The dance tiers aren’t correct. Karina is low t5, ning is high t6, winter is low t6, giselle is ht7 and sullyoon is also ht7. So it’s karina>ning>winter>sullyoon>giselle
@@mimi_imfatkarina is defo not low tier 5 that’s the same as Momo and Enhypens Jay she’s not of their level so she’s defo not a low tier 5 do u mean low tier 6?
Vocals: 1. Ningning (C+) 2. Winter (C) 3. Sullyoon (D+) 4. Giselle/Karina (D) (Debatable) Stage presence: 1. Karina 2. Ningning 3. Giselle 4. Winter 5. Sullyoon ৹ Sullyoon is D+ because in KVA, in order to be a C-, you need to have consistent and non shallow breath support, which Sullyoon lost. ৹ Giselle has overall better technique than Karina, but she lacks material (especially belting), so Karina can be considered better. ৹ Aespa overall improved A LOT in stage presence. Even though Sullyoon is last, she is really good and her and winter are almost tied, so they are pretty interchangeable. ৹ Dance and rap Ningning>Sullyoon.
I mean it doesn’t really matter. Visual is subjective. For example, NingNing would be considered the most beautiful worldwide and she’s the only person on this list that gets nominated in the top 100 most beautiful faces in the world year after year. But again it’s all subjective especially because KPop is now branching outside of only Korea
@@Ghost-bn7ce imo if i giving position to aespa i think ningning can be another visual or maybe face of the group but officialy Karina and winter are the visual ! so it's for that i put Karina and winter before ningning and gisele , and imo sullyoon is most beautiful than other member of aespa but all idol are beautiful
Sub vocals* she is more close to Kariselle than winter. Ning is a better dancer. No dance position and rina is a much better rapper and even ning is a better rapper so sub rapper as well.
I think Giselle ranks 4th position in vocal like don't get me wrong, Karina actually has a lower vocal range compared to Gisele. And I think her vocal is underrated (From a perspective of a musician specialist)
@@Celestial-c8z y'all wanna talk about reasoning when all you say is X vocalist is B+ or mid weak or whatever bs it is? None of it talks about the extent to which they support their notes, their vibrato, their understanding of vocal dynamics or ANYTHING like that. They just talk about stability, which is the most vague thing you could say. Half of you kva worshippers don't even understand what breath support even means or how to use it while singing KVA, while made by people who have a good knowledge of singing in general, is a completely flawed concept in general. You CAN'T measure a vocalist by just 1 or 2 metrics and generalise them into a tier with visibly better/worse vocalists because it just doesn't work like that To go on bit more of a tangent, is anyone aware that ningning has a better lower register than the greats like taeyeon, or that yuju is a better belter than wendy? Probably not, because all they're aware of is that ningning/yuju are in lower tiers than wendy and taeyeon and thus are automatically weaker in all aspects
@@ArrozConPollo_34 Sullyoon's mix is a more refined version of winter's mix and definitely more consistent Both winter and sullyoon's lows are quite average, but sullyoon does edge her out WInter has a clearly better controlled vibrato (that's probably her biggest strength) and she is slightly stronger in the upper registers Sullyoon has quite a clean transition b/w her registers and does play around with her vocal dynamics/delivery a lot more than winter Another thing to add is stamina, winter, along with the whole of aespa has improved a lot over the last year, but sullyoon still reigns supreme there If you wanna say something else, please don't use vague terms like "technique is better" for two vocalists that are not far apart in skill
@@k0k0m0nunfortunate for you i know that ning is better in low register. Even in her group, winter is the one for high register and the belter. How unfortunate you poor little person.
![[#2024MAMA] aespa - Bored! + Spark + Dopamine + UP + Supernova (MAMA ver.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oijZZiLG4CY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#2024MAMA] aespa - Bored! + Spark + Dopamine + UP + Supernova (MAMA ver.)](/img/tr.png)
Sullyoon being the middle child 💀💀
Sullyoon be like: Stuck In The Middle 😂
sullyoon is in the middle, sullyoon all rounder. 😻❤️✨
Sullyoon - I am stuck in the middle with Aespaaaaaaaa.........
Just check out Sullyoon singing 'Next Level,' and you'll see how great her vocals are
Ikr! But ningning and winter are just that good. Their vocals are a bit better but sully’s vocals ate and left no crumbs
@Fromis_9_defender I'M BOTH SAD AND HAPPY FOR FROMIS_9 😭🫶🏻
center sullyoon 💙💪🏻🔥
always slay, queenn🔥🔥🔥
Sullyoon and ning are the all rounders in this list damn
Sullyoon all around
But Sullyoon can sing well while dancing pretty hard
Okay but this Intro is Fire 😍😍😍🔥🔥
YASSS THE QUEEN AN YUJIN 👑
@@lwgrwqx_7631 OUR QUEEN ATE 🔥🔥😍
What is the song name?
