OSHA BLEEDS THE KYBER CRYSTAL WAY TOO EASILY...
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- In the season finale of Star Wars the Acolyte , Osha takes Sol's lightsaber and bleeds the blue crystal to a red crystal and it happens way too easily.
In this video, I go over the differences between Darth Vader bleeding his kyber crystal compared to Osha bleeding her kyber crystal and just how easily she was able to do it compared to vader.
I hope you enjoy the video, and may the force be with you!
Instagram - StarWarsTalkOfficial
Twitter - StarWarsTalks
why anakins lightsaber didnt just instantly turn red when he invaded the temple then?
Who knows 🤷♂️
He definitely had more hatred and range than osha has ever experienced so it would make sense for him if it would have.
Because bleeding a Kyber crystal to red wasn't canon until 2017. It was shown in the David Soule comic.....and was labeled canon.
@@starwarstalk_ she hulk logic. Banner had like more than a few movies to control his anger, she hulk could do it, because 'wamen are better at controlling anger'
For me it has nothing to do with gender or anything I just think the writing was all over the place
This is a good point too
As far as I've seen, it seems that the cristal has been broken and the hilt was damaged, allowing for Osha's hands to touch the cristal
In the comic, Vader's only able to bleed the crystal once he had touched the cristal, as Osha did
Also, Osha made her choice immediately because she had already experienced the Light and lived for a long time in the shadows of Sol's failure, being convinced to even betray her own twin sister in order to "make things right"
So she did the same things, just a lot faster because of episode lenght
Of course, this is my understanding as a writter myself. I sense their intentions, but I've got to say...
I had a bad feeling about this
Plus, in the close up you can see little black veins in her hands. My assumption was that was more than dirt. I figured that was the darkness literally flowing through her and thus around the crystal
I mean ol boy in Jedi Survior bled that shit easy as hell too. He just had built up rage for eons.
Yeah I think that’s really the difference
His wasn't fully bleed. He ended up with an orange blade
I imagine that bleeding a crystal inside of the hilt would damage the lighsaber. The shockwave could easily damage some internal components. Bleeding a crystal is a very violent process.
Bleeding the crystal SHOULD be a violent and crazy process, but not in this show I guess
@@FormerlyDuck2 I think having the lightsaber activated would make all the difference here. With the blade on all that energy coming off of the crystal actually has an exit point so there’s no build up and no blast like we see in Jedi survivor.
@@chancellorpalpatine4035 I guess but that feels kind of lame
Rumor has it that some stage lights fell on an actor at Disney and he spent several months in the hospital. The same day they were working with the script for the Acolyte and hadn't settled on a name for one of the characters, they were served paperwork for the lawsuit, and that's how they came up with the name "Osha".
😂😂😂
If they misuse plagueis I'm never gonna forgive them
AND YODA. They better treat these characters with respect.
@@starwarstalk_ Yoda I've already accepted is fucked, if they're willing to overlook the ramifications of putting Ki Adi Mundi in this show then they're gonna fucking destroy Yoda. The best thing they could possibly do is just have Vernestra lie to him at the beginning of the season like she started to do at the end of the episode and he says some bullshit about "always in motion, the future is" and then leave him out of the rest of the show.
@@mortalitydoesstuff8965 yeah absolutely. They didn’t think about what would happen if they put Ki Adi Mundi in the show for whatever reason. Even though it destroys the lore of the LEGITIMATE CANON MOVIES. It baffles me…
Yeah please either have Yoda say one line or have him say something like “know everything that has happened, I do.” And then proceed to release every single Jedi from the council that has lied or not come forward.
I was thinking this too. There's no way she bled it so quickly and easily. It should have turned orange or at least purple.
EXACTLY. I think purple makes the most sense as she’s clearly in a battle between good and bad. She doesn’t convince me that she’s bad at all
@@starwarstalk_ Man this is the first video of yours that I've seen and wish I could have found you sooner. I'm glad you agree with me and consider me subscribed😁
Thing is that Vader still had a struggle with the light. Padme even said that there is good in him still. Thing with Osha was that while she did train with the Jedi she still had struggles with holding her emotions in check. Being told all these years that Mae killed their mother. And if you paid attention, which I don’t think you did, she did not believe Mae when she tried to explain what happened before their fight. It was hearing Sol explaining what happened that tipped her anger, the father figure who killed her mother and blamed her sister for his own selfish actions. The thing about the dark side is not necessarily that it is more powerful than the light side but how quickly you can obtain that power by giving into that hate. Also remember that Dagan Gera was able to bleed his Kyber Crystal with ease as well.
