ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.พ. 2025
- Donald Trump's promised crackdown on irregular migration has sparked controversy halfway around the world, in India. Images of Indian deportees being flown in a US military aircraft with their hands and feet bound prompted opposition lawmakers to demand an explanation. The issue has erupted just as Prime Minister Narendra Modi prepares to meet with Trump to improve relations with the US.
#migration #india #usa
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
For more news, analysis and background information on the German election 2025 go to our dedicated page: www.dw.com/en/...
Follow DW on social media:
►Instagram: / dwnews
►TikTok: / dwnews
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
Subscribe: www.youtube.co...
do not enter US without visa ,A valid visa is required for all US citizens traveling to India, regardless of the purpose of travel.
Simply no one go to the US 😊
Was it applicable to the colonisers that came to America who took the land of native Americans and prosecuted them. What was the reason for the decline in population of native Americans there if we research further a story of mass genocide will be unfolded.
@@Patrioticindian-c6w Welcome to 2025 grandpa 🤪 You must be over 400 years old!
That visa will take his lifetime to get accepted 😂
If you don't want to be shackled don't stay there illegally.
I don't understand, what is stopping the Indian Government from sending their own aircraft and bring back their people in humane conditions?
Don't wanna waste our tax money on this.
Our tax money should only go to politicians wallets
This is a wastage of money
time. the budget must be decided, then allocated, then the planes hired and supplied. it cant be done in a day. usa could at least talk about that and agreed on a timeline.
yes
They have no money
Isn't India deporting Bengali's and other minorities from neighboring countries OR they think this only apply to USA. They made themselves suffer and humiliate on the way to US and wouldn't leave voluntarily.
Was India by and large not convinced Trump would be a President in their favour..?! 🧐
do politicians lie?
yes
do people believe that bs en masse?
yes
any further questions?
No?
Only opposition is making this ruckus because Budget session is going on and they have nothing to say bad about the Budget. So, this issue is like a distraction
It is, India will gladly take back potential workers and the educated.
It takes a genius to antagonise allies.
Why are they so surprised?
You broke into the country illegally and treated as criminals when deported.
White man came from a far land. To the great Indiana nation illegally the américas. North américas And kill the great Indian nation..is not there land it's the Indian nation. Look what is happeing to the hispanic ppl
No one surprise , that's a opposition not ruling party
U can't put shackles on their feet, they r not animals.
@anonymousman2521 then tell Indian govt to send their plane to get them back with luxury
It's politics by opposition parties trying to whip up the emotions. These guys who got deported have lost 5-7k usd to gangsters who enticing them to do this.
Ask India how they treat their neighbours' countries.
How do they treat them? I don't think they deported millions of afghans like pakistan
Ask United States how they treat their non neighbours even neighbours.
Why stop at that? Ask how people from the made up lower castes are treated there.
Trump is a nationalist and only cares about his own people, which is kinda good! India should take Ane example. @@shahnavazvhora2286
India has problem with every country that it borders.
I am a Legal US immigrant from India and am treated with dignity in the USA. What do you expect after violating a nation's security-driven entry laws and violating their laws? Do you expect 'Dignity' after becoming a criminal? May be then stay back in India.
Don't forget that the guy implementing this is also a criminal.
@@rickcrammond6330 Your'e confused, FJB and his entire crime family is out of power.
Indians thought they are American ally.
Exactly but they need to don't make more children that's enough 2b people that's too much
@1.4billion65 nope America don't have any ally
I noticed they were still in handcuffs when they were in Indian custody
I believe the UAE has been treating Indians very very badly for years. Why are they not standing up against the UAE?
Brilliant get them out. Illegal is illegal!
You don’t exist 😘
@ oh but I do
Illegal isn’t the same as criminal.
You really need to educate yourself.
They did illegal activities and I have no sympathy for them
indian (immigrant) ..E..N..V..Y..I..N..G another indian immigrant
What activities?
@@abdiqaniahmadhe us not an immigrant. He lives in his own country. Abdol go do your 4th prayer to kaba
As an Indian I approve this message
@@hazelflatts7403 entering the U.S. illegally for one.
What they expected? Rose shower?
Most ex-British colonial countries still manage to retain a decent level of civilised behaviour that the USA, as an infant culture a mere 250 years old, has yet to achieve.
Human rights violation
Do any of you want to be 35,000 feet in the air in an airplane full of unshackled criminals? I bet not. The safety of our air crews is much more important that what YOU think of it.
To get treated with dignity by the "beacon of democracy" , "the shining City in the hill" you absolute ...
Criminals don't get human rights, and foreigners don't get citizens rights.
Is really skyward simple. If you want your rights, obey the law. Law is what creates your precious rights.
Criminals are criminals, treated like criminals for harming the nation they were in.
If you are so anti-criminal, why did you vote for Trump?
