NGL, if The Last Jedi had this scene it would have really helped. That one line of dialogue, "You're not the last jedi because you failed, you're the last because you're meant to be the first of something new" would have been great to hear for Luke's story arc.
What I appreciate about your channel is that your stories feature elements from both "EU/Legends" & current Canon. Thank you for seeing the good in both and creating engaging content of your own.
I can't really say the same in terms of respect, but it is a better take on his self-imposed exile. He still comes off to me as a broken man wallowing in misery.
I genuinely love how these stories use so much of the Legends material while taking the few good things from the current canon and combine it into something excellent. Why can't Disney see that THIS is what they should've done?
I was hoping that it was gonna be Luke left to learn about what was before th jedi and how that is what is truly needed. Realizing when Rey comes how much he missed and what has happened cuz he left and having to make up for it. If they wanted to go down this Luke messed up plot.
@@DontrelleRoosevelt No it wasn't. TLJ clearly shows Luke exiling himself because he felt like he failed Ben when he thought of killing him. The real Luke would never do that. He wouldn't think of killing his family, and he wouldn't abandon the universe. They set up for the real Luke in TFA, where Han said that Luke went out in search of the first Jedi Temple to seek knowledge. It set up Luke preparing to take on the First Order 🤮🤮🤮 and returning when he was prepared. TLJ threw that out the window to where Luke just abandoned everyone.
Wouldn’t say it’s selfishness. Luke lost his confidence in himself and eventually his connection to the force. He felt shame over his attempted murder of his nephew. Granted this fanfic is much better as it does makes Luke’s exile more of an ideological battle versus the canon uncharacteristic moment that he had. We see Luke exile himself not because he feels he failed personally and that everything he taught was a failure, it’s more of “maybe the galaxy is better off without me.” In canon he did not stop his nephew from becoming a fascist killer he knew what his nephew would do after their confrontation and instead of telling the truth to his family and friends and trying one more time to talk to Kylo, he left. Here, it’s a battle weary Luke who exiled himself after battling against a..very odd expanded universe character and he has a revelation that shakes him. That empathy/moral flexibility/insightfulness is more present here than the Canon
“What’s wrong father?” -Luke Skywalker “I’ve had dreams…nightmares…about you drinking green milk.” -Anakin Skywalker “You need to lay off the death sticks Anakin.” -Obi-Wan Kenobi
Luke would never make such missteps in the first place. The man that confronted Vader and The Emperor on the Death Star by himself knowing he could possibly die in order to save the galaxy does not fit in with that god awful storyline.
I ain't gonna lie I was kinda caught off guard hearing Hayden's and Ewan's voices cause of so many videos using Matt's and James's voices in videos lol besides that amazing video as always 🤩
the Cycle will continue now till the end of time. but it's the lessons that are left behind that are passed down through the Generations, Revan, Anakin, Obi wan, Ahsoka, Darth Vader, Darth Malak, Darth Marr, Darth Bane, and many more. it's their lessons that the Jedi can grow. achieve true balance between the light and Dark sides of the force. when attachments are formed those must be balanced as well, you can't compromise love for the duty of a Jedi. it doesn't work like that and it will back fire. secrecy and deceit are what destroys a relationship. as it did with Anakin and Padme. but it's those lessons that people, that the jedi and even the Sith can grow from.
man I've been watching all your videos in order, and you are only getting better and better.... thank you for making these, breath of fresh air in the state Star Wars is now, brings me back to a time before disney where I would wonder about theories or googling about the lore and learning
So many Skywalker-related requests... I would love to see the following: - Vader and Thrawn discussing the Art of War. - Vader reviewing Thanoth (voiced by Morgan Freeman) and Gideon (voiced by Giancarlo Esposito) as potential candidates for ISB. - Kanan assuring Ezra that his sacrifice is not a thing to be sad about and going off the deep end over. - Ahsoka meeting Leia Organa for the first time. - Luke having a conversation with BOTH Anakin and Vader - to get their sides of the story.
@@Politebanana1 She was reimprisoned in The Maw but I guess we have to assume the events of Sword Of The Jedi happened which was about Jaina finding Mortis to get the dagger and defeat her for good.
