@@joelmoses1139 much true brother And what ever you said is evident in the video also Many were giving him tips of info. till then he was not saying but watching.
Cji dallal hai suo moto cognizance sirf political agenda ke liya hai desh mein kya kya ho gaya itne dino mein tab nahi socha suo moto cognizance ka, yahan par facts saaf bata rahe ki speculation chal raha cji ko khud nahi fir kab darj hui. Murder hua nahi yeh toh fir ke baad tafteesh mein chalega.yahi suo moto manipur,sebi, butch,neet ,upsc ya kisi aur mudde par nahi liya waha logo ko petition file karni pad rahi aur yaha bjp ko chamkane ke suo moto cognizance liya jaa raha jabki high court bhi jurisdiction wise capable hai cause its a constitutional court too.cji is fishing for issues to blow them out of proportion and make them as if big incompetence of police,people have been misdirected with all sorts of bogus data ,here news channels should have also be taken to task for making the mockery of investigation and victims family.cji is hell bent into declaring that there is incompetence baar baar facts se hath ke mehta idhar udar ki baat kar raha hai politics keech raha beech mein kyoki proceedings telecast ho raha hai .
Shameless capil sibil and Congress supporting West Bengal police and principal defending them ..... Fo they have any more responsibility in heart ?? Everything is money and politics?? Wrostu
@@punisherwarlord very apt words, however it's the side this lawyer argues for -even if he had always sided with the perpetrators, it's not a crime. It's only the fact that he argues for those who are against BJP. Is this a legal or a political defense?
Yeah during my internship we used to do 36hr.. and during this 36hr we were not even able to sit sometimes, but recently increasing number of seats have made things little easier yet it's still inhuman. But somewhere during residency it gave me strength. I agree it should be changed.
The unfortunate Doctor who was brutally murdered was subjected to this torture after 36 hours of duty, and then the ex Principal along with his powerful accomplices ( he is probably close to CM) were trying to pass on as suicide and mentioned the Doctor's name multiple times. The CM then tried to perception wise blamed the opposition for vandalism when even a child knows that culprits tried to erase any proof of murder. All goons then under pressure subsequently imprisoned are from the ruling party. Does this not prove the direct involvement of the most powerful people in West Bengal?
It’s not only inhumane but it also decreases the cognitive ability to take decision when your brain is tired……these people are crazy and have zero sensibilities……
The lawyer defending WB Gov...is very dangerous for mankind and India💔 the way he is totally denying the victim's parents statement 💔I am in shock how he is raising his voice against the truth and the bench.
Cji dallal hai suo moto cognizance sirf political agenda ke liya hai desh mein kya kya ho gaya itne dino mein tab nahi socha suo moto cognizance ka, yahan par facts saaf bata rahe ki speculation chal raha cji ko khud nahi fir kab darj hui. Murder hua nahi yeh toh fir ke baad tafteesh mein chalega.yahi suo moto manipur,sebi, butch,neet ,upsc ya kisi aur mudde par nahi liya waha logo ko petition file karni pad rahi aur yaha bjp ko chamkane ke suo moto cognizance liya jaa raha jabki high court bhi jurisdiction wise capable hai cause its a constitutional court too.cji is fishing for issues to blow them out of proportion and make them as if big incompetence of police,people have been misdirected with all sorts of bogus data ,here news channels should have also be taken to task for making the mockery of investigation and victims family.cji is hell bent into declaring that there is incompetence baar baar facts se hath ke mehta idhar udar ki baat kar raha hai politics keech raha beech mein kyoki proceedings telecast ho raha hai .
Shame shame! There are women lawyers backing sibal who is representing wb govt. They seem so eager ! Shame on them. Tomorrow who will represent these women lawyers if they land in the same situation ??!!
Why only safety in hospital....we need to look into safety accross India what about cab, auto, travel during night, bus, gim, school, college, hostel, PG, training centre... girls need safety in all this places too.
Because hospital is where doctors are dealing with people in very sensitive moments of people's life. Only with a strong law can you expect some level of safety in such highly sensitive situations. What aboutism doesn't help solve things probably one thing at a time or one place at a time will help
@@pinakimukherjee3142Everyone residing in WB knows who are those people. ‘Right to Violence and Vandalism’ is a fundamental right of ruling party workers in WB. Be it CPIM, TMC or if in case any other party wins in future, this right will be exercised by them also. After all it’s a Fundamental Right of the Ruling party in WB !!
