Joshua’s alleged girlfriend pregnancy rumors! (G)I-DLE’s Minnie leaves stage mid-performance!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2024
- Seventeen's Joshua is not taking a break as his alleged girlfriend keeps getting malicious comments from his fans! (G)I-DLE's Minnie had to leave stage mid-performance due to her worsening health conditions and fans are outraged! EXO's Sehun is enlisting and we have other news about more K-Pop idols!
Instagram: bit.ly/3NWCjW1
Twitter: bit.ly/3NyjmJS
Facebook: bit.ly/3OhuslH
#kpop #kpopnews #KOOKIELIT
these idols are gonna be 85 years old and yall are still gonna cry over them dating and having kids. yall need to grow up
yess Queen!
FACT
THIS- the marketed "boyfriend/girlfriend" fantasy is so dangerous tbh
@@That2004Kid yeah and then they get stalkers that are in love with them and it's scary
yeahhh exactly
i dont understand why joshua or his company isn't saying anything. Just say it that they are not dating even if they are dating. just sat it to these childish/toxic fans.
No one cares what u think. Shush
Poor Joshua, even if it were true, what business is it of fans? The fact these people have the entitlement thought process they use to justify the hate they are sending to that poor woman is disgusting and honestly, I hope she sues every one of them for harrassment and bullying. Get somebody on it now. Stupid people won't stop until more of a stand is taken against these actions.
LOL. It's so pointless to her the poor girl. We don't even know whether the pregnancy badge is hers or not since she was in her friend's cars. And it looks like in her post, she just wanted to show how bad the weather was and then people jumped to conclusions that she is pregnant. These people must be so bored
@@chickenhate_r Even if it were hers, its still ridiculous for them to send her that kind of hate. Like...be HAPPY for them...hell even if it weren't planned. If they are dating and all then they have been together for awhile which shows she is sincere and they love each other. I dont know why delusional people have to go and be mean about things.
Wait I heard that she is married and has a whole kid cause some fans researched deeper into this and found out she has a whole man and the whole rumour got disclosed.
@@kad4897 honestly this is my first time even hearing the rumor. So if that is the case then these people even dumber than I first assumed.
Joshua have solid fandom, I hope he can lean on real fans that will support him no matter what. As long as svt serve a banger, we fans dont have any rights to care who he banging. Wake up joshua fans, u guys should support ur idol. There is no problem even if Joshua starting his own family. Those fools fans who think their bias to stay single forever, while them going out banging someone and drooling over thirst trap also having their life but they want a innocent grown ups idols. Lol. Those fools should be thankful their idol have a healthy s*x life and taking on new step. Let those bro having their life. Agreed to disagreed.
Thought it said Minnie leaves g idle I almost had a heart attack
same
FRR
Minnie has such good stage presence, the best after Soyeon. It would be a huge loss if Minnie left G-idle.
OMG same!
Frfr😭😭😭
Joshua is almost 30!! LET HIM DATE!!!!
Fr
It never stop
Fr!!! He doesn’t even need anyone’s permission, people are just so entitled and weird
Fr like seventeen doesn’t even have that rule so WTH😂 and if you a true seventeen fan or just a kpop fan you definitely wouldn’t be butt hurt over that.
Ikr he has been in the industry for 8 years who are fans to criticize him
All the hates towards Joshua is so sad. None of it has been confirmed and I can nit imagine how much stress it is putting on him. I'll never understand how netizens believe idols owe them a relationship or something? They don't owe you nothing but that goes deeper into the entertainment industry. Even if they are true it is not our business and never was Joshua is a grown man that can do the things he wants.
I agree 100%.
Stf drama addict queen
Also his rumored gf is also getting hate its sad
I feel bad for Joshua and the girl's situation
It all unfair
I thought hybe does not allow dating or something.
@@Bettyjk-py8oothey allow dating but not publicly dating thus they never confirm relationships.
@@miavs2074 Ohh thanks for the info.
@@Bettyjk-py8ooPledis has no dating ban actually
Joshua is busy with promotions and his personal life is his own. Plus he is an older idol now, don't use mean words to him when you read rumors.