Please do Anakin speaking to Padmé in the afterlife of the Netherworld of the Force, Jacen Solo speaking to Kreia/Darth Traya, Qui-Gon Jinn speaking to Revan (the Keanu version you use), Ben Skywalker speaking to Anakin Solo's Force Ghost, Jacen Solo speaking to Qui-Gon Jinn, Vergere speaking to Kreia/Darth Traya, Jacen Solo speaking to Revan (the Keanu version you use), etcetera.
I like how Anakin is no longer Darth Vader that I remember . because it was nothing but a curse and a nightmare to him. and truthfully, that Sith ego he used to carry is no longer meaning for me.
Bro this is so incredibly well done. Gives us the extra bit of dedication from Luke, and why he made the decision to step away. Absolutely incredible storytelling. ❤
Bro, you gotta listen to me! I have ideas! Do a video of Luke interacting with his son Ben, and another video of Ben interacting with his mom, Mara Jade, then Ben interacting with Anakin. Ben with Qui Gon, Obi-Wan. And Padme, if that could be possible. Or even Han and Leia. Do these videos please
Disney should give up and hire you to write their movies; you have a gift for making short stories that are full of heart, warmth, and hope, and this is, in my opinion, the best one you've made.
Oh man you got “ feel” Luke on this subject he trying his best to find both balance and peace but his father and mentor are right. I like that they trust him to do the right thing now that powerful.
It always gets me that Padme Amidala is Force-Sensitive. I hope she can appear as a spirit of the Force. I would want her to talk with Leia as a way to guide her and help her understand forgiveness. That way, Leia would be ready to forgive her father.
Not possible you just only invite the LORE Breaking rules how’s that justifying Power over principles the world building the character traits background the Force user and Non-force sensitive user. You think while everyone or a certain group individual deserves that which can’t be obtained for a certain means only seems none plausible and easy understood, obtainable plus achievement with success or failure. NO!🫵🙅🙂↔️🛑⚠️⚖️🕳️🩸📜📄📃📈.
There is no reason for Luke to be so insufferably cynical! This is Disney's messed up fanfiction, not true canon! I want to cuss so badly here, but I won't!
That’s gonna change. The book Secrets of the First Order won’t show Luke as being insufferably cynical, but as a concerned father who wants to help his son Orion
@@alexfischer7876 True, but the dialogue in this could be used for the special edition version of the Sequel Trilogy, since the dialogue in this video is so moving but slightly disappointing Ince we see traces of Disney Luke. To be clear, the special edition version represents what George Lucas should have made instead of Disney
“When I was very young, I was foolish enough to believe that our creed could put a end to all this conflicts. If only I possessed the humility to say that myself. I’ve seen enough for one life, I have done my part. Then again there’s no greater glory, than fighting to find the truth.” -Altair Ibn-La’Ahad.
Jedi and Sith are deluding themselves thinking their actions or lack thereof mean all that much in their insignificant galaxy. There are trillions of galaxies in this universe and countless other universes and omniverses.
Legends knew how to create proper nuance between good and evil despite George Lucas’ definition of good and evil. Canon tried but ended up making gae fan fiction with the acolyte
While an improvement (and I appreciate it immensely) over TLJ, the only thing I would change is “Luke’s” name. This is Jake Skywalker, Luke Skywalker’s evil twin.
IMAGINE...if Filoni and crew used this as a perfect context around Luke and Kylo Ren: The battle with Abeloth led to the deaths of Luke's fellow Masters and most of Ben's fellow padewans, so the two of them and the future Knights of Ren are the sole survivors. The desolation leads to conflict between Luke and Ben...eventually leading to the confrontation That Night. And THIS scene leads into Luke's encounter with Rey.
Outside of the Abeloth stuff, a scene like this could have literally saved The Last Jedi. Just a smidge of context as to Luke's mindset as to why he's doing what he's doing. Not just "I fucked up, and I'm giving up and dying alone and forgotten". Even if he's wrong, you can at least understand why HE thinks he's right.
I really love your videos I dont think you are gonna notice this but I request a conversation between Darth Plagueis amd Darth Tenebrous about Tenebrous telling him that he broke Darth banes rule of 2 Or a Coversation between Darth Sion and Darth Kreia before she was killed by Nihilus and Sion
The reasoning here is cowardly at best. *Evil exists,* Those who follow the path of light keep it in check. That is what being a guardian protector or peacekeeper means.