Being an advocate I really ashamed of Mr. Sibbal. They way he is denying and the actual facts is really disheartening.. the poor soul may rest in peace.
The defence lawyer Sibal is arguing for his commercial benefit angle and non as a humanitarian. But unfortunately the government appointed AG or SG gets only salary and transportation, naturally not aggressive.
5:32 What’s a “unnatural Death” registration? Was the Principal not sure looking at the dead doctor that it was a “Homicide? 5:32 Why did the Principal tried to downplay ?? He is the key culprit here. Definite cover up.
@@ra-wj1wl did it take up the issue of the role of the state in protecting the evidence? Wtf did you find in this two hundred minutes of judicial farting
Kapil Sibal I lost your respect on you this is a man who mislead the case instead of supporting the victim very bad hope justice must be prevail for the victims
Where is the humanity , one girl murdered but here everyone pretending like its normal and kapil sibbal shame on you why you trying to save culprits if this incidents happens with your daughter then what should be you do ?
A perverted SC postpones CBI report for 2 days. It however does NOT order WB Govt to provide security to striking docs till such time they call strike off. So clearly SC trying to give clean chit to WB Govt. Docs pls don't call strike off. We the People are with you on your fight against WB Govt in fight for Justice.
No power in hands of CJI... These much harsh facts of heinous crime. And no power to arrest a notorious principal, erring police heads or college authorities... Where does the hell of fear any of these have even aftr this dirty act.... Only the parents lost a daughter. Do these people, the lawyers, police or any have any loss.....
Mamata is a great states woman , she transformed Republic of Bharat into a banana republic of Bokoharam. We are unarmed and helpless But why Center has become a witness only. Can Modiji answer that as well .
Judges take summer and winter vacations, but due to deficient doctor patient ratio doctor's dont have vacations , but junior doctors have to work 36 hours many days with no toilet facilities or restroom for proper rest inbetween patients, they sleep in patients bed . This state for doctors or police is shameful in this country.
Why didn't anyone register the FIR as soon as they found the body. So if they say the first was filed at 11 in the night it means 12 hrs after the body was discovered. Why didn't the principal or anyone file an fir right away after the discovery of the body, or calling the police to the campus. Does it mean the autopsy was conducted without an fir.
SIBAL. IS TALKING BIG WE KNOW HIS BACKGROUND HE IS SORRY. IN EVERYTHING WE KNOW HE WILL PROTECT MAMATA HE SAYS HE HAS VIDEOS HE AGREES TO THIS OR THAT.
This Kapil Sibbal advocate has daughter? If he paid highly money for the case If his daughter treated the same way wheather he will defend the culprit??? Indians Demand for Justice
SC is right in setting up a National Task Force.Doctors Community needs to be protected and they shld be given proper basic facilities at the Workplace..
Sir,36 and 48 hrs of duty.has it any reasoning and no lace for taking a little rest even.what are these young doctors supposed to be? Human beings or Robots?
I wish the court finds out the exact facts not the fabricated story and regarding the photographs taken must be considered as another issue.I think if the photograps were not taken it would not have reached to the rest of the public which would have made the protest weak.This principal and the government would have got a lot more chances to fabricate the story.
It looks like diversion tactics are used here. As a common human being, I'm worried whether the culprits will be punished. But why is there so much importance given to sibil? I believe CJ will give justice.
CJI has caught on the vein of the subject. Very pertinent issues raised by him...should be answered. Official operations like reg of comp, FIR, PM etc done hours after the incident. That too in a hospital.
Cji please Create a bench to have a thorough investigation the which Political party indulge in this henious crime in a holistic approach and Judgement on systems failure. Should also see if there is conspiracy to tople the government. Politicians taking milage should also be monitored.sack the principal from, the truth will come out.
Greatful to Lordship. My daughter completed her MBBS in Government Hospital. No Proper Duty Room in Government Hospital. She has slept in chairs during her night shifts. She has slept on empty patient beds. She has slept on benches without blanket.😢
Last year a house surgeon was brutally killed by a prisoner while she was treating him, after that incident kerala government has ordered atleast one day a week off for house surgeons and resident doctors, let us start from there.. bring a change to these inhumane atrocities. Dr. Vandana will be in our minds forever, RIP beautiful soul.
