Some might say I should've gone into more detail about the Klingon mating rituals...well, there's arguably enough material to make for an entire video. Maybe one day, after I cover their political history and technology first...lol P.S. We're almost at 10K subs as of when I'm writing this! Thank you all so much for helping me grow so quickly this year. I have something special planned to celebrate this milestone.
Klingon sun is similar to the Vulcan sun and slightly dimmer than ours? Then why did the Vulcan's develop a secondary eye lid to block out the brightness of the Vulcan sun? You should recheck your facts.
Best way to handle the Klingon redesign in "Trials and Tribble-ations" would have been to have Worf appear without ridges when they went back in time and *absolutely nobody mention it or notice it at all*.
The old explanation was that the Klingon Empire made human/Klingon hybrid people called fusions that were used for spy purposes. And the other smooth heads were offspring of those.
This brings up one of my major quibbles with Trek. Klingons are said to have all these redundancies that enhance their warrior lifestyle. Vulcan/Romulans are said to be much stronger than many species. And yet in fights our heroes are consistently shown to be able of going toe to toe with these aliens that could take them out with no trouble. Would you want to fight a chimp or gorilla? Starfleet must have incredible combat training for humans.
To be fair, this is not always the case and depends on the era and individual. In the Discovery era, there was a war going on and as such Discovery's crew are shown engaging in extensive martial arts practice. I'm sure that Tilly and Stamets would still get there butts though. In other eras, TNG, DS9, Voyager, this seems more a personal choice or occupational training. Yar is good, she's the head of security, Geordi no so much as an engineer. RIker is proficient, but this is due to training from his father through childhood. Sisko is proficeint, he was Academy wrestling Captain. Still lost to a Vulcan in that. Dax had a personal interest in martial arts, Kira was a guerilla fighter, O'brien better have a phaser. In effect, training and choice. As to the biological superiority, not as big a deal as you would guess. Still a definite factor don't get me wrong but not an overwhelming or insurmountable one. Smaller fighters can and do beat bigger opponents right here on Earth. Its all in how you use the advantages you have versus the disadvantages of the opponent. Pretty much the entire reason for the invention of martial arts in general.
@@jamesdelorto6933 Been training most of my life and let me tell ya: our huge male students are never in as much pain as they are when fighting a tiny female student. Being bigger also makes you a bigger target and slower to get out of the way
I have never liked that humans, on Star Trek, were always depicted as being a physically and/or mentally weaker species (as humanoids go) in this quadrant. Consistently mediocre, at best.
The Klingon makeup had already been updated sufficiently in Star Trek Into Darkness. Why the makers of Discovery couldn't stick with that update--and allow their actors to give a better performance in the process--still eludes me.
Very true. STD seems to do everything wrong. The characters are boring. What’s-Her-Name is a Mary Sue… The feel of the whole thing is wrong. It seems like they’re just there to use the restrooms.🚽
@@MAMoreno One thing I love about Voyager is the absolute lack of stakes. It makes for great comfort TV. Ironically, it makes it really rewatchable for me, even though, as you've pointed out, it's not narratively the greatest ST of all time.
I’m not against the idea of redesigning Klingons in theory- but that particular design was a huge misstep. It was vaguely hydrocephalic and not at all helped by the stiff voice acting.
That's the exact reason I don't like the Klingons. They are one dimensional, nothing past them loving to fight. We know their must be Klingons who are into other things like science and art. But we never see any of them. And the tiny glimpses we get usually portray them as only doing other jobs because they aren't strong enough to be a fighter.
He literally references an episode that addresses this topic. The augments remember the scientist and how he talks about how Klingon society views scientists.....
@@theFLCLguy I agree. Because of this, especially in DS9, I find many of the stories to be a bore. It was the same thing: honor and glory. Nothing was better than when Ezri Dax told Worf that the Klingons were a decaying society full of rhetoric and nothing more.
@@theFLCLguynot true, that's just the "ideal" Klingon. There's a stigma against them, but they're treated as just as important as the warriors, they do take opportunities to shit on them for lacking honor though lmao
I always thought random dynamic intercellular mutation was occurring rather than de-evolution. Riker and Ogawa becoming proto-human ‘cavemen’ I can understand, but Barkley becoming an arachnid was a bit of a stretch (what’s next; one of the crew changes into a Centaur?) 😅
The bit is Pawns and Symbols about Klingons not being able to see red, wouldn't make sense in the canon universe considering how red the light on Klingon ships is. They would be stumbling around in the dark.
Light vision and color vision are different. I'm red/green colorblind. Red light to me looks yellowish brown if not amber depending on the hue. But it's no less bright for me.
The three lungs makes sense to me, because there are a lot of clouds shown in the atmosphere; the air may be denser than most Class M Planets, and harder for other humanoids to breathe. Klingons seem to prefer darker, warmer climate, which explains why they would us an ice world as a prison planet.
I'm not sure if it's still canon.. but in the book "worlds of the federation ".. it also went over allies like the klingons.. it said that their homeworld had very little fresh water. So very little vegetation of any kind.. thus, every single animal there was a carnivore. And it's entire evolution was based on kill or be killed. So everything from klingons to targs evolved to have extra organs as backups because every day involved being both predator and prey.
@@joshythehand2960would be cool if that was possible lmao. Carnivores out numbering herbivores results in an ecological collapse, as there's too much energy lost from carnivores eating one another. Life is cyclical because it has to be. bacteria convert corpses to nutrients, plants absorb those and the sun, herbivores eat the plants which in turn keeps them in check, carnivore does the same to herbivores, and when they die the bacteria do their thing. Each step in this chain starting from bacteria must have less then the one before, as each step provides less nutrients from the start of the chain, any more or less of any part could cause a total collapse. Basically, the klingons wouldn't have existed if everything on their planet was carnivorous, even if 50% of animals were they'd die off
Subscribing to your channel has been an excellent decision so far. These kinds of deep dives and detailed explorations into lore are one of my favorite things.
As for star trek discovery just remember there's a reason everyone refers to it as an S.T.D. as for Klingon's strength I will have to point out the fact that captain James T. Kirk did not have any problems going Toe to Toe with an augment enhanced Klingon but came very close to having his behind handed to him by a Gorn captain.
That's because Captain Kirk is a member of Starfleet and Starfleet at that time was training their members in multiple forms of martial arts from all planets not just martial arts of Earth the main martial arts that they learn revoking martial arts which is about taking advantage of leverage and not about raw strength Klingons typically overpower you once you understand that you understand how to fight them so your argument is not valid
So when Worf was 13 and killed that kid in that soccer game before they moved to Russia on Earth. You're saying he had a full grow male Klingon body? DAMN!
This is easily one of the best videos I've ever seen about Klingon anatomy and physiology. I wish I'd known about som of these details before I started swimming for Klingon characters in various Star Trek settings.
The different metalloprotein chemistries are more than just about colours. They also affect oxygen transport efficiencies in different energy environments, different temperatures, different saturations of non-binding substances/toxins/etc. There's always a balance of tradeoffs, though. More of something means less of something else, more of everything means higher metabolic costs. Interesting that klingon blood has been shown as pinky-purply-red in klingon atmosphere, as crimson-red in human atmosphere. Perhaps human blood would appear the same colours in those environments.
I acquired post-illness color blindness where blue and brown are confused. Didn't even know I had it until my favorite "navy blue" leather belt was on a hook, near my wife. She stopped and told me it was brown. I somehow never surfaced until then.
