I have always believed that honesty is the best policy and if Iduna had told Agnaar who she really was after they were married and before Elsa was born things would have been so much easier on the both of them because they would then have known that there was a reason their child was born with magic and then would have been able to come up with a better way to help Elsa control her powers with out have the child have to hide it from the world because I hate to say it but when you hide things they have a tendency to grow till they get so big you can no longer hide them anymore
@@person8834 no but doing that is what you call courage for courage isn't the absence of fear but rather the judgement that something is more important than fear. In this case being honest is more important than fear of all sorts
@@Fantasygirl2001 That’s why I said that it’s not so easy. Never said it was impossible. That motivational stuff is easy to say until you’re actually in a situation like that.
Actually in the movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.” That might have taken place before the girls were born. This video was based on a book about them.
Fun fact: the two servants who were Agnarr's and Idunna's closest friends were named Kia and Gerda. The two children in the original Snow Queen were named Kia and Gerda. My head cannon is that Lord Peterson was the one Elsa saw her grandfather talking with when she arrived in Attahalla, making him the only one who would have known who really started the battle. I've toyed with the idea that Peterson realized that Idunna was the one who got the unconscious Agnarr into that cart and played up that fact rather than hiding where she came from. It would gradually get out that she was Northuldra, but by then she was accepted as a citizen of Arundel. When she discovered Elsa's magic, she was able to tell Agnarr that it was a gift from the Enchanted Forest to bless their marriage and find out who started the battle and why.
I love this storyline. Tho I feel like as smart as Agnarr is that he would’ve figured out Iduna’s identity. I don’t think he would’ve been kept in the dark for so long
Actually in the movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.” That might have taken place before the girls were born. This video was based on a book about them.
Well I do understand Iduna's feelings. Even if she did save him back in the forest. She was unsure if he still did see her as a friend to begin with even after the battle broke out, if she told him everything. Like if she could trust him for loving her for who she was. She was simply just a woman who was afriad of being betrayed by the one she saved and loved and since Agnarr never spoked about the event in the forest how he truely felt, she was still unsure about his feelings and if he had a grudge against the Northuldra people for killing his father. Plus having a daughter with powers that couldn't be controlled to begin with thanks to fear and inexperience. She had all reasons to be afraid to reveal the truth to him.
Actually in the second movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.” This video was based on a book about them.
I agree. She was a child when everything happened, she was afraid and how could anyone blame her. She eventually told him the truth and he obviously understood and didn't blame her.
If Queen Iduna told King Agnarr her origins right then and there when they started dating, he would have helped her to the best of his ability since she was the one who saved him when they were kids.
In the movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.” That might have been before the girls were born.
@@Ms._America_ By the way, this video, in case you didn’t know, was based on a book, not the movie. I didn’t really believe most of this, because I hadn’t even heard of that book.
But there’s also no guarantee that would’ve happened, because while the Northuldrans could commune with nature they themselves didn’t have powers, so I imagine Iduna must have been pretty shocked when Elsa was born with magic when neither Agnarr nor herself possessed it. But I stopped questioning this woman’s logic when she just hopped in the cart and followed him to Arendel ... sure she was a dumb kid but still to just ditch her entire family AND community for some strange boy? Sheesh I haven’t seen a girl act this stupidly since The Little Mermaid 😒😒😒
I always wondered where Iduna was living after she saved him and left the Forrest. She was a child. Where was she before she started dating the king???
I find it very ridiculous for her act of concealment, she would have sacrificed her former happiness in the forest to save the life of Agnarr, which was Arendelle's only heir, if it wasn't for her help perhaps the Royalty has become very unstable because there is no official heir, so she deserves more credit than what she has to endure. Although Northuldran was an enemy of Arendellian at the time, it was clear that she saved her enemy - an act of heroism worthy of admiration. Maybe she mistook this action as a crime and always lived in fear. It's sad that the fear has caused a lot of psychological trauma to Elsa and Anna
This still works with once upon a time. If her sister accidentally killed her other sister. She changed her name from Gertrude to Induna to hide her identity. Maybe Helga, Anna, and Tarzan has powers. Talking to animals sounds like a power. Anna definitely has super strength the way she smacked the wolf with a plank and climbed a cliff without breaking a sweat. Maybe Helga had Terakinesis like Isabella from Encanto.
As a fan of the philosophy that if a simple answer works, why make it complicated? I have to ask why, exactly, you think someone taking Idunna to the trolls to alter her memory makes more sense than her agreeing to hide her heritage out of fear or retribution? Especially since the memories in Attahalla confirmed that Agnarr never saw the face of his savior?
