Dr. S. Jaishankar calls out the West! (Honest reaction by a Slovak European)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 มิ.ย. 2023
- Come and join me to see what is my reaction as a Slovak European to Dr. S. JaiShankar's reaction to the hypocrisy of the West.
I'd love to see what you think in the comments section below.
Dr. S. Jaishankar calls out the West! (Honest reaction by a Slovak European)
Check out also my reaction to Dr. S. JaiShankar on the Ranveer Show here: • Dr. S Jaishankar on Ra...
#jaishankar
#ranveerallahbadia
#reactionvideo
#european
If you feel that is how it works, this is the exact reason we have a good relationship with Russia because when Europe and US supported Pakistan during the 1971 war, only Russia stood with India even in UN vetoeing in favour of India.
So yes, we do repay back the good faith and remember the betrayal from before.
I actually do have a video (not yet produced) on Russian Indian relationship - I really wanted to understand as you might imagine a perception of people from Central Europe that had to endure communism may not be all that favourable towards our fellow Slavic nation
@@zuzanareacts yes, I completely understand your point. Was just giving you the Indian perspective to the reason behind India not isolating Russia completely.
Looking forward to that video of yours. Cheers and good luck.
@@zuzanareactslike how you can have a point, same way India and Indians have their point.
@@zuzanareacts don't stop video intermittently... It's annoying
@@zuzanareacts We have thousand years of history and the only reason we think different is because in our scriptures we are taught to be considerate of interests but without harming others!!! What Ukraine is undergoing is not because we messed up…its because the west messed up and they should find a solution not us!!
India never attack any country first. We Indian's believe in VASUDHAVE KUTUMBKAM means the whole world 🌎 IS ONE FAMILY, for that's why we are not supporting any side . We are Standing with peace ✌ 🙏.
amazing - it's such a philosophy of mine! I wish the world listened to you guys more!🙏
@@zuzanareacts that cost us alot already and we should always remember that the world doesn't think the same. this is the reason our older gens let Britishers enter our country and treated them like some guest.
Dear lady, Dr. S. Jaishankar is not a politician, he is a best technocrat (a very highly educated government officer who have raised to the top administrative post ,a technocrat is a well educated government officer who has cracked very very difficult exams ,handled difficult jobs and reached to highest rank officer ) selected to take over difficult job which can not be properly handle by a publically elected leader.
thank you for sharing.
But she does not know about to divine soul dr.jaishakar sir very intelligent people I love them❤
"She has no idea about how geopolitics works" Whatever he said is 110% true word by word. ❤❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I'm not disagreeing with him - just sharing my own perspective even though it might be uneducated as I'm trying to learn.
They are educated u don't misunderstand,u know what online geopolitical clases in India,thies guy r preparation for competative exams ,u see their responding
Keep it coming, It's interesting to see your perspective.
Btw I didn't know much about slovakia and The best thing I got to know about your country is "YOU BANNING ISLAM"🗿
Islam really is a threat to humanity. And We wish we could do the same to protect our country from this violent cult.
This means a lot. Thank you for your kind words. Slovakia is a very small country in the heart of Europe so we are a Central European nation only 5 million big. I actually find similarities between India and Slovakia in terms of culture. Slovaks are very family orientated and live with their parents till quite late - multi generational households are still a thing here. Sometimes when I watch (guilty as charged Indian Matchmaking on Netflix) I see similarities :).
@@zuzanareacts ❤
@@nikhil_01a religious books divides Hindus and muslims and not constitiution.. You must tell muslims to follow constitution instead quran
@@nikhil_01a Read their "bookS" and then say the same thing about uniting.
@@nikhil_01a I wouldn't slide "hindus" together when it comes to extremism! However it seems you lack the knowledge to understand that. Have you read their(islamic) scripture? Banning islam is not the way in a large country like India and I know that. But first step would be that we shouldn't run away from the facts. But when you include hindus, sikhs, christian, while addressing extremism in india, You are running away from the fact that Islam has some fundamental problems.
Thats what Jaishankar sir was trying to convey...as an European,you dont even know that there is a conflict going on between India and China.
By saying that you dont know about this problem,you have actually proved his point i.e. "World's problems are not Europe's problems" .
I get it now and he is right!
Not so long ago China tried to "move" the border, there was a physical fighting and few Indians were killed.😢
@@pancake5707 Chinese too were killed
Well said
@@zuzanareactsneed to be matured
. *DEFINITION OF INDIA*
*Sometimes I feel so proud to be an Indian that tears come to my eyes.*
*That I am a resident of that country, in which people of all religions live peacefully.*
𒊹︎︎︎ *And the country which helps other countries without any greed but also helps those countries which are anti-India.*
𒊹︎︎︎ *The country in which every person(except Muslims) considers Every religion as their religion.*
𒊹︎︎︎ *The country which does not consider any country as small, gives equal respect to every country, even if it is anti india.*
𒊹︎︎︎ *the country where animals, trees, rivers Everything is all given equal Respect to human beings.*
𒊹︎︎︎ *The country which has a culture of helping Everyone without any greed, which has a culture, the whole world is our family "those who are with us are also our family and those who are against us are also our family".*
𒊹︎︎︎ *The country which puts humanity above all in the world.*
𒊹︎︎︎ *the country which has not attacked any country before till date. Even if it did, it was only a retaliatory attack on Pakistan and that too when Pakistan carried out terrorist attacks on India several times.*
*Despite this, till date India neither thought bad about Pakistan nor gave any statement against Pakistan and Pakistani PM. (such as Pakistani Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto called Indian PM Modi a butcher and also said that if G20 meeting will be held in India We will give a befitting reply to India).*
𒊹︎︎︎ *When I was a child, I had heard many times that there is a heaven, I did not believe it. When I grew up, I understood a little bit of worldliness, then I came to believe that there is a heaven and that too on earth, the name of that heaven is "India".*
𒊹︎︎︎ *(I am a Sikh and I say with 100% surety that if India is heaven then only and only because of Hindus(Sanatanis).*
*Because till date I have not seen Hindus speaking ill of anyone and doing bad things to anyone.*
*Some people are bad in every society but I am 100% sure that 99.99% Hindus cannot even think of doing bad to anyone. Those who are vegetarian because no animal should be killed, will they think bad of anyone.*
*(I love and respect Hindus(Sanatani) a lot)*
𒊹︎︎︎ *Whatever I have written about the culture of India in this comment, only and only Hindus have contributed in maintaining it for centuries.*
𒊹︎︎︎ *India, which is the world's largest democracy and secular country, has a huge contribution of Hindus in keeping it secular.*
𒊹︎︎︎ *I am 26 years old till date whatever I have experienced as an Indian and as much as I have read the history of India. I am saying all this on the basis of them.*
𒊹︎︎︎ *Everyone wants to praise their country but I am talking about facts.*
. *Gurdeep Singh*
This is very beautiful and deeply touching. Thank you for sharing your thoughts with me.🙏❤
@@zuzanareacts You should understand from his comment that 99% of sikhs loves India and that 1% is controlled by Pakistan in the name of "Khalistan" creating chaos is every part of the country... Sikhs are warrior elite of India, there contribution to the country is sky is the limit... Only muslims are not happy in every country that they live, only chaos chaos chaos. Parsis are happy, Jews are happy here, Majority christians are happy, zororastrians are happy, buddhist are happy, jains are happy. Etc..
