Even if Demon Souls was the first one, it had his own fights what were just different than the rest. Some were puzzle fights, others were against really aggresive foes, other times the environment played against, and with Astrea you encountered someone who didn't wanted to fight. Garl Vinland surpassed you, but he was not aggresive, and Astrea can't fight, just lay somewhere you can't reach without getting the plague. You even could shot at her at distance, hear her begs, and kill her just to see Garl Vinland lower his arms while feeling defeated. Demon Souls will get a remake, and i know there wil be differences, but i really wish to see this fight as similar it can be at the original, but with the capacities and limits that DS3 has. This deserves it.
@@flavioaugusto2202 I feel the exact same way. The music was a ton too epic for what the fights were. Anyway, thank you for replying! I've been wanting to get insight on people who made predictions and other comments.
I know I wasn't part of this conversation but I do feel they either missed the intent of the original songs implication on the situation or (and unfortunately more likely) they knew a lot of gamers just want their epic belting chorus's. Pretty much all of the remake is a improvement but this was by far the one area of the game the first will likely never be surpassed by (well, unless they remake it again in 15-years and someone on the team feels the same way).
This is what I loved from DsS that got lost in translation with the other titles in time. Boss fights that were varied, not the same button smashing Dodge-Dodge-Dodge-Attack-Dodge-Dodge-Dodge like NK or Twin Princes. Flamelurker was an awesome rollercoaster of a difficult fight, but if EVERYTHING was like that , it would lose the exciting part, I feel like. Astraea fight shocked me to my core and I remember it 14 years later. With NK and TP I just wanted the fight to end already and after 3 tries the feeling gets worse every try I die. The only ones that are saved from that feeling in ds3 for me are Friede, Midir and the dancer, the rest are just either normal or annoyingly boring.
i've been playing video games since i was 7 years old way back in 1992, and now i'm 30. Nothing will ever match the emotion i felt when fighting this for the first time on PS3.
This version and the original are so much better than the remakes. I was really disappointed with how 'epic' they tried making it sound, instead of sort of hopeless depressing feeling this and the original have
@@Teh0nlyMessiaH It's really sad, since BluePoint were so adament of keeping the soundtrack of Shadow of the Colossus Remake as authentic to the original as they could. Dunno why they decided to make Demon's Souls' soundtrack so bombastic compared to the original.
@@Roxaski2 "Astrara isn't the demon, it's the player for killing her." , it isn't that hard to figure out what they were trying to say, stop being a dick not everyone speaks perfect English in the world if they speak it at all.
@@Goldenkitten1 but sir it's really hard to me since i never played demon souls and just stumbled into this song by pure recommendation, so i ask you too just reprimand the other party not so harsh after all no one knows the true condition of the other party
@@Asphyx12 Then enjoy the song. Why would you be trying to understand lore from an Engrish TH-cam comment? If that's your intent there are sites that go into excruciating detail for you. *ANYTIME* someone says "English please?" (or pls/x) it's an insult, that's not me being politically correct or a white knight, it's literally the words people use online to insult someone over their lack of English skills regardless of if it was a mistake or the individual is not a fluent English speaker. You'll find the phrase on pretty much any comment that has broken English on social media sites it's that pervasive.
You... You killed him, didn't you?
Very well. I can no longer resist you. Do as you like. Take your precious demon soul...
still my favorite boss in all the souls seriese. the one bossfight where you question your alignment. demon souls needs a remastered or a sequel
FUNNY YOU SHOULD ASK.....
Valscer forr reeaaalllllll!!!
@@xgreedxx Here, all our wishes have come true. th-cam.com/video/2TMs2E6cms4/w-d-xo.html
radiant chocolate hero umbasa!
You had a heart of gold and let them take it from you...
I understood that reference 😅
@@nemmy7007 i believe that's exactly what Stockpile Thomas was talking about...
@@bigroxxor420 live long enough to become the demon yourself.
They didn't take it from you. You ripped it out and threw it at their corpse after barging into their home and slaughtering them, unprovoked...
It’s awful
Even if Demon Souls was the first one, it had his own fights what were just different than the rest. Some were puzzle fights, others were against really aggresive foes, other times the environment played against, and with Astrea you encountered someone who didn't wanted to fight. Garl Vinland surpassed you, but he was not aggresive, and Astrea can't fight, just lay somewhere you can't reach without getting the plague. You even could shot at her at distance, hear her begs, and kill her just to see Garl Vinland lower his arms while feeling defeated.
