What an AWESOME comparison! You know, I leaned more towards the original. Had such an aliveness to it. Sparkle if you will? I LOVE the VxMR version which I’m lucky enough to own.
Fantastic channel you have. I enjoy your comparisons and the informations you also provide with each cartridge. I am one of those who likes the Type 1 best - musicality and drive, whereas the Type V xMR sounds dull, like my V15 V :-). I have between 80 and 90 MM cartridges myself, but not the V15 Type 1, - unfortunately. For me it could be interesting to hear a comparison between the Shure M44 and the Type 1. My guess is, that they sound pretty similar.... Thank you again for this fine and interesting work!
V15vxMR hands down! That is, if you like the natural sound of acoustic instruments. If you are more into rock and pop, "natural sound" does not mean much, so it's a matter of taste. I have a V15vxMR and a V15III and I think they are excellent.
SHURE v15 has a massive 6mv output ... and you can hear the difference against the 2.5mv output of the v15 V xMR... shure v15 should play rock music and blues a lot better than than v15 V xMR... I've got SHURE v15 IV and ortofon GT : I prefer the last one when I wanna listen to Led Zeppelin or Muddy WAters... the Ortofon GT has an outstanding 8mv output and that makes the difference when you wanna hear the punch in low frequencies ...
No comparison original smokes the v which I found inferior to the 3 The type 2 has more output than the 3 and is alive sounding like the 1. The more they improved them the worse they got. I even heard the 4 sounding good it’s less bright than the 3 The V is the one I sold a week after I bought it
The VxMR is smoother but the high frequencies are too dull. The Type 1 sounds grittier, more realistic (live music is seldom smooth sounding) with greater detail. It'd be my pick.
Maybe a good idea would be to compare the flagship cartridge of each Shure generation, since you have them all, like M3D vs M33-5 vs M44-5 (?) vs V-15 1 vs V-15 2... Or just the V-15 series, either one is a not bad idea for a future video
@@vinyltranslators3730 If comparing the M3D to the M33-5 or M44-5, it would be good to use a N22D stylus which has a .6 mil tip and light tracking force
@@midmodaudio6576 I don't have the N22D stylus but I do have an N21D which has a 0.7 mil and tracks at 1.5 - 2.5 grams. I has thinking of using the upgraded stylus.....I always cringe when I play my records at 3+ grams..
What an AWESOME comparison! You know, I leaned more towards the original. Had such an aliveness to it. Sparkle if you will? I LOVE the VxMR version which I’m lucky enough to own.
the first time I heard the V15 I, I thought the same thing, a lively sounding cartridge
Fantastic channel you have. I enjoy your comparisons and the informations you also provide with each cartridge. I am one of those who likes the Type 1 best - musicality and drive, whereas the Type V xMR sounds dull, like my V15 V :-). I have between 80 and 90 MM cartridges myself, but not the V15 Type 1, - unfortunately. For me it could be interesting to hear a comparison between the Shure M44 and the Type 1. My guess is, that they sound pretty similar.... Thank you again for this fine and interesting work!
Great video. The V-15 MR sounds better but also has better rejection of surface noise of the record itself.
I also prefer V-15MR I feel It more natural, too much detail tires me
Much prefer the first V15, which goes against most things I have read? The music was more...er...musical!
V15vxMR hands down! That is, if you like the natural sound of acoustic instruments. If you are more into rock and pop, "natural sound" does not mean much, so it's a matter of taste. I have a V15vxMR and a V15III and I think they are excellent.
SHURE v15 has a massive 6mv output ... and you can hear the difference against the 2.5mv output of the v15 V xMR... shure v15 should play rock music and blues a lot better than than v15 V xMR... I've got SHURE v15 IV and ortofon GT : I prefer the last one when I wanna listen to Led Zeppelin or Muddy WAters... the Ortofon GT has an outstanding 8mv output and that makes the difference when you wanna hear the punch in low frequencies ...
The Shure V15 has better mids and musicality.
For my eats, V15VxMR. Type 1 has audible distortion by comparison. Contrast in sound, indeed.
No comparison original smokes the v which I found inferior to the 3 The type 2 has more output than the 3 and is alive sounding like the 1. The more they improved them the worse they got. I even heard the 4 sounding good it’s less bright than the 3
The V is the one I sold a week after I bought it
The VxMR is smoother but the high frequencies are too dull. The Type 1 sounds grittier, more realistic (live music is seldom smooth sounding) with greater detail. It'd be my pick.
Maybe a good idea would be to compare the flagship cartridge of each Shure generation, since you have them all, like M3D vs M33-5 vs M44-5 (?) vs V-15 1 vs V-15 2... Or just the V-15 series, either one is a not bad idea for a future video
Thanks for the suggestion. I'm always looking for new content for this channel.
@@vinyltranslators3730 Happy to share my 2 cents
@@vinyltranslators3730 If comparing the M3D to the M33-5 or M44-5, it would be good to use a N22D stylus which has a .6 mil tip and light tracking force
@@midmodaudio6576 I don't have the N22D stylus but I do have an N21D which has a 0.7 mil and tracks at 1.5 - 2.5 grams. I has thinking of using the upgraded stylus.....I always cringe when I play my records at 3+ grams..
V15xMR is neutral and better sounding especially on bass.
Your record is slightly off-center.
I’ve got several like that, it’s a pain (shame)…