Joshua Lynch I think the original thought was that modern is 40 minutes while classic was 20. And idk if you’ve noticed but Joe has been writing the other trailers for other weeks.
Modern is 40 minutes with 13 episodes per season for 10 seasons. Classic is 20 minutes with 25-40 episodes per season for 18 seasons. Dan, Spencer, Joe, and Lon all have other work to do besides this. I’m not gonna even try to debate who does more work at Screen Junkies. Besides, I was only messing with them. Didn’t think it was that serious a statement.
Hey Joshua Lynch! I wasn't fighting you, I was pointing out something nicely, but now it is a FULL ON FEUD!! 😡😡😂😂😂 Thanks for re-writing my comment about the time of the episodes DUDE!!!!!🤬 😂😂 "Well actually" I was telling you what they said during the classics commentary, that they thought it was evenly distributed during the initial part, then they realized that it was more!!!! I AM RESPECTFULLY COMMENTING AND MAKING SATIRE OF HOW PEOPLE THINK EVERYTHING IS A FIGHT!!!!!! 😅
What I found hilarious was the moment I heard "That thing David Tennant's voice does" before the clips played, I knew EXACTLY what you were referring to.
Having watched each modern era episode 3 to 4 times at least, yeah, this is accurate And now your song has ended. (No Joe, but he's in the thumbnail, did I get clickbaited? Maybe a little lol)
This is it. Screen Junkies has officially hit a new peak. If they can tackle the entirety of Doctor Who, they can do anything. EDIT: And now that they’ve loved this comment of mine, I wonder what TV shows they’ll tackle next? Maybe Adventure Time, which just ended recently and has been requested for years, and could begin these guys’ foray into the bizarre world of modern animated TV?
I just want to say thank you Screen Junkies. This video was the final push I needed to finally start watching the Doctor Who modern series and I absolutely love it! P.S. David Tennent is my favorite Doctor
Sorry, Thanos snapped him out of existence in the trailer for Infinity War. He was dusted with Scarlet Witch. Hopefully, he will come back when she does.
The "Radio Dramas" are genuinely good, especially the eighth Doctor Paul McGann ones. The Big Finish audio adventures are an underground secret only a small segment of Whovians know about. The Eighth doctor only had a film (and a minisode) on the screen, but his entire life as a Doctor lives on in audio form acted out by Paul McGann (plus comics/books). They are really a lot of fun, and he's a great doctor. Also, Bbc has made them (mostly) canon. Great work on these two episodes of Honest trailer!
You guys are the best, most creative group of individuals AND have gifted your fans with a slogan for a great Doctor Who tee shirt, "spatial justice warrior"
Definitely worth the wait!! Awesome honest trailers! Thank you for helping out, Riley!! I was hoping they’d have a Doctor Who expert to help explain stuff
I absolutely agree!! I don't understand why no one told JD to pause it....Maybe they thought JD would pause when they started talking? But then they just kept doing it and Spencer was the only one who would say "pause."
The "The Doctor's name is a paradox" is wrong, though. The line/explanation is the the human word/idea of Doctor came from him. That doesn't clash with him choosing or even creating the word....and us old earthlings taking it up from there. Hmph.
Really fantastic that we got an honest trailer of both the classic and modern era Doctor Who! Just a thought, but not pausing while the panel was discussing during the recap made it a bit difficult to watch at times. This was still an excellent production and the time put into all these episodes is admirable. Keep up the awesome work!
For Spencer: Douglas Adams script-edited one series of the show and wrote two stories: "The Pirate Planet", and the one you talked with Dan about in the other commentary "City Of Death" (the one set in Paris with Leonardo DaVinci). What Riley was saying about Dirk Gently is that the plot of the first book is a combination of "City Of Death" and the *other* story he wrote "Shada". There was a strike during the filming of "Shada", and it was never finished or aired, although many years later there was an animated version made from the script with the 8th Doctor, and they've just recently made a new version with the parts that were unfilmed animated. Also, FWIW, "Life, The Universe, And Everything" started life as a script he submitted to the series which was rejected for being too silly (if you can believe that). Tell me you can't see the DNA of Doctor Who in the Krikkitmen.
"A life this long-do you understand what it is? It's a battlefield like this one...and it's empty...Because everyone else...has fallen. Thank you..thank you both...for everything you were to me...Capaldi's goodbye had me in tears. Didn't think any could have topped Tenant's goodbye for me. Imagine the Internet if we could all follow the Doctor's words..."Always try to be nice...but never fail to be kind." Outstanding job to all of you-can't believe Joe missed this after all the hours you spent on this. But great having a person with knowledge of the series. I watched it a bit growing up in the 70's but didn't really become a real fan until the 2005 re-launch and I've watched it ever since. Outstanding Screen Junkies...
