Céline did better imo. The voice and stage presence is still there. Also the 2019 Aretha Franklin tribute isn't icluded which is basically a showcase how good Céline still is. It's one of her best performances imo.
i love mariah's voice more(this is personal) but here celine really maintain her vocal condition... omgs, cant believe these 2 vocalists have been in the industry and singing way longer than my age.
I watch them both performed live on the Philippines last year, and all I can say is....... they can still outshine new singers of this generation!! I wonder if they have a collaboration, but I know that they are both busy on their tours... Overall, QUEENS!!
Their mids were tie up to c#5 Celine was kinda a little bit better here especially around D5 to Eb5. While Mariah started to has a little issue on her D5.
@@tedypermana9552 the Fact is Mariah Have Nodul from her begining Career. And Nodul is something that can make your throat smaller and cant control your voice. This is absolutely Singers Nightmares rather than sinus. Example Julie Andrews have that and she cant be able to sing anymore (poor her)
@@danielerlanggasantiagosila7170 the fact celine singing more offten than mariah ..she singing profesionaly at 12 years old she making her first album at that age and she is singing everynight in las vegas ..and u know what celine have problem to ..the problem is SINUS
@@tedypermana9552 Lmao its not all about how much she sing, its about the cronic condition, Sinus is not that big problem compare to vocal nodules which can make someone not able to sing again (Julie Andrews) And the Fact Mariah song is 10000x harder than Celine Song. You can't deny it lmao. Alot Musican have said that. And Celine song?? My Nephew can sing her song with original notes
Im a lamb but I love how Celine seems unaffected and fearless in hitting notes. She seems consistent and assured. Mariah is too conscious and holds off. Mariah’s voice has so much weight while Celine’s voice is light.
Having nodules since the beginning of your career and have the most difficult discography ever and still able to sing those songs (even in lower key which still hard for us to sing) and sounds so amazing and agile 💖💖 Go Mariah
@@latinadavis3691 And at least she's breathing and can still sing her song. Unlike other artists who only depends from their songwriters, using unknown voice to their song, was over used of drugs and more.
@@Patrick-gq1mv I don't really like putting other artists down because they are all only human beings. Drinking isn't any better than drugging, but Mariah will always be talented!
I grew up with Celine, so it's hard to overcome that bias. Is it fair to say she's more textured than singers like Mariah Carey and Lara Fabian? The latter two seem to be more clear, but Celine is more distinct with a little grit.
Celine Dion is BETTER!!!!... she WINS!!!... for her Great Support, Tecnichs, Resonance and Agilities!!!!.... She PERFECT with Control and Discipline!!!! She COMPLETLY!!!!! TRUTH.....
Two living legends!! Still after all these years, better than most of the singers today!!! Celine has preserved her voice and is better today, but both slay!!!
@Beyonce & Celine & Jennifer Fan Look I know you don't like Mariah(Most Celitics don't) and you prefer Celine but don't deny she can't sing because she can. Mariah can still sing but I will say this she hasn't hit a belted G5 and above live since the 90s. And she doesn't sing like she used to but she isn't assured with her voice. I will say this Celine realizes her voice has changed as she's gotten older and her voice has matured but she is very confident and assured in herself that even if she goes flat or sharp she goes for it anyway. Mariah is not as confident or assured in her voice anymore and she holds back vocally. Also Mariah's voice didn't really have major changes until 2005. Look everyone knows Celine's voice has aged better than the rest of the vocal trinity but don't say she can't sing because she still can. Just not like she used to. Also I'm a huge Celine fan and Mariah fan, so I'm not biased.
Equally good on low notes. (But Mariah had clearer vocals and better support) In the G4-C5 belts I liked both, but Céline showed better support. In notes above C5 Céline was better, with clearer and more consistent vocals. (I like Mariah too). Head Voice also preferred Céline, Mariah was never good at this record, however she is the best at falsetto and Whistle register.
the middle belts for me G4 up to B4 maria is more in the tone of her tone of voice which is darker .for C5 / D5 celine enters the range of her natural voice .. she is the queen of C5 ... without any problem ^^
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 Although Mariah has nodules, the alcohol that she consumes really doesn'g help out, if she quits completely then she'll sound like 2010riah again, maybe even 2008riah
@@instasingingvids3529 She drinks wine but yeah, it's still not good for the voice, she also does back to back shows but as of recently she's been slowing it down(which has allowed her to sound INCREDIBLE)
@@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679 Nope mariah in her prime strain so much above C5. th-cam.com/video/tltw9KPWKVE/w-d-xo.html at 3:33 Mariah cannot support C#5 climaxes with her diaphragm in make it happen undubbed live at MTV during 1992 which is during mariah's prime. th-cam.com/video/fUi7GGeZDz0/w-d-xo.html at 3:01 and 3:33 Mariah strains D5 climaxes in dreamlover live at Paris during 1996 daydream tour. Daydream tour is so overrated! th-cam.com/video/4pQ2Qt0z0Dk/w-d-xo.html at 2:40 Mariah strains Eb5 climax live at David Letterman during 1994 anytime you need a friend. Also her debut era she mostly strains anything above E5 belt.
