Beauty Is Suffering [Part 1 - The Mathematician]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ก.ย. 2024
- Beauty Is Suffering [Part 1 - The Mathematician]
It is not his specific journey which is crucial, it is what his journey represents. Whether we are listening to a piece of music, using a piece of technology, or gazing into a painting, we are, in those very moments, connecting with some sort of human experience other than our own.
In many cultures around the world, there is a tendency to idolise great achievement without taking heed of the very real human struggle which takes place in order for our own senses to receive new wisdom. True culminations of these types of enjoyment, reveal themselves in what can best be described as transcendent awe.
Whilst many outpourings of the human soul don't stem from suffering and sacrifice, the majority of them do, no matter how subtle they seem. Many of our greatest artistic, social, and scientific insights came about because one or more human beings paid for them in one currency or another.
The paradox is; if a large portion of your culture of which you enjoy is connected to suffering and you had the power to remove suffering from human history, would you?
This series is dedicated to the living and dead, sung and unsung heroes, who continue to struggle or struggled in any way in order for me, to every now and then, experience that transcendent moment of true connectedness to my humanity and my existence.
It is for these moments that I live for.
Video: BBC Horizon - Fermat's Last Theorem.
Music: James Horner - Of one heart, of one mind.
'the race is long and in the end it's only with yourself'. Here is a man who understands that fully
Nobody can imagine the kind of adrenaline rush this guy had after having gone through 7 years of suffering, never knowing whether he would ever achieve his goal, and then suddenly coming to a solution. It must be an instant high better than any crack pipe.
Math > Crack
@@IsaacSMILElol
This man not only inspired me but unlocked something which has been laying dormant within me I was lucky to find this video.
Go after what heart desires, fellow human
Godspeed!
Get after it !!! (David Goggins voice)
Yes, so much suffering choosing the lonely way of life, always looking for a higher truth as others are content with deception and lowly thoughts. You want friends who you can talk to and yet no one has the ability to connect with emotionally or intellectually. Everyone hates you because of your gifts, and yet they are unaware of the sacrifices, of the constant battle one has to make internally to combat the demons who constantly tell you to give up and that you are deceived through some idea of grandiosity and under the spell of delusion. It seems we are on a boat and there is a beautiful island in sight, where solitude and eternal nourishment reigns, and yet to arrive on the coast one has to evade serpents and lakes of boiling pitch. Stay strong, brothers, I hope you find your castle and your word is spread through the generations.
bhishma movie mithun chakraborty
@@kalkishiva6054 wtf ?
beautiful words
I really needed this man
I really needed this man
I don't understand a single line of his proof, but at least my desk looks like his.
😂😂
You have tried to understand it . That's great.
I'll take your word for it since we can't see his desk. Apparently it was a bit too big for Fermat's margin.
I knew that you will not understand a single line of his proof, but i will tell you this strange fact: Kurt Godel a well-known logician, mathematician and philosopher starved to death!. In order to understand the last sentence "starved to death" you must read one more line!. Go and look for it...
🤣🤣🤣 and?
At 2:40-58 what a wonderfully moving and humbling moment. It's a privilege to watch a great genius contemplate his own achievement in this profoundly emotional way.
I'm very happy that people like this exist.
Very emotional ❤
the stuff of life, it's as if he was speaking his last words as was the profundity of the moment.
This video moved me to tears.. as it immediately took me back to the years struggling towards my vision.
What a powerful dose of authenticity, for those who can relate.
Just a quick note. The problem statement at 0:45 is stated incorrectly. The actual statement is a^N + b^N = c^N does not have any positive integer solutions in (a,b,c) for N>2.
Was hoping someone else would point that out
It's still valid. The question is simply asking to find the solution set. And in this case it's empty. Just the same way in some exam questions you might be asked to "find the limit at x" even though the limit does not exist in some cases. That does not invalidate the exam question. All we are required is to state the solution set whether it is infinite, finite or 0.
@@AntoRossi614don't manipulate
If you don't know then just s
Up
@@AntoRossi614such a way to sound smart. WOW
@@AntoRossi614 Hmm. So, you mean that you read it as a comprehension, like {(a,b,c) | a, b, c > 0 and a^N + b^N = c ^N }, and now express the function f(N) = | {(a,b,c) | a, b, c > 0 and a^N ....} | for N > 2 in a trivially computable way? (Which we know now is f(N) = 0 for all N > 2) Still in that case the question as stated is not complete. Then they should have added: "... is equal to the empty set", because that is what Fermat proposed.
