She was the only trained dancer and she is there in the vocal mix for sure on every track. If you watch their audition, Posh was the one who knew all the steps, knew the harmonies and performed well.
@@brandonaldaymachuse6669 she wasn't the only dancer trained, Mel C and Mel B were dancers before the spice girls, and also Emma was a trained dancer, the only who wasn't trained as a dancer is Geri....
They always give the best group harmonies. They were not the best in vocal abilities, but they complement each others so well, and that's what makes them exceptional ❤️
@@andyr8577 I'm not hating. You're just hyping up Victoria for no reason. Lmao. She's never a good singer. If u think she's a standout vocalist, your standards must be low 😂
POSH!! Yay !!! Omg I’ve been waiting to hear her go a Cappella 😍 yas queen 🎉 beautiful voice you’re my idol still I love u !! #watchedSpiceWorl26 times at the cinema
Each of the Spice Girls has their own unique tone. All of them can sing very well. I like it when their singing voice is just like their speaking voice (can be recognized instantly whose voice is it). Love this acapella! They can have an acapella album singing other artists' songs.
... true pieces of pop history, music, beauty, fun, and somehow innocence... in short, utter gems. The five creatures carved their special place in the hearts of millions kids and teens worldwide, putting up a phenomenon that - for many a different and valid reasons - NEVER will be duplicated. Not tomorrow, nor in one thousand years. In a certain sense, girls, you came from another galaxy... love and respect forever, from Italy.
La gente creía que Victoria no cantaba, sólo porque no hacía tantos solos.. . Pero su trabajo era full haciendo las voces de fondo. Ella tiene una voz que es la mezcla de todas las demás. En el video a veces se aprecia que las otras estan acapella un poco fuera de tono en las armonías y ella es la única que nunca lo estuvo.
Mel B and Victoria's lower registers were used... Geri doesn't quite have the range to go either way, she can't go as low as Victoria, let alone Mel B and she can't get to Emma or Mel C's vocal highs. Actually, she can't get to Victoria's vocal highs either as the nixed Victoria's part from Holler rather than have Geri sing it. And the reason Victoria took over Geri's verse in 2 Become 1 was partly because she didn't get a verse in Wannabe and partly because Victoria could hit the higher notes easier (it apparently took a while for Geri to nail it in the studio and they didn't have time to go through that again).
JaiProdz I think it’s like the same with Victoria poor song choices for their vocal abilities when they were solo artists so it knocked their confidence
She struggled to keep up vocally. I don’t think Victoria and Geri had the same issues. Geri wasn’t as gifted vocally as the rest and she worked super hard to keep up so and she knew that. Victoria was actually really decent at the beginning and throughout the Spice Girls, her confidence shrunk more and more and her vocals suffered because of it.
@@tandyandy8819 very true and thanks for replying because I really love talking and discussing the girls. I think that Geri definitely did improve and you can hear it on her reunion tour with the girls in the late 2000s, but on that tour I don't think Victoria really sang Live at all. It's sad that they kind of switch personalities and then by the time 2019 came around Geri wasn't singing at all either on the reunion tour
@@JaiProdz agreed! They both had confidence issues just for very different reasons. I mostly hate it for Victoria since she had a, in my opinion, rich and unique tone and voice. Either way, I hope we get to see the five of them together again soon with both Geri and Victoria singing live with all of the confidence in the world. They may not be the best, but they’re amazing performers and that’s what it’s all about.
... it depends wich the respective clip is... aside of the very last one (May 2019), all the other clips are taken between October 1994 and December 1999. Anyway at 7:00, she's three months short of 19.
Creo que tiene un tono muy bonito y que aporta una parte importante al grupo en toda su variedad. Está claro que ella no es Mariah Carey pero canta con un tono lindo.
That's fine. All of them had very different vocal takes. Geri was at her best a lounge singer. Mel C was the pop diva. Emma was the retro-60s sweetness, Mel B was the warmer and grittier urban vibe, Victoria gave us musical theater chorus girl. Vic's audition song was Mein Herr.
Not ONE of these girls can sing or dance!!! AT ALL!! They had ONE HIT SONG with the help of AUTOTUNE!!! This video clearly confirms that they are NOT artists!! Why have we never,ever heard one of them sing solo??? They took a lot of money from people for tickets to their ‘concerts”. I have been asking fans if they have ever gone to their concerts twice, and I found about 15 people that have. Most concert goers just go to see their costumes, cleavage, and legs…NOT their music. Beckham is not a pretty lady and cannot sing on pitch. There is NO VIBRATO in any of their voices that I can hear. Their harmony is just all of them singing over eachother and it’s just chaos. I don’t care for the group at all. These are just my opinions.