Doesn't matter if he's older or not. It's not a question of age, respect is entitled to everyone no matter their age
True@@TheSeriousAnalysist
Get better soon Minnie. We need you.
Cube need (G)-idle more.
How do these so called “carats” say they love SVT and Joshua, but go on and shame and hate the ABSOLUTE hell out of an innocent human being for loving someone like an average person would?? They NEVERRR realize that hating and “protesting” on an idol that doesn’t even know them or their names and calling him shameless will NOT get them ANYWHERE in life. The delusion is so- there..
i honestly will never forgive the toxic delulu stans that claim to love their idols but hate on them more then actual haters. if you really loved Shua you would be happy that he found someone to love. like i know we all make jokes about meeting our favs and marrying them but i thought we all knew we were joking💀. please remember that joshua is also human and stop hating on him for not living up to your delulu expectations .
Stop it! Just saw another vid of the pregnancy! It is ridiculous. Stop making up rumor, harrass, & attack others for these nonsense. Let them live like normal human.
I am so sad to hear about poor Minnie. I hope she gets well soon
Sehun we love you and will patiently wait for you uri maknae.. so proud of you that you’ll be serving your country.. please be in good health and come back safely❤️
I'm gonna miss my boy so much 😭😭 I'm just gonna rewatched all his moments when I miss him
Joshua is a young Man living his life, he must be free to have a personal life. Good luck to him and his girlfriend, may they always be happy together ❤️
I really hope she doesnt have to go on hiatus, I love Minnie shes my bias it makes me cry.
Joshua STILL hasn't confirmed if the rumors of him and his alleged girlfriend are true or not, and yet "fans" believe that it's true that he's dating a girl.
True or not, Joshua or his alleged girlfriend shouldn't be receiving hate bullying just because of rumors that may or not be even true!!! Just leave them alone!!
He is probably dating that girl. There is too much facts about it this time. But that girl do act strange, so there is a possibility it actually is fake. Like the girl is porposely making it more and more obvious. I am starting to feel the girl is a troll. At first it seemed very obvious Joshua and that girl dated, but after the girl’s newest post she seemed like a troll.
@@vixxexo6855 what do you mean?
@@chayazeff1995 Like at first it seemed like they dated with all the proof, but then she started making weird posts and seemed like a troll.
I reminded of Exo Chen's case even though this case is very different from Chen's case..Chen was the one who admitted to have a fiance who are pregnant but this one is different..like the girl is trying to get the attention..idk if it's true or not but I hope the fans stop believing in this rumor unless the idol himself admit it..btw Chen's also got so many hate that the fans want him to LEAVE Exo.. it's the same thing happened here..a delusional fans won't accept if their idol date or have a life like a normal human
@@vixxexo6855same thought
Announcing you're getting married again and youre pregnant when you aren't even divorced yet is wild 💀
I don't believe those rumors, BUT i think Joshua would be the best dad 😂
Such a shame that fan girls would prefer their delusions to be satisfied than to see REAL PEOPLE live normal lives and be happy.
Dropping the title idol would be the best thing Kpop can ever do for the industry
😢😢 pray for Minnie’s recovery 🙏
bro if joshua has a gf and shes pregnant then im happy for them so everyone else stfu and let them live their life
Facts.💕✨
I wish the best for Areum honestly. I hope she gets better and really takes time for herself and her baby. She should find peace and happiness within herself before searching for it in other people.
For those of you who don't know, because you aren't old like me, my god Areum has been through it.
-Cyber bullied for being added to T-ara late.
-Main victim of the Ryu twins' bullying during the T-ara scandal.
-Cyber bullied for making 'strange' ig posts after leaving T-ara (people spread rumours she was schizophrenic)
-Public marriage breakdown
-Now this. If you are spreading malicious rumours about her fiance please please leave them alone. And if it's true, I hope she can get away safely.
Edit: also kinda wild that this video concentrated specifically on the bullying and hate directed at Jo Miyoung and yet most comments are all 'Poor Joshua' without even mentioning her.
