ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 พ.ค. 2021
- Get 20% off your first order: trycaliper.com/whatif You can try Caliper CBD risk-free for 30 days. If you don’t love it, they’ll give you a full refund!
We can thank the Moon for predictable weather, ocean currents and the circulation of important nutrients. The Moon also helps stabilize the Earth's tilt. Take away the Moon, and the Earth would go wobbling all over the place. And it would cause what I can only describe as climate change on steroids. Imagine if one day you looked up into the night sky, and saw Mars or Saturn where the Moon was supposed to be. That would sure turn our Earth into an alien world. And not just because of the new view. How would replacing the Moon change the Earth's orbit? What planet could we safely replace our Moon with? And what planet would be the most disastrous?
Transcript and sources: whatifshow.com/what-if-each-p...
Get our 100 best episodes in one mind-blowing book: bit.ly/ytc-the-what-if-100-book
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @whatifscienceshow
Watch more what-if scenarios:
Planet Earth: bit.ly/YT-what-if-Earth
The Cosmos: bit.ly/YT-what-if-Cosmos
Technology: bit.ly/YT-what-if-Technology
Your Body: bit.ly/YT-what-if-Body
Humanity: bit.ly/YT-what-if-Humanity
T-shirts and merch: bit.ly/whatifstore
Suggest an episode: bit.ly/suggest-whatif
Newsletter: bit.ly/whatif-newsletter
Feedback and inquiries: underknown.com/contact/
What If elsewhere:
Instagram: bit.ly/whatif-instagram
Twitter: bit.ly/whatif-twitter
Facebook: bit.ly/facebook-whatif
What If in Spanish: bit.ly/YT-Spanish-what-if
What If in Mandarin: bit.ly/YT-Chinese-what-if
Podcast: bit.ly/yt-what-if-show-podcast
What If is a mini-documentary web series that takes you on an epic journey through hypothetical worlds and possibilities. Join us on an imaginary adventure through time, space and chance while we (hopefully) boil down complex subjects in a fun and entertaining way.
Produced with love by Underknown in Toronto: underknown.com
#whatif #moon #tidalsystems #jupiter #binarysystem - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Get 20% off your first order: trycaliper.com/whatif You can try Caliper CBD risk-free for 30 days. If you don’t love it, they’ll give you a full refund!
second probably
fun fact did u know that more people die from pigs than from sharks!! i will post regular videos like this so make sure to subscribe!!
@@THINKPATH I never knew people even died from pigs
HIIIIIIIII
I LOVE YOU CHANNEL :)
Jupiter would look absolutely horrifying. I got chills just watching the simulation.
I did too. I was like when it was it's turn... "Oh boy, now the big boy's turn!"
Horrifying but amazing!!! Hahaha
Jupiter is beautiful and horrible at the same time
@@cristobalsapiain2709 Jupiter protects the earth from comets ☄️
@@jth1954 but it makes me look away from it everytime becuase it gives me intense chills but Thank U Jupiter for saving us from asteroids and comets
Mercury: Replaces the moon
The Moon: Why have you cheated on me?
Lol
Earth:oh sorry i didnt realize it.i thought hes you
@@MinecraftSurvival123 U kinda ruined the joke, That wasn’t very funny :^
@@MinecraftSurvival123 not funny mate
@@arnavsaxena4278 ikr im bad at making joke(for real)
6:06 why would you roast the planet this bad
✋🏾💀
Bc Uranus is known for smelling like ASS!
It’s in the name homie
I had a dream of this.. It was Saturn as the Moon and it was so big! The sky was so beautiful but I can also imagine how terrifying it would be if it was real
😮😮😮😮
I did not have a dream of this but that sounds horrifying😮😮😮
what if : oh yeah , we just have to replace our moon with each planet and yes , TADDAA .. 8 different ways of deaths in 1 vid . XD
7 you mean?
@@SANSYYGAMESFAKE pretty sure my man included Pluto.. I miss Pluto being a planet
@@SANSYYGAMESFAKE oops included earth itself too 😂
@@himanshiraturi9091 😂😂niiiyyce
Yup deaths in every vidoe
ive actually had dreams where Jupiter sized planets and larger planets took the place of the moon. it was terrifying yet gorgeous
Had a dream similar to this a couple nights ago. In the dream I looked straight up into the sky to see a planet that was supposedly over a trillion miles away but it so so large that it appeared to be about as big as the moon looks from earth.