Kapil Sibal is a serial liar. He says we (the government, police & hospital administration) never circulated the picture or revealed the name. The truth is that the Commissioner of Kolkata Police himself took the name of the victim several times. When CJI said no FIR was filed or was filed late Sibal again says that's again not true. Another lie. The FIR was filed at 11.45 pm 3 hours after the cremation. It's a joke. And this shameless person tries to pass the buck to the parents.
I am full of high regards to our honorable CJI so highly intelligent with such high position but so humble down to earth n the manner he conducts SC case discussion n judgement is amazing
Power should not be unleashed on peaceful protestors. But, should peaceful common people suffer and die wuthout medical treatment at Government hospitals for this stalling of works by doctors? Is not it duty of competent authority to restore normal services at hospitals by applying Essential services maintenence act?
Yes, Exactly...Am not sure why people are surprised that the 'great' Kapil Sibal is arguing on behalf of the Mamata Government..What else you expected from him? That he'll abstain from this case, with a pinch of conscience..
Supreme court should have dismissed this bengal government long time ago. Supreme Court in the name of democracy allowing such a rowdy government event after event. I do not see any hope for Bengal government to come out of violence in near future.
It is impressive the chief justice is shown televised live in a case giving his opening statement in a very dignified and calm character the chief justice is meticulous accurate and very focused keep it up it is commendable 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮
These people want the doctors to work! If this girl wasn't a doctor or the doctors wouldn't have come on streets to protest. They wouldn't have cared. It would be like any other case where you go from place to place, court to court begging for justice against the inhumanity
if u notice something, everytime the CJ asks an important question, Kapil Sibbal says, ok, anyway then makes his point glorifying the WB govt. I hate this man!
Kapil sibbal is misleading the case to benefit Mamata's political career.
WE. KNOW WHAT. TYPE OF PERSONS HE IS . HE REGRETS HE KNOWS COMES WITHOUT GETTING INFORMATION HE FOOLING.
@@joelmoses1139 much true brother
And what ever you said is evident in the video also
Many were giving him tips of info. till then he was not saying but watching.
Cji chandrachud.....the best cji.ever
@@GloomyGlue yes doing his job both proffessionaly and personally
@@GloomyGlue yeah yeah .. his job is to protect Govt side,
How many times did he protect BJP Govt. While fighting their opponents ?
In any case which is against humanity, we will see Kapil sibal is fighting for them.
यह मानवता का सबसे बड़ा दुश्मन है।इसकी शक्ल से ही हैवानियत टपकती है
Well, he has stood up against anti Indian government so many times. This time he is representing WB. So no issues.
Cji dallal hai suo moto cognizance sirf political agenda ke liya hai desh mein kya kya ho gaya itne dino mein tab nahi socha suo moto cognizance ka, yahan par facts saaf bata rahe ki speculation chal raha cji ko khud nahi fir kab darj hui. Murder hua nahi yeh toh fir ke baad tafteesh mein chalega.yahi suo moto manipur,sebi, butch,neet ,upsc ya kisi aur mudde par nahi liya waha logo ko petition file karni pad rahi aur yaha bjp ko chamkane ke suo moto cognizance liya jaa raha jabki high court bhi jurisdiction wise capable hai cause its a constitutional court too.cji is fishing for issues to blow them out of proportion and make them as if big incompetence of police,people have been misdirected with all sorts of bogus data ,here news channels should have also be taken to task for making the mockery of investigation and victims family.cji is hell bent into declaring that there is incompetence baar baar facts se hath ke mehta idhar udar ki baat kar raha hai politics keech raha beech mein kyoki proceedings telecast ho raha hai .
They take such cases thats why they are top lawyers.
@@nupurmahato4236you mean toper interms of falling to the lowest level?
I have officially lost all respect for kapil sibbal
He was never respectable
@@barshasahu79exactly
Kapil Sibal is a Shameless Politician, Crooked Lawyer - Just Eats Money and Flesh
@@barshasahu79 Exactly..
Why? He is a good Advocate. It doesn't matter if anyone loves or hates him, he's still a good Advocate
Shameless capil sibil and Congress supporting West Bengal police and principal defending them ..... Fo they have any more responsibility in heart ?? Everything is money and politics?? Wrostu
Chup lordu
@@Andbhaktkabap1 teri bhen nii h kya ghr m
@@Andbhaktkabap1 chuslim ka baap
Another shameless replied to you....he can't even spell also
@@Andbhaktkabap1We are a civillised country dude, so you will always considered as polluted bloods. The venomic blood of the mlechaas.