Dagan was full of hatred, and was stuck essentially frozen for hundreds of years holding onto that anger. He was waiting until he was unstuck so unleash havoc in my opinion.
@@starwarstalk_ and so did Osha. All those years living with the failure of not becoming a Jedi. Then finding out her mother was killed by the person who she looked up to as a father figure and him lying to her tipped her over the edge. See the difference between Osha and Anakin was that Anakin still had Padme that kept him from losing himself to the dark side when he killed the sand people and after the siege of the Jedi temple he still wasn’t completely gone because of Padme and his unborn children. Now Osha on the other had did not have that.
I think maybe because of some writing issues or acting issues it was just hard for me personally to believe that Osha even thinks she’s achieved going to the dark side. There wasn’t much emotion
They tried to make her look cool but the problem is most people don’t like her, it’s more cringe than cool
The acting was just very lackluster, and extremely emotionless.
Thank you for a civil explanation. So many sites hurl insults and the "w" word while explaining their disappointment.
Absolutely! I’m here to show my opinion, but also to be civil at the same time. I love Star Wars. It’s my favorite franchise of all time, genuinely.
Thank you for checking out my video/channel! Have a great day 😁
You gladly ignore the wider story telling to support your argument. Sol didn't give a valid reason.
If you think its valid for the Jedi to take children away. Control who can use the force. And kill those who don't comply. Because that is what happened.
Sol didn't apologise for what he did. Not once. He killed their mother and lied about it all the time she was with him, till that point.
Her anger and hate was insular. She was in shock. That's what shock looks like. An overwhelming collision of emotion that can't be expressed outwardly.
Vaders bleeding experience all happened within his head, plus Vader was always conflicted. Always. Even in that comic, it's there to see, he turns on his master and goes back to obi wan,thats why it took more effort for Anakin to bleed the crystal. But the visions would have been happening in an instant, not drawn out over hours.
Osha was not mentally present from the point she started to choke Sol. Her crystal was being bled from the moment she heard the truth. Anger and hate doesn't not always present it self as shouting, frowns and tears.
I wasnt blown away by the acolyte. But I will always observe content with a critical eye. And apply exterior context to it. I think you've missed things out or not gone far enough in your analysis to help weight your argument.
I think for the audience, it would make much more sense if they showed some type of emotion. Throughout the show we didn’t get much of that at all. It seems bland in my opinion
Disney did great things with the kyber crystal bleeding concept. It's much more interesting than the synthetic red kyber crystals in the old canon. But they are about to ruin it with stuff like this.
I also think it is an AMAZING concept and idea, poorly executed here, I think.
Ehhhhh the bleeding of a Crystal I think is more of a meter of where your hate is at at that moment. In Vader’s early years hate was sort of a secondary emotion, he was mostly just sad. Oshas super hate that she has I guess lol, doesn’t take awake from Vader. All it has to do is with where they are at mentally.
I can see that argument too. I just think at the end of the day, that part of the vader comic creates genuine emotion for the reader, whereas the scene in the show does nothing for the audience
@@starwarstalk_ yeah I agree. It was some fan service. The last episode they just tried to stuff a bunch of random stuff in lol ie Yoda/Plagues/Crystal etc lol
It's laughable too because all of the other episodes were sooooo lame. Like $180 million? Every episode should be lit.
@@starwarstalk_ yeah idk why with that 180 mil they don’t hire some decent actors lol. I think a good portion of why the show sucked was that Osha/Maes character needed like a god tier actor to make work and that’s not what Amandala was lol
No one can beat Hayden Christensen as Anakin 💪
OSHA is not a person, she is the force itself, why wouldn't it be easy?
Osha being “the force itself” causes more issues to the plot of Star Wars then it helps
I don’t think she’s the force itself. She’s just one being split into two.
@@chancellorpalpatine4035 agreed
You're right.
Anakin had so much trouble because he's still in conflict with himself, even when he's ruthless. Anakin never "died". Anakin having a hard time is more canon breaker because everyone else had it easy. Anakin struggling with it shows more about how conflicted he always was.
For example: as soon as he finds out Luke is his son, he is willing to completely 180 and overthrow Sidious together. Seems out of character for a guy with no internal struggle.