Same love to Sikhism. We love it.
@@MohanKumar-xx6mu Interesting - thank you for sharing!
Dude I appreciate your sentiment but why so cringey with tears and stuff
It's always lovely to hear different opinions from other parts of the world.
Yes ,I agree
AS Indians, We shouldn't be worried about Western opinions especially the EU.
Don't take them seriously just for entertainment only
Media is just a break time snaks for him 😂
lol
I think we indians are very emotional and go out of our way to do the best for people who genuinely think good for us, who care, respect, help us in the time of need and we consider those our real friends. And this happens at all level from family and even globally. And if new people are partnering up with us we will definitely resprocrate and even go further but we would never ditch the old friends
I think this is such a wonderful quality to have!
He is not just a politician he is the mind which is filtered from UPSC..🇮🇳
🙌
That too is from Indian foreign service. Top of UPSC 🔥
Your attitude and deneanour is fresh, open ended and ready to learn. That is very ethical. As a senior citizen of India i will clarify your issues in a couple of days.
thats the problem of europe whenever europe has a problem they want to whole world to act on it but whenever asia has a problem (like india and china conflict in ladakh) their media just dont show to them. if sometimes any cases happens in india regarding (internal issue) whole europe lecturing about democracy in danger (india). i am sorry about harsh.
No it's ok. I'm very open and I like to hear different points of views and how it's perceived and I very much appreciate your comments.
Thank you for letting us know the Slovakian perspective. Your perspective was refreshing to hear. On your China question, India and China have a raging border issue. China audaciously claims an entire Indian state (Arunachal Pradesh) to be Chinese territory. There are issue on other border points as well. When JS says Europe's problems...he is also hinting to what Europe did in the pandemic. Vaccines were hoarded in EU, Indian vaccine was not recognised, and India suffered a lot because of US and EU.
All the best for your channel. You're doing really well.
thank you for sharing and for your kind comments and support! Much appreciated ❤
You are correct bro. But I want to highlight the lady that when India says collective Europe in geopolitical terms most of the time it targets Western Europe especially Germany, Netherlands, French , Belgium like countries not Eastern Europe. Eastern Europe from Hungary to Lithuania even to Georgia we have a very bright relationship (UK is considered the Anglo-Saxon although they are in Europe but we consider them as a US state😂 just like Australia, Newzealand, Canada but we don't say them openly). Coming to Vaccines the west really hoarded the Vaccines and threw them in dustbin but didn't give it to global South countries so we had to increase our capacity and provide for 100+ countries which costed us billions of dollars. Europe and west initially didn't approve our vaccines despite them being best in the world but latter when we tried to sanction their Rich businessmen then they approved. We are in G10 and have 2nd highest number of US FDA licence for Pharmaceutical manufacturing. In global influence war sorry to say Eastern Europe is not important for both India and China which is good otherwise your politics would have been more dirty.
💝💗 india much diverse than europe
Basically we are more diverse and different then any country in the world.
amazing
India first responsibility is to take care of its 1.4 Billion population where poverty is major issue. Is west/Europe so naive to understand this where household income is many folds more than Indian household? Why the priority of 1.4 Billion people comes second to west interest? They have looted India for centuries and left us with nothing. We don't need any freebies from west but we need to take care of our own people first to by making commodities available at affordable price. This is the least we can do for our people.
I hear your point!
When Dr. Jaishankar talked about collective Europe it is not in terms of diversity but about mindset which europeans have toward developing countries,least developed countries and African countries, they( collective europe) behaves like it's not big deal and not gonna affect them(europe) so why to worry.
What collective Europe is interested is in criticising developing countries and have done a wonderful job.
I have noticed that before. It is sad and maybe even sadder is that they are really unaware and might even think they are doing good.
When you say Europe is diverse than always thought of India which is much diverse in one country. In 50-100 km , dialect of language change , and in 500 km , language change.
Also, Mr. Jaishankar said about Europe collectively because EU mindset about India, Asia , and rest of world is same and as you said they are bound of EU policies, not their own sovereign policies.
You would be surprised as Slovakia is so small - distances are much closer but within 10kms you can easily have a different dialect. And also there are dialects in Slovakia I have no chance of understanding and we are only 5 million.
@@zuzanareactsAccording to the Census of India of 2001, India has 122 major languages and 1599 other languages. However, figures from other sources vary, primarily due to differences in definition of the terms "language" and "dialect". The 2001 Census recorded 30 languages which were spoken by more than a million native speakers and 122 which were spoken by more than 10,000 people.
How much in Europe???
@@81kvlogsjitendradude just stop arguing with her and just enjoy her videos she has the right to show her viewpoint. 😊
@@zuzanareactsthen you can imagine that India is a country which can contain multiple Europes, in terms of culture, traditions, language, dialect, and facial structure, skin color etc. You name anything you can find here. Weather, landscape, food anything.
That's the reason it is called a sub continent within a country.
@@81kvlogsjitendramajbut 💪
European union is not even half diverse that BHARAT ( India ) is
I think you are right there!🙈
Dr.Jaishankar is not a conventional politician. He was a career diplomat. He was former foreign secretary. Our PM Modi handpicked him to become external affairs minister of India due to his diplomatic skills.
