hello world nope she wrote the whole ass lyrics to the song Walter helped her with the music so she was nice enough to give him credits she said herself in an interview
Ariana is good on her own, no doubt about it, she has so much potential. But Mariah is on another league, her technique is way proficient. Comparing them on their same age, Ariana is completely crushed. Mariah mastered embellisments, phrasing, placement, resonance, disconnected registers, chest and mix, dynamics and etc. Ariana has a lot of things to improve: her diction, larynx position, breath support, jaw and tounge tension.
She was making an airy whistle for blending mood in a song (National Anthem) it's not a weak whistle.She can make her whistle sound Airy,piercing,Clear blablabla check out her empress of the whistle register
@@piyawatcarey7149 reddragon here...I am sure you can't...you are clearly delusional. To the point of not being able to read. I said these things are not needed to be a good singer.
No offense, but frankly they're not even in the same universe. Mariah Carey's vocal transition, jumps, support, resonance, range, agility, and melismata are way ahead Ariana Grande's, who is indeed a talented singer yet still immature technically, let alone Mariah Carey's artistry as she writes and produces most of her stuff.
@@elioaboujaoudeh1242 i hope you're not talking about any of the two singers mentioned in his comment. Mariah literally saved a woman from cancer by paying for her treatment and now they're great friends. What do you mean be kinder? And Ariana has done charity work also but she doesn't talk about it much. And Mariah has been running MariahCamp for like 24 years now.
I love Ariana. I have most of her albums. She's a very good singer, but c'mon Mariah is Mariah, one of the best ever. It's silly to claim that they're on the same level.
Hm? I mean- Ariana was the one hitting higher falsetto note. Yeah they aren't both the same level but the way you wrote the comment sounds a bit toxic.
@@arianasgaybf Ariana wouldn't exist in the first place without Mariah since she's one of her inspirations lol If you are stand of Ari you should know better xoxo
Ron Viray that’s because she can talk to dolphins! Thats only something she and the dolphins can explain to us!! And I mean that in a good way! I’m a Mariah fan
Ari's voice is pleasant, it's not bad at all. I think it's a matter of preference. Comparing vocal quality, any vocal coach will say Mariah has better technique and vocal quality. The reason is Ari sounds nasal at times. Her larynx is raised and closed when trying to project the high notes, her words are slurred throughout a song, also she has a plasant, but thin voice... whereas Mariah sings comfortably and has a neutral larynx position most of the time when singing the high notes, she has crazy resonance, good articulation and agility, her voice could change from pleasantly airy n smooth to sharp and strong... Anyways, I think Ari is a great singer for this time in music, one of the best..., but if she were a singer in the 90s when the Trinity was top, she would be labeled as a "good singer" only. Competition was tough back then 😘
i really miss the 90's where singers can really SANG! today it's mostly auto tuned and who has the nicer beats that tops the chart. LOL. it's not about the vocals anymore. so sad. just saying. If i want to listen some nice vocals i don't listen to the radio anymore I would rather listen to covers by normal people on youtube that can really SANG too. haha
I agree 100% with everything said esp the back in the day reference. 90s was full of great singers. I do think ariana has a really lovely voice, but Mariah's is truly unnatural and angelic
omg iconic. but she probably won't have much reaction to mariah's effortless chest to whistle transition since she doesn't seem to get impressed by anything.
Ariana is much closer to Aguilera than Mariah, she likes tense throaty singing and her runs and adlibs don't fit the music, she extends her falsetto up the 6th octave, while Mariah typically prefers whistle in this territory (with some falsetto and hv exceptions). Mariah at her best had the fastest runs in the industry, unparalleled musicality, her runs and adlibs are creative, she has good diction and can phrase throughout her entire range, her voice extends much lower than a typical soprano and best control over whistle register since Minnie Ripperton, so I don't really hear the similarities.
Ariana isn't even near to Christina... Christina is powerful, husky and very good at falsettos... Yes Ari can whistle, but her whole way of singing is very airy and mumbles a lot it gets so annoying
Ralph I dislike I don't like Arians singing either but Christina ain't much better... While Arians sings with a lot of air, Christina is just the opposite, Christina sings with a lot of growls which is quite annoying... Neither of them can support a good C5 though both of them strains to go that high although C5 although that shouldn't even considered high for a girl.
Ralph Canete Christina isn't really powerful, she's pushing and straining, true vocal power comes from open, relaxed and supported singing. But she sure does sound more mature and less whiny than Grande. Of course they have different styles, but they are similar in having poor musicality and technique.
Go watch mariah vs ariana at the same age to make it clear. It just make the difference so far. And yeahh mariah did wrote the all I want for christmas is you with walter
Sweety correction: both could never be equally good.. Mariah is miles infront better. Let's be real sis, don't negate a legend's reputation by saying she's equally to ariana..