Celine's voice has always been superior to mariah and whitney even in their prime . If you are a fan of the three you know that . Whitney's voice was melismatic and powerful .. mariah's voice was not powerful but its magical and full of melisma too . Celine has the highest upper voice range among the three and her voice was both powerful and angelic . But she was just the last to come out before mariah and whitney . The two was already known and famous before her so they got more recognition from the people back in the day . But celine proved worthy to be a legendary vocal powerhouse and people has recognized her for her amazing vocals and live performances . She sold millions of albums and won so many awards just like mariah and whitney . I love all three of them but celine is the best for me .
KingofMeereen celine's career back in the 80's was revolving only in canada . Most of her songs back then are only french . She studied englsh and polished her communication skills in 1989 . Then she released unison which debuted two years after . Her real international breakthrough was in 1991 when she sang beauty and the beast with peabo . In 1990 mariah already debuted in her first album 'mariah carey' . She started recording it 1988 which means she was already in the hollywood back in the late 80's even before celine started her career in the us . This is as far as I remember .. I maybe wrong idk .
destined tobe both Whitney and Celine already had fanbases. And Mariah’s songs were mostly written from when she was a teenager, and had demos for some of em. When she rerecorded and polished for her debut, she worked with Hollywood people, yes, but she didn’t have fans until she actually put herself out there. Out of the three, she’s the newest artist.
the middle belts for me G4 up to B4 maria is more in the tone of her tone of voice which is darker .for C5 / D5 celine enters the range of her natural voice .. she is the queen of C5 ... without any problem ^^
@@Jomari1998 it's about sounding good live. Céline can sustain a powerful g#5 belt live. Mariah has troubles sustaining a c#5 live. Besides Céline has tons of resonance. Mariah lipsyncs most of her climax, she has never sung live WBT, the Hero sustained b4, Without You etc etc live in years. Céline can sing any of her songs live even after a throat infection. Céline is much more professional and consistent than Mariah, hands down. If Mariah sang always live and had the guts to do all her high belts live, that would be a different story.
I am here to hear Celine's struggling from SPS... How her viice changed .. i am so excited to her recovering from sps and hear her singing with her well rested voice❤️❤️
Only for me Mariah-Song bird supreme (by her vocal agility) Whitney Houston-Song bird Phoenix (by her vocal tone) Celine Dion -Song bird nightingale (by her vocal colour)
Both can no longer sustain well😂😂😂 but ill go with more distinct. Mariah wins in lows celine in mid and upper belts but mariah can outshine celine in falsetto. I think tie in most aspect but as i said mariahs voice is more distinct
@Adam Buentello Well yea it does But nodules affect singing derectly because they appear in the vocal folds wich is the parte used to sing and as timé passes they get harder so it becomes harder to sing over timé its a miracle shes can still sing at nearly 50
Lawrence Paz I don’t think he’s pissed with your answer. He’s just saying some parts for that certain notes lacks on mariah’s recent performances. That’s why it shorter.
I do love both of them. To be fair, Celine has preserved her voice better. Her image too is a symbol of strength and courage. Mariah has had obvious downfalls ( career and marriage life) but she remains one of the biggest divas overall. She is still creative and fierce. In terms of live performances, I go for Celine. Hits and songwriting, Mariah is irreplaceable. Concert ticket sales, Celine is still raking in and winning. Stage presence and connection with the audience, Celine. More meaningful songs, Mariah.
Celine has lost some of her gorgeous tone and sounds quite nasally. And Mariah has lost some ease with her belts honestly above C#5. You can tell Celine practices and cherished her talent. I can’t imagine if Mariah had celines discipline with her voice. Imagine no alcohol and singing lessons for Mariah. Mariah literally has her daydream tone pop out every now and then. Both queens reguardless. I say Mariah wins for overall for “musicality”. Her tone is still very pleasant for many genres. Celine is a ballad queen nowadays.
