Why Pep Will Never Manage Spain's National Team
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- Manchester City Manager and ex FC Barcelona player Pep Guardiola is one of the most respected footballing minds in the world.
Would he be the perfect fit for the Spanish National team in the future?
The proud Catalan is a staunch advocate for Catalonia's independence. Something that doesn't sit right with the Spanish Government.
With Spain's National Team on the rise and Pep reaching the end of his time at Manchester City. Is it even possible for the two to work together?
In this video we'll take a look back at Catalonia, FC Barcelona, and Spain's history and find out why it is improbable Pep Guardiola would ever consider coaching the Spanish National Team when there are other options to choose from.
This video covers the following topics: Catalonia history, Spain History, Premier League, Premier League Managers, Premier League News, Premier League Manager Transfers, Spanish History, Spanish Football History, Pep Guardiola Football Manager, Mikel Arteta Football Manager, Isabella the Catholic, Lionel Messi, Xavi, Iniesta, the Spanish National Team, The future of the Spanish National Team, Pep Guardiola's future as a football manager, Manchester City's manager and Johan Cuyff.
You failed to mention how most people in Cataluña don't want independence and feel Spanish. Only a small minority want separatism. Greetings from Tarragona SPAIN 🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦
no
@@pompeurare you from catalonia ? if not then your comment doesn't matter
All these independence talks are bullshit
you can barely survive in the modern time economy without proper governing body and association
You are probably right.
Well, that's directly a lie. The pro-independence sentiment in Catalonia is much more than a 'minority'. If you live in Catalonia, you know this perfectly well.
According to the Centre d’Estudis d’Opinió (CEO), in 2024, 42% of the population supported independence. In 2017, with the 'referendum', it reached 49%. To keep Catalonia as a "autonomous community", it's still the winning position. But to say that 40% of Catalonians opinions is a 'minority' is savage.
For a very personal reasons, the only country he wishes to manage is the Netherlands. Sadly the Dutch FA will never look outside their countries post the seventies.
why would he want the Netherlands
@@AlphaDaxter1 Because Pep's entire coaching philosophy/tactics was developed from Johan Cruyff's football philosophy/tactics. Pep's so-called Tiki-Taka is an evolution of Cruyff's Total Football where players are capable of playing multiple positions and having versatility in term of skills. Cruyff pioneered passing/possession based tactics as a manager upon retirement/becoming a manager.
Pep played under Cruyff at FC Barcelona and it was Cruyff who encouraged Pep to become a coach after retirement as a player. Pep's been on record saying that everything he does (as a manager) is merely/building upon the foundation that Cruyff built.
@@AlphaDaxter1 Cause he's Cruyff's heir when it comes to football tactics/philosophy.
Duh.
he owes Cruyff a lot
Funny story when Cruijff was overwhelmed by tactical questions from La Masia kid name Guardiola who he just brought in to the first team, he grabbed Koeman and told him, "From now on the kid live with you."
There was also "A Crijff's Gang" in Barcelona, with Laporta, Txiki Begiristain, Guardiola, and many. They all moved out to Man City when Guardiola hired by the English club and when the opposing faction (Rossel/Bartomeu) won the elections.
Picasso is from Málaga, my man. And Iniesta is from Albacete. None of them is Catalan.
These people's careers were born out of Catalonia. Messi is Argentinian.
@@SAMUTHESAMBABALLnot anymore than these people’s careers were born out of Spain because Catalonia is part of Spain. There are many regions in Spain with their own identity.
@@SAMUTHESAMBABALLMessi & Iniesta arrived to FCB when they were 12 years old… Picasso left Andalucía when he was 8 years old and moved to Galicia. When he was 12 years old he arrived to Barcelona where he lived until he was 22 ….it’s risky to say that they started their career out of Catalonia…
Messi & Iniesta arrived to FCB when they were 12 years old… it's risky to say that they started their career out of Catalonia…Picasso is Andalusian, at the age of nine he went to Galicia and at the age of 12 he arrived in Barcelona where he lived until he was 22 when he left for Paris... it is foolish not to recognize the Catalan influence in all of their careers
@@Mon-w8vNacieron en España y se trasladaron a Cataluña.
Messi no se considera ni catalán ni español. El es Argentino.
Otra cosa es que ame a Cataluña, España.
