Indian Students getting Swept Up in Donald Trump's Deportation Drive? | Vantage | Palki Sharma |N18G
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.พ. 2025
- Indian Students getting Swept Up in Donald Trump's Deportation Drive? | Vantage with Palki Sharma | N18G
Reports say that Indian Students in the US are becoming collateral damage amidst President Donald Trump's Mass Deportation Drive. The Indian students entered the US legally, on valid visas. But they say they are now being subjected to more frequent questioning from US immigration officials. They say uniformed officers have been questioning them more frequently, and demanding to see their student IDs and documents. Is Trump's deportation drive becoming an all out purge of migrants, irrespective of whether they're in the US legally or not?
---
Donald Trump | Deportation | Indian Migrants | Mass Deportation | US | Trump Deportation Plan | Trump | Donald Trump Big Decisive Announcement | Donald Trump 100 Days | Donald Trump to Do List | Donald Trump Elections | Donald Trump to Do List 2024 | Firstpost | World News | News Live | Vantage | Palki Sharma | News
#donaldtrump #deportation #indianimmigrants #migrants #massdeportation #usa #trump #deportation #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.c...
If students are working outside campus and or full time, when they have been granted visa to work part time only on campus, then yes they broke the law. It's not discrimination when you get caught for breaking the laws. If you can't respect laws of the country you are in for study, then yes, that country has the right to deport you. It's as simple as that.
Dude they are paying thrice the college fees, this own wife Melania is illegal 😂 . Stop bullshit
well not if the cost of living has gone much more up, that its not enough to sustain themselves, they are doing this as a last resort most indians go to college and work at the same time, its not feasible to do with 20hrs of work time, they have so many more people who are doing more illegal stuff, instead you target the thing you need to clear out in the last does show discrimination of indians.
Indian students are in the USA to seek Citizenship for a better life than India has to offer. India has dozens of Good universities , so why don't Indian students study there ? Self Explanatory .
well said
It's discrimination when they target you because you look a certain way. They aren't targeting white immigrants even if they are in the country illegally. Is it ok for illegal white immigrants to stay in the country?
Well Indian student are not going there on for study purpose. They are looking for the PR and green card.
Now canadian and australia economy is already struggle so they thought usa is best choice for them.
But they forget that west will treat them as a third world country citizens.
Well this is my personal opinion.
Exactly 💯 they do the same in the UK..
They treat a visa like a passport to citizenship, but definitely not studying because most of them overstay..
Canada will straight reject indian visas. No questions asked. That's the issue not the economy.
💯
With 30 lakh, they can enjoy in India🇮🇳
Very good decision. Respect the law of the land and dont expect your government to back you up, save you when you break law, or commit crime
Most of them aren't students , they are part time students only , they are in US for only work .
WTF?? If someone breaks the law.....he/she goes. There is nothing called 'hardened' or 'soft' criminals. I find it dumb to say somebody broke the law to make ends meet. I am not sure what will eventually come out of this ordeal. But I hope it makes the younger generation in India appreciate the value of freedom, respect and dignity they enjoy in India (being a Citizen). These Western countries will NEVER treat them with respect. There will always be discrimination.
Tell that to all the business executives that don't get a criminal record when they break the law.
Mrs Sharma you report is totally false misleading, this students who suppose tobe studying but instead working in Hotel/Motels, Gas stations, grocery stores and restaurants.
Sharma is a fake journalist promoting anti Trump narrative. Watch all her episodes.
also in brothels
Indian students are in the USA chasing the Almighty Dollar . They have no interest to study .
Go chase Indian dream not Americans dream. Stay in your own home please.
They would if they could print infinite money like US😂🤡
Alia hashimi 😂? .
An migrant telling other migrant go back 😂
Why do so many people want to leave India? I think that's the number 1 question the Indian government should be asking!
Same Should Happen In CANADA . Too Many HINDUSTANIS In Canada Too , Claiming To Be Students , But Doing DoorDash 16 Hours a Day ...😂😂😂
Thank True-dog for creating the mess
Funny how there are thousands of young military looking Chinese men illegally crossed the border and NOT ONE WORD ABOUT FINDING THEM
Nothing wrong; every student is not legitimate
When people are on any visa, they are not citizens and are fully subject to the conditions under which the visa is issued. Entry to another country is ALWAYS A PRIVILEGE NOT AN ENTITLEMENT! If the rules are violated wilfully, the students are choosing to expose themselves to action. “chasing the US dream” is no excuse for doing things that are not permitted. Pl stop this victimhood game!