I usually don't listen to recent Celine performances. I haven't realized her voice stills being powerful, she stills holding notes like a pro and thats what amazes me the most. I don't think myself of a fan of her but I respect her as the legend she IS. Mariah, well, Mariah is simply my love, my favorite overall and even with her vocal struggles and damage, I'll follow her, I'm not saying she lost her voice, but I think it is a fact she can't sing as good as she used to, only when she rests up her voice, she sings like she really has to. I really aprecciate the fact that you actually didn't make a competition video between these legends (Cause tbh I think Celine could easily win this), it was more a vocal showcase for me. Great video, I just wanna see a collab between them, imagine how amazing it would be having the Whitney - Mariah collab and then the Mariah - Celine collab before one of them leaves us 😥
Read the comments and some Mariah fans are bitter here haha even bringing up lipped videos made by mariah fan haha (why not make one for you idol lol) anyways, For you to be happy Céline doesn’t have a Whistle note. At least there’s one thing Céline can’t do until now. The whistlenote. LOL 😂
Mariah for the Low Notes, Mariah For the Midbelts. Celine obviously has better upper belts since she always has the better vocal condition. Mariah could still hit 6th to 7th octave notes though
Mariah y Céline, solo falta Whitney para tener la Trinidad Vocal completa. Una lastima que ya no este Whitney. Pero Mariah y Céline si estan y sus voces siguen siendo mucho mejor que la de artistas actuales de 25 años.
Lows : Mimi Belt G4: Mimi G#4: Mimi A4: tie A4: mimi Bb4: tie Bb4: tie B4: Celine B4: mariah C5: tie C5: Mariah C5: tie C#5: Mariah C#5: Celine D5: Celine D5: Mariah Eb5: tie Eb5: Celine E5: mimi F5: Celine G5: tie Head voice : both good Did count g#5 since mimi doesn’t have one…and if it count them should put whistle…even tho Celine doesn’t have them
-Lows I would say if it's not a tie it's all to Celine. She just sound better. -Middle belts Celine without a doubt. Mariah's good up to B4 and even not that good. -Upper belts (Eb5+) Celine obviously -Head Voice: Celine again. She's always had a good head voice so
I have a video suggestion, and I didn’t know where else to put it...😅 Anyway, can you do a compilation of the high note in Love Can Move Mountains? The A5 I think it was, after the lyrics: “If we got love, that is strong enough, you gotta feel it right here, right here, right there”. I’d LOVE to see that
Céline RO it was awhile ago that there was some issues from posting the vids, not sure of it was copyright or demonetization, but they had to redo the channel and they posted on a TH-cam discussion what vids we wanted them to keep
Celine has somewhat lost her resonance, and Mariah her longevity in belting higher notes. But both are legends in their own right with nothing left to prove because they, even in their great age, can still outsing the "best" of this new generation.
She is not losing her resonant, but 2019 was not really her best year for her voice but in her asian tour 2018, her resonant is very clear. How can Mariah is a good high belter, while her voice above D5 is throaty?
When I said Celine SOMEWHAT lost her resonance, it was comparing her to her younger self. I did not say she COMPLETELY lost it. As for Mariah, I DID NOT say she was better at higher belts. I just said that she had lost her ability to sing high notes longer. They had both aged and sang night after night for decades, their voices are not bound to stay as they used to and I just pointed out what I noticed has changed. I NEVER said one was bad, or one was better than the other.
Kwensil Basaiawmoit, of course we can compare, regardless of age. We can compare them to both Ariana and Barbra. Age doesn’t mean you can’t compare. Especially when Céline would slay all of them regardless of age (I know I’m biased but it’s true).
@@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679 Nope mariah in her prime strain so much above C5. Mariah's prime is extremely overrated but I won't deny how unique mariah is as a vocalist. th-cam.com/video/tltw9KPWKVE/w-d-xo.html at 3:33 Mariah cannot support C#5 climaxes with her diaphragm in make it happen undubbed live at MTV during 1992 which is during mariah's prime. th-cam.com/video/fUi7GGeZDz0/w-d-xo.html at 3:01 and 3:33 Mariah strains D5 climaxes in dreamlover live at Paris during 1996 daydream tour. Daydream tour is so overrated! th-cam.com/video/4pQ2Qt0z0Dk/w-d-xo.html at 2:40 Mariah strains Eb5 climax live at David Letterman during 1994 anytime you need a friend. Also her debut era she mostly strains anything above E5 belt.
I'm gonna pretend like "Celine Dion and Mariah Carey recent vocals slayage" is the real title.
Céline did better imo. The voice and stage presence is still there. Also the 2019 Aretha Franklin tribute isn't icluded which is basically a showcase how good Céline still is. It's one of her best performances imo.
Céline Dion's low note here is just amazing.
This is how Mariah warms up for Christmas. She stopped touring and then this. Watch out for her next shows. :D
Ikr, as She should! That Voice needs to Rest and fully recover man, for her and the worlds sake 🙌🏽
The residency shows are much tiring. If she can do what Céline did back 2003-2007 5 nights a week performing at the desert for 5 years.
i love mariah's voice more(this is personal) but here celine really maintain her vocal condition... omgs, cant believe these 2 vocalists have been in the industry and singing way longer than my age.
I watch them both performed live on the Philippines last year, and all I can say is....... they can still outshine new singers of this generation!!
I wonder if they have a collaboration, but I know that they are both busy on their tours...
Overall, QUEENS!!
I would love to hear them make a performance together.