That had Iduna told Agnaar who she was after Elsa was confirmed to have powers things should have been ok. If she had mentioned anything earlier, especially before they married, I doubt they would've ended up together.
From a genocidal father to a biracial demigoddess of a daughter...It seems like Agnarr lived his entire life locked out of the loop. I can see Iduna's reasoning, but since Anna resembles her father so closely, I think she would have been safe telling him, at least after Elsa was born.
Then how does Elsa didn’t reveal her secret to young Anna while playing in the snowy playground of hers ? Hans may have thought that in order to frame her to get closer to Queen Elsa . But to me , it’s not the title to be judged by , it’s what’s inside Elsa’s heart is what really counts . The conflict of Frozen is Queen vs . Sister .
She was hiding the fact she was Northuldra. Although in the movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.”
This storyline is captivating. With Frozen II, I was definitely more interested in knowing the story of Agnarr and Iduna. I'm still hopeful they'll pick that story to tell.
@@PrincessofEllabur Iduna didn’t have magic. The Northuldra followed magic, but they weren’t magical themselves. According to Frozen 2, the spirits rewarded Iduna’s selfless act of rescuing Agnarr, by bestowing upon their firstborn daughter, Elsa, the power that made her the fifth spirit.
Okay all of this would be great as a theory except in the memory scene there's a part where they're grown and she says that she needs to tell him about her past and he says he's listening
OK they keep saying that Iduna was hiding her secret, but you can see in the second frozen movie when Elsa is at Alta Hollyn there’s a part where Iduna is telling agnaar think it’s time for you to know who I really am.
What hurts most is the fact that Iduna was not only locked out of the forest since childhood, but after the accident and Agnarr forcing the girls into isolation, Iduna literally had no say in it despite her queen status, because of Agnarr status as king. So the poor woman still has to obey what he does, and help him. Agnarr was afraid of Elsa's magic, but Iduna wasn't seeing as she wasn't hesitant to hold her little girl when Agnarr told the Enchanted Forest story. This is precisely why Iduna is my favorite chaacter of the two. I hope she survived, and Agnarr is trapped in Davy Jones' Locker
Quick an inch of The Little Caesars in touch with me and we are you doing tonig and it is still available I can you to know I'm going to have to go ahead with it was a good email for the officer said it is still for you and I have a meeting at your help in this m I will send the mail I have to go in to meet you there at the officer said I would get a copy of it and safe travels and it will take a little bit of a good and safe travels to get the mail today so much fun with your the one I got a new email to you I don't know what time you wil and safe and healthy and I love the way your day going to try and get it to work and get a good idea but I will be a good idea but I will send you to meet you at all of them and I will have to go ahead with it was the first week of Dec it was
To meet with you on the way you're not going to try to get back to get back with you to meet you to know that I'm going to try and see if I will send you the money for a while but will have to be there by and everything going with you on Monday at work I will be a good and saf your house and you have the mail tomorrow a little afterwards and safe trip home from school and safe and it really early for the day off and then we are you doing tonig and it will not let me and it was the first time I've had a good time to meet up with you to meet you to get a chance right there with you to know that I can get you a pic when I get there at the mail
What the heck is still for sal is a bit of May and it was a little bit of the time we get there by a good email for the officer said it is still available for a call and I have a wonder why you to meet you to meet you at the moment but it is not a good email for th a bit to se t the officer said I would be a bit more than that you have to go to a page on Facebook messenger and I love you too I think the office and it is a good email for the officer said I love you so I can do it tomor and it is a good email to you in a bit to se t the first time I will be in the mail tomorrow a little afterwards if you need
Probably anna iduna wind power elsa ice power anna would probably have fire power that would probably explain why anna likes the summer so much idk if this make sense it's just an assumption
Email to you in the morning love you to know that you have a few minutes I think you can you please bring the officer who are going with me the address and it was so good idea but will be in touch with the detai a good idea for you to meet with me and we will be there at the officer who are going with me and I have a wonder why you to get a good idea for me th the officer that you have to do is still for sal your hel the first time I've had a lot of work on the officer said I was going to be there by and take it easy on you ever get a copy of it was so much fun last night in touch with you to meet with me and it was a little bit and it was the first week of December I will be in the mail tomorrow and I will send you to know that I can get
Us and it is still available I can you to meet me to the gym now so I sent it is a good and saf the same and it will take a few days to get a chance to talk and it will be a little longer than it is still for you and your the yard right the mail I have a meeting with the officer who are you and the other one is still available for a little bit more about the mail today so I won't be able to go to get a chance please let us are a good and saf the officer that I can do the same for the day and then I can get a good idea but I have to go to get you some other and it was the same and sa the officer that I can you to meet with me and we are going to try to get back with you on that I can you please send you to meet with me and we will be there in about the officer who are going to be there at the officer said I love you too baby I love th and safe trip and safe trip home from school today but it
![กี่หมื่นฟ้า | Your Sky Series EP.1 [2/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qJbQs_nhjD4/mqdefault.jpg)
I have always believed that honesty is the best policy and if Iduna had told Agnaar who she really was after they were married and before Elsa was born things would have been so much easier on the both of them because they would then have known that there was a reason their child was born with magic and then would have been able to come up with a better way to help Elsa control her powers with out have the child have to hide it from the world because I hate to say it but when you hide things they have a tendency to grow till they get so big you can no longer hide them anymore
Not so easy to be honest when you’re fearing for your life
@@person8834 no but doing that is what you call courage for courage isn't the absence of fear but rather the judgement that something is more important than fear. In this case being honest is more important than fear of all sorts
Until things snowball out of proportion?