@@AnchalSwain-n1t Chicken Teriyaqi
Yesss our come slayeeedd
What i really think is that it's too accurate ranking.. ❤❤
Lead everything, visual
So,her position
Lead Dancer
Lead vocalist
Lead rapper
Visual
Maknae
Thanks to do my request😊
No need for thanks ❤
💫⭐💝💖✨🌟
Not lead sub vocal
Sub rap
Fotg
Dancer
@Rezsc No she is lead vocalist winter and ning ning are both main vocalists.So she will be the lead vocalist
@@anuraudayakumara3596 winter is lead vocalist
The fact Sullyoon was in third except Stage performance is just crazy 😅
Sullyon positions
Sub vocalist (C-)
Sub rapper (Low tier 6)
Maknae
Visual
i think she can be lead vocalist with winter :)
it's not maknae
She is @@miyeon_gidle2018
@@miyeon_gidle2018 she is 20 years old, the younger member in aespa is 23 or 22 (I don't remember) years old
@@кто_о_о yeah she and Winter are so good in vocals
My pretty biased❤❤❤❤
VOCALS:
1. Ningning (C+)
2. Winter (C)
3. Sullyoon (-C)
4. Karina (^D+)
5. Giselle (D+)
DANCE:
1. Karina (Mid T6)
2. Winter (Low T6)
3. Sullyoon (High T7)
4. Ningning (High T7)
5. Giselle (Mid T7)
RAP:
1. Giselle (Low T4)
2. Karina (Mid T5)
3. Sullyoon (Low T6)
4. Ningning (Low T6)
5. Winter (Low T6)
SP:
1. Ningning
2. Sullyoon
3. Karina
4. Winter/Giselle
VISUALS:
(My opinion):
1. Sullyoon
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
5. Giselle
• Thanks for watching I love you all 💗
The dance tiers aren’t correct. Karina is low t5, ning is high t6, winter is low t6, giselle is ht7 and sullyoon is also ht7. So it’s karina>ning>winter>sullyoon>giselle
@@mimi_imfatkarina is defo not low tier 5 that’s the same as Momo and Enhypens Jay she’s not of their level so she’s defo not a low tier 5 do u mean low tier 6?
Vocal
Ningning - Low A-AA (C+)
Winter - Mid-High Average (C)
Sullyoon - High(est?) W-A (D+)
Karina - Mid-High W-A (D+)
Giselle - Mid W-A (D)
Dance
Karina 8.50
Ningning 7.15
Winter 7.05
Sullyoon 6.55
Giselle 5.65-5.75
Rap
Giselle 18/50
Karina 17.50/50
Winter High NR
Ningning High NR
Sullyoon Mid NR
SP (again SUBJECTIVE)
Karina 17/50
Ningning 16/50
Giselle 16/50
Sullyoon 15/50
Winter 15/50
First of all,there is nothing like vocal tier's,dance tier's or any tier's at all
People misusing the C tier 🤦♂️
This would be a Visually blessed group ✨
Position: ALL ROUNDER 😝
Sullywon always in the middle lol
sullyoon in the middle :D
Haneul by kof in new jeans!!
Sullyoon be like i am center in easpa 😅
Imagine comparing an idol with a grp
Make Karina in BLACKPINK ❤❤
Imo dance 2 vocal 1 (with rosé) rap 2 visual 1 sp is subjective I would personally put her as 4
@@zaiconic ME
Vocal - 1. KARINA AND ROSE
RAP - 1. JENNIE
2. LISA
3. KARINA
DANCE - 1. LISA
2. KARINA
SP - 5 AND VISUAL 1 WITH JISOO
@@gab_lestrange objectively speaking
1st vocals , 2 dance, 3 rap, 3 sp if im not wrong or 4 but above jisoo for sure
i like winter vocal and visual 🥰
Vocals:
1. Ningning (C+)
2. Winter (C)
3. Sullyoon (D+)
4. Giselle/Karina (D) (Debatable)
Stage presence:
1. Karina
2. Ningning
3. Giselle
4. Winter
5. Sullyoon
৹ Sullyoon is D+ because in KVA, in order to be a C-, you need to have consistent and non shallow breath support, which Sullyoon lost.
৹ Giselle has overall better technique than Karina, but she lacks material (especially belting), so Karina can be considered better.