@ because he is not a criminal, but illegally prosecuted by criminals inside the government. Malicious prosecution is a criminal act on multiple levels.
Trump is a convicted criminal. So what is your point?
Ilegal imigrants are not criminals.Trump is ...
Were they in the US illegally? I’m from Ireland, I have lived in other countries……legally. It isn’t that hard. If any of my Irish brothers and sisters are in countries illegally, I would expect them to be deported.If that means in chains (because they performed an illegal act) then so be it. Might make sure they do not reoffend. If you can’t live in a country legally you should probably start taking a look at why that might be. And before anyone kicks off, no it is not racism in remand we have imported a lot of foreigners who are NOT working. They have come to live off the state, which means. Tax payer money which is meant to be used to improve the living conditions of the people who pay said tax money
Do you feel people should be chained for parking tickets?
Only opposition is making this ruckus because Budget session is going on and they have nothing to say bad about the Budget. So, this issue is like a distraction
Massive Irish illegal immigration in the 80s and 90s to the U.S.
Do your Irish "brothers and sisters" make 2 dollars for a day's labor?
Do you really think "No racism" would cover for the racist rant that followed? Are you that slow?
It’s not just Mexicans. It’s Indians a lot other nationalities.
🤷🏻♂️🤣🤣🤣
1:20 Dignity? What about the dignity of my country when they broke our laws?
You elected a criminal 😂😂😂😂oh please
@hazelflatts7403 progressive talking points rather than countering my idea? Weak. Very weak.
@mikethomas4598 you have no ideas. Your country is be run by a convicted criminal who is turning the world against your country. Dignity, who has dignity? Your own laws are being broken by your criminal president and his rich buddies and you talk about dignity 🤣🤣🤣
@@mikethomas4598i guess he is already countering your idea but you couldn't get it
ITS AN INSULT THAT THEY ARE IN ANOTHER COUNTRY.
@@nathancurtis-w3u Simmer down. Also, wut? 😂
you mean on our planet?
To who?
Imagine, had Trump's own grandfather not been illegal to the USA, we wouldn't be putting up with the maniac now.
It's an insult to call the US a democracy.
Where was the respect of india when its people came illegally into the USA?
If you exclude natives, you are all immigrants..
Working for cheap, precariously... how generous!
Yes they are illegal and must be deported but also some of them suffered due to fraud travel agents and agencies.
@@jeffreyjones8531 what are you talking about and bring receipts. TIA
@ I did bring them they came back to you in India cuffed . Have a good day.
It is politics by opposition in india. The entire illegal immigration should be cracked down. Each one of them have lost 5-7 k USD to gangs
Hopefully Modi is not like US Congressmen to lick Trump's you know what.
Thousands of Indians have been persecuted and have died in the middle east in the last 50 years . Why hasn't successive Govts not taken up the issue with the Gulf nations concerned?
Million of them died because they don't have medicine and vaccine I see one poor little girl she died because they don't gives her free vaccine even iran even iran gives free vaccine for children
What do they expect? A business class flight?
I don’t know why they are so upset they’ve been doing that to Mexicans for years
When a country has a joker like jayshanker as its external affairs minister....this is what will happen.
This is NOT designed to be a pleasurable experience.
Why cant DW get a good reporter in India?
An explanation to those not from India-
The opposition's job is to just pick up any issues that they can find to , they really don't give a f. All politicians send their children to elite universities abroad, their wealth completely insulates them from this. It's all part of political theatre
Trump & Modi have good relations and Trump campaigns for the Indian-American vote. Those who vote for Trump tend to also support Modi and his ilk. They're now on a mission to save face because Modi has built this(nationalism) image of what the perception of India is on the world stage- as a well-respected formidable superpower
No one cares about the indignity that those on the planes faced. The indignity faced in India is 10x worse, whether from the police, the government, schools, infrastructure,.......
Understood! But we are going to be outspoken and defend this situation.
Not only are the shackles on military planes cruelly disrespectful, but they are also wastefully expensive.
I'm sorry, DOGE is too busy cutting some of the most effective government spending (basic research, USAID) to worry about this. Please contact your local teenager to pass along your concerns to Elon.
@@szurketaltos2693this is GOLD ❤❤❤😂😂😂
@ your estimated wait time is. Nine. Thousand. Years. Please hold.
Lawless fraudsters do not deserve dignity. They violated the US security-driven laws to enter USA. Would you ever treat, with dignity, someone who enters into your home by stealth and stays there without your consent?? Ask these protesters that first?
We have plenty on hand I can assure you. Do any of you want to be 35,000 feet in the air in an airplane full of unshackled criminals? I bet not. The safety of our air crews is much more important that what YOU think of it.
India don’t even back bone to question srilanka after killing over 1000 fisherman who fish close to srilankan water
Actually, it's embarrassing to stay there illegally . Whats the point in protesting?