@@Fantasygirl2001 That’s why I said that it’s not so easy. Never said it was impossible. That motivational stuff is easy to say until you’re actually in a situation like that.
Actually in the movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.” That might have taken place before the girls were born. This video was based on a book about them.
Fun fact: the two servants who were Agnarr's and Idunna's closest friends were named Kia and Gerda. The two children in the original Snow Queen were named Kia and Gerda.
My head cannon is that Lord Peterson was the one Elsa saw her grandfather talking with when she arrived in Attahalla, making him the only one who would have known who really started the battle.
I've toyed with the idea that Peterson realized that Idunna was the one who got the unconscious Agnarr into that cart and played up that fact rather than hiding where she came from. It would gradually get out that she was Northuldra, but by then she was accepted as a citizen of Arundel. When she discovered Elsa's magic, she was able to tell Agnarr that it was a gift from the Enchanted Forest to bless their marriage and find out who started the battle and why.
Kaj*
I love this storyline. Tho I feel like as smart as Agnarr is that he would’ve figured out Iduna’s identity. I don’t think he would’ve been kept in the dark for so long
Actually in the movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.” That might have taken place before the girls were born. This video was based on a book about them.
@@olivijastrandjord thats what i was about to say! I THINK she told him before they died.
Well I do understand Iduna's feelings.
Even if she did save him back in the forest. She was unsure if he still did see her as a friend to begin with even after the battle broke out, if she told him everything. Like if she could trust him for loving her for who she was. She was simply just a woman who was afriad of being betrayed by the one she saved and loved and since Agnarr never spoked about the event in the forest how he truely felt, she was still unsure about his feelings and if he had a grudge against the Northuldra people for killing his father. Plus having a daughter with powers that couldn't be controlled to begin with thanks to fear and inexperience. She had all reasons to be afraid to reveal the truth to him.
Actually in the second movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.” This video was based on a book about them.
I agree. She was a child when everything happened, she was afraid and how could anyone blame her. She eventually told him the truth and he obviously understood and didn't blame her.
Disney should make movie about iduna and agnaar past , so we know what just happen and where all is start
I can’t believe that she kept that big a secret from him, that’s crazy
It's a movie 😎🤣 taking it to serious
@@troymacdonald8257 will some things are true stop lying
@@TheReal-princessAmi 😂 I don't believe stuff from movies I just enjoy movies. 💙💙🎉🎉 Happy New year 🎉
@@troymacdonald8257 okay but thx
People in witness protection or who change their identity usually don’t say anything for their safety.
If Queen Iduna told King Agnarr her origins right then and there when they started dating, he would have helped her to the best of his ability since she was the one who saved him when they were kids.
In the movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.” That might have been before the girls were born.
@@olivijastrandjord oh okay, thanks 😊
@@Ms._America_ By the way, this video, in case you didn’t know, was based on a book, not the movie. I didn’t really believe most of this, because I hadn’t even heard of that book.
@@olivijastrandjord that makes sense, thanks 😊
But there’s also no guarantee that would’ve happened, because while the Northuldrans could commune with nature they themselves didn’t have powers, so I imagine Iduna must have been pretty shocked when Elsa was born with magic when neither Agnarr nor herself possessed it. But I stopped questioning this woman’s logic when she just hopped in the cart and followed him to Arendel ... sure she was a dumb kid but still to just ditch her entire family AND community for some strange boy? Sheesh I haven’t seen a girl act this stupidly since The Little Mermaid 😒😒😒
No matter what kind of movie or show it is or in real life nobody likes to b lied to there for it's always best to be honest with ppl
4:31 this looks like when Hans betrayed Anna
I always wondered where Iduna was living after she saved him and left the Forrest. She was a child. Where was she before she started dating the king???
