My final input: how is sustainable a structure in the middle of a desert with hundreds or thousands people living there? Is at least enough ground water there? How fast does it replenish, so the structure doesn't sink eventually (like those in China?). Where will the food come from? And what variety? Will they have cattle and herrings or other fish breeding there? Or at least growing their potatoes and wheat? And if all food imported, what will they offer to the suppliers to or the wider world for exchange in value? Fina ces? Market to spend money in like in Dubai? Tourism... to see the desert behind the glass?
So Mohammed bin Salman is building a carless city that stretches 110 miles (170km) and he himself has a car collection worth 100 million dollars. For starters who's going to live there? Upper class elite or middle class, or low level workers, and who in their right mind wants to live between two walls where you can only go sideways and having everything within 5 minutes walk means as you go down the line, everything repeats itself every 5 minutes.
What will the residents of this city do to earn money? What business and job opportunities are available there? How these opportunities expand? Those who dream of startups are extremely limited by space, money, market and real estate.
Great questions! The residents of this city have a variety of opportunities, from local businesses to innovative startups. It’s all about finding that niche and making it work within the constraints.
If it is a reality, then the Crown Prince will be applauded for his efforts. If it fails, then the Crown Prince will be in exile or worse. This project, along with all the other projects, is his legacy. He will either go down in history as an innovative modernist who continued the work.of his predecessors in moving Saudi Arabia forward - or - he will be a footnote, known for his failures and his demise.
The transportation time issue can be resolved by using multiple train lines. Only a few people will need to go end to end, so why not have 2 tracks, one in each direction, but multiple segments, or color lines. Red line goes 20 stops, blue line 20 stops, etc etc. If you include all of the stores, restaurants, businesses, homes, and entertainments/parks in each segment, there won't be much of a need to go into other segments. The other thing is not to use electrical engines in the trains, but use magnetic lev to increase speed between stops.
As depicted the wall, is well a wall, wind will be one of the primary issues. Another would be the need to build on bedrock, for a structure to stand a chance. 500m of anything built into resembling a wall is going to be heavy and noting short of bedrock could support that. 20 minutes end to end? Seems unlikely, unless it is express. Even then, the structure is 170Km long, so that's 510 Kph / 317 Mph, non stop. Cant think of many commercial vehicles that can do that, that isn't a plane. The energy needed for a ground vehicle to get to and maintain that would be ... impressive. Lets say I'll be impressed if they can even do the 3rd option, as a proof of concept.
Well, the reality is that Samario III can be effective. A friendly question from you: If you had the conditions, would you want to live in such a place?
@@MassiveBuild I am effectively a hermit, so as long as I have food, shelter, internet, pretty much anywhere would be fine, be it my current home, middle of nowhere, busy urban city, or the wall.
The third option is the most likely and will be the most costly on the basis of persons per km. But MBS will not be able to admit the mistake let alone defeat. The expensive and impractical folly will be interesting to see and may turn out to be a significant architectural and construction proving ground for future projects.
Train-problem can be solved with parallel electric train-line, spin trains up to meet the fast train, sync speed, and have a bridge-crossing open up. If you think this is madness, look at the speed and control of Supertrak, used in factories. (Old videos from Prof Laithwaite from Imperial College, Elec Eng).
I would also wonder whether technically you could launch satellites or reaction-engine style X-Fighters (if you put the rail on the roof)... you need to get fast enough, that horizon falls away before you hit it... then see how much lift you can generate, before you have to start engines...
5:30 - They could travel the whole length in 20 minutes if there are dedicated trains that straight shot from one side to the other. Either in rotation or that's their daily task is to commute from end to end.
Bitcoin 40% annual price increase per year for the next ten years and 20 % for 20 years after that. Digital property almost nothing to hold or maintain ..
I think they gotta do it in small blocks, work out the kinks then build the next block all while improving systems n shit. Proabaly the best way to go about this beside just not doing it
But so much relies upon continuous components from end-to-end and economies of scale. But it should have been circular to begin with. But that much humanity, and glass, in a desert? No.
The Line is anti-murca. Everything that is dumb in murca, will be fixed in the line. Thank god for the Saudis. The only alternative to the stupidness of Murca.
