I was thinking the same. I though "when will he stop talking...poor interpreter how will she remember all this?" But she proved herself to be very skilled and professional.
As a bilingual speaker in English and Chinese, the translater made a 100% accurate translation. My questions are : How the hell did she remember every single thing Wang Yi said and how the hell did she translate every thing so well?
@@masahirogo3330 No, they translate on the spot in real time. If you look at meetings of some world leaders, you can see them translate instantly on the spot without pen or papers. Besides, they donno what the leaders are going to say to each other beforehand.
@@Tl7121 Iam afraid Lim Cantonese is Indeed a Chinese language but Chinese in itself is no language, just like Indian is no language but a nationality.
The translator has soften the tone by like 10 times. Listening to the Chinese version and the translated version gives a completely different feeling... The anger can only be felt in the original speech...
No they do not. You do not know CHinese culture at all then. Among their elites, they do NOT speak English at all, and it is seen as a source of pride because they are showing that they do not bow down and accept English as the world's language but remain Sino-centric. Xi Jinping does not speak any English and neither do any of their top echelon. Just like our leaders don't speak Chinese....they see it as the same.
Not true at all. They don't speak English at all. If you knew about China you would know that Chinese elites do not speak English and they wear it as a badge of honor, that they don't need to learn English. They are too proud to learn it as that would be, in their eyes, admitting that the West is better than them. Xi and the other elites purposely do NOT learn English...they are totally Sinocentric
@@somkaranbhardwaj5484 Your girlfriend left you? Sister ran away with your best friend? Mom dumped your dad for his co-worker? What's bothering you boi?
As a Chinese-English Interpreter myself, I stood up applauding the interpreter at the end of the video. She did a fantastic job! Such a lengthy statement would have had the interpreted rendition compromised without clarifying/verifying/ repetition. She deserves what she earns!
And I would wish to see that lady ☺️ No doubt she impressed me. I wish she could add the tone of aggression / affirmation that Chinese FM had in his response. That would have been a cherry on the cake
My thoughts exactly. It would seem people care more for entertainment and care less for authoritarianism. Perhaps they're simply unaware (and look where that's led us now)
The Chinese translator already A better tone to translate into English. But Mr Wang speaks very tough and sharp. If you understand mandarin. You will understand.
Why China is so rude towards freedom of expression....That reporter is just asking questions,its her views only.... Mr Wang need not to be so rude on her.....
No she doesn’t. First of all she’s interpreter not translator secondly she’s there to represent words exactly in the same register and tone as the speaker.
Dipendra Phuyal Someone: Did you beat your wife and children? Wang: Have you been to my home before? Are you familiar with my family? Someone: I don’t have to know your family’s well to prove your home violence. Wang: Do you know how rich I am? Do you know how poor I was? Someone: I don’t care about how much money you have, I just want to know something about your home violence. Wang: Wahahahahah!!!! Do not ask this again.
@@mutton9622 Come on the question of the journalist has no foundations at all, and it's indeed full of ignorance and arrogance, which can make every Chinese who loves their country be angry. China, firstly has never occupy any other countries' territory in last hundred of years, secondly, look at hk now, those so called “peaceful protesters” are threatening the safety of normal citizens and even tourists and personal safety is the most important part of human rights.
I seriously doubt that the translator will benefit in anyway other than perhaps living a little longer, She has to do what she does for the Regime, and as we know Regimes that don't honour human rights, means that whenever credit is due, that credit actually goes to the Dictator of the Regime..
First of all you shouldn't call them red indians. Second of all we admitted to the atrocities that have occurred in our past. Currently the new Canadian gov is trying to rectify it. We still have thousands of indigenous groups living across Canada. The thing with china is that they don't admit or apologize for the atrocities they have done. They just ignore them and pretend they haven't happened. For example the Tiananmen Square massacre. China pretends that didn't happen.
I think foreign minister's response serves you well too because you obviously don't know truth, don't even want to spend time searching for truth. You just regurgitate what you like to hear. Do more research on the so called "Tiananmen square massacre" before you post any such accusation
Exactly. +BrothaJeff, why don't you start with a clip video from a Spanish press team? They were at the Tiananmen Square that night and retreating with the students - the clip was released 5 years after the incident. And do tell what kind of "massacre" you saw in there.
newjack I have researched Tiananmen square extensively. I know the truth about it. The truth is it happened and many Chinese students and soldiers unnecessarily lost their lives. Why does the Chinese government deny that it ever happened? Why don't they confront their mistakes? They pretend it didn't happen... China said that reports of the “massacre” in Tiananmen Square were a fabrication created both by Western media and by the protest leaders who used a willing Western media as a platform for an international propaganda campaign in their interests.
J Lam 300 people or more died that june. There is no way to tell really because the Chinese government tried to suppress it as soon as possible. But many eyewitness accounts describe the truth. Students and soldiers slaughtered but your government declares that it was not a massacre... HA Your leader says it didn't happen. And you follow him like a good little pet and listen to everything your government says and believe everything it says when the world really knows what happened.
Ahmadinejad speaks English. I saw a video of him doing it and it’s damn fluent. Yet he never replies to reporters using it. Sometimes I do feel that many world leaders and important figures who do understand English just choose to speak to the media using their own languages. That’s called being proud of ur mother tongue. 🇲🇾🇨🇳 身为黄炎子孙的我们也要好好的学习他们，维护母语，维护普通话。但同时也要记得学好自家方言。
In 2013 august, a Chinese reporter asked a question to Stephen Harper the previous Canadian prime minister, and the reporter was rudely driven out. so bullshit about freedom in Canada, it's completely double moral
He didn't ask any questions. He shoved a woman and because of that he got kicked out. No one should shove or push a woman because they are upset. Reporters get a select number of questions to ask and he had to wait his turn and had a hissy fit.
wow BrothaJeff you don't have to denigrate somebody just to cover the lack of human rights in Canada. Groundless and unwarranted accusations must be rejected
I wonder if that journalist would ask the same question about the territorial ambition of the USA in Afghanistan, Iraq, Lybia Syria, Venezuela and Haiti...
@@dinuxplay8003 So interfering with the politics of a country, often while using military, is not territorial ambition? Ok, what is the "territorial ambition" of China then?
@@Tomy-im8zl Not really. Territorial ambition means the desire of expanding by acquiring new lands or regions. You seem to have confused the term and most countries you mentioned aren't close to that. CAS and SEA are different. P. S. - This is not saying US are saints. Just addressing the conflation and whataboutism.
Western world does not know the type of effort china and india are putting to get people out of poverty...as an indian...i have huge respect for china story...hope india can also achieve success like china
So funny ro see the Canadian minister first smiling candidly While the journalist starts asking her question and as soon as she says "human rights" his smile disapears and he looks down at his notes 😂
Intinya kenapa anda tidak mengatakan kalau rumah subsidi untuk rakyat Tiongkok hanya untuk menengah keatas bukan menengah kebawah. Pertanyaannya kenapa ada yang tidak di spasi.
Right - well we know how dedicated and devoted to civil & human rights his government is lol!!! Was half-expecting some chinese tanks to appear! His being "offended" means little to human beings in the "civilized" world who care about the welfare of ALL humans - f*cking loser clown!
@@dungenwalkerr619 well, if it wasn't at him his little temper tantrum sure made it look like the question was directed at him so he should have at least tried to answer the question that was not directed at him as you so clearly pointed out. I guess he thought throwing shade was going to make all of us who are watching stand up and applaud his ignorance.
The translator is legendary. She impressed me with robust memory and selective choice of words. She must be having strong command over both English and Chinese languages.
