Love the thought they went behind this video!! Mariah’s confidence is totally knocked and it’s gotten so much harder as social media becomes ubiquitous. That It’s Time hate clip on Tik Tok would surely make her even more nervous to attempt anything live. She’s a prisoner of the expirations she’s set
She could do the current arrangement for Butterfly as well, it’s just 1 chorus and the backup singers sing the main melody. All she has to do is ad lib over the bgvs.
1:20 off topic kinda but i have noticed that the higher the key in hero is, the more inspiring and powerful it sounds and feels, while the lower the key, the more intimate and emotional it feels!
I also think she would slay "melt away" and "crybaby" if added to the setlist, the song is singed in a lower register and she could play around the high notes.
Here’s my order of priority (just hopes and wishes no expectations): 1. VOL, this is *her* song. It represents her challenge and success as an artist and her love of creating. I think she can definitely do it, especially in -2. 2. Hero, I disagree with some people saying the lower key sounds weird. Yes, it sounds a bit different but with Mariah’s current range, the big G4 could sound almost like the big Bb4 from, say 1996. Hero is another quintessential Mariah song and I hope to see it back (even in old formula). 3. The Roof, given her recent collab with Brandy I would love for her to acknowledge it a bit and maybe perform it once or twice during the TCOM. Like you said, it’s not too vocally challenging but it still is a “Mariah” song. Maybe she can even bring out Brandy! 😅 4. Melt Away, I like this song and I do hope she performs it but I’m not sure where it would fit in. She hasn’t really brought out any deep cuts from Daydream yet (besides Looking In) but she might surprise us? 5. Lullaby of Birdland, seems to require a bit of improvisational confidence and punchy notes which Mariah may stray away from currently. I do think it would fit her voice now though!
theres like so many she could do fully live if she changed the key and arrangement, and other songs she never performs like caution, giving me life, and sent from up above
the slay intro is back !! i completely agree with what you said regarding hero. tbh the most known performance in 2001´s key is the medley with never too far cause she does a cool riff and the transition from ntf to hero (the crowd applauded !!) to ntf was just immaculate !! and that ending whistle, so heroic ! in her current voice, that key might sound underwhelming 1:43 the guitarist was eating why did he stop 😭 girl MELT AWAY - ur demanding much omg 😭 5:20 well 🌚 6:35 omg i must have had this riff in mind - earlier i was thinking of a jazzy VOL run and i came up with similar to this sksksk
This is a brilliant list, probably the best top 5 songs for her to perform LIVE in her current vocal state! I hope she’s watching this from her secret account 😂
2:28 is a perfect example of what could be if mariah allowed herself to sing live more. she went for that belt and it came out PERFECT and so she did it again cus she knew she ate that and it was easy for her to hit. so many other notes and things she could do if she just had the confidence to just go for it! but the hate she got for her christmas show was so dumb and annoying so i get why she is hesitant
Such great points, thank you for all your hard work. I love your channel and the fact you always demonstrate your points with examples. Your channel is informative and smart, while not taking itself too seriously - please keep up the great work 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 I really wish MC and her team could see this particular video and hopefully one day they do! Because you make a great case for changing the keys to her repertoire. I’m a huge fan of hers…. But will never pay to see her sing “live” again, it was way too expensive and after a few concerts over 10 years… I feel burnt and a bit foolish, because she really isn’t great at pretending to mime and often she seems like she’s going through the motions snd not even having fun. I have honestly had more excitement watching TH-cam clips of Mariah and got tingles watching her singing (example, ‘You and I’ for Stevie Wonder, on TH-cam) than I have ever felt at her so-called live concerts. I suspect she would rather mime and hold onto that prestige of the legendary singer with the freakish voice, then humble herself and lower keys (what I would prefer) to give us lower keys and sound authentic and like she’s singing from the soul. Aretha maintained her legacy and her voice changed. Mariah is big enough to change and adapt too. She has a reputation as messy, the cringe-worthy “darling” act and most of all, for never really singing live. I suppose what I’m saying is - if it is her ego that is stoping her from changing her approach to live performance… her reputation couldn’t get worse, it could only improve by singing live. That is one of the biggest tragedies of her career - we didn’t get more SOUL which we know she has, instead everything was so stiff and polished - she could have given us so much more ART if she hadn’t been obsessed and haunted by the vanity of the freakish notes.
