'India Lacks Sufficient Understanding Of China And Its Intentions'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ย. 2024
- NEW DELHI: It seems there's something wrong with India's understanding of China, even among top diplomats. That's the view of Hemant Adlakha, professor of Chinese at JNU who answered questions on the The Gist programme.
Prof. Adlakha argues that India needs to carefully track whatever China says and what it does. While both may seem at variance with each other, they in fact go together. He suggests that India must carefully study China's claims to Indian territory, gently hinting that India's claims in Ladakh and other places may not rest on very sound foundations.
He believes that clashes like the one at Yangtse in Tawang late last year, actually help China. Tune in for more in this conversation with Prof Hemant Adlakha.
#india #china #arunachalpradesh #tawang
Since many of our well-wishers requested a UPI payment id to contribute and support us, here’s the link, which gives us 100% of what you choose: stratnewsgloba...
You can also click and buy a TH-cam Super Thanks(the heart icon where you liked this video), which directly supports StratNewsGlobal, with 70% of your chosen amount.
Leave your comments, questions and feedback. Like and share our videos.
Subscribe to our TH-cam channel. Click on the 🔔icon to get notified of our latest uploads.
To get instant updates join our telegram circle - t.me/stratnews...
JNU prof is actually trying to threaten India on Cheen's behalf...
He is actually spitting facts.
@@anuttampani1271 he contradicted himself at the end by saying that Cheeni Scholars say this is a game...
@@skg901 he was telling what the scholars and media are talking in China. The prof. Studied the media nicely. He said that the Chinese wants to destroy some post and gain some trategic point. I think India govt must take LAC more seriously and increase its patrolling in whole Lac from Ladakh to AP and more clash are coming.
@@anuttampani1271:he’s a joke. He’s merely trying to interpret from what Chinese media wants the world to know. Pathetic fellow.
Surya Gangadharan is an absolute professional. Even with a highly biased guest like Prof Hemant Adlakha. Surya is an asset for Strat News.
A JNU professor amplifying Chinese propoganda.
Not unexpected.
If this is propaganda, why didn't india report this incident for an entire day, and all that came out was a video from months ago.
@@anuttampani1271 India was the first one to report, there may be operational necessities because of which it was reported a day late. Anyway, why do you need same time reportage?
Chinese amassing of such large troops during GALWAN clash is not possible ,without getting approval from very top from CPC.
So its not some local issue , that JNU professor is saying.
That is how the Chinese top bosses want their own gen pop & the world to see it.
They want everyone to think that these incidents are nothing worth writing home about.
What they are doing on the ground tells the real story....
Completely vague this guest speaker. Like 1+1=11.
The JNU professor is a true admirer of China and he had no business to draft a headline that China was victorious without any basis.
His explanation now given is very weak.
His questioning by Surya is very telling.
Prof. Adlakha has dedicated his entire life in studying China, and he has a very clear and deep understanding of how China thinks and works. All he is doing here is putting an expert analysis of what the Chinese think about the current situation. It is very important to understand the enemy, and it is the field in which we lack. Maybe because of language or the unavailability of information from China to the outside world. Prof. Adlakha is only bringing out the talks that are going on in Chinese local news and social media. Now it is up to our policymakers to draw conclusions from it and act accordingly.
I think this is what an expert is supposed to do.
Absolutely correct!
Whatever this professor says needs to be verified and analysed from a military perspective by Indian Army and our strategic thinkers.There is absolutely no rational that Our Media which is an independent media ,unlike that of China ,should discuss about what China's Media ,which is obviously controlled by their state,who refused to give even the covid numbers recently after spurt in covid cases,says about Tawang or Galwan or the entire border dispute with India.
All the info which we Indians have about China comes from western scholarship, western media, western think tanks and western politicians. But at the same time, Indians love to disbelieve western commentary about Indians affairs, and call it biased, anti-Hindu, propaganda, etc. It is important to study your potential enemy of your own. Do not disbelieve every Chinese source as state propaganda.