America could never stay angry at Canada. They've weathered too many difficult times together. China, otoh, doesn't remember US/Canadian/UK assistance to and for them during WWII as they were occupied by the Japanese while maintaining a nasty civil war vs the Communists before and after the "big war".
@@NVRAMboiUS supported ROC during and even after the civil war, PRC has diplomatic relations with the US but they hate each other all that time. The big four countries of the allies in wwii united for their own interest, not any favor here and of course they hate each others. They immediately separated when the axis felt off
Can we please for a moment appreciate the interpreter? She did a very good job interpreting, especially with the continuous statements that the Chinese foreign minister has said. Amazing.
Oh yeah - for sure - the entire raison d'etre of the journalist asking pretty loaded and relevant questions for the entire western world, was actually ONLY to prove something about an interpreter lol!!! Get a life and wake up!
Whatever you think of China. Some journalists need to have respect. A little respect will get you a long way in this world and this journalists may have gotten an answer to her question. I have had a lot of contact with Chinese people and they have Always been respectful to me.
The traslatorr did a brilliant job , but i wish she did it in a tougher tone cos that's more true to what the foreign minister actually meant and said in Chinese.
@subash bist Nah foreign ministers are allowed to be passionate about their country. And if you're talking about how much growth Europe and America has given China, why not turn the other way and say the same of China to other nations? Walk out of China's door if you're not happy.
The interpreter did not translate every word of Wang Yi said . She missed the phrase of translation : " You (reporter) have no right to justify the human rights about China , only Chinese people who live in China who have the right to justify the human rights about China."
"Justify"? or Judge you mean? I dont think he said "justify". Anyway the reporter is entitled to ask anything she wants based on her own opinions. that's called freedom of speech, one of basic human rights. Instead it's a joke that Mr wang was trying to define what the reporter can or cannot ask.
Chinese people in the most part actually have hope in their future, and support their Gov... So this truthful translation actually reflect positively vs what the hypocrite journalist said.
James L Asking a strong question does not make a person a hypocrite. True hypocrites are people who cannot stand a question. To question is to doubt, to doubt is to desire reassurance. Politicians in the PRC really cannot accept even the lightest question of their power. That is from fear of the people, nothing else but fear. That is the smell of hypocrisy. "Everyone who agrees raise your hand."
As a Chinese, I want to make two points here. Firstly, China has indeed ignored human rights in many places I have been, and schools rarely teach us those things. Secondly, a country's economic development can not be the measurement of its human rights, it is completely nonsense and I have heard China's diplomats use it several times as an excuse to hide its ongoing human rights issues.
Human rights are universally recognized moral principles or norms that establish standards of human behavior and are often protected by both national and international laws. These rights are considered inherent and inalienable, meaning they belong to every individual simply by virtue of being human, regardless of characteristics like nationality, ethnicity, religion, or socio-economic status. They encompass a broad range of civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights, such as the right to life, freedom of expression, protection against enslavement, and right to education. 中国在言论自由，政治权力上面确实不怎么样。生存权，受教育全本身就是人权的一种，这个维基百科都有的大佬。这个记者确实没水平，一天天的huaman rights，一天天讲一些白痴干话，你精准打击行不行啊。中国真实的人权问题那么多不去讲，不正是因为那些浮夸媒体炒作propaganda听起来最让西方选民愤怒么。没水平，怼王毅也找点高级点的怼
Scrotum Monster This is what I meant. Such low energy people. Aren’t y’all tired of just being a puppet of America? Political correctness and lack of stamina killed your country, I feel sorry for you.
@Mwaniki Mwaniki For me, it sounds more badass and true to their roots, proud of their heritage regardless of what others say and caring only for the opinion of those that matters, which is, and should always be, a leader's own people and own nation. So when a leader speaks in his mother tongue, it goes to show that he has solidarity about him, and that for me, is far more important than morality or idealism or any of that abstract stuff. Besides, some languages sounds way better and awesome than English. Examples are Mandarin, Japanese, German, Russian, Spanish, Polish, Greek, and Turkish.
I'm rewriting two years later. All he had to do was answer the question. Accusing someone of arrogance and indirectly accusing them of ignorance is Ad Hominem. Address the question, don't attack character, it doesn't follow logically. Also, it could seem like you're avoiding the question, which may then raise suspicions. Not so great for a foreign minister.
I’m guessing this is the first time you’ve heard a Chinese foreign minister speak. They always dodge questions about human rights and freedom of speech. Watch Victor Gao’s interview with Mehdi Hasan. Mehdi asks very direct questions about these things and he dodges every time.
Hehehe! she is supposed to translate verbatim and yet sound proper grammatically and structurally - minus the emotion and expression - instantly! Admirable translator!
Fun fact:At least 600 million people in China have a monthly income of less than 1,000 CNY(140 dollar), and 900 million people have a monthly income of less than 2,000 CNY. These info came from a few years ago. Given the increasingly tense economic situation in recent years, these figures are still increasing.
No he dogged her questions with economic wealth or lifting property or its people has say ! That is the real problem its people has no say ! They only do when they are outside of China ! This is how the rest of the world knows lol
@@sereknight9241 did I said I never been to China ? Ok you have no point ! Btw I still have many relitives live in China ! We just don't voice our opinion when we are in the country ! We voice it when we are out ! The next thing our family members gets a visit from the local authorities !
the interpreter was under a lot of pressure to do this accurately but she did a quite well job. and it's right, I suggest people watch Americans doing videos about China like Nathan Rich.
MAJIME[SRT] For him human right abuse is, if you DO NOT agree what I think, then you DO NOT deserve freedom of speech, democracy and you ARE under abuse LOL
China wants to be succssful civilisation, this cannot be achieved in isolation from other nations, US and UK think they are always going to have tech and military superiority, they don't comprehend that this no longer the case, China is far more advanced then Westren nations know or want to acknowledge, this because of inbuilt cultural racisim in westren mindset. China is expanding recruiting disaffected countries from US such as Pakistan CPEC etc to enlarge marcket, nurture design in technology not just within China but external trading partners. Instead of giving fish to its neighbours, it is teaching them to fish. Wealthy neighbours make good customers, unlike US and west want to drive neighbours into poverty to make themselves feel superior.
Hah!! china brought nothing but misery to the East and South East, I don't care if they are super power country or live longer than any country in the world, and don't respond or ask question in such irresponsible manner? Look who's talking! I saw on TH-cam where a mother let her son piss on a subway train! How's that for irresponsible manner!
@@ishikawagoemon4397 excuse me? There isn't always a toilet nearby and mind you, it was a little boy and fyi, seeing that you obviously do not understand this, little kids have poor self control so pls shut it
The very same question once from some arrogant foreign reporters were directed at late Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Singapore) many years ago . And guess what was Mr Lee rebuff.. "The fact that I, Mr Lee Kuan Yew, have won 35 elections in Singapore since 1955 and turn this city around from third world to first world standards makes me more qualified to judge Singapore than the foreign reporter who asked that question in this room" ...
this translator sounds very similar to the one who completed an epic real time translation of almost 20 mins long speech given by a Chinese director in a meeting with U.S in Alaska, this 2 mins one must be a piece of cake for her..
Yeah, the Alaska translator did not miss anything and was delivered in perfect wordings. I do admire their shorthand skill if any was used. I would stand up and tell the minister to hold on until I finished writing (Just kidding)
this is not a question, it is an accusation, the west have yet to show any proof for any of their accusation of China, no wonder why Wang Yi is angry, he have enough of american's lies toward his country.