DAMMIT! You just had to write that down, didn't you? Now you had me choking up again just from reading it! Actually, on second thought: thanks for that. I have too little genuine emotion in my life, frankly, so that's well-needed jolt to the heart there.
OK NO SERIOUSLY PLEASE PAUSE THE TRAILER WHEN THEY’RE GOING OFF (i mean obviously me screaming it twice in one video won’t fix the video but please for god’s sake do this in the future)- this isn’t the only trailer commentary where this is a problem
Hi, guys. Jonathan Pryce was not in Harry Potter! Did you accidentally use his face instead of Jim Broadbent, his co-star in Dr. Who: The Curse of Fatal Death?
First thing I did when I heard that was scroll down to see if someone had corrected that. That and Fathers Day wasn't a Bootstrap Paradox it was a Hitler Paradox - using time travel to erase the reason for the time travel.
Good work guys. I have a lot of love for the fact that they brought it back slightly too late for me to be young enough to be its actual target audience... Great trailer!
Wait, when did the doctor and rose do anything physical? She fell in love with him, he has love for all of them, he loves what he sees in them, he understands things differently. The reason the two doctors worked with rose is because he made a human version of himself who was capable of loving and being there for her.
I didnt realise how much I loved Doctor Who until I started irrationally angrily defending things in my head 😂😂 You leave those Tennant stares alone. I live for them. Save Martha is one of the best names you guys have ever done. Still chuckling.
Days of Our Lives of Future Past was definitely the right choice. It may actually be my favorite Honest Trailer title yet! Also, even though it was funny, did anyone else tear up at come of the clips, remembering how sad the actual event was?
Kinda disappointed you guys didn’t do a paradox/pair o’ docs thing with the shot of Tennant and Smith mirroring each other, but you had a hell of a lot to contend with in this. 😜
I love Clara, the actress is great & I really appreciated her confronting the Dr & him respecting her more than some of the previous companions. A lot of the Capaldi episodes struggled with inconsistencies & personality changes which weren't congruent with the characters or show. I really hope this new series irons out the wrinkles.
I'm with Spencer about 11 and Amy. Half the reason I hated that run is it always felt like Amy would drop Rory immediately if the Doctor looked at her sideways. Also I mostly watched this because I wanted Martha to get the attention and credit she deserves and I got "rebound rose". UGHHH (Also you definitely need to do Supernatural now...its equally long, dramatic, and nonsensical. It also does the balance of Very Serious and complete foolishness too. See scooby doo)
Ehhh....I see what they were trying to do with Amy. The Doctor was her best friend/celebrity crush rolled into one but Rory was the one she seriously loved. I just don't think they nailed the execution. Martha gets more hate than she deserves, she just has a less pronounced arc than, say Donna. And while if love for them to conquer Supernatural, it would be too much, there's just too many episodes and not enough consequences.
I could write entire essays about why the idea that Amy didn't love Rory is completely wrong, but I'm a bit tired so instead I'll just point you in the right direction. Essentially, Moffat likes to write about Mental Issues and topics related to Mental Health. Look up Fixation on Google, and then realize *a)* the hellhole that was young Amelia's life *b)* how the Doctor was her only hope of escaping that and finally *c)* how holding on to his existence with all her mental might when the entire world was telling her that her one lifeline wasn't real was her only way of surviving for 10-12 long years with her brain at least largely intact (or possibly even surviving at all) and you'll likely start to see where Amy's sexual "attraction" to the Doctor came from. It also explains why she ran away on her wedding night, and how she responds when she might lose people she love, by the way: Amy can handle most things, but she has an extreme fear, almost a phobia really, of abandonment, and that in turn is her greatest Character flaw, with her entire Character Arc revolving around finally being able to commit to the person she loves most in all the world, namely Rory.
It's something that I'm in two minds about. Classic Doctor, he never fell for a companion (except maybe Romana), and you can understand why for the reasons stated in the video. Romana was his equal, even his superior, so you could see it with her. You could see why companions WOULD fall for him, but they didn't play with that that much (not that I remember anyway). New Who seems obsessed with the romantic side, except for maybe Donna, who made a refreshing change. I welcomed Peter Capaldi as I hoped it would put that to one side for a while. The Doctor always seemed more like a grandfather to me, with his elongated lifespan, and the felt like the relationship he had with the majority of his companions.