I absolutely get your point, and its not a bad point of view either. Still Makes Anakin unique
i loveeeee the prequels and OT lol
@@starwarstalk_ I think having that point of view helps with swallowing that it's easier for other characters to bleed their saber. They flirt with the Dark side so it's easier to fully embrace it, whereas Anakin did it because he wanted to save people, not because he was angry. He flirted with the light when he was in the dark side the whole time.
Sadly, I think Leslie showed it this way to show how powerful her own chosen one was. And ain't that shit sad.
No that’s not why it happened. Look at Sol’s lightsaber when she’s bleeding it. The crystal is exposed in a broken hilt. That’s the only reason it changed.
ANAKIN IS THE TRUE CHOSEN ONE
I completely agree. My thing with the kyber crystals was that she never experienced the crystal fighting back Osha's attempt to bleeding and she just bleeded with no resistance from the crystal. I guess that Disney forgot that the crystals are living and they will resist. 😕
It really frustrates me that they don’t seem to acknowledge this. Her crystal barely resists for about 5 seconds and then lets go. If you also notice, she never gets sith eyes either, just like Qimir.
The crystals are living, and Disney seems to not remember their own lore…
It’s disheartening
Well, you guys forget a detail here. That is legends stuff. And no, this is not a "Disney is against legends", as George Lucas himself also stated during his time, that he'd only consider the movie stuff, his own work, as hard canon. And this also includes, funny enough, the books and comics released alongside the movies, which are just inconsistent af. To give one mere example, in the official book to the prequels Windu is described to have a blue light-saber.
These are not continuity issues. These are at best interpretation differences. Also, fun fact to the side, Anakins lightsaber had a cinematic, not lore, reason to not turn red in Revenge of the Sith. Geourge Lucas acknowledged that a red lightsaber would visually conflict with the lava-design of Mustafar in the duel with Kenobi. Thus he kept his blue lightsaber.
The biggest problem is, and that is the legacy George Lucas left for Star Wars, Star Wars was never about consistency. It is more or less a space-opera in which the "rule of cool" supersedes anything. But it gets even funnier than that.
Consistency is something that... Disney brought into Star Wars. By officially decanonizing (again, GL already did that, but no one seems to remember) all of legends stuff, everything besides the movies. They also decanonized the original CW series. And they did that for a simple reason, to make a consistent storytelling possible from then on.
This though also meant that they would shovel a lot of stuff people really liked away into legends. And yeah, we could put George Lucas back in charge, but guess what, he only considered the movies, his movies, as canon. Everything else was interesting and cool, but nothing he would have to follow.
Sure, it is easy to blame Disney, but... it has never been different. Funny enough, these entire debates and aggression towards story writers was one of the reason Lucas sold Star Wars, as he didn't want to have anything to do with this kind of stuff.
@@starwarstalk_ This isn't the first time bleeding a crystal was shown. Dagan Gera in the Jedi Survivor game bled his crystal very easily. So watch that. But then again, Dagan had decades locked in a bacta tank for that anger to really build. Also, Dagan was incredibly powerful.
I’ve played the game and recognize that about Dagan. But like you said he was in that tank for a long time.
Also that scene where he bleeds the crystal is him thoroughly explaining why he did so. The Jedi turned against him and tanalorr, and it caused him so much pain anger and suffering as a result.
IDK i may be misinterpreting this and might get hate but the way I saw osha bleed the lightsaber seemed to have had assistance from qimir/ smiloren, ill get into this in a second, as there are a few factors i wanna go over, first its her old masters lightsaber, the master who was like a father to her, raised her and believed she could follow her dream of becoming jedi even though the entire time he was the reason for her mixed emotions as she didn't know he had lied and murdered her mother and coven. a lot of emotions about that betrayal and even more there is a connection through the force between sol and osha and connection between her and his crystal, we also hear in the episode that mae who has lived with the hatred of this betrayal for years and osha are actually one, two sides of the same person created using dark side rituals (witch) through a divergence in the force so all along the darkness has been in osha and most def in mae, meaning that osha feels all the years of pain from her "other self/ Twin" taking all this into consideration, plus the unknown hatred of smilo ren here is what i saw happen, Smilo ren looking for a new acolyte, has sensed the power in osha more so then in mae and has sensed osha's darkness (through both being near her when she wore the cortosis helmet and earlier through mae) he sees this is his chance to manipulate and turn her especially considering she just heard sols betryal and killed him with out a weapon (the feat he was previously trying to get mae to do) so now he can confirm osha is a far better candidate then mae, he sees the kyber crystal is exposed and that osha was close to this crystal and while she is still angered and confused he reaches out with the force and physically towards her and the saber, i believe Smilo Ren/ Qimir is the one who started the bleeding process connecting his hatred on top of osha's to the kyber crystal bleeding the saber to make osha believe she had fully embraced the dark, she doesnt realize this is happening which is why she is confused when the saber slowly turns red and she even looks like she cant believe she has fully embraced the dark, this completes smilo rens plan making her think its her idea to switch places with mae becoming the new Acolyte.