LUUCCKKYYY
Not Ariana
Both ladies have been through alot and their still going! 😊
I agree
I wish Whitney fought through her struggles
4:11
4:39
Their voices traveled to 90's
I caught that too
Mariah wins lows and mids. Where as Celine takes the upper belts. Still two of the greatest vocalist of all time
nope
Support: Mariah > Celine
@@black3lvis94 Celine wins...don't cry.duh
They both tie in mid belt
Their mids were tie up to c#5 Celine was kinda a little bit better here especially around D5 to Eb5.
While Mariah started to has a little issue on her D5.
The fact that Mariah can go until G5 with her ''damaged voice'' means she's still slaying them with nodules. Hahahahha
Celine have sinus and troath virus ,and she can hit G5
of course with her whistles but i still want to hear that in her current vocals :)
But no G#5?
@@tedypermana9552 the Fact is Mariah Have Nodul from her begining Career. And Nodul is something that can make your throat smaller and cant control your voice.
This is absolutely Singers Nightmares rather than sinus.
Example Julie Andrews have that and she cant be able to sing anymore (poor her)
@@danielerlanggasantiagosila7170 the fact celine singing more offten than mariah ..she singing profesionaly at 12 years old she making her first album at that age and she is singing everynight in las vegas ..and u know what celine have problem to ..the problem is SINUS
@@tedypermana9552 Lmao its not all about how much she sing, its about the cronic condition, Sinus is not that big problem compare to vocal nodules which can make someone not able to sing again (Julie Andrews)
And the Fact Mariah song is 10000x harder than Celine Song. You can't deny it lmao.
Alot Musican have said that.
And Celine song?? My Nephew can sing her song with original notes
A lot has changed, I'm just glad both of them are still here and still slaying ❤
0:08: Low Notes (C3-G3)
1:13: Belting Range (G4-G#5)
5:35: Falsetto/Head Voice (E5-A5)
My Opinion
LOWS: Mariah
Mid Belts: Celine
High Belts: Celine
Head Voice/Falsetto: Céline
Agreed.
@@bakbakhemu Disagree just in mids, Mariah been slaying hard - doesn't mean Celine isn't, too
Amen to the fact that we still have these 2 Ladies singing in 2019. Celine & Mariah are vocal Beasts.
celine dion for me. I love her stage presense on stage, especially her those movements when hitting high notes.
To be honest I am so obsessed with both of their stage presences
Walang wala si reginang luka 😂 laos na sarado ng abias cbn 😂 samantalang si Mariah nag #1 sa Billboard Hot 100 ngayon 2020 net worth 525 Million USD
The Fact is Celine Dion is still Great until now
@@theemancipationofmimiera8745 wtf hindi naman billboard conparison san ka galing?
3:53 that’s one of the best times she’s ever hit that note in that song imo
YES! And the crazy thing about it is that it was the day she lost her voice at the beginning of the show haha
come on guys, that's not live!! And i love celine, but BE HONEST!!
@@alessandroiannonemusic Yes, it is live. You can tell it just before the high note that she went out of tune.
Imagine being soooo good your get accused of lip singing al the time. (Read in another video) 😜
@@alessandroiannonemusic 🤡
Omg Céline still killing it. Such a Queen! Power and range
I like Céline's G5 in 5:13
Im a lamb but I love how Celine seems unaffected and fearless in hitting notes. She seems consistent and assured. Mariah is too conscious and holds off. Mariah’s voice has so much weight while Celine’s voice is light.
Having nodules since the beginning of your career and have the most difficult discography ever and still able to sing those songs (even in lower key which still hard for us to sing) and sounds so amazing and agile 💖💖 Go Mariah
She drank a lot and got sick mentally, she's a trooper!
@@latinadavis3691 And at least she's breathing and can still sing her song. Unlike other artists who only depends from their songwriters, using unknown voice to their song, was over used of drugs and more.
@@Patrick-gq1mv I don't really like putting other artists down because they are all only human beings. Drinking isn't any better than drugging, but Mariah will always be talented!
Whatever they say...Celine Dion is a Legend
@@steverythingalmonds4908 he is only complimenting Mariah... Why you are so pressed about It?
I grew up with Celine, so it's hard to overcome that bias. Is it fair to say she's more textured than singers like Mariah Carey and Lara Fabian? The latter two seem to be more clear, but Celine is more distinct with a little grit.
Their Voces are tired!!! But Celine is more preserved !!!
Nodules are not a chronic condition.
@@queenofvegas8761 yes she does
Kemuel Valdes it is when you haven’t had surgery to get them removed due to the fact that you might loose sum of your range.
Queen Of Vegas i was thinking, what if She rested for long enough, wouldn’t the nodules heal? In combination with a better lifestyle
Pepe Andate she did but got rid of them
Celine Dion is BETTER!!!!... she WINS!!!... for her Great Support, Tecnichs, Resonance and Agilities!!!!.... She PERFECT with Control and Discipline!!!! She COMPLETLY!!!!! TRUTH.....