Are u really that naive? Private media lie all the time. Haven't u watched CNN and BBC? They are all "private media" and yet they collaborate with the CIA. India is no exception.
The are many China B-Teamers in JNU. Like the biggest one Kishore Mahbubani
@@Parasuram5 He's a Singaporean, isn't he? How is he from JNU?
Totally incoherent analysis - if this is the quality of “research” at JNY, one can see why the university is viewed with contempt from the wider community.
You want to get pro_India opinion, watch Indian mainstream media. They all propagate the same western propaganda and western content. But why you shout when the same western media shows India and Hindus in bad light?
JNU professor - "I DON"T KNOW" It is pathetic to say Chinese are not opaque. JNU should be disbanded at the earliest.
The professor narrated the Chinese prospective towards India .. now let's wrap up one china policy 💯 so war is inevitable
Nobody is talking of two China policy- not even the Taiwanese !!! If anything has to happen then India should have to be politically more closer to Taiwan and Tibet. This is not going to happen so soon- unless the Pakistan issue is unwrapped !!! Wait and watch; few years in the life of Civilisational Nations is not asking too much. 🤔🤔😁😁😁⚔⚔⚔
The professor appears to be a stooge for the Chinese. He's only obfuscating deflecting & avoiding the issue . We need an anchor more confrontational than Surya Gangadharan to tackle such charlatans masquerading as Chinese experts .
The guest seems like on chinese payroll
After having wrongly titled why this prof.wasting others time.
The problem is that india has many shades of adhlakhas as warped, biased and anti govt of the day for whatever reasons! We respect that. But the inaccuracies and biases reinforcing a narrative since one is bought over cannot escape a common sensical observer. Pl convey this to him.
The problem is Indians don't undertake independent study on China. All their scholarship on China is of western origin, which is biased obviously. The same Indians hate to believe any western commentary about India or any western media opinion about India.
This professor is from JNU, that is enough to understand his loyalty
Largely a dissatisfying discussion - it was not very clear what the Prof was getting at apart from his unhappiness with Indian newspaper correspondents in China :) His Chinese scholarship seems to have affected his ability to speak straight & to the point. Dissenting & heterogenous views are most welcome but his awkward commentary was quite confusing. The Prof seemed to be rather conscious of appearing to have sympathies & admiration for the Chinese. He need not be - after all there are many CPC admirers like him all over the world.
Yaa!! He made us felt like he is scared from something. Even though being scholar his main duty is to put his views as coherently as possible and let audience decide for themselves.
This guy is a Chinese mouthpiece. How blindly he is ready to accept Chinese stories, but does not accept anything Indian. A balanced discussion would have been better.
A rare sight to see Surya gangadharan ji gets impulsive and emotional when" he said we lost a colonel and 20 odd soldier " when professor was praising China's point of view
The big problem with India and Indian media when dealing with China is that India carries a very big historical baggage. Since losing the border war in the 1960s, India and Indian media could not rest until the score is settled. This historical baggage is unnecessary and counterprodictive. If we weigh ourselves down with history, we'd lose the present and the future.
He shifts his eyes from the camera - can’t even look at himself when lying
I don’t think there is any problem in understanding China. The fact is that they have grown in wealth and power and so their attitude has changed.
Chinese attitude never changed . But their economy and military had grown much faster bigger than india. Now the chinese are flexing their muscles
Does the learned guest of the show expect China to welcome a stronger India? Does he expect progressive building of excellent infrastructure at Indian side to marginalise their (Chinease) infra advantage will be welcomed with open hands? Aren't China famous for information warfare and their so called scollar are only a part of it? Is it wise to believe China who even disown their solders who laid down their lives during Galwan? Okay, he has his democratic right to opine and so do we have our right to reject his version.
If this are the scholars of Bharath than May the Gods and Goddess have mercy on it,s people...
Sounds true, even though Chinese and Indian peacefully coexists for the past 2000 years!
