Freeman Dyson: A ‘Rebel’ Without a Ph.D.
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 มิ.ย. 2015
- A wide-ranging interview with the legendary mathematical physicist Freeman Dyson in which he discusses his work with Richard Feynman, his attempts to build a spaceship propelled by nuclear bombs and his controversial views on climate change.
QUANTA MAGAZINE
Website: www.quantamagazine.org/
Facebook: / quantanews
Twitter: / quantamagazine
You can also sign up for our weekly newsletter: eepurl.com/6FnWj.
Freeman Dyson is a world-renowned mathematical physicist who helped found quantum electrodynamics with Richard Feynman. Read Quanta Magazine’s conversation with Dyson: www.quantamagazine.org/201403.... Video filmed by Ben Henretig/Micro-Documentaries. Editing by Aaron Biscombe. Music by Dexter Britain.
Quanta Magazine is an editorially independent publication launched by the Simons Foundation. - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
What is really amazing is the clear state of mind this man was at the age of 92, truly remarkable person. A great inspiration for all researchers.
Agreed.
Shame they cut off an edited his climate answer.
Larry
maybe that’s how it ended but
It seemed he had more to say on the topic of climate change but was tentative about speaking on it because his opinions go against the narrative. He was clearly saying that it’s not at all like what we’re being told and he is correct.
I've always liked rebels... Because these are the ones that tear up the old rule books and do their OWN thing! Einstein was another rebel... So was Feynman! And when I used to teach, I was always drawn to those students who had their own unique way of doing things. Squeaky clean and obedient students that simply followed the rules were... Nice... But were pretty forgettable by and large!
@@sdwone I agree as well. It often takes incredible courage to go against the grain though, most people aren't cut out for that part of it. I always look for the outside thinkers.
The best mathematician is the one with curiosity and humility. Dyson is a legend of any age.
It's a shame he's not with us anymore.
The best is the one with the best results.
He showed the world that 'Curoisty is much more important than any degree anyone who is smart enough to study a subject gets PhD but to make contributions you need a driving curiosity and dedication' 🙏🏼🙏🏼
@@dutcheastindies8354 no
Beautiful
He died on 28 February 2020, I feel surprised that I didn’t know much about him until today.
Same. May he rest in peace.
You think that you would have heard something!!
This guy transformed fyenmen's diagrams into pure mathematics! This guy is a legend.
@@someone1059 A few years before his death, Einstein commented on Poincaré as being one of the pioneers of relativity, saying "Lorentz had already recognized that the transformation named after him is essential for the analysis of Maxwell's equations, and Poincaré deepened this insight still further ...." --- saw this on wiki
Schwinger already knew how to make those calculations without having to draw them as little wiggling pictures.
”He loves to talk”
I think Richard Feynman was the most charming and outgoing Scientist ever.
Who also creeped on Cornell undergrads while he was a professor there. He was an idol to me until I learned about that.
@@jacob9673I've heard of him taking trips to local strip clubs and going out with married women before, never this.
I talked with Mr. Dyson (now more than 25 years ago) when he was at the Institute for Advanced Study (Princeton). During our conversation, he asked me why I was pursuing my PhD (knowing that he didn't complete his under Hans Bethe at Cornell). I said, "Well, for me it's like a carrot before me and I want to bite it and then eat it." To which he replied, "Okay." Then we talked about other things. May he RIP.
I assume you need the PhD to get in the door so people would take you seriously. Dyson had produced seminal work with Hans Bethe and Feynman, so he was already well inside the door and very productive. At that point the diploma is not important. But he probably should have gotten it anyway just to placate his parents.
@@stuartwiner7920 Had he completed the PhD he would not have spent so much of his time talking about why he didn't think it was important.
I had the *supreme* honor of meeting Freeman Dyson after a summer lecture at the Chautauqua Institute in the late 80's. I was an undergraduate physics major at a nearby University, and we had a wide-ranging conversation about the future of science and practical applicaitons of mathematics in emerging tech. Wonderful, personable man; a real pleasure to speak with.