I hope we can be like him, pursuing his childhood dream with a burning passion, and succeeding.
Sadly only few can do this most fail
succeding is not for everyone unfortunately
@@dantdt4693 bcs everybody cant sacrifice and work hard consistently
Mighty is the mathematical theorem but mightier is the mind who dedicates itself to formulate and prove these theorems, a huge respect to all mathematicians out there who suffer for improvement of knowledge in mathematics for the sake of humanity.
They don't suffer more than anybody else. They like doing math
@@holomurphy22Nope, we suffer
They don't suffer instead they enjoy and cherish
@@holomurphy22They are motivated to do so, doesn't mean it's always comfortable though, think of an athlete for example, do you really think an athlete really enjoys the pain he suffers in every single workout? Pain is pain, and both pushing through very intense physical efforts, and spending a lot of time thinking and investigating the result of an equation, even without a single bit of hope, are painful. But we still push through because we believe something good is coming out of it, some benefit, some discovery, some satisfactory performance, whatever, maybe the result is in fact pleasure, but the process, majority of the time if excellence or maybe even basic survival if you were born in a bad condition is what you seek, consists of suffering. And that's okay, as long as we have enough willpower to push through and enough reason to do it, that's how a lot of our ancestors survived and thrived, we were meant to care about things we consider meaningful and sacrifice ourselves for it.
@@scienceaffairs2919They do suffer just like artists. They dedicate so much time on their craft while giving up time on people believing well that their product may live on for centuries to come
What a mind; I have such admiration for this man
***Are you **#Mathematician** or **#Scientist**?***
***Then stay far away by **#Science_Charlatans**!***
If we loss The #Road_In_Science , need maybe 1000 years to find it back.
Because :
*****#The_Best_Ever_Humanity_Logical_Science_Discovery*****
*****#Best_Ever_HSCUT_Components_AEPDF*****
where
*****#HSCUT** = ***
*****#Humanity_Science_And_Culture_Universal_Thesaurus*****
*****#America_Earth_Proud_Day_Fundamentals*****
#7_Years_Hide by #Civil_Society_Institutions - #Science_Institutions via - I can’t say exactly if - #Microsoft_Hackers, #Facebook_Hackers , #Oracle_Hackers, or #Oracle_Hackers or #Intel_Hackers !
A lot of People , #Scientists, #Mathematicians yet are working desperate for
*****#Fermat_Last_Theorem***** as a intuitive answer to an inexact #Proof even for n=4.
*****#BUT***** *****#Boyss****
, Fermat’s Last Theorem is #Fundamental in #Science by #2015_September_24 by #Ion_Murgu_From_Ohio .
#Fermat_Last_Theorem_Certified in #Accurate, all Science rigor for n [2, #Infinity ) and sent in fundamental , keep also it’s old name as respect for #Fermat!
Thanks for helping My as AEPDF to take theirs place into #HSCUT !
See “www.climaticdisorder.com/hstp/” and don’t ask for what “#Climatic_Disorder_DOTCOM” . I thought the fight against all climatic disorders will be to us a duty for future as a #Good_Morning_Future for Eternity!
The passion you feel from his words, just amazing
this man is the only reason i wanted to pursue math
It is so powerful and motivating to pursuit your dreams. I can feel his passion even after 40 years since he solved the problem.
I can't believe the video can't even get the statement of the problem down correctly.
Yes, you're right
Yes, that's a total disgrace. Who made that opening text?
@Fernando Cunha Well, I don't think that Fermat's last theorem, or at least the idea, has to be presented _that_ way. Especially as an open-ended question, we do not need to affirm the result.
As an unanswered question, it can be presented as: "Does a^n+b^n=c^n have integer solutions for a,b,c for n>2?" Or something to that effect.