The fact is , no matter what age or era, Mariah has and will always be better than Ariana, even current Mariah has a wider supported range than Ariana in her whole career, Ariana is just another singer with a nice instrument but doesn't use it properly, kinda like Jessica Simpson except she totally ruined her instrument , as for Mariah she had an extraordinary instrument and she reached her full potential in her prime.
@Hei Dinglepop yea she is, even current mariah is better than ariana today, in many aspects, since shes older now shes obviously not as good as she used to be, buts shes still going and her voice is still incredible, and she still has an incredible range
Ari can't touch Mariah. Ari is talented but something about her vocal styling that just gets me. Kinda like finger nails on a chalkboard. She kinda mumbles her words and it's distracting.
Ariana Grande’s cover of ‘Somewhere over the rainbow’ was an emotional day for her and she started crying because of the Manchester Attack. One day she will make a more clear version of the song.
You really need to educate yourself a bit more on Mariah's vocals and her whistle register. There's a video on TH-cam explaining all of that. You should really check it out.
Thanks for reacting to my video!!!! :) Some clips are not the best but they are the only ones of each song. National Anthem (Ariana), Lady Marmalade (Mariah) and other. Both are amazing :)
blurrysick; I like watching and listening to Ariana live. I love them both, but you’ve got to admit that Mariah is simply better. They’re styles are different but when Ariana sings Mariah’s songs you can hear it.
one thing I really agree is that Ariana doesn't have depth to her voice, it's like everything should be on that straining position thus sounded a bit of struggling, and the tone of Ariana is just too light no soul into it. but then again because MAriah is half black and her mother was an opera singer, that's what you get when you join two together, A great technique and great depth to the voice
How can you say this. Her voice is so much of potential. Well you all go and bang your face somewhwre coz she has got a Grammy for best pop vocal ( just mentioned for the reason you said abt her voice) she was also nominated for the global awards just because of her voice and immense talent . So if you can't listen her songs so pls do not comment. STAY AWAY FOR MY QUEEN
Mariah can sing circles around Ariana even on a bad day. Ariana is not the best singer. She’s just good compared to some of today’s younger artists. I never understood the comparison between them. Mariah is undoubtedly the best vocalist in the world. I subscribed, btw! Love your videos! Can you compare Ariana’s vocals to Tori Kelly’s? They’re about the same age and Tori has a beautiful voice, but she always goes unnoticed, sadly.
I think you should have given ariana a little more praise when sining somewhere over the rambow considering it was a tribute to the victums of the terrorist attack at her concert and was crying when sining it
Of course Mariah is better, she has brilliant control, abilities, technique and melismas, runs and riffs, a unique, dominant and beautiful voice. She sang in a very touching way (from deep inside) and as you said from the chest. She also has larger vocal range (she has 5-7 octaves, she gets really low to very high...she has 4 notes and her longest Note is 20 Seconds, Her vocal type is, Whatever her mood for the day is, coloratura light lyric soprano) And she whistles phenomenally! Plus she's here for many years and she also creates and writes her music. And many of her music is smart and with depth unlike most of the music of today. Even though she does fun songs she has lots of songs with messages, and quality stuff she wrote or co-wrote that even saved people lives.
Im surprised you didn't comment or acknowledge the control(accuracy), speed & creativity of the melisma at 4:02 Another great video. I do love your objective ear.
@@tibu4760 how was getting number 1's easy back then? people had to actually buy real albums at store standing in long queues and they didn't have internet to stream music unlimitedly. it was very hard to get a #1
Sylvester Lamoonski LMAO ariana has 1 grammy cut the slack😂😂 Tbh I think Ariana should recieve more acknowledgement from her, even tho everything she says it’s true but her vocal abilities are incredible. But mariah produces her music and writes all. As well as has way more resonance and agility
I remember watching Mariah's National anthem performance. She had an interview right before she went on and said she was worried about her whistle coming out. She wasn't sure if she'd hit the note. After the performance they caught up with her and she was all smiles. She said she was happy it came out.
She’s singing “somewhere over the rainbow” in DWT. She’s lowering her larynx and darkening her tone in that tour. But in 2018 her bright tone is back. And Mariah never sings her studio version of oh holy night FULLY live. That’s why the uploader chooses that performance. She slayed 2014 Christmas shows. Her confidence then is up to the roof back then in 2014.
2:07 faulty premise! The person who originated the song isn’t necessarily going to sing the song best. Whitney’s version of I Will Always Love You is superior to Dolly Parton’s version. Mariah herself has covered other artists like Phil Collins and improved the song. The person who sings the song the best is always going to be...“the person who sings the song best”.