I can't believe I live in a world where streamers exist and people make them rich and famous when there are people like this man who deserve more
It's seriously sad thing
I don't think he cares about money much. Money is a medium. A profesor at a good university don't have to worry about money, and thats enough.
Much like athletes, streamers provide a service in entertainment.
cringe
Me too
This is the exact feelings i have for mathematics, like playing a piano, i may not be as brilliant as this man far from it i know, but i just see alot of myself in him its amazing, i never relate to anyone like this before my whole life
Moist
Go ahead with your passion..
I support you brother From Tamilnadu India.
What a brilliant, curious, and humble man. It is wonderful to see a man of this age still so lucid. His youth reminds me the curiosity Feynman had as a youth. It is sad that science gets choked by men who have an agenda but that has always been so.
Freeman John Dyson FRS (15 December 1923 - 28 February 2020)--Rest in Peace
Humility is underrated. He is a legend. 🙏
Currently reading his book "Origins of Life" and his insights are both lovely and amazing. It reminded me of my love for science since I was a kid. I admit I do not understand a lot of the physics jargon and equations since I am mainly on the medical field, but it is amusing to skim through and read the simplifications. He is indeed a legend.
He transformed Feynman's diagram in pure mathematics. He is a genius. He is a legend. Live long sir.
Unfortunately he is no longer with us "Physically"
These five minutes feel awesome and refreshing. 👌👌
What an outstanding gentlemen
Very inspiring interview, fascinating man
Wow, how did I never know abt this gem before, tysm YT for such recommendations 🙏
Thanks for the interview
One of my heroes....God bless him
Rest in Peace Champ the world needs more people like you wayyy more!
He looks like that lonely guy, yet he's happy. Bravo, the first video that gave me goosebumps in a while.
Edit: Lol 40 likes
The man who follows the crowd will usually get no further than the crowd. The man who walks alone is likely to find himself in places no one has ever been before.
@@B20C0 Love that one!
Absolute legend
How was he not promoted based on his works on the feynman diagrams?
May God bless you sir
Wonderful
Glad I had this recommended to me, thank you.
As if geniuses require paperwork from non-geniuses to create unique inventions and/or make discoveries.
20% of people makes 80% of contribution to humanity and this man is surely in the top 5%.
Very good!!
His book, Infinity in All Directions, is well worth reading.
Rest In Peace… such an inspiration; such great honesty…
humble in person
Absolutely Great Man.
What’s the image at 4:29?
Bacana. As ciências exatas são lindas construções da humanidade.
The man the Dyson sphere is named after!
What a wise man. RIP
Until he says racism is still a problem in the USA. Then he becomes public enemy n°1.
This guy looks amazingly physically similar to late John Nash!
There is always a place for the subgenius in the realms of knowledge.
He's exceptionally humble and understated about himself. In reality, Freeman Dyson was a Genius with the capital G, and an enormously visionary one too.
Good man
Wonderful interview with one of the finest scientists that ever lived. Such a terrible shame that there was muzak playing constantly, it is utterly superfluous and can only detract from what is being said.
Quite. Every time.
LOVELY..............
We are getting to see the 1st stage of conceptualizing and creating a dyson sphere.
Could you elaborate? Sounds like you're saying there's some kind of funding or venture for the creation of a dyson sphere? Would love to get info or a link if that's the case
@@zalooooo Not sure about that one, but it was just an expression of feeling. It feels like we at the brink of Type 1 civilization, where we have ran out of energy sources on earth.
@@nisc_k A type 1 civilisation has nothing to do with running out. Its about the amount of Energy a Civilisation can use.
famous
the guy
movement
i loved to listen
result
it will take alot of hard work journey
He is amazing scientist
Y nos regaló la oportunidad de imaginar su esfera
This guy lived upto his name.
where
I always wondered who was behind that great vacuum
Amazing man genius
If he is alive, somebody tell him, he was right about Dyson spheres but in a very very different way....