Trump and Modi, two faces of the same coin. Now we just need to pull the popcorn out of the shelf, and see how two nationalists deal with their same ideas but different origins. It’s going to be fun these years watching all the extreme right leaders have to deal with each other.
Irregular migration? Is that the new term for illegal immigration?
Illegal = breaking the law
But it's not always criminal, there are three aspects of "illegality"
Administrative = which immigration offenses fall under, requiring only administrative proceedings
Civil = minimum requirement would be prepoderance of evidence, requires legal/judicial proceedings
Criminal = guilt beyond reasonable doubt, requires legal/judicial proceedings
Edit: added some procedural details for clarity 😊
Do you really think that any Trump (or Modi) supporter has enough brain cells to understand this?
The safety of the crews on those airplanes are most important. Do you want to fly at 35,000 in a situation with an airplane full of criminals?
Most Americans are products of multiple cultures and countries. They try to do best for USA and for the place where they came from. Trump father family came from Germany and mother from Scotland. Harris father was from Jamaica and mother from India. This is a unique place for hopeful and helpless. America is not isolated. USA enjoys influence all over the world through this vital connection. Only difference is arrival time.
'No bobs for you!' - Donald Trump... probably 😂
was anyone actually hurt or only feelings?
40 hours in shackles? And you think that wouldn’t hurt?! Shackles aren’t handcuffs 😢😢😢
They hurt their own feelings on the way to the US with long expensive journey.
They made themselves suffer and humiliate on the way to US and wouldn't leave respectfully and voluntarily.
WHERE IS VIVEK RAMASWAMY, KASH PATEL & ALL INDIANS WHO VOTED FOR TRUMP
YOU REAP WHAT YOU SOW ✅️✅️✅️✅️
It's like saying all arabs who voted for trump deserve his gaza stance, don't be ridiculous
They are developing America as Indians while their country languishing in poverty😂
Dear, Most Indians support what Trump is doing, He is responsible for America not India and he is doing what is required for America
Did you expect 1st class? India should send planes like Colombia.
Not indian govt only the opposition leader 😂😂
And the minister of external affairs… before commenting, at least watch the video man…
@@esztieli he had to react bcz opposition forced him to react if u watched the parliament meeting u will know from start ruling goverment said illegal is illegal and they deserve the punishment
@@esztieli see the drama they 6:56 they did lol at the end he had to react
@@esztieli he only replied when brainless opposition ask this on the parliament. Imagine sneaking illegally into a country and don't being treated as a prisoner. Then how should they treated with a guard of honour 🤣🤣🤣
Don't break the law, you won't be in handcuffs.
As a world citizen I want to offer that this treatment by the U.S. government of Indian deportees should not be experienced as an embarrassment by Indians, but seen as inhumane by the U.S. government and condemned by all world citizens as absolutely unacceptable.
This world citizen deems it acceptable
In the USA and Canada, all people arrested, including citizens of these countries, are handcuffed. The outrage is in support of people who broke the law. I don't understand the outrage. Why are criminals supported and not law-abiding citizens in their countries? In my generation criminals were dealt with under the law and law-abiding citizens supported the law.
Remember, Trump is a criminal, you are supporting him.
Misleading news. Its indian opposition not the government.
No one is taking this as serious news in India but news agencies are trying to overhype this.
How blind have you gone! Doesn't matter if anyone takes seriously or not. No injustice should go unanswered! The national poet has said:
যদি তোর ডাক শুনে কেউ না আসে, তবে একলা চলো রে! (If nobody takes heed, then walk alone)
All other countries deportee treated the same way for security reasons
If only Indian Americans en masse voted for their own interests instead of his, this wouldn’t have happened. FAFO 😔
People without visas and the right of abode in the USA were being deported under Biden and all other administrations. So, yes, it would have happened, but in a different and more economical and humane way.
Are they surprised?
Why not just come legally?????? 😂😂😂😂
What has the government of India to do with this?
@ huh?
India is the world largest democracy, a developed country, the leader in space and military technology, and the world no.1 superpower. So why are they fleeing the country?
Not irregular, but illegal
It's for their own safety to prevent them from fighting amongst themselves and getting injured while in transit. Nothing to be embarrassed about. Anyway they're going back home to INDIA and not sent to some prison to do hard labor for life. They should be happy.
Opposition doesn't have anything to do so they make cheap obligation
Okk saar
I don't think anyone would want to be at 35,000 feet up in the air with an airplane full of criminals. It is for the safety of the airplane crews that they remain shackled.
Wow, we catch you breaking our laws, we're kind enough to give you guys a pass & fly you strait home, avoiding a lenghthy & costly stay in jail with dangerous criminals, and yet still you complain.