The thing is Ariana has no depth to her belts or overall voice, it's all so high pitched sweet. Her voice is not very dramatic like the Mariah, Celine or Whitney. She hits the notes and yes she can belt very high but I don't think it sounds as unique/stylized as Mariah on the belts. They are not equally good, or Maybe only when it comes to technique but even on that component, I don't think Ariana can touch prime Mariah, her sound was so pristine/unique.
Mariah has wider range, better technique, does whistle tone and has a better tone and more power. She writes, sings and produces all of her albums. How can they be equally good? I accept that Ariana is good, I like her songs, but that doesn't mean they are equally good. Mariah is the Queen of Melisma, the SongBird Supreme and Queen of Christmas. She is above the rest.
When Ariana was singing Somewhere Over The Rainbow it was like a few months after the terrorattack at her show so her voice was not so stable and she was crying while singing😪
i wonder how many people realize that thats mariahs rendition of oh holy night and that there are other ways to sing it.... its not the original rendition, but every new artist sings it like it is, Luther Vandross, Patti Labelle and Whitney Houston have there own rendition of the song too to name a few.... i mean i dont blame them the original has a darker quality or deeper melancholy vibe to it but still everyone "trys" mariah's rendition which is cuteto watch i guess
Personally, I don't see the point in comparing singers from two different and distant generations. Mariah is a lot older than Ariana and it's undeniable that many vocalists get better over time because they get to know their voices. That being said, they are vocal references in their own generations and I like to think that Mariah was and probably still is one of Ariana's inspirations.
Ariana always sounds like she’s either shouting or mumbling. Idk if it’s a stylistic choice but Mariah’s timbre and stylistic choices are certainly more enjoyable to my ears.
Also if you wanna hear her enunciation better she is broadway trained she just doesn't always say all her words for stylistic purposes in her pop/Rnb music. Heres a link to her singing at a broadway session: th-cam.com/video/3m6g7rGkUcI/w-d-xo.html
I don't agree that the original artist necessarily sings the song better than anybody who covers it. Whitney and Mariah I think have made better versions of most of their covers including I'll BeThere, Greatest Love of All, Without You, All the Man That I Need, etc. Whitney's I Will Always Love is not better than Dolly Parton's but both are the best renditions in their respective genres, which are like apples and oranges.
YOU ARE FOR ME THE FUNNIEST INDIVIDUAL ON TH-cam! YOUR EXPRESSIONS, YOUR COMMENTS, EVERYTHING YOU DO BASICALLY IS HILARIOUS. THANK YOU FOR BEING SUCH AN INSPIRATION. REACT TO MORE LEONA LEWIS VIDEOS PUHLEASE!
Mariah’s whistle in the National Anthem wasn’t weak she just has more control over her whistles than Ariana and she purposefully made the whistle sound airy.
I really enjoy that you express clearly on how you feel what the artists do. It shows that you aren't favoring them, but respecting both their singing techniques.
well i believe that Mariah is Great Artist and have worked A LOT for her achievements and it is disrespectful to say at least to compare with a new singer like ariana who she haven't done anything yet....Mariah Carey is a songwriter,Singer,record producer...she is a complete Artist...but i believe all the compare game it started from the music intustry and then the people continued that little game by forgeting who really Mariah Carey is...but there are some people also who knows how demonic the music intustry is and our brains are still good...and i think you also as a vocal coach you must know what games music intustry are playing for money....anyway i feel lucky cause in my generation(i was born in the 80's)we had more patience and we waited what the artist will do...now you are making an album and you are the queen of everything...anyway for me...I feel at least from respect people should not compare Mariah with ariana...
False at 2:00 when she said that they tweaked the track of ari’s whistle note. People accused her of that when she made the cover and she later shut them up by posting a video of her doing them A cappella (live).
I wouldn't call Mariah's whistle on the national anthem "weak" since it being airy was an intentional thing she did. She has lots of different textures with her whistles but with this one she went with an airy one rather than a piercing or loud one.
Ariana sings with her head up only because to make her vocals light, airy and beautiful!!!!That's the only reason we call her an angel who is meant to take us off the ground with her vocals......cuz every other singer is digging depths....
Yes! Mariah did wrote All I Want For Christmas Is You!!!
she wrote it with
who?
I dont know him
just a joke
I know she wrote it with Walter
She isn't the only who wrote the song... Other people wrote it as well.
hello world No she wrote the song and there was a guy who composed the music.