৹ Aespa overall improved A LOT in stage presence. Even though Sullyoon is last, she is really good and her and winter are almost tied, so they are pretty interchangeable.
৹ Dance and rap Ningning>Sullyoon.
LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK👏👏
THANK YOU
Karina is D+
Once again I have to explain this Giselle vocals (D+^/C-)>Karina vocals (D+^)
giselle -C??? 😭
Sullyoon's vocals are b-
@@Eunchwsy I never mentioned Sullyoon
@@aidenii Yes Giselle is D+^/C- which is better than just D+^
@@Ra-InSoulsChaloompa I just tried to say that the list was completely wrongbut English is not my native language so I wrote it wrong
I agree with everything but I think Winter should be higher in sp but it's just my opinion
Pls Lia in nmixx❤❤
(major sarcasm warning)
This totally isn't biased at all...
ningning>Sullyoon in dance
Ningning is fr the ace lol-
Prob she'll (sullyoon) be lead vocal, sub rapper, visual, maknae
She's main vocal!!
Main vocal
sorry for not clarifying guys! for the positions i meant sullyoon yes
giselles vocals are good icl
STAGE PRESENCE
KA
NINGNING
WINTER
GISELLE
SULLYOON
Vocals: ning>winter>sullyoon>karina>giselle
Rap: giselle>karina>ning>winter>sullyoon
Dance: karina>ning>winter>sullyoon>giselle
Stage presence (imo): karina=ning>giselle>sullyoon>winter
Visuals (again imo): karina>ning>sullyoon>winter>giselle
in terms of kbs in visual sullyoon would be first
Perfect except for ning> Karina in sp and visuals is sully> Karina> winter> ningning> giselle imo
Karina and Sullyoon is a part of the “JangKaSul” visual trio in Korea btw. The other idol is Jang Wonyoung.
@@jo_valentinot yeah, sure. That visual ranking is based of my personal taste tho. I don’t care how many boxes they check off on a list
@@raiiquexiiz well that “(imo)” can tell you that it’s based on my preference, not in terms of kbs
So she'll be lead vocalist, Sub dancer (Ning is a better dancer) and sub rapper (Again, ning better)
Sullyoons positions: Vocalist(Imo: ^D+) Sub rapper (High 7) Lead dancer( high 7)
Rap
Karina
Giselle
Sullyoon
Winter
Ningning
Rap
Giselle : B+
Karina : F
@@Maenh1714 Giselle T4 high and Karina T5 high ://
Vocal Sullyoon C
Vocal D+ high ;-;
Sullyoon vocal skill is better than winter in my opinion ❤
SP IMO
Giselle/Ningning
Karina/winter
Sullyon
ELLA(MEOW)IN BABYMON PLS
Winter's sp improved so much, it's crime put her the last
they're still basing it on early aespa... i think she's no.1 in SP now..
Can you please do wonyoung in babymonster liliblink?🥺
Can u tell me the song in frist 😊
It's chicken teriyaki
Complete the lyrics :
You tell me that you need me then you walk away keep......
Pls Rora in Ive and Minnie in Blackpink ❤
Could people put things as they are, Winter currently has the best SP of the group, we are no longer in the era of girls you know
She doesn't lol
She doesn’t delulu fan 💀
Errr I think Karina and Winter definitely have better SP than Sully, and this is coming from a hardcore NSWER😬
What song in a intro???
Chicken Teriyaki and search Ive's Yujin dance and it pops out,cuz it's recent
Sp Ningning >Karina>Giselle>Sullyoon>Winter
Can you pls do rat ahyeon in meovv
Ahyeon rat????????? I'm so confused
@@Señorita_thanosaMaybe rank?!!😂
@@Señorita_thanosa i Cut the word it standes for rating
@@Blerinabazaj oh, my bad
She'll be second/third in vocals (not sure), third in rap, and fourth in dance.
imo ningning > sullyoon in dancing & CURRENTLY winter > sullyoon in sp (winter's facial expressions are much more attractive)
Giselle is slightly better in vocals than Karina
VISUAL
KARINA
WINTER
SULLYOON
NINGNING
GISELLE
Visual :
Imo
1. Sullyoon
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
5. Gisele
why bother ranking them in visual thats unnecessary they’re all pretty and the they didn’t rank it either so
@@yoshie3305 you have totally reason but imo if they want a visual ranking , this can be a perfect ranking ! You know what i mean ?
Giselle comes before ningning, she has a higher percentage because she is Korean too, it depends a lot on your opinion.