President Xi and his administration, will be probably the best in our generation. Those people that comment on human rights are a minority compared to those more in need of help, providing the countries' people with prosperity and to be safe. Chinese people now under Xi, lives so much of a happier live, they trust Xi to do the right thing.
spastic.. name 3 things they're doing wrong? If you're not Chinese, you have no reason to speak. This generation has been the best for Chinese, wages gone up.. opportunities everywhere. Only Xi and his party, cares for the country.
Congratulations to the typer who quickly typed everything he said for the interpreter to easily and accurately interpret everything that was stated. They both deserve the same credit for doing their jobs correctly. Without one the other couldn't do their jobs as efficiently and vise versa.
A few western reporters just say China has human rights issue even if they themselves have never been to China. Go to China and see how this country looks like, then you can say something about it.
Foreign Wangyi should have asked the lady about Catholic boarding school Canadian ill treatment of red Indian children that led to over a thousand dead and buried in church compound in Canada, what has transpired? Anybody in Canadian gov apologised, that responsibility and resigned or fired?
China 🇨🇳 🇨🇳!!! proud Chinese Canadian originally born in hong kong. Grew up in Canada. Why shouldn't Canada have a better relationship with China? First of all there is a huge Chinese Canadian population in Canada. I lived my life traveling back and forth between the two countries. If you ask me from my own experiences. The average person in China seems happier then most Canadians I see on the streets of Toronto. They have hope and see a bright future for China and their lives. Yes some people spit on the ground and what Canadians consider to be manners, people in China lacks, but cultural difference plays into that too. Flagging down a server in a restaurant is normal in China (or Chinese Canadian restaurants) but consider rude in Canada. Canadians and Americans, basically the West, sees freedom and human rights as their core value. The West is build on Independence and individualism. China sees unity and family values as its core but that doesn't mean they don't have freedom and rights in China. People just don't care about it as much and it's not their first priority. The best way to exercise human right and freedom is to rise the standard of living of the people. Wealth and development is more practical and effective in giving more freedom to people. Look at the natives, the first Nation in Canada. You can give them the freedom to vote and freedom of expression and speech but other then voting can they really experience the freedoms given to them fully? They don't even have enough gas money to drive out of the native reserves. Some don't even have running water or electricity in their homes. Is that a way to even live in a first world country like Canada? How much freedom do they really have compared to a rural Chinese person who have been lifted out of poverty? Who found a decent job and can now save enough money for a cross country bullet train trip to Hong Kong with their family. And yes China has build a vast network of bullet trains that spans the country build only under 10 years. Talking about 10s of thousands of kms of tracks. Even connecting rural China, places like Tibet, to the rest of China.
Chinese are only 5% of the population, and not all of them are Canadian citizens. " Why shouldn't Canada have a better relationship with China?" Ya, no. No relationships with dictatorships that have active concentration camps. China is an economic bubble thats going to pop spectacularly any day. Canada should not be tied with that.
@@ericcartmann that's old misconception of China. Justin Trudeau dad, the late PM, was friends with the Cuban dictator back in the 70s. The American economy is already collapsing. China and India are the future. It's projected that China will be, if not ready, the world largest economy. India will be the 2nd by 2050, if not earlier, over taking the US as well. Lots of doomsday sayers on the collapse of China. Haters even wrote books about "the coming collapse of China". That was in 2006 I think when it was published. 12 years on China is still here and never better. Don't discriminate. Appreciate and accept.
@@ericcartmann active concentration camps? You referring to places like Guam? We also should not be allies with countries that occupy and invade the middle East. And Torture people with water boarding?
LOL - dude - I want some of what you're smoking !!!- saying a lot as I don't smoke lol!!! Please stop with your bs nonsensical, ideologically compelled and dellusional viral propaganda- have you noticed nobody's buying it anymore and the jig is up - good luck with that
As being a Chinese, I totally admit that China has many shortcomings in terms of human rights and democracy. But I also want to say, things are getting better and the country is running on the right track now. I doubt if the journalist who raised this question knows the history of modern China, not mention the historical evolution of this country for thousands of years. I have found that the sinologists in western countries hold a more objective and moderate attitude towards China than politicians and journalists. I believe, the better knowledge about China a person has, the less prejudiced and arrogrant he/she is.
Chinese economic development has progressed due to millions of hardworking Chinese people. It is not a miracle performed by the ruling elites. The Chinese history shows nothing but the ruling class need to give the power and freedom to the people and let them go do their thing and be themselves. then the result is prosperity. Chinese are never given such opportunity. Those questions were not for Minister Wang. But he himself rather felt the urge to intimidate the journalist, in order to scare away others like her who like to raise painful questions in the future. I have to say what a failed attempt. In a free society like Canada he didn't scare nobody. I overestimated him. I thought he should know how free society functions.
Interestingly, making the other side not know more is perhaps, also a strategy. Rather than burying them with information, swarm them with questions to cast self-doubt and weaken their confidence to continue on such topics.
It is a very important principle for every Chinese citizen that we do not interfere in the internal affairs of other countries, and we will not go against this principle even when the debating scene is conducive to counter the remarks of the other side
Because she doesn’t know what China is like, clearly based on nothing except a couple of things she may have found online. I’m in China right now and it feels just like being in a western country, but it’s much safer here. There’s too much misinformation out there about China and this journalist is just another one of those who spread false accusations and bs about China.
The translator deserve a bonus for that lengthy translation
Indeed
I was thinking the same. I though "when will he stop talking...poor interpreter how will she remember all this?" But she proved herself to be very skilled and professional.
it was toned down 100 times
@@parnilsson8283 she might write down what he says
@@solalstenou6474 Could be. But in that case she writes very fast
As a bilingual speaker in English and Chinese, the translater made a 100% accurate translation.
My questions are : How the hell did she remember every single thing Wang Yi said and how the hell did she translate every thing so well?
They are professionally trained for this and she is one of the best people chosen out of 1.4 billion people.
She read off a script
@@masahirogo3330 No, they translate on the spot in real time. If you look at meetings of some world leaders, you can see them translate instantly on the spot without pen or papers. Besides, they donno what the leaders are going to say to each other beforehand.
@@masahirogo3330 they translate in real-time. How can this be scripted when it’s a response to a live question?
@@ftd7435 translate my a$$
OMG I understand Chinese and was not expecting the translator to translate the entire thing...she did a splendid job!
Yes true I know
U understand Cantonese or mandarin
Chinese is no language.
A VELY GOOOD A TRANSRATOR!!!
@@lavedivsahsay Chinese is a language. And Cantonese is a dialect, amongst the more than 40 or so. Very similar to India...
@@Tl7121 Iam afraid Lim Cantonese is Indeed a Chinese language but Chinese in itself is no language, just like Indian is no language but a nationality.
Me: looking at the chat to see what ppl thought about the response
Chat: translator needs a raise
Translator level: Legendary
Translator level: Asian
She is an interpreter. Translator is more used for written texts.
Yes true I know what you mean
🤜🤜🤜🤜😹🤛🤛🤛
🔖 🔥🔥🔥🔖
YES A VELY GOOD TRANSRATOR!!!!
Comment section:
1% : About the journalist
99% : Legendary level of translation
And now one extra comment for the tactical BS Agency 😂
同志你好
同志好，同志辛苦了，同志工作进展的如何了？
战忽局加拿大分局局长 局长好，英国分局报道
傻逼玩意 。
The translator has soften the tone by like 10 times. Listening to the Chinese version and the translated version gives a completely different feeling... The anger can only be felt in the original speech...
Can you provide me the link
Yeah I’d really like a link.
你去过中国吗？
I guess you’re not one for reading then.
Yeah he has a very rude tone
These guys are super intelligent. They can speak English fluently, but chose not to. That is how you represent your country.
