‘Modi Should Release The Documents’: Subramanian Swamy Speaks On India-China Talks In Kazan, Russia
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
- In an explosive interview at ‘Truth Be Told’, Neelu Vyas is joined by former minister & former Member of Rajya Sabha Dr. Subramanian Swamy and discusses the recent high-stakes bilateral meeting that took place between Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping on the sidelines of the BRICS Summit in Kazan, Russia.
#DrSubramnianSwamy #IndiaChinaTalks #BRICSSummit #Kazan #Russia #SJaishankar #EasternLadakh #LAC #BJP #XiJinping #NarendraModi #IndoChina #BRICS #VladimirPutin #HWNews
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
Support independent journalism by subscribing to HW News English Premium Newsletter: hwnews.in/subs...
To Join TH-cam Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscrib...
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Whatsapp: whatsapp.com/c...
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotio...
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
Our PM told the nation that nobody has come then how they are going back now.
Interesting point
@@rajeevashetty8395 absolutely bull st go learn facts from the military not social media CIA paid brown sepoys
It was a land which was buffer zone.Both countries used to do patrolling.China occupied thad land& Indian Army was not able to do patrolling.There r still couple of such sectors where china has occupied the part of buffer zone.Will be duly handled.I hv served there
Excellent point. Who is controlling the border? CHINA. Period. Modi is just parroting what Xi wants him to say.
The ghosts are going back
Why all BJP are silent none have guts even little to talk against Subramanian Swamy shows he is talking with proof.
What proof has he presented? The moment the U turn master's RS seat was not renewed he started this.
Dr. Swami's stature is very high
@@DineshKothavale-t1b he is not taken serisosly in politics
Clearly you know but you don't wanna accept it... Cuase modi mainly work in the name of hindu and promote. It's hard to accept it but facts is facts
Clearly you know but you don't wanna accept it... Cuase modi mainly work in the name of hindu and promote. It's hard to accept it but facts is facts
Appreciate Dr. Subramanian Swamy speaking the truth and what he is saying is all facts. Even though he belongs to the same party. He is man of integrity.
Yes instead everyone should appreciate him transperancy is the most important to know if our leaders are treating us the citizens of this country as they treat the international deplomats
Very well said !!😊
@@wilfredalexandercoelho8003 Where is the proof ? I think he is just ranting
Subramanian swamy is saying that China is occupying 4000 s.km of Indian land during Modi's period. If that is so, it is a shame on Modi and his government.
Absolutely bull st
If not then what ?
He always talk bull sheet in TV for publicity.
What he contributed to India.
He repeatedly told he got all about RG.For publicity he told filed case .What happened afterwords .
Why he is hiding the proof for the last 20 yrs.
He is afraid of Sonia Gandhi or R Gandhi .
He want be the Finance minister.Modi not obliged so he used to catch hold of TV. anchors,who also could not get free soap from govt. (Free air and train travel,free access to all govt organisation,free govt guest house accomodations,jobs to their relatives or kins etc etc)
These TV anchors and press want so many favours from govt dept .If the govt not giving such favours then they catch hold of any" persons" and conduct interview.
😂😂
buachors
Not IF. Its reality. We lost our land in gaowan valley. Modi lied to whole nation 😂
@@coconutpunch123Goawan valley?
I am not supporting Dr.Swamy but I want govt to show the document as a proof.
and expose Indian venerability to world wow with that intellect u should be an IAS officer
Shetty ji tumhara dimag ghutne meh heh ya tumhare liver meh jo kharab ho gaye
Yes correct
Modi couldnt show his degree certificate 😂
Yes
My countrymen if you guys are a real nationalist then please go to Arunachal and Ladak, you will get the authenticity of what Chinese have grab our land or not.
Our external minister have said on record that the are a larger economy we are not in a position to fight with them. To tell you the truth, we are at the mercy of Chinese because of our government timidity.
Our government is smart only in keeping the citizens in dark.
That’s not true, we cannot afford war not because we are weak but we are aiming long term . Also there are ample of roads open for civilians , also you can’t go in the conflict region from either side . Subramanian wants India to go in war so that his Dravidian mindset flourish
Is your son in the army? If he is not, please send him there. After that we can have all the wars you want
Yes, I saw that video too!! He Darpok!
@@Saraxcxcxcxxcx yes, they have, so what is your point??
Dr. Subranaim is 100% correct. I am from Sikkim. Even in Sikkim, Bhutan and Arunachal Chinese crossed all the red lines. Not only in Ladakh.
Implement Strict 1-CHILD POLICY if India wants to continue as a country
We are from uttaranchal..it's normal for now..