-TLDR-
Smilo Ren reached out through the force and started the bleeding of the crystal
this makes osha and us think she bleeds it and embraces the dark,
this completes smilo ren's manipulation to bring the more powerful twin (osha) to his side as his new acolyte/ apprentice
this is only my personal theory and based on my perception of the show, which i think overall wasnt as bad as people say but i can also see all the flawed writing. again this is just my opinion take it or leave it lol
I like your theory here a lot actually.
The only thing I still have a problem with, is even QImir's turn to the dark side is just boring and seems lame. He turns so he can do whatever he want. I think we need to see some crazy stuff that turned him to the dark side! In my opinion, we should've spent more time with Qimir's background that turned him to the sith rather than just seeing him as a bad guy. It's not very convincing. That being said, your theory is a good one. It does seem like she's surprised when it bleeds red so I could see it!
Hopefully they give you credit for that in season 2 haha.
@@starwarstalk_ i def think that if they do a next season they need to focus on qimir sharing his past and hatred with osha in a attempt to further solidify her fall from the light maybe more indepth in the relation between him and master venestra but yeah I could see them running with this who knows maybe we wont even get a season 2 and we will be left to forever wonder.
they could have made the crystal having plus or use shock wave effects
Agreed… new video today
@@starwarstalk_ if we didn't had flash back episodes, and have osha had form a pseudo family with the 3 Jedi that were killed I think that would be more viable on how the crystal turn red faster. Another theory I have is that Osha and Mei have some from there creation giving them an abnormal boost in the force but cause mental instability and if this were my choice internal degradation
dont give a shit yall acolyte haters trying to find anything to hate on it like what about seeing darth plageius, seeing the founder of the knighs of ren, seeing being bled for the first time in live action, best fight scenes since mustafar not including clone wars, like bro quit hating, and no she wasnt on the light sider her whole life she was manipulated by sol to go with him she had no idea that he killed her mother, and that mae setting the fire was an accident she had no idea she was manipulated by the jedi and when she found out the truth it led her to the path of the darkside despite how fast her lightsaber turned red it still shows that she became an acolyte.
If you liked it that much then I’m glad. There were parts that I thought were cool (notably some of the fights) but cmon… the slow motion parts of the fights were extremely lame. Not an “acolyte hater” it just wasn’t for me and I think you have to be okay with that just as much as I’m okay with you enjoying it.
The knights of ren thing is a theory I don’t think there’s anything backing that up other than his helmet kinda looks Renny lol
I don’t think it was the worst sw show ever but the show definitely deserves criticism. Fan service isn’t good writing. The bleeding crystal and Plagues playing peek-a-boo doesn’t make up for the shit ass acting and terrible pacing.
As much as there was a lot that I disliked with the show I do actually
Hope it gets a season 2 because I think a second season could patch up where it fell flat imo.
Criticism is always good. I sometimes think it’s funny how people come to my comments mad at my criticism of the show, yet they criticize my content.
I’m the one that has a $0 budget and makes videos because of my passion for Star Wars. Disney is giving out $180 million dollars for projects like this. I think it deserves criticism
Have very low expectations when it comes to Disney Star wars once they said the force has no gender I knew it would go downhill after that so let her have that rainbow 🌈 lightsaber
Couldn't agree more. It sucks because this time, they got the action right (the lightsaber fights were awesome) but the story, and if I'm being quite honest much of the acting as well, was just so bad. I wish they'd focus on KOTOR projects instead
I agree with you, the lightsaber fights and most of the fights as well were pretty well done. I heard that they got the people that did the end scene for rogue one to do some of the combat shots as well, which is really great! But the story, acting, and writing, were all completely lackluster.
I had no attachments to any characters (aside from a tad bit with Sol), and I thought the writing was all over the place. We need some real writers and directors back with Star Wars.
I think we need Andor’s team to create more stories.