This scene alone is so much better than having Luke, in the mouse canon, break away fully from the galaxy for the most pathetic reason. Trying to kill his nephew Ben, seeing his order fall, and just being a worse hermit than Obi-Wan by the way suffered far, far worse than Luke. Still, the self imposed exile is better explained here.
"Luke...I'm so proud of you for picking a planet without sand."
"Failure isn't the end. It's a step forward, a lesson." Damn good line.
NGL, if The Last Jedi had this scene it would have really helped. That one line of dialogue, "You're not the last jedi because you failed, you're the last because you're meant to be the first of something new" would have been great to hear for Luke's story arc.
“Not the last of the old Jedi, Luke. The first of the new.”
Excerpt From
Heir to the Empire: Star Wars (The Thrawn Trilogy)
Timothy Zahn
Thats exactly what i thought. Nice anyone else got that reference
Yeah i loved the reference
That awkward moment when you are older than your dad
What I appreciate about your channel is that your stories feature elements from both "EU/Legends" & current Canon. Thank you for seeing the good in both and creating engaging content of your own.
Where other students? Corran or kyp?
Way better explanation than what we got in the movies. This is a Luke I can still respect after becoming a hermit.
I can't really say the same in terms of respect, but it is a better take on his self-imposed exile.
He still comes off to me as a broken man wallowing in misery.
@@refurbishedtechpriest9076
Of course he would be wallowing.
The galactic-wide Yuuzhan Vong scuffle certainly had something to do with it...
at least the people who wrote the movies were human, and not ChatGPT
@@SoTeeko If this script was written by chatgpt, then it's really sad because a mid A.I. did a better job than actual writers.
"Ben, you look... younger."
"Oh right, I am here as not an old man this time."
why not just become ones prime again when they are a force ghost amiright?
@@RikouHogashihis prime is a new Hope
I genuinely love how these stories use so much of the Legends material while taking the few good things from the current canon and combine it into something excellent.
Why can't Disney see that THIS is what they should've done?
'Cause they don't UNDERSTAND.
These videos are absolutely phenomenal the writing in your short videos... Totally beats anything we have seen
This did exactly what TLJ should’ve. Luke’s exile as an act of sacrifice rather than selfishness from a bitter old man.
I was hoping that it was gonna be Luke left to learn about what was before th jedi and how that is what is truly needed. Realizing when Rey comes how much he missed and what has happened cuz he left and having to make up for it. If they wanted to go down this Luke messed up plot.
It was sacrifice. Did you see Episode VIII?
@@DontrelleRoosevelt No it wasn't. TLJ clearly shows Luke exiling himself because he felt like he failed Ben when he thought of killing him. The real Luke would never do that. He wouldn't think of killing his family, and he wouldn't abandon the universe. They set up for the real Luke in TFA, where Han said that Luke went out in search of the first Jedi Temple to seek knowledge. It set up Luke preparing to take on the First Order 🤮🤮🤮 and returning when he was prepared. TLJ threw that out the window to where Luke just abandoned everyone.
Wouldn’t say it’s selfishness. Luke lost his confidence in himself and eventually his connection to the force. He felt shame over his attempted murder of his nephew. Granted this fanfic is much better as it does makes Luke’s exile more of an ideological battle versus the canon uncharacteristic moment that he had.
We see Luke exile himself not because he feels he failed personally and that everything he taught was a failure, it’s more of “maybe the galaxy is better off without me.” In canon he did not stop his nephew from becoming a fascist killer he knew what his nephew would do after their confrontation and instead of telling the truth to his family and friends and trying one more time to talk to Kylo, he left.
Here, it’s a battle weary Luke who exiled himself after battling against a..very odd expanded universe character and he has a revelation that shakes him. That empathy/moral flexibility/insightfulness is more present here than the Canon
I love that Anakin and Obiwan are trying to help Luke with how to resolve this endless conflict of the darkness that follows the light.
“What’s wrong father?” -Luke Skywalker
“I’ve had dreams…nightmares…about you drinking green milk.” -Anakin Skywalker
“You need to lay off the death sticks Anakin.” -Obi-Wan Kenobi
Luke: "Strange, I had a similar nightmare. That's what happens when you drink too much Corellian Ale when celebrating the end of the Empire."