No they do not. You do not know CHinese culture at all then. Among their elites, they do NOT speak English at all, and it is seen as a source of pride because they are showing that they do not bow down and accept English as the world's language but remain Sino-centric. Xi Jinping does not speak any English and neither do any of their top echelon. Just like our leaders don't speak Chinese....they see it as the same.
Yeah, I wish Modi ji too spoke Sanskrit
Not true at all. They don't speak English at all. If you knew about China you would know that Chinese elites do not speak English and they wear it as a badge of honor, that they don't need to learn English. They are too proud to learn it as that would be, in their eyes, admitting that the West is better than them. Xi and the other elites purposely do NOT learn English...they are totally Sinocentric
Yang yi doesnt speak English but he speaks Japanese
@@TrueDreeamssHe speaks English too, he studied in the United States
Wang Yi was so pissed off that I thought soon he'll break into English and leaving the translator thoroughly confused.
Underrated comment
@@yashikaagarwal8724 ha to mt padh kisne bola , underrated khud hogi apni zindagi me fokat mendhak ki tarah uchal rhi h
@@somkaranbhardwaj5484 bhai!!! kya hua aaj ? din bura gaya kya?? 🤣🤣🤣🤣😂
@@somkaranbhardwaj5484 Your girlfriend left you? Sister ran away with your best friend? Mom dumped your dad for his co-worker? What's bothering you boi?
@@SS-yv9cq they cooked his dog for dinner. Again. He is mad.
As a Chinese-English Interpreter myself, I stood up applauding the interpreter at the end of the video. She did a fantastic job! Such a lengthy statement would have had the interpreted rendition compromised without clarifying/verifying/ repetition. She deserves what she earns!
And she actually translated everything pretty accurately, and probably sounded more gentlemanly than the original chinese version ...
你好呀，我也是做口译的(◦˙▽˙◦)
And I would wish to see that lady ☺️ No doubt she impressed me. I wish she could add the tone of aggression / affirmation that Chinese FM had in his response. That would have been a cherry on the cake
I believed that she had great work with her techniques
黃沙長沙屬於越南
The interpreter did well to paraphrase nearly a full minute of speaking during the second response.
i was thinking the exact same thing. he just didn't stop talking!!
That is professional. The best interpreter can do a 5-minute one without taking notes.
Interpretor have a good memory, such a long winded sentences, its hard to translate the proper words at times
PARAPHRASED! It sounded more harsh in mandarin lol
No. At this level, an interpreter should have done much better.
Why is everyone talking about the translator and not the question itself?
Because the question was about left wing hatred of China.
The question ain't worth answering. Anyway, it wasn't directed at China's FM.
@@brockabaddy985 but he did answer, because it was worth answering and he answered poorly
My thoughts exactly. It would seem people care more for entertainment and care less for authoritarianism. Perhaps they're simply unaware (and look where that's led us now)
Oh hang on. The question? That's called free speech. One of life's rare pleasures.
The Chinese translator already A better tone to translate into English. But Mr Wang speaks very tough and sharp. If you understand mandarin. You will understand.
Why China is so rude towards freedom of expression....That reporter is just asking questions,its her views only....
Mr Wang need not to be so rude on her.....
@@abhisheksrivastava4236 be responsible with expressing your opinions.
ABHISHEK SRIVASTAVA because of Mandate of Heaven.
Ok but It's about the sentence. He dodged her question on human rights violation.
ABHISHEK SRIVASTAVA 那是因为对于胡说八道的人就该这样，它们没有资格谈人权，现在开始，西方人将永远低人一等！
See the face of that Canadian guy when she was asking question 😂😂
Canadian is only good in making maple syrup
I meant Jacob Rothschild
When they will remove Canada's PM
lol
Imagine thinking that BREAKING CHINESE LAWS is a humans rights issues 😭
Translator deserve credit for making tone soft
Hahaha
Haha yes I know what you mean
Facial expressions and body language are universal, im sure she got the message.
@@philipwong5066 right lmao
No she doesn’t. First of all she’s interpreter not translator secondly she’s there to represent words exactly in the same register and tone as the speaker.
Gotta love those subtitles...😂
" What is your function booty shot?"
Such a great translator. I salute her if she really was able to capture everything right. Now I need to do my research...
She did translate each word corroectly without even a miss.
Yes. She really did this.
@@xizhiyu and she delivered Minister Wang’s emotion accurately as well. Incredible.
@@xizhiyu she did, but one thing you should know she expressed in the way that as gentle as possible.
She write fast
His expression is telling more than he speaks 😂
Dipendra Phuyal
Someone: Did you beat your wife and children?
Wang: Have you been to my home before? Are you familiar with my family?
Someone: I don’t have to know your family’s well to prove your home violence.
Wang: Do you know how rich I am? Do you know how poor I was?
Someone: I don’t care about how much money you have, I just want to know something about your home violence.
Wang: Wahahahahah!!!! Do not ask this again.
at least we have this other face, which is apart from Xi Zinping, who looks disappointed/frustrated of what you are going to say....😆😆
@@mutton9622 Can you understand english The translator just said that China has written human rights into the constitution. Little clown.
actully not
@@mutton9622 Come on the question of the journalist has no foundations at all, and it's indeed full of ignorance and arrogance, which can make every Chinese who loves their country be angry. China, firstly has never occupy any other countries' territory in last hundred of years, secondly, look at hk now, those so called “peaceful protesters” are threatening the safety of normal citizens and even tourists and personal safety is the most important part of human rights.
Fantastic interpreter!! ... she repeated everything he said (which is ALOT) accurately without missing a beat! Bravo!!
she missed the part where he said, human rights are written in their constitution
No she said that. Did you not listen or can i suddenly understand Chinese.
@@TToTToTT 2:16?
One part is missed:the average income of Chinese
I bet they skipped the part where they put the order to have that reporter disappear
Yea. He’s right. She should go home.
Maybe, you should go back to China and live under the CCP boot...
this incident just made the translator's career...
I seriously doubt that the translator will benefit in anyway other than perhaps living a little longer,
She has to do what she does for the Regime, and as we know Regimes that don't honour human rights,
means that whenever credit is due, that credit actually goes to the Dictator of the Regime..
Joe Wayne what does that have to do with anything
Wang is the biggest liar
@@kadenyap where is trump in this?? Its a video on Wang!!
@@kadenyap the comment section is meant for the relevant video. There are many liars in this world besides Wang
Serve them right. There is no human rights problem in USA or Canada because they had eliminate all the Red Indians and nobody left to complaint.
First of all you shouldn't call them red indians. Second of all we admitted to the atrocities that have occurred in our past. Currently the new Canadian gov is trying to rectify it. We still have thousands of indigenous groups living across Canada. The thing with china is that they don't admit or apologize for the atrocities they have done. They just ignore them and pretend they haven't happened. For example the Tiananmen Square massacre. China pretends that didn't happen.
I think foreign minister's response serves you well too because you obviously don't know truth, don't even want to spend time searching for truth. You just regurgitate what you like to hear. Do more research on the so called "Tiananmen square massacre" before you post any such accusation
Exactly. +BrothaJeff, why don't you start with a clip video from a Spanish press team? They were at the Tiananmen Square that night and retreating with the students - the clip was released 5 years after the incident. And do tell what kind of "massacre" you saw in there.
newjack I have researched Tiananmen square extensively. I know the truth about it. The truth is it happened and many Chinese students and soldiers unnecessarily lost their lives. Why does the Chinese government deny that it ever happened? Why don't they confront their mistakes? They pretend it didn't happen... China said that reports of the “massacre” in Tiananmen Square were a fabrication created both by Western media and by the protest leaders who used a willing Western media as a platform for an international propaganda campaign in their interests.