I mean, yes poor Joshua obviously, but also poor her!!
getting ready for another marriage before even ending one properly wrong in many ways. So, they met during marriage and she is getting divorced just found another man?And she has kids. Imagine how it would affect their psychology. Even if she gets attention I doubt it would be on positive side. So I cant say I pity her. But I hope all those rumors are wrong
I wouldt even compare this with Joshua situation. Grown man getting hate because dating rumors from delusional fans that is sick
Hope Minnie gets better soon! She was sick during the first Jingle Ball performance too, but still did the whole show. She seems to be pushing herself too hard 😭
fans need to grow tf up!! let joshua date whoever tf he wants 😭😭 bro is almost 30 !!
0:00 Ahreum marriage
2:28 Sehun militairy enlistment
3:09 aespa fans complaining
4:01 Minnie poor health
5:39 Joshua “girlfriend”
thank u for this!!
For gods sake please let joshua live peacefully
Even if he’s dating or not iam always gonna support him
❤️❤️
These fans that hate who Joshua is with are so rude. They need to leave him alone, it's his life. It makes me sick to my stomach to hear these rude and god awful things that they say about this poor girl. She has done nothing wrong to anyone. Please leave them alone👍. Thank you to the rest of the fans who care about these boys, it makes me happy to see that so many others, beside me show support and love to them. I love you guys so much💝!
I knew k-netizens were insane but this is actually getting ridiculous, Joshua and Seunghan’s hate is so sad and they deserve sm better
People really need to let these actual grown adult men live their lives and just enjoy the content they make.
If anyone stands against Joshua for having a gf and expecting a child then shame on you. Have dignity and support positive growths that people are tend to undergo in their lives ik it's not confirmed news but some people just have to get out of your delusional life as your idols private life has nothing to do with you and you have no say. So go and do something productive in life instead of hating people.....
Idols are humans too they deserve a life of their own.
They are human, idol or not, just like us. Spreading rumors can be very hurtful to everybody involved no matter how involved you are. I’m speaking from my own personal experience. Let’s treat them like normal human beings and support them in a HEALTHY way.
I hope Minnie gets better♥️
As a CARAT, I feel very bad for Joshua...
Joshua is busy with his schedule now... Don't involve him in these kinds of rumors... He didn't confirm his dating rumors. As a fan, I believe in him. So please don't put him in a bad situation.
I hope minnie is okay i love gidle 😢
(G)i-dle needs to rest for a while. When I watched their concert last year, Shuhua needed to step back for a while because she wasn't feeling well. They have been releasing albums and touring non-stop since 2022. They are overworked. Cube isn't doing anything about it since they are the company's main source of income. So frustrating.
Joshua doesn’t deserve the hate, even if he is dating someone he’s a grown man and deserves to do what he wants. i also feel bad for the girl in this as she is also getting sm hate for something that isn’t even CONFIRMED.
Not the dating scandal again oml, ppl were just starting to forget it, I’ve literally seen NO ONE talking about it in months, stop talking about it and it’ll naturally go away like omg
LET JOSHUA LIVE ...JEEZ 😒 MAN'S A MATURE ADULT MAN ..
Going after someone because they might be pregnant. Typical kpop "fans"
Ya’ll there are more 10+ million carats all over the world and 80% of us are in our 20s AND WE WANT THEM TO DATE AND HAVE A HEALTHY LIFE BALANCE. Trust me when i say this “THE FANS” who are being toxic towards Joshua regarding this whole situation aren’t actual carats.If he is dating anyone we will support him and his girl.
Omg can Joshua not have a life? When I saw him crying on stage , I literally felt so bad for him.
Y'all need to leave joshua alone.. Like KEEP MY BIAS NAME OUT YOUR DAMN MOUTH
Fans should let idols liveeee like bruh
WHY THE HECK IS PLEDIS SILENT IT MAKES ME MAD THE MOST
Cube didnt send minnie on stage she didnt want to disappoint fans (even tho we would be fine) cube said they told her its ok to sit out but she insisted which a lot of idols do on their own which is why she left so quickly after her decision and realizing she couldnt go on
Get well soon Minnie🥺❤
TBH, if you were in a long-term serious romantic relationship with a person with a high profile job, wouldn't it be more sensible and prudent to keep the relationship private and low-key? It's really none of anyone's business so why keep flaunting it and reminding people of its existence? It's probably an ego thing ATP.