You had an interesting set of points there. However I don't agree with all of those.
1. You said about the diversity of Europe. Good point, but thats actually not the point being discussed. India has fought 5 major wars and many other minor conflicts in the last 75 years. We got collectively ignored by the countries of Europe and the west. Thats why Minister used the word 'collectively'.
2. America has taken lead in trying to push back Russia and is putting so much pressure on India to stop buying Russian oil. The same America was supplying weapons to our enemies during the course of most of the wars we fought. And Russia was supplying us with defensive weapons. In fact we were gonna be attacked by the 7th fleet of America during The 1971 war with Pakistan. At that time it was Russia which deployed its Fleet in the Arabian sea to stop the American fleet. If that attack was successful God knows what would have happened. So we can't blindly trust America.
3. 9/11 terrorist attack got so much coverage in Europe and the west. But only a handful people know about 26/11 terror attack on India. So again everyone ignored us collectively.
4. About the conflict with China what minister said was right world actually doesn't work that way. If every country pursuing India to move away from Russia is actually ready to help us against China then thats a jackpot for us. But in truth no western country currently has the capacity to take on China.
5. I know that Europe has seen world war. But back then India wasn't living in happy times either. We were under colonial rule for more than 100 years which included both the world wars. And now since the war has returned to Europe after so many years, there is so much noise and expectations of global support. No one even took a notice of conflicts happening in other parts of the world. Thats what Minister was saying.
6. About the entrepreneurial and political point of views that you mentioned. We don't mind if our actions send signals that we are supporting Russia because Russia has stood with us when the world was against us and thats why we can never view them as a villain. And from the entrepreneurial perspective, we are the 5th largest economy and emerging as the 3rd we have our own aspirations. To keep growing we require energy. Many countries who sanctioned Russia have moved towards the middle east for their oil supply which has increased the oil prices. Middle east is the major supplier of oil for us so it has put pressure on our economy. To ease that pressure we moved towards Russia and this action is not immoral in our eyes because of all the reasons I have mentioned.
If you have taken the time to go through all my points I really appreciate your patience🙏.
Also I can't blame you for your perspective because the western media doesn't cover other parts of the world.
Have a great day😁
I completely hear you! :) Thank you for sharing!
About the 4th point, only the USA can take head on to china, but USA can't be trusted
Good read
Appreciate buddy 👍
Absolutely right
This man was once ambassador of India to many countries including US and China. An Ex-IFS
The Indian External affairs minister Mr Jaishankar, is not a politician. He is a technocrat
I saw how you spoke about Europe being ravaged by the world wars.... I agree but I would like to add that the colonies suffered for the allies much more than the allies themselves(ex: Bengal famine, troops from colonies, heavy taxation etc.) But other than that... I liked the video!
Thankyou so much
look, we all have perceptions and opinions based on the information that we have gathered through news channels .we should be more open to the new age fact based info . I'm just learning 🙂 and I'll definitely love to explore more
@@zuzanareactsver 3 million indian soldiers fought in ww2, most of them died. And 3-4 million people died in Bengal famine caused by churchill policies.
We love sir Jai Shankar and New India’s approach towards the west. We Indians no more stay silent for western hypocrisy! We will definitely give it back to you if you guys try to insult us! No other Indian minister is as open and transparent as sir Jaishankar ! We love ❤️ him! Welcome and enjoy new india 🎉! Jai Hind 🇮🇳!
I think it's great and you are not even aware that you are speaking for the countries (in the west) that cannot publicly call this out.
@@zuzanareacts if you want to I can mention that 😂
When he's talking about europe collectively being silent about Asian affairs, he has in mind the Indo-Pak and Indo-China conflicts. If in both of them you look at all the facts, there is clearly a right and a wrong side. Still most countries (including eastern europe) try to appear fair to the wrong side. I think serbia has supported india on Kashmir issue, i never heard of any others doing that.
Interesting - thank you for sharing!
Since you mentioned the 2 world wars; I hope you know or will check out how many Indian soldiers died in Europe during these wars. ( It is in millions and not tens or thousands.) With regard to China we have had many disagreements on the border. ( We have approx 3000 KM border with China) However we entered into bilateral agreement as to what is the LAC ( Line of Actual Control) and also that we will not use firearms against the soldiers who are eyeball-to-eyeball along the border. Then on 16-June - 2020 the Chinese army, with no provocation killed 20 Indian soldiers with clubs, sticks, iron rods. (Yes. they did NOT use firearms). We gave our soldiers full military honours and publicly conducted the last rites. While China was ashamed to admit how many soldiers died. That is because Indian soldiers also killed more than 100 Chinese soldiers ( Indian soldiers account) with their bare hands. ( No firearms)
I really appreciate you sharing. This is very insightful and very sad to learn.
Let's together educate other countries what china does👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
One of the worst countries esp the CCP and there is so much propaganda there that Chinese ppl now have been brainwashed so I feel govt and ppl are on same page...
Europe talks about principles and democracy but trades so much with China and keeps mum on human rights issues in China because China serves their purpose...European political leaders and media houses get so much bribes and money from China... China is everywhere in almost all western democracies and influencing them for China's interests...it's better if you recognize this sooner
Talking about varied cultures, each Indian state has different culture, different cuisine, different language/dialects to name a few and there are 28 states in India 🇮🇳
Sister Respect and support from India 🇮🇳.
Bless you! ❤ Means a lot! ❤
She already know majority of viewer's are from India only
Welcome to India❤❤❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏
thank you!!!❤🙏❤
🤦why you people comment like this .she isn't going to come 😂
@@human8454it's lesson bro
Some of the crisis in Asia the west overlooked: Tibetan invasion of China, Bangladesh massacre by Pakistan, 4 Indo-Pakistan wars, Indo-Chinese war in 1962, Taliban take over Afghanistan.
The west never took part or chose sides simply reported what was happening and gave their opinion. Although in the case of Taliban they did a little, by sanctioning them, but others no steps were taken.
So India/most of Asia is doing the same in Russia-Ukraine war.