There’s no telling what she’s really capable of or will do next year, she surprises us every year, either with struggling and more damaged vocals, or random moments where her voice is in great shape delivering things we didn’t think she could anymore. I think for hero she could go down another semitone tho instead of going all the way down to the medley key which is 4 semitones lower, a C key. She could do a D key for Hero and I’m certain her voice could retain that key and she could play more in that key for the rest of her life.
I haven't really let it sink in yet that if she does VOL live again, I (and probably the whole lambily) will start crying tears of joy. Like it seems so unimaginable at this point. 😭
Great video I wish she saw it and did it, I also hope that with the romance she is experiencing with Anderson she regains her energy, she deserves all the happiness❤
I think she can still sing Hero perfectly lowering one more semitone. She still has easy vibrato on A4, she could do a A4 on the big note with no problem.
honestly has she even done an A4 with vibrato in this year💀 but I agree that key would be fine for her too. She might as well just lower it all the way though cause the Glitter key sounded good too
Yes for melt away omg imagine how good it would sound with her lower tone now! I'd also like to add crybaby with a cut climax, similar to the medley version she did in 2020!
What would really benefit her is to actually re-arrange the full songs rather than just lowering the keys (of course lowering the keys help too) but for example, there are a lot of songs that she could easily do even on the og key, there are just specific moments where whe has trouble finding a way out, putting her on an akward state (like whens she dodges Emotions C#5s or Hero C5s) if she plays with the instrumentals or make the background vocals took the lead over those parts she could pretty much go with a more comfortable place.
seeing her overall performance of Emotions in 2023 I actually support her lipping it for now😭 until she's more confident with hitting the flat C#5s consistently. but she should do a laid back version of the intro live instead to compensate😍
she could sing any song live tbh 😭😭 with a few modulations nothing is impossible for her, its just that for some reaosn she chooses to lipsync even though she's fully capable of singing them
It's cuz her voice is inconsistent, like that Viral video of her slightly messing up its tiiiimee, and people are already bashing her, but i hope the viral moment bring up the flames inside her to sing Live again to prove them wrong like usual
I believe she should explore songs that leave her freer to be able to improvise. Only then will she be more willing to sing live! She needs a free and less tight repertoire.
I was thinking she could also sing underneath the stars. The whisper voice that is so dominant in that song would make it so easy for current Mariah to sing.
even in the current key i think mariah could do hero well because she made many creative dodges for the big note in rainbow era and a Bb4 should be easy for her throughout the entirety of the 2010’s
Mariah's greatest strength is her artistry. I'd love to see that artistry shine thru as she tackles a new arrangement or whatever changes necessary to actually make her sing. People bitching about a lower key are absolutely stupid and should piss off. Re-read it if you must. The status quo is pathetic and disgraceful. I'd love an entire concert of TGIFY-eseque style performances. She's an artist first before she's a singer, though thats gotten really difficult to remember of late.
I agree with all of these, tho I think she might struggle with The Roof a bit-specifically the second verse, because of all the 5th octave whispering, and the C#5 that's placed a lil strangely in the phrase (that'll prolly make it difficult for her to execute). And because the melody of the second verse is so intricate and much wider in range than that of the first verse, I think it'd give Mariah a difficult time to make alternate note changes and melodies that's just as beautiful and impactful as the original. but idk tho, we never know with Mariah's musicality!! I'd swap "The Roof" for Can't Let Go, Caution-era arrangement 😍 (edit: she can prolly still pull off the key change even tho it's lowered to the D key! she'd devour those Eb6 whistles 😍😍😍😍)
Didn't know she sung The Roof on her recent tour @2:02 I do think it's about time now that she sings a fully live version since we're never gotten that from her before.