I honestly don't know where this idea that Catalunya is distinctly different from the other Spanish regions as an actual important fact comes from. I mean, sure they are different from the rest but, so is Galicia, so is the Basque Country, so is Andalucia, so is Castilla, so is Madrid, so is La Mancha. All of this big regions (and many smaller ones) are distinctly different from the rest and many also have their own languages. Being different is of no consequence in Spain, because everyone else is as well.
The fact that you agree does not mean the other spaniards agree
@@unanec ????? It wasn't an opinion, I just stated facts.
catalunya has been a concept for at least 900 years more than you so i don't think you would understand all of the reasons why catalunya is distinctly different from spain either
@@adrianbv1993 language makes the difference. Many Vascos want independence too.
@@rmv9194 Galicians also have their own language. And there are another couple minor languages in Spain too (Asturias and Vall d'Aran inside Catalonia). Having a regional language is not something special in Spain.
Using a painting of a scene literally refered as: "Los fusilamientos de los patriotas madrileños" by Goya. Which has nothing to do with Catalonia, their nationalist movement and is a symbol of Spanish, common folk resistance against the Napoleonic Imperialism. Struggle which united the hispanic world as a whole, including across the Atlantic is to say the least, missleading.
Nice catch! I don't know much about art. Thanks for watching
The Black leyend
Guardiola will never manage the Spanish team, 'cause he will never be offered that position by the federation
And if he were, he would never ACCEPT.
And even if it were offered , Pep would not accept it. Not even consider it , not after 1-O 2017 anyway
@@Xoman08
He seems to like the money. Hence the fact that he manages a club that is sponsored by a country that has a criminal record with human rights violations. The fraud says nothing about that.
The truth is heard by the masses sooner or later. Pure hypocrisy. The reason why most don't respect or give two gks about Catalan independence.
Pep wants to coach Spain, but he probably knows that the RFEF (Spanish FA) won't call him. And many things have to change on the RFEF to allow someone like Guardiola to coach Spain. But I also believe he is ready to coach an NT after coaching clubs for a while.
he said he’d love to coach england
That is bullshit, Pep doesn' t want to manage the Spain team ... In Bernabeu Pep has been shown pure hatred by Madrid supporters for being outspoken Catalan and pro/independence.
No chance in heaven or earth for Guardiola to be offered the Spanish team and not change for Guardiola to accept it.
@@Xoman08
Bullshit. Money talks. Hope the RFEF don't ever consider him. Would love to see how good he is managing a club without unlimited corrupt funds .
Funny how he says nothing about being employed by what is possibly the most corrupt football club on the planet. Says nothing about the tremendous human rights violations commited by the country that sponsors city. Talk about being a whore.
Little wonder most people don't respect such hypocrites.
@@Xoman08 We don't want him. It's too good a job for him.
if pep manages spain, the intl football will be boring bcs of domination
2:18 Messi is Argentinian, Picasso from Málaga, Iniesta from Albacete and Salvador Dali not only was a Spanish centric person but also fascist pro Franco.
What Is fascism?
He didn’t say they were from the Catalonian region. He says they were “propelled onto the world stage by Catalonia”
He did not say they were catalan, paranoid spaniard
pep is Catalan bleed Barca.
if you were Pep, you were blamed by Barcelona fans for just losing a few games, but overall your team performed so well.
Why the hell should you coach Spain?! since the fans are the same people!
Pep was never blamed for losing games, he was acclaimed to stay in Barcelona and left as a hero
The fight between independentist and the Spanish loving permeates into the Barcelona club polítics. The Cruyffists vs Nuñistas. Nuñistas did everything to make Pep's work as hard as possible, that's why he left. Fans know they left go the Best manager they ever had.
“Most people in this region wouldn’t call themselves Spanish at all”… really??? Not such a well informed video after all…
Well, better informed than what you are.
@@perrymanso6841 If believing it makes you happy, be my guest man
@@mmplayer8 It's not believing, it's knowing my homeland, therefore, knowing about the topic.
@@perrymanso6841 that’s my homeland as well… but as I said, if believing that makes you happier… congrats!
@@mmplayer8 if you think like that, then you're probably a Castilian living in Catalonia, NOT a Catalan.
All this history didn't stop another Catalonian coaching legend from coaching Spain (Luis Enrique) so I don't know why pep will be so different.
The hell, Luis Enrique is from Asturias and his football career was molded in Mareo (Sporting de Gijón academy), back in the day one of the most modern in the world.
@@08Rolling man for a decade I believed he was home grown Catalonia talent but seems that you're right, can't even remember where I picked that from honestly.