Why's Kapil Sibal arguing for the culprits? This is a clear violation of law and lapses
i think its the job of a lawyer to defend..... dont blame him its his job... without defense lawyer there can be no justice
A lawyer representing his client is against the law??? Sorry which world do you live in?
@@punisherwarlord very apt words, however it's the side this lawyer argues for -even if he had always sided with the perpetrators, it's not a crime. It's only the fact that he argues for those who are against BJP. Is this a legal or a political defense?
@@geethamani9448 this guy is laughing
All for money
36 hours of duty for doctors is too much. Something must be done about it. I think its really inhuman
Yeah during my internship we used to do 36hr.. and during this 36hr we were not even able to sit sometimes, but recently increasing number of seats have made things little easier yet it's still inhuman. But somewhere during residency it gave me strength. I agree it should be changed.
36 hr has came to light that’s y you know about it but jr doctors residents work more than that sometimes 48 - 72 hrs
The unfortunate Doctor who was brutally murdered was subjected to this torture after 36 hours of duty, and then the ex Principal along with his powerful accomplices ( he is probably close to CM) were trying to pass on as suicide and mentioned the Doctor's name multiple times. The CM then tried to perception wise blamed the opposition for vandalism when even a child knows that culprits tried to erase any proof of murder. All goons then under pressure subsequently imprisoned are from the ruling party. Does this not prove the direct involvement of the most powerful people in West Bengal?
It’s not only inhumane but it also decreases the cognitive ability to take decision when your brain is tired……these people are crazy and have zero sensibilities……
Kapil Sibal shame of you.
KAPIL SIBBAL TRUE RAVAN
Are you stupid? He is a lawyer representing his client. Learn about law.
No he is true RAM
irony is he is the chief of Indian bar council
why is Kapil highjacking the court proceedure. only he must speK kya? Ridiculous!
Ravan is better than sibbal, ravan never raped and protected rapists, but sibbal .......... crossed limits
Mr Sibal please dont lie there is a limit
uski beti nhi thi n
Will people teach him a lesson soon....just wait and
not only India but entire World is watching ...let us prove that we are civilised and law-abiding nation and justice will be done at any cost 🙏🙏🙏
Why Kapil is playing like nothing is happened 😕 😐 😒 really shameful. Nation is united but these advocates were here to defend
The lawyer defending WB Gov...is very dangerous for mankind and India💔 the way he is totally denying the victim's parents statement 💔I am in shock how he is raising his voice against the truth and the bench.
coz its his job... u can abuse him as much u can... but fact is if he does not defend the accused in the court there can not be justice
@@punisherwarlord because it's his job he will sell his soul. pathetic
Just like AAP, Mamta and TMC is using lots of tax payers hard earned money in top lawyers to defend and escape from their negligence and corruption 🎉
Kolkata police reputation has gone down the drain. It will take them decades of exemplary work before they are recognised as a good police force.
What drain? Even drains are cleaner than kolkata police and Tmc govt
They are disgusting
they don't care about reputation .......these bastards only are after money
Cji dallal hai suo moto cognizance sirf political agenda ke liya hai desh mein kya kya ho gaya itne dino mein tab nahi socha suo moto cognizance ka, yahan par facts saaf bata rahe ki speculation chal raha cji ko khud nahi fir kab darj hui. Murder hua nahi yeh toh fir ke baad tafteesh mein chalega.yahi suo moto manipur,sebi, butch,neet ,upsc ya kisi aur mudde par nahi liya waha logo ko petition file karni pad rahi aur yaha bjp ko chamkane ke suo moto cognizance liya jaa raha jabki high court bhi jurisdiction wise capable hai cause its a constitutional court too.cji is fishing for issues to blow them out of proportion and make them as if big incompetence of police,people have been misdirected with all sorts of bogus data ,here news channels should have also be taken to task for making the mockery of investigation and victims family.cji is hell bent into declaring that there is incompetence baar baar facts se hath ke mehta idhar udar ki baat kar raha hai politics keech raha beech mein kyoki proceedings telecast ho raha hai .