USA 🇺🇸 🌎 country born of colonialism and slavery is making rules 😂😂😂
if they have the proper documentation and arent doing anything illegal I don't think they have anything to worry about
Good decision trump ❤
What about the Indian dream, do Indians have dreams that involve their country.
Great job.. President..
Great job by going after legal people? You are a not smart
Biggest lie told in this story is that they’re picking people out because of what they look like. If you’re living with someone who’s getting arrested for being here illegally and you’re here illegally you’re gonna get taken with them.
You think they gonna check it they will handcuff and send them here no one cares abt the law 😂
Wouldn't the Native Americans consider all else in America as illegal immigrants?🙄
Your deportation drive will build india superpower, because they have built US.
@ that’s OK because the India’s people are friends and we’re totally fine with helping to educate them and send them home to make their homeland a better place.
This is project 2025 they are trying to make the USA white again, truss they are not sending any germans or west Europeans back they want more of them.
India needs 25,% more understanding that these Indians got a free flight home.Next time,India should pay for it.
US and all the anglo countries should pay back the $65T. Thats 65 with twelve zeros. This was the money stolen from India and invested in the MNCs of US,UK,Australia,Canada,NZ, according to Oxfam report. Return them back please. Cost of 1 air ticket would be $500, deduct that fkn amount and pay back the rest. Thanks
@@AnoNymous-i1o Well,why don't you ask them for that money? Why all these "they should"? No need to be silent,stand up for your belief. Why are you complaining on TH-cam,that makes no sense.
As an Indian I am baffled by their audacity to raise discrimination charges at an uninvited party!
STUDENTS WHO STAYED OVER THEIR VISA
LIKE ELON MUSK DID
Yes. During the 1990’s Elon and his brother Kim Musk were here illegally after they withdrew from their university. Kim went to visit their mother in Canada 🇨🇦 and when he tried to re-enter into the country 🇺🇸 fortunately border guards stopped him. Kim found a way to illegally sneak back into the country. Afterwards, he and Elon got spooked 😱 and they obtained professional help to stay here.
Glory!!! After so much struggles I now own a new house with an influx of $155,000.00 every month God has kept to his words,my family is happy again everything is finally falling into place. God bless America.
Hello how do you make such monthly??
I'm a born Christian and sometimes I feel so down 🤦of myself because of low finance but I still believe in God 🙏.
Thanks to my co-worker whom God used to give a great opportunity of crossing paths with 'Mrs DEBORAH LEE CLERK
She's a licensed broker here in the states 🇺🇸 and finance advisor.
Yes!! That's exactly her name (Deborah Lee Clark) so many people have recommended highly about her and am just starting with her from Ottawa Canada🇨🇦
This is a definition of God's unending provisions for his people. God remains faithful to his words. I receive this for my household
Not just Indian students. Everybody from all over the world. Don’t be like CNN.
No, they are not targeting white immigrants.
Lies those students are not going to school, they are rather doing jobs
I am do not understand madam why Indian people going to USA after all now India is the world teacher😅😅 this is says Indian government
Palki my brother is in USA too on student visa since 2 years. He says he’s not worried and there’s a lot of rumours going around. People who came legally with a student visa have nothing to worry about, absolutely nothing. This is all over hyped.
After finished studies, students go back to help india develop & modernise no??
They drive taxis, work in gas stations, shops.
@rivertonhigh-v4t so they're not students but opportunists stealing america jobs omg
They keep lingering in US under ANY AND EVERY pretext.. higher education is merely an excuse to get their foot in the door! That’s fairly obvious!
In other words, they should've been treated like Delta first class flight passengers and serving them 3 course meals during the flight. 🙄🙄🙄
This is karma for Vivek Rather Swarthy, Nikki Halley, Patel Kash, and all the other Indian-Americans who voted MAGA.
ICE IS DOING THEIR JOB WHICH IS NORMAL CHECKING THE IMMIGRANTS
ARE THEY CHECKING THE WHITE IMMIGRANTS? HOW WOULD THEY TELL THE DIFFERENCE? YOU BIGOTED IDIOT!
As an Indian who has lived in Canada for 10 years let me tell you that ‘chalta he’ attitude is not here in Canada and US.Be very careful and don’t break rules small or big. Working more than 20 hours per week as a student itself is breach of student visa rules and is ground for deportation or work permit rejection next time you apply.
This is called karma. Modi govt in India is harassing minorities nd now pay back for Indians around the world.
This keeps popping up in my feed and I've come to love their indignation. 😂
Because they know they won’t leave after school.