J Lam 300 people or more died that june. There is no way to tell really because the Chinese government tried to suppress it as soon as possible. But many eyewitness accounts describe the truth. Students and soldiers slaughtered but your government declares that it was not a massacre... HA Your leader says it didn't happen. And you follow him like a good little pet and listen to everything your government says and believe everything it says when the world really knows what happened.
I actually like the fact that the minister know English but did not use English to respond!!!
Understanding is easier than speaking
Ahmadinejad speaks English. I saw a video of him doing it and it’s damn fluent. Yet he never replies to reporters using it. Sometimes I do feel that many world leaders and important figures who do understand English just choose to speak to the media using their own languages. That’s called being proud of ur mother tongue. 🇲🇾🇨🇳 身为黄炎子孙的我们也要好好的学习他们，维护母语，维护普通话。但同时也要记得学好自家方言。
WOOOOR A VELU GOOD TRANSRATOR!!!
The same goes for Russia and many other leaders. They have strict policies to promote their nations interests at all costs.
Anyway, it’s much better this way. I don’t want to see how terrible it would be should they all be speaking English in their own accents 😂😨
Why does she not concentrate finding out on finding out about human rights in Gaza
what about human rights in Iran?
The girl doing translation job has a very sweet voice
Lets be honest, none of us searched this video.
pat herboub i agree! It’s just show up.
😄😄😄👍
Lol
pat herboub we didn’t search but TH-cam did it for us!
We did not search this video but TH-cam did it for us!
In 2013 august, a Chinese reporter asked a question to Stephen Harper the previous Canadian prime minister, and the reporter was rudely driven out. so bullshit about freedom in Canada, it's completely double moral
well say
Feedback
He didn't ask any questions. He shoved a woman and because of that he got kicked out. No one should shove or push a woman because they are upset. Reporters get a select number of questions to ask and he had to wait his turn and had a hissy fit.
ASK a question about israel and c what happens
wow BrothaJeff you don't have to denigrate somebody just to cover the lack of human rights in Canada. Groundless and unwarranted accusations must be rejected
I wonder if that journalist would ask the same question about the territorial ambition of the USA in Afghanistan, Iraq, Lybia Syria, Venezuela and Haiti...
Click expand to see the whole list
No they only love hypocrisy
territorial ambition? That doesn't apply to pretty much any of these.
@@dinuxplay8003 So interfering with the politics of a country, often while using military, is not territorial ambition? Ok, what is the "territorial ambition" of China then?
@@Tomy-im8zl Not really. Territorial ambition means the desire of expanding by acquiring new lands or regions. You seem to have confused the term and most countries you mentioned aren't close to that. CAS and SEA are different. P. S. - This is not saying US are saints. Just addressing the conflation and whataboutism.
That translator sure took notes very fast...wow, give her a position in the government level
I believe these interpreters are fatly paid. They don't care for governmental jobs.
You mean dictator level right
Okay
Shortland writing is fast.
YES A VELY GOOD TRANSRATOR!
China minister looks like a chinese leonardo dicaprio😑
nice looking chad.
😂😂😂
Now I can’t unsee it 👀
He look like boss mafia chinese
@@blackpinkgangster8162 yeah😂😂
I can guarantee you she will never ask same question to Saudi Arabia's Salman
I'm sure she would, IF that prick takes questions.
Why?
Western world does not know the type of effort china and india are putting to get people out of poverty...as an indian...i have huge respect for china story...hope india can also achieve success like china
@Sean Steele read economics..
No..then u must know that you just can not take money from one person and give to other. Anyways...why should rich give their hard earn money to poor?
So funny ro see the Canadian minister first smiling candidly While the journalist starts asking her question and as soon as she says "human rights" his smile disapears and he looks down at his notes 😂
caus they with the US,uk,and WaSP were and still are the greatest human rights abuser in history.
Intinya kenapa anda tidak mengatakan kalau rumah subsidi untuk rakyat Tiongkok hanya untuk menengah keatas bukan menengah kebawah. Pertanyaannya kenapa ada yang tidak di spasi.
Got you to 100 likes.
Right - well we know how dedicated and devoted to civil & human rights his government is lol!!! Was half-expecting some chinese tanks to appear! His being "offended" means little to human beings in the "civilized" world who care about the welfare of ALL humans - f*cking loser clown!
Does anyone notice he still has not answered the question though.
The question was not for him.
@@dungenwalkerr619 well, if it wasn't at him his little temper tantrum sure made it look like the question was directed at him so he should have at least tried to answer the question that was not directed at him as you so clearly pointed out. I guess he thought throwing shade was going to make all of us who are watching stand up and applaud his ignorance.
It's standard CCP tactic to evade tough questions. Search Jiang Zemin did the same to chimese reporter.
No moron
That's just the trick they are good at, never answer the question with their answer
"We welcome goodwill questions but we reject groundless or unwarranted accusations." That translator is bomb.
But I think she interpreted Wang Yi's idea accurately. That's exactly what he expressed in Chinese.
@@mastermirror3888 Yup, bomb means awesome.
@@md51236 Thanks for clarifying that:)
It's actually sounds more gentle than what he says in Chinese, but still good though. His tone is very critical, angry and aggresive
Bruce Liang the interpreter should avoid communicating the emotional aspect of the dialogue, that's one reason why.
The translator is legendary. She impressed me with robust memory and selective choice of words. She must be having strong command over both English and Chinese languages.
She knows her boss s back in Beijing are going to send her into a gulag in the Desert somewhere if she says the wrong thing.
They use some tricks like stenographer
The question could be expected, the answer rehearsed and communicated.
@@jhonsen9842 There are still best among best interpreters. They are not all equal.
@@jhonsen9842p
The Chinese Foreign Minister was super-tactful and polite for not simply replying in one word, namely "Inuit?"
I could hear the translator being breathless by the words she had to speak! Tough crowd!
From someone who's bilingual the translation is head-on correct
Yeah like that's what matters here!
And to be able to do that almost immediately, damn.
yeah exactly, I would have forgotten what the minister had said before I could fully translate it
She forgot the 8000 gdp per capita
We're not sure if she has added more fire to the minister's statements.
jeez, I couldnt even properly translate my families' language that fast. and i was raised to be their translator. props to her.
LOL
she's using shorthand to write down what he said, then just reading it back.
how can the interpreter memorize such a long dialogue?
note-taking
clear paraphrasing
Intelligence.
She has the pen
Illuminati confirmed
I love the facial expression change of the canadian minister
but even crazier was the Yi's body language when he pay attention what she said :D.
He knew full well, was are planned, all reporters there are hand-picked.
hahah he straight to read a paper
00:09
The Canadian Minister: please not now. 😰😓
🤣🤣🤣
🤭🤭🤭😁😁😁😂
Lol!
Lol
I loved that! .... I'm just going to look at these papers and hope this all blows over.
Saad@🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Canada has a unique ability to piss-off China, India & Russia and apparently US as well, very unique ability ... LOL
Feminine soul
America could never stay angry at Canada. They've weathered too many difficult times together. China, otoh, doesn't remember US/Canadian/UK assistance to and for them during WWII as they were occupied by the Japanese while maintaining a nasty civil war vs the Communists before and after the "big war".
we do what we can.
@@NVRAMboiUS supported ROC during and even after the civil war, PRC has diplomatic relations with the US but they hate each other all that time. The big four countries of the allies in wwii united for their own interest, not any favor here and of course they hate each others. They immediately separated when the axis felt off
How does she remember everything wtf
They write some signs on a notebook, signs that may make them remember words.
