I lost my mother and got to see Mike with Neal Morse front row and I remember being so down and Mike looked at me and gave me a smile and wave I had so many emotions that night. Thank you Mike for being an inspiration to me. Been listening to dream theater since I was 5 years old!!! I'm 29 now lol. My first album I ever heard in my life was scenes from a memory.
Very heartbreaking to see Mike in that state, but he soldiered through like the pro he is. JP is like a brother to him, and so nice to see him up their comforting Mike. Rest In Peace, Samantha
I honestly admire Mike as person even more after this heartbreaking performance. To find strength to power through the whole concert moments after receiving the news about his sister passing. If i was at his place, i would have canceled the show just to be with my family (i believe mike's wife and kids are traveling with him in this european tour). But he needed to play this concert. To help to ease his pain and deal with his mourn. Mad respects to Mike. Love you man, and RIP Samantha. She is finnaly free. May her soul rest in peace.
it takes a lot to make a grown man cry. but this... this is just pure. the friendship, the relationship between these guys... RIP Samantha. stay strong MP.
Never thought I would see a crying drum cam. Huge respect for Portnoy to muster the strength to finish this show. His efforts helped these people see a show they will never forget. I hope he gets time to mourn with his family.
Man, I'm watching this after my older brother passing last night, fucking hits home so hard, you can see the pain on Mike's face, nice to see Petrucci going out of his way to be with him, life is definitely too short, My brother played guitar which got me into playing guitar which probably led me to discovering DT. Strange how life works sometimes... R.I.P to Samantha and my brother Valentin Carlos. You will be sorely missed.
Life on the road has its own difficult details. In 2005, I went to their show in São Paulo, Brazil. They divided the show into two parts, and in the second part, they would play Metropolis pt. 2 in its entirety. During the break, they told Labrie that his father had passed away, and he did the show in the most professional way possible. I only found out about this event months later in an interview.
Losing family is something that is very painful. Especially if you lose your brother or sister who accompanied you to play together from childhood until you were old. Rip 🥀
Why am I crying 😢 rip SP 🙏🥁 you had the best seat to capture this beautiful and heartbreaking moment I hope there's no 3rd sad concert footage the 2nd being the 2 songs Chestert Bennington sings at the barrier with the front row at the Birmingham uk show 2 weeks before he ....
😢😢 i love this song very much, sudah puluhan tahun saya dengar dan tidak pernah berubah kenangannya, hidup terasa singkat setiap mendengar lagu ini.. salam dari Indonesia
Didn't expect to have tears in my eggs and bacon this morning... My deepest condolences to Mike and his family. I will be cheering you on in Copenhagen the 10th with all my love and admiration
I Remember my Dad when the time He just past away and i was on the stage too playing drums i cry while am playing i feel you mike p. sorry for the lost of your sister🙏🏻😔
So many comments about people finding this emotional, painful to watch, crying …. I agree. I don’t dislike Dream Theatre but the singing makes me feel all the things above!
Normally, I have crying urge when listening this beautiful song....just that night I had one more reason to cry listening them live...however even filled with grief we celebrated music and felt his pain, because Spirit Carries On
Nada mejor q este video para saber lo q se quieren mike y john , el apoyo q le da mientras tocan es emocionante, cteo q cualquiera de nosotros si estuviéramos ahi hariamos.lo.mismo, qepd Samantha, mike sos todo lo bueno q uno puede conocer en esta tierra, no me equivoqué al elegirte como el.ejemplo a seguir... Te quiero mucho loco y nos vemos el 19 de diciembre en Argentina
Mereka adalah keluarga,karena itu DT dengan tangan terbuka menyambut kembali kepulangan MP ke DT karena DT tau bahwa fans sangat merindukan kembali nya MP ke DT. Aku pribadi sangat merasakan kesedihan yang dirasakan MP. RIP to samantha. Semoga MP bisa tabah dan merelakan kepergian samantha. 🙏🙏🙏
This New Drumer is too many styles, has no skills, no groove, not fast & very slow. Where did DT find it? He destroyed DT music. They should also change vocalists, she is very obsolete, lyrics are not clear, even my grandmother is better than her while singing!