Ive had a dream also about the moon it was very near to the earth it's so big that u could see its details, & when I turned to the right I saw the Sun was bloody red swelling & about to explode, people in my dreams didnt noticed the sun they're busy staring at the moon. Whenever I dream about the space it feels nightmare for me.
I've had a dream that there was this blue hypergiant that replaced our moon
I had one where there were 2 earths
I had one last night where i got some superpowers and i use my power to move moon from its place and throw it on earth ...
I was in the space while doing that and i could hear the screams of people from earth 😂
It was actually pretty cool ngl💀
One thing they didn't mention about Pltuo is that it's crust is mostly made Frozen Nitrogen, which obviously would boil and escape, so it'd would be REALLY bright, like a MASSIVE comet.
🙂
'No wonder it got such a name' (for Uranus)
it had me dying
The
L
Nah, it would be super terrifying, not only in the “we’re all gonna die” way, but in the general way.
Exactly. It would be so fkn scary to see that mofo covering most of the sky.
I have had some dreams with big and strange astros in the sky and is scary asf, most times they caused the world to "die" like they would in real life.
terrifying, but beautiful
Probably not as scary as watching TV just chilin and then the nuclear siren goes off and then you hear a boom and look through your Windows and you remember taht you have no shelter so all you can do is just watch the explosion come closed and closed until its kills you
@@personrod2973 u watchin some messed up shit these days. i do too. those feelings wont last long tho. death is peaceful.
Stinky Uranus
*Timestamps*
0:46 The Moon (The Actual Satellite)
1:29 Pluto (The Dwarf Planet)
2:19 sPOnSOr TiME
3:33 Mercury (The Moon Planet)
4:11 Mars (The Red Planet)
5:01 Venus (Earth's Sister)
5:46 Neptune/Uranus (The Ice Giants)
6:31 Saturn (The Ringed Planet)
7:00 Jupiter (tHE BiG gUy)
thenks
This video showed Uranus and Neptune both at the exakt same time!
It look like mars is orange 🟧
damn venus really likes colliding with its brother then
Earth is a girl-
The moon controls the axial “wobble” known as nutation. Even so, this periodic change in the axis’ tilt accounts to a lot of climate change along with precession. We’ve had ice ages and periods of great heat before.
It's your way of storytelling that makes things so much interesting.. otherwise these facts make me want to cry... I love this channel .. keep it up.. great great job as always..
this made appreciate our little moon even more it literally is taking care of us everyday😭🌕🌑 ur perfect the way u r
Simping for the moon?
Tbh for a moon ours isn’t that little
@@justaguy1229 Yeah, thats true
Jupiter looks really horrifying. Hope this never happens
Same
It would be like saturn is the planet and earth is the moon bcoz of the size difference
lol @ hope this never happens... its impossible to ever happen
It's not like gravity is gonna take the day off
@@DJWhylafihya no shit
i love the music at the start of the video.
since it was like my favorite
but seeing saturn in my night sky has to be my favorite
this was helpful
I actually have dreams like this. Like we see planets in the night sky clearly. It's amazing because heavenly bodies are very pretty but it's also very terrifying. It feels like having a nightmare but instead you see beautiful things.
Just yesterday I asked myself "What If the Other Planets Replaced Our Moon" and look at who was on the job today
LOL COINCEDENCE??!?!!!!!!
@@frogface2960 I THINK NOT!!
Answer: Not the moon.
Nanííí
Fun fact: You can fit all the planets side by side and it would fit comfortably within the orbit of the moon.
Even Pluto :)
People either seem to choose to forget this fact or just don’t know it.
When you truly think about what you just said, cosmic scales are only just beginning to unravel.
@@jrzgcwrocks gg
people think the moon is right next door when in reality its pretty damn far away
The moon is almost 400k km away
Us - “A 16 hour work day doesn’t sound fun.”
Corporations worldwide: “….”
5:33 Wow Venus moving pretty fast
Nobody:
What if: Answers the *real* important questions in humanity's life
Lucky you got a heart.
Indeed
He answered just about every question i can think of except for this one, What If we were Saiyans?. I would definitely love to know how life would be for us.😁
Congcrats
You got a heart from WHAT IF
:HYPERS:
If mercury replaced the moon:
“Hey look! Look at the mercury!”
“omg it’s a full mercury tonight!”
“LOOK! BLOOD MERCURY!”
I get it
Hg
Me : Why do I see Mercury ;-;
@@Ihatemylife9 Dad: Woah, Luna, you look weird today!
WAIT WHAT ABOUT BLUE MURCURY!