Kailash mansarovar pilgrimage need to open along with trade between Indo-china-nepal in taklakot (Tibet)..
Nepal has started recently after covid..
Both Jawaharlal Nehru and the US are responsible to create a direct land border with China. Prior to 1950, it was Tibet that sat between China and India.
What has arnab goswami to tell about modi shaking hands with xi jinping?
There are millions of people in our country who do not know what "POLITICS" is neither do they know what "DIPLOMACY" is, and yet they would like to make any comment they believe they are right. The question is how they would have behaved if they were in the place of Modiji. I invite them to name just ONE prime minister who was more HONEST and more DIPLOMATIC than Modiji who made INDIA more INTERNATIONAL and more PROGRESSIVE. No doubt the POWER HUNGRY and CORRUPT opposition party will always envy the brilliant record of performance of Modiji.
Only shaking hands. Perhaps xi jing ping did not like the hugging and embracing tactics of modi.
I agree Indian economy really improved alot but before he gave lots n lots of loans to the African countries he should create job sector first to give opportunity for all the citizens of this country instead creating GST that is very important
@@Shanmugam-c8d Xi loves the Congress more because they are genuinely sellouts 😂😂
Arnab is a lap d0g of Modi. He is being paid by the BJP to scream against the opponents of BJP
Swamy is 💯💯💯% Right
Let Swamy prove in court
Supreme court of india 😅😅😅
LMAO - You are naive my friend
@@rajnair1357😂
@@shaileshparikh6920 You are Naive About Modi my dear friend 🙂
@@rajnair1357 Supreme Court has taught Lessons to Modi many Times too 😂
Nice to know Dear Neelu , first time i listening your flunt English. And no doubt this man is so great as i hear him
I think he spoke the truth he knows couse he is there he's in the govtmnt at that time
However Mr. Swamy is still A Great watchman for INDIA’s Interest !
With Gora wife ?
Remember he pulled down Vajpeyi govt
Toxic person.
Nonsense
@baskar SubramanianSwamy capable of doing unbelievable things
He is traitor and CIA agent runs propoganda of CIA
Kuch bhi re. Vajpayee lost fair and square and resigned on his own accord.
Subramanian Swamy is actually correct and nobody not in power and neither in opposition dares to message with him 😂😂
Subramanian Swamy for surasamharam save india jai swamy with meenakshi Amman blessings 🔱
Great sir
Susu Swami did not get renewal of his RJ seat and never won election would save theives
Swamy married to Angrez Amman ! 😂
Sir, you are the real leader of nation, speak truth about Moti
Susu Swami 😂😂 bashed pappu too
Very well said sir that's why I have huge respect for you as a true nationalist
Swamy should speak in Rajyasabha (upper house ) let ppl know
We are cat in tiger clothes on media propaganda 😂😂😂😅
😂
Uncomfortable truth is always bitter be it swamy or anybody else
30 villages of Arunachal Pradesh already has China names .
Because they belong to China...your British master gave you those lands they stole from the Chinese..get your facts right
It was renamed by INDIA too.. and China not only claiming arunachal pradesh as their land but also a some parts in Japan, Malaysia, Phillipines, and entire taiwan😂...
@@kimchiba4570 A Big No... Arunachal Pradesh was always ours and undisputedly so... The PLA soldiers have encroached on our land
@@kimchiba4570 are you brain dead … knowing nothing about any history .
@@kimchiba4570 another brain dead comment 😂
❤❤❤ Great word's by the greatest person CR ADISESH Bangalore
Dear Swamy why are you not ready to file a case against Modi in SC ?
Subramanian swamy showed some guts to speak the TRUTH.
same old bla bla
Old is Gold. I do agree with you.
Na koi gusaaya hai 😂
Great Interview
❤❤❤
Bullshit interview with a liar.
Swamy is the bravest politician of 21st century
❤❤❤
If Rahulji has taken money let swamy go to court and punish him instead of black mailing
Rahul Gandhi has taken money legally so he can’t take him to court.
I agree with Mr Swamy up to some extent. The PM once said that nobody has come and nobody has occupied any part of our land. What for this "disengagement" now? Yes. Where is the document they have signed? But Rahul Gandhi has raised questions on several matters but he has been cornered and the ruling is not allowed for any discussion or debate.
80% of his cases has fallen flat, what happened to 2G and others
It was Nehru that gave up Indian land learn history first you sound ridiculous
👌👌👌@@keeya_ks
First of all modi should resign first. He betrayed whole nation for he lied to whole nation about chinese invasion
Dr Swamy has raised good questions
The interviewer needs to avoid the following:-
Beginning a lot of questions with ‘No, but’ or ‘but’.