@@coruscant100
*Anakin:* That's what probably certain Kennedy did.
*Obi-Wan:* Stop being meta, Anakin!
this conversation is ,in a way, obi wan and anakin trying to prevent luke from making last jedi happen.
If only.
They are way past _The Last Jedi._
Chronologically, Abeloth happened later than that.
This comment means so much to me! 😇😇😇
I concur.
Luke would never make such missteps in the first place. The man that confronted Vader and The Emperor on the Death Star by himself knowing he could possibly die in order to save the galaxy does not fit in with that god awful storyline.
Adding legends with the sequel trilogy makes it a true sequel trilogy.
And regardless the sequels still suck
@@Shane-fd5es That's because Legends was missing in that regard!
Watch and learn, Ruin Johnson.
And Jar Jar Abrams, for that matter.
@@alexfischer7876don’t insult Jar Jar like that lol
@@mvos858
Like he insulted every property he touched with his movies?
@@alexfischer7876He’s saying don’t insult Jar Jar Binks by using his name for JJ.
I ain't gonna lie I was kinda caught off guard hearing Hayden's and Ewan's voices cause of so many videos using Matt's and James's voices in videos lol besides that amazing video as always 🤩
The voices here are so good. It’s absolutely insane
The cycle NEVER ends. With or without the Jedi or sith
the Cycle will continue now till the end of time. but it's the lessons that are left behind that are passed down through the Generations, Revan, Anakin, Obi wan, Ahsoka, Darth Vader, Darth Malak, Darth Marr, Darth Bane, and many more. it's their lessons that the Jedi can grow. achieve true balance between the light and Dark sides of the force. when attachments are formed those must be balanced as well, you can't compromise love for the duty of a Jedi. it doesn't work like that and it will back fire. secrecy and deceit are what destroys a relationship. as it did with Anakin and Padme. but it's those lessons that people, that the jedi and even the Sith can grow from.
man I've been watching all your videos in order, and you are only getting better and better.... thank you for making these, breath of fresh air in the state Star Wars is now, brings me back to a time before disney where I would wonder about theories or googling about the lore and learning
Faulty thinking. Where there is no light darkness reigns naturally. Legends Luke would know this. His walking away can never make sense.
I hope you can add a video with Luke Skywalker, Mara Jade Skywalker, and Ben Skywalker.
So many Skywalker-related requests... I would love to see the following:
- Vader and Thrawn discussing the Art of War.
- Vader reviewing Thanoth (voiced by Morgan Freeman) and Gideon (voiced by Giancarlo Esposito) as potential candidates for ISB.
- Kanan assuring Ezra that his sacrifice is not a thing to be sad about and going off the deep end over.
- Ahsoka meeting Leia Organa for the first time.
- Luke having a conversation with BOTH Anakin and Vader - to get their sides of the story.
This clip alone is better than The Last Jedi itself.
This head canon is way way way better than the sequels ! nice videos
How about Yoda talks to Revan? Or perhaps Qimir talks with Darth Malgus? Or something different, the bouncer Laa talks with Darth Zannah.
This might be the best tales of the galaxy thing you’ve ever made. This reflects everything about Star Wars in a whole in a 5 minute period
You have 5 minute videos and they are better than anything Disney created
It's been noted hundreds of times. You're not the first one to express such praise.
@ so many talented people not in mainstream it’s sad
I love the amount of dedication and love for star wars put in to these videos😊
These vids have been quite healing to see different lores explored with accurate voices. Thank you
Great video Skywalker Stories. Much better explained than TLJ.
Abeloth was never destroyed or killed completely!.
yes
@@Politebanana1 She was reimprisoned in The Maw but I guess we have to assume the events of Sword Of The Jedi happened which was about Jaina finding Mortis to get the dagger and defeat her for good.
another brilliant scene may the force be with you and I'm waiting patiently for the next scenes
It's funny how having respect subtlety changes the tone. So much of the ST could have worked if there was respect and understanding.
Please do Anakin speaking to Padmé in the afterlife of the Netherworld of the Force, Jacen Solo speaking to Kreia/Darth Traya, Qui-Gon Jinn speaking to Revan (the Keanu version you use), Ben Skywalker speaking to Anakin Solo's Force Ghost, Jacen Solo speaking to Qui-Gon Jinn, Vergere speaking to Kreia/Darth Traya, Jacen Solo speaking to Revan (the Keanu version you use), etcetera.