Can you please elaborate more. I am curious
WHAT DOES THIS MEAN
Amazing man, no PhD and can increase people's understanding of scientific knowledge!
1:32 Richard Feynman
Great vacuum cleaners too. This guy has it all.
Give that man a PhD.
Forget the Dyson spheres, I am a big fan of his hair dryers.
Freeman Dyson, the daddy of Gordon Freeman :)
Holy suit, he has a perfect blend of American and English accent
@@ccriztoff u don't say
Why does TH-cam seek to place its own information whenever a person questions climate change?
he is right about climate, so humble, that's a genius trait.
Completely wrong about climate change. No background in that particular science, all a desire to convince people that his gut feelings mattered much. Not very humble about his climate science musings, which had been and continue to be proven wrong.
@@scottekoontz This man has more background than any climate change pseudoscientist 🤣
@@janos1945 So you're OK with an expert in one science commenting on some other science he or she never studied? I guess if you want to call Dyson a pseudoscientist then we could all agree as long as he's commenting on climate.
You think a virologist is great at rocket science?
@@scottekoontz Climate science is not reliable, it is a field that still needs a lot of progress. This man was a theoretical physicist and a first rate mathematician, that is enough to have a credible opinion on climate change, he was an expert on it by extension.
@@janos1945 He was clearly not an expert. Here are the zero papers he wrote or co-authored regarding climate science:
...
...
(end)
Poor guy had some gut feelings, and you think they were papers.
Know who else didn't have a PhD? Jay Forrester, and he did okay.
Moral of the story: You don't need a PhD if you do pioneering work with Feynman and Bethe
He was named Freeman for a reason.
LOUD MUSIC
RIP
💗💖💝🇧🇩❣
Hm.
This man tried to go to space using the combustion engine lol
no he didn't nuclear bombs haha and it worked but the way
This scientist is telling me that Richard Feynman is a genius and another scientist online is telling me that Richard Feynman is overrated. Who do I listen to?
are you talking about unzickers view? he talks a lot of rubbish
Freeman Dyson's view on climate is the one we should adopt, that is to be skeptic. That's the correct way of science. To push a conclusion to the public that's not solid or well understood enough is simply not a good idea.
Unfortunately it is pretty well understood. By this I mean that we understand the impact that CO2 (and other greenhouse gases) have on the climate. They cause a warming effect. This exact effect was first predicted in the late 19th century, and it was confirmed in the 20th. Our predictions have been frighteningly accurate, if a bit conservative. The evidence is absolutely overwhelming at this point. We have already been very skeptical, and it turns out that the people saying that CO2 causes global warming which will change the climate were right.
Wait why could he not get a Phd for his work translating feynman
Because that's not how getting a doctorate works
☝Ahh Dyson 🙈🙈
Physics
Hey Freeman, maybe you should be aware that climate change refers to long-term shifts in temperatures and weather patterns, mainly caused by human activities, especially the burning of fossil fuels.
was this guy inspired by Seinfeld or just Yudkowsky? either way he talks like Thunderfoot 😂
Dyson - Scientist with a capital letter.
No immediate relation to James Dyson lol
Climate research is closely controlled by political and economic interests, so his objections might not actually be wrong.
Another right thing that he thinks
Well, he said it himself, he is no expert at the topic.
He said himself he doesn't object per se, but that the study of climate is so poorly understood that it wouldn't surprise him either way. Like weather systems, it is functionally impossible to make confident projections into the future. These are non-linear systems. And you're right about there being powerful lobbyists pushing both sides of the narrative. The truth is we are essentially imposing order on a system which is technically "chaotic."
@@alexandermuller8587 There are a lot of people who claim to be experts on that topic, that really aren't.