Learn to pause or wait giving the main guest the maximum time and not to arrogate to yourself half the time.
Dr Swamy is a slow, steady and confident speaker and therefore needs to be given his time. Even when he pauses for a moment, probably to catch his breath considering his age, the interviewer butts in promptly without letting him say more starting off with ‘No, but’. With his erudition and experience, Dr Swamy has very interesting anecdotes and views to share which viewers are more keen to listen than to the frequently interruptive questioning with needless preludes and preambles.
Learn to phrase your questions as briefly as possible (ideally a single sentence) without prefixing them with many sentences and paragraphs wasting a lot of time.
An interview that could’ve been better but for the interviewer!
Most of these videos are u tube money making jhoomla . Crass . Scum . No accountability .
We want PM like Dr. SWAMI
Traitor .
He is US puppet
This man wants minister position in central government .
But they do not give him .
He is CIA asset
😂. Do you have any answer to him? 😂
But why is Modi govt shit scared to act against Swami if he is lying❓- Swami not getting a ministerial position is a secondary issue here 😊
This is just a logical fallacy.
Just because you don't have any counter argument , you are writing all this shit here .
The narrative of the old man:
1 I was Harvard university trained scholar, hint: I am a something . Actually, Harvard did produce junk, he is the proof.
2 I met Deng Xiaoping in 1980s. Hint: I am as influential internationally as Deng. Actually he was nothing when he met Deng
I feel bad for Indians to have such kind junk politician.
Where is Indian land? The nation wants to know!!!!! Where is Arnav Goosami?😅😅😅
in ur ass
Ask Arnab to speak with Mr. Swamy . As you know Arnab is biggest lier who paid media broker😢
Susu Swamy is going crazy over here. Somebody please give him some attention please
Dont cry
Modi ji is great...doing good things for the betterment of nation.
Hello, the British came and drew an imaginary boundary without survey, and claimed South Tibet (now India renamed Arunarch Pradesh) and Ladakh.Then when India gained independence, she kept in possession of stolen land from the British. Doesn't India know it is illegal to keep stolen property? Tibet sits in the Himalayan and merges with China and they have interacted with the Chinese for a thousand years . Indians had never been able to go up the mountains since the Chinese came to Tibet during Yuan and Qing Dynasties.
If Tibet is legitimately chinese, then why did Dalai lama had to flee and live it exile in India as of now.
@@Mira-c6k7d If Punjab is legitimately indian, then why the Sikhs had to flee and live in exile in Canada as of now?
@@Mira-c6k7d FYI, the 14th Dalai Lama Mr Tenzin Gyatso happens to be the only surviving Vice Chairman of the PRC 1st National People's Congress in 1954.
@@Osman-jz2zs Yes 1985 has been a scar to India after Indira Gandhi assassination.Right after her death , the govt was crippled and spineless and directionless. The emotional reaction that followed is not the general character of Indians. Sikhs are respected and loved in India. If that was not the case , how could there be sikhs in all fields in India.
@@Mira-c6k7d Tibetans are respected and loved in China. If that was not the case , how could there be Tibetans in all fields in China?
He is bittered because Modi do not trust him.
Whether he is bitter or not , he speaks the TRUTH .. gotta respect his courage 🔥👍
Yes I think 🤔 so!!
Subramanian Swamy has never supported the Gandhi family at any point of time. He talks with proof and BJP maintenance pin drop silence never questioned Swamy why a million dollar question BJP must answer.
what is bjp doesn't answer?
So Where's the proof ?
Because he is a bramin. Bjp is a bramin party.
@@Shanmugam-c8d bjp is not a brahmin party, modi is a obc, so bjp ultimately became obc party, brahmins started hating bjp and even most of the Congress has brahmin members.
@anandms7537 Everybody knows that modi belongs to obc. But rss and bjp are dominated by bramins. See jaysankar and nirmala are not elected by the people but they occupy the key ministerial posts.
Sorry, Madam this is an unacceptable allegation by Mr. Swamy ji. He should ask the Nehru-Gandhi/ Congress family for the Historic blunder done in 1962.
India lost Aksai Chin 38000 sq km in the 1962 war. You can thank Nehru for that.
and now the whole country is sold to india by dhokla baba for his gujju scam-chho bhais ....... you should kick dhokla out of this country for that ......
In the past have a lot of respect for Sub. Swamy. He is fearless n speaks the harsh truth. However when he makes such strong accusations against the PM he must follow two basic principles
1. Share proof.
2. It’s unethical to be part of BJP n speak to press in this manner. Resign from BJP.
He has the luxury of speaking his mind without the responsibility of its fallout.