I'm Indian. US just did right. ILLIGAL is ILLIGAL
Finally there is too many Indians in America
Rejoice, those has not been sent to Guantanamo
Boohoo
They are lucky to only be deported for breaking the law. Some countries throw you in jail for 20 years ! If india doesnt like this , they should pay the cost of sending a plane and getting their citizens back to india !
Germany should watch and learn.
Where are the "Proud to be Indian" commentators?🤭🤣😂😅
also where are those " Moo-di and Dump are the best friends forever " comments 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@ArmyMan2303-n3d 🤣
Bots talking
@@vikaskasaudhan900 P@jeet talking 💩
@@vikaskasaudhan900 says the bot
If you violate the law of a country, then you are consider a criminal of that country! Hence you will be treated as criminal! Lucky, you are not going to jail! Also you save money for going back to your home country for not paying air fare!
We can expect the same mistreatment with our people from a German Hair cutter illegal immigrant .
The opposition is Like School Protest..
Can DW do a report how the US ICE manage to work so fast knowing how slow Courts in US process is.
😅
They have an express lane!
@xx_Joker_xx I think we should wait for mainstream media such as DW or France24 to report it.
👮♂️
@@kongthai.. This is DW.
W.T.F. You can't have a bunch of criminals unrestrained. My GOODNESS this is not Con-Air
Dont cross any international border illegally. Period!!
👍🏻😁😁😁😁👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻❤️
What they want red carpet and Military leaders saluting them ? 😂
😂😂😂😂
When you try to enter other country illegally it is a great insult to the country..
So Indians feelings are more important than security of US personnel?
Indian opposition reacts not the Modi govt who is a stooge PM
When they said strong crack down to illegal migration it just mean Shaikh migration
But Indians were trumps biggest supporters. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Cry me a river of deceit.
Ok India now you know what will happen if you don't follow our laws so lets not let it happen again !
😂😂😂 no preferential treatment for you 😂😂😂😂😂
Thats the point. Don't come here unwelcomed, and you won't be disrepected.
In shackles? WTH???
You don't want people you're deporting to take control of the airplane, so you have to secure them during the flight. If you don't want to be deported, follow immigration laws.
Thought India and US had a strategic comprehensive partnership.
Keep thinking criminals don't belong in shackles. 😂😂😂
What can anyone expect from a crazy narcissist like trump!!!
Illegal entry to any country isnt acceptable
why are they sending out the peaceful people first and dont seem to be checking exactly who they are sending out .
Lol, Indian government pretty much said they were illegal immigrants and just opposition say it's bad😂😂😂.
You weren't listening properly. The opposition party also clearly stated that they were illegal immigrants and that they understood a strong response. The opposition is to the way in which it is conducted, not to the fact that it is happening. I understand that the Trump regime is using military planes for effect and to act as a deterrent, but those planes are not the most efficient and chartered flights as used under the Biden administration are likely far cheaper and less of a burden on the American tax payer. Of course, the average MAGA mob member doesn't realise that their taxes are paying for these flights.
They should be honoured to be able to take a military plane. Civilians do not get the opportunity to take those planes as if they're commercial. I am sure it's a good experience for the deportees.😊
Colonial behavior never leaves 💀
Indias target should to develop its cities into livable, employment providing metropolitans... opportunities during developing its cities itself will provide lot of jobs to its people
It's a security risk if you don't properly secure the transfer of deportees, hmmm a good Idea, send a contracted charter flight paid by the Indian government or send an Indian Airlines to pick up the deported Indian passengers. Peace
Nothing better can be expected from USA
This is a very insulting move on the US Immagration. I support India. ✌🏻
If you have hundreds of lawbreakers on a plane and no more than ten security officers to monitor them, you must find a way to secure these undocumented immigrants. While I don’t condone the use of handcuffs and leg shackles, I understand that security jobs can be potentially very dangerous, and measures must be taken to ensure their safety.
Good
huhh!!, insult to indians when they commit a crime ? Don't understand , how can you say this? If the other religious groups which commit crime were treated this way, none would be objected
How should they deport people who breaks the law by entering and staying illegally putting garland in their necks
The ambassador should ask for coordination. If India objects to the military flights it could send its own aircraft to pick up the deportees. The way Colombia did.
Why should India send for criminals , they have broken the law . India is treating them some one who break the law so it’s not caring about them
This is just a show for Trump supporters. They are filled with hate and love this stuff even though it’s costing US 10x as much to use military planes but again they love this stuff
YT censoring my post no insults no hate speech
_“salty salty salty”_ jumping up and down
Human rights should be respected
Does that include the human rights of the host country?
@cheesengyeap524 all humans deserve respect doesn't matter if they are legal or illegal .
Human rights should be respected in India too UNLESS you think only US and western countries are obliged by it.
For what
@@human8454 but you said different things about Pakistan