I don't know if you intentionally made the comment, but for those that don't know, look online Rowan Atkinson did play the Doctor for Comic relief sometime before 2005.
Spencer - reel in your panel, man. You’ve done it before. Tried watching it twice, even with subtitle captions. Can’t hear a word when they talk over the HT. Maybe it’s a time consumption issue, but in effect, the commentary takes LONGER when people try to talk about each part as its playing, as opposed to just pausing after every few series of “bits.”
here's one thing I always meant to ask Jack. Back in the old days. I wanted to know about that Doctor of his. The man who appears out of nowhere and saves the world. Except sometimes he doesn't. All those times in history when there was no sign of him, I wanted to know why not. But I don't need to ask any more. I know the answer now. Sometimes the Doctor must look at this planet and turn away in shame. I'm recording this in case anyone ever finds it, so you can see... you can see how the world ended.
Doctor who 'Expert' says that it's powered by the time vortex. It's powered by the Eye of Harmony which is a star collapsing in on itself endlessly due to time fuckery by the Time Lords.
I knew someone would ding me on this. Yes, both have been named on the show as the power source, amongst other things as well. These kinds of conversations move fast so it's hard to pull all those details before the convo moves on. Like we said, the show loves to contradict itself.
This is perfectly on point, I've loved this show ever since it came back in the UK and you do sometimes end up with a love-hate relationship on certain series, but there's always something to admire! ... also I feel like being *that person*, so for Spencer mentioning the thought of a Victorian-era person seeing aliens and screaming "Satan!" - Torchwood: Miracle Day has a flashback Captain Jack in the 20s, and he's kept in a basement and repeatedly killed/revived by some religious folks who are trying to figure out if he is an unholy creature or a blessing in disguise... it's a long story.
Can you guys fix the pauses please? So it pauses when people are talking, and then scrolls back to the point before the people started talking? Please - there was way too much talking over the trailer in this
Love both old and modern trailers, great job. One correction to commentary: Godzilla Cybermen was mentioned again by the Eleventh Doctor when her pondered why Amy didn't know this historical event
Regarding Douglas Adams (discussion around the 6 minute mark), his fourth Doctor episode "City of Death" includes a twist that also appears at the end of Dirk Gently that life on Earth came from the explosion of an alien spacecraft. At first, I thought Douglas Adams had stolen from Dr. Who, until I realized that he had stolen from himself.
Joe is on the thumbnail for time travel reasons. He was in it, but had to go back to change the past, but forgot to change the thumbnail, and now he's his own grandpa.
Regarding the size of the TARDIS, there is an episode of classic Who (Castrovalva - S19E01) wherein they're forced to jettison 1/4 of the TARDIS rooms to produce the energy needed to escape a dangerous time event. It's a sort of relativistic convert mass into energy kind of thing.
Yeah, and there's also the Invasion of Time episodes in Tom Baker's run where the Sontarans invade Gallifrey and they chase the Doctor and his companions through the TARDIS, which I forgot to mention on the show before we moved on.
I have been going through these commentaries and am at the Star Trek: The Next Generation one, and it was said by one person that there might never be a Dr. Who one. Well, waddya know.
Can Screenjunkies or anyone else recognize the music that begins at 26:30 at "Every British actor"? Really like the beat in that short section and not going (too) over the top like most trailer musics. Also thanks for the commentaries and left over jokes. Seems like there were more material for them than the TARDIS has rooms.
I had to run to get to a screening - I also didn't do any work on Modern Who, so this is the perfect group to talk about making this particular trailer. I'd just be sitting there silently! - Dan
There is such a difference between the RTD era and the Moffat era, it would have been interesting to have Joe's thoughts. Most of this is from the Moffat era.
I loved it!... Just a comment thought, I believe you got it wrong when you commented about the doctor's name. River is talking about the people that raised her, not the gallifreyan, but I might be wrong.
Why did the show make that ridiculous handbrake joke about the iconic TARDIS sound??? Talk about a flat joke, no one even smirked on screen or acknowledged the joke in any way... Was she just trying to test the companions and their TARDIS knowledge!?! Such a weird moment... : /
Where is Riley from and why were you saying thank you as if she wouldn't be back? I would say hope she's on more often, but since this is from Oct.2018 I know that she didn't end up coming back :( maybe in 2019?