Not ONE of these girls can sing or dance!!! AT ALL!! They had ONE HIT SONG with the help of AUTOTUNE!!! This video clearly confirms that they are NOT artists!! Why have we never,ever heard one of them sing solo??? Thetook a lot of money from people for tickets to their ‘concerts”. I did a little poll and of my own and I have never
Actually Victoria provided a lot of essential lower harmonies, along with some of the higher parts. And if I'm being honest she's a better singer than Geri. She's classically trained and has a good range. Just because she wasn't getting solos doesn't mean she wasn't important
Love Victoria's singing voice. Her tone is so soft & mellow. A very good Alto. Makes the harmonies harmonise even better. Love. ❤
Victoria's voice ❤️❤️
Here we may realize how good Victoria could sing, specially in Do you think about me? :)
Man, they all got to her head with the "she's the one who can't sing" stuff. You can watch her confidence in her singing go down year by year
@@andreid.8568 sad but true
She was the only trained dancer and she is there in the vocal mix for sure on every track. If you watch their audition, Posh was the one who knew all the steps, knew the harmonies and performed well.
@@brandonaldaymachuse6669 she wasn't the only dancer trained, Mel C and Mel B were dancers before the spice girls, and also Emma was a trained dancer, the only who wasn't trained as a dancer is Geri....
@@brandonaldaymachuse6669 I never understand why people will just tell a straight lie as if its the truth 🤣😂😭
And that's exactly what you did
They always give the best group harmonies. They were not the best in vocal abilities, but they complement each others so well, and that's what makes them exceptional ❤️
Give this to the honest vocal coach. Just love this .
Agreed! She’s awesome
@@gustavoguinez4026 Yes please!!!
Georgina ir gr8!!!
These five beautiful spices changed the world
I love Mel B's voice so calm
Lol, Geri's rap.. is such unique. Geri and Mel b do their own rap lyrics.. and they give so much fun every show. Spice Girls are the best!
8:42 shows how Victoria's vocals were so important to their harmonies. Her voice stood out the most in that entire clip, even over Mel C's.
She just got louder for a few secs and u thought she stood out from the rest...delusional hahaha
@@musicislife.2602 so you’re telling me her voice didn’t stand out there?
@@andyr8577 NOT AT ALL. She didn't standout.
@@musicislife.2602 but she did. And still does. Don’t hate so much lol, it’s not that serious, friend.
@@andyr8577 I'm not hating. You're just hyping up Victoria for no reason. Lmao. She's never a good singer. If u think she's a standout vocalist, your standards must be low 😂
Mel C has such a distinctive tone
They can sing! 😭 No better than your favorite but that's fine, I'll take this. Yes, all five of them. Love their beautiful harmonies.
2:17 I didn't even notice Geri hit the wrong note until every head swiveled to her with Mel C being like "wtf" 😂
Emma eyerolled a bit later 😂
They all looked 😂
they still sounded great to me.
3:15 Do You Think About Me - love it. Victoria's verse!!
Geri also sings lower harmonies that's why sometimes she doesn't sing. but their harmonies are dope
We can hear the same - the lower - from Victoria, I've just looked (heard) the Two Become One official clip once again - and there)
And there's still people who think Victoria can't sing... 🤦
Yes thank you !!!❤❤❤ agreed x1000000000 🎉🎉
Now Victoria can't sing anyway... she doesn't want to participate in the band's last concerts. 🤦🏻♂️
Because she’s “posh,” gorgeous, and sexy., You can’t be all 3 of those and talented to the majority of people, it’s so ignorant.
Right!!! She holds the harmonies down!!!
Victoria had more bass than Mel B
Emma voice so lovely
Love Mel C's voice so much ❤️❤️❤️
POSH!! Yay !!! Omg I’ve been waiting to hear her go a Cappella 😍 yas queen 🎉 beautiful voice you’re my idol still I love u !! #watchedSpiceWorl26 times at the cinema
Breaks my heart Victoria isn’t in it anymore.
Noe Cases anyways....
