I have just listened to both versions for the very first time in immediate succession, so hopefully I can contribute a different perspective when comparing the new version to the old. I definitely think the original version starts off better, it communicates a more complicated emotion than this one does. The original's opening feels like it has so much more going on under the surface, layers and layers of subtext that are flying completely over my head, but that I can sense are there. I didn't get that so much with this remake version. As the song progresses though, I think the remake surpasses the original, because it feels like this is what the original wanted to be if only they'd had a full orchestra to do it with at the time. I don't know that for certain though, maybe the simplicity was an artistic choice. It doesn't contribute much new, but I prefer it that way. I applaud the composers for resisting the temptation to try and make it their own, and instead simply expand on the original. I will say that this version nearly made me cry. The original did not.
Just like every other song on this soundtrack, the remake goes for EPIC ORCHESTRA every time. That does not make me cry, it makes me groan. It's like Bluepoint could simply not stay away from adding a choir to EVERYTHING, regardless of whether it fits or not. This ending track is supposed to be the 'bad ending' music, yet here it almost sounds heroic and triumphant.
Yea they left out a major chord progression too which was my favorite part, the part that would normally come after 1:48 but overall this theme is much better than some of the other ones, it at least captures the atmosphere of the OG really well.
@Dman [Formerly Sneed] But the original game still exists... Bluepoint didn't ruin anything. No matter what small changes they add into the remake, nostalgic players would always complain about it. By saying Bluepoint ruined the franchise you just sound like a spoiled kid.
great piece but i still tihink the original version gives way more focus on what you just did, it makes you feel powerful and filthy at the same time. this just feels like an outro
I get tonal whiplash from the pieces in this soundtrack, this song fits so well with the objectively bad ending but then you have music that doesn’t serve the tone of the game at all, still an amazing composition however.
Objectively bad ending? Who says the demons are bad and humans good? Both are relatively social constructs, I mean, DONT YOU UNDERSTAND!? No one wishes to go on...
Don't get me wrong but I honestly think that the original track holds up much better; the perfect simplicity of the original just isn't there anymore. Also this sounds waaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much like Dark Souls (a little bit more like Bloodborne, now that I think about it).
This sounds incredible even if it's a little worse than the original. This is by no means a bad song, the only people who think so are people who can't accept the fact that something new can be good too. The remake has way too much hate imo
Kind of a stagnant opinion, tbh. It is not a universal law, remade games can actually be good you know. I haven’t played Demon Souls nor the remake, but going from the consideration this particular remake might be worse than the original, to stating that From games are not to be remade because they would certainly be worse… it’s a bit too far lol
@@hiimshanawell being stagnant is a core element of the soul community. Always the same non written rule for the pvp, always shiting on everyone that doesn't use a pure strength build or maybe some miracle. The best example is elden ring when everyone started insulting everyone that used summon or particular build. Like the soul timeline the community is in a stagnant state when new things are rejected
@@cedricbordeleau3841 both are good brother, and sound effectively the same emotion wise, idg how people can blatantly and brainlessly hate the new tracks just for being slightly different
Bro... Go to another comment section and talk about other videos without thought. You literally said you never heard the OG theme, so why are you here?
![Demon's Souls (Remake) OST - Flamelurker Theme [EXTENDED]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vZiIbvyHn9o/mqdefault.jpg)
![Demon's Souls (Remake) OST - Flamelurker Theme [EXTENDED]](/img/tr.png)
This is probably the most underrated song ever in my opinion
This master peace of a song deserve a hek lot more views
"master peace"
For sure it does. Should be mainstream tbh
@@Moonscentedhunteryea, if only classical music was appreciated more
So beautiful, I can listen to this piece forever. Thanks for extended version.
if u havent heard the original i reccomend u check it out its better in every way in my opinion
I have just listened to both versions for the very first time in immediate succession, so hopefully I can contribute a different perspective when comparing the new version to the old. I definitely think the original version starts off better, it communicates a more complicated emotion than this one does. The original's opening feels like it has so much more going on under the surface, layers and layers of subtext that are flying completely over my head, but that I can sense are there. I didn't get that so much with this remake version.
As the song progresses though, I think the remake surpasses the original, because it feels like this is what the original wanted to be if only they'd had a full orchestra to do it with at the time. I don't know that for certain though, maybe the simplicity was an artistic choice. It doesn't contribute much new, but I prefer it that way. I applaud the composers for resisting the temptation to try and make it their own, and instead simply expand on the original.
I will say that this version nearly made me cry. The original did not.
But when the song progresses though that's where it completely lost the meaning of that ending. It's not supposed to be bombastic and epic lol
@@NinjapowerMS how is this epic lmao
Just like every other song on this soundtrack, the remake goes for EPIC ORCHESTRA every time. That does not make me cry, it makes me groan. It's like Bluepoint could simply not stay away from adding a choir to EVERYTHING, regardless of whether it fits or not. This ending track is supposed to be the 'bad ending' music, yet here it almost sounds heroic and triumphant.