@@brandonporter6223 If I have to choose which opinion I trust most on a certain subject I look to the consesus of experts of the certain field, and not to someone who claims to be not an expert of the field. Him being intelligent neither means that he is the most intelligent nor does it mean that he is the most knowledgable in fields he didn't study.
The juvenile january beautifully bang because run grossly record by a far thistle. hesitant, romantic shape
Even his name spits rebellion against Peter Pan Syndrome... "Free MAN Die SON"
This video keeps coming up again and again in my youtube recommendations for reasons I cannot fathom.
Why on earth does anyone consider Dyson "legendary"?
It's very difficult indeed to point to anything which Dyson got right, or anything he actually achieved, beyond taking notes for Feynman. I read his autobiography a few years ago, the only thing remarkable is Dyson's self-estimation. Most of his ideas were completely crackpot. See Hugo Barnacle's letter to the Guardian for some examples.
There are some funny interviews on youtube with Murray Gell-Mann discussing Dyson, worth looking up.
[Edited to correct the name "Hugo Barnacle"]
@@Brad-qw1te Even Dyson admits, on other videos you can find right on youtube, that his main contribution to QED was taking notes for Feynman, because Feynman was too lazy to write them down. You've also forgotten about the Dyson tree and the astrochicken to add to Dyson's grand list of achievements.
But it speaks for itself that the best you can offer for Dyson's legacy are a few bits of mathematics and fantasies like the "Dyson Sphere" or Project Orion (which is the same thing as the Helios propulsion system).
@@Brad-qw1te Unfortunately he wasn't being humble. Dyson's autobiography which I mentioned above is the book "Disturbing the Universe".
There are some videos of Dyson on a channel called "Web of Stories" talking very extensively about what he did, and there are other contributors such as Murray Gell-Mann talking about Dyson, if you want to find out more. TH-cam doesn't allow links in comments so please search for them yourself.
I agree with you that we should all try to educate ourselves better. I hope this discussion has been a little productive or educational for the two of us, or for some future reader of our dialogue. Best wishes.
@@benkasminbullock It has been educational, thank you for giving example to someone who wants to learn.
He was a crackpot in many areas from biology to climate science indeed, but to suggest he was anything less than a top tier particle physicist and mathematician is ridiculous. Gell-mann talked shit about everyone from Einstein to Feynman.
@@kreitzerova2371 I'm ridiculous then since I will continue to suggest that Freeman Dyson was quite considerably less than a top tier particle physicist and mathematician.
Looks like Ellen
Im even better than Freeman. I dropped out of college alltogether.
The climate comment is nothing more than an opinion, not relevant to his real achievements.
The nature of his stated beliefs was a sufficiently competent assessment of the required state of mind for an all-inclusive understanding of Mathematical Conjecture. (Compatible with Hit and Miss, probabilistic Actuality)
He is humble enough to admit he is not a climate scientist but still thinks all climate scientist are wrong. Unfortunately, some people take his views on climate as valid as those of actual climate scientists.
Climate scientists work with numerical models, and numerical modeling is not a hard science. Anyone can make numerical models spit out erroneous results if so inclined. Dyson was an expert on numerical models, and understood the dangers of manipulating numbers with a pre-conceived bias in the outcome.
feynman to freeman the legacy continues
The amused blue optimally behave because lamb nally long pace a animated army. diligent, physical disease
Is this a concert or a bio of Dyson? The music is overbearing. Why would you sugar this up with this cliche-ridden soundtrack?