Bharati Students please note, I am a born in Bharat woman. I am an American Citizen and worker legitimately. I have full rights in USA. I am terrorized all day and every day in USA. In my house, when I am at work or going to get groceries, people break into my house spoil my food and 2 times poison my food. They break my things, furniture, steal my jewelry, id documents, clothes disconnect and sabotage my appliances and electrical wiring in my house. THIS IS WHAT AN INDIAN WOMAN GOES THROUGH EVERY DAY IN TEXAS IN USA. DO YOU STILL WANT TO COME HERE? WHY? I AM NOT AN INDIAN CITIZEN. I HAVE NO CHOICE. YOU ARE IN YOUR COUNTRY AND YOU HAVE A CHOICE. STAY IN YOUR COUNTRY. EAT ROTI AND DRINK WATER IT IS STILL BETTER IN YOUR OWN COUNTRY.
Infosys fired 700 new joiners
That strange situation appears due to a great offer from Mr Trump to his "Dear Friend" Modi for the poor Indians living in the US!! 😲🤔🤣
Government of USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and all other nations should reiterate and clarify that student visa is limited to studies and not a stamp for permanent residency and citizenship....And all money minded immigration consultants using unfair means to show big dreams to aspiring students should be criminalized and brought to justice....
That is because these students in the US are not supposed to work outside the Campus or even if they are working outside the Campus it should be in an organization in the field of their study after gaining approval from the university and getting a CPT card which authorizes them to work 20 hours per week legally. Many of these students don't adhere to this law and go and work in Gas stations which is truly forbidden according to the terms and conditions of the F-1 visa, there by again making it ILLEGAL. So it is true that they will be subject to deportation if they are found to be working at gas stations, grocery stores and other places which is either not in line with their course and is not apporved by the University.
Anything done against the law is a crime doesn't matter your nationality.❤
The students come on legal F1 visas which does not let them work outside. Also, when they go for the visa they sign papers that they have enough funds to sustain during their studies. Working outside is illegal and anything illegal is criminal, which is what they are looking for.
So they are not paying taxes like every legal american and taking there jobs while getting paid under the table it's good for business owner for paying less not for the country
We can’t deport Bangladeshis in 25 years … but see how this guys started deporting writhing few days … who is true Nationalist!?
He and his party : Let's make America more down . 😂
Oh no billions of dollars in revenue from Indian scam center will be at risk 😱
If you are in a place as a guest you must follow the guest’s rules or they will kick you out. Does India allow anyone to come in to the country and act as any way they want. If not, stop talking BS! Follow proper immigration laws and regulations and follow your dreams the correct way. If you do sky will be the limit!
Wow wow GREAT NEWS. TRUMP💪💪💪👍
To work in America without the Right Visa is also a Crime. Keep that in mind
Not blaming Trump for Keeping American whiye. Indian Modi, Arabs and Latino should know all these. No sympathy for them
Make America Native Again
STOP BEING ENTITLED..We don't owe you anything here in the US..
And Indians are the original owners of USA according to history 😢
जय हो डंकापति नरेश विश्वगुरु की, घुसपैठियों की सुवर्ण काल में घर वापसी हो रही है, राशन की लाइन में लग जाओ 😊
Thank you from for doing this, for clearing illegal migration within a week after elected as president. We have Indian government working from more than 10 years and they could not throw out any illegal Bangladeshi and rohingyas. A country's law must be respected no matter if it is USA or India. Every legal migrant is welcomed for purposeful work.
To study in india as an african its hell, i am surprised to hear indians saying they are targeted then what should africans students say?
This video is painting the US Law enforcement as though "harassing" the "legal" students.
The Law established states that F1B students cannot work on grocery stores, retail stores outside of the Campus - Doing so is breaking the law. That is the Law. And it needs to be followed.
This is not INDIA Where everything can be bent,
ICE is not looking to harass legal students ( they are only legal visa holders but then they are breaking the law thru unlawful activities)
I'm pretty sure these students are paid in cash, not paying taxes and possibly not in any workplace protections.
Lets see you make a video about these.
Firstpost will loose its credibility by releasing such biased videos. Illegal means illegal. If students are not allowed to work full time, it means they are not allowed to work full time. I think Indians and Firstpost understands that much english. Don't try to play sympathi card. If there is another video showing symapthy for illegals, I will immediately unsubscribe.
Rubbish video. So Indian students working illegally shouldn’t be deported ? The news channels should stop spreading rumors, stop supporting illegal activities by Indians and report if Indians living legally in the US are deported
Legal is different and illegal is different. Students doing illegals jobs off campus is not a good idea.