@@dobbie4598 Mariah wrote the lyrics alone, Walter helped her with the melody of the song.
hello world nope she wrote the whole ass lyrics to the song Walter helped her with the music so she was nice enough to give him credits she said herself in an interview
Ariana is good on her own, no doubt about it, she has so much potential. But Mariah is on another league, her technique is way proficient. Comparing them on their same age, Ariana is completely crushed. Mariah mastered embellisments, phrasing, placement, resonance, disconnected registers, chest and mix, dynamics and etc. Ariana has a lot of things to improve: her diction, larynx position, breath support, jaw and tounge tension.
Facts, also Mariah naturally had that one in a million instrument, which Ariana nor 90% of pop singers can compete with .
you SAID it.
Mariah came out in 1990 to be huge. Ariana cant be compared
you are right. Maria is the best, her songs are very difficult to sing.
Gray sings ummmmm your wrong
She was making an airy whistle for blending mood in a song (National Anthem) it's not a weak whistle.She can make her whistle sound Airy,piercing,Clear blablabla check out her empress of the whistle register
Exactly...
Hahaha Empress of whistle and Queen of lipping..both really unnecessary in good singing
@@reddragonready ...
Just stop.
@@reddragonreadyif Mariah is not a good singer I can't imagine who the hell is a good singer lol
@@piyawatcarey7149 reddragon here...I am sure you can't...you are clearly delusional. To the point of not being able to read. I said these things are not needed to be a good singer.
They arent equally good... compare mariah same age and shes always better.
Always? Mmmh....... no
@@medannefff mmmmmm yes
@@medannefff yes always. 6 years first or mariah career she never lipsync and do her best vocally
@@medannefff yes always. 6 years first or mariah career she never lipsync and do her best vocally
equally?
No offense, but frankly they're not even in the same universe. Mariah Carey's vocal transition, jumps, support, resonance, range, agility, and melismata are way ahead Ariana Grande's, who is indeed a talented singer yet still immature technically, let alone Mariah Carey's artistry as she writes and produces most of her stuff.
That's right, mariah is the very best in 2018. Her unique and powerful timbre make her a unique artist.
Ariana sings well but she has no carism.
Thank you Voyage!!
“They are not even in the same universe.” Omg you spoke the truth 😭😭😭
Right, but as if Ariana does'nt write/produce her own stuff. Lmao.
Ariana is young and still mastering her craft....really
Ariana is great but Mariah is a LEGEND. Untouchable. Just it. 🥰
True
You said it
She has to be kinder to be a "queen"
@@elioaboujaoudeh1242 i hope you're not talking about any of the two singers mentioned in his comment. Mariah literally saved a woman from cancer by paying for her treatment and now they're great friends. What do you mean be kinder? And Ariana has done charity work also but she doesn't talk about it much. And Mariah has been running MariahCamp for like 24 years now.
Sandcastles oop you just put Elio in place 🤷🏽♂️ with receipts
I love Ariana. I have most of her albums. She's a very good singer, but c'mon Mariah is Mariah, one of the best ever. It's silly to claim that they're on the same level.
Hm? I mean- Ariana was the one hitting higher falsetto note. Yeah they aren't both the same level but the way you wrote the comment sounds a bit toxic.
Just hitting higher notes doesn't make someone a better singer. As good as Ariana is, Mariah is better at all ages.
Ariana is Ariana... what's your point?
Why r people hating on this comment? It is factual and not rude.
If Mariah debuted on this generation, it would be the end of em all. 🤣😂
Not when Ariana exists xoxo
@@arianasgaybf Ariana wouldn't exist in the first place without Mariah since she's one of her inspirations lol If you are stand of Ari you should know better xoxo
Nope this generation would ignore Mariah Carey as they're too depressed 😭 to give any attention to real talent
@@Numb-ty5mcso what inspiration does not mean she's inherited that talent. Have some sense of please
Mariah wins and im not a fan of either of them. I dont know but Mariahs voice is something i cant explain so soothing
Ron Viray that’s because she can talk to dolphins! Thats only something she and the dolphins can explain to us!! And I mean that in a good way! I’m a Mariah fan
Ari's voice is pleasant, it's not bad at all. I think it's a matter of preference. Comparing vocal quality, any vocal coach will say Mariah has better technique and vocal quality. The reason is Ari sounds nasal at times. Her larynx is raised and closed when trying to project the high notes, her words are slurred throughout a song, also she has a plasant, but thin voice... whereas Mariah sings comfortably and has a neutral larynx position most of the time when singing the high notes, she has crazy resonance, good articulation and agility, her voice could change from pleasantly airy n smooth to sharp and strong... Anyways, I think Ari is a great singer for this time in music, one of the best..., but if she were a singer in the 90s when the Trinity was top, she would be labeled as a "good singer" only. Competition was tough back then 😘
i really miss the 90's where singers can really SANG! today it's mostly auto tuned and who has the nicer beats that tops the chart. LOL. it's not about the vocals anymore. so sad. just saying. If i want to listen some nice vocals i don't listen to the radio anymore I would rather listen to covers by normal people on youtube that can really SANG too. haha
@addicted to good music thank u 😘
Amazing comment
chipmunkaraoke I liked it when people could spell
I agree 100% with everything said esp the back in the day reference. 90s was full of great singers. I do think ariana has a really lovely voice, but Mariah's is truly unnatural and angelic
You are so hilarious! Please react to Mariah's SNL Vanishing Rehearsal
Fly Like A Lamb omg hey queen.
omg iconic. but she probably won't have much reaction to mariah's effortless chest to whistle transition since she doesn't seem to get impressed by anything.