If I ever get a chance to the a one on one with Mariah I’ll show her all the ways she creatively dodged high parts of songs throughout the years like VOL and say “girl just do this you’ve already done it before”
@rockerfeller2014 songs like yours and lullaby are low and singable for her nowadays, I said the whole album because that diamond deserves justice 😭 but there are hard songs like saving grace and through the rain
She can rearrange her songs to handle them fully live, but she just has the "Why risk it when I can just take the safe and easy way?" mindset (for which I can't blame her looking at how aggressive the media gets when she even DARES to have a bad day). The 2022 Global concert arrangement of Always Be My Baby could make a comeback and that way she can perform it fully live again, VOL could be lowered down to Emotions' key, she can handle My All fully live in a good day, I support your choice to lower Hero to the NTF medley key, she could bring back Love Story in the acoustic version she sang it in that little performance for MTV, or choose other easier songs, like all of Caution lol
Like many others already stated she's still able to sing live but the confident is def one of the main problems here.....A new year open new hope let's patienly wait !
As a tenor that can go toe to toe with her vocals now. Peaking BELT(Eb5). I would said she could start from a G4 and go up to a D5. For vision of love climax. OR do what she did infinity era snd do two C#5s . Or growl a C5.
I think she could still perform a big portion of her catalog fully live, the problem is that what’s left of her confidence is very inconsistent and lipping is the easiest way for her to control everything that happens, so it’s the safe route and she knows that so it’s what she’ll go with. It keeps the GP happy, avoids stupid viral comments like the It’s Time “fail”, and she knows what to expect out of the show. Our hope is that she gets bored of lipping (which I think is what happened in the Christmas shows, as well as the whole viral tweet thing), and decides to just go for it to have some fun.
I don’t really like artists who lower their songs so much they become unrecognisable and I imagine this is the same for Mariah. I think Hero and VOL could be lowered another semitone and be fully live
@@Solo-vh9fm she doesn't even have to lower VOL tbh. she can basically sing the whole song without going higher than C5. And for the last note she can do TURNED OUT TO BE TURNED OUT TO BE or BEYEAHBEYEAHBEYEAH to avoid sustaining it
@@alexlecookiecat she could, either would probably work well for her. If she REALLY wanted to make it easier she could lower it to G#, one semitone below Emotions
It just seems so BORING to sit around picking every performance of hers apart like this. I just don't get the point. She's going to perform the way she performs. Period. You can listen to these songs on an album if you need some nostalgia, but you're not the one doing this multi-day performances with known vocal limitations unless you thinks he's lying and somehow just lazily not wanting to sing. If that were the case, why would she put effort into all the rest of it? Honestly... This is tiring and boring. I want real Mariah content. Provide or move aside.
@@VMariah If they could tell me how to avoid you popping up in my feeds, then I would. But, for as long as you post BS, I'mma comment on it. You're welcome for the feedback. :)
@@jacksonsunwoo My time and leisure are very valuable to me; I def pay for it when I open a video looking for something good. I would rather it not be clogged with trash. And, I didn't watch it. I just commented on it. I type 140 wpm. I can spare a few seconds to comment on pointless things when I see them.
Honestly, without the climax, she could possibly sing almost every song live
and some climaxes are doable if she lowers the keys and/or dodges a couple notes
I pray for a fully live Vision Of Love 🙏( I prayed through the nights )
SWEET DESTINYYYY 🗣️🗣️
Omg ur pfp-
@ 😭😭😭 I changed it because someone told me to
@@TheStoryOfMariah what was ur pfp before this 😭
😭😭
Love the thought they went behind this video!!
Mariah’s confidence is totally knocked and it’s gotten so much harder as social media becomes ubiquitous.
That It’s Time hate clip on Tik Tok would surely make her even more nervous to attempt anything live. She’s a prisoner of the expirations she’s set
jamaica 2015, we need you in 2025 😭
PD: Happy New Year ‼️
ok no
or yeah idk
Yes we do😩
The way the residency is beginning on the 10th anniversary of Jamaica😭
@@VMariah her mind>>>>
She could do the current arrangement for Butterfly as well, it’s just 1 chorus and the backup singers sing the main melody. All she has to do is ad lib over the bgvs.