The fact that Choi Mi Young keeps posting photos like these make it seem like she doesn't care about the consequences of her actions or how it may affect Joshua and his job. He's been deeply affected by this issue but it seems she won't stop until she gets what she wants. I don't see this ending well at all.
When the rumour was revealed with all the proof I was like it is 100% true. But now that girl posted that post she seems like a troll who just wants fame. If Joshua is not dating that girl I feel so bad for him that some stranger is making him get lot of hate. If Joshua is dating her then I hope that girl stops posting dumb stuff that will trigger Joshua’s lunatic fans. Like her latest post is not something a normal person would post.
no but i really feel like the girl's milking it for what it's worth
it's way too obvious at this point
maybe at some point they did date but had a bad breakup? either way i find it hard to believe that if joshua is still with the girl, she wouldn't be cautioned against those sort of posts/actions, from HYBE/pledis or from the man himself.
idk, the whole thing feels weird.
What did she post?
Or maybe... just maybe the things she post only seems like she is trying to get attention in the context of a relationship. If she isn't in a relationship then what she is posting is normal mundane stuff.
Because in reality it's people who don't actually know either of them reading into everything to get the conclusion they want based on a rumor. Some random started because they were bored.
It is pretty sad that people are hating on a girlfriend. What happened to woman empowerment and there isn’t one person doing the deed. I think it’s also no ones business how they live their life. Isn’t seventeen members pushing 30yrs soon?
What a beautiful baby Joshua would produce. I hope they are very happy if this turns out to be true. The only way to shut these deluloos up is ignore them and keep living your life to the fullest and happiest, because they will always find someone else to criticise next.
So mad at BLONKS who's comparing Minnie's leaving mid performance to Jennie who casually leaving mid performance like bruh Minnie was sick before the start of their Jingle Ball concert at the start of this month but still performing til the last city they need to perform vs Jennie who casually leaving at their concert (especially their France Concert)
Imagine what would happen to that poor girl if their relationship was confirmed
Leave Joshua alone! He's is not fan's puppet! His life, his love! Also don't y'all dare to harass that girl!
It is insane to me that fans think they OWN idols. They’re just normal people, who cares if they’re in a relationship; they’re never going to date you or know your name ever.
The member of Riize who is on High hiatus ( I can't spell his name properly) did nothing WRONG . HE DIDN'T COMMIT A CRIME ITS HIS PERSONAL LIFE🤷
Is it so hard to celebrate these idols's relationships? I want to live in a world where they can be pubic and be able to openly gush about these small cute moments with their fans..
Okay #1: It seems like all these companies with idols who have health concerns say the same thing. That they wanted to continue performing, but the company insisted that they think about their health. And while I can see that happen because of how some of the idols are conditioned, I also still find that hard to believe the company insisting them not to continue the performance. #2: I love how the last girl is "seeking attention". Yeah, she's just forcing you to watch and comment LOL.
Leave joshua alone for God's sake. What has he even done? Did he commit a crime? The toxic fans need to know their place.
Okay but why is the Joshua situation so similar to the jennie and V rumors yall need to stop spreading shit😭
I feel incredibly bad for Miyoung because all of the so-called fans, as soon as she posts a picture of herself enjoying her life, swarm her instagram comments to hate on her about her probably non-existent relationship with Joshua. Even if they were dating, I wouldn't go out of my way to bother their private lives. The idols are not us fans' public property to go f-around with.
I feel like hybe would make these people go through loops and sign NDAs if they were dating their artists. The way she’s been so open about everything is just suspicious to me, but regardless Josh is an adult. It just hurts to see one of the kindest souls in the industry being subjected to so much hate. I wont ever forgive those who made him feel so bad that he cried during one of their Japanese shows.
we should be happy joshua found a gf with his face like that!! not hate them . spreading hate is never good when will netizens understand that
joshua is the idol who inspire us and the person who create these kind of rumour and hate comment are don't deserve to be human because it gives mental toucher to our artist so plz be gental to your words while speak and write.
there is one thing we can be assured of :-
a group that has lasted for almost a decade with a company that treats them right in this industry without letting any scandal or allegation break them, we can be rest assured that they will not be removing anyone from the group just cuz of some random claims (true or not it aint gonna break svt )
Carats, lets us all stop talking about this rumour to prevent hates on these 2 innocent souls! The more we ignore the more it fade!