I mean Mariah had better support if her belts up until C5 but I guess overall you could say Celine wins but personal preference.
Two living legends!! Still after all these years, better than most of the singers today!!! Celine has preserved her voice and is better today, but both slay!!!
You can also make a battle in recent ‘months’.You know what i mean.Celine performed perfectly in London
Celine does better
Mariah is great but Céline is my queen and she will always be my queen ❤️🔥
Thanks for the video!!! I choose to not say who did better lol because it’s really just taste lmao, they’re both incredible legends
For me Celine dion is the best singer of all time no body can beat her i love you celine
Low: Mariah
Mid belting: tie
upper belting: Celine
Head Voice: Mariah
Whistle: Mariah Carey
LOWS -- Mariah
Mid Belts -- Tie
High Belts -- Celine
Head Voice and Falsetto -- Celine
@@pascalpetit403 Sorry but this gear Mariah do a D6 em Head Voice so...
@Adam Buentello but Mariah has more facility
Head voice definitely céline.
@@rosimeireramos8255 celine has more control in head voice
Celine Dion hands down !!!
5:28 should end this debate!
Mariah can do it idiot
@Beyonce & Celine & Jennifer Fan she definetly can still hit whistles do some research before hating.
@Beyonce & Celine & Jennifer Fan I'll take a screenshot of this and answer this to the delusional lambs.
@Beyonce & Celine & Jennifer Fan Look I know you don't like Mariah(Most Celitics don't) and you prefer Celine but don't deny she can't sing because she can. Mariah can still sing but I will say this she hasn't hit a belted G5 and above live since the 90s. And she doesn't sing like she used to but she isn't assured with her voice. I will say this Celine realizes her voice has changed as she's gotten older and her voice has matured but she is very confident and assured in herself that even if she goes flat or sharp she goes for it anyway. Mariah is not as confident or assured in her voice anymore and she holds back vocally. Also Mariah's voice didn't really have major changes until 2005. Look everyone knows Celine's voice has aged better than the rest of the vocal trinity but don't say she can't sing because she still can. Just not like she used to. Also I'm a huge Celine fan and Mariah fan, so I'm not biased.
Celine voice is more health and her tecnique is better, Mariah voice is unique and more passionate but very damaged... I love both.
Mariah Carey wins for me, the technique is better, she supported more than Celine now.
I love Celine I love Mariah... two legends
WINNER : CELINE DION 👑
NO DOUBT. AS ALWAYS. ❤️❤️❤️
Equally good on low notes. (But Mariah had clearer vocals and better support)
In the G4-C5 belts I liked both, but Céline showed better support.
In notes above C5 Céline was better, with clearer and more consistent vocals. (I like Mariah too).
Head Voice also preferred Céline, Mariah was never good at this record, however she is the best at falsetto and Whistle register.
the middle belts
for me G4 up to B4 maria is more in the tone of her tone of voice which is darker
.for C5 / D5 celine enters the range of her natural voice .. she is the queen of C5 ... without any problem ^^
Celine has done supported D3
Am still counting days for Celine Dion & Mariah Carey - *song title* , instead of Celine Dion vs Mariah Carey.
Celine’s energy tho 😭🔥💖
Oh my God...the high notes of Celine Dion
CELINÉ ALLLLL THE WAY!!!
Two queens sharing the title as the Vocal Goddesses!!!
Celine Dion still sing hight note perfect
I think Celine has looked after her voice much better than Mariah....even with age she can maintain the higher notes with ease and clearness.
Mariah have nodules is clear, bit her tone still better my God dont say that
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 Although Mariah has nodules, the alcohol that she consumes really doesn'g help out, if she quits completely then she'll sound like 2010riah again, maybe even 2008riah
ᐯ丨乃乇 she doesn’t drink as much as 2015 her voice isn’t as dry
@@instasingingvids3529 She drinks wine but yeah, it's still not good for the voice, she also does back to back shows but as of recently she's been slowing it down(which has allowed her to sound INCREDIBLE)
Mariah can still hit and sustain notes in the 6th octave though. Even notes in the 7th octave
Great video! Two legends, but Celine is the better one, she has kept her voice.
Hahahaha is true lipsync Celine
Leandro Wiliam she lip syncs to preserve her voice
@@ethanlonchar smilessssss, ok!
Lmaoooo have severalseats
Lmao that doesnt make her better on that principle . Mariah has nodules doesn't mean she is any less
Celine Dion preserved her voice more than Mariah Carey
Mariah in her prime vocally destroys her and Mariah has nodules,Celine has not,if Mariah didn’t have nodules she would put an end to Céline career
@@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679 but the mariah did not remove the nodules, so she ended up "destroying" her voice ...