I know Victoria can struggle with her confidence during solos, but she really rounds out the harmonies very well
Each of the Spice Girls has their own unique tone. All of them can sing very well. I like it when their singing voice is just like their speaking voice (can be recognized instantly whose voice is it). Love this acapella! They can have an acapella album singing other artists' songs.
... true pieces of pop history, music, beauty, fun, and somehow innocence... in short, utter gems. The five creatures carved their special place in the hearts of millions kids and teens worldwide, putting up a phenomenon that - for many a different and valid reasons - NEVER will be duplicated. Not tomorrow, nor in one thousand years.
In a certain sense, girls, you came from another galaxy... love and respect forever, from Italy.
La gente creía que Victoria no cantaba, sólo porque no hacía tantos solos.. . Pero su trabajo era full haciendo las voces de fondo. Ella tiene una voz que es la mezcla de todas las demás. En el video a veces se aprecia que las otras estan acapella un poco fuera de tono en las armonías y ella es la única que nunca lo estuvo.
Mel B Victoria and Geri lower register should of been utilized more they sound great
Mel B and Victoria's lower registers were used... Geri doesn't quite have the range to go either way, she can't go as low as Victoria, let alone Mel B and she can't get to Emma or Mel C's vocal highs. Actually, she can't get to Victoria's vocal highs either as the nixed Victoria's part from Holler rather than have Geri sing it. And the reason Victoria took over Geri's verse in 2 Become 1 was partly because she didn't get a verse in Wannabe and partly because Victoria could hit the higher notes easier (it apparently took a while for Geri to nail it in the studio and they didn't have time to go through that again).
it makes the harmonies sound so full
I miss Victoria
Why is Geri so shy? I love her tone it compliments and blends with Mel B's so well
JaiProdz I think it’s like the same with Victoria poor song choices for their vocal abilities when they were solo artists so it knocked their confidence
I think it’s because she wasn’t trained vocally so she gets a little nervous singing
She struggled to keep up vocally. I don’t think Victoria and Geri had the same issues. Geri wasn’t as gifted vocally as the rest and she worked super hard to keep up so and she knew that. Victoria was actually really decent at the beginning and throughout the Spice Girls, her confidence shrunk more and more and her vocals suffered because of it.
@@tandyandy8819 very true and thanks for replying because I really love talking and discussing the girls. I think that Geri definitely did improve and you can hear it on her reunion tour with the girls in the late 2000s, but on that tour I don't think Victoria really sang Live at all. It's sad that they kind of switch personalities and then by the time 2019 came around Geri wasn't singing at all either on the reunion tour
@@JaiProdz agreed! They both had confidence issues just for very different reasons. I mostly hate it for Victoria since she had a, in my opinion, rich and unique tone and voice. Either way, I hope we get to see the five of them together again soon with both Geri and Victoria singing live with all of the confidence in the world. They may not be the best, but they’re amazing performers and that’s what it’s all about.
2:15 acapella they all look at Geri cuz she was off. Lmao!! She got it by the second line tho. Lol love them.
Lol cause she sang softer the second time
then somehow she sang on off-key again towards the end of it
She raised her hand showing it was her lmao
this clip at 3:20 always amazes me how geri never sings a note! lol love her tho
Love the ending!
I always loved Emma and Mel C. Voice
I MISS VICTORIA! there is said it
Mel C the best spice girl ever!
Legends !!!
WOW son fabulosas sus harmonias. Las amo 😍
The gods bless you for uploading this!! 😂
Thank God for Mel C ♥️
I love Mel B's voice
Yesss
Ah gosh Mel C..I could listen to her singing all day
3:05 Posh is a mood 😛
They should release We're gonna make it happen as a single!!!
Brilliant!
Love this. But I find it weird they get the high harmony on say you’ll be there wrong constantly lol. The first ‘everything’ is half a step higher
Maravilhosas 💚💛🇧🇷
7:00 Mel C shows why is the best of them.
I swear in a good bit of these I didn't even hear Geri.
3:16 Geri performing with the same outfit as the cover of the first Spice Girls album ...
Leurs voix s accorde tellement bien surtout avec Mélanie c qui a une voix puissante ❤❤❤❤❤✌✌✌✌✌✌
i wonder how old emma is in this video, she's so cute
... it depends wich the respective clip is... aside of the very last one (May 2019), all the other clips are taken between October 1994 and December 1999. Anyway at 7:00, she's three months short of 19.
who are the 5 dislikes i will fight u
Now 6
And I’ll back you! How dare they!