Even if Joshua and his supposed girlfriend are having a kid, what business is it of anyone else? I am not a Seventeen stan but that is ridiculous. These Kpop idols do not owe anyone their private life, nor are they children (or at least this one is not a child) that need to be protected or chided for living their lives. Just because someone is a fan does not mean that they are entitled to keep these idols from having meaningful relationships with anyone they see fit.
Let him have a kid, do you want them to be alone forfckingever???! Baby Shua would be SO CUTE
Omg not this girlfriend stuff again with Shua yall get over it
Why company not revealing if Joshua is dating or not why they did not confirm yet bcz of company everyone making false accusation against them it was better if company talk about it and clear things
Minnie was looking and walking like how all women look when its that time😖 For me, I don't even wanna get out of the bed, So for them to let her go out and preform for 3days in a row in different cities without no rest or pain killers...yikes!!😬😢
So fans think she's pregnant and their first thought as fellow women, as most of them are, is to cause her stress?? You guys, if you find yourselves reacting that way keep it to yourselves and step back from svt or kpop in general, go outside and smell the fresh air, get a new hobby. Idc about the dating rumors, could be very true and that's wonderful for Josh, and besides that being her friends car, isn't Josh a religious person? I don't think she's pregnant or if she is there would've been a Bobby/Chen style announcement asap. Just leave that poor woman alone bro...
I feel so sorry for Joshua and the model like honestly some fans need to grow up and leave them alone.
Who goes after some idol because he/she is dating? That's just insane... People really needs to understand being an idol is a job. And idols have a life outside that job.
These Fans should Pressure the Govt for the Protection of Idols. A company can only take the bare minimum as they don't want to spend their time and money with Online Harrasment of their Idols.
The fact that ppp are hating on Mi young for no reason. Typical toxic K-pop fans and they don’t or WE don’t even know if they are dating or not. And Cube Ent did say for Minnie not to preform but she still did and ppl are hating on Cube Ent? WHY?!
Koreans need Jesus Christ in their lives and hearts ❤️ so they can stop being so mean and always hurting people for being in love and in relationships. We should celebrate love and not hate and meaness.
Pls leave our Joshua and that poor girl alone 😮💨 I'm so done with these PPL and I just can't do anything besides feeling sorry for both of them ,,, they are dating or not it's not our business ,
the company dont mind getting hated..they just want their idol to get empathy and so they let them get hate intentionally and pretend to not see fan complain. to the ceo, company getting hated by fan is a norm as long as their idol getting fans bond and support
if they want to date let them date. fans be crazy over the stupidest stuff!
Poor Joshua and the girl.
Edit: sorry if "and the girl" wasn't showed (My Yt is idk why broken/buggy.) Hope it's now showed!
Poor joshua? So youre just ignore the woman being hated and harrased over a non confirmed remationship and pregnancy? I understand Joshua has gotten hate but this video doesnt even involve him much
@@christinadouglas6203 ofc I mean the girl too! I actually wrote her in the comment too. (My Yt is on his buggy days ig it deleted itself but I swear to 100% I wrote her too)
@@christinadouglas6203why can’t they feel bad for Joshua he’s getting attacked for living his life
@@SUNSHINELIX-hl8ds im not saying they cant i just felt like this time the hate was mostly on her and found it kinda rude that people only felt bad for joshua
@@christinadouglas6203 well it doesn’t matter who is getting hate the most because they are both getting hate for living their life as a carat I hope they are doing better & ignore all the hate
5:22 Ok, company says “don’t perform, you don’t feel well” artist says “but the fans, I need to perform”… the company is to fault.
Company says “don’t perform, you don’t feel well” artist says “ok I won’t”… fans say “the company wouldn’t let them perform, or even try”
I only see people getting mad at the company either way… both sides need to accept responsibility for the choice.