Up ❤
I was so weak when she said "I wonder If she lowers her chin while singing if she'll have more depth" I was CRYINGGG
I love it 🥰
Ariana is much closer to Aguilera than Mariah, she likes tense throaty singing and her runs and adlibs don't fit the music, she extends her falsetto up the 6th octave, while Mariah typically prefers whistle in this territory (with some falsetto and hv exceptions). Mariah at her best had the fastest runs in the industry, unparalleled musicality, her runs and adlibs are creative, she has good diction and can phrase throughout her entire range, her voice extends much lower than a typical soprano and best control over whistle register since Minnie Ripperton, so I don't really hear the similarities.
Ariana isn't even near to Christina... Christina is powerful, husky and very good at falsettos... Yes Ari can whistle, but her whole way of singing is very airy and mumbles a lot it gets so annoying
Christina’s agility and embellisments are still way superior than Ariana’s plus she has more ease than Ariana in the 6th octave.
Ralph I dislike I don't like Arians singing either but Christina ain't much better... While Arians sings with a lot of air, Christina is just the opposite, Christina sings with a lot of growls which is quite annoying... Neither of them can support a good C5 though both of them strains to go that high although C5 although that shouldn't even considered high for a girl.
You're right, Ariana does not have charisma and Mariah's songs are very difficult to sing.
Ralph Canete Christina isn't really powerful, she's pushing and straining, true vocal power comes from open, relaxed and supported singing. But she sure does sound more mature and less whiny than Grande. Of course they have different styles, but they are similar in having poor musicality and technique.
They aren't equally good lol. Even when compared at the same ages
Mariah wrote “all i want for christmas” with her writing partner :)
She wrote the lyrics as Walter made the music for the most part.
@@90Outside fake... Mariah did the melody and lyrics. Walter just produce it
Nope, mariah wrote all of it and did the melody in a very short time span. Walter did the producing and music on the computer.
Go watch mariah vs ariana at the same age to make it clear. It just make the difference so far. And yeahh mariah did wrote the all I want for christmas is you with walter
Mariah writes all of her songs and "All i want for christmas"music and lyrics is from Mariah
Sweety correction: both could never be equally good.. Mariah is miles infront better. Let's be real sis, don't negate a legend's reputation by saying she's equally to ariana..
Mariah is just the supreme songbird
Mariah is a way better singer ..no comparison
Nahhh
True
MARIAH WROTE ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU. As well as she’s written 95% of her songs.
Mariah Carey is the main writer for All I want for Christmas is you.
The fact is , no matter what age or era, Mariah has and will always be better than Ariana, even current Mariah has a wider supported range than Ariana in her whole career, Ariana is just another singer with a nice instrument but doesn't use it properly, kinda like Jessica Simpson except she totally ruined her instrument , as for Mariah she had an extraordinary instrument and she reached her full potential in her prime.
Art Aspire Lol. Hear her live in Jimmy Fallon a couple weeks ago? I haven’t heard Mariah perform live whistles for years.
Art Aspire | yeah, I’m sure if Mariah is 80 she can still sing like this🙄
Travis McGowan then you haven’t paid attention she dies them .
Travis McGowan Sure her "live" "whistles" you call them when they were like squeaks LMAO Ariola didn't even sustain the notes properly guuuuurl
@Hei Dinglepop yea she is, even current mariah is better than ariana today, in many aspects, since shes older now shes obviously not as good as she used to be, buts shes still going and her voice is still incredible, and she still has an incredible range
Ari can't touch Mariah. Ari is talented but something about her vocal styling that just gets me. Kinda like finger nails on a chalkboard. She kinda mumbles her words and it's distracting.
Tony Mullenix exactly!
It’s 2020 you probably have a different idea
@@marcusedwards1471 girl no mariah is still better than ariana coming from an arianator
TheArianator Life let’s be specific, cause at the end of the day, she cant sing as good as she used to.
Yes!