@@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679 Nope mariah in her prime strain so much above C5.
th-cam.com/video/tltw9KPWKVE/w-d-xo.html at 3:33 Mariah cannot support C#5 climaxes with her diaphragm in make it happen undubbed live at MTV during 1992 which is during mariah's prime.
th-cam.com/video/fUi7GGeZDz0/w-d-xo.html at 3:01 and 3:33 Mariah strains D5 climaxes in dreamlover live at Paris during 1996 daydream tour. Daydream tour is so overrated!
th-cam.com/video/4pQ2Qt0z0Dk/w-d-xo.html at 2:40 Mariah strains Eb5 climax live at David Letterman during 1994 anytime you need a friend.
Also her debut era she mostly strains anything above E5 belt.
mariah is inconsistent but she has some amazing moments like her live performance of "if its over" live at the grammys during 1992 she slayed.
You should put more Mariah low notes, since you put more Celine upper belts, it would be fairer.
Tbf Celine has more upper belts that are live anyway.
thank GOD Celine can hold a note higher than a B4 WITH vibrato
Céline’s voice touches me in a way that no one else can. ❤️❤️❤️
Celine's voice has always been superior to mariah and whitney even in their prime . If you are a fan of the three you know that . Whitney's voice was melismatic and powerful .. mariah's voice was not powerful but its magical and full of melisma too . Celine has the highest upper voice range among the three and her voice was both powerful and angelic . But she was just the last to come out before mariah and whitney . The two was already known and famous before her so they got more recognition from the people back in the day . But celine proved worthy to be a legendary vocal powerhouse and people has recognized her for her amazing vocals and live performances . She sold millions of albums and won so many awards just like mariah and whitney . I love all three of them but celine is the best for me .
destined tobe Mariah was the last to come out lmao. Whitney and Celine are already pretty established as artists in the 80s.
KingofMeereen celine's career back in the 80's was revolving only in canada . Most of her songs back then are only french . She studied englsh and polished her communication skills in 1989 . Then she released unison which debuted two years after . Her real international breakthrough was in 1991 when she sang beauty and the beast with peabo . In 1990 mariah already debuted in her first album 'mariah carey' . She started recording it 1988 which means she was already in the hollywood back in the late 80's even before celine started her career in the us . This is as far as I remember .. I maybe wrong idk .
destined tobe both Whitney and Celine already had fanbases. And Mariah’s songs were mostly written from when she was a teenager, and had demos for some of em. When she rerecorded and polished for her debut, she worked with Hollywood people, yes, but she didn’t have fans until she actually put herself out there. Out of the three, she’s the newest artist.
KingofMeereen ahh I see. You may be right about that
Omg celine 🙏❤️
the middle belts
for me G4 up to B4 maria is more in the tone of her tone of voice which is darker
.for C5 / D5 celine enters the range of her natural voice .. she is the queen of C5 ... without any problem ^^
celine
The two Legend are now in 1 vidoe
There both amazing,there both Good in Singing.
Celine wins for me, but Mariah's tone is just heavenly.
Celine all the way! She can sustain high notes compared to Mariah Carey.
bitch is not about sustain it's about the resonance.
Is about the quality of the note
Mariah more resonance
@@Jomari1998 it's about sounding good live. Céline can sustain a powerful g#5 belt live. Mariah has troubles sustaining a c#5 live. Besides Céline has tons of resonance. Mariah lipsyncs most of her climax, she has never sung live WBT, the Hero sustained b4, Without You etc etc live in years. Céline can sing any of her songs live even after a throat infection. Céline is much more professional and consistent than Mariah, hands down. If Mariah sang always live and had the guts to do all her high belts live, that would be a different story.
@@icydelight3693 You dont know what you talk about, shut up 😂😂😂😂
both of them are very respectful artists but i prefer mariah
Im so proud of Celine💖
Actually, I fell Celine Dion is much better than Mariah Carey now
Always was
Why compare them? They're both great. Learn respect.
@@mariahcareygreece hi Kon
@@mariahcareygreece I have respect for both. celine is just vocally better, and more humble and loving!
Dan Beedie Mariah is definitely humble don’t you ever
No one can dethrone Celine Dion’s greatness! Outsing, outsold and outgrossed! Indeed, the greatest singer of all time 👑🙌🏻
She didn't outsell.
mariahcareygreece yeah Mariah Carey didnt outsell. Celine Dion Ashes sold more units than her Caution Album periodt! Celine Dion’s longevity
Why gotta be toxic for? It isn't a battle 🤦♀️
Omg stop comparing. They're both legends. You're so annoying, trying to start battles between fandoms
Jan Seven Cabrera ohhhh Yes!!!!!..... Celine is THE VOICE... THE QUEEN of The QUEENS!!!!!
Just the fact that they can both still belt as high as they can is amazing considering that both of them have been in the industry for 30 years now.