The main problem with their wording is that the quantifier seems universal. When they say "for any three positive integers a, b, c, prove that a^n + b^n = c^n for n greater than 2", this reads as though whatever a, b, c you pick, a^n + b^n will always equal c^n for any n>2.
swindler
@@EpicMathTime
Can you give an example
I can understand the feeling that after solving those problems which your colleagues can't solve, you feel you are above sky. It gives you that kind of confidence that nothing can give, a pleasure which can't be expressed. Only you-you -you.... you can feel. For Mr. Andrew wiles Sir 👍. I would love to prove Fermat theorem in another way.
@@nikolajkjrkatballe2209 He didn't say that it had to do with the abilities of his colleagues. Ashutosh is saying he can understand the feeling when he solved problems his colleagues couldn't solve.
They cut the bit where he breaks down . A really moving moment
Suffering becomes beautiful when anyone bears great calamities with cheerfulness,
not through insensibility but with greatness in mind.
~ Aristotle ~
I remember this documentary in 1995 I think or 1996. It was very good. It was before the internet existed. Those were the days!
There is a typo early in the video (about 0:43) that says FLT says that what is true isn't true. "For any three positive integers; a,b,c; a^N+b^N=c^N for N>2, but the "=" should be "≠".
Yup
@Schrodinger's cat 'rolling' in his grave is the term. Crying indeed.
beauty is symmetry mixed with utility mixed with love
Beautiful... thank you for sharing. Very humbling for the average physics or math undergrad frustrated from being stuck on a problem for a day or two.
Speechless,so much feeling accomplishment this is perfect hardworking suffering passion
The beauty of suffering is innovation and discovery 🙏🏻🙏🏻
I will also spend my whole life in solving the Reimann hypothesis
When you finally solve it, make sure that you spell the name correctly in the title of your paper.
@@toddtrimble2555 oooooooooooooooooooooooooof burnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
@@toddtrimble2555
Riemann Hypothesis
Pure feelings!
One of the greatest video, its touches the soul.. ❤❤❤❤
Your channel is wonderful. Thank you for this.
If you want suffering and maths, check out the life of Euler. He had everything. War.Shiprecks. Did much his work while blind. He did so much math that 3 out of the 10 of tthe greatest discoveries come from him, and it will take a team of mathematicians over 200 years to go through it all!
i completely agree. if wiles was fleeing Iraq while the US & UK were bombing the hell out of it I could say Wiles suffered. Wiles' biggest threat was a papercut
Bastards
The best mathematician of all time after Gauss.
@fhhfhdfdhhdhhdfhdf138 The wording was off. Instead of suffering, it should be struggling.
so beautiful. I felt like when thinking of it it still moved him to tears. I cannot imagine how such an experience changes life.
What good is beautiful;
simple is beautiful!
Everything should be as simple as possible but no simpler.
Yup reading mathematics , struggling to absorb the full meaning of the structure of the proof, it feels like banging your head against the wall. So in the struggle, you knock and knock and knock... then sometimes, it happens. you get a revelation from the beyond, or by the philosophers, the revelation is in the form of sudden remembrance. what is unclear is made clear. what is unknown is made known. and the imagination is graced with the form of understanding.
Beautifully put!
Beautifully said 😮🎉❤
Nowhere does he say he was suffering.
Amazing result from an amazing mathematician. Great video.
according to me he forgot to tell uncertainty is a blunt truth
I do not know exactly how but this video was great inspiration. And after that i searched for Mr Andrew and found that we share the same birthdays mist be a sign. 🙌🏻
What a beautiful human being 🥹
Wiles is beyond a great man for completing the impossible.
Also I must now read all Aristotle for the quotation
Suffering becomes beautiful when anyone bears great calamities with cheerfulness not through I sensibility but through greatness of the mind.
Such a beautiful logical way of conducting life how I feel I live is exactly the same and maybe when it's mocked because of someone else's angry/stress etc etc it's definitely a quotation to make...
I think I either want to study math or help humans socially involved either way this video has inspired me.
He loved it & he worked it
He is a hardworking mathematician.
@Douglas Sirk are you expert?
Damn, he was near tears.
They cut the bit where he breaks dow
My hero ❤️
This is so beautiful. God bless him.
Wonderful
This is one of the most beautiful things i have ever seen. Thank you
You did it ....For the love of God you solved it. BEAUTIFUL .😔
How could he have done this for the love of God
@@ShinichiMotizoki Figure of speech… not a theological description.