Unseen threats? Everyone knows how dumb this project is and have been talking about it from the start. If it happens it will look nothing like the glitzy CGI images. Stop milking this thing for content.
Another negative video about infrastructure outside America. If Dubai can successfully built...Neom will definitely succeed . You keep blowing trillions of dollars of illegal wars ...then wonder why others are building infrastructure.
why do I get the feeling you believe in the hyperloop and that we will be living on Mars in 5 years as well. and there are plenty of videos putting US infrastructure under the spotlight but carry on believing in you delusions you might need them when the line fails like the dumb idea it is
Actually the sales pitch is false. 'Green' energy like windmills and solar panels occupy vastly larger amounts of land than, say, a nuclear power plant, and use hundreds of times as much in resources (steel, copper, concrete, etc.) as nuclear or coal-fired electricity. Also, solar panels fall off steeply in efficiency under intense heat and sun, like in Saudi Arabia.
World's largest prison. "You have everything close and you never need to leave"
More importantly, robots bring everything to your door😂👌
😂😂👍👍
@@high-qt8gt 😍
Don't forget, no alcohol and this is basically just a bigger building to throw gays off
My final input: how is sustainable a structure in the middle of a desert with hundreds or thousands people living there? Is at least enough ground water there? How fast does it replenish, so the structure doesn't sink eventually (like those in China?). Where will the food come from? And what variety? Will they have cattle and herrings or other fish breeding there? Or at least growing their potatoes and wheat? And if all food imported, what will they offer to the suppliers to or the wider world for exchange in value? Fina ces? Market to spend money in like in Dubai? Tourism... to see the desert behind the glass?
I think they could be added to the number of factors that could cause its failure😅
They’ll want to feed the people insects, Genetically Engineered Fruit and Vegetables and Lab grown meat proteins.
So Mohammed bin Salman is building a carless city that stretches 110 miles (170km) and he himself has a car collection worth 100 million dollars. For starters who's going to live there? Upper class elite or middle class, or low level workers, and who in their right mind wants to live between two walls where you can only go sideways and having everything within 5 minutes walk means as you go down the line, everything repeats itself every 5 minutes.
Exactly. It was a good way of looking at the subject
What will the residents of this city do to earn money? What business and job opportunities are available there? How these opportunities expand? Those who dream of startups are extremely limited by space, money, market and real estate.
Great questions! The residents of this city have a variety of opportunities, from local businesses to innovative startups. It’s all about finding that niche and making it work within the constraints.
If it is a reality, then the Crown Prince will be applauded for his efforts. If it fails, then the Crown Prince will be in exile or worse. This project, along with all the other projects, is his legacy. He will either go down in history as an innovative modernist who continued the work.of his predecessors in moving Saudi Arabia forward - or - he will be a footnote, known for his failures and his demise.
The transportation time issue can be resolved by using multiple train lines. Only a few people will need to go end to end, so why not have 2 tracks, one in each direction, but multiple segments, or color lines. Red line goes 20 stops, blue line 20 stops, etc etc. If you include all of the stores, restaurants, businesses, homes, and entertainments/parks in each segment, there won't be much of a need to go into other segments. The other thing is not to use electrical engines in the trains, but use magnetic lev to increase speed between stops.
Yes, those things are possible. As I said in the video, this problem can be solved, but the other 4 problems are a bit difficult.
As depicted the wall, is well a wall, wind will be one of the primary issues. Another would be the need to build on bedrock, for a structure to stand a chance. 500m of anything built into resembling a wall is going to be heavy and noting short of bedrock could support that.
20 minutes end to end? Seems unlikely, unless it is express. Even then, the structure is 170Km long, so that's 510 Kph / 317 Mph, non stop. Cant think of many commercial vehicles that can do that, that isn't a plane. The energy needed for a ground vehicle to get to and maintain that would be ... impressive.
Lets say I'll be impressed if they can even do the 3rd option, as a proof of concept.
Well, the reality is that Samario III can be effective.
A friendly question from you: If you had the conditions, would you want to live in such a place?
@@MassiveBuild I am effectively a hermit, so as long as I have food, shelter, internet, pretty much anywhere would be fine, be it my current home, middle of nowhere, busy urban city, or the wall.