I see
fascinating to hear from people's perspective not anywhere connected to India about Indian politics and politicians. India in the last 10 years have been trying to do a things right! you have a bunch of politicians who are dedicated to do good to the nation than good to themselves. Hope this carries on for a long time! I hope to see you and your channel grow immensely :) best wishes!
Jaishankar is actually not a career politician. he is actually a diplomat throughout his entire career. He recently joined politics.
Yep so in my eyes he is both if that makes sense.
@@zuzanareacts yeah, it's totally fine. You are entitled to express your opinion. No problem. I m also a fan of Jai. Nice to see that you are also a fan. Thank you for your content.. 🙏👍
If you think that Europe cannot be considered "collectively" based on diversity of cultures, then you should be reminded that India offers most diversity in terms of cultures (& many more parameters) as a one country. But Dr. Jaishankar was referring to collective Europe in terms of European Union, your collective trade and economic policies. Not related to any cultural thing.
Got it. Thank you. I don't think a person in Europe thinks that they are European, I don't know if that makes sense, first and foremost it is your country - so I'd say I'm Slovak. I would never go describing myself as European. I'd say I'm from Slovakia and if they probed more - I'd say central Europe. I don't believe there is such a thing as European identity. Everyone identifies with their country and we live on the same continent. Not sure I'm making sense. This is not the US - where everyone has the same constitution and is bound by the same principles - nowhere close.
@@zuzanareacts You're right when you're describing your identity, I am sure you would identify with your nation and not a continent, but at the same time the policies of the European countries are rarely sovereign, they are influenced by all but some certain world power because you have treaties in place with those countries. Thus to outsiders, your foreign policy is only different when it comes to bilateral trade, otherwise EU dictates the other policies in major forums.
Also interestingly, people in Europe on an average really dont have any idea about things that are happening in Asia or Middle East etc, the same can be said for the masses in USA but it's not identical here, a big portion of youth here is into geo-politics, history and talks and discussion happen over the platforms for the same. It's interesting because the popularity of Dr. Jai Shankar is a clear indication of our nations collective awareness of geo-politics, it mainly represents the youth.
Since we have a history of inflicted conflicts with China and Pakistan, general knowledge has always been the talk of the town.
It is good to learn about the diverse nature of political understandings of Europe. But when we, the Indians or the global south mention about Europe, we mention as the European Union's stand on issues as a whole. It was heartening to see that france taking a different stand on a certain Nato issue. Independent thoughts and ideas are to be celebrated.
I think there is a lot of disagreements in the EU - e.g. Hungary or Poland. I'm not even too sure if the whole EU project is working. It would be the best if it was left at free trade and movement.
@@zuzanareacts that will be good for Europe and specifically the eastern European nations.
276th subscriber ❤ from India 🙏
thank you!! ❤
India have population is 1.5 billion population 22 official language, 1500 unofficial language, 15000 dialect. WE have all seasons and all geographical templates.
love
That's the problem. You are calling out the trauma of world war on Europe and ignoring the trauma of other global south countries that's the direct result of Europe's colonialism. For example in India the British did such scathing acts that has their impact resonates even today in the heart of common people of India.
Slovakia is not an 'imperialistic' country never was - quite the contrary but I hear your point.
India like becoming " partners " not " ally " that's j shankar doctrine . Their's a difference btw them two
got it - thank you!
Ignorance and arrogance still can't able to ignore powerful interview of Jaishankar
he is speaking the truth and trust me speaks what actual Europeans think but cannot voice out loud.
See Zuzana this is the issue in Europe, like you pointed out. I don't have idea about India - China conflict that happened. This is what he is saying. Coming to an earlier point, he was not pointing out the cultural similarity or there off. And world politics, I am sorry, Zuzana Europe or the west is not concerned of the Asian conflicts. China comes up because it's a threat to the US. You need to investigate US and Europe's involvement in Pakistan during the Indo-Pak war. The US sided with Military dictatorship of Pakistan. The US sent nuclear bombs to attack India which is the world's largest democracy.
Exactly
I think you are very likely right. I was never really interested in politics simply because I just wanted to focus on positive things in life. Hence, not too sure how European Union perceives Asia but I never if I think back remember Europe really talking and indeed being concerned with Asia much - seem too far away. But then again, I might be wrong since I didn't really follow. I'm just sharing my perception.
@@zuzanareacts I understand. I'm just sharing my opinion and information. You are right, politics is not everyone's cup of tea. A lot of us, in India do discuss politics especially geo-politics. Please continue spreading positivity.
Nowadays,he is eating Europe in his routine lunch..😂
Lol - i'm here for it - at least someone is calling things out and I don't see Europe reacting to this either interestingly ...
@@zuzanareacts eventually they were now....did u think France is dull that they chooses china ... Did u think Germany is in false flag operation that they gave submarine tech to India... Did u think Finland is so obsessed with Sweden and Greenland that they don't care what was happening on the border of Sweden against Russia.... connect the dots...🌝💀
Whole time in this video, before the question ends, you anticipate and anticipate well (just by you facial expressions, i could guess) what's coming as an answer!
Intelligent and brilliant!
3:03 I beg to differ here... In Slovakia's case it is difficult to implement a foreign policy that is completely based on the economic interests of the country... This is of course because it chose to join an economic alliance... But India doesn't think in terms of alliances it thinks in terms of long term economic benefits and interests... At the end of the day a country will make judgements based on what it perceives as beneficial not to further a political agenda... An example of this is the West buying cheap Chinese products despite knowing the human rights abuses it has done on the Uighurs and other non Han ethnic groups...
fair enough
Yes, I agree Europe is always diversified. If one sees Briton as member of EU, it done the brexit.
Poland after listening to US, couped in damaging the Russian gas pipeline against EU concern and for the control of Germany - ofcourse England knows it.
These r some recent examples of Europe politics.
not too sure I fully understand your point but European countries don't really see each other eye to eye
@@zuzanareacts then what for EU?
India is in heart of every Indian and P.M. Modi is pride of India 🇮🇳💪🇮🇳🇮🇳 and Russia 🇷🇺🇷🇺 is Friend of India 🇮🇳🇮🇳 , because Russia stood by with India when nobody else stood with India , when India went to war like 1971 war for Independence of Bangladesh , and during time of crisis , it was Russia that stood for India , and west , europe and america combined tried to attack India , and Russians stood by the side of India , while there was impending War with Europe and US , end of the story
thank you for sharing!