It's not about honesty. This show is shite. The writing is abysmal. Every plot twist is foreseeable. FFS Lezly showed us a weirdo peeking around a cave wall. That's our introduction to a Sith Master Plaguis? Really?
Smylo and Osha holding hands looking at the ocean?
There is one way to redeem this awful show......don't cancel. Instead have a season 2 set 25-30 years in the future.....focus on Sheev Palpatine slicing up Smylo and both the twins and taking his place as Plagius' apprentice......then we see his progression to becoming a Sith Master.
I think there would’ve been some redeeming qualities if we had seen Darth tenebrous light up the sith characters in the show… but they won’t do it.
The writing to me was abysmal.
Well, as we know now "The Force is Female" and the also have the "Power of Many" So they need no training ,they only need to be sligthly aware of its existence to make full use of it !
Let’s gooooo!!!
Osha and mae
Sol is the villian of the alcolytes first season
From my point a view
The twins obviously came.from a loving family
In his way good intentions or otherwise
Sol had no right to murder the.girls family
Never come between a set of genuine loving parents and their children and their family
From my.point of view sol is a murderer beyond redemption
I can see that point of view
Degan gera did it ez tho, why did we gloss over that?
I’ve mentioned it a few times in other comments. I honestly think he did it easily too, but my only reasoning for that is because he was holding onto his hate for the Jedi for 1,000s of years at this point. Probably meditating in his head the entire time maybe even speaking to the force…
@@starwarstalk_ He was only a few hundred years old but fair point.
Bad faith argument, dagan gera does it in under a min
He was holding in hatred for 100s of years…
I’m hyped
Thanks for joining the live today!
Does Anakin even have time to bleed his crystal during all the commotion happened in Revenge of The Sith?
If it only takes a few seconds like it did for Osha, then I would say yes!
But bleeding crystals didn't exist back then
@@starwarstalk_ I see. But shouldn't a force user who's committed to the Sith needed to focus on the crystal inside their lightsaber to fully bleed it? It's untill Anakin became Vader is when he's really committed to the dark. While in RoTS, he's only doing so for his own gain. Which was to save Padme from death. Even if he has time, I don't think he's committed that time.
And what I said really made what was shown in the Acolyte more stupid. Because Osha wasn't even focusing her nonexistent hatred on her lightsaber. Sure, she's gripping it super intensely. But her hatred isn't fully focus on it.
My conclusion, never let or trust someone to direct a Star Wars series or film with a mindset like they're making a Hazbin Hotel series. And that's already bad.
Yes, there should be a level of focus and time in changing your crystal to red! That’s why I love how Vader does it in the comics. He had to focus so hard on doing it, and he failed multiple times.
The acolyte just throws that focus aspect into the garbage. Osha is focused on SOL and what he did, and her lightsaber turns red. Interesting
The writing was terrible
@@AfterthymeGaming she’s touching the crystal itself with her bare hand. That’s why it changed.
I feel like it would have worked better if she used the lightsaber to kill Sol. It would still be a bit easy, but thematically I think it works better if her hate flows through the lightsaber in the killing blow.
I agree with you on that! I think that would have made way more sense. It’s crazy how bad the writing has been.
@@starwarstalk_because ur a writer right 🙄
Boy did you forget Jedi survivor? Vader had trouble, but it seems everyone after it had it easy. All those inquisitors with a red lightsaber, I have a hard time thinking It's that hard. If anything, the vader comic writer wanted to emphasize his remaining light side, and what could have been If he did the right thing.
It's a matter of interpretation.
It's not that deep. Love the vader comics tho, just wouldn't use that as a comparasion.
Ans not enough hatred? Boy she literaly just slowly killed her master while he was saying "It's ok", if anything she had a lot more sure of her anger than Kylo ren did when he killed Han Solo. Vader was conflicted, Osha was not.
Survivor is goated btw. Cant wait for the next one
Vader only struggled because there was always that tiny sliver of goodness in him. The same goodness that defeated Palpatine eventually.
Does osha not have ANY good in her?
The Inquisitors probably had synthetic crystals. Those can be made red much more easily.
they definitely did
What about how easily Dagan Gera bleeds his crystal? Mid conversation with no visions or struggle... It's almost like you're cherry picking reasons to hate...
@@Bobdobbinks the guy that hated the Jedi and was frozen for thousands of years just sitting on his hate and anger? At least he has more emotion when he does it.