@17:00 still need to factor in that she ran off because she figured she could get back in time for the wedding. That was portrayed as the deciding factor in her head, whether or not she was going to follow through with returning or not.
Y’all gave Dan 18 years of Classic Doctor Who and you split modern Doctor Who 3 ways? Dan really got the short end of that stick
Joshua Lynch I think the original thought was that modern is 40 minutes while classic was 20. And idk if you’ve noticed but Joe has been writing the other trailers for other weeks.
Modern is 40 minutes with 13 episodes per season for 10 seasons. Classic is 20 minutes with 25-40 episodes per season for 18 seasons. Dan, Spencer, Joe, and Lon all have other work to do besides this. I’m not gonna even try to debate who does more work at Screen Junkies. Besides, I was only messing with them. Didn’t think it was that serious a statement.
Joshua Lynch - Every statement said about Who is a serious statement.
Hey Joshua Lynch! I wasn't fighting you, I was pointing out something nicely, but now it is a FULL ON FEUD!! 😡😡😂😂😂 Thanks for re-writing my comment about the time of the episodes DUDE!!!!!🤬 😂😂 "Well actually" I was telling you what they said during the classics commentary, that they thought it was evenly distributed during the initial part, then they realized that it was more!!!! I AM RESPECTFULLY COMMENTING AND MAKING SATIRE OF HOW PEOPLE THINK EVERYTHING IS A FIGHT!!!!!! 😅
Cool. I’ve never been in a feud before
Thumbnail of lies
I am not worthy of 2 honest trailers and 2 commentaries. Thank you ScreenJunkies!!
What I found hilarious was the moment I heard "That thing David Tennant's voice does" before the clips played, I knew EXACTLY what you were referring to.
Me too!
“Yeeeeeaaa”
O YES!
Having watched each modern era episode 3 to 4 times at least, yeah, this is accurate
And now your song has ended.
(No Joe, but he's in the thumbnail, did I get clickbaited? Maybe a little lol)
You were clicking no matter what, so it's ok. :)
Mostly accurate. Few inconsistencies like the Tardis being powered by the time vortex.
This is it. Screen Junkies has officially hit a new peak. If they can tackle the entirety of Doctor Who, they can do anything.
EDIT: And now that they’ve loved this comment of mine, I wonder what TV shows they’ll tackle next? Maybe Adventure Time, which just ended recently and has been requested for years, and could begin these guys’ foray into the bizarre world of modern animated TV?
even reverse the polarity of the neutron flow?
Every episode of The Simpsons next XD
Futurama maybe?
Or go into radio series with The Archers, which has had over 18,700 episodes over 68 years. An everyday story of country folk
How about we give them a break from TV shows for a while?
Season 7.2 Episode 6. The Crimson Horror - Has the Victorian dude that keeps passing out when he sees different aliens.
I just want to say thank you Screen Junkies. This video was the final push I needed to finally start watching the Doctor Who modern series and I absolutely love it! P.S. David Tennent is my favorite Doctor
Why is Joe on the thumbnail?
The question should be...why isn't Joe on EVERY thumbnail.
Joe regenerated into Riley offscreen .
How is Joe? Where is Joe? Who is Joe?
What is a Joe? When is a Joe? Whose is Joe?
Whenever Joe isn't on screen the other characters should be asking "Where's Joe?"
4 videos about doctor who!??! I'm not skipping any ads on any of your videos from now on ✌✌
No 'Alan' clip? is this even an honest trailer?
He was obliterated in the the last Avenger's trailer.
This is a TV trailer though.
Sorry, Thanos snapped him out of existence in the trailer for Infinity War. He was dusted with Scarlet Witch. Hopefully, he will come back when she does.
okay Brit-ney Spears for Billie Piper british princess of pop was absolutely hilarious and you should have kept it in.
The David Tennant sadly staring into the middle distance killls me.
There wasn’t enough Wilfred in the trailer
I am deeply ashamed to say that I didn't realize this until reading your comment, but you're absolutely and unequivocally right.
There will never be enough Wilfred.
That HT was beautiful. Very respectful of everything but still punching where it needs punching and covering a hell lot ! I tip my hat to you guys !
The editing and work to find those clips.... must have taken forever. Much appreciated
The "Radio Dramas" are genuinely good, especially the eighth Doctor Paul McGann ones.