@@abdixsimplix2582 beside it's her job she has to translate it all smh
@@wut2697 Exactly, but there are few translators who translate well.
Because they train for a long time
Noting signals on their notebooks
Can we please for a moment appreciate the interpreter? She did a very good job interpreting, especially with the continuous statements that the Chinese foreign minister has said. Amazing.
And under tremendous pressure and tension
*Interpreter. Translators deal with written documents. Interpreters deal with live speech. Interpretation is MUCH harder than translation!
@@JeremyGalloway oh ok thanks for correcting!
Oh yeah - for sure - the entire raison d'etre of the journalist asking pretty loaded and relevant questions for the entire western world, was actually ONLY to prove something about an interpreter lol!!! Get a life and wake up!
The translator can completely express the length of Chinese foreign minister and should be perfectly shown
Whatever you think of China. Some journalists need to have respect. A little respect will get you a long way in this world and this journalists may have gotten an answer to her question. I have had a lot of contact with Chinese people and they have Always been respectful to me.
You must work for the CCP?
The traslatorr did a brilliant job , but i wish she did it in a tougher tone cos that's more true to what the foreign minister actually meant and said in Chinese.
😁😁
@@retnos33 WOW THE TRANSRATOR DID A VELY GOOD JOB TRANSRATOR
@subash bist Nah foreign ministers are allowed to be passionate about their country. And if you're talking about how much growth Europe and America has given China, why not turn the other way and say the same of China to other nations? Walk out of China's door if you're not happy.
The interpreter did not translate every word of Wang Yi said . She missed the phrase of translation : " You (reporter) have no right to justify the human rights about China , only Chinese people who live in China who have the right to justify the human rights about China."
That makes it even worse, not better. Human rights are human, after all.
"Justify"? or Judge you mean? I dont think he said "justify". Anyway the reporter is entitled to ask anything she wants based on her own opinions. that's called freedom of speech, one of basic human rights. Instead it's a joke that Mr wang was trying to define what the reporter can or cannot ask.
Yeah except Chinese people are the last ones who can justify rights in China.
Chinese people in the most part actually have hope in their future, and support their Gov... So this truthful translation actually reflect positively vs what the hypocrite journalist said.
James L Asking a strong question does not make a person a hypocrite. True hypocrites are people who cannot stand a question. To question is to doubt, to doubt is to desire reassurance. Politicians in the PRC really cannot accept even the lightest question of their power. That is from fear of the people, nothing else but fear. That is the smell of hypocrisy. "Everyone who agrees raise your hand."
She is good and fast in translating. There is pause, but she is quick to come out with the correct words.
As a Chinese, I want to make two points here. Firstly, China has indeed ignored human rights in many places I have been, and schools rarely teach us those things. Secondly, a country's economic development can not be the measurement of its human rights, it is completely nonsense and I have heard China's diplomats use it several times as an excuse to hide its ongoing human rights issues.
Human rights are universally recognized moral principles or norms that establish standards of human behavior and are often protected by both national and international laws. These rights are considered inherent and inalienable, meaning they belong to every individual simply by virtue of being human, regardless of characteristics like nationality, ethnicity, religion, or socio-economic status. They encompass a broad range of civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights, such as the right to life, freedom of expression, protection against enslavement, and right to education.
中国在言论自由，政治权力上面确实不怎么样。生存权，受教育全本身就是人权的一种，这个维基百科都有的大佬。这个记者确实没水平，一天天的huaman rights，一天天讲一些白痴干话，你精准打击行不行啊。中国真实的人权问题那么多不去讲，不正是因为那些浮夸媒体炒作propaganda听起来最让西方选民愤怒么。没水平，怼王毅也找点高级点的怼
The Canadian Minister was visibly uncomfortable 😂
Canadians are so weak.
Scrotum Monster This is what I meant. Such low energy people. Aren’t y’all tired of just being a puppet of America? Political correctness and lack of stamina killed your country, I feel sorry for you.
@@magnus123DF I agree with you, Mr.unpronounceable unreadable name.
Рафаэль Преза if your country is so strong, then why do you live in a poor shithole?
Turn on the Eng subtitle, trust me, you won't be disappointed
👉🤜😹⛳🤛🤛👁👁👁👁👁
Ahahahhahah
There’s English Spanish and some unknown languages in the caption hhhh so funny
YES A VELY GOOD TRANSRATOR!!!
That was horrible
I like when people say things in their mother tongue with full confidence not in English.
A VELY GOOOD A TRANSRATOR!!!
?
@@quyenluong3705 VELYGOODTRANSRATOR!!!!!!!
They know and can speak English very well. But since Chinese is one of the official UN speaking languages... so...
@Mwaniki Mwaniki For me, it sounds more badass and true to their roots, proud of their heritage regardless of what others say and caring only for the opinion of those that matters, which is, and should always be, a leader's own people and own nation. So when a leader speaks in his mother tongue, it goes to show that he has solidarity about him, and that for me, is far more important than morality or idealism or any of that abstract stuff.
Besides, some languages sounds way better and awesome than English. Examples are Mandarin, Japanese, German, Russian, Spanish, Polish, Greek, and Turkish.
I'm rewriting two years later. All he had to do was answer the question. Accusing someone of arrogance and indirectly accusing them of ignorance is Ad Hominem. Address the question, don't attack character, it doesn't follow logically. Also, it could seem like you're avoiding the question, which may then raise suspicions. Not so great for a foreign minister.
I’m guessing this is the first time you’ve heard a Chinese foreign minister speak. They always dodge questions about human rights and freedom of speech. Watch Victor Gao’s interview with Mehdi Hasan. Mehdi asks very direct questions about these things and he dodges every time.
Marvellous translator.
Turn English auto-generated subtitles on and then read them when he's speaking Chinese
😭😭😭😭
Illuminati confirmed wohoo!!
What's your booty function shot
😂😂😂
You children wanna judo😂😂😂
The interpreter deserves a huge credit for such lengthy interpretation. And also she made it sounds a lot softer.
A VELY GOOD A RANSRATORRRR!
@@haldavis8981
*translator
@@supermaster-jz4di Chinese people can’t pronounce L
Hehehe! she is supposed to translate verbatim and yet sound proper grammatically and structurally - minus the emotion and expression - instantly! Admirable translator!
@@Samuelon552 yes they can, that's the Japanese you're thinking of
Wang Yi is handsome. Love him for his answers.
Handsome? 😂
0:11 Wang Yi in his mind says here it goes again. You want to play fine
王毅心想SB，又TM来这一出，今天爷给你好好说几句。
请问 您是在十一学校 读书吗😯
Really?
Turning on subtitles is very much recommended when China's Foreign Minister answers. I had a hell lotta fun reading them.
That was hilarious 😆😆 I read it all.. forget the real answer .
Function of booty 😆
Bite penguin man was the best in this one.
😂😂😂😂😂
You discovered Google®'s auto-captioning hooter only now?
來美國快20年了，看著天天罵中國的新聞，說中國要崩潰的輿論。但中國在默默耕耘地建設，人民越來越富有。我覺得沒什麽不好。
这是一些没有意义的汉字Abner 怕西化那你西装也别穿了
Why did you flee China to live a better life in oversea? lmao mainland China trash
就像视频里这位Minister说的，你都没有在中国生活，你的这句话哪里来的底气？
看到你的评论的好心情全被一堆鸡屎给污染了，墙外的一些人真的好恶心(；一_一)
不用在意有些中国人不友善的言论 他们就是歧视海外侨胞 切记大多数人一定不是这样的 不要因此影响您的心情
I just think the translator is so good...