@@starwarstalk_ he was in unconscious in suspended animation, he wasn't sitting on his emotions for thousands of years. Osha found out that the man that raised her, wanted to indoctrinate her so badly that he murdered her mother, her family, willingly made the choice to let her sister die so he could take her away, and then lied and blamed it all on the (supposedly) dead sister.
Emotions can be internalised, the point of bleeding the crystal is to convey the level of rage, pain and betrayal she felt in that moment.
@@Bobdobbinks you should look up Dagans story, it’s really crazy!
But yeah I definitely get that emotions can be internalized, I feel like I had a hard time reading any emotion from her throughout the show which is an issue for a viewer in my opinion
@@starwarstalk_ I've replayed the game several times now, and read the expanded material, I find him quite a boring villain tbh. He wears his emotions on his sleeve, shouts and screams all the time, and there's nothing in his story that's particularly new or interesting.
To me, he becomes more interesting in the wider context of the high republic itself, where jedi are more empathetic to the galaxy around them compared to the prequels, but, like with cases like Sol, Elzar, Avar, etc., those feelings become unhealthy attachments that cause them to fall from the true path more often.
Tbh I was glad that she wasn't screaming and raging as she turned, that feels like treating the audience like they're dumb in my opinion. Her entire world view has been confirmed as a lie, she kills sol and then collapses into silence as she tries to process it all, the corruption of the crystal is there to clue the audience in on how it's settling in for her.
Why not complain about Dagen Gera?
@@thatcacci9304 bro was sitting on his hatred for the Jedi for HUNDREDS of years… plus the scene where he actually bleeds his crystal is way more emotional.
People don't anderstand what is the dark side the dark side is not about been evil or hate or anger is about fellings
It’s literally about hate, anger, and suffering. Quoted from Yoda btw.
You sir...... don't understand either.
Love lead to fear fear to anger anger to hate all of those are fillings the difference of the light and the dark side is dark side are emocional and the light is template and law no tellings you need to read a lot of SW dude you bare still bin your dampers
No idea what you’re saying.
Of course you don't understand, you don't know anything about the SWU and what daekside really is, like I told you, you think you know and you're in diapers.
Snoke voice she is no Darth Vader
Hahaha
Is not hate and and anger is a rush of felling learn more about the canon dude
I absolutely know the canon + lore. Did you watch the video? Look at the difference it takes for DARTH VADER to bleed his crystal vs. OSHA. Vader fails several times to bleed his, yet osha first try?
@@starwarstalk_. Why does everyone’s experience have to be the same? Your argument is that one person cannot do it easily because someone else had difficulty doing it. What kind of argument is that?
Take any skill ever. Anyone can learn that skill. Some people pick it up very easy. Some people find it so difficult they give up. Some people master the skill but it takes longer
Keanu Reeves learned how to master a gun for the movie John Wick
So let’s say any random person wants to learn how to handle a gun like John Wick. You are basically saying that Keanu Reeves said a bar and that no one is allowed to master that skill, any faster than what he did. Period. End of discussion. For the sake of argument, let’s say it took him one year to learn their skills. You’re saying that no one can ever learn that skill faster than one year or it’s just not realistic.
The simple fact is some people will pick it up faster than Keanu Reeves. And some people will take longer to learn that skill.
Sorry, but saying this scene, her ability to do this, is invalid because she didn’t do it the same way someone else did is just horrible.
Never said the scene was invalid, just thought the process of turning the crystals colors seemed genuinely easy. I guess I just didn’t really feel the emotion in the scene but that’s just me. It’s also my opinion and that’s really all it is at the end of the day
@@starwarstalk_ Be careful, the series is bad but it has very redeemable things and the bleeding was great because it was not only the moment, it was everything he told his sister before about the hatred he had for her because of his mother and his teacher came to tell him that he loves her just when he finds out that he killed his mother it was obviously a load of very strong emotions and in Ani's case it was so difficult because he was really trained as a Jedi and he already had many of his feelings suppressed That's why it was so difficult for him to have that rush of overflowing emotions to be able to achieve the bleeding. I do believe that the scene was well done.
@@starwarstalk_ no one connected with Osha and Mae. That’s a big problem with the show. It’s possible the actress was the wrong person for the job. It’s possible, the show was edited/told incorrectly. I think it was a brilliant story. It was just not told in a very good way.
I think the bleeding crystal scene was incredible. But it would’ve been 1000 times better, it would’ve been something epic that we would talk about for 50 years, like Vader being Luke’s father, if we had actually cared about that character.