Most of the videos in this channel never fail to scare me. But its interesting to watch. I love space , lol😅🌌
Omg SAMEE
The detailed exploration of how such a transformation would impact our planet's ecology, infrastructure, and even gravitational forces sparks. i love every bit of it.
This makes me wonder how any of Jupiter's moons even exist still.
jupiters moons are further, and their land is already broken.
@pleromadiscourse also makes sense coz jupiters moon dont have land
pleromadiscourse also earth is bigger than any jupiters moon so the land would definitely crash as it's closer
@@GabeGamePlayz they do, it’s just frozen cracked ice
They built different bro
In short :
Ocean waves on earth will be like in movie - Interstellar
I think some water will even leave the planet
@@nuke8110 only to gas and ice giants when 400 km of atmosphere is lost
😃😃😃
@@BL-gives_butterflies thats what i mean
those aren’t mountains
Imagine having Jupiter as the moon,that would be horrifying
5:42 hopefully that does not happen to pluto and charon (plutos moon)
Moon : I’m gonna take a day off.
Earth : Ummm, Fine!
*Next Day*
Moon : Hey, Earth!
Moon : Earth?
Edit: Holy, 1k likes, I’m famous MA!
.
Lol
Mercury sounds nice
Where is Earth
Next suitable planet to live in is Mars
People in 2050 be like : "Only OG'S remember the MOON"
Lol
Um its actually in 3700 or 2700 idk i think it was at 700 but the first one idk
I will remember the moon when I'm 40 years old
@@soggyturbo6431
Welp that’s a loooooooonnnng ass time lol
aliens a day after: "ONLY OG'S REMEMBER THE HUMAN SPECIES"
Having a lucid dream derived of these videos is the most terrifying thing ive ever gone through.
There was a clip of my hometown at 2:08 in the video. :)
*"Pluto: I tried, but at least l got my cute planet tune"*
I won’t lie, I’ve always sort of day dreamt about massive planets just hovering over earth. It would look so incredible, but the thought of it just makes me nervous and anxious inside haha.
I had a similar kind of dream like this couple of days before
What was it like?
with vr we should be able to see this someday
Where I live, when we have perfectly clear skies and a full moon, the moon shines very brightly over my apartment building and when I wake up at night to open the window, I always look in the opposite direction because it kinda terrifies me lol it's so huge and clear and bright like a huge light bulb. I thought it was stupid of me, now Im relieved to see people are scared of seeing big planets closer than usual
Same here i see Jupiter
Thank you for including Pluto 😊
This is an absolute nightmare for me. I’ve had dreams about this before, they’re so bizarre. There’s just something terrifying about this.
Seeing Jupiter in the place of the moon would be my younger self's worse nightmare come to life 😳
I love how we all have been scared of Jupiter since childhood
I love it,looks interesting.
@@Mari-sq6cx I wasn’t scared of it i loved it
Very good video, but I want to add a few things:
Actually, Earth-Mercury and Earth-Mars would also be considered binary systems (or double planets), because in these cases the center of gravity would be outside both planets. Since Earth has a significant bigger mass than that of Mercury and Mars, the center of gravity would be much closer to Earth, which would do a circular orbit around it, while the other planet would do an eliptical one. For comparison, it would be like Pluto-Charon, a stable binary system. Earth-Venus, however, would be a very bad thing like the video said, because the two planets have a so similar mass that would would put the center of gravity in the middle distance between them, meaning that they would share the same circular orbit with a risk of colision in the long run.
About Mercury being the safest planet in our Solar System to replace our Moon, which is indeed true, that doesn't mean it would be safe at all. Mercury's mass is almost 4,5 times bigger than the Moon's mass, which means we would experience tidal forces 4,5 times stronger than the current we have. Costal cities would be at constant risk of flooding, and daily-night cycles would be longer, affecting all enviroment on Earth.
THANK YOU, it’s like they just thought that mercury was only a little bigger than the moon it wouldn’t make much of a difference
Is not one person Going to metion that he said that the moon is ONLY 41 times bigger than the moon
Thanks about Mercury I put the same in a comment, for some reason he keeps talking about size.
Everyine has the letter J
All of this is dependent on the size of the orbit. If a planet of higher mass than the moon orbits the earth it's higher gravity could be canceled out if it's distance were longer.
1:48 But What If Pluto Had The Same Exact Pull On Earth As The Moon Does?