It may possibly help to understand the context of a thing before you comment on a thing. Mike Portnoy had just heard about the passing of his sister prior to performing this.
@tobyb4304 Well, I know Portnoy left the band and returned after not having success...and the guys fired Mangini. So he cried becuase he got his old job and salary back ?
@@Homie3794 and I know a lot more about DT. ...cause I really wanted to understand what is the hype with them. I did not know about his sisters death but maybe he should be with his family and calling Mangini to replace him in this moment
What true professional musicians the members of Dream Theater are. Portnoy has had some major tragedies in his life. I wish him & his family ✌️❤️& Understanding. 😢
![Dream Theater - Hollow Years [Live in Chile, 21/12/2024]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_RyXwtYtY3o/mqdefault.jpg)
![Dream Theater - Hollow Years [Live in Chile, 21/12/2024]](/img/tr.png)
To see how Portnoy moves his head towards Petrucci in search for comfort is so touching. Rest in heaven, Samantha.
Ah man that broke me seeing that
@@Kyler_951ho pianto come un bambino!
He was crying for Samantha. We all cried 😢😞😢
By the end of the day, our superheroes are just humans like us... Stay strong, Mike! RIP Samantha! Your brother is home now, where he belongs! :)
Man, I’m already crying then James sings the chorus.
Not only was Mike crying, but John as well. Family
I lost my mother and got to see Mike with Neal Morse front row and I remember being so down and Mike looked at me and gave me a smile and wave I had so many emotions that night. Thank you Mike for being an inspiration to me. Been listening to dream theater since I was 5 years old!!! I'm 29 now lol. My first album I ever heard in my life was scenes from a memory.
Mike Portnoy is the real deal and it’s wonderful to see Petrucci support him on the utmost level. RIP Samantha.
Thanks for the video. Astonishing to see him playing all the way, through tears and mind numbing pain. He's one tough son, much respect 💪🫀🫶
Astonishing panorama of the end times..
Very heartbreaking to see Mike in that state, but he soldiered through like the pro he is. JP is like a brother to him, and so nice to see him
up their comforting Mike. Rest In Peace, Samantha
He plays with his heart soul. His dad was his biggest inspiration.
I honestly admire Mike as person even more after this heartbreaking performance. To find strength to power through the whole concert moments after receiving the news about his sister passing. If i was at his place, i would have canceled the show just to be with my family (i believe mike's wife and kids are traveling with him in this european tour). But he needed to play this concert. To help to ease his pain and deal with his mourn. Mad respects to Mike. Love you man, and RIP Samantha. She is finnaly free. May her soul rest in peace.
Never thought a drum-cam video could make me cry....
it takes a lot to make a grown man cry. but this... this is just pure. the friendship, the relationship between these guys... RIP Samantha. stay strong MP.
Never thought I would see a crying drum cam. Huge respect for Portnoy to muster the strength to finish this show. His efforts helped these people see a show they will never forget. I hope he gets time to mourn with his family.
I also cried watching this. I'm sorry for your loss. Rest in peace
Even the mightiest warriors must shed tears sometimes. Love and prayers to Mike 😢
Purely a magical moment! This is now my favorite DT moment. Brotherhood, family, beyond music!
Man, I'm watching this after my older brother passing last night, fucking hits home so hard, you can see the pain on Mike's face, nice to see Petrucci going out of his way to be with him, life is definitely
too short, My brother played guitar which got me into playing guitar which probably led me to discovering DT. Strange how life works sometimes... R.I.P to Samantha and my brother Valentin Carlos. You will be sorely missed.
I am sorry for your loss, may her rest in peace and be with you always
4:12when the lyrics say “Has helped me to find, The meaning in my life again” John leans 😢❤
Labrie even managed to sing well, to make this video more wholesome
What? Are you people completely tone deaf??