Head canon for early Klingon appearance, Sun Tzu “To know your Enemy, you must become your Enemy.” “Engage people with what they expect; it is what they are able to discern and confirms their projections. It settles them into predictable patterns of response, occupying their minds while you wait for the extraordinary moment - that which they cannot anticipate.”
Years ago, after TMP Gene Roddenberry was asked about the Klingon redesign by a young teen. His reply was "what redesign? This is how they ALWAYS have looked". He then went on the explain that when in the 60s the TV networks received the broadcasted images from whatever sector the Enterprise was in, the broadcasts lost some detail in the Klingons. No matter what anyone says about The Great Bird of the Galaxy, he was quick on his feet.
The line from the Klingon drinking song that says that "the River Skral ran crimson red" should not be seen as an indication of the actual color of Klingon blood. This is just the English "translation" of the song. The word used in the original Klingon lyrics is "Doq" which does not simply mean "red" but covers the entire reddish colour spectrum including orange, purple and pink. The colour of the river in the song is a matter of interpretation. It can be red, but also pink or purple.
Don't forget in the TNG episode "The Chase," an alien species seeded ancient lifeforms with their own DNA. Please forgive if it was mentioned somewhere in the comments already.
I love the vast diversity of Klingons, it makes them feel more real and organic. I see your biology videos as a great addendum to Certifiably Ingame's cultural indexes. With the two combined it really pains such a beautiful and full picture.
What me bothered about Discovery's depiction of Klingons, is that they made them into monsters, star trek was never about that, quite the opposite to be clear.
Why not redundant blood oxygen transports? If they have multiple kinds, the pink color could be a color blend effect, and the secondary decaying rapidly could cause it turn crimson. Therefore a crimson river of blood would indicate old decaying blood, and long battles
It would be interesting for you to do a video on the Hur'q conquest of Quo'nos, during the Klingon's "medieval" period, Klingon enslavement and eventual Klingon uprising. Worf stated that the Klingons first ventured into space using captured Hur'q ships (as seen in Discovery's "Battle of the Binary Stars") to wage war on Hur'q colonies and wipe the Hur'q completely out. The Klingon Empire is founded on the remains of the previous Hur'q Empire.
I seem to remember a line in Next Gen episode "Genesis" stating that the virus contains DNA from other species and that this is what causes the changes in crew. Not necessarily that these traits were primitive versions in that species' line. This may be 100% wrong and just my head cannon.
@@FallenPhoenix86 I’m not a biologist, but I also remember something about how we have tons of dormant trash DNA we get from viruses that picked it up on other critters. So right now you may have dormant anteater dna just hanging about.
Loved this video on Klingon physiology. The other two Star Trek races I would be interested in exploring are the Vulcans and Romulans, including the ancestral links between the two, their divergence, and the ramifications of all this. For example, when Spock is fighting Kahn in the most recent (re-booted) movies, Vulcan strength and speed is featured. While Kahn appears to be stronger and faster, Spock in his rage, is still a formidable opponent for Kahn. Given that Spock is only half Vulcan, how might a full-blooded Vulcan fair against Kahn? Also, I would be interested in physiological comparisons, based on cannon, between Klingons, Romulans and Vulcans regarding strength and speed..... Finally, the "mind meld" feature of the Vulcans would be interesting to explore. Can Romulans do this? How did this evolve? .
Truth be told I never seen in the show Romulans doing a mind meld. My guess is part of the Vulcan’s mental training includes this ability as being learned rather than innate. You need a calm mind to sense things better in your environment, like hearing a soft noise in a quiet room.
@@walterlyzohub8112 what I find interesting is that Remans appear to have mental abilities somewhat similar to Vulcans, the Viceroy projects Shinzon into Troi's mind. There is of course debate whether Remans are related to Romulans but I suspect they are and they continued to develop mental abilities as the Vulcans did while the Romulans did not. So it's possible the Romulans have the mental abilities but just don't use them for whatever reason or maybe they're not aware of them because they never studyed and developed them so they don't know how to access them, for lack of a better term.
Recently found your channel. Your deep dives like in this video are so informative and entertaining. It's amazing how much knowledge you have accumulated.
A true Star Trek fan does not miss pronounce the name of characters. It is pronounced mole are not mole or. note that this is not the spelling of the word, just meant to demonstrate proper pronunciation.
There was another reason Klingon blood was shown as purple or pink in Undiscovered Country but it was in a cut scene: At the climax of the story, where the President of the UFP was about to be assassinated by a Klingon, Scotty bursts in the room and fires his phaser at the Klingon, causing him to fall out of the windowed loft. When everyone came to inspect the body, Dr. McCoy noticed that the blood was red, not purple, indicating this person was not a Klingon. It turned out to be another human Federation co-conspirator made to look like a Klingon to further the collapse of the treaty.
Rather than the convoluted Augment explanation for the changes in the Klingon appearance I would have gone with the fact that the Klingon Empire has several conquered races that serve the Empire identifying as being Klingon's in the sense of the Empire and not Klingon's the species.
If in a pinch and without another Klingon around, Romulan blood can be given to Klingons who need it, and vice versa. I can’t recall the TNG episode, but Dr. crusher summons Worf to medical and she ask if he’ll donate blood to help save the dying romulan she had on her operating table. Both Worf and the romulan refused to help; Worf by donating his blood, and I believe the romulan had valuable information or something that Picard needed.
I rather liked how the old Star Trek RPGs and wargames explained the forehead thing: That being that the Klingons were not a single species but infact several different species living under the same homogeneous culture. It's actually possible to stretch that to include even the Discovery Klingons . . . if one is feeling very, very generous.
I believe that I would like a more detailed explanation for why Worf said that the Klingons do not discuss the changes in their appearances in the "Trials And Tribble-ations" episode of Star Trek Deep Space 9.
Interesting video. Question. Were you stating that the Klingon retina can respond to the ultraviolet, stating 32,000 Å as an example of how far into the UV spectrum or were you stating that the Klingon retina is responsive from the UV spectrum on one end and up to 32,000 Å at the other? I ask as 32,000 Å (3,200 nm) is firmly in the infrared spectrum and far removed from the UV.
They should have given Worf the TOS Klingon makeup. And never mentioned it at all. The "we don't discuss it with outsiders" is indeed a mildly funny Worf line. But just have Worf look like an old style Klingon, and it's never addressed would have been better, and funnier.
I never had an issue with ENT’s explanation of the Klingon’s difference. The transporter was invented because of real world limitations. The warp drive on TNG was the same drive in the TOS movies, because of a real world limitation. Star Trek, like all tv shows and movies come up with canon reasons for real world limitations. It’s all fun, no need to take it so seriously.
Its fun to note that the 2 reasons given by Bashir and O'Brien "Genetic mutation" or "A Virus" - turned out in Enterprise (underrated show) to be exactly what caused it... I liked those episodes...
The idea that Klingons might have a variety of different blood proteins, affecting blood color in differing situations, would just fit right in with their other redundancies and survival adaptations.