@@neamraven having an orchestra/choir doesn't make it epic, the tone of this track Is still obviously sad
@@yab3146 It does make it epic. The tone is heroic and triumphant. It builds up towards that.
wow this song legit best song because it holds itself back abit and doesn't over do it
The beginning reminds me of Bioshock
I thought I was the only one until I saw your comment lol
@@berkaykurkcu no, you're not LOL
My man spitting strait facts
Same, big balls to you sir.
oh that violin at the beginning is just *chefs kiss*
absolutely beautiful. gives me chills every time.
The build up is god like......
I don't dislike this new version, is probably one of the better remade songs. But whenever I hear it I think of the original
Because the original is the creative one, this is a remix and there's a lot of remixes out there, BluePoint's is just another one.
Bravo! tão linda quanto a original 👏👏👏....
I can't understand why they would leave out the piano + violin crying together that the original song had. I *really* liked that part of the song!
It has but its not in the start
Yea they left out a major chord progression too which was my favorite part, the part that would normally come after 1:48 but overall this theme is much better than some of the other ones, it at least captures the atmosphere of the OG really well.
You’re not meant to understand.
@Dman [Formerly Sneed] But the original game still exists... Bluepoint didn't ruin anything. No matter what small changes they add into the remake, nostalgic players would always complain about it. By saying Bluepoint ruined the franchise you just sound like a spoiled kid.
It wouldn't be a different version if they made exactly like the original
hauntingly beautiful
I like this equally to the original version honestly. Great stuff
Perfeição...
Beautiful
I don't really see why people hate this as much as they do, it's beautiful.
Almost as good as the og. Jim approves
approved by jim?! 😳
@@topichu970 Jim the knight.
@@JimTheKnight01 amazing
@@topichu970 Jim thanks u
@@JimTheKnight01 Have a good day, Jim!
I like demon soul the story are so touching
The original will always be the best.
\[T]/
I think the original is better. But this one is amazing too !❤
great piece but i still tihink the original version gives way more focus on what you just did, it makes you feel powerful and filthy at the same time. this just feels like an outro
Can you please make an extended penetrator theme 🙏 🙏 🙏
I get tonal whiplash from the pieces in this soundtrack, this song fits so well with the objectively bad ending but then you have music that doesn’t serve the tone of the game at all, still an amazing composition however.
what u mean doesnt fit the tone
actually i get what u mean
Watch this. th-cam.com/video/7i2A_5UDqks/w-d-xo.html
Objectively bad ending? Who says the demons are bad and humans good? Both are relatively social constructs, I mean, DONT YOU UNDERSTAND!? No one wishes to go on...
@@dylanschmeichel2008 we live in a society
Okay so it get's really good at 2:18
I don’t know about that
I haven't played DeS,but I like this version more than the OG
God this song will always be so beautiful
Does this song play in the game? I never found it.
bad end credits
If only the maiden astrea remake ost got this treatment
Heh ratio
New lulaby for certain.
this is better than the original
When did they use this ost
Bad ending
Hit the Maiden in Black as she’s sealing the Old One.
Plays during the credits
Don't get me wrong but I honestly think that the original track holds up much better; the perfect simplicity of the original just isn't there anymore.
Also this sounds waaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much like Dark Souls (a little bit more like Bloodborne, now that I think about it).
Prefer the original version
Bu ses bozuk orijinali
nerede
This sounds incredible even if it's a little worse than the original. This is by no means a bad song, the only people who think so are people who can't accept the fact that something new can be good too. The remake has way too much hate imo
The remake songs aren’t bad it’s just some of them give different tones
3rd
This version is trash dude.
Everything in the original is better. You don’t remake From games. You remaster them. Otherwise you’ll just end up with something worse.
You don't remake or remaster games period. But, creativity is dead.
Kind of a stagnant opinion, tbh.
It is not a universal law, remade games can actually be good you know.
I haven’t played Demon Souls nor the remake, but going from the consideration this particular remake might be worse than the original, to stating that From games are not to be remade because they would certainly be worse… it’s a bit too far lol
@@hiimshanawell being stagnant is a core element of the soul community.
Always the same non written rule for the pvp, always shiting on everyone that doesn't use a pure strength build or maybe some miracle. The best example is elden ring when everyone started insulting everyone that used summon or particular build. Like the soul timeline the community is in a stagnant state when new things are rejected
first
Sounds like shit . I have never played demon souls , but ps3 version is more better than this
no
@Epsy _ no bait dudo, old demon souls is better
Ah yes. More better.
Youve never played demon's souls and you never will so dont come here thinking your opinion has any value
GTFO and go back to playing fortnite.
@@advcrim77 bruh
This sucks
Not good as the original, but still excellent
Wtf it’s one of the best songs in the game dumbass
wtf, its good
Go listen to the original if you haven’t. Much more emotion, and overall better song.
@@cedricbordeleau3841 both are good brother, and sound effectively the same emotion wise, idg how people can blatantly and brainlessly hate the new tracks just for being slightly different
Sucks lol
this sucks. I don't know what the original sound like and I dont care, but this sucks. that is all I have to say for now.
You came here for attention, so here's mine, take It.
thanks vic❤️
Love from brazil
Its okay man, its your opinion
Bro...
Go to another comment section and talk about other videos without thought. You literally said you never heard the OG theme, so why are you here?
@@Khmer_Socialist im here to annoy you