No one under 50 knows who this guy is and Logan Paul is a millionaire, we are so fucked
IT WAS CLEARE THAT ,WHEN GOD WANT TO SHOW HEAR GREATNES THE GREATNES OF GOD,THAT TIME THE ANGELOF GOD, TAKEN SOME ONE ESPEACIEL HUMAN ON EARTH ,THAT TIME WAS SAND MORETHEN BEFOR OF HUMAN EARTH TIME,"IN EVERY HOWLLE BOOK GOD TOLD,"I PUT EVERY KNOLADGE IN SIDE OF HUMAN LIFE TIME ", AND WHO ARE EXPLANE THEY ARE ESPASALE FOROM GOD.🤖💬🗨🕳🧠🙎♂️🙎♀️🧝♀️🧝♂️🗣👣🦲
FARRE MONO YOU KNOW HOW I WILL BE SOME TIME HAPPY SOME TIME UPSADE ,FOR YOU GOD PARAY HALLP ME ON TIME.😇❣💬🧝♂️🧝♀️👣🦲👨👩👧👦
*bomb bomb bomb bomb bomb*
Interesting story, it resonates because I'm interested in learning more science. Only that during the pandemic, I had already used physics as applied biotechnology to deal with the COVID. I haven't had any infections for over a decade and swear by it! With an understanding of the essential scientific method, I call my wildcard method that goes beyond the necessary through my own tacit experience that is thankfully relatively simple. So does that make me a rebel without an PHD too? Only that I am curious as I know we have what I call a the "green quantum fourth industrial revolution" which I have applied myself does the best of our western liberal "do-it-yourself"! Indeed, inner conviction that it is 50%+ complete strategy and tipping-point that is industrial and energy conscious that is certainly scientifically and economically literate, if you will!? Over and above this, I am sanguine that 100%+ will be reached! For I know this is about what I call the "statistically significant probability" that I discovered through make your own mistakes and learn your own lessons of which I cross-referenced with the best of the past for the best of the future!
Best of luck, mate.
Best of luck, bud. Extremely proud of you :)
I have a BS in electrical engineering and an MS in physics; and I have worked as a full-time physics professor and, presently, a full-time math professor. His story further encourages me to continue my research interests in math, theoretical physics and engineering. Thanks for sharing this.
Awesome! I want to become a professor of CS or Maths, and idk just seeing a random person on youtube who has already made the journey I plan to make is kind of inspiring.
@@abijo5052 I hope you got it
Don't stop educating yourself, kaninima, we need more educated and intelligent people in this world to help improve life!
Six years later, how’s the research coming along?
How can anyone NOT love Freeman Dyson?
By not loving him
I just had an epiphany seeing all those books around him. Im an engineering student and I almost never use a physical textbook when seeking information. I always look online or watch youtube videos to learn. Its sad in a way, as there will be no physical record of my years of studying other than the notebooks and diploma.
Soon the notebooks and physical diploma will go away too. Many students use a laptop entirely, and we've already started using block-chain technology for diploma verification.
I'll be totally honest, video and online forms of learning are SO much more efficient than physical books
@@dalirkosimov4623 it doesn't feel the same and doesn't give the same pause for reflection..
@@dalirkosimov4623 no
@@evanjameson5437 pause and reflection is up to the student and how dedicated they are. Having more accessible content anytime only boosts learning.
I just love Freeman Dyson and the way he said "...was an absolute genius..."!
Mohsen Ansari Javid where r u
Richard Feynman was a clown - Freeman Dyson 1:47
@@99bits46 lol
Probably the most amazing fact ive ever heard about anyone is that Freeman Dyson at the age of 6 worked out how many atoms are in the sun. Now for anyone with knowledge of basic mathematics thats not a hard thing to do. Find the formula, find the average density of the sun, plug one into the other. Volume = 4/3Pi r^3. But for a 6 year old to get that is friggin amazing!
This guy carries a handful of butterscotch candies in his pocket.
OMG yes!
Tooth decay, analagous to his environmental truth decay
@@dougr.2398 you gotta chill buddy
@@anthonylangston23 to make you and corporate anti-environmental people more comfortable? Never! Corporations subjected activists in Japan and America to death threats in the McCarthy era and beyond. Truth is unpleasant at times. Learn from it and deal with it appropriately.
@@dougr.2398 What even is your pitch?