“What a weak whistle.. that wasn’t very good”
*realises that was Mariah*
“Oh I feel mean now”
PLEASE do more Mariah Carey she is my idol
Mariah was using a different texture for her whistle in National Anthem lol
They are NOT equally good singers or artists imo.
Ariana is great (lover her) but Mariah is A-M-A-Z-I-N-G..
There is a video where they are comparing them with the same age. That was 1995 daydream Mariah so... lmao
Marco Sebastião it was complete SLAYAGE, poor copycat didn’t stood a chance 🤣😂💀
Please react to more mariah carey !!!!!!!!She’s great come on :))))
Ariana Grande’s cover of ‘Somewhere over the rainbow’ was an emotional day for her and she started crying because of the Manchester Attack.
One day she will make a more clear version of the song.
T H A N K YOUUUUUUU
Mariah queen 💖
You really need to educate yourself a bit more on Mariah's vocals and her whistle register. There's a video on TH-cam explaining all of that. You should really check it out.
Thanks for reacting to my video!!!! :) Some clips are not the best but they are the only ones of each song. National Anthem (Ariana), Lady Marmalade (Mariah) and other. Both are amazing :)
She write all I want for Christmas is you together with Walter (her friends back then)
1. They’re not equals
Mariah Carey at Ariana’s age sang circles around Ariana
2. Ariana is fantastic for what she is.
3. Mariah wrote AIWFCIY
#2 made me laugh 🤣
I agree with you
7:51 it wasnt meant to be piercing because she added more dynamics after. So it would only make it sound extra af
Ariana raises her head like that to get it out cuz you are correct it's all in her head I find her quite nasally
"Equally good"? Sooooooo wrong lady! Statement. You can't compare a true vocalist and legend to a little girl with a pretty girly voice.
Herminio Perich What she meant was they r good on their own style
lol pretty girly voice?😂 atleast her "pretty girly voice" better then singers nowadays lol.
hun, obviously mariah is a legend, but omg, you can't say that about ariana, i mean... watch her live perfomances, jesus christ.
blurrysick; I like watching and listening to Ariana live. I love them both, but you’ve got to admit that Mariah is simply better. They’re styles are different but when Ariana sings Mariah’s songs you can hear it.
Ariana sound like a nasally micky mouse. Annoying af.
Fans need stop pitting vocal mother and daughter against each other and just enjoy the music
Hugh W sksksk agree
Hugh W omg I’ve never seen a Mariah stan say this
@@DarrenHazel lol ariana is mariah's maid, not mariah's children.
Ummmm i think you have lost your damn mind. Her vocal daughter is jojo or tori. The end.
Nah
Ariana is great but Mariah is a legend and she’s gone down as one of the most legendary singers.mariah is untouchable.
FACTS 🦋💖💜
Mariah without question. Come on now, she is simply on another level #MC 👑
Mariah gives me chills sometimes omg.
Ariana literally lacks proper techniques to be any comparison to Mariah
one thing I really agree is that Ariana doesn't have depth to her voice, it's like everything should be on that straining position thus sounded a bit of struggling, and the tone of Ariana is just too light no soul into it. but then again because MAriah is half black and her mother was an opera singer, that's what you get when you join two together, A great technique and great depth to the voice
Personally Ariana voice irritates me. I love Mariah Carey voice so much more
Me too! Holy. Ariana’s voice stays in the same pitch and she’s nasally. Can’t stand it.
Agree! I never understands what she is singing she needs to enunciate
DON'T COME FOR MY QUEEN! ☕
Thank God, me too. Me irrita su musica.
How can you say this. Her voice is so much of potential. Well you all go and bang your face somewhwre coz she has got a Grammy for best pop vocal ( just mentioned for the reason you said abt her voice) she was also nominated for the global awards just because of her voice and immense talent . So if you can't listen her songs so pls do not comment. STAY AWAY FOR MY QUEEN
I dont even know why that video and comparisons exist in the first place tho..
It's obviously Mariah.
Talent and personality. Mariah Carey.
Mariah is miles ahead of Ariana. But ariana is also good no question
They're not equally good singers. Mariah is the best. But I agree with most of what you said.
Mariah can sing circles around Ariana even on a bad day. Ariana is not the best singer. She’s just good compared to some of today’s younger artists. I never understood the comparison between them. Mariah is undoubtedly the best vocalist in the world.
I subscribed, btw! Love your videos! Can you compare Ariana’s vocals to Tori Kelly’s? They’re about the same age and Tori has a beautiful voice, but she always goes unnoticed, sadly.
I think you should have given ariana a little more praise when sining somewhere over the rambow considering it was a tribute to the victums of the terrorist attack at her concert and was crying when sining it
Of course Mariah is better, she has brilliant control, abilities, technique and melismas, runs and riffs, a unique, dominant and beautiful voice. She sang in a very touching way (from deep inside) and as you said from the chest.