I need cube to get together asap. they've been around far too long to still be this sh*tty. I really hope Minnie gets better soon. And not people out here shaming Joshua and our fandom. I know with a lot of fans comes a few crazies but y'all know better and it's none of your business.
She just has to be more careful sharing things>.
It could be one of two
1- shes doing it out of mallice, wants attention so she posts things like that
2- shes really just doesnt care and is still with joshua and showing the fans theyre still together
Im all for women empowerment but theres absolute no way they dont realize this is damaging to their career. If this were any country its fine, but this is SOUTH KOREA. They cant date in public and sasaengs are EVERYWHEREEEE. To me its more of a safety thing rather than anything else. Joshua has one of the biggest fanbases in KOREA, people are wacko.
Im all for showing it off but please be saaaafeeeeeee
even kids are having girlfriends nowadays, a grown up man shouldn't be in a relationship. what kind of rubbish is this?
Seventeen is my ult grp, so if I see netizens hating on our Shua one more time istg-
Carats where are u'll?! We need to fill his socials with all the love we can, so these netizens cannot make him sad.
Also let the girl LIVE!! Even if she was pregnant, u'll aren't the ones who got her pregnant NOR do u have to look after her or her family. So who the heck are u'll to hate?! And even if Joshua is dating her/ even marries her, how does that matter to u guys?!! Idols are complete strangers to us at the end of the day, and we are strangers to them, doesn't matter how much they say they love us. So be grateful that they even do so much for u'll. Some western artists dont even share so much of their personal life with u'll, so stop hating on someone when THEY are doing YOU a favour by loving u'll.
It’s normal that sometimes you wearing clothes similar to your idols. I also have similar clothes that Jeonghan wear. I think fans are overthinking about Joshua’s situation. I believe Joshua is not dating. Even though he is dating, just leave him alone.😅
The hate against Joshua is seriously stressing me out if it's true good for him and if not hope all of the people who threw hate to him go to hell
Bruh I swear idols well turn in to 80 yrs still they won’t get married 😂if fans are like this and they r crying over them
Joshua SHOULD NOT have to deal with this foolishness. The man is almost 30 years old for goodness sake. I would love to see protest trucks that show SUPPORT for Joshua. That would make him feel better I'm sure. I also would love to see idols stand up for themselves by openly dating.
My imagination is running wild. Indulge me for a moment... What if idols decided to "come out" as dating at the same time and didn't address the haters at all as a sort of protest of their own? To fight for their own rights as adults. There wouldn't be enough protest trucks to cover all of the anti-fans demands. It could be a step in normalizing the idols dating. Something like that is not likely to happen BUT it would be epic. I'm tired of seeing idols and actors still single in their 40's because they're afraid of backlash. It's crazy...smh.
Apparently Knetz think they will be dating Joshua or any other idol. Wierdos.
At what age is it ok for yall immature kpop fans to let them date and make their own decisions? 50?? 🙄🙄
They have nothing else to do Just leave both of them alone
Unexpected??? Gurl we literally have been waiting (for months…) for him to join the military 😒 we are more than ok with that new ✌🏻
What is happening to Joshua and the girl is damnly unfair.
They are Adult.
Grow Up knets...
Soo where's Riize's SeungHan's protest truck asking for his protection against malicious comments? Ohh, right its ok to protest he be removed because he once had a girlfriend, smoked... The hypocrisy
Joshua should just get married and have as many kids as he wants- if the hate hasn't stopped Chen of Exo from being free, then Joshua should have no fear, it's his life
CARATS it's just a humble request form u guys that don't discuss about this rumour at all as u guys know previously we carat took a step to not to spread or talk about this matter automatically it will be stop so let's just act responsibly nd do not give this rumour that much value it will be beneficial for joshua nd that girl also..
(Sry for English as English is not my first language)
Please are they going to live idol peacefully for once , there’s no rumours stop that to harm someone
I don't know what happened to karina but i heard seulgi had a staker always checking her midnight and that's really creepy
So first it was Lia from itzy And now it's Minnie from (G) Idle, these agencies are really overworking these idols in my opinion and they need to take better care of their idols because this is ridiculous
Joshua is literally in his 20s. He can have kids now if he wants to.
starting the video off with my fave ahreum. NOT expected 😂😭