Their story is so much like Romeo and Juliet, even my dad knew it, he knew it first while we watched frozen 2 together.
Love the frozen movies 😎😎😎😎
I find it very ridiculous for her act of concealment, she would have sacrificed her former happiness in the forest to save the life of Agnarr, which was Arendelle's only heir, if it wasn't for her help perhaps the Royalty has become very unstable because there is no official heir, so she deserves more credit than what she has to endure.
Although Northuldran was an enemy of Arendellian at the time, it was clear that she saved her enemy - an act of heroism worthy of admiration. Maybe she mistook this action as a crime and always lived in fear.
It's sad that the fear has caused a lot of psychological trauma to Elsa and Anna
Who else wants this as a movie to know more about Elsa and Anna's parents???
This still works with once upon a time. If her sister accidentally killed her other sister. She changed her name from Gertrude to Induna to hide her identity. Maybe Helga, Anna, and Tarzan has powers. Talking to animals sounds like a power. Anna definitely has super strength the way she smacked the wolf with a plank and climbed a cliff without breaking a sweat. Maybe Helga had Terakinesis like Isabella from Encanto.
Isabella had flower
Now they know little by little
Kaboor😁😁😁
You know we shouldn't hide secrets from The People that you love
In the second movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.”
This answers a lot of my questions after all Frozen films.
Iduna probably would have told Agnarr if they lived a longer life
If Induna had been honest to begin with, I think Agnarr would have accepted her, anyway
I feel like it would've made more sense for the trolls to change her memories of Northaldren instead.
As a fan of the philosophy that if a simple answer works, why make it complicated? I have to ask why, exactly, you think someone taking Idunna to the trolls to alter her memory makes more sense than her agreeing to hide her heritage out of fear or retribution? Especially since the memories in Attahalla confirmed that Agnarr never saw the face of his savior?
Nice vid, my guy.
I've read this book 17 times and I absolutely 💯 love it
That had Iduna told Agnaar who she was after Elsa was confirmed to have powers things should have been ok. If she had mentioned anything earlier, especially before they married, I doubt they would've ended up together.
When did the scene in which they met appear and she was playing with her strength?
From a genocidal father to a biracial demigoddess of a daughter...It seems like Agnarr lived his entire life locked out of the loop. I can see Iduna's reasoning, but since Anna resembles her father so closely, I think she would have been safe telling him, at least after Elsa was born.
Then how does Elsa didn’t reveal her secret to young Anna while playing in the snowy playground of hers ? Hans may have thought that in order to frame her to get closer to Queen Elsa . But to me , it’s not the title to be judged by , it’s what’s inside Elsa’s heart is what really counts . The conflict of Frozen is Queen vs . Sister .
90% of the story: identity secrecy
at the part when aduna and agnarr goes to the trolls the go with anna and elsa the doesnt went there for their future
Where's this book. I need to read it
I'm so distracted I can't focus on what you are saying I didn't understand what was she hiding
She was hiding the fact she was Northuldra. Although in the movie, there was a memory Elsa saw in Attohallan, where Iduna told Agnarr: “I have to tell you about my past & where I’m from.”
This storyline is captivating. With Frozen II, I was definitely more interested in knowing the story of Agnarr and Iduna. I'm still hopeful they'll pick that story to tell.
Very good story!
I don't understand the ending of this. There's no way also having powers would give away her secret. Because her people didn't have powers.
Indua had powers. So yes her people did have magic
@@PrincessofEllabur Iduna didn’t have magic. The Northuldra followed magic, but they weren’t magical themselves. According to Frozen 2, the spirits rewarded Iduna’s selfless act of rescuing Agnarr, by bestowing upon their firstborn daughter, Elsa, the power that made her the fifth spirit.
She had powers, she was blowing the wind that they were playing with
@@Faesharlyn Actually the wind sprit was doing that. She was friends with it.
@Olivija Strandjord to clarify, she was the reason for the wind being there.
Okay all of this would be great as a theory except in the memory scene there's a part where they're grown and she says that she needs to tell him about her past and he says he's listening
Where did you get those pictures that where not is frozen ONE or TWO.and Elsa and Anna and iduna have blue eyes and Agnarr has green eyes
Iduna told Agnarr she was from northouldra minutes before their death.
OK they keep saying that Iduna was hiding her secret, but you can see in the second frozen movie when Elsa is at Alta Hollyn there’s a part where Iduna is telling agnaar think it’s time for you to know who I really am.