She also has larger vocal range (she has 5-7 octaves, she gets really low to very high...she has 4 notes and her longest Note is 20 Seconds, Her vocal type is, Whatever her mood for the day is, coloratura light lyric soprano)
And she whistles phenomenally!
Plus she's here for many years and she also creates and writes her music.
And many of her music is smart and with depth unlike most of the music of today. Even though she does fun songs she has lots of songs with messages, and quality stuff she wrote or co-wrote that even saved people lives.
*2 VERY TALENTED SINGERS* stop the hate lambs and stop being weird arianators. 🖤
Wrong... she wrote it alone entirely. The music was with Walter. Lyrics only Mariah
Mariah Carey Grande Butera sksks stop being weird ahaha
@@darylacesantos umm u okay dahlin? btw just curious where does the "often imitated....." starts. who started that word? its annoying lol.
@@DarrenHazel It's from a Mariah song.
Loverboy remix. I think
@@darylacesantos Ariana is good. i think the 'best' in 'her generation'. but mariah is on a different level honestly.
Im surprised you didn't comment or acknowledge the control(accuracy), speed & creativity of the melisma at 4:02
Another great video.
I do love your objective ear.
Equally good? No. Mariah is better.
The Honest Vocal Coach Oh really? I didn’t realize Ariana had 5 Grammys and 18 number 1 hits.
Sylvester Lamoonski back then getting number one hits were easy Mariah can’t even get above 50 no a days
@@tibu4760 how was getting number 1's easy back then? people had to actually buy real albums at store standing in long queues and they didn't have internet to stream music unlimitedly. it was very hard to get a #1
Sylvester Lamoonski LMAO ariana has 1 grammy cut the slack😂😂
Tbh I think Ariana should recieve more acknowledgement from her, even tho everything she says it’s true but her vocal abilities are incredible. But mariah produces her music and writes all. As well as has way more resonance and agility
@@laug1576 you had me till more resonance
I remember watching Mariah's National anthem performance. She had an interview right before she went on and said she was worried about her whistle coming out. She wasn't sure if she'd hit the note. After the performance they caught up with her and she was all smiles. She said she was happy it came out.
Whats rhe interview called and where can i find it
She’s singing “somewhere over the rainbow” in DWT. She’s lowering her larynx and darkening her tone in that tour. But in 2018 her bright tone is back. And Mariah never sings her studio version of oh holy night FULLY live. That’s why the uploader chooses that performance. She slayed 2014 Christmas shows. Her confidence then is up to the roof back then in 2014.
2:07 faulty premise! The person who originated the song isn’t necessarily going to sing the song best. Whitney’s version of I Will Always Love You is superior to Dolly Parton’s version. Mariah herself has covered other artists like Phil Collins and improved the song. The person who sings the song the best is always going to be...“the person who sings the song best”.
The thing is Ariana has no depth to her belts or overall voice, it's all so high pitched sweet. Her voice is not very dramatic like the Mariah, Celine or Whitney. She hits the notes and yes she can belt very high but I don't think it sounds as unique/stylized as Mariah on the belts. They are not equally good, or Maybe only when it comes to technique but even on that component, I don't think Ariana can touch prime Mariah, her sound was so pristine/unique.
Mariah has wider range, better technique, does whistle tone and has a better tone and more power. She writes, sings and produces all of her albums. How can they be equally good?
I accept that Ariana is good, I like her songs, but that doesn't mean they are equally good. Mariah is the Queen of Melisma, the SongBird Supreme and Queen of Christmas. She is above the rest.
Mariah wrote all of her songs, YAS! ALL 😊 of course except the cover songs but she owned it the way she sings 😂
One of greatest noise vs One of greatest voice
girl dont do that. ariana is that gworl come again.
Mariah Carey and Walter Afanasieff wrote All I Want for Christmas in supposedly 15 minutes!
When Ariana was singing Somewhere Over The Rainbow it was like a few months after the terrorattack at her show so her voice was not so stable and she was crying while singing😪
Did anyone else’s audio cut out for like a min and a half during Emotions????
These have the most amazing voice of the century,but Mariah has more technic,we all know that.
"That was annoying" - good old northern honesty.
Ariana sounded great I didn’t hear anything wrong with it! They both are great! Let’s stop comparing women. They both sing amazing!
i wonder how many people realize that thats mariahs rendition of oh holy night and that there are other ways to sing it.... its not the original rendition, but every new artist sings it like it is, Luther Vandross, Patti Labelle and Whitney Houston have there own rendition of the song too to name a few.... i mean i dont blame them the original has a darker quality or deeper melancholy vibe to it but still everyone "trys" mariah's rendition which is cuteto watch i guess
Personally, I don't see the point in comparing singers from two different and distant generations. Mariah is a lot older than Ariana and it's undeniable that many vocalists get better over time because they get to know their voices. That being said, they are vocal references in their own generations and I like to think that Mariah was and probably still is one of Ariana's inspirations.