I actually like the way Klingons are depicted in Discovery, it gives them a unique look, I like how distinguished they look, they aren't too human-like but not too alien, they are a perfect medium, I also did some digging and found that the reason why the Klingons in discovery are bald, its a ritual they perform that they cut their hair for war, kinda like many human nations that did the same in the ancient past, especially Norsemen. I like the Grey skin they give the Klingons, it once again makes them different in a good way, also if their ancestors are insects or crustaceans then how did they become humanoid? it makes no sense because they would just evolve into a smaller crab-like creature or bug man, so perhaps their ancestors were artificially enhanced and created into a proto Klingon kinda like how humans had Homo erectus, Neanderthals, etc. I believe that may just be the case, I also wonder how did they achieve warp tech and particle weapon tech if they were primitive from the start? Either their creators gave them tech or did they steal it, if so how? maybe an invading alien force that they defeated give them the weapons? either way they have developed a very neat and fascinating society and culture, I wish they looked like Discovery version in the past recent movies so it wont look like every movie and series has different ideas on what a Klingon looks like.
Truly surprised nobody has mentioned John M. Ford's novel "The Final Reflection". While I have accepted the klingon versions of STNG, STDS9, and STVOY; always liked the concept the novel brought. The novel is one of my favorites. However, to the point at hand, pretty good video and keep up the good work. Looking forward to more.
Correct me if I’m wrong and I can’t remember where I had seen it but wasn’t there a canonical source once stating the ancestors of Klingons were a type of crustacean? I swore it was an explanation to their ridges.
I wonder if Klingon organ redundancy is not all it's chocked up to be. They may have evolved redundancy as an alternative strategy to evolving durability. Three lungs, but each lung has less capacity to human lungs. Two livers, but each liver is less effective at filtering or regrowing. By distributing their physiological needs across additional organs, they would be able to compensate for inferior-functioning organs They're depicted as bulkier and able to take a lot of punishment but are not necessarily stronger, since they're defeated in melee combat by Starfleet et al all the time
I like the augment virus as a concept. It’s an easy explanation for the more human looking Klingons that ties into the genetic engineering lore with humans. It also works to give us an explanation for why the Klingons haven’t tried that type of thing themselves given their warlike nature. They have and it went horribly wrong. The idea that generally Klingons believe that genetic engineering is dishonorable because the last time they tried it they lost something super significant to their identities makes sense too
I believe what happened with Barclay in the de-evolved episode, I believe they said he has a type of surgery that involved another species DNA and that part was triggered separately to his human half.
I wouldn't mind learning about their political economy. I get the impression that the Klingons have some sort of feudal system. In DS9 Warf and other Klingon characters often talk about their family's "lands". Also it's revealed in DS9 that the Klingon Empire is not in any way democratic. And what about the reason why the Klingon empire is an empire? Does it have something to do with their native economy? What would happen to Klingon civilization if their Empire did not continue to expand?
I have talked to actual Klingons. And there is something that is always missed, the ridges are in more than one place. I used to have a Klingon girlfriend, YOU figure it out. And for the Klingons in STD. The Narn from Babylon 5 would like to talk to about that.
I love these sorts of in depth lore videos, be it on physiology or politics or really any aspects of the aliens (and humans) of Trek. Thank you! Stay well out there everybody, and God bless you friends! :)
ive always wondered how the skull ridges of klingons are so different, even between family, is there anything like that in real nature, or maybe something from the extended universe?
@@DMSProduktions im mostly talking about bone structure, there’s a lot of unique traits present in nature, but the unique bone shapes of klingon skull ridges is different than anything ive seen before
like many have said, it is like finger prints. They are very unique to families- Worf had never seen Grilka before and thus didn't recognize her crest (her head, not her family badge). Gowron is unique as he seems to have no children.
For diversity and inclusion. They didn’t want to keeps all the species separate. This way, everyone can get along with everyone else. Tho, many, if not most hybrids, required medical intervention. I can’t think of a natural one. And of course it’s explained by us being seeded across the galaxy, from the same genetic stock. Even tho species really shouldn’t be able to interbreed. We can’t breed with any apes. Tho we did breed with Neanderthal. So what do I know
@@jamesbizs ok. Back then I was like, It's just a novelty thing. Mixed messages, the federation weren't the role models, and the famous prime directive, and all the times they broke it or used it conveniently... Also I saw there were just a few "hybrids". Since they were main cast, they were visible, and not many more of them anywhere to be seen. So. there's the big man (+) Spock,.. Deanna Then one Klingon + human, wtf don't kill her so... Soon What's done it's done 😅 Oh, and Sela Yar. Then, Quark with a glorious Klingon Lady, Worf and the goauld... Didn't watch Voyager, there was another Klingon + human... If they showed lots of love among all people from all over the quadrant, THAT would have been a good message I would've appreciated. You know. It was like, one character of this ethnics, another one of those others.. And the rest are the same. I know that were the 90's and that was a good step forward to be better ppl, and I guess it didn't work heh heh. I mean, it's one of each in the main cast, but the rest of the species, or better, too many humans and not many others. One Vulcan sometimes? I think there should be a lot of Vulcans on those ships. Come on, they mostly do a good job. With Klingons, breeding was said to be difficult, but not with Vulcans. Oh. So no real equalité. It would be nice to have a world where you see ppl from any "ethnics" and "alien species" living along in peace... The worst idea ever. If there's no conflict, it's boring and a total failure. 🖖😁
Man you are smart YOUR RANGE of knowledge is vast, I do enjoy the breakdown of why things are is interesting. Thanks for sharing your information on the Klingons I would like your insight into one of my favorite races THE Jem' Hadar
Klingons being red-black colorblind makes the choice of red light on their bridges and in their flag... interesting. Also makes the "crimson river" absolute gobbledegook
wow I never knew that supposedly a K type star has a better chance for life then our own star that is something I never expected to hear. Well if Barclay can become a spider so can Worf.
My personal head cannon is that Klingons start out in utero as twins or multiple zygotes before merging and this lends itself to why they have so many extra/redundant organs.
Yeah... I think rather than having done the Enterprise augment virus storyline, if they really HAD to make cannon consistant, they could have maybe used CG when they redid TOS to add forhead ridges or something... I didn't really like the augment virus thing. Especially at the end when the doctor says that he might get in to cranial ridge reconstruction. Like if this is all in universe... Then why did nobles like Kor and Kang have flat brows in TOS? Would their families (especially given their noble bloodlines) have not had such a proceedure. Just none of it actually makes sense.
The only thing I think bothers me about the Discovery Klingons is that all that makeup made the actors sound like they had peanut butter in their mouth. In the past, when the actors had trouble speaking through their false teeth, sometimes they would record the lines again and dub it over. They didn't do that in Star Trek Discovery. I actually had to read the subtitles.
I think the TNG era style of Klingons is better, both in terms of physical appearance and cultural development. But it also always annoyed me that there was no cannon explanation for the difference in physical appearance between TOS and TNG. Something that big should have an in-universe explanation. When I was a kid, there was one theory that the TOS Klingons were genetically engineered to resemble humans more closely so that infiltration would be easier. I think this came from some Star Trek novels which I can't remember the names of. Another possibility was that there were more than one race of Klingons, and during the TOS era a different group was dominant. But the problem with that was that Kor, Kang, and Koloth all ended up with TNG era physiology when they appeared on DS9. Enterprise actually did a really good job resolving the issue, which was a natural outgrowth of what was already established in the universe. The time period of Enterprise is closer to the eugenics wars, and it would make sense for the Klingons to be threatened by that. It would also make sense for them to try to make their own augments and botch it up because their medical science is less precise.