I like how Anakin is no longer Darth Vader that I remember . because it was nothing but a curse and a nightmare to him. and truthfully, that Sith ego he used to carry is no longer meaning for me.
Bro this is so incredibly well done. Gives us the extra bit of dedication from Luke, and why he made the decision to step away. Absolutely incredible storytelling. ❤
Bro, you gotta listen to me! I have ideas! Do a video of Luke interacting with his son Ben, and another video of Ben interacting with his mom, Mara Jade, then Ben interacting with Anakin. Ben with Qui Gon, Obi-Wan. And Padme, if that could be possible. Or even Han and Leia. Do these videos please
This was awesome!!
Would love to see luke and kratos have a nice calm chat, or revan and Kratos having a chat
That was really good!
I love these videos!
I always felt like Anakin and Obi-Wan’s ghosts should’ve appeared to Luke in TLJ instead of Yoda.
Is it possible to do Obi-wan with Sir Alec Guinness? Or is it impossible to get samples?
Stephen Stanton's voice work from _Rebels_ might be the likeliest opportunity.
The best thing about your great videos is how they add context and deeper meaning to parts of the actual movies!
This is kinda how I pictured it would end after TFA.
You’re making real Star Wars
Okay... THIS explains things and adds continuity with the EU. It both makes something new yet acknowledges what came before.
I'd love to see Luke commune with the gods of Mortis.
That's just Anakin now though right?
Disney should give up and hire you to write their movies; you have a gift for making short stories that are full of heart, warmth, and hope, and this is, in my opinion, the best one you've made.
Oh man you got “ feel” Luke on this subject he trying his best to find both balance and peace but his father and mentor are right. I like that they trust him to do the right thing now that powerful.
Greatest missed opportunity is not having Ewan and Hayden as force ghosts speaking to Mark.
It always gets me that Padme Amidala is Force-Sensitive. I hope she can appear as a spirit of the Force. I would want her to talk with Leia as a way to guide her and help her understand forgiveness. That way, Leia would be ready to forgive her father.
Not possible you just only invite the LORE Breaking rules how’s that justifying Power over principles the world building the character traits background the Force user and Non-force sensitive user. You think while everyone or a certain group individual deserves that which can’t be obtained for a certain means only seems none plausible and easy understood, obtainable plus achievement with success or failure. NO!🫵🙅🙂↔️🛑⚠️⚖️🕳️🩸📜📄📃📈.
5 minutes later Mara Jade shows up and gets Luke off his ass and back to being the true Jedi she fell in love with.
She can't cause she dead. Jacen killed her.
There is no reason for Luke to be so insufferably cynical! This is Disney's messed up fanfiction, not true canon! I want to cuss so badly here, but I won't!
That’s gonna change. The book Secrets of the First Order won’t show Luke as being insufferably cynical, but as a concerned father who wants to help his son Orion
@@Wildboyz6913
But this ain't First Order.
We are approaching the Sith Empire led by Darth Krayt.
@@alexfischer7876 True, but the dialogue in this could be used for the special edition version of the Sequel Trilogy, since the dialogue in this video is so moving but slightly disappointing Ince we see traces of Disney Luke. To be clear, the special edition version represents what George Lucas should have made instead of Disney
Dude you should totally do a Ewan McGregor version of Obi Wan's holocron message from Rebels.
I love these videos keep going
The last of something to be the first of something new... I LIKE IT!
💯💯
I wish they would do Anakin as Sebastián Shaw.
Oh I hope to see Abeloth in your take so as the Vongs.
Yuuzhan Vongs... of course.
Supreme Overlord negotiating with Jedi.
“You are the last because you are meant to be the first of something new”
🔥
WHY COULDNT DISNEY STAR WARS DO THIS???? All the actors are STILL Alive!!?!?! 🤦🏽♂️ I can’t take their foolishness anymore.
Somebody get this person a job at Disney/LucasFilms!!!!!!!
Excellent
No doubt this happened in that Prologue novel set before Ep 7.