@@fletcherchristian6411 I've been following Luis closely ever since he joined psg I'll say he's been the best psg coach in the modern area (did as well as touchle even though he had a way worse squad.) so I would say he's pretty smart as a coach. Fascinating that he played for both RMA and FCB but judging by his goal celebration against the former in the 90s he definitely loved the latter more. I guess he was really just a Spanish guy caught up in the whole Madrid vs Catalonia thing. Though he DID start his managerial career with barca B so that's probably where my misconception about him being a full on Catalonian started.
@@robthewells7182 He was not "just a Spanish guy caught up". LE as same as Cruyff, really loves and respects us Catalans. His wife is in fact Catalan. His kind words towards Catalan people have cost him some hate from Spaniards.
@@perrymanso6841that's such a shameless lie lmao, he has never been hated for that
Your talking rubbish.
Brilliant video. Learned a lot here.
Awesome! Thanks for watching
Wait for Gavi to marry their princess,
He will give independence to Catalans
Hope you mentioned the fact that Madrid fought Francos fascists for more than 3 years. Catalonias resistance didnt even last 3 months
What Is your point?
@@rmv9194
Catalans are great at telling people that Madrid was fascist, while they were virtually the only city that was anti fascist.
@@martymiguel4496 Just because they resisted for more time doesn't mean it was the only antifascist part. Madrid is the biggest city in Spain, so you will have more population which harder to control.
@@rmv9194
Back then. Barcelona was bigger
My wife is Catalan and fully Spanish.
Catalans not happy tjat Madrid is the powerhouse of Spain. Like Paris for France and London for England.
Somebody has to be yop dog.
Others play second fiddle
Amazing video, fantastic pronunciation too, never realized you were Dutch until you mentioned Johan's name. Subscribed for more!
Wow thanks for subscribing. I'm surprised you picked that up!
Picasso is from Andalusia my friend!
You fumbled this one. You can't have an outspoken traitor lead your national team. By the way, you omitted and gave the impression that the Catalans never had a choice.
This is a terrible video because when General Franco died, then the provinces now known autonomous regions created the Spanish Constitution in 1978. The Constitution states that for an independence movement to be legal, all Spanish citizens would have to vote for a desolation of the union, not just Catalans. The referendum was illegal, and the reason why politicians went to prison and some are still hiding from justice for attempting a Coup D'Etats.
Again, did Catalans have a chance to vote for their autonomy? They did!!! It was Pep's parents who said no. It was the grandparents of the college students waving the independence flags who said no.
Again, only talking about Franco and Johan is at best short-sighted and at worst propagandist. Pep has spit in the eyes of Spaniards who supported him on the national team. He has rejected a union that brought prosperity to the region. Your next video should be about the investment that all of Spain gave Catalonia for the Barcelona Olympics of 1992. There is justified bitterness towards people like Pep and Gerald Piques.
Be careful giving people history lessons. You made interesting points until your last sentence…
Do latin American have a right to be justifiably bitter?
You mention choice:
What about the conquistadors? Did they have a choice to not annihilate a race of people? Perhaps the writer of this video should do his next video on how the Spanish destroyed and created genocide for millions of people.
Just as you state Catalans had a choice, you also have a choice not to be bitter. There is no such thing as justified bitterness. It is the sign of someone who is not mature enough to understand the workings of his/her own mind. Unclench the hatred that you imprisoned yourself and let it go. Why carry on the bitterness of previous generations. You do have a choice!
BTW - I’m half Spanish and Peruvian but living in catalunya but raised in Australia.
@@edniembro1309 Latin Americans are Masters of self-pity and self-righteousness.
@edniembro1309 I stand by what I wrote. You didn't offer anything that was compelling. Pep deserves the hate. I gave the real factual reasons behind the hate, and you stick up for someone like him. A person who benefited financially from the national team to then talk shit about the country that put money in his pocket. The thesis of the video is about a very rich man being ineligible for a job. So, it shouldn't be anything too high on the priority list.
@@shonehi546tim9 Can you go into more detail about why Pep is a traitor who "spit in the eyes of Spaniards". Did he levy for Catalan Independence? What did he do that contradicted his grandparents who voted against Independence? I'm out of the loop on what voting choices he made, let me know.
@@edniembro1309
So do you feel like an invader? You do know that Aboriginals are the rightful owners of Australia . So you obviously migrated into a country that is immorally controlled by British invaders.
Are you sure you know your history?
Have always been curious that Latin America is full of indigenous DNA.
Whenever I visit countries colononised by the British, spotting original locals is virtually impossible. Have the invaders virtually exterminated them. Since you mentioned genocide.