I’ve always thought that Klingon culture must have developed from tree-cutters who used bow saws to fight off predators and burn cultural fires. Maybe lived mostly outside and didn’t build, priding themselves on clearing spaces, having bonfires visible from afar and protecting their and other families from larger and larger beasts
I have said this before about DIS, they still could have made slight alterations and added diversity to Klingons without totally alienating existing fans. What they did was rewriting a lot of the backstory to fit in the narrative that they wanted to tell. Thus some things got quite silly.
I think a fun way to model the klingon's appearance in universe would be that they evolved from the bug creatures due to the progenitor DNA influencing them towards a humanoid form. Eventually their chitin evolved into skin, and they took on the appearance of the Discovery Klingons. Very distinct ridging all over their skin, their skin still being segmented like their ancestors chitin. Humanoid in form, but clearly not human. From there the story with the augment virus plays out, but retconning the earlier klingons to have the discovery appearance, from which point a complete explosion of diversity happens in their genetics. The first generation and those directly infected became visually very human, as segments of their DNA was overwritten. and we get the Original Series klingons. But after a few generations, after vaccines are rolled out, after things are quarantined, and the virus is no longer a threat, you start seeing a blending of the forms, some looking more human, some looking more like the discovery klingons. most having an appearance somewhere between the two, looking like the TNG klingons.
In the ST:TNG comic "Shadowheart", Nikolai Rhozhenko finds himself with another group of klingons that are much big and scarier than what we knew as klingons.
Only change i liked to the klingons in discovery was the 4 nostrils definately made sense for an evolving predator in a hostile world. If i remember right a book said something about sensory organs in the ridges to sense atmospheric pressure changes of an impending storm.
I wish someone would do a TH-cam series specifically on the climate and geography of the planets in trek. I had a book in 1990 that was great.. worlds of the federation. It's allies. Neutral planets and enemies. It's the only thing I've see that gives detailed descriptions.of the topography of the planets themselves and how it effected the races from there.. for instance.. the klingon home world was very rocky with small forests scrabble forests.. but had very little fresh water.. just a few very salty seas. Because of lack of potable water, very few plants grew which meant almost no herbivores.. so every animal in the planet , including klinhons,, were derived from carnivorous hunters.. everything there hunted each other.. and this is why the klingons have such a warrior bearing naturally.
On the blood. I have a personal explanation/head canon that it is something in the atmosphere that reacts to something unique in their blood. Either something naturally occurring in the Qo'nos atmosphere, or a common industrial byproduct that is produced by technology of the era and usually filtered out by proper environmental filters. Klingons just do not usually prioritize for cleaning this byproduct out of the atmosphere or filtering them from the byproducts of their technology. Klingon ships tend to have a lot less creature comforts, as does their society as a whole. In scenes where we purple blood, this impurity has not been filtered out and is present in the atmosphere. It may even be present in air used in their space suits if they do not see it as something to worry about. It may even be more or less common in certain areas of Qo'nos. It could even be a byproduct of the augment virus or treatment for it. A piece of Trek history that really did not need to happen to explain anything...but does. Those closer to the time of the augment virus may be more likely to have purple blood. There also could be something related to diet; some food, additive, beverage, or pharmaceutical intoxicant which causes those who use it to have the color of their blood change. For the most part, I'm completely fine with how modern Trek has updated how different species look. It has kind of become a staple of the franchise. The stereotypical "nose ridges" has been a budget minded solution to creating aliens in Trek, so it makes sense as itt becomes easier to make better looking aliens that we do just that. Diversity is an important part of the franchise, and having that diversity stand out more is really important. But there is taking changes a bit to far. Discovery Klingons added way to many changes at once. Both in makeup design and in the look of their costumes and technology. There was no way to look at anything and be reminded of a Klingon or a Klingon ship or costume. The change between TOS and TMP was pretty drastic; but recognizable.
If the Klingon sun was a K star, it would be cooler and dimmer than ours and have a habitable zone that was both narrower and closer in. Thus Qo'nos would be subject to greater radiation of the kind that is less conducive for life, not more. Solar flares for instance would be more intense and damaging.
Actually, K-type stars have a relatively low amount of solar flare activity and are thus deemed perhaps _more_ conducive to life than stars like our Sun. Again, this is in large part because they're longer lived, giving more time for life to evolve. Really, it's M-type stars that are known to have the most violent flares and force tidal locking on planets in their habitable zones. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Habitability_of_K-type_main-sequence_star_systems
![[Live] : ONE FIGHT NIGHT 25 วันนี้!! "อเล็กซิส vs รีเกียน"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/suVr9a6BM2g/mqdefault.jpg)
Some might say I should've gone into more detail about the Klingon mating rituals...well, there's arguably enough material to make for an entire video. Maybe one day, after I cover their political history and technology first...lol
P.S. We're almost at 10K subs as of when I'm writing this! Thank you all so much for helping me grow so quickly this year. I have something special planned to celebrate this milestone.
An history video of the klingons lore would be great!
As long as it doesn't require the reading of Shakespeare in the Original Klingon!
Cool video. Can you do more?
Klingon sociology?
Klingon sun is similar to the Vulcan sun and slightly dimmer than ours? Then why did the Vulcan's develop a secondary eye lid to block out the brightness of the Vulcan sun? You should recheck your facts.
Best way to handle the Klingon redesign in "Trials and Tribble-ations" would have been to have Worf appear without ridges when they went back in time and *absolutely nobody mention it or notice it at all*.
Haha love it 😆
They could have simply said Q did it.
That would've been hilarious.
The old explanation was that the Klingon Empire made human/Klingon hybrid people called fusions that were used for spy purposes. And the other smooth heads were offspring of those.
Agreed. That would've been clever
This brings up one of my major quibbles with Trek. Klingons are said to have all these redundancies that enhance their warrior lifestyle. Vulcan/Romulans are said to be much stronger than many species. And yet in fights our heroes are consistently shown to be able of going toe to toe with these aliens that could take them out with no trouble. Would you want to fight a chimp or gorilla? Starfleet must have incredible combat training for humans.
Gotta love that unstoppable plot armor the writers endowed upon the human officers.
To be fair, this is not always the case and depends on the era and individual. In the Discovery era, there was a war going on and as such Discovery's crew are shown engaging in extensive martial arts practice. I'm sure that Tilly and Stamets would still get there butts though. In other eras, TNG, DS9, Voyager, this seems more a personal choice or occupational training. Yar is good, she's the head of security, Geordi no so much as an engineer. RIker is proficient, but this is due to training from his father through childhood. Sisko is proficeint, he was Academy wrestling Captain. Still lost to a Vulcan in that. Dax had a personal interest in martial arts, Kira was a guerilla fighter, O'brien better have a phaser. In effect, training and choice.
As to the biological superiority, not as big a deal as you would guess. Still a definite factor don't get me wrong but not an overwhelming or insurmountable one. Smaller fighters can and do beat bigger opponents right here on Earth. Its all in how you use the advantages you have versus the disadvantages of the opponent. Pretty much the entire reason for the invention of martial arts in general.
@@jamesdelorto6933 Been training most of my life and let me tell ya: our huge male students are never in as much pain as they are when fighting a tiny female student. Being bigger also makes you a bigger target and slower to get out of the way
Humans have been genetically augmented and... Doh! I guess not. Never mind.
I have never liked that humans, on Star Trek, were always depicted as being a physically and/or mentally weaker species (as humanoids go) in this quadrant.
Consistently mediocre, at best.