This is truly beautiful
2:49 his silence shows his struggle
One will never know how it feels to do such a feat, until they actually do it. I remember once at my job on my lunch break I prayed to GOD to show me unique mathematical proofs on the CROSS hidden from the eyes of men. That was 11 years ago, and I learn something new everyday....I have to discover that it is limitless...just like what the symbol represents spiritually is limitless! Read JOHN 1:1-3 KJV. Its ALL right there one the CROSS hidden in plain sight! It takes spiritual perception to "see it".
this just makes my cry
That's so inspiring and emotional at the same time
😊😊❤🎉
I don't think there is suffering involved. Blissful work would be closer to the truth perhaps. 7 years of just doing maths among stacks of paper - I understand this may be the epitome of suffering for some people. But for an expert of the field, for a mathematician, this is meaningful work, not suffering.
There is a part where he is fighting tears. I wonder if this is misunderstood as a show of self-pity after enduring considerable suffering. It's not that. I think he is fighting tears out of sheer awe of the beauty of what he discovered.
Where is the full documentary? if anyone knows, please let me know :(
This was so beautiful to watch ✨
Notice how he never says "um" or "uh". He simply stops talking to think.
the most romantic thing in the world
Oh please. He says he "loved every minute of it". He was presumably paid well for his work.
You cannot equate "suffering" in the sense of working for years on a problem, with the suffering of the human race. War, disease and other senseless injustices are nothing like the privileged work that this man did.
What? He was working in secret, Plus, you're comparing oranges to bananas. It's not because these things you wrote are suffering that studying a problem for years and not solving it isn't
Don't wanna sound mean but...
I feel like his wife suffered, too.
Beauty is suffering!
I love this video
Also, I wonder how this video would feel if there wasn’t that fancy music in the background. Like a sitcom when you take away the laugh track
Isaac Newton genes living in this guy
Turns out the prompt is about his wife. She is absolutely gorgeous
Great
Yeah my face goes from hey man to Russian beauty flat when under load from general painful things. Then I get intellectual and my face goes to average looking male. Three facial holds in static nervous system, used to like number three but Russian beauty flat is way better with a beanie on. Like this is literally nervous system tension with one stimulus.
Wish one day I expirence emotions of winning
Thanks
That was lovely
Theology is the advanced course of religion.
No matter how theological arguments are asserted by their experts, they can't really lead to discursive bold new programs of action for the average religious indivdual.
Theology can only serve as a sphere of insights that can inform and console the religous when reflected upon, and influence a society over time.
No-Free-Will is the advanced course of the secular.
A lack of free will can't really lead to discursive, bold, new programs of action for the secular.
Rather, no-free-will can only serve a sphere of insights that can inform and consle the secular when reflected upon, and may influence a society over time.
1:22 did he literally mean he understood it at 10!
Stay...
Brilliant
Legend
Where is part two??
How could anyone over those 350 years have been so certain that there was, in fact, a solution?
This theory so important
what about the sequel ?
1:30 - 1:52
Beauty is suffering
FeelsStrongMan
I too want something hopeful
Cutie pie.
Is there any movie of wiles ? because i think it should be made
I believe there is a play based on wiles' journey on discovering a proof of Fermat last theorem. Personally, I feel that the documentary on BBC is better.
I think he likes doing math tho lol. He loves his struggle it seems.
Im moved
wow
This guy's desk is out of control!
There’s a desk under there? 😅
This guy loves math, I can tell
Agreed, its like 4chan, if anyone except for google owned this site it would be cleaned up, but google get too much info on people here
2:29 thats me at month end completing pending work
lol the statement of Fermat's last theorem is absurd.
2:26 - next time they ask you to clean up, show'em this!
I was like him as a math student . Then the real world hit me and I needed $$ so had to move to financial mathematics.
Damn thats sad
@@dedededededededede that is the real world. That is why investment banks sucks all top talent instead of brightest should be in research and academia
The statement of the theorem is wrong at 0:38. LOL.
Pls tell starting music name
now compare this side by side with the way a greek mathematician would have handled it.
Typo in the problem statement. Should say not equal for n greater than 2.
0:36 uuhm you meant to write a^N + b^N ≠ c^N ?
4:50 Well, he has a very beautiful wife actually.
***
So I don't get it what did he do by his proof what does that mean did he prove that it's unsolvable or did he solve it