are cyclical - what goes up must come down - the circle of life. I appreciate your kind words ❤
@@zuzanareactswhat a beautiful way to look at it 🖤
Speaking with ur real voice
Context- He is talking at COP convention where the EU has proposed a carbon credit system for heavy industries world wide, which is heavily rigged in favour of the west.
Essentially poor countries have to pay carbon taxes in order to be able to access the EU markets for their finished products.
This carbon tax is based on the amount of total carbon emissions of a country and not on the basis of per capita carbon emission.
Most African nations and India have a high population but very low per capita emission.
Plus they are not sharing critical technologies, which may help the LDC's of the world reduce their carbon footprint.
That's not for the Climate change, it's for them to suck the blood of non western countries till there's none left, while they are responsible for the most of it 😂😂...
Meanwhile,
India met it's COP 27 goals 5 years earlier than expected.
Founded one sun one grid solar alliance with 70+ nations.
40% of India's (1.44 billion people) energy consumption comes from renewable resources.
Most Indians are vegetarians, which is in contrast with the west's meat processing industries, who are not only the biggest carbon polluters of the world but also responsible for mass scale animal cruelity.
Thank you very much for sharing!
Never miss with India 😎⚡💥
haha
Such unnecessary arrogance!
@@sewaligoswami781 do you have any problem???
@@aravind4090 see you proved my point brother.
@@sewaligoswami781 you just cross your limit so mind your words ok 👍👍 👍
History
You should check history facts
You will know the truth
Truth can't be hidden
Truth is supreme
When the British left India in 1947, they left India hungry. India didn't have the food to survive. Our grandfather told us his story that they didn't have two meals for the day.
I think she does not know how much was taken from India in the classic colonial period . No other colonial country is actually comparable to India , as India was the jewel in the crown for the british raj , their best cash cow .
I'm here to learn
1:50 in very short, they used India as a raw material supplier and a market, while eliminating native artisans and handicraft workers by chopping their hands. plus their ruthless tax policies, ….u can understand colonialism. plus looting indian artefacts, diamonds, valuable statues all kept in british museum
v sad
A sincere public apology by colonial forces to Bharat is the least we can expect from them.
However they are not humane enough to do so.,🥴
I think they have proven that this might not happen but you never know. In the meantime, we move forward with the head held high.😎❤
you studied western books you cant feel our history...
we studied all over the world but I guess it's not really in that much depth so naturally more attention is given to closer regions which I believe is logical
of couse she just wants the indian views from youtube and nothing else. they are cunning xd
@@zuzanareacts Author can manipulate any scenario. Read INDIAN author books.
This is the history of British real history😢😢
Sorry Suzana....INDIA is not just a colony......INDIA was the biggest cash cow of BRITAIN.......We were the richest on the planet before they came in.........
Yep - I think in the Oxford address it was mentioned. Thank you for pointing it out.
He was talking about independence india
I see - thank you!
Ya that's true
His speech is for People like you, who don't know what's happening in the world beyond their immediate view. Sorry if that sounds harsh but that's the truth...
no offence taken - I think it is important to speak up and I'm hear to learn so I really enjoy it
Look at your smirk when you say you think that you threw the british out, yes we deed and it was netaji shubhash chandra bose who threw the british out from India
I smirk because I like you did - so many people got this so wrong about me!
@@zuzanareacts ohk, I'm sorry about that but it seriously looked like you mocked indian people
many people thought like you but it is not what I thought at all quite the contrary :)
Smells like, Zuzana is defending colonialism !
Isn't this amazing when your mind cannot comprehend 45 trillion pound, how someone could steal that much of money ( and by money he meant the amount of resources that has been took from here and the tax that was paid and the money was not spent on anything besides what was needed for britishers, so please don't say things like they built railways and we know why they built it & how much times more it cost to use 😂)
And about debt, there is international institutions like IMF, World Bank, etc. in which every member invest their money and they took loan when they need it, its basically I'm investing for our worse days, so what he meant is, inspite of lecturing help would go a long way.
Seems like you too have a colonial mentality Suzanna
My country never led a war or colonised any other country so I must respectfully disagree. I don't even know what colonial mentality mean to be very honest.
@@zuzanareactsthen you shouldn't have supported the west when he was referring to them as people with colonial mentality,not only the influential people but the common people also has the colonial mentality which I have seen in many videos,you aren't one of them Zuzana 💜
45 trillion worth of gold and other precious metals and artifacts..... It took around 70 80 years... Not a one day task
By the way, I am a strict person but now I feel that I will fall in love with someone. Only zuzana is to blame for this. ❤😂🇮🇳
haha - that is very sweet :) ❤
India didn't throw the British out . British left India after WW2. The Chinese were still fighting to throw out their colonizers . Many chines lives lost in fighting against zcolonizers and they never left Taiwan. I agree with Vijay on most of the facts. India still sucking up to their colonizers. 😅 😂
Just some lines I found in comments sometime back about history (not mine):-
Studying history will sometime disturb you.
Studying history will sometime upset you.
Studying history will sometime make you furious.
If studying history always makes you feel proud and happy, Then you probably aren't studying history
If your ( specially west US, UK, and others) history makes you feel that you achived something in past, you did greater goods ( by looking at some western people's videos, It's clear that they are proud and happy with their history) then my friend you should know you are learning WRONG history.
BTW you are trying to learn zuzana, keep it up!!
2:04 yes, we threw them out and not at all gandhian way (which is farce created but british empire) but by rebels from sides of india. Total britishers in india was less than hundred thousand and indians were 300 million. 99% of the army, navy, police force were indians, now image they'll started rebelling.
Please go find out what mr. Clement attlee (former prime minister of uk) has to say about whether their are chased out or just a matter of "good conscience".
No Zuzana what he means is that while the West has centrally heated homes on Natural gas and coal, countries like Ukraine, etc. do not waste or splurge energy.
He is talking about those 45 trillion euro which Britain looted from India when they came to India. Today's so called civilized Britain is from all those looted money.
Hey British lady Kohinoor diamond and gold Britisher😅😅
Fact, dark past ,truth
fair
Mam every word of his is very very true
I think you should learn and read colonial era and its effect 🙂🙏