SHE NEEDS TO GIVE US A LIVE PERFORMANCE OF MELT AWAY
Maybe in the next lifetime🥲
JUSTICE FOR MELT AWAY🥲
she needs to give us a live performance period!
Yes, please!
Fr we have been needing that 😭. I have been asking since 2022
1:20 off topic kinda but i have noticed that the higher the key in hero is, the more inspiring and powerful it sounds and feels, while the lower the key, the more intimate and emotional it feels!
Rarityriah could do a whole concert live our great mother fears ending daydream😍😍😍
I also think she would slay "melt away" and "crybaby" if added to the setlist, the song is singed in a lower register and she could play around the high notes.
Here’s my order of priority (just hopes and wishes no expectations):
1. VOL, this is *her* song. It represents her challenge and success as an artist and her love of creating. I think she can definitely do it, especially in -2.
2. Hero, I disagree with some people saying the lower key sounds weird. Yes, it sounds a bit different but with Mariah’s current range, the big G4 could sound almost like the big Bb4 from, say 1996. Hero is another quintessential Mariah song and I hope to see it back (even in old formula).
3. The Roof, given her recent collab with Brandy I would love for her to acknowledge it a bit and maybe perform it once or twice during the TCOM. Like you said, it’s not too vocally challenging but it still is a “Mariah” song. Maybe she can even bring out Brandy! 😅
4. Melt Away, I like this song and I do hope she performs it but I’m not sure where it would fit in. She hasn’t really brought out any deep cuts from Daydream yet (besides Looking In) but she might surprise us?
5. Lullaby of Birdland, seems to require a bit of improvisational confidence and punchy notes which Mariah may stray away from currently. I do think it would fit her voice now though!
I just realized Mariah only really does deep cuts from Butterfly and TEOM these days lol😭 but given it's also Daydream30 next year she totally should!
theres like so many she could do fully live if she changed the key and arrangement, and other songs she never performs like caution, giving me life, and sent from up above
She could slay Crybaby and Givin Me Life as well 😭
That melt away clip gags me everytime.
the slay intro is back !!
i completely agree with what you said regarding hero. tbh the most known performance in 2001´s key is the medley with never too far cause she does a cool riff and the transition from ntf to hero (the crowd applauded !!) to ntf was just immaculate !! and that ending whistle, so heroic !
in her current voice, that key might sound underwhelming
1:43 the guitarist was eating why did he stop 😭
girl MELT AWAY - ur demanding much omg 😭
5:20 well 🌚
6:35 omg i must have had this riff in mind - earlier i was thinking of a jazzy VOL run and i came up with similar to this sksksk
You forgot slipping away!!! She sang that song with a laid back arrangement that sounds so goodddd, i need that song back so desperately 💔
We need hero in the 2001 key , like WE NEED IT
That was well thought out and put together nicely. Great job
I need someone from Mariah’s team to show her this 😭
This is a brilliant list, probably the best top 5 songs for her to perform LIVE in her current vocal state! I hope she’s watching this from her secret account 😂
2:28 is a perfect example of what could be if mariah allowed herself to sing live more. she went for that belt and it came out PERFECT and so she did it again cus she knew she ate that and it was easy for her to hit. so many other notes and things she could do if she just had the confidence to just go for it! but the hate she got for her christmas show was so dumb and annoying so i get why she is hesitant
Hero 2001 is what I want to hear
Such great points, thank you for all your hard work. I love your channel and the fact you always demonstrate your points with examples. Your channel is informative and smart, while not taking itself too seriously - please keep up the great work 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 I really wish MC and her team could see this particular video and hopefully one day they do! Because you make a great case for changing the keys to her repertoire. I’m a huge fan of hers…. But will never pay to see her sing “live” again, it was way too expensive and after a few concerts over 10 years… I feel burnt and a bit foolish, because she really isn’t great at pretending to mime and often she seems like she’s going through the motions snd not even having fun. I have honestly had more excitement watching TH-cam clips of Mariah and got tingles watching her singing (example, ‘You and I’ for Stevie Wonder, on TH-cam) than I have ever felt at her so-called live concerts. I suspect she would rather mime and hold onto that prestige of the legendary singer with the freakish voice, then humble herself and lower keys (what I would prefer) to give us lower keys and sound authentic and like she’s singing from the soul. Aretha maintained her legacy and her voice changed. Mariah is big enough to change and adapt too. She has a reputation as messy, the cringe-worthy “darling” act and most of all, for never really singing live. I suppose what I’m saying is - if it is her ego that is stoping her from changing her approach to live performance… her reputation couldn’t get worse, it could only improve by singing live. That is one of the biggest tragedies of her career - we didn’t get more SOUL which we know she has, instead everything was so stiff and polished - she could have given us so much more ART if she hadn’t been obsessed and haunted by the vanity of the freakish notes.