Just enjoying two Legend singing nothing to compare. Both successful, legend
Lows : Mariah
Belts (G4-D5) : Mariah
Eb5-G#5 : Celine clearly
Head Voice : Celine even tho mariah has very good HV moments this year too
C#5-D5 should be celine tho
these 2 ladies should never be compared, they're both great in different ways❤️
2 Divas 😍😍
I am here to hear Celine's struggling from SPS... How her viice changed .. i am so excited to her recovering from sps and hear her singing with her well rested voice❤️❤️
Only for me
Mariah-Song bird supreme
(by her vocal agility)
Whitney Houston-Song bird Phoenix
(by her vocal tone)
Celine Dion -Song bird nightingale
(by her vocal colour)
Celine is Winner for Sure :)))
Celine's Voice is great! Doesn't sound damaged!
But nasal
@@summer-sk1xn but her voice and tone still pretty no nasal and heady tone
@@ondyandraandra5346 very true, which is the reason I still prefer Mariah. In addition to her song writing skills and better musicality😊
ondy andra andra So? Boxscores doesn’t care lol
@i dont know her no one cares of you too lol and that’s my opinion. Bye 😂😂🤣🤣🤣
I love them both! They are legend, icon the real queen of music! But I’m for Mariah Carey! 🥰
I think the quality and resonance of mariah was so more better, céline was good but she dont put power in the notes👑love both👑
I know this is all vocals, but can we appreciate how beautiful this women are
Love seeing these videos coming from a Céline channel instead of a Mariah channel all the time
I love Celine's hairdo. It's so refreshing and makes her look younger. As far as the voices go, I can't complain with these two queens.
Both can no longer sustain well😂😂😂 but ill go with more distinct. Mariah wins in lows celine in mid and upper belts but mariah can outshine celine in falsetto. I think tie in most aspect but as i said mariahs voice is more distinct
@@imthatchickyoulike98 I mean she can but not as well as a few years ago.
Also, I would it's a tie in mids.and Celine has the Headvoice.
@@samuelking9497 don't mind that comment. i becoming a lamb because of hating her sksksksksksk
“both can no longer sustain well”
meanwhile, celine: 1:14, 5:28
Depite the throat virus infection Celine can hit all these notes then she's older than mariah but i love them both ❤️💕💪🏻
And mariah has nodules soo its Not so easy for her ...
@Adam Buentello Well yea it does But nodules affect singing derectly because they appear in the vocal folds wich is the parte used to sing and as timé passes they get harder so it becomes harder to sing over timé its a miracle shes can still sing at nearly 50
Celine Dion WINS!!!!.....
Mariah is my Choice, even tho her vids are shorter.
@Adam Buentello awe sweetie dont get butt hurt, it's not a penis... it is a simple opinion...dont take it so hard. Calm down
Lawrence Paz I don’t think he’s pissed with your answer. He’s just saying some parts for that certain notes lacks on mariah’s recent performances. That’s why it shorter.
I do love both of them. To be fair, Celine has preserved her voice better. Her image too is a symbol of strength and courage. Mariah has had obvious downfalls ( career and marriage life) but she remains one of the biggest divas overall. She is still creative and fierce. In terms of live performances, I go for Celine. Hits and songwriting, Mariah is irreplaceable. Concert ticket sales, Celine is still raking in and winning. Stage presence and connection with the audience, Celine. More meaningful songs, Mariah.
Céline dion >>>
Celine has lost some of her gorgeous tone and sounds quite nasally. And Mariah has lost some ease with her belts honestly above C#5. You can tell Celine practices and cherished her talent. I can’t imagine if Mariah had celines discipline with her voice. Imagine no alcohol and singing lessons for Mariah. Mariah literally has her daydream tone pop out every now and then. Both queens reguardless. I say Mariah wins for overall for “musicality”. Her tone is still very pleasant for many genres. Celine is a ballad queen nowadays.
I usually don't listen to recent Celine performances. I haven't realized her voice stills being powerful, she stills holding notes like a pro and thats what amazes me the most. I don't think myself of a fan of her but I respect her as the legend she IS.
Mariah, well, Mariah is simply my love, my favorite overall and even with her vocal struggles and damage, I'll follow her, I'm not saying she lost her voice, but I think it is a fact she can't sing as good as she used to, only when she rests up her voice, she sings like she really has to.
I really aprecciate the fact that you actually didn't make a competition video between these legends (Cause tbh I think Celine could easily win this), it was more a vocal showcase for me.