Sententia, such a shameless liar and you are a slave among all bjp slaves 😂😂😂 modi is the worst burden of India that should be thrown away out of our (excluding you) home land and he is the worst criminal of India ,do you know anything regarding Manipur issue ah, and what the hell he is doing, i Mean he is doing nothing and just simply roaming in the house ,that's all ,so without knowing anything, just don't blabber, ok......
6:44 When S.Jaishankar said that Europe was silent when a lot of things happened in Asia. He also meant about the Gulf war, Syrian War, Afghanistan and etc., conflicts that occurred in Asia when Europe as a whole was silent about and continued to support the US.
You guys (Europe) may be culturally vast and different, but your (European) opinions weren't as vast and different when the US invasion was taking place. It may be wrong to put the whole of Europe into the same bracket, but in this scenario, it totally fits the case.
Mind you, Middle East and Gulf is Asia too.
thank you!
When Dr. J said "taking Europe collectively", he did mean it politically and not culturally. If you guys were so diverse politically, you wouldn't have had "European Union" in the first place.
that's the problem we are very diverse politically and not too sure how long the EU project will last. It is great for free trade and movement but culturally we are quite different = every country different unique culture and nature - so impossible to unite. It's not like we have a common constitution like the US does - we are not bound by the same principles. I don't think this 'project' will last.
@@zuzanareacts Thanks for the insight. Really appreciate.
Best of luck for ur TH-cam journey ...lot of ❤ from India
Thank you for your kind words! Much appreciated ❤
Zuzana, you seem to be a rational person, and it's not your fault that you don't know about the Indo-China conflict. This is what Dr. Jai Shankar is mentioning that most Europeans don't know about the various conflicts happening in Asian countries. The reason is very simple. Since such conflicts are not affecting the Western world and its people, therefore people don't know/take an interest in the things happening in Asian countries. Let me give a glimpse of the INDO-CHINA Conflict. In 1962 China stealthily inflicted a full-fledged war against India and illegally captured a sizable part of India and included it in its territory. The west remained silent. In 1967 again China tried to inflict wounds on India but the West remained silent. In 2020 despite, the whole world facing the COVID pandemic, China again encroached into our border areas in GALWAN Heights. For the last 3 years, despite facing the aftermath of COVID, our 1,00,000 Army personnel with arms and ammunition are face to face with CHINA, to contain them from grabbing our land in the high peak mountain ranges. Even now, the West is silent and we are fighting our own battle and we are confident in handling the nefarious designs of China at our own level. PAKISTAN has waged 4 wars against India in the last 75 years and they lost all 4 wars. Now they keep sending terrorists to India to destabilize our country. Pakistan Army, after losing all wars now following the strategy of bleeding India by thousand cuts. West has chosen to be silent on the issue of Pakistan spreading terrorism and indulging in a constant war with India. I hope to a certain extent, you would have understood the background of Dr. Jai Shankar's statement.
I really appreciate you sharing this. And you are right we have no idea. Right now all that you hear in news is Russian disinfo - I don't really watch news - that's another layer but last couple of years it has started to be harder to avoid - I dip in and out
Dr s jaishankar is not politician...he is a diplomat and cracked UPSC , india's toughest civil services exam.
Very interesting - I had no idea about the toughest civil service exam! She is super smart that's very clear!
@@zuzanareacts Upsc Is not only India's toughest exam but it's world's second toughest exam after Chinese exam
@@zuzanareacts world 2nde toughest Exam dear
Thanks for reacting this video 🤗💖
My pleasure!!
5:20
India is so much more diverse than the entire europe, so I don't see why people think europe can't be referred collectively if european union takes a decision all of its member are responsible for it.
It is because we don't see ourselves that way. For me I'm Slovak first and foremost - I'm very culturally far from the UK or France - in fact we don't know much about them to be fair. We don't really have same believes as a continent pr abided by the same constitution like the US - there is a common knowledge or value share that doesn't exist in Europe. The only thing that's European is the fact we live on the same continent but we are all very different. Hence why the EU project is not working out and countries want out and that's the reason why the UK is out.
Refreshing to see some unique and genuine thoughts
I really appreciate your comment!❤
Europe is very diverse.. Habibi come to India. Language, dialects, culture, architecture, food, everything changes every 100 kms
so I hear! :)
Wow yesterday I subscribed i am 63rd subscriber but today it's more than 260 congratulations 👏🎉
Thank you so much for subscribing I very much appreciate it ❤
@@zuzanareacts when you make good content people will always support keep going 👍
There are several things I would point out but just to start with, around 6:50 , your rationalization for disagreement is that Europe is very different. But you're missing the point, Europe still collectively had the same response to issues in Asia.
That's the context of the conversation, not that all of europe always acts as a collective block in decision making
ok - thank you!
You are an awesome, loved your content!
Thank you so much!
New Subscriber from Kerala, India 🥳🤩😉
Wellcome and thank you for subscribing!! ❤
Speak:: Har Har S.JAYSHANKAR ❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉
I guess The phrase the Europe problem are world problems and word problem are not Europe problem comes from the the context of US sudden withdrawal from Afghanistan and the Taliban took over of Afghanistan and there is a video Jaishankar saying that Europe at that time asked to india have more trade with Afghanistan during Taliban took over and now Europe is asking india to sanction Russia (the video your watching, timeline)
that's very insightful. Thank you for shraing. There is undoubtedly a lot of hypocrisy in my end of the world. People see it but the 'unpopular opinions' are not encouraged if you know what I mean. Seems India is way more level-headed.
I don't believe that he meant there are no cultural differences, or political views in different countries in Europe. He was merely saying the European nation's foreign policies tend to be inline to the top 4-5 countries in Europe. I don't want to name them. Everyone knows what those countries are. He was not hinting that these countries will not have cultural differences, different languages and even that internal politics are same. It's not and neither was he hinting that.