原尧燊 那个叫interpretator 不是translator、translator是笔译员
lucaslee1991 same thing, u get the point
tbh she's not flawless. the translation's not that difficult if she was using software to help taking notes or something.
what can you translate?fool
Body language says it all.. his facial expressions conveys everything and more
Yeah conveys his complete denial of very real Chinese human rights violations.
Fun fact:At least 600 million people in China have a monthly income of less than 1,000 CNY(140 dollar), and 900 million people have a monthly income of less than 2,000 CNY.
These info came from a few years ago. Given the increasingly tense economic situation in recent years, these figures are still increasing.
That’s a bad comparison, the living costs in Canada compared to China is almost greater by 10 fold in some places
因为六亿人中包括了还没有工作的孩子与退休的老人
your talking about india right?bigotted creep!!
希望你继续沉浸在西方媒体的谎言里，永远不要醒来
Waooo I just love this China's Foreign Minister great response. Placed the journalist in her place good job well done
No he dogged her questions with economic wealth or lifting property or its people has say !
That is the real problem its people has no say ! They only do when they are outside of China ! This is how the rest of the world knows lol
@@bockscar1 U cannot represent chinese people if you never come to china and never speak to any normal chinese people randomly on the street
@@sereknight9241 did I said I never been to China ? Ok you have no point ! Btw I still have many relitives live in China ! We just don't voice our opinion when we are in the country ! We voice it when we are out ! The next thing our family members gets a visit from the local authorities !
@@sereknight9241 You want to praise that CCP system ? Go do it there ! Not here ! If you do it here it will make you a hypocrite !
@@bockscar1 lol I can feel the intense agitation from your reaction when you cannot support that U have been to China.
This translator is one of the most honest ones.
@Lacveg rd for what?
All is see is english+spanish language
Not only honest, she translated all the nuance to reflect Wang Yi's body language to the T...or else she would've been replaced later.
the interpreter was under a lot of pressure to do this accurately but she did a quite well job. and it's right, I suggest people watch Americans doing videos about China like Nathan Rich.
I saw his videos. They are enlightening
But still, human rights abuse. Just sayin'.
Al As 57 did you not just watch the video... where are you getting human rights abuse lmao
MAJIME[SRT] For him human right abuse is, if you DO NOT agree what I think, then you DO NOT deserve freedom of speech, democracy and you ARE under abuse LOL
He is such intelligent guy , go and check his channel out !
OMG! Listen to this Chinese Dude.
Wang didnt really need a translation as hes about the same level fluency in English as the translator
Can you share any video that he spoke English, thks
@@robintang7304 Wang Yi did go to college in USA
He able to speak fluent japanese too
@@heinhtetzaw9463 I humbly repeat can you share a video of him speaking English.
@@robintang7304 Probably wont be able to find one
Dont get in others country politics and let a mess just like Libya , Syria , Iraq Yemen
TH-cam algorithm ... I'm seeing it in 2019
😂😂😂
Yeah me too... Right now
What did Canada with the indigenous peoples and how they companies behave in the global south???
China went through a lot! We made huge sacrifices to achieve that, only we know that. The future is bright for us!!
China wants to be succssful civilisation, this cannot be achieved in isolation from other nations, US and UK think they are always going to have tech and military superiority, they don't comprehend that this no longer the case, China is far more advanced then Westren nations know or want to acknowledge, this because of inbuilt cultural racisim in westren mindset. China is expanding recruiting disaffected countries from US such as Pakistan CPEC etc to enlarge marcket, nurture design in technology not just within China but external trading partners. Instead of giving fish to its neighbours, it is teaching them to fish. Wealthy neighbours make good customers, unlike US and west want to drive neighbours into poverty to make themselves feel superior.
Hah!! china brought nothing but misery to the East and South East, I don't care if they are super power country or live longer than any country in the world, and don't respond or ask question in such irresponsible manner? Look who's talking! I saw on TH-cam where a mother let her son piss on a subway train! How's that for irresponsible manner!
@@ishikawagoemon4397 excuse me? There isn't always a toilet nearby and mind you, it was a little boy and fyi, seeing that you obviously do not understand this, little kids have poor self control so pls shut it
its ok, if you play fair, we dont mind,
You forgot "stole a lot of stuff"
The very same question once from some arrogant foreign reporters were directed at late Mr Lee Kuan Yew (Singapore) many years ago . And guess what was Mr Lee rebuff.. "The fact that I, Mr Lee Kuan Yew, have won 35 elections in Singapore since 1955 and turn this city around from third world to first world standards makes me more qualified to judge Singapore than the foreign reporter who asked that question in this room" ...
singapore is not really a democracy, most critics are in jail
Juju Rellama Utter nonsense!
Juju Rellama USA is freedom and demoracy! You can make a fun at the president
李光耀是我最敬佩政治的人物
@@lunafringe10 Your can keep your braindead democracy to yourself, Singapore doesn't need it, nor does China.
this translator sounds very similar to the one who completed an epic real time translation of almost 20 mins long speech given by a Chinese director in a meeting with U.S in Alaska, this 2 mins one must be a piece of cake for her..
Yeah, the Alaska translator did not miss anything and was delivered in perfect wordings. I do admire their shorthand skill if any was used. I would stand up and tell the minister to hold on until I finished writing (Just kidding)
I think she is the one
its one and the same interprter
Its usually hard for authoritarians to handle tough questions.
they're not used to being questioned
this is not a question, it is an accusation, the west have yet to show any proof for any of their accusation of China, no wonder why Wang Yi is angry, he have enough of american's lies toward his country.
I don't think Wang Yi have done anything wrong with his responses. he's like a boss. xD
President Xi and his administration, will be probably the best in our generation. Those people that comment on human rights are a minority compared to those more in need of help, providing the countries' people with prosperity and to be safe. Chinese people now under Xi, lives so much of a happier live, they trust Xi to do the right thing.
He Is Not The Boss, More Like A Wiener
No, He Wants To Rule The World & Suffer Everyone In His Power
Xi & The CCP Is Doing The Wrong Thing
spastic.. name 3 things they're doing wrong? If you're not Chinese, you have no reason to speak. This generation has been the best for Chinese, wages gone up.. opportunities everywhere. Only Xi and his party, cares for the country.
This is what u called power and confident.. do not let others step on you and your country, never the less, use words as an insult
The interpreter did a great job for being able to convey the long message.
Too young too simple sometimes naive
Indeed it's not a hotel. It's more like a state of USA.
Go back to kindergarten where you could be taught something.
我还以为是傻逼白左。原来是傻逼轮子啊哈哈哈哈哈哈哈！
作为一个长者，我要给你一点人生经验，叫闷声发大财，识得唔识得啊！我可是身经百战了，什么轮子我没见过？你们啊，too young too simple, sometimes naive.
粗鄙
+1000 social credits for the translator
For stating the truth?
bok choi up your arse pinoy
Excellent translator : able to convey meanings and intentions without evoking emotions and respectfully to the listener ( reporter)
Doubt that reporter hears anything he said .... as she was beyond her conscience when she brought up such Q's .
I think Minister Wang Yi totally understood what that Canadian reporter was asking.
He is fluent in English .
he doesnt care hes one of their puppy dog warrior politicians
His face def showed it and he's probably pissed bc the way he said was portrayed accurately
@HZKIAFKY is their reason he didnt just reply in english ?
@@sakurakou2009 Power move.
Congratulations to the typer who quickly typed everything he said for the interpreter to easily and accurately interpret everything that was stated. They both deserve the same credit for doing their jobs correctly. Without one the other couldn't do their jobs as efficiently and vise versa.