Great video, I just wanna see a collab between them, imagine how amazing it would be having the Whitney - Mariah collab and then the Mariah - Celine collab before one of them leaves us 😥
Lets say they both are backkkkkkk
Read the comments and some Mariah fans are bitter here haha even bringing up lipped videos made by mariah fan haha (why not make one for you idol lol) anyways,
For you to be happy Céline doesn’t have a Whistle note. At least there’s one thing Céline can’t do until now. The whistlenote. LOL
😂
@@darylacesantos Then, Same 😂🤣 only my opinion too 😂🤣
May I remind that lambs just don’t have that same confidence in present times when their fave’s vocals are being compared to Céline. Haha
Mariah for the Low Notes, Mariah For the Midbelts. Celine obviously has better upper belts since she always has the better vocal condition. Mariah could still hit 6th to 7th octave notes though
DION
Mariah y Céline, solo falta Whitney para tener la Trinidad Vocal completa. Una lastima que ya no este Whitney. Pero Mariah y Céline si estan y sus voces siguen siendo mucho mejor que la de artistas actuales de 25 años.
Lows : Mimi
Belt
G4: Mimi
G#4: Mimi
A4: tie
A4: mimi
Bb4: tie
Bb4: tie
B4: Celine
B4: mariah
C5: tie
C5: Mariah
C5: tie
C#5: Mariah
C#5: Celine
D5: Celine
D5: Mariah
Eb5: tie
Eb5: Celine
E5: mimi
F5: Celine
G5: tie
Head voice : both good
Did count g#5 since mimi doesn’t have one…and if it count them should put whistle…even tho Celine doesn’t have them
The G#5 sounded so good and Effortless. She shd do it often.
-Lows I would say if it's not a tie it's all to Celine. She just sound better.
-Middle belts Celine without a doubt. Mariah's good up to B4 and even not that good.
-Upper belts (Eb5+) Celine obviously
-Head Voice: Celine again. She's always had a good head voice so
I have a video suggestion, and I didn’t know where else to put it...😅 Anyway, can you do a compilation of the high note in Love Can Move Mountains? The A5 I think it was, after the lyrics: “If we got love, that is strong enough, you gotta feel it right here, right here, right there”. I’d LOVE to see that
He has already done that video.
Céline RO no, they did the ending to Love Can Move Mountains, not the A5 high note
PokeToadNetwork, he did the video with the A5 in LCMM and the climax of RDMH but it’s now gone. I don’t know why so many of his videos got deleted.
Céline RO it was awhile ago that there was some issues from posting the vids, not sure of it was copyright or demonetization, but they had to redo the channel and they posted on a TH-cam discussion what vids we wanted them to keep
Celine has somewhat lost her resonance, and Mariah her longevity in belting higher notes. But both are legends in their own right with nothing left to prove because they, even in their great age, can still outsing the "best" of this new generation.
She is not losing her resonant, but 2019 was not really her best year for her voice but in her asian tour 2018, her resonant is very clear.
How can Mariah is a good high belter, while her voice above D5 is throaty?
When I said Celine SOMEWHAT lost her resonance, it was comparing her to her younger self. I did not say she COMPLETELY lost it.
As for Mariah, I DID NOT say she was better at higher belts. I just said that she had lost her ability to sing high notes longer.
They had both aged and sang night after night for decades, their voices are not bound to stay as they used to and I just pointed out what I noticed has changed. I NEVER said one was bad, or one was better than the other.
Do Céline vs Xtina vs Mariah 2019 recent vocals. Xtina XTour has amazing showcases of her and celine is brilliant as well
We cannot compare xtina with these two cause she younger than these two
Kwensil Basaiawmoit no comparison. Just three great vocalist
Kwensil Basaiawmoit, of course we can compare, regardless of age. We can compare them to both Ariana and Barbra. Age doesn’t mean you can’t compare. Especially when Céline would slay all of them regardless of age (I know I’m biased but it’s true).
Thanks to these two vocally legendary women, our lives are much happier!!
The voice of Celine Dion is better an higher
....mariahs whistle register enters the chat ...
As duas São maravilhosas
Ofcours nowadays celine won
I love them on both! I'm excited to see Celine next year here in Floriana, Malta (Europe)
They're both legends and have been singing for decades and both have strong voices not like used to and that's fine
We love the greatest singers of all time 👑
Lows: mariah
Mid belts: tie
Everything else: celine
And this is coming from a mariah fan
Lol such a liar
@@ralphanthonymallillin2712 lol what
Mariah destroys flopline in her prime ahaha
@@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679 Nope mariah in her prime strain so much above C5.
Mariah's prime is extremely overrated but I won't deny how unique mariah is as a vocalist.
th-cam.com/video/tltw9KPWKVE/w-d-xo.html at 3:33 Mariah cannot support C#5 climaxes with her diaphragm in make it happen undubbed live at MTV during 1992 which is during mariah's prime.
th-cam.com/video/fUi7GGeZDz0/w-d-xo.html at 3:01 and 3:33 Mariah strains D5 climaxes in dreamlover live at Paris during 1996 daydream tour. Daydream tour is so overrated!
th-cam.com/video/4pQ2Qt0z0Dk/w-d-xo.html at 2:40 Mariah strains Eb5 climax live at David Letterman during 1994 anytime you need a friend.
Also her debut era she mostly strains anything above E5 belt.
@@johnchong3193 u are so right