Throughout discussion I heard only ,perhaps.....I don't know ...that's what they are saying
Humans and apes are from the same family tree in the animal kingdom. We share 99% of our DNA with them. Humans possess intelligence far exceeds that of apes. When a colony of apes are trapped by a forest fire, in spite of the impending disaster, they don’t stop squabbling and fighting amongst themselves for territory and control.
Are we humans behaving any better than apes? You tell me. Our planet is deteriorating right before our eyes threatening the existence of every human being on this planet and those yet to be born. Yet, we’re squabbling over territory disputes and fighting petty geopolitical games.
India and China, the two oldest human civilizations, need to work together to address our shared destiny and the survival of the human species. Stop our squabbles. Stop the irrational hate and suspicion between the two peoples. Press our governments and politicians to start behaving like humans instead of apes.
Sense of entitlement by the Chinese for the all the hooliganism and playing victim card....
An absolute Naive Bookworm..
wasted my time.
India's reading of Cheen is accurate, precise and very much actionable.
They are 'better organised'...so, multiple border disputes of past were 'local incidents'? If they were, are their local commanders so bold as to take such actions without consent of politial leadership? Both seems contradictory to be honest. Either they can be better organised or these incidents were never just 'local'.
Another confusing statement: We have fallen into Chinese traps...okay, trap for what? Make India hate them? Push India into USA's arm? How can making a semi-neutral country your full blown enemy can be a strategic move?
I'm sorry but I'll have to accept my inability to take his assertions at face value.
Indian and China has many aspect to work with eg stability in west asia. Which two countries interest converge
Defeating India or sponsor insurgents in India has never been China's policy
This is the level of a professor! Now I understand why JNU is in news for all the wrong reasons.
Knowing Chinese position and thinking is important but Professor Adlakha seems naive to a certain extent. If his point is to do research then that is valid. His point on the poor levels of Indian reporting is correct. There is no analysis in the media of any substance and intellect, just sensationalism at best and at worst regurgitating what is known. I also agree that the border issue is seen by the Chinese as a local issue. That said there just should be no debate in India - it is aggression against India - and Indian politicians have been meek in the past. Strengthen your armed forces to keep your territory and regain that lost in time.
Agree that better research is required and our strategic experts and diplomats need ti focus in China better. But Chinese narrative propagation through JNU scholars like Dr Hemant definitely needs to be discouraged
Issue is , Chinese media will interpret things from their perspective but is it believed by the world?
Thank you Surya garu for putting such very wise and intelligent questions,Chinese policy is to hide the truth and there is no transparency in it and it widely known fact
No transparency?!? READ CHINESE, fool.
@@ajwo5984 ok peanut pen*s chowmeen
@@ajwo5984 🐷CCP🐷💥😁😂🐗😁💥💥💥😂😂
@@ajwo5984 Get educated..ping pong
@@ajwo5984 🇨🇳xi🇨🇳Pig🐽🐖🇨🇳
*Nice to see Chinese, who look like Indians* 😂
Ye kaunsa XiXiPee Ghulam paradise laye ho.
He is in one sentence saying he thinks Xinese are open in THIS case.
Next sentence he generalizes that Zinese are transparent system.
Pathetic programme.
Login out
I have a map, but I cannot show it to you. Is this how you prepare your lectures/seminars/ tutorials?
This is what you get from 20 th century intellectuals who haven't evolved yet!!
Clear as mud. The professor appears to be a Shantidoot or Aman ki asha from JNU. It appears to me from his English that he thinks he is giving us a Sandesh from the Chinese side. All I could understand otherwise is that we need to understand Chinese better by reading articles from other news outlets than just The Global Times. If the Chinese media were to be so truthful now with tons of content about the recent incident, then does that mean what they have said very little since Galwan were all lies?
Are there commentators based in Taiwan who could decipher chinese designs clearly and our media could access them to better understand and be warned about their intentions?
Why should India understand China,it is noth side who should understand each other.