SWAMY is just handling the entertainment portfolio of BJP otherwise serious affair that is getting Bharath going forward.
Dont cry. 😂
HAPPY DEEPAVALI to all. After listening to the Dr., I am very very sad and feel down. We BHARATWASEES, have lost our SPINE, top to down. ...
I m not surprised with the fact he never lost a defamation case ever , your a real life hero dude 😂❤❤❤
We are from uttranchal higher himalay natives..
Please open Kailash mansarovar teerth yatra (pilgrimage) and Vyapar (trade)..
many village and valleys comepletly depend on trade, Barter system and kailash yatra..
It's the life life of all Himalayan region for centuries..
suport you ,my brother from China
THE GOVERNMENTS MUST SURRENDER..
Dr. Swamy hit the nail on its head. All this meeting hype is just casual and nothing is put on record or paper. Bricks or fix is sitting sitting on both sides of the fence
Subramanian should be a comedian.
Appreciate your Brave and Honest journalism Madam ❤
Dear Dr Subramanian Swamy....
🌎*(づ๑•ᴗ•๑)づ* Better be Vegan and promote '0 Child' aka Celibacy likewise the Honorable Prime Minister Narendra Modi... *"for the environment and for the planet sustenance"*
There's no political neta in BJP capable of countering his claims. He is more patriotic than anyone else and a real challenge for any political party.
Appoint Swamy to Rajya Sabha, then everything will be fine !
Its good to know
Its funny when swami was critisising modi, neelu was quiet and enjoying it. But the minute swami turned on rahul and sonia, she started to defend them. Shows what this channel is all about 😂
Mirch lag gayi hai 😂
True
Well said. maybe cause of frustration he opened the truth. But reveled the truth with well balance stand.
We must remember, the current LAC is a perception line for both countries and not a fixed line so far, due to which the prevailing border dispute is Sir.
🎉 Dr swamy for PM 🎉🎉🎉
This guy wants to 'teach China a lesson'. He is a funny guy.
he will be teached by China
She Subramaniam is speaking truth..Chinese brazenly carried out agression on india in April/may 2020 and gobbled up 3000 km of Indian territory that too without firing a single bullet. **naa koi aaya hai naa koi ghusa hai *se kam nahi chalega.india must defend its territorial integrity and sovereignty at any cost as china brazenly gobbling our territory.
Don't need to watch the whole video, all the main points are in the intro.
As if in the past all international agreements have been shared in public!!, what a funny expectation!!
Swami just talk fearless about modi nothing else..
I had great regards for him as a lawyer with in depth knowledge about our constitution. But, his hunger for power and position has consumed him into such level to advocate India to go for war with china. It doesn't matter who has got big and powerful army. War will bring destruction into both sides. At present India has more powerful position in the global diplomacy and i believe the only deal might have made would be the Taiwan. Xi is preparing for to invade Taiwan and he doesn't want India on the opposite side, so the quad.
Brilliant mind. Fights on the basis of justice as he understands not on the basis of goondaraj.
You are right. Narendra Modi may not be different than Nehru and congress of last 70 years. He should publish the documents. On paper might be something different than the media’s are talking.
I urge Dr.Swami to please focus on Bsnk of China in Mumbai and its partnership with SBI
Neelu ji's heart breaks everytime Swamy claims Rahul and Sonia are totally compromised regarding China. Does Swamy not know they are her great big hopes.
Subramanian Swamy should come out on the street and open the chapter of Modi if u r taking genuinely people will appreciate and will joined and to support u for the rights
Mr Swamy does know geography of China. On China side is a plateau of over 1,000 km with fast train connection. It is on the India that has steep inclines.
Dr SS sometimes talks like a CIA sgent..... But he is very courageous person.
Well i disagree with this guy...my filling is bjb is playing smart in US-china contest but Congress is pro American....india may be disagree with china in so many levels but we need china more then US
Has Mr.Subramanian Swamy won any lok sabha election?.He has always been choosing to be a Rajya Sabha Member. Does he have guts to contest in any lok sabha seat ?
Yes. He has won twice from Bombay. First time in Janata Party's first government
What about nirmala,ashivini Vaishnav etc
Never.?
Nirmala thai, s jaishankar, ashwani vaishnav all
He was elected 5 times as MP. See his bio.. yaa
As i am watching your clip, following questions come to mind:
1. Please elaborate [for those who have not kept up with] on mei says vs army.
2. Please detail out LOTs of Territories China has captured.
3. Would be nice if the guest details out what we have lost - he seems to speak LIKE a TRUE POLITICIAN.
I also wonder if the guest truly comprehend the concept of attacking China! I must admit i am at not his level but TRULY love to hear his side. The COST of WAR with china - potential loss of more territory, loss of humans, deeper and longer chism, loss of face in the world,.........