The Klingon makeup had already been updated sufficiently in Star Trek Into Darkness. Why the makers of Discovery couldn't stick with that update--and allow their actors to give a better performance in the process--still eludes me.
Very true. STD seems to do everything wrong. The characters are boring. What’s-Her-Name is a Mary Sue…
The feel of the whole thing is wrong. It seems like they’re just there to use the restrooms.🚽
@@jaybee9269 The best praise I can give Discovery is that it's still better than Voyager, but that's rather faint praise.
@@MAMoreno One thing I love about Voyager is the absolute lack of stakes. It makes for great comfort TV. Ironically, it makes it really rewatchable for me, even though, as you've pointed out, it's not narratively the greatest ST of all time.
Discovery jumped the shark with Klingons.
That redesign was not welcomed.
Discovery jumped the shark on a lot of things.
I’m not against the idea of redesigning Klingons in theory- but that particular design was a huge misstep. It was vaguely hydrocephalic and not at all helped by the stiff voice acting.
They didnt just redesign the look- complete misunderstanding of the culture that basically turned them into romulans.
Be good to hear about non-warrior roles in Klingon society and how they’re thought of by the Klingons.
That's the exact reason I don't like the Klingons. They are one dimensional, nothing past them loving to fight.
We know their must be Klingons who are into other things like science and art. But we never see any of them. And the tiny glimpses we get usually portray them as only doing other jobs because they aren't strong enough to be a fighter.
He literally references an episode that addresses this topic. The augments remember the scientist and how he talks about how Klingon society views scientists.....
@@theFLCLguy I agree. Because of this, especially in DS9, I find many of the stories to be a bore. It was the same thing: honor and glory. Nothing was better than when Ezri Dax told Worf that the Klingons were a decaying society full of rhetoric and nothing more.
@Doom Posterior Korath is the leader of the Great House, so not all scientists are overlooked.
@@theFLCLguynot true, that's just the "ideal" Klingon. There's a stigma against them, but they're treated as just as important as the warriors, they do take opportunities to shit on them for lacking honor though lmao
Barkley intro a spider always bothered me too. Spot being turned into an iguana almost came off as a sight gag though.
I always thought random dynamic intercellular mutation was occurring rather than de-evolution. Riker and Ogawa becoming proto-human ‘cavemen’ I can understand, but Barkley becoming an arachnid was a bit of a stretch (what’s next; one of the crew changes into a Centaur?) 😅
As for the redundancies, I remember a novel briefly mentioning that Klingons had 3 testicles.
Having 3 of anything , is just weird.
They might have more white blood cells in their blood that makes it look pink.
The bit is Pawns and Symbols about Klingons not being able to see red, wouldn't make sense in the canon universe considering how red the light on Klingon ships is. They would be stumbling around in the dark.
Light vision and color vision are different. I'm red/green colorblind. Red light to me looks yellowish brown if not amber depending on the hue. But it's no less bright for me.
That’s not how that works….
The three lungs makes sense to me, because there are a lot of clouds shown in the atmosphere; the air may be denser than most Class M Planets, and harder for other humanoids to breathe.
Klingons seem to prefer darker, warmer climate, which explains why they would us an ice world as a prison planet.
I'm not sure if it's still canon.. but in the book "worlds of the federation ".. it also went over allies like the klingons.. it said that their homeworld had very little fresh water. So very little vegetation of any kind.. thus, every single animal there was a carnivore. And it's entire evolution was based on kill or be killed. So everything from klingons to targs evolved to have extra organs as backups because every day involved being both predator and prey.
@@joshythehand2960would be cool if that was possible lmao. Carnivores out numbering herbivores results in an ecological collapse, as there's too much energy lost from carnivores eating one another. Life is cyclical because it has to be. bacteria convert corpses to nutrients, plants absorb those and the sun, herbivores eat the plants which in turn keeps them in check, carnivore does the same to herbivores, and when they die the bacteria do their thing. Each step in this chain starting from bacteria must have less then the one before, as each step provides less nutrients from the start of the chain, any more or less of any part could cause a total collapse. Basically, the klingons wouldn't have existed if everything on their planet was carnivorous, even if 50% of animals were they'd die off
Your occasional humorous asides are awesome!
Subscribing to your channel has been an excellent decision so far. These kinds of deep dives and detailed explorations into lore are one of my favorite things.
How about a video about the differences between romulans and Vulcans.
As for star trek discovery just remember there's a reason everyone refers to it as an S.T.D. as for Klingon's strength I will have to point out the fact that captain James T. Kirk did not have any problems going Toe to Toe with an augment enhanced Klingon but came very close to having his behind handed to him by a Gorn captain.
Prob pumped up FULL, of 'safe', 23rdC steroids!
That's because Captain Kirk is a member of Starfleet and Starfleet at that time was training their members in multiple forms of martial arts from all planets not just martial arts of Earth the main martial arts that they learn revoking martial arts which is about taking advantage of leverage and not about raw strength Klingons typically overpower you once you understand that you understand how to fight them so your argument is not valid
Technique over brute strength. Everytime.
No... it's ST:DISCO and it's a great show
So when Worf was 13 and killed that kid in that soccer game before they moved to Russia on Earth. You're saying he had a full grow male Klingon body? DAMN!
This is easily one of the best videos I've ever seen about Klingon anatomy and physiology. I wish I'd known about som of these details before I started swimming for Klingon characters in various Star Trek settings.
Maybe Klingon blood may have two different oxygen carrying blood cells? Well, this idea is consistent with the redundancy of their physiology.
The different metalloprotein chemistries are more than just about colours. They also affect oxygen transport efficiencies in different energy environments, different temperatures, different saturations of non-binding substances/toxins/etc.
There's always a balance of tradeoffs, though. More of something means less of something else, more of everything means higher metabolic costs.
Interesting that klingon blood has been shown as pinky-purply-red in klingon atmosphere, as crimson-red in human atmosphere. Perhaps human blood would appear the same colours in those environments.
I acquired post-illness color blindness where blue and brown are confused. Didn't even know I had it until my favorite "navy blue" leather belt was on a hook, near my wife. She stopped and told me it was brown. I somehow never surfaced until then.
It's really cool you're going over the physiologies of Star Trek's species. I was wondering if you can do the Vulcan brain?
Head canon for early Klingon appearance, Sun Tzu “To know your Enemy, you must become your Enemy.” “Engage people with what they expect; it is what they are able to discern and confirms their projections. It settles them into predictable patterns of response, occupying their minds while you wait for the extraordinary moment - that which they cannot anticipate.”
Years ago, after TMP Gene Roddenberry was asked about the Klingon redesign by a young teen. His reply was "what redesign? This is how they ALWAYS have looked". He then went on the explain that when in the 60s the TV networks received the broadcasted images from whatever sector the Enterprise was in, the broadcasts lost some detail in the Klingons. No matter what anyone says about The Great Bird of the Galaxy, he was quick on his feet.
"... and worse, Threshold." could be the answer to virtually any Star Trek question or comparison.
The line from the Klingon drinking song that says that "the River Skral ran crimson red" should not be seen as an indication of the actual color of Klingon blood. This is just the English "translation" of the song. The word used in the original Klingon lyrics is "Doq" which does not simply mean "red" but covers the entire reddish colour spectrum including orange, purple and pink. The colour of the river in the song is a matter of interpretation. It can be red, but also pink or purple.