The Big Finish audio adventures are an underground secret only a small segment of Whovians know about. The Eighth doctor only had a film (and a minisode) on the screen, but his entire life as a Doctor lives on in audio form acted out by Paul McGann (plus comics/books). They are really a lot of fun, and he's a great doctor. Also, Bbc has made them (mostly) canon.
Great work on these two episodes of Honest trailer!
Natala - And 8's adventures were made canon during the 50th anniversary episodes. :-)
Great job on both trailers. I'd love to see one more commentary/roundtable with everyone involved.
Thanks guys! Spencer, you are a real trouper for sitting through both commentaries. I am sad that Joe Starr didn't get to play though.
Your thumbnail promised a fez
It also promised Joe.
Paradox.
Fezzes are cool.
0:30 why is there a dog walking around the studio?
omg 😂
We are ScreenPuppies now.
@@fandomentertainment covering up for the fact you turned joe into a dog on accident eh
+ScreenJunkies News Prove It and have that dog fight on Movie fights!
I'd totally Like and Subscribe to ScreenPuppies
You guys are the best, most creative group of individuals AND have gifted your fans with a slogan for a great Doctor Who tee shirt, "spatial justice warrior"
GREAT WORK GUYS, THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH FOR CLASSIC & MODERN FROM A FAN FROM THE 70'S!
Definitely worth the wait!! Awesome honest trailers! Thank you for helping out, Riley!! I was hoping they’d have a Doctor Who expert to help explain stuff
Aaaaahhhh no Joe or Dan. Fine
Please pause more often when they start talking. The multiple voices all at once was very disorienting
I absolutely agree!! I don't understand why no one told JD to pause it....Maybe they thought JD would pause when they started talking? But then they just kept doing it and Spencer was the only one who would say "pause."
Surely there's a way to rig a pause button on the desk.
JTE
Yeah they gotta get better at utilizing the "pause" function
I'm not alone. Thank goodness.
As a brit, you nailed this trailer
I feel like Riley is saying my thoughts as I think them! Good job everyone!
The "The Doctor's name is a paradox" is wrong, though.
The line/explanation is the the human word/idea of Doctor came from him.
That doesn't clash with him choosing or even creating the word....and us old earthlings taking it up from there.
Hmph.
I love that you’ve taken the journey that every Whovian takes and just made a crash course for it.
Really fantastic that we got an honest trailer of both the classic and modern era Doctor Who!
Just a thought, but not pausing while the panel was discussing during the recap made it a bit difficult to watch at times. This was still an excellent production and the time put into all these episodes is admirable.
Keep up the awesome work!
For Spencer: Douglas Adams script-edited one series of the show and wrote two stories: "The Pirate Planet", and the one you talked with Dan about in the other commentary "City Of Death" (the one set in Paris with Leonardo DaVinci).
What Riley was saying about Dirk Gently is that the plot of the first book is a combination of "City Of Death" and the *other* story he wrote "Shada". There was a strike during the filming of "Shada", and it was never finished or aired, although many years later there was an animated version made from the script with the 8th Doctor, and they've just recently made a new version with the parts that were unfilmed animated.
Also, FWIW, "Life, The Universe, And Everything" started life as a script he submitted to the series which was rejected for being too silly (if you can believe that). Tell me you can't see the DNA of Doctor Who in the Krikkitmen.
"A life this long-do you understand what it is? It's a battlefield like this one...and it's empty...Because everyone else...has fallen. Thank you..thank you both...for everything you were to me...Capaldi's goodbye had me in tears. Didn't think any could have topped Tenant's goodbye for me. Imagine the Internet if we could all follow the Doctor's words..."Always try to be nice...but never fail to be kind." Outstanding job to all of you-can't believe Joe missed this after all the hours you spent on this. But great having a person with knowledge of the series. I watched it a bit growing up in the 70's but didn't really become a real fan until the 2005 re-launch and I've watched it ever since. Outstanding Screen Junkies...
DAMMIT! You just had to write that down, didn't you? Now you had me choking up again just from reading it!
Actually, on second thought: thanks for that. I have too little genuine emotion in my life, frankly, so that's well-needed jolt to the heart there.
Never be cruel, never be cowardly!
OK NO SERIOUSLY PLEASE PAUSE THE TRAILER WHEN THEY’RE GOING OFF (i mean obviously me screaming it twice in one video won’t fix the video but please for god’s sake do this in the future)- this isn’t the only trailer commentary where this is a problem
omg, you guys you did it. thanks for inviting an actual expert.
and someone more expert than the self appointed celebrity experts who appear on the local DW "aftershow jawfest".