Latin America had a great economy up until the last 70-80 years. Things change.
I also live in Australia and can tell you this country is going to shit creek. The young generation can't even dream of renting a house let alone buy one. More homeless people per capita than the USA.
Yet I wouldn't blame the British colonizers. The country has been independent for a long time and is being economically ruined by the current local Australians.
If Latin America is basically third world. That's down to the locals. Nothing to do with the Spanish
Y Dali, Miro, Gaudí.... nunca tuvieron conflicto con España, ni con Franco .
La aristocracia catalana vive en Madrid, la Bueguesia catalana colaboraba con la dictadura de Franco. La Banca catalana están sus centrales fuera de Cataluña.
Mas de la mitad de la poblacion de Cataluña no quiere la independencia de España. Etc.etc.😊
Enclaves!?...Autonomous communities.
Never will manage Spain 😂, yet he represented Spain National team as a player for years.
And even captained it
OFC, since Spanish regulations can cancel your player license if you REFUSE to play for Spanish national team. You could explain it all, but as a dirty Spaniard you have to lie out of your ass...
Spain behaved somewhat properly vs Catalonia since 1982 (when the law forbidding Catalans names was actually withdrawn) until 2006 when the then ruling party PP took the Catalan autonomy statute to the Constitutional Tribunal. The ruling in 2010 sparked the following independence bid culminating in the 1-O 2017 unilateral referendum.
When Guardiola played for Spain, relations between Spain and Catalonia were "cordial" , but that all changed after 2010.
Because players are FORCED to play in Spain, they can lose their license if don't. Casually this comment has been erased, some bastard may not be interested in the true showing up...
@@perrymanso6841 what a bunch of irresponsible lies. Oleguer, defender from Barcelona refused to go with Spain National team for his independence ideas, upon being called, and nothing happened to him.
Traitors Or Rebels, depends on the perspective
Historically speaking, the Castilians have been the traitors. No one of the different Realms/Crowns would have united if they knew what Castile truly wanted through treason.
Never knew this,great vid
There is no dilemma or anything. We all know he's Pro Catalan independence. And we all know how the Castillian Spanish treated Pique.
Pep has always known managing Spain was impossible for him, so that's why he has never sought it.
Pep Guardiola is NOT Spanish but Catalan. The Spanish authorities would never aknowledge Pep 's success and even if they did, Pep would not accept any accolade from the Spanish monarchy.
So he is officially Catalan not Spanish?
So he obviously has a Catalan passport?
And Catalans dont pay their taxes to the Spanish state?
Don't get me wrong. I wish Catalonia was not part of Spain. Can't stand the bullshit I hear concerning politics in which I couldn't give a rats arse every time I visit my wives home town of Barcelona. Having said that there are many pro Spanish Catalans. Virtually all of my wives family that are virtually Catalan from generations.
I understand you too would love an independent state for Catalonia.
But the fact remains that it's not.
So don't lie about people not being Spanish but Catalans when you well know that they have a Spanish passport and ID card.
Does Guardiola have a Catalonia passport?
@@liul None of us, catalans, have a catalan passport because we are an occupied country by Spain/Castille. We tried an unilateral referendum and Spain sent 10 thousand paramilitary police to beat up peaceful voters.
#SpainIsAFascistState And in the European Union there are catalan political exiles free in Europe but they will be detained if they entered their homeland.
It's because he's Catalan, not Castellano
Still spanish
@@JOKERATM I never said he wasn't
@@JOKERATM No we don't.
@@perrymanso6841 si ho som
@@JOKERATM NO. You're a Castilian settler living in Catalonia, not a Catalan.
insightful video
Amazing video
Pep Guardiola es una gran persona, pero....esta infectado del catalanismo independentista. Nadie es perfecto.😂😊
Si fuera una gran persona haria Una critica contra Los abusos de derechos humanos cometidos por el Pais dueño del club qué maneja en Inglaterra.
Es UN autentico hipocrita y fraude.
Cero respeto
Doesn't have a transfer market or the greatest crop of young players coming out of La Masia so will have to work with what he's got
As a player Pep was among the best of his generation, but to see him in the political terrain is a complete different matter. One can be tolerant or shows solidarity with the feeling of being anti or not-Spanish, but then follow that up with an embrace with the Arab oil machine is a bit of a stretch. Politics and sport should be not mixed.