I wonder what is guest's opinion to side [India] with West.
The outlook needs to change, which includes our border issues with China. It is better to invest our resources and energy on more productive issues. Economic development increases as conflict and hostility decreases in the neighborhood. Every sovereign state tries to work on win-win situations, we also engaged on similar lines in Kazan. Nobody is going to give a gift to us in geopolitics. Please remember parallel lines doesn't meet at any points, you have to converge to meet at certain points with your neighbors. There is nothing to expose strategically, conflicts are counter productive, how long we have to sustain with this counter productive narratives.
Very nice conversation. 🙏
All said n done Modi Government has no guts to fight for reclamation of the Ladakh territory occupied by China. This is because he has been a broker to the advancement of Adani acqui ing a business stronghold in China. One step taken by Modi government to get back this land back then phew Adani's businesses in China will be kaput
What if the Adani is being funded by China?
We still dont have much idea about his source of fund.
What to do? What is the solution? Has china returned the 4000 sqare kms of Indian land ?
Swamy means something concerning. Country's goodwill towards its immediate neighbours are vanishing, which is not a good sign with bully China around the corner.
Excellent sir, now let the so called smart speakers of BJP replay on this.
The nation wants to know If Modi has given more land to China than Nehru did... why media is silent?
We have an intellectual in Mr. Swamy ....it's a pity P.M.Modi has not kept him in good books....he can consult him on important matters .. & give a key position in the cabinet ....in my eyes...he is the best contender for the post of P.M.of India.....he is likely to steer India in the right direction ....hope it happens before he gets any older......
Neelu ji ur podcasts r sensible
Subramanyam Swami is Atrupta Aatma.
Dr Swamy said that he recomended RSS chief to make Mr Modi as PM but Modi did not make him a minister. Now he is not having any post in BJP.
Should quit gracefully.
If he has guts get the age bar of 75 years implemented and try to become PM if eligible. Modi has to vacate on 17 Sept '25.
subramanyam swamy has issues with Modi as he was not made a Cabinet minister as swami was claiming before 2014. he is spewing venow non stop. However Indian Government needs to show proof to right people. I am sure Mr.Swamy will use PIL to see the government.
Sour grapes, Subramaniam Swami!!!
"This is not an era of war, but of diplomacy and trade"
- Prime Minister Narendra Modi
So India has the responsibility to live up to this
Was the money a donation for the foundation and if yes, then it is not a bribe.
Never has the MEA Minister refuted allegations of Swami. Whatever PM thumps his chest for, clearly indicates it's a humbug.
Subramanyam swami has guts but he also known for supporting west
Yes is information source is the west, starting from the time he was a fullbright scholar.
HW news has nothing good to say about the ruling dispensation.. Sujith nair the chief editor was gloating when Arnab was imprisoned..these people are just evil ...
If they want to be co structive tell them to participate in a debate and express their views
Speaking and getting things done are two different things. CJI was speaking a lot but didn't deliver anything substantial. Mr. Swamy similarly speaks a lot against the BJP and PM but when it comes to action he takes action against those who oppose the BJP and the PM.
Mr.Subramanian Swamy has messed-Up his own house and his own family, so he has no right at all to talk about such things.
Typical Pappu
😂. Poor chaddis 😂
As an Indian citizen Swamy has every right to talk on matters pertaining to the country ..... why club his personal and family matters with this 😊 ???
If Modi is so weak how did he scrap art 370 , if he is weak what did HM Amit shah say in parliament abt PoK and Gilgit Baltistan
Because he had majority and during in 2nd term people thought modi is a super man😂😂😂
You will understand more if you stop reading news from WhatsApp univercity 😂😂😂😂
😂. Amit shah said in parliament that we will take aksai chin from china. Just after that galwan happened
Adani has opened a new energy company in Sahangai, CHINA recently. Obviously this help the Chinese to dump the excess solar panels produced in China in India. This will help the Adanis.
PLA in Indian territory. No kidding!
Waiting for him to oppose 'Party funds immune to IT scrutiny' law made by Modi Govt. and get it deleted.
Dr. Subramanian Samy is the most suitable Personality to become the Prime Minister of India. Congratulations for making India Proud.
Why didn't the army get involve in consultations before Modi and Jaishankar went to Russia?
Occupation of foreign territory as a result of war is understood. Even then post war territories occupied are returned. But China occupation of large part of territory of India is not as result of war. It is a walk in the park for China. Modi हे तो मुमकिन है ।