Don't forget in the TNG episode "The Chase," an alien species seeded ancient lifeforms with their own DNA. Please forgive if it was mentioned somewhere in the comments already.
I mentioned it towards the beginning of the video--I always try to squeeze it in whenever I talk about humanoid species
I love the vast diversity of Klingons, it makes them feel more real and organic.
I see your biology videos as a great addendum to Certifiably Ingame's cultural indexes. With the two combined it really pains such a beautiful and full picture.
@Michael Hayes: paints* -- Considering how much Klingons love pain, the typo is ironic! 🥴
@@pablohammerly448 Ha! Didn't even notice. That's a keeper lol.
What me bothered about Discovery's depiction of Klingons, is that they made them into monsters, star trek was never about that, quite the opposite to be clear.
@Theodor Lajas: bothered me* (you reversed the order) 🙄
Why not redundant blood oxygen transports? If they have multiple kinds, the pink color could be a color blend effect, and the secondary decaying rapidly could cause it turn crimson. Therefore a crimson river of blood would indicate old decaying blood, and long battles
It would be interesting for you to do a video on the Hur'q conquest of Quo'nos, during the Klingon's "medieval" period, Klingon enslavement and eventual Klingon uprising. Worf stated that the Klingons first ventured into space using captured Hur'q ships (as seen in Discovery's "Battle of the Binary Stars") to wage war on Hur'q colonies and wipe the Hur'q completely out. The Klingon Empire is founded on the remains of the previous Hur'q Empire.
"it gotta come out"
Marsupials: "you fool"
I seem to remember a line in Next Gen episode "Genesis" stating that the virus contains DNA from other species and that this is what causes the changes in crew. Not necessarily that these traits were primitive versions in that species' line. This may be 100% wrong and just my head cannon.
Would go a long way to explaining Barclay turning into an eight legged freak.
@@FallenPhoenix86 I’m not a biologist, but I also remember something about how we have tons of dormant trash DNA we get from viruses that picked it up on other critters. So right now you may have dormant anteater dna just hanging about.
@Mr. Mickles: canon* (unless your "head cannon" means you've got a large gun stuck in your head) 🥴
@@pablohammerly448 no no, It's a cannon that shoots heads. XD
I'd like to see a topographic analysis of the klingon homeworld.
Loved this video on Klingon physiology. The other two Star Trek races I would be interested in exploring are the Vulcans and Romulans, including the ancestral links between the two, their divergence, and the ramifications of all this. For example, when Spock is fighting Kahn in the most recent (re-booted) movies, Vulcan strength and speed is featured. While Kahn appears to be stronger and faster, Spock in his rage, is still a formidable opponent for Kahn. Given that Spock is only half Vulcan, how might a full-blooded Vulcan fair against Kahn? Also, I would be interested in physiological comparisons, based on cannon, between Klingons, Romulans and Vulcans regarding strength and speed..... Finally, the "mind meld" feature of the Vulcans would be interesting to explore. Can Romulans do this? How did this evolve?
.
@Shannon McStormy: canon* (not "cannon" which is a big gun) 🙄
Truth be told I never seen in the show Romulans doing a mind meld. My guess is part of the Vulcan’s mental training includes this ability as being learned rather than innate. You need a calm mind to sense things better in your environment, like hearing a soft noise in a quiet room.
@@walterlyzohub8112 what I find interesting is that Remans appear to have mental abilities somewhat similar to Vulcans, the Viceroy projects Shinzon into Troi's mind. There is of course debate whether Remans are related to Romulans but I suspect they are and they continued to develop mental abilities as the Vulcans did while the Romulans did not. So it's possible the Romulans have the mental abilities but just don't use them for whatever reason or maybe they're not aware of them because they never studyed and developed them so they don't know how to access them, for lack of a better term.
Recently found your channel. Your deep dives like in this video are so informative and entertaining. It's amazing how much knowledge you have accumulated.
Hes obviously got a high IQ! Great channel huh?
@@jeffhallam2004 I agree wholeheartedly. Fantastic content by a creator who obviously cares about the subjects he covers.
Is it canon that Klingons have no tear ducts and, if so, what prevents their eyes from drying out?
I actually liked the explanation of the changes of Klingons in Enterprise.
A true Star Trek fan does not miss pronounce the name of characters. It is pronounced mole are not mole or. note that this is not the spelling of the word, just meant to demonstrate proper pronunciation.
There was another reason Klingon blood was shown as purple or pink in Undiscovered Country but it was in a cut scene:
At the climax of the story, where the President of the UFP was about to be assassinated by a Klingon, Scotty bursts in the room and fires his phaser at the Klingon, causing him to fall out of the windowed loft. When everyone came to inspect the body, Dr. McCoy noticed that the blood was red, not purple, indicating this person was not a Klingon. It turned out to be another human Federation co-conspirator made to look like a Klingon to further the collapse of the treaty.
Rather than the convoluted Augment explanation for the changes in the Klingon appearance I would have gone with the fact that the Klingon Empire has several conquered races that serve the Empire identifying as being Klingon's in the sense of the Empire and not Klingon's the species.
If in a pinch and without another Klingon around, Romulan blood can be given to Klingons who need it, and vice versa. I can’t recall the TNG episode, but Dr. crusher summons Worf to medical and she ask if he’ll donate blood to help save the dying romulan she had on her operating table. Both Worf and the romulan refused to help; Worf by donating his blood, and I believe the romulan had valuable information or something that Picard needed.
I rather liked how the old Star Trek RPGs and wargames explained the forehead thing: That being that the Klingons were not a single species but infact several different species living under the same homogeneous culture. It's actually possible to stretch that to include even the Discovery Klingons . . . if one is feeling very, very generous.
I believe that I would like a more detailed explanation for why Worf said that the Klingons do not discuss the changes in their appearances in the "Trials And Tribble-ations" episode of Star Trek Deep Space 9.
Interesting video. Question. Were you stating that the Klingon retina can respond to the ultraviolet, stating 32,000 Å as an example of how far into the UV spectrum or were you stating that the Klingon retina is responsive from the UV spectrum on one end and up to 32,000 Å at the other? I ask as 32,000 Å (3,200 nm) is firmly in the infrared spectrum and far removed from the UV.
I’m late but here! Happy for you getting to 10K
They should have given Worf the TOS Klingon makeup. And never mentioned it at all. The "we don't discuss it with outsiders" is indeed a mildly funny Worf line. But just have Worf look like an old style Klingon, and it's never addressed would have been better, and funnier.
Came here to broaden my understanding of Klingons.
Left with an awareness that penis worms are actually a thing.
I never had an issue with ENT’s explanation of the Klingon’s difference. The transporter was invented because of real world limitations. The warp drive on TNG was the same drive in the TOS movies, because of a real world limitation. Star Trek, like all tv shows and movies come up with canon reasons for real world limitations. It’s all fun, no need to take it so seriously.
Its fun to note that the 2 reasons given by Bashir and O'Brien "Genetic mutation" or "A Virus" - turned out in Enterprise (underrated show) to be exactly what caused it... I liked those episodes...
Yes a new video!! I always look forward to your videos my dude! You are, indeed, the man!
They should definitely stuck with DS9's explanation for the foreheads.
Sometimes, less is more.
The idea that Klingons might have a variety of different blood proteins, affecting blood color in differing situations, would just fit right in with their other redundancies and survival adaptations.