The other thing you said was that, one has to pick sides or have a strong identity with certain groups that have formed. The biggest problem with that is, India is not in the same boat as let's say Europe. If the Indian economy collapses, no European country will come to it's aid. But on the other hand, let's say a European country like the 2009 crisis, many countries were saved because they were part of Europe. So it's very straightforward for you guys. That is why you feel there are only two or three sides. But for India, it is not like that. America has been funding, aiding Pakistan since long, while Russia and India have a long standing military relationship. So when nobody gave weapons to India, Russia did. Similarly, India is Israel's close ally, but it cannot openly support it. The reason is that, then Pakistan can also say it's illegal occupation of Kashmir is legal as is Isarels over Palestine. Again India cannot pick sides. It will be a political suicide. India's conflict with China-India knows no European country will come to it's aid. The reason most of the economies of major European countries are tied closely with China. Most European economies will collapse if china really wants it. So India knows there was never any help and there will be none in case of the India- China war. So no, it doesn't matter if most of the European countries have different cultures, different view points, even different political agendas. None of them will go against the mutual consensus and act on their own. So in the end, they will protect their personal interests, but India cannot. By the way, i was in Sweden for quite sometime and toured major countries in Europe. I agree, they have different attitudes, they speak differently and so on, but that doesn't mean they will act individually in making big political decisions. Not saying they will not have different local political or even global decisions which do not directly hurt the top countries in Europe.
I really appreciate your insight. This is truly interesting. I feel like we don't get any of what's happening over in your part of the world unless you proactively look into that. I think you are right he is talking about the decisions of the European Union which most countries anyways disagree with ... haha. However, all of this is super interesting to learn about. Do you think that India will become "next China" and will overtake it? (As this is what it seems to me watching from afar. Would love to hear your thoughts.
you have replied what I was thinking 👍
Wow, you are too good with your writing perfectly... I was thinking to the same reply but i didn't know from where to start and how should I write so that it get conveyed properly...
You should start writing classes 😂😂
@@zuzanareactsyep.. EU..lols. But it doesn't matter who accepts it or not. When it comes to foreign policies most of them sing the same song. Mostly the song that America wants them to sing. I have hardly seen any of them stand out in the crowd, let's say in major UN decisions.
Anyways, coming to China, the USA is worried that China will take over. So the next move I think will come from China. The USA knows that India is the next best option for it as it follows democracy. China and India accommodate for one third of the world's marketplace. Reading, watching a lot about these two economies, I don't feel it's a matter of years, but decades for India to reach the top position in regards to economy or gdp/ppp.. before understanding if India can take China over quickly, we have to understand how did China grow so fast.
I know China is facing many problems of its own. Like big realtor companies collapsing, Banks collapsing. Its strict policies against un regulated banking sectors have created greater problems. And many other problems.
But it still leads the manufacturing industry in a big way. It did a lot of reforms, attracted FDI's, and promoted manufacturing industries in 1978. Probably, the best time they could pick. Because within decades, the IT revolution took place and now they have a vast array of products to manufacture. That is not the only thing, China created trained workers or robots who worked for hours, slept less, with lower income. This reduced the company's manufacturing cost by a lot. They almost created robots. But American companies saw this as an opportunity to lower their cost and also evade the strict manufacturing laws in America. Let's say like the pollution emitted by the companies and many such factors. Remember, China is a communist nation. So they are like gods. No one can question them. But that's not the scene in India. What China did in the last 70's or 80's, India cannot do it. Many NGO's will come after the government, there will be protests done by the opposition even if it's for something good. Forgot about ruining the environment or even making ppl machines. So India will never get that sharp rise as China did. So the manufacturing cost in India will never be less than let's say in China. So Indian manufacturing companies cannot compete in price with a Chinese company. So why will Apple and other big countries come to India. Well the answer is China started IP infringements. Meaning, they used let's say Samsung's technology and created an exact duplicate of it. Infact, the phone i have OPPO, is exactly the copy of my favorite phone samsung S and note series. It costs one fourth of what Samsung's S series will cost. I know many ppl will get angry for me using Chinese products. Yep, here there is a wave to boycott Chinese cheap products. But really financially it makes no sense to buy a phone 4-5 times costlier and which has better configurations and looks/feels exactly the same.
So no it will take time. Although, American companies are now realising that for cheaper manufacturing costs, they are losing much more customers and sales.
Just a note, it's different here, not like Sweden, Where everyone is brand conscious and wants an iPhone. Here ppl look at the configuration and what it offers rather than the brand. That's why the Chinese are selling these to us..lols 😂🤣 although, lately it has been changing with genz kids as they are watching TH-cam influencers having iphones and creating a brand within the the community. Like my niece wants an iPhone or they will create havoc in their parents' life. Hope you will read till the end. Took a lot of typing. Please forgive the spelling mistakes as i am typing it with my long fingers on a smaller clipboard.
@@AkashSingh-nf5eylols i was thinking of starting a TH-cam channel on this. But I have a full time job so cannot concentrate. I like writing so it's easier to comment than making a TH-cam video I guess.
In India we are not transactional. We always stand by our friends. If a nation wants to engage with India, stay with us for the long run.
this is very interesting. I guess I look at it with the sceptical 'hat' of the west and what I feel like some people might be thinking. It's great that India is not like that - a real example
Good analysis Sister .. Hope your channel grow faster ..👌👌👍👍
Thank you so much 🙂 - it means a lot!
Loved that u reacted it, culturally Europe may differ internally, politically are of same mindsets that is own interest,....., So now other LDC are also following your path,😂
I would argue that politically we are forced to follow the western countries but yes I'm sure it's should generally follow the interest's of the EU but actually that does not mean every country agrees in the EU with this.
@@zuzanareacts did u ever noticed why Europe is so divided into many small and tiny countries comparatively to rest of the continents.. because of the delusion superiority complex within themselves, so much unrest Between two different beliefs, ..so much so that it broke apart, and interestingly from the past all the world wide colonization was done by European countries...
So from the past onwards Europe has a mindsets of taking things from others but not giving..
Some interesting Fact u should know about India:
Way before ibrahim religion came into existence, there was hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism Jainism, ( all are sanatan dharma, Sanatan dharma teaches all the problems are created from within and could be cured from within, that means looking inward, through meditation, yoga, mantras, bhakti/prayers, humanitarian works, non violance, truthfulness..it says one is free to choose any path they wanted to because same goal may have several paths to achieve that goal, no force, afterall purpose of religion should be upliftment of spiritual growth not of destruction.) etc so many more which got extinct over lapse of time.....all this way of living and beliefs were coexisting peacefully , yes there was war though, but war for territory not on the basis of religion or superiority complex....kings and queens were adopting different way of living, example the great king Ashoka , after winning a war and watching so much violence and blood he gave up his kingdom and followed the path of Buddhism...