Lofl. Pep was a bang average player
@@martymiguel4496 Pep was the regista of that Barca team. Yes, the one with Romario, Laudrup, and Stoichkov. And he was damn good at doing his job. Just like Redondo was
The problem isn't Spain, the problem is Castille/Madrid
You got it right: he won't and for the reasons mentioned in the video.
We don’t give a shit about him either.!!!!
Guardiola no se siente español, no puede ser seleccionador.
Y DelaFuente es mejor.
Easy. He is not spanish. He is Catalan
I still don't get it why do they want to have their own country apart from Spain?
Starting all over again?
Because some people are idiots. Most people in Cataluña don't want that and are normal spanish
there's historical reasons but the main point is culture, language and managing our own resources
@@pompeur How would look a catalonian football selection??
@@pompeur Your "own resources" are the resources of Spain. The culture is as unique as others from other parts of Spain. The language is just a dialect of Spanish that the authoritarian regional authorities are trying to inject into the kids' brains in schools by amongst other things prohibiting teaching the Spanish language, which is the official language of Spain and one of the two official languages in Catalonia, together with the Catalan. Así que, deja de contar mentiras en comentarios que te va a crecer la nariz. Hala, a seguir sonando.
Its really started around 1992 olympics, and jordi Pujol massive corruption. Independence wasnt really the agenda, but when they saw the dangers they started that path, allecturing in schools to youngsters and hoping with independence, law and justice wouldnt get them. Now we have Pugdemont in Belgium cowardly fleeying from justice for years and many youngsters brainwashed for their corruption for an imaginary country that will never happen.
Very goood analysis!
Thanks for watching!
Free Catalunya
From separatists
@@JOKERATM From Castilian invaders.
But the majority want to be part of Spain. Are you another one that doesn't give a shit about the majorities wishes?
Is it all about getting your way?
Sounds a little bit fascist.
@@martymiguel4496 The majority OF CATALANS want independence. FASCIST is people from other lands forcing others to do what they want, THAT's fascist.
@@perrymanso6841
No they don't. They lost on the last referendum. Why do you lie.
Who's fascist?
FC Barca maybe
I feel like people don’t understand or realize why even in Barcelona’s bad seasons, Barcelona still always have some of the most attendees at their stadium.
They don’t fill the stadium up to the maximum, but on average they have like 80,000 fans.
Barcelona being a representative for their culture is the reason. Even if Barcelona lose 8-2, or real Madrid seem like they are gonna dominate for the foreseeable future, they will still have a strong fanbase.
If pep would manage Spain you got to understand he's got a lot of talents to use Rodri, Pedri, Gavi, Fermin lopez ect. Pep wants Spanish players who fit that Barcelona mold and tiki taka playstyle which he plays which is basically all of the Spanish players who play in Spain. With Spain current coach it's about getting balls in the box for morata and the attackers like olmo, yamal ect. Tiki taka is still used by the current Spain team just not as much.
Not like Arteta isn't a typical Basque name and Basque separatism (ETA) wasn't historically much fiercer than the Catalonian one.....
Guardiola pro-Independentist stance is well known and ultimately his own personal decision.
Pep rejected them,
And they would make excuses that they never offered him the job
Manipulative and twisting facts. Making a really complex issue, a bad tale of David vs Goliath
By the same method, everyone born in Northern Ireland is Irish, those born in Scotland are Scottish, and none of them are from Great Britain
These Spanish folk got a lot going for them. Thanks for the documentary. 👍
1:49 most people in this region just voted for Spanish parties in the last elections... Most cities like Barcelona never voted for independtist parties
You just made a 11 minute video full of misinformation? 😂
I believe that Pepe Guardiola is not suitable for training the Spanish national team, neither Spain nor any other, Pepe has a methodology and it is not useful for him to have a group 20 days a year to work at his pleasure.
the real key for england is carlo ancelotti.
Also would be so much fun to see how Catalonia has its own league and played for years against Girona and other villages and never El Clásico. Also never getting enough points to qualify for Champions league.
Wouldn’t that be fun?
They would join Ligue 1. Barcelona could probably join the Premier League
No idea what you are talking about, inaccurate and misleading, most Catalans like myself consider ourselves Spanish.
Siempre eres bienvenido a venir y dirigir a la selección nacional de los Países Bajos
ArtetA isn't special in the slightest
Such a great video. I’m a Barcelona hater but this boosted a little respect from me.
Why the hate???
❤❤Now I understand better about Spain and Pep.❤❤
I am surprised by Arteta getting an award considering he tried to qualify for england when he could not get a game for spain