Demon Souls will get a remake, and i know there wil be differences, but i really wish to see this fight as similar it can be at the original, but with the capacities and limits that DS3 has. This deserves it.
Tell me, now that the remake is out, how do you feel? Did the remake do the fight justice?
@@okayoni6342 Yes, it does. Except for the song, wich in my opinion sounds a little too much epic, for a fight that is so sad.
@@flavioaugusto2202 I feel the exact same way. The music was a ton too epic for what the fights were.
Anyway, thank you for replying! I've been wanting to get insight on people who made predictions and other comments.
I know I wasn't part of this conversation but I do feel they either missed the intent of the original songs implication on the situation or (and unfortunately more likely) they knew a lot of gamers just want their epic belting chorus's. Pretty much all of the remake is a improvement but this was by far the one area of the game the first will likely never be surpassed by (well, unless they remake it again in 15-years and someone on the team feels the same way).
This is what I loved from DsS that got lost in translation with the other titles in time. Boss fights that were varied, not the same button smashing Dodge-Dodge-Dodge-Attack-Dodge-Dodge-Dodge like NK or Twin Princes. Flamelurker was an awesome rollercoaster of a difficult fight, but if EVERYTHING was like that , it would lose the exciting part, I feel like. Astraea fight shocked me to my core and I remember it 14 years later. With NK and TP I just wanted the fight to end already and after 3 tries the feeling gets worse every try I die. The only ones that are saved from that feeling in ds3 for me are Friede, Midir and the dancer, the rest are just either normal or annoyingly boring.
i've been playing video games since i was 7 years old way back in 1992, and now i'm 30.
Nothing will ever match the emotion i felt when fighting this for the first time on PS3.
This has been stuck in my head for days.
It has been intermittently stuck in my head for years. That is not a complaint.
This song is just a masterpiece. Thanks for uplaoad that !
“Ye covetous ones, let it be known. We shall defend our heart and home to the death.” -Garl Vinland-
dude really said "Ye" 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
It’s archaic English, “ye” is the plural for “thou” which means “you”.
@@matthewmartinez3907 I'm just messing with you, but I also love you 😍 👀
I can't wait to hear how this holds up compared to the remake's version of this theme.
The remake is good but Alex version is godly
I have some bad news for you chief.
This version and the original are so much better than the remakes. I was really disappointed with how 'epic' they tried making it sound, instead of sort of hopeless depressing feeling this and the original have
@@Teh0nlyMessiaH It's really sad, since BluePoint were so adament of keeping the soundtrack of Shadow of the Colossus Remake as authentic to the original as they could. Dunno why they decided to make Demon's Souls' soundtrack so bombastic compared to the original.
@@Teh0nlyMessiaH "oooh the remake OST are better than the original versions 🤢"
Prepare to cry...
Thank you!
This is a sanctuary for the lost...and wretched. There is nothing here for you to pillage or plunder. Please, leave quietly...
I can listen to this all day
god why am i getting square enix vibes from this masterpiece?
Job well done to both of ya!
The one and only boss I didn’t want to kill. I was the bad guy in their eyes. She just wanted to comfort that lost.
cool
Ah yes everyday sadness
It is a shame that we couldn't show them talisman of beasts.
astraea are not the demon the demon are nost character good remix
English please?
@@Roxaski2 "Astrara isn't the demon, it's the player for killing her." , it isn't that hard to figure out what they were trying to say, stop being a dick not everyone speaks perfect English in the world if they speak it at all.
@@Goldenkitten1 but sir it's really hard to me since i never played demon souls and just stumbled into this song by pure recommendation, so i ask you too just reprimand the other party not so harsh after all no one knows the true condition of the other party
@@Asphyx12 Then enjoy the song. Why would you be trying to understand lore from an Engrish TH-cam comment? If that's your intent there are sites that go into excruciating detail for you.
*ANYTIME* someone says "English please?" (or pls/x) it's an insult, that's not me being politically correct or a white knight, it's literally the words people use online to insult someone over their lack of English skills regardless of if it was a mistake or the individual is not a fluent English speaker. You'll find the phrase on pretty much any comment that has broken English on social media sites it's that pervasive.
Unfortunately, I have succeeded