The craziest thing about this is that the earth survived 4.2 billion years without the moon 🌕
Time line
Pluto 1:32 to 3:42
the sponcer (caliper CBD) 2:21 to 3:33
mercry 3:43 to 4:11
Mars 4:12 to 5:02
Venus 5:03 to 5:47
The ice giants Neptune and Uranus 5:48 to 6:32
Saturn 6:33 to 7:00
Jupiter the big guy 7:01 to 8:01
The stinky story of the fart gaint 8:02 to 8:17
99:59:59 idk
I can just imagine if the moon suddenly gets destroyed and someone goes up in a rocket and pushes another planet in its place 😂
ik like how can u replace something in spwce
@@espanolbuletiolo885 ikr *space
I was thinking that too..🤣.... How will another planet take its place
7:38 looks like an eye 👁
I had a question about Pluto, that I was hoping would get answered in the video, but he never got around to it...
What if Pluto was closer to Earth?
Would that help make up for the low gravitational pull?
Or would Earth simply pull it in, and Pluto collide with us?
Would anything be enough to make Pluto work, and if so, how might it work, and would there be any other effects?
It's probably too much to have in one video because of how many there are, but what if we replaced any other planet in our solar system's moon with ours? Maybe it would react differently, better or worse!
Thanks whatif
It was soo informative...and funny😂
Thanks for watching. 🙂
If Jupiter was Earth's moon earth would actually be it's moon
Edit: holy shoot I wrote this comment 3 hours ago now it has likes thanks guys
Yeah ! it was already mentioned here ! wts new n t ?
Yep.
Will happen with Saturn too
Yes
@Aquatic Cubez no its hw the turns have tabled 😂😂😂😂🤣👍
This video gave me bubble guts! I'd be so creeped out seeing the planets that close.
I dont usually watch this channel now although I love it lol this would literally give me nightmares than any other horror movie made hahahaha
Seeing large planets up close would be so cool, but terrifying at the same time.
Yeah cause you would be scared that something might go wrong
fun fact did u know that more people die from pigs than from sharks!! i will post regular videos like this so make sure to subscribe!!
5:10 Venus: YEYyyy lm the brightest planet! :)
Sun: what about me :(
Earth: boi u no planet O.O"
Its Funny How He Says "But, We wouldnt let the moon take a day off, we would find it a replacement" and i was like, "Oh, so scientist are gonna be like" "Hello Mercury, Can You Replace The Moons Place Because The Moon Went On Vacation AROUND THE ENTIRE SOLAR SYSTEMMMMMMM"
When I Heard Him Said "It Would Make Tsunamis Smaller" I Was Like "YAY!" But Then when I heard him said "But it would make normal waves massive" I was like "Oh SHHHI---" I would say thats good having smaller Tsunamis, but normal waves bigger, NAH, Tsunamis Are Much More Rarer Then Normal Waves, And The Moon Replaced With Mars, Yea.. You know how this goes..
0:13 for some reason with Uranus, Mars and Mercury in the sky in reminds me of the move Onward
I have the worst anxieties watching this video. I'm loving it because I'm feeling a certain way about it but just imagine seeing something like that in the air everyday. It's too scary too scary
I have absolutely no reason to know what would happen if the moon is replaced by planets and it would probably not help me in the future yet i continue to watch and like these videos because i have nothing to do in life
Yea,lol im worried i might need this info 1 day
seeing jermemy in the starfish sketch in this video made me so happy
I truly wish we would see the other planets from Earth like this (well maybe smaller for the outer planets) without any of the repercussions.
Everyone's gangster until you realized that you can fit all planets including Pluto between Earth and Moon and still has room to spare.
Yes
thats gotta be a myth
Write Jupiter instead of Pluto to make it more effective
Pls
source?
Only 40 seconds in:
I hope he mentions the fact the we would become a moon instead because the bigger planets' gravity it bigger than ours. Let's hope he does mention it.
Thanks, he said it.
Ok
What's the movie in those clips?
I've had nightmares about this, about seeing saturn in the sky, terrifying.
5:48 *OOF*
0:06 OMG THATS SO BIG I WOULD BE SO SCARED
Congrats, this is one of my favourite what if's 👍🏻 Keep up the good work!
The best kind of What ifs are the ones where earth is screwed by other planets.
@@Joes850 Yeah that's true.
I love your videos
I LOVE UR VIDEOS ISTG😭😭😭😭
The moon gets replaced by jupiter...
Earth: "YOU PICK THE WRONG HOUSE FOOL!"
jupiter: **pulls asteroids**
6:01 i have to say your humour is A+
A+++ excellent
What is the name of the soundtrack for Jupiter (7:00) ?
0:50
sun: AY WHAT ABOUT ME?!
7:43 👁
I’m feeling like death cause of this vid...