He might be the only king in the world to gave up his kingdom after winning a war.
..I'm saying this because here in Asia,, first alian religion which was introduced to us was ISLAM, .... They invaded, not only for wealth and territory but they want to make India a islamic country but with forceful conversation and those who didn't accepted got killed....and u already know about what Britisher did to India, ...
India is the Most invaded country in the world, yet never invaded other and still progressing and optimistic about her future...
I'm a tribal from northeast region of india, arunachal pradesh, got my education from a Hindu school were we learn that Evey religion is equal, Hindu, Christian, Islam etc.. we even performed drama and songs on unity... I thought every countries teaches like that but later in my adulthood I got to know that there are many countries who give religion or race at first priority. My way or highway is no religious at all, forget about spiritual.....
I hope world can learn lot more things from India 🇮🇳 .
@@natyapashyatayangvlog6642 I really appreciate your comment. The west is definitely more ego driven and we definitely need more of what India has to offer here.
we do help irrespective of thinking of getting that same from other side . that he means by the statement ..trade in terms of helping each other....its our job to help others without thinking politically and rather be on humanity side ..
it is very interesting - as my being brought up here working for UK businesses - I'm rather very cynical as I know how 'these' people think - hence my comment. However, it's very admirable if India perceives things differently!
@@zuzanareacts yahh our foreign policy is always to help mid eco countries rather than business oriented +also seeing well being of our people and in context of russia we not support russia its just cheap crude and stuff and russia helped in our crisis time more than any other countries soo we dont stand with them but we at same time dont crticize them too ... tht our policy of non alignment since decade to be in between and maintain good relation with all
No one's talking about collective EU culturally...we are talking about energy trade where collectively EU has a collective single front!!
got it- thank you!
10:00 you still have that european mindset, maybe because of the 2 major wars. That is why you make allies and NATO is the result of that.
We, India on the other hand are non-aligned and so are independent. Else, China, India due to it's closeness to Russia might team up. That is a dangerous proposition. The non-aligned countries want UN to function effectively to punish the perpetrators.
interesting - what do you view as European mindset and honestly, I don't get offended - just keen to learn. Indeed NATO is a result of that. We are super small country and there are many small countries in Europe which I think makes more sense to team up rather than have each other own militaries.
this is my dear that's why you listening otherwise 70 years India has the same terms but nobody listens
very sad, huh?
That guy @4:48 is a Lithuanian journalist. Being from Baltika, you would have to expect a lot of anti-Russia bile coming from him. Instead of worrying about India, he should worry about his own country. If Russia invades Lithuania, nobody will come to help, despite it being a NATO member, just like nobody helped Portugal during the India-Portugal War of 1961, despite Portugal being a NATO member. NATO membership only ensures a captive market for US weapons manufacturers. All the talk about collective security is nonsense.
I agree with you on this.
By asking the about incident between india and China you have proved Jaishankar's statement indirectly saying that Europeans doesn't know or care about what's happening in world,but if anything happens in Europe they poke others in every possible way
I'm not saying he is wrong
@@zuzanareacts you means not particularly you but I'm talking about majority of European also don't know what happened between india and China or you can say what's happening in world outside Europe
1:35 He's not a politician , he's a technocrat.
thank you for sharing
Indian and China has its dispute border issue with each other, but also having dispute with 14 countries by its neighborhood. So India is capable to Manage China as friend or as enemy ❤❤
I see so a frenemy 🙈
Jai Shankar is now the external affairs minister, but he previously served as a diplomat.
That's why I believe he could stand his ground and be convincing.
Atleast from our side he's convincing, i wouldn't know how the European union took it
he is - and. I think they have nothing to counter it with
@@zuzanareacts while logically it might seem like it, i wouldn't be so sure because politicians always find something to complain about
When talked about European Union, thats what he referred to politicians only, those people who has say in affairs and policies.
good - as ordinary people barely agree with the EU politicians
You should watch Jaishankar interview with the Austrian journalist.
I actually think I might have watched it but haven't done a reaction on this one. I shall. I did one of a German Ambassador that I will post soon.
You again misinterpreted his point of conflicts, because he said first line , that we are capable of dealing with China, didn't need support from EU, if required then we will purchase Ammunition from EU and USA , India will not beg for anything.
Even , he said our conflicts are predated and EU didn't support and recognise those conflicts earlier. But , now, after Ukraine war , they are asking to support EU 😂
I hear you!
Also, don't think I said things in any arrogance, I just wanted to make you understand in some points. By the way , good initiative. 🙏
Nice analysis sister....love from 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Thank you so much ❤
God of foreign affairs❤
10:08 Indian diplomacy and politics is based on welfare of people (from people, for people) while the west seems to be focusing on how to make your own country rich by exploiting other nations. In the whole history of humankind India has never attacked another country or their sovereignty in any way whatsoever. So in my opinion his opinion of how politics and diplomacy works is very different from what a average diplomat from US or Europe thinks like.
fair enough!
You are beautiful and intelligent 🤓
awww - bless your soul! You are very kind ❤
First indo-china war happened in 1962, when china attacked on North and north-east Frontier of India. At that time India was not prepared for mountain war. Indian prime minister asked for military equipments from USA and Britain but they refused. USSR helped India with military supply but officially remained neutral. Europe remained silent. China captured Indian land equal to area of Switzerland.
Interesting - this is the time of Communism actually in my part of the word.
I have nothing against Europe, but Europe does have to grow out of it's mindset that "Europe's problems are the world's problems and the world's problems are not Europe's problems ". I think this should be the slogan for the non European nations who are being lectured by any European nation
I don't even think Europe likes to be lectured by Europe :D. There are tensions in the EU itself
Hi Zuzana, I personally admire the analysis that you have done here. However, I would like to point out one point here: you said, Solovakia (or eastern Europe in general) is culturally and politically different in a big way from western Europe.....but yet you are a member of the EU. Why there is no separate Union for eastern European countries?
Slovakia as a central European country is part of the EU as it has economical benefits - free trade and free movement. However, many people don't agree with the EU politics and the fact we are being dictated by unelected representatives.