@@dudee499 get out
IM sorry bro, that def didnt happen
OMG! 4:47 is so moving. My heart is with you, Mike. DT forever. Rest in paradise, Samantha.
Life on the road has its own difficult details. In 2005, I went to their show in São Paulo, Brazil. They divided the show into two parts, and in the second part, they would play Metropolis pt. 2 in its entirety. During the break, they told Labrie that his father had passed away, and he did the show in the most professional way possible. I only found out about this event months later in an interview.
Losing family is something that is very painful. Especially if you lose your brother or sister who accompanied you to play together from childhood until you were old. Rip 🥀
So painful to see this ❤ Bless you Mike. May her soul rest in peace.
How old was she?
@@bbdrms7283idk
@@bbdrms7283 not sure but she was in very bad health, she had told Mike to still go on tour and tried to make the London show but couldn't
Дорогой Майк, я плакал вместе с тобой... Спасибо за эмоции и добро пожаловать домой❤
Why am I crying 😢 rip SP 🙏🥁 you had the best seat to capture this beautiful and heartbreaking moment I hope there's no 3rd sad concert footage the 2nd being the 2 songs Chestert Bennington sings at the barrier with the front row at the Birmingham uk show 2 weeks before he ....
I mean…. That’s the most beautiful song EVER!!!! Always gets me too.
My heart, Fandom, and prayers go out to you Mike. You have reclaimed your throne. Your sister is looking down upon you with great pride.
Mike we love you so much!!
God Bless You Mike. 🙏😢🖤😭
By seeing, full tears on my eyes..feel you Mike, but you have John Petrucci beside you. RIP Samantha😢
Thanks for everything Mike. You’re the reason I play drums. That’s tough brother. Might be the first time I teared up pooing.
I Can Feel The Sorrow In His Face...
His Eyes, Full of Tears...
😢😭
May Sam Rest In Peace... 🕊️
Gran baterista, mejor persona, RIP Samantha!!!! Todo el apoyo para Mike!!
My Sincere Condolences Mike Stay Strong For Samantha its what she'd want 💕💐
😢😢 i love this song very much, sudah puluhan tahun saya dengar dan tidak pernah berubah kenangannya, hidup terasa singkat setiap mendengar lagu ini.. salam dari Indonesia
This is absolutely heartbreaking. I burst into tears.
Didn't expect to have tears in my eggs and bacon this morning... My deepest condolences to Mike and his family. I will be cheering you on in Copenhagen the 10th with all my love and admiration
Stay strong hero 😢
I’d cry listening to that voice all night
I Remember my Dad when the time He just past away and i was on the stage too playing drums i cry while am playing i feel you mike p. sorry for the lost of your sister🙏🏻😔
Im not crying you crying!!!
Sending the biggest hug to Mike right now
Sad 😢 I can’t imagine. Stay strong Mike. Sorry for your loss.
Mike ....sorry for your Lost....but the show must go on.....❤😊
That must have been so difficult..prayers for mike and his family for comfort and strength ❤
So sorry for his families loss. And not only that, to get back out on tour knowing his sister was ill.
He was crying for Samantha. We all cried 😢😞😢
Sympathies Mike -your home where you belong and so is Samantha ❤
So many comments about people finding this emotional, painful to watch, crying …. I agree. I don’t dislike Dream Theatre but the singing makes me feel all the things above!
Poor soul... stay strong, dear Mike. Her spirit is with you now and forever ❤
Normally, I have crying urge when listening this beautiful song....just that night I had one more reason to cry listening them live...however even filled with grief we celebrated music and felt his pain, because Spirit Carries On
That's why I love DT... and makes this tour so memorable. ❤
Heartbreaking 😢
The saddest video I know… i feel so much empathy that tears come each time 😭
I cried listening to James “sing”
Deep sadness, tiredness and shock of the heart. Honestly, Mike is very sad in his heart.