Totally enjoyed very informative and fun! Thank you!
I actually like the way Klingons are depicted in Discovery, it gives them a unique look, I like how distinguished they look, they aren't too human-like but not too alien, they are a perfect medium, I also did some digging and found that the reason why the Klingons in discovery are bald, its a ritual they perform that they cut their hair for war, kinda like many human nations that did the same in the ancient past, especially Norsemen. I like the Grey skin they give the Klingons, it once again makes them different in a good way, also if their ancestors are insects or crustaceans then how did they become humanoid? it makes no sense because they would just evolve into a smaller crab-like creature or bug man, so perhaps their ancestors were artificially enhanced and created into a proto Klingon kinda like how humans had Homo erectus, Neanderthals, etc. I believe that may just be the case, I also wonder how did they achieve warp tech and particle weapon tech if they were primitive from the start? Either their creators gave them tech or did they steal it, if so how? maybe an invading alien force that they defeated give them the weapons? either way they have developed a very neat and fascinating society and culture, I wish they looked like Discovery version in the past recent movies so it wont look like every movie and series has different ideas on what a Klingon looks like.
Truly surprised nobody has mentioned John M. Ford's novel "The Final Reflection". While I have accepted the klingon versions of STNG, STDS9, and STVOY; always liked the concept the novel brought. The novel is one of my favorites. However, to the point at hand, pretty good video and keep up the good work. Looking forward to more.
Am I the only one who really likes that there is a canon explanation for the smooth forehead Klingons?
Correct me if I’m wrong and I can’t remember where I had seen it but wasn’t there a canonical source once stating the ancestors of Klingons were a type of crustacean? I swore it was an explanation to their ridges.
I wonder if Klingon organ redundancy is not all it's chocked up to be. They may have evolved redundancy as an alternative strategy to evolving durability. Three lungs, but each lung has less capacity to human lungs. Two livers, but each liver is less effective at filtering or regrowing. By distributing their physiological needs across additional organs, they would be able to compensate for inferior-functioning organs
They're depicted as bulkier and able to take a lot of punishment but are not necessarily stronger, since they're defeated in melee combat by Starfleet et al all the time
I like the augment virus as a concept. It’s an easy explanation for the more human looking Klingons that ties into the genetic engineering lore with humans. It also works to give us an explanation for why the Klingons haven’t tried that type of thing themselves given their warlike nature. They have and it went horribly wrong. The idea that generally Klingons believe that genetic engineering is dishonorable because the last time they tried it they lost something super significant to their identities makes sense too
Not only do klingons have two stomachs they have two duodenums and two intestinal tracts.
in the past 2 years I watched every episode of TNG and DS9; I'll be finishing Voyager tonight. Here's to the trilogy!
I believe what happened with Barclay in the de-evolved episode, I believe they said he has a type of surgery that involved another species DNA and that part was triggered separately to his human half.
I wouldn't mind learning about their political economy. I get the impression that the Klingons have some sort of feudal system. In DS9 Warf and other Klingon characters often talk about their family's "lands". Also it's revealed in DS9 that the Klingon Empire is not in any way democratic. And what about the reason why the Klingon empire is an empire? Does it have something to do with their native economy? What would happen to Klingon civilization if their Empire did not continue to expand?
Cover that one DS9 episode where Quark accidentally became a Klingon
dude, im so happy i found your channel and subscribed some time in my past... Best videos on youtube!
I have talked to actual Klingons. And there is something that is always missed, the ridges are in more than one place. I used to have a Klingon girlfriend, YOU figure it out. And for the Klingons in STD. The Narn from Babylon 5 would like to talk to about that.
what?!😂
@@flyingfoamtv2169 Yes, you read that right. They have ridges there too.
I love these sorts of in depth lore videos, be it on physiology or politics or really any aspects of the aliens (and humans) of Trek. Thank you!
Stay well out there everybody, and God bless you friends! :)
i didn't expect just a solid deep dive into star trek races and some real science thrown in. GREAT VIDEOS!
ive always wondered how the skull ridges of klingons are so different, even between family, is there anything like that in real nature, or maybe something from the extended universe?
Horns on cattle are similar but different elephant tusk just to name a couple
EVER heard of FINGER PRINTS?
@@DMSProduktions im mostly talking about bone structure, there’s a lot of unique traits present in nature, but the unique bone shapes of klingon skull ridges is different than anything ive seen before
@@leftygurl Yeah, well i draw it to like that of finger prints!
like many have said, it is like finger prints. They are very unique to families- Worf had never seen Grilka before and thus didn't recognize her crest (her head, not her family badge). Gowron is unique as he seems to have no children.
Ok except that Worf's mate was half human, or Spock, and I don't know how it could be possible. Why was it that important to have "hybrid" characters?
For diversity and inclusion. They didn’t want to keeps all the species separate. This way, everyone can get along with everyone else. Tho, many, if not most hybrids, required medical intervention. I can’t think of a natural one. And of course it’s explained by us being seeded across the galaxy, from the same genetic stock. Even tho species really shouldn’t be able to interbreed. We can’t breed with any apes. Tho we did breed with Neanderthal. So what do I know
@@jamesbizs ok. Back then I was like,
It's just a novelty thing. Mixed messages, the federation weren't the role models, and the famous prime directive, and all the times they broke it or used it conveniently...
Also I saw there were just a few "hybrids". Since they were main cast, they were visible, and not many more of them anywhere to be seen.
So.
there's the big man (+) Spock,..
Deanna
Then one Klingon + human, wtf don't kill her so... Soon
What's done it's done 😅
Oh, and Sela Yar.
Then, Quark with a glorious Klingon Lady, Worf and the goauld...
Didn't watch Voyager, there was another Klingon + human...
If they showed lots of love among all people from all over the quadrant, THAT would have been a good message I would've appreciated.
You know. It was like, one character of this ethnics, another one of those others..
And the rest are the same.
I know that were the 90's and that was a good step forward to be better ppl, and I guess it didn't work heh heh.
I mean, it's one of each in the main cast, but the rest of the species, or better, too many humans and not many others.
One Vulcan sometimes?
I think there should be a lot of Vulcans on those ships. Come on, they mostly do a good job.
With Klingons, breeding was said to be difficult, but not with Vulcans.
Oh. So no real equalité. It would be nice to have a world where you see ppl from any "ethnics" and "alien species" living along in peace...
The worst idea ever. If there's no conflict, it's boring and a total failure.
🖖😁
Man you are smart YOUR RANGE of knowledge is vast, I do enjoy the breakdown of why things are is interesting. Thanks for sharing your information on the Klingons
I would like your insight into one of my favorite races THE Jem' Hadar
Klingons being red-black colorblind makes the choice of red light on their bridges and in their flag... interesting. Also makes the "crimson river" absolute gobbledegook
human gestation is 40 weeks. klingon gestation would therefore be closer to 2 1/2 months longer than humans, not 1 1/2, unless you mean alien months
wow I never knew that supposedly a K type star has a better chance for life then our own star that is something I never expected to hear. Well if Barclay can become a spider so can Worf.
I'd like to see a video on Klingon history, especially the pre-warp eras and the invasion of the Herk.
My personal head cannon is that Klingons start out in utero as twins or multiple zygotes before merging and this lends itself to why they have so many extra/redundant organs.