@@zuzanareacts A small Nation like austria is questioning india because it has political strength from European Union
You may have difference in opinions and culture but you are the part of European Union
European Union has parliament and commission that deals on my governing matters
This is one of the best reaction channel i have ever watched.
I really do appreciate it! Thank you for the support ❤
6:22 he's talking about European democracy preachers who collectively ignored state sponsored Terrorism in Asia, Wars In Asia, Invasion & Killings in Middle east & africa!
EU was silent in Afghanistan sudan yaman war that's why he said Europe problems are worlds problem and world problems are not European problem
understood - thank you for sharing!
No, i'm disagree with u that take a one side......there are many countries in the world, small or big who dont want to indulge in the Ukraine - Russian war cuz if their people won't get basic necessities,price getting high or any kind of trouble then, its only your own country's govt and people will handle this challenge, no one help u in such crisis specially for low income countries like south American, African or Asian countries..... Why unnecessarily support any axis of the war... Just be neutral and care about your own people thatswhy india choose not to take side of any one...... Basically European nation are that much small that they cant take any decision without foreign pressure... And we also understand that its compulsion on many small country like yours who cant refuse to take any side, they have to take one side that is American side against Russia... Its only option for u but in case of india.... Why we should care about war.... We are 1.4 bn people... Govt have to take care everyone and do wise decisions for the betterment of our own people...
I agree bhai
You are not wrong. I think India is taking a geo-political pressure. I think a reality is that you are only as powerful (a country) as a country or institution that funds you. Slovakia is definitely funded by the US and our government is clearly pro US. However, people are divided from what I observe here. Austria has taken a very neutral position which some people in Slovakia wish we did as well but we are not economically anywhere close to where Austria is so cannot 'afford" if you like.
India 🇮🇳 and Russia🇷🇺 freinds
Love to hear your sweet voice
Dr. Jaishankar simply wants to tell is that age of allaince is over and this is the age of partnership... India consider herself as partner and not an ally to any country
love it
I might sound bad but by Europe means UK, France ,Germany and to some extent Italy ..No offence other part of Europe only matters in EU ..As a singular country none of them hold value(world affairs). About second thing that you disagreed where you said one conflict should help in other it was a ironical statement referring to that Well they should then support against the China and Pakistan then (not that we are asking like the West)..And also Politics might be what you said but World affairs is turf of strong countries where Politics work the way the strong countries want ..
no it's ok. It's just when people comment on me as European I believe they are really frustrated with countries that have basically nothing to do with my region so does not feel great.
Thanks to technology that there is an opportunity to know the perspective of India in Indian terms, in Indian lens and India's intrests by the outsider's.
Anyways i got this opportunity to be the 140th member of your channel and I would say "may these numbers grow and you'll find a full-time intrest to look for..... cuz you are interacting with the world's largest country in terms of numbers, world's largest democracy in terms of election's, world's youngest population in terms of age.
✌️ Greetings from Bengaluru
Jaihind 🇮🇳
OMG, I LOVE your note. Honestly, I wish this became my full time job - I genuinely love to learn more about India - already learnt so much and love to interact with people - so far it has been an incredible experience and your support means a lot! ❤🙏
No she is interacting with
1. World's biggest population
2. 5th biggest economy ( soon to be 3 in 2027)
3, 3rd biggest IT exporter
4. 4th biggest good exporter
5, 4th most powerful military
6. Fastest growing economy in the world at the rate of 7.2 per
7. 2nd biggest farmasiutical exporter
8. Country with maximum online transactions of about 1 tri dollars in 2022.
9. 7th biggest land area
10. 3rd biggest automobile exporter
@@bhaviksharma1856 🤯🔥🔥🔥🔥
He is not just politician, he was diplomat for 40+ year
Very educational channel❤
8:25
Well I do think WW1 & WW2 were brutal for europe.
But I'll stand here with Dr Jaishankar as we were dragged in this wars forcefully. All the men who were physically capable of fighting were forcefully sent to europe to fight a war for britain and all the crops were shipped to britain as well resulting in a famine killing millions of innocent women and children. In fact there were more crops of bengal in britain than they were in bengal itself. I mean all this should be already known to you since you are interested in politics, since they never tought all this to avg public. Plus I had rather not mention the inhumane ways which were used by britishers, dutch , France etc to exploit all the resources. In India we are tought "athithi devo bhava" (Guests should be treated as gods), Indians were very respectful.
The kings never used to kill any other king who was unarmed and the war was strictly paused at night by both parties. Now we are forced to adapt the way of others. So it actually is another ex which shows europe made their own problems, the world's problem. My classmate's great grandfather died fighting in WW2 in europe, not even for their own nation.
And still people think that europe has seen the worst of them all, no one talks about how japan was bombed to shreds by USA and how Obama got noble peace award for killing hundreds of thousands of innocents in islamic countries (I do agree that they wanted to wipe terrorism out, but killing innocents is like chopping of the entire farm for removing some weeds).
Fun Fact: Obama killed more people than Osama bin Laden in just 8 yrs of his presidency, It definetly helped USA but all those civillians were the collateral. Also Obama recently raised his concern for minorities of India, So the thing is our current president is from a tribe, previous one was Hindu before him was a Muslim. I don't see why there are no good candidates for president other than christians in USA, come on our constitution is very rigid and treats all people equally. So pls don't raise unnecessary concerns by watching any random street fight online.
The point is if you want to fight wars pls do, but don't exploit other countries in between. Also eu and usa sold weapons to a country which fed terrorists to make money and at that time when India was surrounded from all side Russia provided necessary aid to India.
I really appreciate you sharing. And I hear what you are saying. Slovaks (older ones) not really in favour on the USA and are aware of these facts but we don't speak about it. We were taught by communism to shut up or we end up in jail. sad but true
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂◀️WHY IS INDIA GREAT 2 | भारत महान क्यों 2 Shourya Motion Pictures | Sourabh
I will have a look
You must go with the full interview 🙏
... that's a bit lengthy but thankyou for the suggestion 🙂
I actually like, you are putting your own opinion yet watching the video with open mind.
We also have very different opinion in our parliament too, honestly no country or continent claim to be as diverse as India 🙂
ok