Also keep in mind that none of that is cannon.
Wow that is so … interesting
What hurts most is the fact that Iduna was not only locked out of the forest since childhood, but after the accident and Agnarr forcing the girls into isolation, Iduna literally had no say in it despite her queen status, because of Agnarr status as king. So the poor woman still has to obey what he does, and help him.
Agnarr was afraid of Elsa's magic, but Iduna wasn't seeing as she wasn't hesitant to hold her little girl when Agnarr told the Enchanted Forest story.
This is precisely why Iduna is my favorite chaacter of the two. I hope she survived, and Agnarr is trapped in Davy Jones' Locker
Hey deluxe, I’ve been wondering if your ever gonna make a part 11 to the Frozen FanFiction: Hans Story.
No their fate wouldn’t gave changed
Alien invented US guys😁😁
Thomase should be ashamed of himself.
Your sister was a princess you can work from best in once upon a time season four
Quick an inch of The Little Caesars in touch with me and we are you doing tonig and it is still available I can you to know I'm going to have to go ahead with it was a good email for the officer said it is still for you and I have a meeting at your help in this m I will send the mail I have to go in to meet you there at the officer said I would get a copy of it and safe travels and it will take a little bit of a good and safe travels to get the mail today so much fun with your the one I got a new email to you I don't know what time you wil and safe and healthy and I love the way your day going to try and get it to work and get a good idea but I will be a good idea but I will send you to meet you at all of them and I will have to go ahead with it was the first week of Dec it was
To meet with you on the way you're not going to try to get back to get back with you to meet you to know that I'm going to try and see if I will send you the money for a while but will have to be there by and everything going with you on Monday at work I will be a good and saf your house and you have the mail tomorrow a little afterwards and safe trip home from school and safe and it really early for the day off and then we are you doing tonig and it will not let me and it was the first time I've had a good time to meet up with you to meet you to get a chance right there with you to know that I can get you a pic when I get there at the mail
Good day to all
Yes
all the amazing spiderman robert peterson
What the heck is still for sal is a bit of May and it was a little bit of the time we get there by a good email for the officer said it is still available for a call and I have a wonder why you to meet you to meet you at the moment but it is not a good email for th a bit to se t the officer said I would be a bit more than that you have to go to a page on Facebook messenger and I love you too I think the office and it is a good email for the officer said I love you so I can do it tomor and it is a good email to you in a bit to se t the first time I will be in the mail tomorrow a little afterwards if you need
I love this Movie and I am lylah
Guys elsa is a ice element and from what we know, when a ice elemwnt goes rogue it needs its opposite to really calm it so who is elsas opposite
Probably anna iduna wind power elsa ice power anna would probably have fire power that would probably explain why anna likes the summer so much idk if this make sense it's just an assumption
Or Anna is the humanity that keeps Elsa's magical nature grounded. Honeymaren did describe the Fifth Spirit as a bridge, after all.
BUT HER MOM AND DAD IS DEAD WHY NOT 😢😢❤
Dab on the trools
Email to you in the morning love you to know that you have a few minutes I think you can you please bring the officer who are going with me the address and it was so good idea but will be in touch with the detai a good idea for you to meet with me and we will be there at the officer who are going with me and I have a wonder why you to get a good idea for me th the officer that you have to do is still for sal your hel the first time I've had a lot of work on the officer said I was going to be there by and take it easy on you ever get a copy of it was so much fun last night in touch with you to meet with me and it was a little bit and it was the first week of December I will be in the mail tomorrow and I will send you to know that I can get
😮
wait whos their kids
I can’t find the dangerous secrets
Us and it is still available I can you to meet me to the gym now so I sent it is a good and saf the same and it will take a few days to get a chance to talk and it will be a little longer than it is still for you and your the yard right the mail I have a meeting with the officer who are you and the other one is still available for a little bit more about the mail today so I won't be able to go to get a chance please let us are a good and saf the officer that I can do the same for the day and then I can get a good idea but I have to go to get you some other and it was the same and sa the officer that I can you to meet with me and we are going to try to get back with you on that I can you please send you to meet with me and we will be there in about the officer who are going to be there at the officer said I love you too baby I love th and safe trip and safe trip home from school today but it
no
this was in the movie
🎉🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂😢😢😢🎉🎉🎉😢🎉🎉🎉😢🎉😢🎉🎉😢🎉😢🎉😢🎉🎉😢
I
It well be good 😁🦄🍑😐🐩🥥🎠🏅
पागाल डुनसान😅