You’re not a fan.
There’s no telling what she’s really capable of or will do next year, she surprises us every year, either with struggling and more damaged vocals, or random moments where her voice is in great shape delivering things we didn’t think she could anymore. I think for hero she could go down another semitone tho instead of going all the way down to the medley key which is 4 semitones lower, a C key. She could do a D key for Hero and I’m certain her voice could retain that key and she could play more in that key for the rest of her life.
i love your intro sm 😂 i wish she did that version when she recorded new playbacks
I haven't really let it sink in yet that if she does VOL live again, I (and probably the whole lambily) will start crying tears of joy. Like it seems so unimaginable at this point. 😭
6:37 THE AUDIENCE SINGING 😭
What about Music box, she ate that one 😭😭😭 I need the full versionnn she could re arrange the climax.
Great video I wish she saw it and did it, I also hope that with the romance she is experiencing with Anderson she regains her energy, she deserves all the happiness❤
The melt away run is SOOOO iconic 😭😭😭
Agreed. She can be like Whitney and just lower all her songs in comfortable key and lip some parts she chooses to lip.
Lipping Vision of Love was an unforgettable sin
Honestly she can also sing never too far away' first verse and chorus (changing the D5-C5 to a D4-C4)
I would lose it if she did that! 😍😍😍
yeah she can also dodge the C5/D5 like she did at united we stand 2001
she could probably do the hero/never too far medley if she lowered the key and dodged/ lipped the whistles
Because my heart still believes… maybe you could be ✨ l i v e 🎤 again
You are the Lamb of the Year.
I think she can still sing Hero perfectly lowering one more semitone. She still has easy vibrato on A4, she could do a A4 on the big note with no problem.
honestly has she even done an A4 with vibrato in this year💀 but I agree that key would be fine for her too. She might as well just lower it all the way though cause the Glitter key sounded good too
Yes for melt away omg imagine how good it would sound with her lower tone now! I'd also like to add crybaby with a cut climax, similar to the medley version she did in 2020!
2025 is the year you start from where you are and through belief practice and consistency you will pull through , Mariah and all her lambs
What would really benefit her is to actually re-arrange the full songs rather than just lowering the keys (of course lowering the keys help too) but for example, there are a lot of songs that she could easily do even on the og key, there are just specific moments where whe has trouble finding a way out, putting her on an akward state (like whens she dodges Emotions C#5s or Hero C5s) if she plays with the instrumentals or make the background vocals took the lead over those parts she could pretty much go with a more comfortable place.
seeing her overall performance of Emotions in 2023 I actually support her lipping it for now😭 until she's more confident with hitting the flat C#5s consistently. but she should do a laid back version of the intro live instead to compensate😍
she could sing any song live tbh 😭😭 with a few modulations nothing is impossible for her, its just that for some reaosn she chooses to lipsync even though she's fully capable of singing them
It's cuz her voice is inconsistent, like that Viral video of her slightly messing up its tiiiimee, and people are already bashing her, but i hope the viral moment bring up the flames inside her to sing Live again to prove them wrong like usual
this is delusional beyond belief
She is not adapting her songs to fit her voice that's the issue
2025riah start taking risks
The anticipation for this leg of TCOM is killing me. No expectations, but I hope 2025riah gives us something fresh.