...on being mentally ill.
I hope everyone is aware what a massive job these Junkies did. That is incredible!
26:48 did you guys confuse Jonathan Pryce with Jim Broadbent?
Jeffrey Nunya Yes.
Kylie Minogue is Australian.
But here, more importantly, a British institution.
Hi, guys. Jonathan Pryce was not in Harry Potter! Did you accidentally use his face instead of Jim Broadbent, his co-star in Dr. Who: The Curse of Fatal Death?
That wasn't Jonathan Pryce, that was Julian Glover (King Richard and some other roles in DW / Grandmaester Pycelle in GoT / voice of Aragog in HP)
They used Jonathan Pryce's face instead of Jim Broadbent's for the Harry Potter and Game of Thrones division.
Oh my bad you're right. Thought the original comment was saying they missed Broadbent completely.
I didn't think I would doctor who when I first started but ... it got me. I'm glad you did this
Heh. The notification for this popped up while I was in the middle of reading a review of Sunday’s episode.
"The tardis is powered by the time vortex" no it's not
It's powered by a dying sun held in stasis called the eye of harmony
First thing I did when I heard that was scroll down to see if someone had corrected that. That and Fathers Day wasn't a Bootstrap Paradox it was a Hitler Paradox - using time travel to erase the reason for the time travel.
33:21 did no one catch that *"I don't want to go"* reference? I absolutely loved it.. Perfect ending 👌👌👌
River is full of it.. Every TARDIS sounds like that, the Masters, the Rani's and all the methods the timelords use... Standard TARDIS noise! :)
Yo one guy had to go through ALL of Classic but Modern got split between three people?
Good work guys. I have a lot of love for the fact that they brought it back slightly too late for me to be young enough to be its actual target audience... Great trailer!
Whose puppy is that??
That's my new doggo! His name is Taco.
@@lonnieharris He's adorable
This one of the most 'american' breakdowns ever.
Nice vid. Love from the Commonwealth, Australia.
Spencer saying Amy didn’t love Rory, and suddenly I’m shouting at my iPad !! You are wrong ! Then I realized he can’t hear me
nerd1984 - Tbf, the first chunk of 11's tenure was veerry shaky about her and Rory.
Wait, when did the doctor and rose do anything physical? She fell in love with him, he has love for all of them, he loves what he sees in them, he understands things differently. The reason the two doctors worked with rose is because he made a human version of himself who was capable of loving and being there for her.
i got so excited when i saw Joe in the thumbnail but :(
loved the trailer guys, your work totally paid off!
I was hoping Honest Trailer Voice would say "Dinosaurs! On a spaceship!"
Riley's insights are spot on from the very beginning. Must be a regular. Don't get that depth from any outsider. Keep up the amazing work.
I didnt realise how much I loved Doctor Who until I started irrationally angrily defending things in my head 😂😂
You leave those Tennant stares alone. I live for them. Save Martha is one of the best names you guys have ever done. Still chuckling.
it's too bad they didn't have the guy that actually watched the Tennant episodes on here.
Days of Our Lives of Future Past was definitely the right choice. It may actually be my favorite Honest Trailer title yet!
Also, even though it was funny, did anyone else tear up at come of the clips, remembering how sad the actual event was?
It’s always interesting to see the opinions and perspective from Americans when it comes to a very Britain show like Doctor who.
"Is there a moment where the Doctor contradicts themselves?" "That's all there is." lol the truth.
Im weezing litterally
but this 30:28 aught me off guard HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA
33:22 I HEARD YOU OMFG IM CRYING NOW!
I love the dog casually strolling onto the set at the beginning of the video.
This was cool. Thanks!
Kinda disappointed you guys didn’t do a paradox/pair o’ docs thing with the shot of Tennant and Smith mirroring each other, but you had a hell of a lot to contend with in this. 😜
I WAS PROMISED A JOE
LOL @ 26:54 when you say "every other british actor" and you have a shot of Australia Kylie Minogue.. hahaha
Like how the "reaction" was most just 3 people having their own conversation while vaguely paying attention to the video
I guess we weren't supposed to catch half of the deleted stuff since you kept talking over it?! I demand a separate video!
Agreed. I know it's not unusual for them to do it, but this time was ridiculous! I had to go back 3 times to try and hear stuff (unsuccessfully).
What was the music that played during the bit where you were showing Harry Potter and Game of Thrones actors?