Typer? Must be typing like a Superwoman - with Microsoft or Huawei keyboard! She is the best of the best!
it is recorded in an electronic Chinese to English translator, as you know China has a very sophisticated electronics translator in any language
@@westwoodly the best typists can type up to 300wpm
Chinese are liars, never trust a Chinese.
i do that too. i pretend to be angry when im hiding something from my wife.
A few western reporters just say China has human rights issue even if they themselves have never been to China. Go to China and see how this country looks like, then you can say something about it.
粪坑不用起也知道是臭的，懂？
不用去中国，就看这位王部长对一个记者的提问反应，就可以知道了。 外国记者问个问题都被骂。而且还没问他。人家是问自己的部长。
那应该是剪辑的 你看不出来吗？不是把问题抢过来回答 谢谢。
NicKYKmic good logic!
NicKYKmic 装美国人累不累啊，英语烂成这样，一下就被busted了，少装逼多读书，别天天瞎鸡吧BB.
Even the Canadian PM was like: THAT'S TOO MUCH REPORTER, ARGH. YOU'RE CAUSING MORE TROUBLE!!!
The way he talked was like "I'm disappointed in you son" like the way a father talks to there kids
I imagined his son getting 99 in Maths.
@@aalam5747 He was still disappointed. 100 or nothing
@@frostrune 100? You didn’t do extra credit?
Foreign Wangyi should have asked the lady about Catholic boarding school Canadian ill treatment of red Indian children that led to over a thousand dead and buried in church compound in Canada, what has transpired? Anybody in Canadian gov apologised, that responsibility and resigned or fired?
Wang Yi is very experienced, and bro give the interpreter a rise
YES A VELY GOOOD TRANSRATOR!!!
@Kilroy Robo that's the face all diplomats worldwide
@Kilroy Robo Very attactive right? Maybe u legs are shaking bcuz of his face
@Kilroy Robo He looks like Leung Chun Ying who was the chief executive of Hong Kong.He is as bad as Wang Yi
who is wang yi
1:34 " We will find ya, our chung will find ya!"
Reporter: That said it all... I'm out of here!!!
what is this Sum Dum Chung?
Hacer dedo de von Du teba chunga, 😂
Omg i laughed so hard
Chinese Liam Neeson.
🤣😅😅🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
China 🇨🇳 🇨🇳!!! proud Chinese Canadian originally born in hong kong. Grew up in Canada. Why shouldn't Canada have a better relationship with China? First of all there is a huge Chinese Canadian population in Canada. I lived my life traveling back and forth between the two countries. If you ask me from my own experiences. The average person in China seems happier then most Canadians I see on the streets of Toronto. They have hope and see a bright future for China and their lives. Yes some people spit on the ground and what Canadians consider to be manners, people in China lacks, but cultural difference plays into that too. Flagging down a server in a restaurant is normal in China (or Chinese Canadian restaurants) but consider rude in Canada. Canadians and Americans, basically the West, sees freedom and human rights as their core value. The West is build on Independence and individualism. China sees unity and family values as its core but that doesn't mean they don't have freedom and rights in China. People just don't care about it as much and it's not their first priority.
The best way to exercise human right and freedom is to rise the standard of living of the people. Wealth and development is more practical and effective in giving more freedom to people. Look at the natives, the first Nation in Canada. You can give them the freedom to vote and freedom of expression and speech but other then voting can they really experience the freedoms given to them fully? They don't even have enough gas money to drive out of the native reserves. Some don't even have running water or electricity in their homes. Is that a way to even live in a first world country like Canada? How much freedom do they really have compared to a rural Chinese person who have been lifted out of poverty? Who found a decent job and can now save enough money for a cross country bullet train trip to Hong Kong with their family. And yes China has build a vast network of bullet trains that spans the country build only under 10 years. Talking about 10s of thousands of kms of tracks. Even connecting rural China, places like Tibet, to the rest of China.
Chinese are only 5% of the population, and not all of them are Canadian citizens.
" Why shouldn't Canada have a better relationship with China?"
Ya, no. No relationships with dictatorships that have active concentration camps. China is an economic bubble thats going to pop spectacularly any day. Canada should not be tied with that.
@@ericcartmann that's old misconception of China. Justin Trudeau dad, the late PM, was friends with the Cuban dictator back in the 70s.
The American economy is already collapsing. China and India are the future. It's projected that China will be, if not ready, the world largest economy. India will be the 2nd by 2050, if not earlier, over taking the US as well.
Lots of doomsday sayers on the collapse of China. Haters even wrote books about "the coming collapse of China". That was in 2006 I think when it was published. 12 years on China is still here and never better.
Don't discriminate. Appreciate and accept.
@@ericcartmann active concentration camps? You referring to places like Guam? We also should not be allies with countries that occupy and invade the middle East. And Torture people with water boarding?
@@jjc4232 "Appreciate and accept."
Not with countries with a cucked population sheeps under a dictatorship.
LOL - dude - I want some of what you're smoking !!!- saying a lot as I don't smoke lol!!!
Please stop with your bs nonsensical, ideologically compelled and dellusional viral propaganda- have you noticed nobody's buying it anymore and the jig is up - good luck with that
my hats off to the translator, she is 100% interpreting Wang's statement correctly. Much better than Xi's translator to Biden or Trudeau......
As being a Chinese, I totally admit that China has many shortcomings in terms of human rights and democracy. But I also want to say, things are getting better and the country is running on the right track now. I doubt if the journalist who raised this question knows the history of modern China, not mention the historical evolution of this country for thousands of years. I have found that the sinologists in western countries hold a more objective and moderate attitude towards China than politicians and journalists. I believe, the better knowledge about China a person has, the less prejudiced and arrogrant he/she is.
Can't agree more
Well said!
Chinese economic development has progressed due to millions of hardworking Chinese people. It is not a miracle performed by the ruling elites. The Chinese history shows nothing but the ruling class need to give the power and freedom to the people and let them go do their thing and be themselves. then the result is prosperity. Chinese are never given such opportunity.
Those questions were not for Minister Wang. But he himself rather felt the urge to intimidate the journalist, in order to scare away others like her who like to raise painful questions in the future. I have to say what a failed attempt. In a free society like Canada he didn't scare nobody. I overestimated him. I thought he should know how free society functions.
So the Chinese government is not run by Chinese?
The American government in run by Jewish for sure.
Interestingly, making the other side not know more is perhaps, also a strategy. Rather than burying them with information, swarm them with questions to cast self-doubt and weaken their confidence to continue on such topics.
Yup keep on showing the whole world their true face
黃沙長沙屬於越南
@@quanglongtran3405 大胆点儿，欧亚大陆全是越南的
The Chinese FM should have asked her about Iraq and Afghanistan
It is a very important principle for every Chinese citizen that we do not interfere in the internal affairs of other countries, and we will not go against this principle even when the debating scene is conducive to counter the remarks of the other side
Since Confucius days China’s policy to neighbours is to not interfere with their internal affairs.
You understand that she is a reporter not a representative of a country.
So it is pointless to play whatabout with her.
Why? That's America little wang wang was in Canada
And South America or African or just ask them how they build USA or Canada lol
Translators memory level: Asian
The interpreter was awesome. Not a easy job translating in front of world press and for some of the powerful people.
HOW IS THAT NOT A VALID QUESTION???
Coz it's question full of BS
@@123mrthunder chinese identified
James VS That's not a question, That's a groundless accusation.
@@josephjiao8494 join the 123 man, you biased snake
Because she doesn’t know what China is like, clearly based on nothing except a couple of things she may have found online. I’m in China right now and it feels just like being in a western country, but it’s much safer here. There’s too much misinformation out there about China and this journalist is just another one of those who spread false accusations and bs about China.