VMariah where you at 😔
I'm hereee😍
Girl just give us one song 😭 the way I was waiting for ABMB at the Christmas show. It hits different when she’s singing live, she’s more engaged
I believe she should explore songs that leave her freer to be able to improvise. Only then will she be more willing to sing live! She needs a free and less tight repertoire.
I was thinking she could also sing underneath the stars. The whisper voice that is so dominant in that song would make it so easy for current Mariah to sing.
Yes she could do it how she was in 2012 for example, a bit slower without the belts and it would be beautiful
even in the current key i think mariah could do hero well because she made many creative dodges for the big note in rainbow era and a Bb4 should be easy for her throughout the entirety of the 2010’s
Mariah's greatest strength is her artistry. I'd love to see that artistry shine thru as she tackles a new arrangement or whatever changes necessary to actually make her sing. People bitching about a lower key are absolutely stupid and should piss off. Re-read it if you must. The status quo is pathetic and disgraceful. I'd love an entire concert of TGIFY-eseque style performances. She's an artist first before she's a singer, though thats gotten really difficult to remember of late.
Girl she could sing it in the og key don’t make the songs more dull😭😭😭 0:13
To be fair, even dodging the E5s she still has trouble finding her place around the C5s, and the song feels akward when she skips those
She could go down another semitone. So a whole key down
She could still do so much even in her current state. I don't know why she suppresses her own talent this way.
Someone send this to Daniel Moore and her team🤣
I agree with all of these, tho I think she might struggle with The Roof a bit-specifically the second verse, because of all the 5th octave whispering, and the C#5 that's placed a lil strangely in the phrase (that'll prolly make it difficult for her to execute). And because the melody of the second verse is so intricate and much wider in range than that of the first verse, I think it'd give Mariah a difficult time to make alternate note changes and melodies that's just as beautiful and impactful as the original. but idk tho, we never know with Mariah's musicality!!
I'd swap "The Roof" for Can't Let Go, Caution-era arrangement 😍 (edit: she can prolly still pull off the key change even tho it's lowered to the D key! she'd devour those Eb6 whistles 😍😍😍😍)
cmon mariahhhh we NEED you to sing melt away again !!
Didn't know she sung The Roof on her recent tour @2:02 I do think it's about time now that she sings a fully live version since we're never gotten that from her before.
If I ever get a chance to the a one on one with Mariah I’ll show her all the ways she creatively dodged high parts of songs throughout the years like VOL and say “girl just do this you’ve already done it before”
You'd make her cry, the worst thing you could discuss with her these days is something related to vocal decline 😭
@rockerfeller2014 well the thing she most doesn't want to talk about is probably her age💀 and second her vocal decline
I always wondered why she never did hero like 2001? It would sound so good now😭
Basically charmbracelet as whole is very comfortable for her now, and she would do justice for that diamond
What? Girl charmbracelet is her hardest album 😭
@rockerfeller2014 songs like yours and lullaby are low and singable for her nowadays, I said the whole album because that diamond deserves justice 😭 but there are hard songs like saving grace and through the rain
She can rearrange her songs to handle them fully live, but she just has the "Why risk it when I can just take the safe and easy way?" mindset (for which I can't blame her looking at how aggressive the media gets when she even DARES to have a bad day). The 2022 Global concert arrangement of Always Be My Baby could make a comeback and that way she can perform it fully live again, VOL could be lowered down to Emotions' key, she can handle My All fully live in a good day, I support your choice to lower Hero to the NTF medley key, she could bring back Love Story in the acoustic version she sang it in that little performance for MTV, or choose other easier songs, like all of Caution lol
Uma rainha ❤❤❤❤🌹🌻
2020 really robbed us of some really cool live vocals.
Like many others already stated she's still able to sing live but the confident is def one of the main problems here.....A new year open new hope let's patienly wait !
we need lullaby of birdland again!!!!