These videos would be so much better if it wasn’t made with AI, the script is ok but the art is just devoid of life
“When I was very young, I was foolish enough to believe that our creed could put a end to all this conflicts. If only I possessed the humility to say that myself. I’ve seen enough for one life, I have done my part. Then again there’s no greater glory, than fighting to find the truth.” -Altair Ibn-La’Ahad.
Were do you actually get all the voices from?
Just do an animated series for Luke, with GOOD writing.
I like how the line "Failure isn't the end" is the same one from Fallen Order.
Jedi and Sith are deluding themselves thinking their actions or lack thereof mean all that much in their insignificant galaxy. There are trillions of galaxies in this universe and countless other universes and omniverses.
If they added a canon scene like this, it might put the last Jedi in a better light(at least for me)
I would love to see someone make a video with Luke obi wan and anakin fight alongside each other
Legends knew how to create proper nuance between good and evil despite George Lucas’ definition of good and evil. Canon tried but ended up making gae fan fiction with the acolyte
While an improvement (and I appreciate it immensely) over TLJ, the only thing I would change is “Luke’s” name. This is Jake Skywalker, Luke Skywalker’s evil twin.
Luke Teatmilker... like Epic Voice Guy once said.
Better than Disney!!!!!!
I love these videos
It is great to see MASTER Anakin Skywalker.
Starting to think what Revan and Kreia is true about the force.
Even A I made something better than Rian Johnson
I like how they casually mention Abeloth. No exposition because like the wiever they all know the story.
IMAGINE...if Filoni and crew used this as a perfect context around Luke and Kylo Ren: The battle with Abeloth led to the deaths of Luke's fellow Masters and most of Ben's fellow padewans, so the two of them and the future Knights of Ren are the sole survivors. The desolation leads to conflict between Luke and Ben...eventually leading to the confrontation That Night. And THIS scene leads into Luke's encounter with Rey.
Disney messed up Luke and Lucas vision, I don't consider it canon
Yup. this never happened.
This is literally such a great idea perhaps the Mando verse can incorporate some of this to make the last jedi better
In a way you feel bad for Luke and you understand his pain and suffering
Outside of the Abeloth stuff, a scene like this could have literally saved The Last Jedi. Just a smidge of context as to Luke's mindset as to why he's doing what he's doing. Not just "I fucked up, and I'm giving up and dying alone and forgotten". Even if he's wrong, you can at least understand why HE thinks he's right.
Seems like a more important scene than showing us where Luke gets his calcium from.😂
evil is always around and unchecked makes people pay the price .. not everyone can be a coward on a remote plant
Is this like if the Disney movies were canon and took place after the novels?
So I'm confused. Is this Luke from the sequel trilogy, or the EU?
It's an attempt to make Jake Skywalker more palatable. it's the crap sequels.
Why Star Wars Is Dead 💀 to Me
Sad
I do enjoy your stories though 🥃🔥
EU > Canon. This never happened.
@ Doesn’t Matter
Or even the light sided Wrath of the emperor (SWTOR) having a chat with luke
I really love your videos I dont think you are gonna notice this but I request a conversation between Darth Plagueis amd Darth Tenebrous about Tenebrous telling him that he broke Darth banes rule of 2
Or a Coversation between Darth Sion and Darth Kreia before she was killed by Nihilus and Sion
How was this better than the entire sequel trilogy? Instead of trying to tear down a beloved character give him a real reason for staying away.
Obi wan looks like he’s stood on slightly higher ground
I feel like this takes place just before the Force Awakens
The Farce Awoken🛑🙂↔️🙅🤢🤮🤕🤡👻💩👽🤕.
Очень приятно наблюдать за тем, как один талантливый парень старается исправить то, что сделал дисней.
Да прибудет с тобой сила, друг 👍🌠🌌
The reasoning here is cowardly at best. *Evil exists,* Those who follow the path of light keep it in check.
That is what being a guardian protector or peacekeeper means.
This scene alone is so much better than having Luke, in the mouse canon, break away fully from the galaxy for the most pathetic reason.
Trying to kill his nephew Ben, seeing his order fall, and just being a worse hermit than Obi-Wan by the way suffered far, far worse than Luke. Still, the self imposed exile is better explained here.
Watch them put something like this in the Dave Filoni movie to try and fix Lukes character.
If this was included in TLJ instead of Yoda or with, the film would of made much more sense.
Need a vid with MARA JADE & JACEN SOLO & LUKE!