They have always been like this since the British times. It’s KP that used to catch and jail freedom fighters. They only know 💰and threats
Shame shame! There are women lawyers backing sibal who is representing wb govt. They seem so eager ! Shame on them. Tomorrow who will represent these women lawyers if they land in the same situation ??!!
They love money
Oh not Kapil Sibal, because he will be defending the accused for sure.
MR SIBAL HAVE NO SHAME HE IS LYING
That old guy is such an idiot and menace
People of India has only one hope from our Hon’ble CJI Sir
Please save our Girls 🙏🙏🙏
Why does these senior lawyers interrupt when someone is speaking. Why don't they have basic courtesy to listen before speaking
Chamcha giri,,,quid pro quo ?
Why the learned bench is allowing chamchas to interfere
and Cham has wants to be “, lime light “”
Even the courts have become like parliament sessions
Kapil Sibal defending WB govt is shocking
WB -WARNER BROS😅😅😅
Hahaha😂, we knew it already, now its victim vs Bengal govt and administration, and we know who support who.
Not shocking at all, they are allies. TMC is a part of the India alliance.
Mamta Banerjee must be using lots of tax payers money to fund her legal cases with top lawyers 🎉
Why only safety in hospital....we need to look into safety accross India what about cab, auto, travel during night, bus, gim, school, college, hostel, PG, training centre... girls need safety in all this places too.
Because hospital is where doctors are dealing with people in very sensitive moments of people's life. Only with a strong law can you expect some level of safety in such highly sensitive situations. What aboutism doesn't help solve things probably one thing at a time or one place at a time will help
But why no arrests is being done to sandip gosh n the police comm. For not following the SOP.
Already high court of West Bengal has declared him as powerful man
Exactly When would CBI done investigating ? What is taking Soo time ??😢
Bandits entered on someone's invitation!
Who are they if you know you should disclose before Court.
@@pinakimukherjee3142tmc goons
@@pinakimukherjee3142Everyone residing in WB knows who are those people. ‘Right to Violence and Vandalism’ is a fundamental right of ruling party workers in WB. Be it CPIM, TMC or if in case any other party wins in future, this right will be exercised by them also. After all it’s a Fundamental Right of the Ruling party in WB !!
Yourlordship its not just DOCTORS BUT NURSES AS WELL AS ALL THE HEALTH CARE PROVIDER SAFETY ISSUE
Its not just healcare, its every woman and girl in this country
@@lazyguy4825. exactly...👍👍
Nikal lordu
Women specifically……caution against colleagues as well
Sibbal is equally criminal
Mr sible should be disbarred !! He interrupts too...
Why does this fellow Sibal keep interrupting? Don’t understand why CJI allows him to do that.
Being an advocate I really ashamed of Mr. Sibbal. They way he is denying and the actual facts is really disheartening.. the poor soul may rest in peace.
The defence lawyer Sibal is arguing for his commercial benefit angle and non as a humanitarian. But unfortunately the government appointed AG or SG gets only salary and transportation, naturally not aggressive.
5:32 What’s a “unnatural Death” registration?
Was the Principal not sure looking at the dead doctor that it was a “Homicide? 5:32
Why did the Principal tried to downplay ??
He is the key culprit here. Definite cover up.
Principal being shielded by authorities (police & govt).
Dalal Sibbal once again at it, protecting his masters.
Shame less Dalal and part of the party
Why is the CJI not focusing on the responsibility and accountability of the state in protecting the evidence, that can't be done BY THE DECEASED
They just try to change the direction of the case. They already removed all vital evidence. Now only date after date only for hearing
No justice.
@@brown-girl19 "no justice" ,wtf did u see in this 20 min vid the judiciary doing?
@@ra-wj1wl did it take up the issue of the role of the state in protecting the evidence? Wtf did you find in this two hundred minutes of judicial farting
@@ra-wj1wl the evidence already tempered. They try to change the direction of the case. Now only they give date and date only for hearing.
Sibal defends mamta govt
Kapil is soo inhuman.
Wt if it was his daughter or grand daughter
He doesn't have daughters. He has two sons. He will never understand
Kapil Sibal I lost your respect on you this is a man who mislead the case instead of supporting the victim very bad hope justice must be prevail for the victims
First sibal should be sent behind bars
Kapil Sibal should be banned from advocate's society
I don't know why this lawyer Kapil Sibal keeps interfering when CJI is speaking. No decorum at all.