As a tenor that can go toe to toe with her vocals now. Peaking BELT(Eb5). I would said she could start from a G4 and go up to a D5. For vision of love climax. OR do what she did infinity era snd do two C#5s . Or growl a C5.
that hero from 2001 was SAD and TRAGIC
not as much as you dahhling🥰
Weirdo
do you think 2024riah could do love story fully live if she used the arrangement from the acoustic performance
probably there's a couple C#5s but she could dodge them if she wanted
I think she could still perform a big portion of her catalog fully live, the problem is that what’s left of her confidence is very inconsistent and lipping is the easiest way for her to control everything that happens, so it’s the safe route and she knows that so it’s what she’ll go with. It keeps the GP happy, avoids stupid viral comments like the It’s Time “fail”, and she knows what to expect out of the show. Our hope is that she gets bored of lipping (which I think is what happened in the Christmas shows, as well as the whole viral tweet thing), and decides to just go for it to have some fun.
Omg old intro is back!
yess😍for auld lang syne
join the groope
I'm probably the only lamb who's not a fan of Lullaby of Birdland.
How do we send this video to her?
💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💋💋💋💋💋búék drága love
Somebody please unleash Jamaicariah 😹
4:42 what did your case do that warranted an arrest 😨
lmao I just realized this that was a typo😭
being real she could sing hero original key fully live if she dodged the E5’s in the bridge
as well as VOL -2 semitones!!! her voice is in much better condition than in the past and she always sang it live before 🫣
@@ben-nw1re her voice is better shape than 2022 and that's about it to be honest😭
@@VMariah i feel like it’s better than 2006riah !! to me her voice sounds clear and not strained most of the time !!! Thanks for your videos
@@ben-nw1re her tone does sound better in some areas!
@ her Bb4’s 😍
1:03 which date is this?😮
april 27, 2024!
how many semitones lower was the 01 hero in comaprison to studio key?
edit: nvm u alr said it LOL
2:28 CAN U TELL ME WHAT SHOW THAT IS FROM OMGGG
Detroit Dec. 1 2023! it's the same night she sang miss you most
@ OKOK TY FINDING IT RN
What key is 2001 hero in?
C major, four semitones down from the original
I don’t really like artists who lower their songs so much they become unrecognisable and I imagine this is the same for Mariah.
I think Hero and VOL could be lowered another semitone and be fully live
If you lowered VOL by a semitone you'd end up with D5s still, Mariah's not hitting consecutive D5s in 2025
@ the D5s are pretty dodgeball though, she hadn’t done Eb5s in the last live key for years. She would have only a few C#5s too
@@Solo-vh9fm she doesn't even have to lower VOL tbh. she can basically sing the whole song without going higher than C5. And for the last note she can do TURNED OUT TO BE TURNED OUT TO BE or BEYEAHBEYEAHBEYEAH to avoid sustaining it
Lowering VOL again is just back to the same key she's been performing it since 2000 though? She could lower it to Emotions' key
@@alexlecookiecat she could, either would probably work well for her. If she REALLY wanted to make it easier she could lower it to G#, one semitone below Emotions
lullaby of bitdland was lipped
lmao? at least hate accurately will you
Of all the things you could’ve accused of being lipped you choose a so obviously LIVE performance 💀💀💀
It just seems so BORING to sit around picking every performance of hers apart like this. I just don't get the point. She's going to perform the way she performs. Period.
You can listen to these songs on an album if you need some nostalgia, but you're not the one doing this multi-day performances with known vocal limitations unless you thinks he's lying and somehow just lazily not wanting to sing. If that were the case, why would she put effort into all the rest of it? Honestly...
This is tiring and boring. I want real Mariah content. Provide or move aside.
"Provide or move aside." What about watch or move aside? Thanks for bringing traffic to the channel
😭 you make it sound like you’re paying for these videos. Watch what makes you happy and don’t watch what doesn’t. 😊
@@VMariah If they could tell me how to avoid you popping up in my feeds, then I would. But, for as long as you post BS, I'mma comment on it. You're welcome for the feedback. :)
@@jacksonsunwoo My time and leisure are very valuable to me; I def pay for it when I open a video looking for something good. I would rather it not be clogged with trash. And, I didn't watch it. I just commented on it. I type 140 wpm. I can spare a few seconds to comment on pointless things when I see them.
@@brandon9247 There’s lots of things to unpack in your response, but it’s not my channel, so I won’t. Enjoy being hateful??
3:11 im so glad she stopped doing these lol