One of the finest , intense and deeply exploring discussion between Surya Gangadharan ji and Professor Adlakha. The good thing is that Prof Hemant Adlakha has been able to put his perspective and / or understanding of the China's way of looking at the border disputes with India. Yes, perhaps, we need to have better understanding and debate about China's broader vision. We have to have better understanding of how Chinese like the world to see them in 21st century.
However, it is unfortunate if the starting point of China's understanding is that India is an "apple in the American eyes ". How are China's interpretations of Indian stand on Russo- Ukraine war/ conflict, Kosovo / Serbia .. !!?? During Mao's time Chinese had had a sense of ideological underpinning of the world events; that way of looking at the world events is missing now !!?? Have the Chinese become more nationalistic now ; after the Dengist reforms period !!?? Does Prof Hemant Adlakha look at China as a centrally controlled state system !!?? 🤔🤔⚔⚔
Did the Chinese patrol returned to their base or breached the LAC in Yangtze? Statements are issued for public consumption and their is no record that says who won. So any assumption on the score shows he is working for a fee given by interest groups.
This professor believes in Chinese reports, that's very wise of him. Firstly the area belongs to Tibet/ Indian. China has occupied. Why believe in their reports? #
May be in some deep recesses of our strategic think tanks there is a cold, hard, psycho-political understanding of China. From what passes on TV shows, it all comes across retranslation of us/western assessment of China's strategy, mindset, intentions, and vulnerabilities etc. Indians need critical assessments that explain Chinese day-to-day activities and actions from Indian lens. If you had followed the western assessments and intentions before the Shanghai Communique, India would have been left holding the bag when China became an existential threat for US/west overnight.
The respected Prof kept harping on the China trap but fell short of explaining what that trap is or its consequences. Maybe he is just skeptical of our current policy.
I saw a great documentary on the Sino-India war. The unilateral retreat in 1962 has a Mao side and a geopolitical side. Mao liked India and praised it for its non-aligned stance. But China has a historical promise to reclaim its lands stolen by the British Empire. India was claiming part of Chinese lands, which triggered the war. Mao never wanted to fight India. He admired India as a fellow nation liberated from the same content in the first place.
Mao shaped the nation and its global ambition. He never wanted to taint China's image as an aggressor. After the Chinese army wiped out the entire Indian front, the Indian PM uncharacteristically begged the US for support. India has zero forces left to do anything.
Mao never wanted India, a fellow ex-colony of the British, to beg the US. That's why he unilaterally removed Chinese forces.
It's sad that India is holding parts of China as the British legacy.
Hahaha fool nothing is china territory. It's a very small country which has illegally occupied Tibet , Xinjiang, inner Mangola, Hong Kong and Manchuria. And mao's Army retreated bcz of shortage of supplies and they couldn't hold the ground for long so instead of facing the defeat by retreating Indian Army, they choose to vacate the place by themselves
India has made it clear that it is willing to discuss for border issue settlement with the spirit of give & take, consideration for mutual security concerns etc. But china is not shown interest for talks yet.
@@mylord3003 China decoupled territory issue and their economic ties with India. They welcomed India to their Economic alliances.
India sees China through an unfavorable narrow nationalist lens. Also, politicians try to cash US's anti-China politics to get core technology transfer. People carry away with that card. Indian diaspora in the US and US media agitation have a lot to do with it.
The Asian century depends on China and India's cooperation. China's global leadership and Hindustan's cooperation.
We are half of the world, thanks to the Himalayas. Himalaya gave Hindustanis(India, Pakistan, Bangladesh) a great natural blessing, which China is deprived of. China can lead us to Asian enlightenment, whereas, the West considers us barbarians. India's non-aligned geopolitics needs to walk a fine line between China and the West.
A Sinophile like Hemant Adlakha fails to admit the fact that Indian troops were holding several Chinese as hostages. The more time spent with them the more information India gets. So why would India broadcast the scuffle? How much funding did this Professor get from China? How many free trips to China? Hemant is not alone. The king of MOU has already belittled Indian troops shortly after the clash.