We’re in this together, count on me too !
thank you!!!!
miss this era
We’re gonnnaaa make it happeeennn 🎶
Irrepetibles...❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Geri ❤
La gente que dice que Victoria no canta es gente estúpida JAAJJA
No entiendo porque dicen que Victoria no canta
Creo que tiene un tono muy bonito y que aporta una parte importante al grupo en toda su variedad. Está claro que ella no es Mariah Carey pero canta con un tono lindo.
Mel b has the best voice
😂😂
Que amorosas..♥️✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️
Todas son grandiosas pero vocalmente solo EMMA, GERY Y SOBRE TODO MEL C sostienen el grupo
When I think spice girls I think Chicken Little
8:35 VB gets picked on by Mel B too much
also victoria could always sing, she's just an alto.
5:29 Geri looks confused. She couldn’t have been singing this bc she doesn’t appear to know the words
Victoria era como una especie de colchón vocal, muy importante para las demás voces❤
lol hopefully melanie c were here
Las amooooo🤩👏👏👏💜
👑🕶
I see why they don’t like the first song
Who's doing the very low register voice? It's Mel B.
❤❤❤❤❤legends
🧡🧡🧡
Victoria’s voice was nice, but it seemed like she couldn’t outgrow that musical theatre-like voice.
That's fine. All of them had very different vocal takes. Geri was at her best a lounge singer. Mel C was the pop diva. Emma was the retro-60s sweetness, Mel B was the warmer and grittier urban vibe, Victoria gave us musical theater chorus girl. Vic's audition song was Mein Herr.
Geri has nothing to do there.
3:16 Geri actuando con el mismo modelito de la portada del primer disco de Spice Girls...
Sensacionais, porque aconteceu um fim, não?
5:10
Why did the girls not want to sing that song with Geri?
👏👏👏👏👏
5:11
8:10 What is the song?
1:41 Mel C looks like Billie Eillish here
Indeed 😂❤
Jos and Toady 😀 TV have been
They all were decent singers except Geri who was pretty terrible. Poor thing. Loved her bubbly personnality though!
I think terrible is a bit harsh. She was average but I wouldn’t say she was bad, and she’s improved a lot since they started
I adore Geris voice, my fave tone.
@HI HEY HELLO Agreed! And the first two albums were pre-pitch correction too
She’s better than most, just not better than the rest of the spice girls.
6:16 VB nowhere near the mic tho 🤦🏾♀️ I know she didn’t sing this
I take it back. She purposely blew the last note
Not ONE of these girls can sing or dance!!! AT ALL!! They had ONE HIT SONG with the help of AUTOTUNE!!! This video clearly confirms that they are NOT artists!! Why have we never,ever heard one of them sing solo??? They took a lot of money from people for tickets to their ‘concerts”. I have been asking fans if they have ever gone to their concerts twice, and I found about 15 people that have. Most concert goers just go to see their costumes, cleavage, and legs…NOT their music. Beckham is not a pretty lady and cannot sing on pitch. There is NO VIBRATO in any of their voices that I can hear. Their harmony is just all of them singing over eachother and it’s just chaos. I don’t care for the group at all. These are just my opinions.
😂a quien le importa. El que quiera escucharla paga por verlas y el que no pues no la vea
Not ONE of these girls can sing or dance!!! AT ALL!! They had ONE HIT SONG with the help of AUTOTUNE!!! This video clearly confirms that they are NOT artists!! Why have we never,ever heard one of them sing solo??? Thetook a lot of money from people for tickets to their ‘concerts”. I did a little poll and of my own and I have never
Only Mel C and Emma can sing. Mel Be also has a good voice, but she can't take high notes.
There are a lot of contraltos who don't go very high.
And that's fine. Singers should sing in the range their comfortable in.
They can all sing
Bad song
Vicky was and is the weakest link.
Actually Victoria provided a lot of essential lower harmonies, along with some of the higher parts. And if I'm being honest she's a better singer than Geri. She's classically trained and has a good range. Just because she wasn't getting solos doesn't mean she wasn't important
@@vivitosis4978 THIS
3:28 Victoria's response to your critique. 😌
You clearly didn't listen properly to this video 😂.
@@jexpiperUK you clearly have a tin ear, hun.
They sound ...meh..
lmfao melanie was ADAMENT about not singing 'we're gonna make it happen'
@honestvocalcoach