10/10 Cake reference. Also, press f for respects to Rory.
f
I love Clara, the actress is great & I really appreciated her confronting the Dr & him respecting her more than some of the previous companions. A lot of the Capaldi episodes struggled with inconsistencies & personality changes which weren't congruent with the characters or show. I really hope this new series irons out the wrinkles.
I'm with Spencer about 11 and Amy. Half the reason I hated that run is it always felt like Amy would drop Rory immediately if the Doctor looked at her sideways.
Also I mostly watched this because I wanted Martha to get the attention and credit she deserves and I got "rebound rose". UGHHH
(Also you definitely need to do Supernatural now...its equally long, dramatic, and nonsensical. It also does the balance of Very Serious and complete foolishness too. See scooby doo)
Definitely, she learned to eventually love Rory.
Ehhh....I see what they were trying to do with Amy. The Doctor was her best friend/celebrity crush rolled into one but Rory was the one she seriously loved. I just don't think they nailed the execution. Martha gets more hate than she deserves, she just has a less pronounced arc than, say Donna. And while if love for them to conquer Supernatural, it would be too much, there's just too many episodes and not enough consequences.
I could write entire essays about why the idea that Amy didn't love Rory is completely wrong, but I'm a bit tired so instead I'll just point you in the right direction.
Essentially, Moffat likes to write about Mental Issues and topics related to Mental Health. Look up Fixation on Google, and then realize
*a)* the hellhole that was young Amelia's life
*b)* how the Doctor was her only hope of escaping that
and finally
*c)* how holding on to his existence with all her mental might when the
entire world was telling her that her one lifeline wasn't real was her only
way of surviving for 10-12 long years with her brain at least largely intact
(or possibly even surviving at all)
and you'll likely start to see where Amy's sexual "attraction" to the Doctor came from. It also explains why she ran away on her wedding night, and how she responds when she might lose people she love, by the way: Amy can handle most things, but she has an extreme fear, almost a phobia really, of abandonment, and that in turn is her greatest Character flaw, with her entire Character Arc revolving around finally being able to commit to the person she loves most in all the world, namely Rory.
Save... Martha!
It's something that I'm in two minds about. Classic Doctor, he never fell for a companion (except maybe Romana), and you can understand why for the reasons stated in the video. Romana was his equal, even his superior, so you could see it with her. You could see why companions WOULD fall for him, but they didn't play with that that much (not that I remember anyway). New Who seems obsessed with the romantic side, except for maybe Donna, who made a refreshing change. I welcomed Peter Capaldi as I hoped it would put that to one side for a while. The Doctor always seemed more like a grandfather to me, with his elongated lifespan, and the felt like the relationship he had with the majority of his companions.
It's actually interesting and refreshing to see you stepping into a new fandom
I don't know if you intentionally made the comment, but for those that don't know, look online Rowan Atkinson did play the Doctor for Comic relief sometime before 2005.
Spencer - reel in your panel, man. You’ve done it before. Tried watching it twice, even with subtitle captions. Can’t hear a word when they talk over the HT. Maybe it’s a time consumption issue, but in effect, the commentary takes LONGER when people try to talk about each part as its playing, as opposed to just pausing after every few series of “bits.”
"The soap opera elements don't always work for me" - amen, brother.
here's one thing I always meant to ask Jack. Back in the old days. I wanted to know about that Doctor of his. The man who appears out of nowhere and saves the world. Except sometimes he doesn't. All those times in history when there was no sign of him, I wanted to know why not. But I don't need to ask any more. I know the answer now. Sometimes the Doctor must look at this planet and turn away in shame. I'm recording this in case anyone ever finds it, so you can see... you can see how the world ended.
How's Rhys doing?
Doctor who 'Expert' says that it's powered by the time vortex.
It's powered by the Eye of Harmony which is a star collapsing in on itself endlessly due to time fuckery by the Time Lords.
I knew someone would ding me on this. Yes, both have been named on the show as the power source, amongst other things as well. These kinds of conversations move fast so it's hard to pull all those details before the convo moves on. Like we said, the show loves to contradict itself.
@@RileyJSilverman Journey To The Center Of The TARDIS proved that it is in fact powered by the Eye of Harmony.
@@shauntempley9757 "proved" -- until the show changes its mind or forgets.
Guys, I am really proud of you! You did it :)
This is perfectly on point, I've loved this show ever since it came back in the UK and you do sometimes end up with a love-hate relationship on certain series, but there's always something to admire!