Order arrest of cm and police for negligence
Kapil Sibbal is kind of a person who is almost everytime standing in the court against the interest of this nation and the citizens.😡
Principal was trying to hush up the matter. So is the advocate defending their case.
That lady who is speaking should be ashamed of herself
Kapil Sibal ask your mother, wife and daughters to think of work in the same hospital
CJI Asking the right questions
Where is the humanity , one girl murdered but here everyone pretending like its normal and kapil sibbal shame on you why you trying to save culprits if this incidents happens with your daughter then what should be you do ?
A perverted SC postpones CBI report for 2 days. It however does NOT order WB Govt to provide security to striking docs till such time they call strike off. So clearly SC trying to give clean chit to WB Govt. Docs pls don't call strike off. We the People are with you on your fight against WB Govt in fight for Justice.
No power in hands of CJI...
These much harsh facts of heinous crime. And no power to arrest a notorious principal, erring police heads or college authorities...
Where does the hell of fear any of these have even aftr this dirty act.... Only the parents lost a daughter. Do these people, the lawyers, police or any have any loss.....
Why are lawyers interrupting judges speech.
No manners 😅😅😅
That lawyer must have FIR FILED against him. 😅😅😅
Mamata is a great states woman , she transformed Republic of Bharat into a banana republic of Bokoharam. We are unarmed and helpless But why Center has become a witness only. Can Modiji answer that as well .
Kapil shibal fighting for justice is like asking mercy from azmal kasab
Judges take summer and winter vacations, but due to deficient doctor patient ratio doctor's dont have vacations , but junior doctors have to work 36 hours many days with no toilet facilities or restroom for proper rest inbetween patients, they sleep in patients bed . This state for doctors or police is shameful in this country.
May God save the innocent citizens of West Bengal.
Mr Sibal, stop interrupting and show respect. Let CJI finish speaking.
Why didn't anyone register the FIR as soon as they found the body. So if they say the first was filed at 11 in the night it means 12 hrs after the body was discovered. Why didn't the principal or anyone file an fir right away after the discovery of the body, or calling the police to the campus. Does it mean the autopsy was conducted without an fir.
SIBAL. IS TALKING BIG WE KNOW HIS BACKGROUND HE IS SORRY. IN EVERYTHING WE KNOW HE WILL PROTECT MAMATA HE SAYS HE HAS VIDEOS HE AGREES TO THIS OR THAT.
How come this lawyer is saying it's an individual act after the autopsy reports? And my goodness he has women in his team.
This Kapil Sibbal advocate has daughter? If he paid highly money for the case If his daughter treated the same way wheather he will defend the culprit??? Indians Demand for Justice
Is Kapil Sibbal representing the Bangal government?
If so,.....pls don't
A dalal will do what the dalal always does.
Lol it's not a question.. he is.
@@zainabsaleha829 nasli begairat hai ye. Isme kya shocking hai.
@Ind_u. That's what....I am shocked.
Couldn't believe it 🙄
Money and Sibbal are synonymous. A brute.
When the CJI was speaking, why did the lawyer keep on interrupting him and parroting CJI’s words? Why can’t the lawyer allow the CJI to speak fully?
By this henious act, ms. Mamata benarji has lost faith what government of India would do.
SC is right in setting up a National Task Force.Doctors Community needs to be protected and they shld be given proper basic facilities at the Workplace..
CJI knows what's up
Why only doctors...all women in the hospital including women patients, besides nurses and other para medics.
Sir,36 and 48 hrs of duty.has it any reasoning and no lace for taking a little rest even.what are these young doctors supposed to be? Human beings or Robots?
Waste fellows does not know what time it was happend 😢
I wish the court finds out the exact facts not the fabricated story and regarding the photographs taken must be considered as another issue.I think if the photograps were not taken it would not have reached to the rest of the public which would have made the protest weak.This principal and the government would have got a lot more chances to fabricate the story.
Kapil sibal is actually defending to lose.. Don't worry.. Its a rule..someone has to defend the accused
It looks like diversion tactics are used here. As a common human being, I'm worried whether the culprits will be punished. But why is there so much importance given to sibil? I believe CJ will give justice.
Kapil sibal lost consciousness god will punish him
I truly had a lot of respect for this man. Lost all for a hypocrites he seems to be defending.