Oh my God
Poor guy😢 True man
I cried the whole video
RIP. Samantha
I tried to hold my tears on this video, but i can't. 💔
So touching ขอให้ดวงวิญญาณของ ซาแมนธาสู่สุขคติครับ
Davvero commovente, bentornato Mike, queste sono emozioni vere♥️
Nada mejor q este video para saber lo q se quieren mike y john , el apoyo q le da mientras tocan es emocionante, cteo q cualquiera de nosotros si estuviéramos ahi hariamos.lo.mismo, qepd Samantha, mike sos todo lo bueno q uno puede conocer en esta tierra, no me equivoqué al elegirte como el.ejemplo a seguir... Te quiero mucho loco y nos vemos el 19 de diciembre en Argentina
Mike I feel what you feel.RIP to your sister.
FYI, he's crying because this song was dedicated to his daughter.
Hermoso ❤❤😢😢
❤
I'm so sorry Mike ='(
I can understand Mike.. I'm crying to this as well
RIP Samantha Portnoy. 🙏 ❤
If mike, john cry everybody cries😢
This killed me to watch, losing a sibling is very hard.
Condoglianze Mike...❤
Forza, Mike!
Mike estaba así porque falleció su hermana , que descanse en paz y de la manera que fuese acompañamos en su dolor a Mike
No esperaba llorar hoy
❤
Mereka adalah keluarga,karena itu DT dengan tangan terbuka menyambut kembali kepulangan MP ke DT karena DT tau bahwa fans sangat merindukan kembali nya MP ke DT.
Aku pribadi sangat merasakan kesedihan yang dirasakan MP.
RIP to samantha.
Semoga MP bisa tabah dan merelakan kepergian samantha. 🙏🙏🙏
❤❤❤
Dios, que duro. Bendiciones y que Dios la tenga en la Gloria.
CATHARTIC AS F
Asi voy a estar yo durante todo el recital viendolo sentado en la bateria
E nos chorando junto obvio kkkkk
Thanks is pack mike portnoy i like 👍
😢😢😢
Showman
Who is Samantha
Who is Samantha?
マイク🎶 ご冥福をお祈りします From JAPAN
Masashi
RIP Samantha 💔
Aya Mc Protnoy
Yiddishe Neshoma
Whos samantha?
Mike's Little sister whom passed away moments before this concert due to a Câncer.
@FerreiraLG ok thanks
Where was all that love when they kicked him out of his own band??
Can the poor guy cry in peace without people filmimg him? Jesus get a grip. Why would anybody film a person crying?
Forgiveness is a good thing. Hopefully he won’t throw another tantrum and threatened to quit again
Dude his sister just died can you not be a dick for 1 second or are you that miserable in your sorry life?
This New Drumer is too many styles, has no skills, no groove, not fast & very slow. Where did DT find it? He destroyed DT music. They should also change vocalists, she is very obsolete, lyrics are not clear, even my grandmother is better than her while singing!
finally got job
LOL I can't imagine myself crying to any dream theater song. All their songs are lifeless and pretentious
It may possibly help to understand the context of a thing before you comment on a thing. Mike Portnoy had just heard about the passing of his sister prior to performing this.
@tobyb4304 Well, I know Portnoy left the band and returned after not having success...and the guys fired Mangini. So he cried becuase he got his old job and salary back ?
@@pocojoyo Good one. But maybe this time re-read my comment.
@@pocojoyoyou seem to know a lot about a band you seemingly hate…
Have a soul the guy just lost a lifelong friend.
@@Homie3794 and I know a lot more about DT. ...cause I really wanted to understand what is the hype with them. I did not know about his sisters death but maybe he should be with his family and calling Mangini to replace him in this moment
What true professional musicians the members of Dream Theater are. Portnoy has had some major tragedies in his life. I wish him & his family ✌️❤️& Understanding. 😢