... also I feel like being *that person*, so for Spencer mentioning the thought of a Victorian-era person seeing aliens and screaming "Satan!" - Torchwood: Miracle Day has a flashback Captain Jack in the 20s, and he's kept in a basement and repeatedly killed/revived by some religious folks who are trying to figure out if he is an unholy creature or a blessing in disguise... it's a long story.
Can you guys fix the pauses please? So it pauses when people are talking, and then scrolls back to the point before the people started talking? Please - there was way too much talking over the trailer in this
Love both old and modern trailers, great job. One correction to commentary: Godzilla Cybermen was mentioned again by the Eleventh Doctor when her pondered why Amy didn't know this historical event
Regarding Douglas Adams (discussion around the 6 minute mark), his fourth Doctor episode "City of Death" includes a twist that also appears at the end of Dirk Gently that life on Earth came from the explosion of an alien spacecraft. At first, I thought Douglas Adams had stolen from Dr. Who, until I realized that he had stolen from himself.
Joe is on the thumbnail for time travel reasons. He was in it, but had to go back to change the past, but forgot to change the thumbnail, and now he's his own grandpa.
Regarding the size of the TARDIS, there is an episode of classic Who (Castrovalva - S19E01) wherein they're forced to jettison 1/4 of the TARDIS rooms to produce the energy needed to escape a dangerous time event. It's a sort of relativistic convert mass into energy kind of thing.
Yeah, and there's also the Invasion of Time episodes in Tom Baker's run where the Sontarans invade Gallifrey and they chase the Doctor and his companions through the TARDIS, which I forgot to mention on the show before we moved on.
There are so many shows out there these days that come and go but DW is still at the top and still going strong. Amazing really.
Was that a dog in the beginning? Also love having Riley on~!
Amazing work. I will now pretend I've seen this show in conversation
Can someone help me to find out what the song is during the Harry Potter/ Game of Thrones Division?
Whos doggo was behind lon (0:46) ? Sooo cute!
What is the song at 26:33?
I have been going through these commentaries and am at the Star Trek: The Next Generation one, and it was said by one person that there might never be a Dr. Who one. Well, waddya know.
one of this time the Doctor and her companions will run into the Defenders in those endless hallways.
the fact that spencer might carry on with the show is a victory in itself. probably wont
Where's Joe :( Lon is great, but I do like when at least two of the crew are present.
Lon is "the crew", he co-wrote the thing
Can Screenjunkies or anyone else recognize the music that begins at 26:30 at "Every British actor"? Really like the beat in that short section and not going (too) over the top like most trailer musics.
Also thanks for the commentaries and left over jokes. Seems like there were more material for them than the TARDIS has rooms.
Seriously, you MUST do another one with Joe and Dan. WTF?
Dan is on the Commentary for Classic Who
Joe’s on vacation I think, and Dan is on the Classic Who commentary because those are the episodes he watched!
I had to run to get to a screening - I also didn't do any work on Modern Who, so this is the perfect group to talk about making this particular trailer. I'd just be sitting there silently! - Dan
There is such a difference between the RTD era and the Moffat era, it would have been interesting to have Joe's thoughts. Most of this is from the Moffat era.
Oh wow! Thanks for the reply Dan! I did end up watching both commentaries and I wasn't disappointed! Thanks again! LONG LONG time fan here. -Daniel :p
I loved it!... Just a comment thought, I believe you got it wrong when you commented about the doctor's name. River is talking about the people that raised her, not the gallifreyan, but I might be wrong.
Why did the show make that ridiculous handbrake joke about the iconic TARDIS sound???
Talk about a flat joke, no one even smirked on screen or acknowledged the joke in any way...
Was she just trying to test the companions and their TARDIS knowledge!?! Such a weird moment... : /
Hold on! Hold on... Is Rick and Morty just a more edgier version of Dr. Who? Is this a truth pill I have to realize and swallow?! Lol
OMG, cant wait. Kudos to you boys for watching them all, for the fans ^^.
Where is Riley from and why were you saying thank you as if she wouldn't be back? I would say hope she's on more often, but since this is from Oct.2018 I know that she didn't end up coming back :( maybe in 2019?
@17:00 still need to factor in that she ran off because she figured she could get back in time for the wedding. That was portrayed as the deciding factor in her head, whether or not she was going to follow through with returning or not.
I love Riley "I don''t wonna go" *G* Also her glance when the others loved how they got payed for all that interaction with the show.
You guys will never know how happy this made me.. I can’t stop laughing; so much childhood memories. Lol Gotta love the UK