I mean it doesn’t really matter. Visual is subjective. For example, NingNing would be considered the most beautiful worldwide and she’s the only person on this list that gets nominated in the top 100 most beautiful faces in the world year after year. But again it’s all subjective especially because KPop is now branching outside of only Korea
@@Ghost-bn7ce imo if i giving position to aespa i think ningning can be another visual or maybe face of the group but officialy Karina and winter are the visual ! so it's for that i put Karina and winter before ningning and gisele , and imo sullyoon is most beautiful than other member of aespa but all idol are beautiful
Kyujin in babymonster
So:
Lead vocalist
Lead dancer
Lead rapper
Makne
Visual
Sub vocals* she is more close to Kariselle than winter. Ning is a better dancer. No dance position and rina is a much better rapper and even ning is a better rapper so sub rapper as well.
I think Giselle ranks 4th position in vocal like don't get me wrong, Karina actually has a lower vocal range compared to Gisele.
And I think her vocal is underrated (From a perspective of a musician specialist)
Sullyoon less than ningning in dance and less in SP
I think winter is a better dancer than sullyoon
Yes
Cómo se llama la canción de la intro ?
Sullyoon positions:
Sub vocalist
Visual
Maknae
Dance:
Karina:8.55
Ningning:7.25
Winter:7.05
Sullyoon:6.45
Giselle:5.55
Rap:
Giselle:T4 high
Karina:T5 high
Ningning:T6 mid
Winter:T6 mid
Sullyoon:T7 high
Stague:
Karina:17/20
Giselle:16/20
Ningning:16/20
Winter:15/20
Sullyoon:13/20
Sullyoon is kinda aespa coded with her deadly combination of vocals and visuals
What's intro song name?
What was the song in the intro😂
Teriyaki by Rosalia
Hii
Pin 📌 please i love your edit
Sorry, I can't pin any comments, TH-cam won't let me pin comments😢
@_liliblink why?
Giselle is C- while Karina is D+
Giselle is still D+ and I think they are D/D+
Rami in Blackpink. Lily in kiof. JYP in straykids
What's the title of the intro?
An yujin ive dance performance watch it you never regret
What's the intro??
YUJIN IVE
Yesss i know it's her😅 where is the clip from?! Which cover?! ❤️
NingNing dance 2.
Winter 3.
Winter is lead dancer tho? And she have the best body control alongside Karina
Sullyoon is above winter as a vocalist
And if anyone wants to reply, dont bring up any vocal tier shit cuz its all bs
She is not but ok. Winter's technique is better
Definitely not. What you’re saying is nonsense too. At least those KVA tiers have some reasoning unlike you.
@@Celestial-c8z y'all wanna talk about reasoning when all you say is X vocalist is B+ or mid weak or whatever bs it is?
None of it talks about the extent to which they support their notes, their vibrato, their understanding of vocal dynamics or ANYTHING like that. They just talk about stability, which is the most vague thing you could say. Half of you kva worshippers don't even understand what breath support even means or how to use it while singing
KVA, while made by people who have a good knowledge of singing in general, is a completely flawed concept in general. You CAN'T measure a vocalist by just 1 or 2 metrics and generalise them into a tier with visibly better/worse vocalists because it just doesn't work like that
To go on bit more of a tangent, is anyone aware that ningning has a better lower register than the greats like taeyeon, or that yuju is a better belter than wendy? Probably not, because all they're aware of is that ningning/yuju are in lower tiers than wendy and taeyeon and thus are automatically weaker in all aspects
@@ArrozConPollo_34 Sullyoon's mix is a more refined version of winter's mix and definitely more consistent
Both winter and sullyoon's lows are quite average, but sullyoon does edge her out
WInter has a clearly better controlled vibrato (that's probably her biggest strength) and she is slightly stronger in the upper registers
Sullyoon has quite a clean transition b/w her registers and does play around with her vocal dynamics/delivery a lot more than winter
Another thing to add is stamina, winter, along with the whole of aespa has improved a lot over the last year, but sullyoon still reigns supreme there
If you wanna say something else, please don't use vague terms like "technique is better" for two vocalists that are not far apart in skill
@@k0k0m0nunfortunate for you i know that ning is better in low register. Even in her group, winter is the one for high register and the belter. How unfortunate you poor little person.
Vocals
1 Ningning
2 Winter
3 Sullyoon
4 Karina
5 Giselle
Rap
1 Giselle
2 Karina
3 Ningning
4 Sullyoon
5 Winter
Dance
1 Karina
2 Sullyoon
3 Winter
4 Ningning
5 Giselle
Sp
1 Karina
2 Winter
3 Ningning
4 Sullyoon
5 Giselle
Just my opinion, no hate please ❤❤
I think Ningning is better than Sullyoon in dance
Karina sp>> sully
Nah