Ariana always sounds like she’s either shouting or mumbling. Idk if it’s a stylistic choice but Mariah’s timbre and stylistic choices are certainly more enjoyable to my ears.
Mariah is the best ariana who?
īż al 😂
Mariah is a legendary but ariana is one of the best young artist of this century
But still no need to be rude
These singers are not EQUALLY good Mariah’s technique and the roundness and colors of her voice is monumental
first ariana’s performance was right after the bomb, she was really into that song
Yeah I agree I actually that performance really emotional 😭
The sound is gone?
Yeah same for me?
I’m sorry but Ariana singing oh holy night sounded like a bag of cats screaming
Also if you wanna hear her enunciation better she is broadway trained she just doesn't always say all her words for stylistic purposes in her pop/Rnb music. Heres a link to her singing at a broadway session: th-cam.com/video/3m6g7rGkUcI/w-d-xo.html
I don't agree that the original artist necessarily sings the song better than anybody who covers it. Whitney and Mariah I think have made better versions of most of their covers including I'll BeThere, Greatest Love of All, Without You, All the Man That I Need, etc. Whitney's I Will Always Love is not better than Dolly Parton's but both are the best renditions in their respective genres, which are like apples and oranges.
Its comparing a toddler to a grown woman!no comparison!!
Mariah writes sooo much of her own stuff how much does Ari write?
that "weak whistle" is stylized 100%. check out a mariah whistle video that goes through all her textures. love you vids!
Everybody knows Ariana wants nothing to do when it comes to Mariah! Especially when Mariah was young. Mariah would sing her under a table.
RoRo Gyles Mariah can still sing her under the table
7:00 Unfortunately, they don't make mic stands that go low enough.
I wish I could hear her sing....and arrogantly comment on how she “strains”
YOU ARE FOR ME THE FUNNIEST INDIVIDUAL ON TH-cam! YOUR EXPRESSIONS, YOUR COMMENTS, EVERYTHING YOU DO BASICALLY IS HILARIOUS. THANK YOU FOR BEING SUCH AN INSPIRATION. REACT TO MORE LEONA LEWIS VIDEOS PUHLEASE!
Imo, tori Kelly and mariah are a better comparison. Ariana is a much different artist
Yes, Mariah wrote All I Want For Christmas Is You. She’s written all of her songs except for the obvious covers.
That’s the whistle that gave her , her spot in the guiness book of records. Are you kidding
i really like your videos. you and sam johnson are do unbiased and do such a good job at explaining vocals.
Mariah’s whistle in the National Anthem wasn’t weak she just has more control over her whistles than Ariana and she purposefully made the whistle sound airy.
I really enjoy that you express clearly on how you feel what the artists do. It shows that you aren't favoring them, but respecting both their singing techniques.
Ariana wasn’t even 20 in the o holy night clip while mariah was 45? Thats pretty unfair
well i believe that Mariah is Great Artist and have worked A LOT for her achievements and it is disrespectful to say at least to compare with a new singer like ariana who she haven't done anything yet....Mariah Carey is a songwriter,Singer,record producer...she is a complete Artist...but i believe all the compare game it started from the music intustry and then the people continued that little game by forgeting who really Mariah Carey is...but there are some people also who knows how demonic the music intustry is and our brains are still good...and i think you also as a vocal coach you must know what games music intustry are playing for money....anyway i feel lucky cause in my generation(i was born in the 80's)we had more patience and we waited what the artist will do...now you are making an album and you are the queen of everything...anyway for me...I feel at least from respect people should not compare Mariah with ariana...
No comparison at all. It’s like comparing a Chanel bag to a Walmart bag lol. Same concept.
Did she just say Ariana and Mariah are equally good?!... no shade but... come on
Are u kidding younger Mariah still killed her
False at 2:00 when she said that they tweaked the track of ari’s whistle note. People accused her of that when she made the cover and she later shut them up by posting a video of her doing them A cappella (live).
I wouldn't call Mariah's whistle on the national anthem "weak" since it being airy was an intentional thing she did. She has lots of different textures with her whistles but with this one she went with an airy one rather than a piercing or loud one.
Ariana doesn’t have any resonance. And I mean, like none?
No comparison and there never will be. Ever.
Ariana sings with her head up only because to make her vocals light, airy and beautiful!!!!That's the only reason we call her an angel who is meant to take us off the ground with her vocals......cuz every other singer is digging depths....