Yeah... I think rather than having done the Enterprise augment virus storyline, if they really HAD to make cannon consistant, they could have maybe used CG when they redid TOS to add forhead ridges or something... I didn't really like the augment virus thing. Especially at the end when the doctor says that he might get in to cranial ridge reconstruction. Like if this is all in universe... Then why did nobles like Kor and Kang have flat brows in TOS? Would their families (especially given their noble bloodlines) have not had such a proceedure. Just none of it actually makes sense.
In ST: Into Darkness, there is only one bald Klingon. If you look, you can see the hair sticking out from under the helmets of the other Klingons.
Klingons are very needy lovers. They are always klinging on.
The only thing I think bothers me about the Discovery Klingons is that all that makeup made the actors sound like they had peanut butter in their mouth. In the past, when the actors had trouble speaking through their false teeth, sometimes they would record the lines again and dub it over. They didn't do that in Star Trek Discovery. I actually had to read the subtitles.
I think the TNG era style of Klingons is better, both in terms of physical appearance and cultural development. But it also always annoyed me that there was no cannon explanation for the difference in physical appearance between TOS and TNG. Something that big should have an in-universe explanation. When I was a kid, there was one theory that the TOS Klingons were genetically engineered to resemble humans more closely so that infiltration would be easier. I think this came from some Star Trek novels which I can't remember the names of. Another possibility was that there were more than one race of Klingons, and during the TOS era a different group was dominant. But the problem with that was that Kor, Kang, and Koloth all ended up with TNG era physiology when they appeared on DS9.
Enterprise actually did a really good job resolving the issue, which was a natural outgrowth of what was already established in the universe. The time period of Enterprise is closer to the eugenics wars, and it would make sense for the Klingons to be threatened by that. It would also make sense for them to try to make their own augments and botch it up because their medical science is less precise.
I’ve always thought that Klingon culture must have developed from tree-cutters who used bow saws to fight off predators and burn cultural fires.
Maybe lived mostly outside and didn’t build, priding themselves on clearing spaces, having bonfires visible from afar and protecting their and other families from larger and larger beasts
I have said this before about DIS, they still could have made slight alterations and added diversity to Klingons without totally alienating existing fans. What they did was rewriting a lot of the backstory to fit in the narrative that they wanted to tell. Thus some things got quite silly.
It’s STD. not DIS. Don’t give them that courtesy!
@@jamesbizs You are right: STD - They deserve it. And the name is so bad that it doesn't work as an acronym.
I think a fun way to model the klingon's appearance in universe would be that they evolved from the bug creatures due to the progenitor DNA influencing them towards a humanoid form. Eventually their chitin evolved into skin, and they took on the appearance of the Discovery Klingons. Very distinct ridging all over their skin, their skin still being segmented like their ancestors chitin. Humanoid in form, but clearly not human. From there the story with the augment virus plays out, but retconning the earlier klingons to have the discovery appearance, from which point a complete explosion of diversity happens in their genetics. The first generation and those directly infected became visually very human, as segments of their DNA was overwritten. and we get the Original Series klingons. But after a few generations, after vaccines are rolled out, after things are quarantined, and the virus is no longer a threat, you start seeing a blending of the forms, some looking more human, some looking more like the discovery klingons. most having an appearance somewhere between the two, looking like the TNG klingons.
I don't treat discovery as cannon. All you got to see is how different everything looks and feels from star trek.
Id like to see the dynamic of the kligon houses broken down in depth… and its broader political ramifications. Good video as always.
I am curious to hear your problems with the ST:V episode “Distant Origin”.
I definitely think the Disco klingons belong in the 19th century because by then the mighty House ships are long since obsolete in 23rd century terms.
Don't worry about Discovery Klingons... They're not Klingons. Because Discovery isn't Star Trek.
In the ST:TNG comic "Shadowheart", Nikolai Rhozhenko finds himself with another group of klingons that are much big and scarier than what we knew as klingons.
th-cam.com/video/TEqjA2iNEao/w-d-xo.html
Only change i liked to the klingons in discovery was the 4 nostrils definately made sense for an evolving predator in a hostile world. If i remember right a book said something about sensory organs in the ridges to sense atmospheric pressure changes of an impending storm.
I've been waiting for you to do this one. Great video.
One of the TOS-era novels mentioned that Klingons' favor for the number three derived from their three-nut sacks.
I wish someone would do a TH-cam series specifically on the climate and geography of the planets in trek. I had a book in 1990 that was great.. worlds of the federation. It's allies. Neutral planets and enemies. It's the only thing I've see that gives detailed descriptions.of the topography of the planets themselves and how it effected the races from there.. for instance.. the klingon home world was very rocky with small forests scrabble forests.. but had very little fresh water.. just a few very salty seas. Because of lack of potable water, very few plants grew which meant almost no herbivores.. so every animal in the planet , including klinhons,, were derived from carnivorous hunters.. everything there hunted each other.. and this is why the klingons have such a warrior bearing naturally.
They should've kept to the TNG version of Klingons. Disco Klingons are soulless monstrosities.
5:46 the phrase Open your mouth will always be said in my head like Master Betty's Henchmen from Kung Pow
I call the discovery group klingoffs
On the blood.
I have a personal explanation/head canon that it is something in the atmosphere that reacts to something unique in their blood. Either something naturally occurring in the Qo'nos atmosphere, or a common industrial byproduct that is produced by technology of the era and usually filtered out by proper environmental filters.
Klingons just do not usually prioritize for cleaning this byproduct out of the atmosphere or filtering them from the byproducts of their technology. Klingon ships tend to have a lot less creature comforts, as does their society as a whole.
In scenes where we purple blood, this impurity has not been filtered out and is present in the atmosphere. It may even be present in air used in their space suits if they do not see it as something to worry about. It may even be more or less common in certain areas of Qo'nos.
It could even be a byproduct of the augment virus or treatment for it. A piece of Trek history that really did not need to happen to explain anything...but does. Those closer to the time of the augment virus may be more likely to have purple blood.
There also could be something related to diet; some food, additive, beverage, or pharmaceutical intoxicant which causes those who use it to have the color of their blood change.
For the most part, I'm completely fine with how modern Trek has updated how different species look. It has kind of become a staple of the franchise. The stereotypical "nose ridges" has been a budget minded solution to creating aliens in Trek, so it makes sense as itt becomes easier to make better looking aliens that we do just that. Diversity is an important part of the franchise, and having that diversity stand out more is really important.
But there is taking changes a bit to far. Discovery Klingons added way to many changes at once. Both in makeup design and in the look of their costumes and technology. There was no way to look at anything and be reminded of a Klingon or a Klingon ship or costume. The change between TOS and TMP was pretty drastic; but recognizable.
The open your mouth clip was funny
in so much detail I had no idea I would enjoy so much!!
If the Klingon sun was a K star, it would be cooler and dimmer than ours and have a habitable zone that was both narrower and closer in. Thus Qo'nos would be subject to greater radiation of the kind that is less conducive for life, not more. Solar flares for instance would be more intense and damaging.
Actually, K-type stars have a relatively low amount of solar flare activity and are thus deemed perhaps _more_ conducive to life than stars like our Sun. Again, this is in large part because they're longer lived, giving more time for life to evolve. Really, it's M-type stars that are known to have the most violent flares and force tidal locking on planets in their habitable zones. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Habitability_of_K-type_main-sequence_star_systems
@@OrangeRiver destroyed 😂
My head cannon is that while Hurk conquered the Klingons. Some intermixed with native Klingons