Can’t believe this channel is reporting absurd lies, this rule has always been there, every university also informs the students to not engage in such activities, if students do it at their risk, they face consequences. NOT BECAUSE THEY LOOK DIFFERENT. SHOVE THESE LIES ELSEWHERE.
those are the biden student that got here easy no more easy entry trump is doing a good job keep it up..
This for the time being he is trying please the opponents!!?😂
Students are on a non immigrant visa and not considered immigrants
If only European leaders had the balls to do this ....
Democracy now you know what it is 😂😂😂
Can't you get it that it is illegal to work extra hours ???????????????????????
Don't worry make hody-mody and hawan😂😂😂😂
Palki - Teach people to respect laws and stop supporting folks doing illegal stuff
Karma is working...Don't cry dear India...Modi is being punished by God
I don't trust Trump.
Is the narrator justifying breaking the law by justifying working illegally off campus? Also, the US has the right to deport anyone on an F1-Visa, Indian or not, if they're found working off campus and/or they're not attending their classes and/or studying in a shady university. FirstPoint, this is disappointly biased.
While the F1 visa is a legitimate visa, the moment you break the rules associated with maintaining that visa, no matter your nationality, no matter the desperation, you become an illegal visa holder.
Oh well, no one wants to go home.
If you are here legally, there is nothing to worry!
Tell that to the US citizens that got deported.
Will India accept illegal immigrants from overseas???? No
God bless Prez Trump.
Make America Lawful Again.( MALA)
MAGA Trump and make India Modi...same in all nations
Bruv some of these students don’t even go to Uni, they’ll just hand in their pass to their classmates and they’ll do their attendance for them. I have seen it happening with my own eyes. A guy walked in with a bunch of pass, did attendance for his mates and walked out. 😂
Once I had respect for this lady, but her narrow view of things, misleading info, lost that.
Where's all the videos of this happening?
India is looking at something big.
Teenagers don't go to college! Full grown adults do! You break the law, you're a criminal! Doesn't matter if you're a student or not! We citizens will no longer be manipulated by your emotional drama!
This is poor reporting and very deceiving. I've lost trust in your reporting and will now UNSUBSCRIBE!!
The so-called American Dream increasingly reveals itself as a paradox-a promise of freedom and opportunity that, for many, unfolds into an American nightmare. This pattern is not unique to any land that claims to be “safe”; history has shown that when societies fear the rise of others, they do not seek collaboration but rather suppression. We have seen this before-when brilliance and progress in a marginalized group provoke resentment instead of inspiration.
Rather than harnessing innovation as a unifying force, society repeats its cycles of racial, economic, and social exclusion. What should be an era of shared growth is instead clouded by status-quo anxieties, xenophobia, and racism-an attempt to cling to the illusion of supremacy rather than acknowledge the inevitability of change.
But let us not forget: the land beneath the feet of those who claim ownership today was once home to the indigenous peoples, before it was seized by force and rewritten in blood and conquest. No empire, no illusion of dominion, no artificial hierarchy can escape the law that governs all existence-cause and effect. The wheel turns, and history does not forget. Karma, after all, is an architect more just and inescapable than any man-made law.
What is happening??? Indian was highly welcome by US ?
This sure is a left wing opinion piece. Dig deeper.
No it's they been properly vetted.
what report says,. Palki what happened to you. now days you are so much presenting negativity in everynews. slow down. you are not living in USA so learn to listen from both side, then present the news. Have you ever publsih news how the so called students are working in multiple jobs which is illegal.
Hope that they can be sued 😮
Palki used to provide good news, but now it's mostly biased.
What’s happened to Palki 🤔
Very poor facts.... when students are not allowed to work off campus on f1 Visa are you nuts to say working odd jobs is chasin american dream.... its jugaad trick n of course unfortunately low level Indian dream 😢😅
May USA great again ..
That’s just it, it’s a dream…they’re chasing a dream. 🛌
Seriously these students live in basem as group of 20 , don’t shower don’t wash cloth often , they are very smelly while they come in mall or shopping centre
indian students are working illegally all over Texas and California in restaurants and gas stations.
I live here and seeing this .Please do your research before speaking.
This is incorrect info.
U can’t if u r not allowed to.. simple
Don't do illegal things - simple
Students should boycott Usa and go to study in other countries instead.
Nobody invited them. They applied.
@@christopherlobo8082 What does "Nobody invited them. They applied." have to do with it?
Essentially anyone.
Who is this ignorant guy reporter?
Rubbish report.