On what basis you call him Chinese agent? Do you have any evidence? All you Indian urban folk are such pitiable western slaves with colonial mentality that you cannot study China of your own, but shamelessly believe everything western media and western academicians propagate about China. At the same time, you want to disbelieve the same westerner's opinion about India!
@@svrdev3931 Do you understand the difference between Sinophile and Chinese agent? Watch the interview again and you will see.
It's an eye opener. Totally different perception of the border issue from Chinese side. Our media knows nothing.
Interesting discussion.
What is there to understand? Did we not learn their intentions from 1962? Are we so naive not to understand their end objective and intentions even after hundreds of LAC violations each year? Enhance Military Strength so that we don't have to bother and waste too much time in "Understanding" their Next Salami Slicing move and Conduct "Over Analysis" in Studios and react everytime.
Or Else When the Time comes to take ACTION OR Fight, we'll b left doing all the "UNDERSTANDINGS" in the Studio..
As per adlakha CCP has been more truthful transparent frank & forthright...!!! ‼️⁉️
This discussion only goes to show that if you are open to learn, there could be multiple aspects of a subject. Congratulations Strat News in keeping an open instance on complicated issues such as this 👍.
Sir their is some news in social media that international Gangs are talking about South Asia without India what is the truth
Please select questions and ask experts their point of view.
Okay some game by some intentional with ambugity but why terrorists are protected with what great intention. Yes internal and external games under this some body want benefit out of it. But highest heads of country can't able to find out, means what from both sides
The bully always sets the tone of the conflict.
You mean India 🇮🇳 😂
What an idiotic discussion
For a moment I thot a chinese agent is invited to talk
Also , the questions n answers were all over the place , no objectivity, no conclusion….
There was nothing to learn here … waste of bloody time ….meaningless discussion
Different perspective. Interesting.
Rubbish
As per adlakha CCP has been more truthful transparent frank & forthright...!!! ‼️⁉️ & he's supposed to be a Chinese expert !!!
How does this professor have such a grade or title?
JNU produces such prof.. lol. something to do with the name of this Junk University !!
Thanks Surya garu.. for bringing these views.. Thanks Hemanth garu for your simple and clear analysis and view.
But Surya garu, your questions seem very one-sided (? maybe on purpose to ask most people's view) , but like your questions to be 'more curious' rather than pushing the guest to one-sided view. Regardless, appreciate inviting more views.
The professor seems to be a nefarious troll 😹
I think you invited him to give us the Chinese perspective!
I didn't subscribe your channel for this type of content!
Chinese coole at work it best to propegate it's agenda
For the first time I gave thumbs down to this channel!
A Chinese agent
The thumbnail is true
Professor is right. Our scholars couldn't predict the resentments happening in Chinese side due to border infrastructure push from India. Otherwise they could have guess march 2020 intrusions of Chinese. And on top of it Indian correspondence at Beijing don't speak Chinese 🤣🤣🤣😂😂
Love this video- a very different prescriptive about the border situation with Chee-na
This discussion was a pleasant surprise. I would love to hear Hemant Adlakha again on this channel. Probably, he can enlighten us more about the mindset of the Chinese people as well as CCP. He's so right. Global Times is a propaganda for the people outside China. But what about the propaganda fed to the Chinese people? I believe it is equally important to understand. No media/newspaper talk about it even though much of the information is available online. In other words, mainstream Indian media is lazy af.
Just keep a sharp eye on their actions. Ignore everything else. It's a smoke screen.
@@rakadus how does one keep track of 1.4 billion people?
India lacks everything...
Hopefully you are not from India
Rightly said, one major thing india is lacking is reeducation camps for rape jihad born inbred cousin rapist ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool Muslims
@@Striker-jg9kv exactly.. 👍
@@unconditionalnationalist6202 looks like a bat sheet eater from Wuhan . How's cheen coping with the latest variant of the Wuhan virus ?
🐷Xi🐽Pig 🐖🔥🔥🔥🔥
Biased opinion welcome
I wish more critical thinking scholars like him would speak out!!! I admire his bravery.😮