Sad to see how strongly is this man defending culprits.
Be honest humans
Weak court judgements,make strong politicians.
Kapil Sibal acquired land in Delhi worth crores by paying just 1 lakh rupees?
Kapil Sibal doesn’t have shame in representing WB government.
Appeal all medical fraternity to stop giving any support to Kapil Sibbal….let him feel the pain
Absolutely right
CJI has caught on the vein of the subject. Very pertinent issues raised by him...should be answered. Official operations like reg of comp, FIR, PM etc done hours after the incident. That too in a hospital.
The state government is run by the most unethical people !😢
Cji please Create a bench to have a thorough investigation the which Political party indulge in this henious crime in a holistic approach and Judgement on systems failure.
Should also see if there is conspiracy to tople the government. Politicians taking milage should also be monitored.sack the principal from, the truth will come out.
Hospital was politically directed to be invaded . Can we call spade a spade
Confused, information being shared and spoken about.
Why the advocates interfere while CJ is speaking?
Sibbal is behaving as nothing happened in kolkata, it's all as if we are dreaming on daylight
Greatful to Lordship.
My daughter completed her MBBS in Government Hospital.
No Proper Duty Room in Government Hospital.
She has slept in chairs during her night shifts.
She has slept on empty patient beds.
She has slept on benches without blanket.😢
Last year a house surgeon was brutally killed by a prisoner while she was treating him, after that incident kerala government has ordered atleast one day a week off for house surgeons and resident doctors, let us start from there.. bring a change to these inhumane atrocities.
Dr. Vandana will be in our minds forever, RIP beautiful soul.
Kapil Sibal is a serial liar. He says we (the government, police & hospital administration) never circulated the picture or revealed the name. The truth is that the Commissioner of Kolkata Police himself took the name of the victim several times. When CJI said no FIR was filed or was filed late Sibal again says that's again not true. Another lie. The FIR was filed at 11.45 pm 3 hours after the cremation. It's a joke. And this shameless person tries to pass the buck to the parents.
The greatness of justice is being proved Mylord, and we people still believe in judicial system because of such great judges only. Thank you .
There’s only questioning/questions NO action- if India fails this girl more girls will face the same fate . I am sitting in USA but this Makes me SICK
I am full of high regards to our honorable CJI so highly intelligent with such high position but so humble down to earth n the manner he conducts SC case discussion n judgement is amazing
Their is no difference between courts and police
Thank-you very much HW NEWS ENGLISH for this news...
Power should not be unleashed on peaceful protestors. But, should peaceful common people suffer and die wuthout medical treatment at Government hospitals for this stalling of works by doctors? Is not it duty of competent authority to restore normal services at hospitals by applying Essential services maintenence act?
Unti there are lawers like sibbel , there will be henious crimes
Feeling for those fools... Who were thought... SIBAL was dignified person. 😅
Yes, Exactly...Am not sure why people are surprised that the 'great' Kapil Sibal is arguing on behalf of the Mamata Government..What else you expected from him? That he'll abstain from this case, with a pinch of conscience..
@@arunb8841 All are fkn morons, bhai 🙄
Politics suck judiciary suxks laws and the law makers all are sucks, that's why we are facing this.
Kabul sibiil intervening while the honourable judge is speaking..
Sending notices to those who raised voices
I didn't understand why MR. Sibal is defanding he lost all my respect.
Supreme court should have dismissed this bengal government long time ago. Supreme Court in the name of democracy allowing such a rowdy government event after event. I do not see any hope for Bengal government to come out of violence in near future.
It is impressive the chief justice is shown televised live in a case giving his opening statement in a very dignified and calm character the chief justice is meticulous accurate and very focused keep it up it is commendable 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮
These people want the doctors to work!
If this girl wasn't a doctor or the doctors wouldn't have come on streets to protest. They wouldn't have cared. It would be like any other case where you go from place to place, court to court begging for justice against the inhumanity
if u notice something,
everytime the CJ asks an important question, Kapil Sibbal says, ok, anyway then makes his point glorifying the WB govt.
I hate this man!
some one tell Mr Sibal NOT TO MISLEAD THE HONORABLE COURT.
there is GROSS PROCEDURAL MISHANDLING MISMANAGEMENT by the college administration.
Sibal is 🐷
Chief justice bench is the only ray of hope.