@@Knightymewell that's just sad. Try going out more and interacting with people. It will give you confidence
The third option is the most likely and will be the most costly on the basis of persons per km. But MBS will not be able to admit the mistake let alone defeat. The expensive and impractical folly will be interesting to see and may turn out to be a significant architectural and construction proving ground for future projects.
Well, this insistence will do nothing but harm to Saudi Arabia. isn't it?
Train-problem can be solved with parallel electric train-line, spin trains up to meet the fast train, sync speed, and have a bridge-crossing open up. If you think this is madness, look at the speed and control of Supertrak, used in factories. (Old videos from Prof Laithwaite from Imperial College, Elec Eng).
I would also wonder whether technically you could launch satellites or reaction-engine style X-Fighters (if you put the rail on the roof)... you need to get fast enough, that horizon falls away before you hit it... then see how much lift you can generate, before you have to start engines...
5:30 - They could travel the whole length in 20 minutes if there are dedicated trains that straight shot from one side to the other. Either in rotation or that's their daily task is to commute from end to end.
Bitcoin 40% annual price increase per year for the next ten years and 20 % for 20 years after that. Digital property almost nothing to hold or maintain ..
REALY??
I go will be in charge of the window cleaning ?
I think they gotta do it in small blocks, work out the kinks then build the next block all while improving systems n shit. Proabaly the best way to go about this beside just not doing it
But so much relies upon continuous components from end-to-end and economies of scale. But it should have been circular to begin with. But that much humanity, and glass, in a desert? No.
Wow what a shocking surprise!🤔
why, you didn't expect it?
nice explain , exactly
🙏🙏
All the tunnels have been stopped and bethel are being thrown off site
good sharing
Thank you! Cheers!
@@MassiveBuild you welcome
This thing doesn't have a single external investor. Nobody took MBS seriously.
why?
@@MassiveBuildbecause the idea is so stupid. Also no one wants to invest in Saudi.
It was very easy to guess , it happen
really?!
I love the line. I will be buying my retirement apartment there. Windsurf in morning and ski in afternoon :)
The dumbest thing to ever be considered making?
The Line is anti-murca. Everything that is dumb in murca, will be fixed in the line. Thank god for the Saudis. The only alternative to the stupidness of Murca.
Mostly scenario 3 will happen
i think so
Unseen threats? Everyone knows how dumb this project is and have been talking about it from the start. If it happens it will look nothing like the glitzy CGI images. Stop milking this thing for content.
Well, dear friend, if the video is useful for even one person who doesn't know anything, that's enough for us
nice plan but worst action
exactly
Really it is annoying project
no, i think it is good plan but no action
😂😂😂Lol
💥
wow I'm so shocked.
Why? Did you think everything was going well?
Of course, nothing is certain, but it probably shows this
@@MassiveBuild sarcasm.
First Comment - Sir this is a failed project.
In fact, this project is also walking in this direction
Another negative video about infrastructure outside America.
If Dubai can successfully built...Neom will definitely succeed .
You keep blowing trillions of dollars of illegal wars ...then wonder why others are building infrastructure.
I was in Dubai and would not consider it a success.
Neom is completely crazy.
why do I get the feeling you believe in the hyperloop and that we will be living on Mars in 5 years as well. and there are plenty of videos putting US infrastructure under the spotlight but carry on believing in you delusions you might need them when the line fails like the dumb idea it is
Forget the geopolitics. It's not going to happen. Get over it.
Our goal is not to make the project fail, we only explore the possible possibilities.
😅
A complete nonsense
Project design or implementation, my friend?
hahahahahahahah
🤔🤔
Ai voiced junk video
Is there a problem with the sound?
Actually the sales pitch is false. 'Green' energy like windmills and solar panels occupy vastly larger amounts of land than, say, a nuclear power plant, and use hundreds of times as much in resources (steel, copper, concrete, etc.) as nuclear or coal-fired electricity. Also, solar panels fall off steeply in efficiency under intense heat and sun, like in Saudi Arabia.
It seems that other than that, many problems are happening
Crappy clickbait video
thank you
Why clickbait, do you think the project will continue to be built?