The eye of da dragon looking at meh
WHATT JUPITER EATS EARTH
JUPITER: YUMMY TASTY EARTH!!!!!!!
U NEED 20 EYE OF JUPITERS TO GO SPAWN IN JUPITER DRAGON (ok that would be creepy or UGLY)
@@medtahat653 [reply] JUPITER after lunch: OMG I'M FINALLY BURNING HEAT
Once i was in my car with a friend and we saw the moon ay least 10 times the size it should be, we freaked out so much we thought it gonna fall on earth, i remember having à panic attack, after maybe 50 meters it regained its normal size so we knew it was just an optical illusion of some sort, so we returned back to see it again and yeah, it was really too big that it yet creeped the hell out of us, ofc we took picture of it, i Wonder what kind of optical illusion went on with the atmospher and the air maybe, it was early winter at 2am 2018 or 17
I'd love to try those magic mushrooms you and your friend took that day :)
@@jebise011 we don't have mushrooms from where I am, am from the desert loool, I only see mushrooms in cartoons, and yeah, I confirm that it was an optical illusion we both engineers I know what I saw
Saturn and Jupiter are absolutely HORRIFYING, I cant sleep now.
amazing vid man i love you
Yesterday I just had an dream , that I was on earth but each hour the moon glitches and gets changed with the other planets in the solar system. Look what came in reality...
Thanks for 1 like man
Thanks for your message!
@@anniea9649 thanks
I also had that similar dream where the moon was replaced with jupiter and the world heated so high and boom 'the end of the f***King world'
You play Shadow fight 3
For the first time I am early on What If video..
fun fact: monalisa the picture has no eyebrows i will post regular videos like this so make sure to subscribe!!
@Random Dog with 3g Internet Access no pls do it on real life!! 😅
Same
@Random Dog with 3g Internet Access THANKYOU SOOO MUCH !!
I want 1 hour long videos from you
Thus, the 'Goldie Locks' effect, where everything is 'just right'...
Also, for the much larger planets, (And I know this is a minor point compared to being ripped apart by gravitational forces) the earth would probably not see the sun for long periods of time during solar eclipses. This would probably have devastating effects on our climate.
A very longtime solar eclipse, like in the pitch black film. ^^
if there even is a climate after this
moon
I love these insane cosmic what if videos, rank them as my favourite.
Timestamps:
0:21 How Would This Change Earth's Orbit?
1:32 Pluto (The Tiny Guy)
3:48 Mercury (The Small Guy)
4:12 Mars (The Red Guy)
5:05 Venus (The Bright Girl)
5:48 Neptune and Uranus (The Ice Brothers)
6:33 Saturn (The Ringed Guy)
7:03 Jupiter (The Big Guy)
Satrun : “hey! Moon can I be with moon. Moon : yup is my day off of space”
But one thing to note is, planets brought in the position of moon from their position might change their temperature and other properties.
3000: Only real OGS will remember the moon and humans!
🤣🤣
Love the animations!
I also drew a picture of planets and dwarf planets and another one but the planets have their orbits!
Fun fact: Venus used to have a moon
4:27 The blood moon rises once again...
6:39 Mexico in American movies
Jupiter: *Replacing Moon*
The girls in the windows: OMG! Lets take a picture!.
anyone would take a picture
0:15 thats how i see earth
2:17 I never thought I would see my favorite Studio C here
I hope everyone who reads this, them and their family has an amazing happy and healthy life. Have a good day💙
Hi
7:32 that is so cool looks like a scene from an anime
“Uranus would stick horribly” TF😭 6:03
Amazing cinematic skills props to the team for amazing scenery i am almost feeling wobbly.
We are very thankful for your comment.
@@WhatIfScienceShow i love vids I'm am fan
Indeed, such a perfect system in which everything is playing important role for stability of the universe can not be just a coincidence ~ there must be an external power that gave it proper continuity.
It's not a perfect system, It's actually Human Body which evolved according to this System.
🙏🏼🙏🏼ye
The amount of moons of each planet
Mercury and Venus: 0
Earth: 1
Mars: 2
Jupiter: 79
Saturn: 62
Uranus: 27
Neptune: 14
Pluto: 5
I like how he pronounced Uranus to keep our mind tidy😂
The question I've been in my mind since a year finally got all the answers in just 8:17 min video.
Or 8:59
2:25 damn
Moon: ima take a day off. Every inhabitable planets: ok let's take turns to be the moon. Also every inhabitable planets * ends up causing chaos*. Uranus: *farts on earth*.